Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
\
[ 3300 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT P
ON NO:24822 oF 2021
M/s. Metrochem API Private Limited, 302, Bhanu Enclave, Sunder Nagar,
Eerragadda, Hyderabad, 500038 Represented by its Authorized Signatory.
...PETITIONER
D
1. Reserve Bank of lndia, Main Building, P.O.Box 901 , ShahidBhagat Singh
Road, Mumbai 400001, Represented by its Authorised Officer.
2. M/s. Canbank Factors Ltd., R/o. 67/, Kanakapura Main Road (Near Lalbagh
West Gate), Bsavanagudi, Benguluru- 560 004, Represented by its
Authorised Officer.
3. Credit lnformation Bureau of lndia Ltd, One World Centre, Tower 2A, 1gTH
Floor, SenpatiBapat Marg, Elphinstone Road, Mumbai- 400 013.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed the.rewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, Direction or Order, parrticularly one in the
nature of Mandamus, declaring the action of the Respondent No.2 in initiating the
wilful defaulter proceedings against the Petitioner company as per RBI Master
Circular dated 05.07.20't5 as arbitrary, illegal and contrary to law as Respondent
No. 2 lacks jurisdiction to initiate wilful default proceedings basing on RBI Master
circular dl.oslo7l2o15, and consequently set aside the Show cause Notices dated
19.12.2020, 1SlO2t2O21, 03.04.2021,05.04.2021 issued by the Respondent No.2
against the Petitioner Company and declare the same as being without
jurisdiction, illegal and contrary to law.
lA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
the operation of Show cause Notices daled 19.12.2020, 1SlO2l2O21' 03.04.2021,
05.04.2021 issued by the Respondent No.2 against the Petitioner Company and
further direct ther Respondent No.2 not to take any coercive measures against the
Petitioner Company, pending disposal of the Writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRt VIMAL VARMA VASI REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI V. NITESH
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI B.N. SWAMIJI
Counsel for the Respondent No.3:
The Court made the following: ORDER
:
,7
-i
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI(A
WRIT PETITION No. 24a22 OF 2O2L
21.oL.20/26
Between:
M/s Metrochem API Private Limited,
Rep. by its Authoriz,ed Signatory
..... Petitioner
And
Reserve Bank of India,
Rep. by its Authoriz,ed Officer & others.
Respondents
ORDER:
The case of petitioner is that it is engaged in the
manufacture of Active Pharmaceutical lngredients and is
operating from five manufacturing facilities, four of which are
situated in the State of Telangana and one in the State of
Andhra Pradesh, in addition to a Research and Development
Centre. lts corporate office is located at Erragadda, Hyderabad,
where more than 100 employees are working in departments
such as purchase, finance, accounts and marketing, and that
the total strength of employees of petitioner company exceeds
3000, whose livelihood is directly dependent upon the
uninterrupted operations and financial credibility
of the
petitionr:r company.
1-1.
petitioner contends that M/s p. prafur
& company
Agency (India) private Limited was supplying 2.3 LTJTTDINE
materials (chemicals) from its Hyderabad office godown
raw
locally
to petiti.ner's manufacturing facilities and petitioner company
duly clezrred all valid and rawful purchase bils raised
by the
said entiv up to 29.05.2oLg, reaving no amount due
or payable
thereafter' All such payments were made directry
by way of
post-dated cheques issued in favour of M/s p. praful
company' Agency (India) private Limited, indicating
&
a specific
bank account as per the request of the said supprier,
and that
no disput.e whatsoever existed with respect to any invoice
up to
the said c.ate.
1.2-
Thereafter, petitioner received e mail from the office
of the )rtd respondent at Ahmedabad claiming that certain
invoices factored by M/s p. praful & Company
Agency (India)
Private Limited were overdue and cafling upon petitioner
company to make arrangements for payment.
The contents of
said e mail came as a complete surprise to its
chief Financiar
officer, a. alt invoices had already been settled
outstandirLg barance was 'nil' as on that
and the
date. petitioner
/
'6,
J
contends that no supplies were received by it after 07 -o2'2O19,
the last supply being under Invoice No. HY1800022 dated
06.02.2019, and that all invoices duly accounted for in the
normal course of business were settled by 29.05.2019, with the
ledger account reflecting a zero balance'
l.3.Petitionercontendsthatuponreceiptofemail,the
Chief Financial Officer immediately informed the departments
concerned within petitioner company and expressed that
the
invoices claimed to be overdue were fake, as no material had
been received, bills were never forwarded to the accounts
department, and the same were never accounted for at a[1' tt
is
stated, petitioner had taken aback by the said communication
and consequently conducted an internal audit and enquiry,
which revealed that M/s P. Praful & company Agency (India)
Private Limited had raised five dubious invoices during the
period from 28.O5-2OL} to 23'07 '2019 amounting to
Rs.6,24,92,8OO1- purportedly towards suppty of raw
materials'
without any underlying transaction or supply of goods'
l.4.Petitionercontendsthatsaidfraudwascommitted
byShriNeeIP.Bhalakia,DirectorofM/sP.Praful&Company
Agency (India) Private Limited, in collusion with Mr. Yerra
Sudhakar, who was working in the purchase department of
petitioner company and was entrusted with the dury of
preparing purchase orders and forwarding them to the
appropriate authorities for verification and approval. Upon
enquiry, it was revealed that fraud was perpetrated by raising
fake anC nominal invoices without any supply of goods,
supported by fabricated confirmations of receipt and fake,
unauthorised undertakings and authorisations purportedly
issued ty Mr. Yerra Sudhakar, who was not authorised to
represent or bind petitioner company in any manner.
1.5.
Petitioner contends that upon discovery of the said
fraud, it immediately lodged a complaint dated 19.10.2019
before the Cyber Crime Police, CCS, DD, Hyderabad, pursuant
to which crime No.231 of 2o19 was registered for the offences
punishatrle under Sections 406, 42O, 463, 465, 468, 4ZL and
4O9 rea<l with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. It is
contended, after conducting a detailed investigation, police
officials filed charge sheet dated 23.r2.2o2o in c.c. No. t3010 of
2o2l before the court of the xII Additional chief Metropolitan
Magistral:e at Nampally, Hyderabad, holding that Shri Neel p.
Bhalakia Director of M/s. p. praful & company Agency (lndia)
Private Limited, committed fraud by creating false tax invoices
and factoring them with the 2d respondent, which was
t
managed at the relevant time by Mr. M. Sohan Singh as Branch
Head, Ahmedabad, in the capacity of Assistant Vice President,
for an amount of Rs.6,24,92,8OO/- quoting Purchase Order No.
RM 182132 for 2O,0OO kgs of 2.3 LUTIDINE on payment terms of
120 days.
1.6.
Petitioner contends that charge sheet further
establishes that the alleged delivery challan and goods
consignment note bearing L.R. No.O39 dated 28.05.2019 were
fabricated and the vehicle purported to have transported the
goods was, in fact, transporting some other material on
27.05.2019 to other places and was out of Hyderabad city on
28.05.2019, and that the said transport agency never
transported any material to petitioner company. The
investigation further revealed that there was no generation of
e-way bills and no payment of GST in respect of the five alleged
invoices, despite such e-way bills being mandatorily required to
be generated in the gystem, and that officers of the 2nd
respondent failed to insist upon the necessary requirement of
e-way biIls. The ex-employee Mr. Yerra Sudhakar ensured that
monthly outstanding statements sent by the 2nd respondent did
not reach the accounts or finance departments of petitioner
company and, without receipt of any goods, falsely sent e mails
conlirming receipt of goods and stating that no e-way bills were
required, pursuant to which the Head of the Ahmedabad
Branch of the 2nd respondent processed the false invoices
without'.rerilication and released the amounts to the account of
M/s. P. I'raful & Company Agency (India) Private Limited.
1.7.
Petitioner contends that M/s P. praful & Company
Agency (lndia) Private Limited wrongfully gained by claiming
uncancelled purchase orders and. securing release of funds from
M/s. Canbank Factors Limited, Ahmedabad, through forged tax
invoices, thereby cheating petitioner company. It is contended
that during investigation, police verified the alleged tax invoices
and collected e-way bill details from the office of the Hyderabad
GST corr.missionerate and found that no e-way bills existed and
that GS'll was not paid, rendering all five invoices false and
fabricate<I. M/s. P. Praful & company Agency (lndia) private
Limited had entered into a factoring agreement with the 2.,t
respondent pursuant to which invoices raised in petitioner
company's name were factored. Petitioner contends that a
factoring transaction involves three parties, namely the
assignor, the assignee and the customer, and that there is no
contract between the assignee and the customer, such
transactions being regulated by the Factoring Regulation Act,
2011.
1.8.
Petitioner contends that acceptance letter dated
11.04.2018 and undertaking letter dated 24.04.2018 relied
upon by the 2.d respondent were fabricated by M/s P. Praful &
company Agency (India) Private Limited in collusion with
Mr. Yerra Sudhakar, who was actively involved in perpetuating
the acts of raising fake invoices and who was not authorised to
represent the petitioner company. The 2"d respondent issued a
legal notice dated 2L.LO.2Olg demanding payment of
Rs.6,24,92,8OO1- by invoking the factoring agreement with the
vendor and thereafter, issued show cause notices dated
tg.t2.2o2}, Lg.O2.2O2l, O9.o4.202 1 and o5.o4.2o2 1 proposing
to declare petitioner company as a wilful defaulter' Petitioner
replied uide letters dated 29.12.2O2O and 29.O4.2O2L
categorically asserting that the 2nd redpondent is neither a
lender nor a banker and has no locus or jurisdiction to initiate
wilful d.efaulter proceedings against petitioner company.
l.g.Clause2.t.loftheRBIMasterCirculardated
01.07.2015 defines the term 'lender' as banks or financial
institutions to which any amount is due arising out of a
banking transaction and that the 2nd respondent, being a
factoring company and a Non-Banking Financial Company, is
not engalged in the business of lending and has not been vested
with any power to initiate wilful defaulter proceedings. At best,
the 2nd respondent may be construed as a lender vis-A-vis
M/s P. Praful & Company Agency (lndia) Private Limited but can
never br: a lender vis-d-vis petitioner company and that
petitione;: does not owe any amount either to the vendor or to
the 2"d respondent. Even assuming any liability, it would be
operatiorLal in nature and not a financial debt.
1.
1O.
Petitioner contends that fraud vitiates all
proceedings and that any claim founded upon fabricated
invoices cannot be sustained, particularly when the charge
sheet narnes the officers of the 2"d respondent as Accused 4 and
5. The slrow cause notices issued without jurisdiction are uoid
ab initio and liable to be interdicted under Article 226 of the
Constitut.ion. A perusal of show cause notices demonstrates
that the 2nd respondent has already made up its mind,
renderingg the proceedings an empty formality, and that the 2"a
respondent has also written to CIBIL and the lenders of
petitioner company, thereby damaging petitioner's hard-earned
creditworthiness and adversely impacting its ability to avail
credit facilities from its bankers, including SBI. M/s. P. Praful &
)
')
Company Agency (India) Private Limited has since entered into
CIRP proceedings under Section 7 of the lnsolvency and
Bankruptcy Code and that any hampering of petitioner's credit
facilities would adversely affect the lives and livelihood of more
than 3OO0 employees, particularly when petitioner is a profitmaking company and its accounts for the financial year 2O2l
are to be finalised. Petitioner finally contends that the disputed
amount was not paid as it represents fake invoices raised by the
said company, as conclusively found during police investigation
and reflected in the charge sheet filed against M/s P. Praful &
Company Agency (India) Private Limited and its Director Shri
Neel P. Bhalakia.
2.
By order dated O4.lO.2O2l, this Court granted
interim suspension of the impugned show cause notice as the
same was issued contrary to the master circular issued by the
RBI.
3.
Respondent No.2 filed counter contending that it is
a notilied financial institution within the meaning of the Reserve
Bank of India Master Circular dated O1.O7.2015 and is vested
with jurisdiction and authority to initiate wilful defaulter
proceedings against entities which deliberately avoid repayment
of their dues. It has not violated any statutory provision or
)
l0
constitutional guarantee, including Articles 19 and 21 of the
Constitu'-ion of India, and that petitioner company is a wilful
defaulter, though not for the reasons alleged by them. While it
admits tl:rat petitioner company is . engaged in manufacture of
pharmac,:utical ingredients, the number of employees or
internal r;tructure of petitioner company has no bearing on their
liability to discharge its financial obligations. M/s. P. Praful &
Company Agency (lndia) Private Limited was regularly supplying
chemical; to petitioner company which was depositing bill
amounts directly into the overdraft account of Canbank Factors
Limited maintained with Canara Bank, Paldi Branch,
Ahmedabad, bearing Account No. Ol7 426LOO5272.
3.1.
It is contended, petitioner company was making
payments towards factored invoices by issuing post-dated
cheques in favour of "Canbank Factors Ltd Alc P. Praful&
Company Agency (lndia) Pvt. Ltd." and that such cheques were
issued blr the Managing Director and another Director of
petitioner company. Petitioner company was also making
payments directly through NEFT, RTGS and online transfers
into the aforesaid account and that documentary proof of such
payments has been placed on record. Petitioner company had
issued an undertaking and authorisation letter dated
-l
ll
't
05.1O.2O15, executed through its General Manager (Finance),
undertaking to make all payments directly to Canbank Factors
Limited and agreeing to intimate Respondent No.2 regardingany
discrepancy in invoices. Respondent No.2 further contends that
a revised undertaking letter dated 24.04.2018 was executed by
petitioner company through its Assistant Manager, Mr. Yerra
Sudhakar, reiterating the obligation to make payments directly
to Respondent No.2 on account of M/s P. Praful & Company
Agency (lndia) Private Limited and to report any discrepancy in
invoices.
3.2.
Respondent No.2 contends that pursuant to the
said undertakings, petitioner company had been regularly
making payments against factored invoices and that assertion of
petitioner that all dues were cleared by 29.05.2019 and that
ledger balance was 'nil'is wholly false. If the account was settled
on 29.O5.2019, there was no explanation foi petitioner company
making payments of Rs. 1,01,95,4231- on 28.06.2019 and
Rs.9O,79,5821- on 1O.O7.2019, which payments are evidenced
by bank statements dated 29.06.2019 and 1I.O7.2019. M/s P.
Praful & Company Agency (lndia) Private Limited was its client
and had availed factoring limits pursuant to a Factoring
Agreement dated 20.Ol.2OI5, under which a
\
\
limit of
t2
Rs.5,00,rJ0,ooo/- was sanctioned and subsequently enhanced
to Rs.8,o0,00,000/- by sanction letter dated 30.1 .2ors
followed by supplemental agreements and periodic renewals. In
accordance with the factoring arrangement, it paid the bills
raised e-gainst petitioner company to the supplier after
deductinll the agreed margin.
3.3.
Respondent No.2 contends that the allegation that
paymentsi were released without verification is incorrect
and
that paynrents were released only after confirmation of receipt of
goods a,d supporting documents, consistent with past
transactic,ns between petitioner company and the supplier. It
had been sending monthly statements of outstanding debt to
petitioner company through registered post which acknowledged
receipt oi' the same on every occasion. Despite repeated
communications, reminders and statements of outstanding
debt, including e mails dated o1.10.2019, 10.10.2019 and
15.1o.2o1(), petitioner company neither raised any dispute nor
made payrnent, thereby demonstrating a deliberate intention to
evade repeyment. The due date of Invoice No. HylgoOooz for
Rs.2,10,51,2oo/- expired on 2s.og.2oLg and that follow-up
communications were duly sent to the email address provided
by petitionor company.
'!r/
ta
t-,
'a|
3.4.
Respondent No.2 contends that the allegation of
fake invoices and collusion was raised only after repeated
demands for payment and that the criminal complaint lodged by
the petitioner is false, fabricated and motivated solely to avoid
repayment of legitimate dues. Petitioner company, along with
the supplier, colluded to create a false narrative and falsely
implicated its own employee to evade payment of Rs.6.24 crores
along with interest. All consignments were duly confirmed by
petitioner company as having been received in good condition
and that the allegation regarding absence of e-way bills and
verilication is false. Respondent No.2 is not concerned with
internal disputes between petitioner company and supplier and
that it possesses all documents to establish the liability of
petitioner company.
3.5.
It is contended, charge sheet was filed only after
issuance of show cause notice dated '19.I2.2O2O and that
criminal proceedings were initiated to divert attention from
petitioner's financial distress and wilful default. Petitioner
company continued to make substantial payments even after
29.05.2019, which negates the plea of fraud and fabrication. It
is stated, the audited financial statements of petitioner company
for the financial year 2OL9-2O2O, filed with the Registrar of
t4
Companir:s on 3O.O1 .2021, contain disclosures which contradict
petitioner''s stand and amount to an implied admission of
liability. Under Clause 2.1.1 of the RBI Master Circular dated
OL.O7.2O 15., guarantees and letters of credit are covered within
the definition of 'lender' and that the undertaking issued by
petitioner company constitutes a guarantee to pay the invoice
amounts after the stipulated credit period of 90 I l2O days.
Petitioner company wilfully defaulted despite such undertaking
and is therefore, liable to be proceeded against as a wilful
defaulter.
3.6.
Respondent No.2 contends that it is empowered to
initiate proceedings under Section 7 of the Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code and that there is no restriction on NBFCs,
including factoring companies, from invoking insolvency
proceedings. The insolvency petition filed before the National
Company Law Tribunal, Hyderabad was supported by all
relevant ctocuments and proofs. The plea that fraud vitiates all
proceedings is wholly misconceived, as delivery of goods and
confirmations were acknowledged by petitioner company and
that any internal irregularities cannot defeat Respondent No.2's
right to recover its dues. Respondent No.2 has jurisdiction to
issue show cause notices and the principtes laid down by the
t,/
{l
l5
Hon'ble Supreme Court regarding lack of jurisdiction are not
applicable to the present case.
3.7.
Respondent No.2 contends that updating credit
information agencies such as CIBIL is mandatory under RBI
guidelines upon default and that any impact on petitioner's
reputation is a statutory consequence of default and not an
arbitrary act. Petitioner company has approached this Court
only to protract proceedings and avoid repayment of substantial
public funds. Mere filing of a charge sheet does not establish
that invoices are fake and correctness of such allegations can
only be determined after trial. Until such adjudication,
petitioner cannot avoid its contractual and statutory obligations.
The Executive Director of Canara Bank is not concerned with
the present dispute and that issuance of notices to such
authorit5r by petitioner amounts to harassment, as the
authorised officer for the purposes of the'impugned proceedings
is only the branch head of Respondent No.2.
4.
Respondent No. 3 also liled counter stating that
Writ Petition is not maintainable against them. This Court lacks
territorial jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition insofar as
Respondent No. 3 is concerned, as its registered office is
admittedly situated at Mumbai. Petitioner is fully aware of the
\
!'
\
t6
{
address and location of Respondent No. 3 and yet chose to
institute the Writ Petition before this Court, which constitutes
an abusr: of the process of law. Respondent No. 3 further
contends that the disputes sought to be raised by petitioners
are purely contractual in nature and do not involve any public
law elemt:nt, therefore, are not amenable to writ jurisdiction.
4.L.
It is contended, banks and financial institutions are
not amer.able to writ jurisdiction in matters where rights and
obligatior: s arise purely out of contract, unless a statutory or
public duty is shown to have been violated, which is absent in
the prese:rt case. No fundamental or legal right of petitioner has
been vioLrted and that the alleged rights and obligations arise
solely out- of transactions relating to credit facilities involving
Respondents 2 and 3. In the absence of any statutory dut5r or
public duty being sought to be enforced, Writ Petition is not
maintainzLble against it.
4.2.
Respondent No. 3 contends that Writ Petition
suffers from misjoinder of parties and absence of any cause of
action. It is a company registered under the Credit Information
Companies (Regulation) Act, 2OO5 and that its primary function
is to collect, collate and disseminate credit information as
reported t.o it by banks and financial institutions. Under the
/
t7
proviso to section 21(3) of the said Act, it cannot make any
correction, deletion or addition to credit information unless the
same is certified as correct by the concerned credit institution.
Respondent No. 3 has no authorit5r to declare any person or
entity as a wilful defaulter and that it merely disseminates
information on non-suit filed and suit-filed accounts of wilful
defaulters based on information reported to it by banks and
financial institutions. It is contended, a perusal of the impugned
communication demdnstrates that state Bank of India has
reported petitioners as wilful defaulters in several quarters and
that Respondent No. 3's website merely reflects the information
so reported, leaving no cause of action against them.
4.3-
Respondent No. 3 contends that petitioners have
wrongly impleaded it as a part5r, as it is not within its domain to
decide whether a person or entit5r should be declared a wilful
defaulter or whether such names should be published. such
declarations are made exclusively by banks and financial
institutions and that Respondent No. 3 merely publishes the
information in compliance with its statutory obligations under
the credit Information companies (Regulation) Act, 2oo5 and
the RBI Master circular dated ol.or.2o15. The Master circular
on wilful Defaulters dated ol.or.2o15 expressly provides that
{
\
l8
credit information companies disseminate information as
reported to them by banks and linancial institutions and that
responsil>ility for accuracy of facts and figures rests solely with
such banks and financial institutions. There is no privity of
contract between petitioners and Respondent No. 3 and
therefore, no relief can be sought against it.
4.4.
Respondent No. 3 contends that writ petition is also
liable to be dismissed on the ground that petitioner had
alternate and efficacious remedies and that it is a settled
principle of law that writ jurisdiction ought not to be exercised
where suLch remedies exist. Petitioners have not even pleaded as
to why such remedies were not availed, rendering the Writ
Petition an abuse of the process of law. Respondent No. 3 is a
companJ, incorpord.ted under the Companies Act, 1956 and has
been granted a certificate of registration by the Reserve Bank of
India under the Credit Information Companies (Regulation) Act,
2005, arrd functions strictly in accordance with the provisions of
the said Act, the rules and regulations framed thereunder. It
does not: collate information on its own and has no obligation
except to disseminate information received from banks and
financial institutions. Sections 14 and 17 of the 2005 Act govern
its functions, which include collection, processing and
{
furnishing of cred.it information to specified users, and that it
is
statutorily prohibited from engaging in any activity beyond what
is expressly permitted under the Act'
4.5.
The RBI Master Circular dated 01'07'2015
mandates banks and financial institutions to submit lists
of
wilful defaulters to credit information companies on a periodic
basis and further mandates credit information companies
disseminate such information on their respective websites'
Respondent No. 3 contends that it is bound to compty
to
The
with such
directions and has no discretion in the matter. Respondent
No'
3 does not have the authority to correct, delete or modiff any
or
credit information unless the same is certified by the bank
financial institution concerned and that it cannot act
unilaterally at the instance of petitioner. Upon receipt of
papers
in writ Petition, it verified its suit-filed databases and found
that petitioner's names was not reflecting'either in the'database
pertaining to wilful defautters of Rs.25 lakhs and above or in the
database pertaining to defaulters of Rs.1 crore and above.
4.6.
Respondent No' 3 contends that pursuant to the
interim order dated o4.lo.2o2l, it has neither reported
petitioner,s name in its databases nor received any update or
instruction from Respondent No. 2 in respect of the petitioner's
account. [n view of the aforesaid facts and statutory position,
Writ Petilion is not maintainable against it and no directions as
prayed fc,r by petitioner can be issued against them. They are
also not ilware of the underlying transactions between petitioner
and Respondent No. 2 and under the Master Circulars issued by
the Reserve Bank of India, banks and financial institutions
alone are authorised and mandated to report the names of wilful
defaulterrs, while Respondent No.. 3 is statutorily-bound only to
host and disseminate such information. From a plain reading of
the Mastr:r Circular, it is evident that Respondent No. 3 has no
role whatsoever in the declaration of a borrower as a wilful
defaulter and that it has been unnecessarily impleaded in the
present u,rit petition.
5.
Heard Sri Raja Sripathi Rao, learned Senior
Advocate on behalf of Sri Vimal Varma Vasireddy, learned
counsel ior petitioner, Sri B.N. Swamiji, learned tounsel on
behalf of Respondents 2 and 3.
6.
On consideration of the material available on
record, ttre admitted and incontrovertible factual position which
emerges , s that the 2"d Respondetrt is a factoring company and
a Non-BeLnking Financial company, and that the transactions
forming the subject matter of the present proceedings arise out
a
-f
2t
of factoring arrangements entered into between the 2nd
Respondent and the vendor company. tt is not in dispute that
Petitioner is not a borrower of any loan, advance or credit
facility from the 2"d Respondent. The relationship between
Petitioner and the 2"d Respondent, if any, is confined to the role
of Petitioner as a 'customer' in a factoring transaction, as
recognised and governed by the Factoring Regulatio4 Act, 2olr.
-
Under the statutory scheme of the Factoring
Regulation Act, 2oll, a factoring transaction involves three
distinct parties, namely, the assignor of receivabres, the
assignee or factor, and the customer against whom invoices are
raised. The Act does not contemplate any lending relationship
between the factor and the customer, nor does it create any
privity of contract in the nature of borrower and lender between
them. The factor merely steps into the shoes of the assignor for
the limited purpose of collection of receivables and risk
management, subject to the statutory framework. Therefore, in
law, the customer cannot be treated as a borrower or debtor of
the factor in respect of any lending transaction.
8.
A plain and unambiguous reading of clause 2.L.L of
the Reserve Bank of India Master circular on wilful Defaulters
dated o1.o7.2o15 defines the term 'lender, to mean banks and
\
financial institutions to which any amount is due arising out of
a banking transaction, including off-balance-sheet transactions
such as derivatives, guarantees and letters of credit. The sine
qua non for invoking the said Circular is the existence of a
banking transaction giving rise to a lending relationship.
Factorinl;, by its very nature and by statutory recognition under
the Facloring Regulation Act, 2oll does not constitute a
banking transaction between the factor and the customer. At
best, the factor may be a lender vis-A-vis the assignor of
receivables, but it does not assume the character of a lender vis-
a-vis the customer against whom the invoices are raised.
9.
In the present case, the show cause notices issued
by the 2',4 Respondent proceed on the foundational assumption
that Petjtioner is a borrower and that the alleged non-payment
constitules a default in repayment of a lending transaction. This
assumpl.ion is fundamentally flawed and contrary to the
statutorg framework governing tractoring transactions as well as
the express language of clause 2.ll of the RBI Master circular
dated o1.07.2015. Jurisdiction to initiate wilful defaulter
proceedings flows strictly from the statute and the circular, and
cannot be assumed on the basis of contractual arrangements or
unilater:rl characterisation of the relationship. The record
./'
I/
I
further reveals that criminal proceedings arising out of the very
same set of invoices are pending consideration before the
competent criminal court and that a charge sheet has been filed
alleging fabrication of invoices, transport documents and
electronic records. The order passed in Criminal Petition
No.2598 of 2021 demonstrates that the allegations of fraud are
not speculative or illusory but are serious, triable and founded
upon a detailed investigation. When the very substratum of the
alleged liability is under criminal scrutiny on allegations of
forgery and fraud, initiation and continuation of wilful defaulter
proceedings against Petitioner, who claims to be the victim of
such fraud, is legally-impermissible and unsustainable.
10.
This Court also takes note of the fact that the
criminal proceedings arising out of the very same set of invoices
are pending consideration before the competent criminal Court
and that, in Criminal Petition No.2598 of 2021, the Court, upon
examination of the charge sheet and the material collected
during investigation, has found the allegations relating to
fabrication of invoices, transport documents and electronic
records to be serious and triable in nature. This Court makes it
clear that no finding is being recorded on the merits of the
criminal case; however, existence of such proceedings
I
,L
demonstrzrtes that dispute is
not a mere accounting
d.isagreement but one involving allegations of fraud founded on
detailed investigation. This circumstance lends further support
to the corlclusion that initiation of wilful defaulter proceedings
against the Petitioner, at this stage, is legally untenable.
11.
This court is also mindful of the settled legal
principle ':hat fraud vitiates all proceedings. Any action founded
upon doc,lments or transactions which are alleged to be forged
and fabrir:ated, and which are the subject matter of a pending
criminal ltrosecution, cannot form the foundation for initiating
coercive ,:ivil consequences such as declaration as a wilful
defaulter, particularly when such declaration carries serious
civil, conrmercial and reputational ramifications. The wilful
defaulter framework is intended to address deliberate and
contumac:ious defaults by borrowers who have the capacity to
pay but ,vitfully choose not to do so. It is not intended to be
invoked in cases where existence, genuineness and
enforceab,ility of the very liability itself is under serious dispute
and is th,: subject matter of criminal proceedings alleging fraud
and forgery. It is also brought to the notice of this Court that
the 2"d R,3spondent had filed Company Petition No. 18/8612021
before thr: National Company Law Tribunal, seeking initiation of
Zt'
€rTyr
/
/
./-
Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process against Petitioner
herein by invoking Section 7 of the lnsolvency and Bankruptcy
Code, 2016. The National Company Law Tribunal, upon
elaborate consideration of the factual matrix, the provisions of
the Factoring Regulation Act,2011, the Reserve Bank of India
Guidelines governing factoring transactions, and the definition
of 'financial debt' under Section 5(8) of the Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code, 2016, dismissed the said Petition by holding
that the factoring arrangement relied upon by the 2nd
Respondent was admittedly \rith recourse' and that, in such
cases, exposure and debt are to be reckoned only in the hands
of the assignor, namely M/s. P. Praful & Company Agency
(tndia) Private Limited, and not in the hands of the
customer/ debtor, namely Petitioner
12.
The Tribunal categorically held that there was no
disbursal of funds by the 2nd Resp<jndent to Petitioner;
essential ingredients of 'financial debt', including disbursal
I
against consideration for time value of money, were absent, and
that there was no jural relationship of financial creditor and
l
I
borrower between the 2nd Respondent and Petitioner. The
Tribunal further held that the 2nd Respondent, at best, could
pursue its remedies against the assignor and that it lacked
i
t
i
etigibility to maintain proceedings under Section 7 of tlrre Code
against the Petitioner. Accordingly, company Petition No.
IBl86l2O21 was dismissed with liberty to the 2"d Respondent
to seek remedies in accordance with law elsewhere. The relevant
portion of the order passed by the National Company Law
Tribunal is extracted hereunder:
"
23. The terms and conditions in the agreement between the
Financial creditor and M/s. P. Praful & Company Agency (lndia) Pvt. Ltd
at pg I 1(r of instant Apptication clearly states about the Type of factoring
Facilities which clearly shows'Sale Bill Factoring Limit - With Recourse'.
24 Therefore, in vierv of the above discussion based on the
provisior.s of the Factoring Regulation Act, 201 1 and the RBI Guidelines,
we are cf the considered view that while the Applicant here may have
recourse against the assignor namely M/s. P- Praful& Company Agency
(India) Pvt. Ltd. u/s 7 of the code, it certainly has no eligibility to file
and ma:.ntain the instant Application against the respondent herein
namely IvI/s Metrochem API Pv Ltd. as a Financial Creditor
25. lt is not out of place to mention here that according to
the Applicant factor/financier itself, Corporate Insolvency Resolution
Process has already been initiated against the client i.e. M/s P. Praful&
company Agency (lndia) Pvt. Ltd. vide order of NCLT Ahmedabad bench
dated O3.OZ 2O2O and the factor/Applicant had also filed a claim in
Form-C'on 11.O8.2020 before the RP of M/s. P. Praful& Company
Agency ilndia) Private Limited.
26. On a consideration of all the facts and the legal position,
we havr: no doubt in holding that in view of the explicit clause in the
factoring agreement entered into between the Applicant/Assignee and
the Client/ Assignor in relation to the purchase of debts ON RECOURSE
basis, read with the RBI Guidelines discussed supra, there is no jural
relationship of creditor and borrower between the Applicant and
Respon,lent. Consequently, the Applicant herein cannot claim to be a
I
Financial Creditor qua the Respondent so as to maintain the instant
Application fiIed w/s 7 of the Code against the Respondent.
27. Accordingly, instant Application is dismissed with
liberty to the Applicant to seek remedy elsewhere in a manner known to
Law.
28. With the above, Company Petition lBl86l2O21 stands
disposed. No Order as costs."
13.
It is also placed on record that Respondent No. 2,
along with its Vice President, also approached this Court by
filing Criminal Petition No. 2598 of 2021 under Section 482 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, seeking quashing of the
proceedings in C.C. No. 13010 of 2O2O on the file of the XII
Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad. This
Court, upon a detailed consideration of the pleadings, the
charge sheet, and the material collected during investigation,
held that there were specilic and serious allegations indicating
conspiracy, forgery, fabrication of invoices and electronic
records, and dishonest inducement, resulting in wrongful loss,
and that such allegations were supported by prima facie
material. This Court further held that the issues raised involved
disputed questions of fact, which could not be adjudicated in
proceedings under Section 482 Cr.P.C., and that the allegations
required a futl-fledged trial for proper determination.
Consequently, this Court found no ground to exercise its
'iJ*r
-
,.,;n"l*:'.
..;ra&'
inherent jurisdiction to stifle the prosecution at the threshold
and disnrissed the criminal petition, while dispensing with the
personal appearance of petitioners therein subject to conditions,
and clarifying that all observations made were confined solely to
the purpr)Se of deciding the quash petition. The relevant portion
of the order passed in Criminal Petition No. 2598 of 2021 is
extractei. hereunder:
"
28. It is already stated supra, there are specific allegations
against.:he petitioners that petitioner'No. 1, rvho is working as a Branch
Head at petitioner No.2 company, actively assisted accused Nos. 1 to 3 to
fraudulently get money out of petitioner No.2 company and accused
Nos. I tr> 3 conspired with petitionerNo. 1 and perpetrated the fraud and
forgrng of fake invoices and factoring them r.l,ith petitioner No.2 company
for a hu.ge amount of Rs.6,24,92,8OO1-. Even though respondent No.2
compan'/ has not received the consignment of goods based upon the five
invoices and e-way bills dated 28.05.2019,27-06.2019 and 23.07.2019,
which are forged and fabricated by accused Nos. I to 3 in collusion with
petitiont:r No. 1 and petitioner No.2 and released huge amount of
Rs.6,24.92,8OO1- in favour of accused No.2, even without verification of
the invoices and also due confirmation rvith respondent No.2 company.
This Cotrrt is of the considered view that the above said allegations have
to be a<tjudicated and decided by the trial Court after full-fledged trial
only an,1 the same cannot be gone into in this criminal petition, while
exercising the powers conflerred under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C.
29.|t is very much relevant to mention that in Sau. Kamala
Shivaji Pokarnekar v. The State of Maharashtra & Ors., the Hon'ble
Apex Cc,urt held that the inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. has
to be exercised in exceptional cases sparingly, with caution, only to
prevent abuse of process or to secure the ends of justice; and it cannot
be involled to weigh evidence or stifle a genuine prosecution, but may be
applied u'here the allegations in the complaint, taken at face value, do
I
I
not disclose the basic ingredients of any offence. The case on hand
is
not the rarest of rare cases to exercise powers of this court
und.er
section 482 of cr.p.c. to quash the proceedings in c.c.No. r30r0
of
2020.
30. For the foregoing reasons, this court does not find any
ground to quash the proceedings in c.c.No.l30l0 of 2o2o
against the
petitioners on the file of the XII Additional Metropolitan
Magistrate,
Nampally, Hyderabad.
31. In the resurt, the criminar petition is dismissed.
However, taking into consideration the peculiar facts and circumstances
of the case, the presence of the petitioners in c.c.No. 13010 of 2o2o
is
dispensed with, unress their presence is specifically required
subject to
the condition that the petitioners shall represent through their counsel
on each and every date of hearing. [n case of non appearance of the
petitioners on the specific date so f-rxed by the trial court
for their
appearance, the trial court is entitled to proceed with the matter,
in
accordance with law. It is made clear that any of the observations
made
in this order are confining for the purpose of deciding this case only,.
14.
This court is of the considered view that
jurisdiction is a condition precedent for the valid exercise
of
power under the RBI Master circular dated ol.or.2ors. An
authority which does not fall within the delinition of .lender,
under clause 2.1.r of the circular cannot assume jurisdiction
to initiate wilful defaulter proceedings merely on the basis of
contractual arrangements or undertakings. Jurisdiction cannot
:
be conferred by consent, acquiescence or conduct of the parties,
I
nor can it be created by an erroneous interpretation of t]:e
governing statutory provisions. The contention advanced on
i
i
t:
- . .. .-.;-..^^:'ffi:**:IL
:
H
behalf oi the 2nd Respondent that it is a notified linancial
institution and therefore entitled to initiate wilful defaulter
proceedings cannot be accepted in isolation, divorced from the
statutory context. Even a notified financial institution must
satisfy the jurisdictional requirement that the amount alleged to
be due a.rises out of a banking transaction involving a lending
relationship. In the absence of such a relationship between
Petitioner and the 2nd Respondent, assumption of jurisdiction by
the 2nd I?espondent is clearly without authority of law.
15.
The argument that undertakings or authorisations
issued by Petitioner to make payments towards factored
invoices convert the relationship into one of lender and borrower
is equal$ untenable. Such undertakings, even if assumed to
exist, do not alter the essential character of the transaction,
which remains a factoring arrangement governed by the
Factoring Regulation Act, 20 1 1. A contractual obligation to
make peyment towards receivables does not metamorphose into
a banking transaction so as to attract the rigours of the ,,r.,ilful
defaulter regime. This Court also finds merit in the submission
that the impugned show cause notices disclose a predetermined approach on the part of the 2nd Respondent. The
notices proceed on the premise that petitioner is already a
/
I
3l
defaulter and cail upon petitioner to show
cause onry as a
formality- such an approach strikes at the very
root of fairness
and due process, which are implicit in Article
2l of the
cbnstitution and renders the proceedings vitiated.
L6-
It is we[ settled by a catena of decisions of the
Hon'ble Supreme court that where a show
cause notice is
issued by an authority lacking inherent jurisdiction,
the proceedings are ex facie contrary to law,
exercise of its jurisdiction under Article
or where
the High court, in
226 ofthe constitution
of India, is not required to reregate the aggrieved
party to an
alternative remedy. existence of an alternative
remedy does not
operate as a bar in cases where the action
comprained of is
wholly without jurisdiction or is an abuse of process
the present case, impugned show cause notices
of law. In
scheme governing
factoring transactions, the express provisions
of the RBI Master
circular dated or.or.2or5, and the admitted factual
position
that Petitioner is not a borrower of the 2nd Respondent.
irreversible prejudice to petitioner, incruding
adverse impact on the liverihood of thousands
\
in grave and
impairment of its
creditworthiness, disruption of its business
i
i
have been
issued in clear disregard of the statutory
continuation of such proceedings wourd result
,
j
operations and
of emproyees.
i
This Court is also conscious of the wider public law
17.
implications of permitting entities lacking jurisdiction to invoke
wilful defaultei ffamework. Such an approach would dilute the
sanctity cf the regulatory mechanism devised by the Reserve
Bank of India and would expose businesses to arbitrary and
coercive action without authority of law, which cannot be
countenanced i, ,, constitutional democracy governed by the
rule of law. For all the aforesaid reasons, this Court holds that
the 2"d llespondent lacks jurisdiction to initiate wilful defaulter
proceedirrgs against Petitioner under the RBI Master Circular
dated O1.O7.2O15, that the impugned show cause notices are
vitiated by lack of jurisdiction and legal infirmity, and that
initiation and continuation of such proceedings are
unsustainable in law. Consequently, Writ Petition deserves to be
allowed.
The impugned show cause notices dated
18.
19.12.2O2O, 19.02.2021, O3.O4.2021 and 05.04.2021 issued by
the 2"d Flespondent are hereby set aside. The 2"d Respondent is
restrained from taking any further steps pursuant to the said
notices or from initiating wilful defaulter proceedings against
the Petitioner in respect of the transactions in question. The
writ petition is accordingly allowed. No costs
,/
t/
r'--....-"
!
JJ
19.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed
S
//TRUE COPY/
To,
. PONNA KRISHNA
ISTANT REGISTRAR
SECTION OFFICER
901'
pa.nk of lndia, Main Building' P'O'Box
:Kanaka pu ra
iii;hidBh;sat singn Road, Mumbai 400001'
rt-r-'"to is Ltd'''R/o' 67/'
2. The Autho riseo ofHc,ilillii. G
1. The Authorised officer, Reserye
['n
;"'"'*3;F,:{Tl!:;?1??3f i'
uru##flffiig,l'BglU"fi lStfl rff
4. B';sb$[,s[+#,ft'#tiSrlN€ieff ai.Xt*siJ?33,]3i
q
v. i.irieSH, Advocate toPuql
3.
^6c i; SFii
il;
Ro'ocate 1oeucl
6. il; cc i; SRi e.N.'swAvtiti,
CD CoPies
-
7. Two
BN
W,,
HIGH COI..IRT
DATED i2110112026
{ r{E i\
tJ
ORDER
WP.No.24822 of 2021
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
1 ?,
',.1
0 6 rtB 2$20
*
'9(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review