Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA : HYDERABAD
MAIN CASE No: W.P.No.31108 of 2026
PROCEEDING SHEET
SL.
NO
1.
DATE
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
22.09.2026 JAK, J
Matter is being take up today under the
caption “ON BEING MENTIONED”.
This Writ Petition is filed with the following
prayer:
“… to issue to issue a Writ, order or direction more
particularly one in the nature of a Writ of Mandamus,
declaring the action of the Respondent No.3 / Addl.
Collector and EOED, TGSCSC Ltd., District
Kamareddy in inviting a second tender notice in Ref.
Lr. No. 225/DMO/KMR/PTC /KMS 25-26/KMS 26-27,
Dt. 12-8-2026, for appointment of contractors for
transpiration of Paddy and Gunnies for KMS
2025-26 (Rabi) and KMS 2026-27 (Kharif) season for
contract period i.e., up to 31-3-2027, for sector-02
(Bichkunda and Birkur Mandal), as illegal, arbitrary,
unjust and violation of Article 14 and 19 (1) (g) of the
Constitution of India and consequently direct the
Respondent No.3/ Addl. Collector and EOED TGSCSC
Ltd., District Kamareddy to execute the contract in
favour of the Petitioner in pursuant to the tender
awarded to the Petitioner on 13-8-2026, in respect of
initial
tender
notice
Ref.
Lr.
No.
225/DMO/KMR/PTC/KMC 25-26/KMS 26-27, Dt. 252-2026, issued by the Respondent No.3, in respect of
Sector-02 (Bichkunda and Birkur Mandal ) District
Kamareddy, for KMC / 2025-26(Rabi) and KMC 26-27
(Kharif) Season for remaining period up to 31-3-2027
and to execute the work in the interest of justice and
pass any such other order or orders as this Hon’ble
Court may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of
the case.”
Heard Mr. S. Bhooma Goud, learned counsel
for petitioner, Mr. N. S. Arjun Kumar, learned
Government
Pleader
for
Civil
Supplies
for
respondent No.1 and Mr. K. Devender, learned
Transferred
to IO folder,
before
corrections,
if any.
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
Standing Counsel for Telangana State Civil Supplies
Corporation (for short, ‘TSCSC’) for respondent
Nos.2 to 4.
The grievance of petitioner appears simple and
the
act
of
respondent
authorities
appears
complicated and unknown to law, rather strange to
law.
Learned counsel for petitioner submitted that
office of Additional Collector and EOED, TGCSSCL,
issued a tender notice, dated 25.02.2026 (Ex.P1,
page No.14) for appointment of contractors for
transportation of paddy and gunnies from various
paddy
purchase
godowns/wagons
centers/buffer
centers/storage
to
various
godowns/rice
points/buffer
paddy
mills
purchase
and
other
godowns within and outside the district as entrusted
by TGSCSCL for Kharif Market Season (KMS) 202526, Rabi & KMS 2026-27 Kharif Season i.e.,
01.04.2026 to 31.03.2027.
It is further submitted that petitioner applied
for Sector–2 i.e., Birkur & Bichkunda, a Technical
Tender Form annexed as Ex.P2 at Page No.17 of writ
papers
was
submitted
by
one
Gowrishetty
Venkatesh, Managing Director of M/s. Meher Sai
Transport (petitioner herein). Ex.P3 at Page No.22 is
a Financial Tender (Annexure-VIII) submitted by the
petitioner.
Learned counsel for petitioner submitted that
petitioner was declared as L1 in respect of e-tender
issued for Sector-2 i.e., Bichkunda & Birkur.
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
Learned counsel invited the attention of this Court
to the contents of Ex.P4 at Page No.25 of writ
papers, which is a photocopy of eGP Portal –
Tenders
(e
procurement
by
Government
of
Telangana). Pointing to the contents of Ex.P4, it is
submitted
that
Sector-2,
Birkur
&
Bichkunda
(Kamareddy District) was awarded to the petitioner.
The following are the relevant details pointed out by
the counsel for petitioner from Ex.P4.
“…
Tender Awarded Details
Awarded to
MEHER SAI TRANSPORT
To
substantiate
his
Awarded on
13/8/2026 5:36 PM”
contentions
further,
learned counsel for petitioner invited the attention of
this Court and pointed at the reference in the etender notice to the Letter No.225/DMO/KMR/PTC/
KMS/25-26/KMS/26-27, dated 25.02.2026 (Page
No.14), and also pointed that the same letter
number details are reflected in the photocopy of eGP
Portal – Tenders, where tender was awarded (Page
No.25). Learned counsel further submitted that
these details indicated that the e-tender in respect of
Sector-2 i.e., Bichkunda & Birkur was awarded to
M/s.Meher Sai Transport as per the details in Ex.P4
at Page No.25 (eGP Portal – Tenders) on 13.08.2026.
Learned counsel invited the attention of this
Court to the other e-tender notice issued by the
office of Additional Collector on 12.08.2026 (Page
No.26, Ex.P5) in respect of the same Sector (i.e.,
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
Sector-2 Bichkunda & Birkur) and further pointed
out that the reference number of letter is same as
that of the first e-tender notice, dated 25.02.2026
i.e., letter bearing Lr.No.225/DMO/KMR/PTC/KMS
25-26/KMS 26-27. It is further submitted that this
tender notice also emanated from the office of
Additional
Collector
&
EOED,
TGSCSCL,
Kamareddy, in respect of the same Sector, without
the earlier e-tender notice being cancelled, which
was awarded in favour of petitioner, as the petitioner
was L1.
Learned counsel for petitioner contended that
once the e-tender in respect of Sector-2 (Bichkunda
& Birkur) was awarded in favour of petitioner on
13.08.2026, issuance of e-tender dated 12.08.2026
for the same Sector i.e., Sector-2 (Bichkunda &
Birkur) by the same office is arbitrary, illegal and
needs to be set aside.
On
the
respondents
other
hand,
placed
on
learned counsel
record
two
sets
for
of
instructions received from the office of Additional
Collector dated 07.05.2026 and 17.09.2026.
It is submitted that objections were raised by
one Mr.Sunkara Hanush (L2) in respect of M/s.
Meher Sai Transport, who was L1 in Sector-2 for etender, dated 25.02.2026.
The following are the contents of instructions
received on 07.05.2026:
““TELANGANA STATE CIVIL SUPPLIES COPRORATION
LIMITED
DISTRICT OFFICE : KAMAREDDY
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
Sri V. Victor,
Addl. Collector & EOED
Lr.No.Mktg/Paddy Proc/KMS 2025-26/KMS 2026-27
Date:07.05.2026
To
The VC & Managing Director
TGSCSCL, Hyderabad.
Sir,
Sub:- TGSCSCL – DMO- Kamareddy – Tenders held for the
appointment of paddy & gunny transport contractors
for Rabi 2025-26 and Khariff 2026-27 – Complaint
filed by Sri Hanush Sunkara w.r.t. the conduct of
tenders – Detailed report submitted – Reg.
Ref:-1.Lr.No.PROC/P1/350/PTC
KMS
2025-26-27
Dt.13.04.2026 of the VC & Managing Director,
TGSCSCL, Hyderabad.
2.A/o Sri Hanush Sunkara det.11.03.2026.
3.A/o Meher sai transport Dt.11.03.2026.
4.This office Lr.No.Mktg/1/Paddy Proc/KMS 202526/KMS 2026-27 Dt.13.03.2026
@@@
It is to submit that vide reference 1st cited, the
VC & Managing Director, TGSCSCL Hyderabad has
communicated that Sri Hanush Sunkara who is
participated in paddy & gunny transport tenders for
sector – 2 (Birkur & Bichkunda Mandals) has raised
objections against M/s. Meher said transport who
stood as L1 in paddy & gunny transport tenders for
sector – 2 (Birkur & Bichkunda Mandals). The
objections are as follows.
1. Upload of Black & White scanned copy instead of
colour scanned copy.
2. Missing signature on the sixth page.
3. Incomplete submission of tender document (50 pages
uploaded out of 59).
4. Mismatch of Signatures in partnership deed and RC
books.
5. Incomplete GST document submitted by M/s. Meher
Sai Transport.
In this regard it is to submit that after opening
the technical bid, some mistakes were also found in
tender submitted by the Hanush Sunkara transport
contractors which are as follows:
1.
In financial tender form ASOR rates not written in
words.
2. Signature and stamp not done on EMD Receipt, GST
Certificate, Aadhar & PAN Card.
3. Signature not done on financial bid.
4. Signature and stamp not done on all the vehicle
OFFICE
NOTE
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
documents i.e., RCs, Permit, Fitness, Insurance and
tax documents.
As both the tenderers committed mistakes while
submitting the tender, the Tender Committee decided
to call for a re-tender for Sector-2 (Birkur and
Bichkunda Mandals). However, both the tenderers,
namely M/s. Hanush Sunkara Transport Contractors
and M/s. Meher Sai Transport, have submitted
individual representations vide reference 2nd and 3rd
cited requesting that both tenders be opened and the
contract be awarded to whichever party qualified as
L1.
Accordingly, the tender committee chaired by
the Additional Collector & EOED has considered the
representations and qualified both the tenderers in
technical round in view of the commencement of Rabi
2025-26 season and to ensure smooth functioning of
paddy procurement operations.
After opening the financial bid M/s. Meher Sai
Transport stood as L1 for Sector-2 (Birkur and
Bichkunda Mandals). The details are as follows.
Sl.No
Name of the
Tenderer
M/s. Meher
Sai Transport
M/s. Hanush
Sunkara
Transport
Contractors
ASOR
quoted
78%
Remarks
98.48%
L2
L1
As M/s. Meher Sai Transport stood as L1, the
tender committee has decided to send proposals to
Head Office for approval rates quoted by M/s. Meher
Sai Transport. Accordingly, proposals have been sent
to Head Office vide reference 4th cited.
It is further submitted that the decision taken
by the Tender Committee to open both the tenders was
solely based on the requests made by the two bidders
and in view of the fast approaching of Rabi 2026-27
season, and no external influence was exercised by
anyone.
It is also submitted that the Tender Committee
has forwarded proposals for approval of the rates
quoted by M/s. Meher Sai Transport, who stood as L1.
The rates are not a loss to the public exchequer; on
contrary, they result in savings to public funds, as the
lower rates have been sent for approval.
This is submitted for information and necessary
action.
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
Yours faithfully
Addl. Collector & EOED
TGSCSCL:: Kamareddy
Encl: Ref 2 & 3”
It is observed from the contents of document
dated 07.05.2026 that objections were raised by Sri
Hanush Sunkara in respect of Sector-2 against the
petitioner, who stood as L1.
It is further observed from the contents of the
document, dated 07.05.2026, that after the opening
of the Technical Bid, mistakes were found in the
tender submitted by Hanush Sunkara Transport
Contractors.
It is also observed from the contents of the
document that as the rates quoted by petitioner who
stood as L1 were not a loss to the public exchequer,
on the contrary, they were resulting in saving public
funds, the Tender Committee forwarded proposals
for approval of rates by petitioner.
It is apparent that the petitioner stood as L1
with
lower
rates
and
the
Tender
Committee
forwarded proposals for approval of the rates quoted
by the petitioner.
The instructions, dated 17.09.2026, forwarded
by the office of Additional Collector, EOED, placed
on record by the Standing Counsel are as follows:
TELANGANA STATE CIVIL SUPPLIES CORPORATION LTD
DISTRICT OFFICE KAMAREDDY
---------------------------------------------------------------------------Date:
17.09.2026
From
V. Victor
Additional Collector & EOED,
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
TGSCSCL, Kamareddy
Sir,
Instructions submitted in
WP.No._______/2026 filed by M/s. Meher Sai Transport
represented by Gowrishetty Venkatesh.
A e-Tender notice issued by Additional Collector &
EOED, TGSCSCL Kamareddy, vide Lr. No.225/DMO/KMR/
PTC/KMS25-26/KMS 26-27, Dated 25.02.2026 calling
tenders for (10) sectors in Kamareddy District for
Transportation of paddy and gunnies from various paddy
purchase centers/storage points/buffer godowns/rice mills
and other godowns for KMS 2025-26 (Rabi Season) & KMS
2026-27 (Kharif season) from 01-04-2026 till 31-03-2027.
The Petitioner and M/s. Sunkara Hanush have filed their
Tender bid for Sector-2 (Birkur and Bichkunda).
As per the Tender schedule, First the Technical Bids were
opened Later, Financial Bids were opened. The Technical
Bids were opened before the District Tender Committee
(DTC) consisting of the Additional Collector & EOED,
District Manager-CSC, DCSO, AD (Marketing), RTA and
qualified both tenderers. Later, the Financial Bids were
opened and M/s. Meher Sai Transport stood as L.1 for
Sector 2 (Birkur and Bichkunda Mandals).
Subsequently, the Tender Committee has forwarded
proposals for approval of the rates quoted by M/s. Meher
Sai Transport, who stood as L.1. The rates are not a loss to
the public exchequer, on the contrary, they result in savings
to public funds, as the lower rates have been sent for
approval.
Further, the VC & Managing Director, TGSCSCL
Hyderabad has communicated that Sri Hanush Sunkara
who is participated in paddy & guny transport tenders for
sector - 2 (Birkur & Bichkunda Mandals) has raised
objections against M/s. Meher sai transport who stood as L1
in paddy & guny transport tenders for sector 2 (Birkur &
Bichkunda Mandals) and requested to inquire into the
allegations leveled by the Hanush Sunkara.
In this regard, the Additional Collector & EOED enquired
in this matter and found that both the tenderers committed
mistakes while submitting the tender, the Tender committee
decided to call re-tender for Sector-2 (Birkur & Bichkunda
Mandals) However, both the tenderers, the Petitioner and
M/s. Hanush Sunkara Transport Contractors, have
submitted individual representations requesting both
tenders be opened and the contract be awarded to
whichever party qualifies as L1 and the same communicated
to the VC & Managing Director, TGSCSCL Hyderabad.
In view of the above, the VC & Managing Director,
TGSCSCL Hyderabad, vide Lr.No.Proc/P1/350/PTC KMS
2025-26-27,
Dated
03.08.2026,
upon
careful
consideration of the facts and circumstances of the
case, requested to take necessary action to invite fresh etenders for Sector-2 (Birkur & Bichkunda Mandals) for
the remaining contract period.
OFFICE
NOTE
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
Accordingly, A e-Tender notice issued by Additional
Collector & EOED, TGSCSCL, Kamareddy, vide Lr.
No.225/DMO/KMR/PTC/KMS25-26/KMS 26-27, Dated
12.08.2026 calling tenders for sector-2 (Birkur & Bichkunda
Mandals) in Kamareddy District for Transportation of paddy
and gunnies from various paddy purchase centers/storage
points/buffer godowns/rice mills and other godowns for
KMS 2025-26 (Rabi Season) & KMS 2026-27 (Kharif season)
for remaining contract period i.e., upto 31-03-2027.
(4) tenders were filed ie, 1 K. Maruthi Sanjay, 2 Sunkara
Hanush, 3 Gourishetty Venkatesh and 4 Thirumala
Transport.
On scrutiny it is found that K. Maruthi Sanjay technically
dis-qualified due to Vehicles insurance copies uploaded in
Black & White and Thirumala Transport dis-qualified due to
vehicles original tax receipts not uploaded.
Further Sunkara Hanush has raised his objection on the
petitioner Le, Gowrishetty Venkatesh regarding alteration of
insurance copy as Among the own vehicles declared by the
Gowrishetty Venkatesh, for vehicle number TG 12 U 4502,
the insured name shown on the insurance copy
submitted appears to have been edited/altered.
The same was verified by this office duly scanning the QR
code printed on the uploaded insurance copy and found that
the insurance is registered in the name of Nangunuri
Srikanth who is the previous owner of the vehicle which
is altered as Gowrishetty Venkatesh at the time of
uploading.
In view of the above, the tender committee has decided
to disqualify Sri Gowrishetty Venkatesh due to
alteration of name on insurance document.
After technical verification, financial tender was opened
for the technically qualified tenderer on 07.09.2026. Hence,
Sunkara Hanush stood as L-1 tenderer, the District Tender
Committee has opined that the final ASOR offered by the L-1
tenderer are reasonable and the same was sent to the VC &
Managing Director, TGSCSCL. Hyderabad for approval of
final proposed rate.
It is submitted that the petitioner has no vested or
enforceable right merely by participating in the tender
process, and the action of the respondents is well within the
scope of administrative discretion and in accordance with
the tender conditions. The tender process is neither
arbitrary nor mala fide, but is based on objective
assessment of discrepancies and in furtherance of public
interest. The action is also justified under the doctrine of
maintaining a level playing field among bidders.
Therefore, the learned Standing Counsel is requested to
defend the action of the respondents by justifying the fresh
e-tender awarded to L-1 tenderer as legal, valid, and in
public interest.
Hence it is requested to appraise the above facts to the
Hon'ble High court of Telangana, Hyderabad.
OFFICE
NOTE
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
Yours faithfully,
Additional Collector & EOED
TGSCSCL KAMAREDDY
ADDL. COLLECTOR
KAMAREDDY.”
It defies the logic of this Court as to how the
office of Additional Collector could have issued
another e-tender notice dated 12.08.2026 for the
very same cluster i.e., Sector-2, i.e., Bichkunda &
Birkur, for the same purpose, for the same seasons
and for the same period i.e., from 01.04.2026 to
31.03.2027, without cancelling the e-tender notice
issued on 25.02.2026, in which petitioner was
declared as L1 by the competent authority and the
Tender Committee had forwarded the proposals for
approval of the rates of the petitioner, as lower rates
were quoted by petitioner and there being no loss to
the exchequer.
It is submitted by the learned counsels for the
respondent authorities that the issuance of e-tender
notice, dated 12.08.2026, cannot be found fault
with. It is also submitted that the petitioner herein
and Mr. Sunkara Hanush participated in the tender
process.
It is also pointed out that the petitioner
herein altered the name on insurance document and
hence, was disqualified though being L1 in respect
of e-tender issued on 25.02.2026 for Sector-2. It is
submitted that the respondents would abide by the
directions if any issued by the Court in the facts and
circumstances of the case.
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
Heard learned counsels, perused the record
and considered the submissions.
This Court, on 18.09.2026, dictated the order in
open Court. After noticing that petitioner participated
in 2nd tender and stood disqualified, which was not
brought to the notice of this Court, the matter is
posted
today
under
the
caption
‘ON
BEING
MENTIONED’ and heard.
It was noticed that petitioner participated in
individual capacity in the 2nd tender (12.08.2026)
and was disqualified in the 2nd tender. This writ
petition
is
filed
by
M/s.Meher
Sai
Transport
(Registered
Firm)
represented by
its
Managing
Partner Gowri Shetty Venkatesh.
At Paragraph No.5 of writ affidavit, petitioner
stated that he reliably came to know that in the 2nd
tender, respondent No.4 is the highest bidder and
he was declared as L1 and was awarded the
contract.
It is pleaded before this Court, when the
matter is posted under the caption ‘on being
mentioned’ that the writ petition is filed in the
capacity of the Managing Director of the Firm and
the Firm participated in the First tender and that in
the 2nd tender issued on 12.08.2026, the Managing
Partner participated in his individual capacity and
was disqualified and hence the distinctness.
It is stated in paragraph No.5 of the writ
affidavit that “he reliably came to know that in the
2nd
tender,
respondent
No.4
was
declared
as
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
successful bidder (as L1).”
Though, it is contended that in the writ
petition filed, the challenge is by the Firm and the
petitioner Firm being represented by Managing
Partner, there is a distinctness from the person who
has participated in the 2nd tender in his individual
capacity.
It is not in dispute that the Managing Partner
of the Firm is the very same person who has
participated in the 2nd tender in his individual
capacity.
This fact should have been stated very clearly
in the writ affidavit, for reasons best known, it was
not stated so, in such clear terms, it is only stated
that the Firm has come to know reliably.
Having participated in the tender in his
individual capacity, though being a different juristic
person, still the petitioner Firm being managed by
the very same person cannot plead ignorance. The
minimum he could have done was pleaded the same
in the writ affidavit in a lucid manner.
These facts need to be answered by the
respondent authorities by way of a counter affidavit,
these aspects need to be gone into, at the time of
hearing of the writ petition after filing of a counter
affidavit.
It is submitted to this Court by respondent
counsel that petitioner in his individual capacity has
uploaded a copy of the insurance which was
registered in the name of Nangunuri Srikanth,
OFFICE
NOTE
SL.
NO
DATE
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
ORDER
OFFICE
NOTE
owner of vehicle bearing No.TS 12U 4502 and the
insurance
copy
was
altered
by
Gowrishetty
Venkatesh at the time of uploading.
These facts of participation in the 2nd tender
by Gowrishetty Venkatesh in his personal capacity
for the same Sector-2 Bichkunda & Birkur and the
very same person is representing as Managing
Partner of the Firm have to be heard.
Learned counsel for respondents seeks time to
file counter affidavit with all the documents filed by
the Firm, represented by its Managing Director in
the 1st tender (Gowri Shetty Venkatesh) and also in
his individual capacity in the 2nd tender, having
participated and disqualified in the 2nd tender.
It is trite law that a person who stood
disqualified in the 2nd tender cannot now turn
around by challenging the first tender on the ground
that E-tender issued in February, 2026, has not
been cancelled, though in the individual capacity,
having participated. Matter requires a hearing.
Issue notice to respondent No.4.
Learned counsel for petitioner is permitted to
take
out
personal
notice
on
respondent
No.4
through SPAD and file proof of service by next date
of hearing.
Post the matter on 01.10.2026.
__________
JAK,J
plp
W.P.No.31108 of 2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review