Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
\
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[ 3488 I
THURSDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION NO: 24'103 OF 2025
Between:
M/s. Meghana Avenues Private Limited, Rep. by its Director Sri B.Venkat
Reddy, AgeO 74 Years. H.No.8-3-293/82lNU169, MLA and MP Colony, Plot
No.169, Road No.10/C, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad-500033, Telangana.
...PETITIONER
1. The commissioner of tncome ,r:,::r"ats), Nationat Facetess Appeat
Centrg (NFAC),) lncome Tax Department, Delhi.
2. Assessment Unit, lncome Tax Department, National Faceless Assessment
Centre, lncome Tax Department, Ministry of Finance, Government of lndia,
New Delhi.
3. The Joint Commissioner of lncome Tax, Range 5, lncome Tax Department,
Hyderabad, Telangana.
4. The lncome Tax Officer, Ward 16(3), lncome Tax Department, Hyderabad,
Telangana.
5. Union of lndia, Ministry of Finance, rep. by its Secretary,166-8 North Block,
New Delhi - 110
oo1
..RES'.NDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to. (i). lssue a Writ, Order or Direction. more particularly, one, in the nature of Writ
of Mandamus, declaring the order passed by the Respondent No.1 dated
04.06.2025 in DIN & Order No.|TBA/NFAC/S/250 t2}25-26t 1076684699(1) for the
year 2017-18 upholding the order passed by the 2nd respondent National Faceless
Assessment Centre dated 1911012022 whereby a penalty of an amount of
Rs.40,50,000/- has been imposed on the petitioner under Section 271D read with
Section 274of the lncomeTaxAct, 1961, as illegal, arbitrary, bad in law, void ab
initio, violative of the principles of natural justice and being violative of Articles
14,19 and 265 of the Constitution of lndia, and consequently set aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit file(l in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to grant
stay of all further proceedings for recovery of the penalty pursuant to the order
passed by the 1st respondent dated 0410612025 in DIN & Order
No.ITBA/NFAC Et2SOt 2025-26t1076684699(1) for the yqar 2017-18 upholding the
order passed by the 2nd respondent National Faceless Assessment Centre dated
1911012022 whereby a penalty of an amount of Rs.40,50,0001 has been impo.sed
on the petitioner under Section 271D read with Section 274 of the lncome Tax Act,
1961 and a dernand proceedings dated 16/06/2025, pending disposal of the Writ
Petition.
Gounsel for the Petitioner: SRI B.KRISHNA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.l TO 4: SRI K.SUDHAKAR REDDY, SENIOR
SC INCOME TAX
The Court made the following: ORDER
a
AT HYDERABAD
AND
Dated: Of.03.2026
Between:
IWs.Meghana Avenues Private Limited,
Rep. by its Director Sri B.Venkat Reddy
.Petitioner
and
The Commissioner of [ncome Tax (Appeals)'
National Faceless Appeal Centre (NFAC)'
lncome Tax Department, Delhi and four others
Respondents
ORDER:
Mr. B.Krishna Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioner'
Mr. K.Sudhakar Reddy, learned Senior Standing Counsel
lncome Tax Department for respondent Nos'l
for the
to 4'
2.WhetherpenaltyproceedingsunderSectionzTlDofthelncome
Tax Act, t96t can be initiated on satisfaction being
recorded by the Joint
commissioner on perusal of the assessment records
assessing offrcer is the question involved
instead of the
in the present writ petition?
)
I
3.
Ttre order passed by the first respondent/National Faceless Appeal
centre (NFAC) dated 04.06.202s for rhe assessment year 2ol7-lg
upholding the order passed by the second respondent/National Faceless
Assessm,:nt centre dated lg.l0.zo22, whereby p.nut,y of Rs.40,50,000/-
was imp,lsed upon the petitioner under Section 27lD read with Section
274 of ttre Income Tax Act, 196l (hereinafter reflemed to as.the Act') is
under ch;lllenge in the present writ petition.
4.
The facts relevant for consideration of this issue are briefly stated
as under:
(i'r The petitioner/assessee had filed its retum of income for the
assessment year 2017-18 on 04.11.2017 declaring total income of
Rs.8,60,t1004. The assessee had deposited Rs.14,39,000/- in his bank
accounts during the period of demonetization. Accordingly, proceedings
under Section 147 of the Act were initiated. Notice under Section 148 of
the Act was issued on 31.03.2021 after approval of the competent
authoritl'. The assessment was completed on 15.03.2022.
(ii) The third respondent/Joint commissioner of lncome Tax
issued n,otice under section 274 read with section 27lD of the Act on
28.04.2022 on the basis of information available with the department
that
transacti'Jns carried out by the assessee were in contravention
of
J
)
provisions of section 26955 of the Act. Accordingly, penalty
Rs.40,50,00,000/- was levied on the assessee. The
petitioner challenged it
of on
in appeal before the first respondent. The said appeal was disposed
04.06.2025 confirming the penalty under section
27-lD of the Act' The
petitioner has assailed it on the ground that the penalty
proceedings must
be processed through the Faceless Penalty Scheme with effect
t2.01.2021. However, it was initiated by the Joint
from
commissioner of
lncome Tax, Range-5, Hyderabad on 28.04.2022 and concluded
Faceless Penalty Unit on lg.l}.2)22. Learned counsel
by the
for the petitioner
has relied upon the case of srinivasa Reddy Reddeppagari
vs' Joint
commissioner of Income Tax, central circle, central
Range-2
(w.P.No.44285 of 2ozz,dated 26.12.2022)r and submitted that the
whether without satisfaction being recorded in the assessment
penatty can be levied by the Joint Commissioner under Section
issue
order'
27lD of
the Act was decided in favour of the assessee by this Court'
petitioner has also relied upon the judgment of the Kerala High
I
of
Court in
Grihalakshmi vision vs. Additional commissioner of fncome
Range I, Kozhikode2. The petitioner took a plea that
The
Tax,
pursuant to the said
judgmenr, CBDT Circular No.9/DV/2016, dated 26.04.2016 was issued
to the effect that the assessing officers, below the rank of Joint
I ManuJTLl2245l2022
[ZOtSl 63 taxmann.com 196
(Kerala)
)
Commissioner, may be advised to make a reference to the Range Head
regarding any violation of the provisions of Section 26955 and Section
269T of t-he Act, as the case may be, in the course of the assessment
proceedings. The petitioner submitted that in the reassessment order
passed under Section 147 read with Section l44B of the Act on
15.03.202.2, there is no reference to penalty. There is no mention of
reference made to the Joint Commissioner regarding the said penalty. The
petitioner has also relied upon the case of Commissioner of Income Tax
vs. Jai Laxmi Rice Mills3. According to the petitioner, the assessing
authority has to record the satisfaction regarding the initiation of penalty
proceedings. The High Court of Andhra Pradesh has also in the case of
Grandhi Sri Venkata Amarendra vs. Joint Commissioner of Income
Taxa hetid that satisfaction of the assessing officer is required to be
recorded because the officer, who passed the assessment order would not
be levying the penalty under Section 27lD of the Act, unless it is
recorded in the assessment order, he cannot refer the file to superior
officer, i.e., the Joint Commissioner for initiating levy of penalty. Unless
the assessing officer during assessment proceedings, arrives at a finding
that there has been a violation of the provisions, like Section 26955 of the
Act, the, Joint Commissioner cannot initiate the proceedings to levy
o
lzors; 3;'9 ITR 52t (sc)
lzoz+132.t crR (Ap) 947
\
\
.{.
lh
,j
I
-1
penalty under Section 27lDof the Act. Section2TlD
accepting any loan or deposit otherwise than
penalises taking or
by account payee
However, it is
cheque/drafl/electronic clearance above Rs.20,000/-.
subject to exception of reasonable cause under
Section- 2738 of the Act'
Learned counsel for the petitioner has further
argued that the appellate
authority chose not to appreciate the detailed
submitted in the Grounds of Appeal and
written contentions
proceeded to frnalise the appeal
stating that the authorised representative of the
appellant had not filed any
written submissions or appeared before him. This
is against the principles
of natural justice. The petitioner also relied upon
the decision in respect
of discharge of burden under Section 105 of the Evidence
as in the case of State of uttar Pradesh
5.
Act, 1872' such
vs. Ram Swarups.
affidavit' Learned
The respondent Department has f,rted a counter
counsel for the Revenue has opposed the rvrit
petition on the ground that
the petitioner has an effrcacious alternative remedy
by way of appeal
before the learned lncome Tax Appellate Tribunal
(trAT) against the
orderpassedbytheCommissioneroflncomeTax(Appeal),National
Faceless Appeal centre conftrming the imposition
Section 27lD of the Act. tt has also taken a
plea that the Faceless Penalty
Scheme, 2021 provides for faccless conduct
t RtR t9z+ sc l57o
of penalty under
of penalty proceedings'
I
However, it nowhere prohibits or invalidates the issuance of show cause
notice or initiation of penalty proceedings by the jurisdictional authority
where initiated in accordance with law. The initiation of proceedings
under S,sction 274 read with Section 27lD of the Act by the Joint
commissioner, who is the prescribed authority under Section 27ID(Z)is
therefore: valid and within jurisdiction. [t is fully in accordance with the
statutory mandate. The F'aceless Penalty Scheme is meant to regulate
procedural aspects of conducting penalty proceedings in a faceless
manner, but they did not override or curtail the statutory jurisdiction of
the Joint Commissioner as conferred by the Act.
6.
Leamed counsel for Revenue has also placed reliance on the
decision of the Kerala High court in the case of Grihalakshmi vision
(iupra). It is submitted that the Kerala High court took note of the
decision in D.M.Manasvi vs. commissioner of Income Tax, Gurajat
116 and held that in the said case, penalty was levied under Section
271(l)(c) of the Act. As is evidenr flrom the provision itself, rhe
proceedings under that section are to be initiated on the basis of the
satisfaction of the officers mentioned therein including the assessing
officer. unlike the provisions of section 27\(l)(c), under the provisions
section 27lD and2T lE of the Act, the exclusive authority is conferred on
o
1tttz1 86 trR 557
\
!fl!!
.l:l
r!t.
'l
t
the Joint commissioner.
I
in the case of
Therefore, the principles laid down
i
,
:
D.M.Manasvi(supra)cannotbecalledinaidtoimpugntheconcurrent
I
I
I
frndings of the lower
has
authorities. Learned counsel for the Revenue
also referred to order of
I
I
i
I
the learned IT$T' Mumbai in
i
i
l.T.A.No.139/Mum/2ol2.ItissubmittedthatthelearnedITAThas
i
i
examinedtheissueindetailbyalsoreferringtothejudgmentoftheJai
Laxmi Rice Mills (supra) and observed that
proceedings were initiated by the assessing
assessment proceedings and the
in the said case' the penalty
offrcer during the course of
assessment order was passed to
of his judgment under Section 144 of the
the best
Act. The said ax parte order was
setasidebythelearnedClT(Appeals)andtheassessingofficerwas
directed to frame the assessm ent de
novo. However, the assessing officer
passedpenaltyorderunderSectionzT:lDoftheActonthebasisofthe
observations made in the original assessment
order' The High court took
theviewthattheproceedingsunderSection27|DoftheActarenot
independentproceedingsandthepenaltyorderwouldpractically
submergeinviewoftheorderpassedbytheCommissioneroflncome
Tax(Appeals).Theoriginalassessmentorderwassetasideandthecase
since the assessing officer did not
was remanded for de novoassessment.
refer ro the violation of provisions
of Section 26955 and 269T of the Act
in the said proceedings, the Tribunal
deleted the penalty' The High court
/
/
did not admit the appeal on the ground that no substantial questions of
law arose. Hence, the limited question urged before the apex court was
whether the penalty proceedings under Section 27lD of the Act is
independent of assessment proceedings. This question arose for
consideration in respect of assessment years l99l-92 and, 1992-93. The
Tribunal held that the issue before the apex court was not related to
recording of satisfaction, but whether the penalty proceedings under
Section 27lD of the Act are independent of assessment proceedings.
Since the original assessment order, in case of which the impugned
penalty proceedings were initiated, had been set aside, the apex court
upheld tht: view of the High Court that the penalty proceedings should not
have beer, continued on the strength of the assessment order so set aside.
Hence, all the observations made by the apex court were related to the
question posed before it. It is submitted that the decision of the apex court
in Jai Larmi Rice Mills (supra) has to be understood in that context. It is
further submitted that in the present case, original assessment proceedings
have not been set aside. The penalty proceedings have been initiated by
the competent authority under Section 27lD of the Act on the basis of the
facts nan'ated by the assessing offrcer in the said proceedings. Therefore,
the impugned proceedings are not susceptible to challenge on the point of
jurisdictir>n of the Joint Commissioner of Income Tax.
i
I
i
!It5
.l
I
I
T.Wehaveconsideredthesubmissionsofthelearnedcounselforthe
I
parties and Perused the records'
8.Thefactstakennoteabovedisclosesthat.thereassessment
i
I
I
proceedingswereclosedwithoutanyadditiontotheincomeofthe
I
I
I
assessee'[talsodisclosesthattherewasnoreferencetotheJoint
I
initiate penalty proceedings under
commissioner of lncome Tax to
'l
rl
Sectionz|.iDoftheActintheorderofassessment.TheJoint
il
ril
ii
it
CommissioneroflncomeTax,thereafterissuednoticedated2S.04.2022
requiring the petitioner
il
27lD
to explain as to why penalty under Section
,t
/
ii
ii
I
oftheActshouldnotbeleviedforviolationoftheprovisionsofsection
i
I
;
26gssoftheAct.TheappellantsubmittedexplanationbeforetheJoint
commissioner of [ncome Tax. It is
submitted that lands sold at Nakrekal'
Nalgonda District and Mahaboobabad
District were purchased by persons
whowerenon-taxassessees.Theamountsreceivedbythefarmerswere
officer did not
as genuine. The assessing
accepted by the assessing offrcer
The assessing officer did not
dispute the genuineness of the transactions'
i
I
I
l
I
,l
I
:l
I
t
initiate proceedings under Section
27lD of the Act or any other penalty
proceedings. The amounts were received
against the sale of property
and
,l
werepartofamountsrecordedintheregistereddocuments.Theincome
from the said transactions was also
disclosed in the returns of income
and
/
l0
I
I
was accepted by the assessing officer. The Joint Commissioner of [ncome
Tax did not accept the explanation and levied penalty of Rs.40,50,000/under Section 27lD of the Act. The order of the Joint Commissioner was
upheld by the National Faceless Appeal Centre, Delhi observing that the
appellant despite several opportunities had failed to make any
submissions in support of the appeal. Therefore, it was not interested in
prosecuting the appeal. The appellate authority quoted number of
judgments on the point that if an assessee fails to participate in the
proceedin.gs and it has not adduced in evidence, the appeal is liable to be
disrnissecl. The appeal was accordingly dismissed upholding the order of
the Joint,Commissioner.
9.
Ar; referred to in the opening paragraph of this judgment, the
question posed t<l be answered is whether in the absence of any
satisfaction rccorded by the assessing oflicer for initiation of penalty or
referring the matter for initiation of penalty proceedings, the Joint
Commisr;ioner for lncome Tax could in exercise of the power under
Section .271D(2) of the Act initiate the proceedings on its own on the
ground of violation of Section 26955 of the Act.
10. S,:ctions 26955 and 27lD of the Act are extracted hereunder for
appreciation of the issue involved in this case.
)
)
fi
l1
i
I
:
"section 269-55 of the Act:
:;
269-55. Mode of taking or accepting certain loans, deposits and
specified sum:- No peison shaLl take or accept from any other
plr.on (herein referred to as the depositor), any loan or deposit or
any specified sum, otherwise than by an account payee cheque or
account payee bank draft or use of electronic clearing system
through a bank account or through such other electronic mode as
may be prescribed,
if,-
(a) the amount of such loan or deposit or specified sum-or
the aggregate amount of such loan, deposit and specified
sum; or
(D)onthedateoftakingoracceptingsuchloanordepositor
splcified sum, any loan or deposit or specified sum taken or
accepted earlier by such person from the depositor is
."*"iningunpaid(whetherrepaymenthasfallendueornot),
the amount or the aggregate amount remaining unpaid; or
(c) the amount or the aggregate arnount referred to in clause
(a) together with the amount or the aggregate amount
refened to in clause (D),
is twentY thousand rupees or more:
Provided that the provisions of this section shall not apply to any
loan or deposit or ipecified sum taken or accepted from, or any loan
or deposit or specified sum taken or accepted
by,-
(a) the Government;
iai unv banking company, post office savings bank or cooperative bank;
(c) any corporation established by a Central, State or
Provincial Act;
(A any Government company as defined in clause (a5) of
Section 2 of the Companies Act,20l3 (18 of 2013);
(e) such other institution, association or body or class of
institutions, associations or bodies which the Central
Government may, for reasons to be recorded in writing'
noti$ in this behalf in the Official Gazette:
provided further that the provisions of this section shall not apply to
any loan or deposit or specified sum, where the person from whom
the loan or deposit or ipecified sum is taken or accepted and the
person by whom the loan or deposit or specified sum is taken or
u"""pt"O, are both having agricultural income and neither of them
has any income chargeable to tax under this Act'
'
I
lr
t2
(
!
Provided also that the provisions of this section shall have effect, as
if for the words "twenty thousand rupees", the words "two lakh
rupees" had been substituted in the case of any deposit or Ioan
rvhere,-
(a) such deposit is accepted by a primary agricultural credit
society or a primary co-operative agricultural and rural
development bank from its member; or
(D) such loan is taken from a primary agricultural credit
societl, or a primary co-operative agricultural and rural
development bank by its member.
For the purposes of this section,(i) "banking
company" means a company to which the
provisions of theBanking Regulation Act, 1949 (10 of
1949) applies and includes any bank or banking institution
referred to in Section 5l ofthat Act;
Explanation
(ii) "co-operative bank", "primary agricultural credit
sociew" and "primary co-operative agricultural and rural
development bank" shall have the meanings respectively
assigned to them in the Explanation to sub-section (4) of
Section 80-P;
(iii) "loan or deposit" means loan or deposit of money;
(iv) "specified sum" means any sum of money
receivable, rvhether as advance or otherwise, in relation to
transfer of an immovable property, whether or not the
transfer takes place.
Section 27lD of the Act:
271-D. Penalt5r for failure to comply with the provisions of
S,ection 269-55:- (l) If a person takes or accepts any loan or
deposit or specified sum in contravention of the provisions of
Section 269-55, he shall be liable to pay, by way of penalty, a sum
equalto the amount of the loan or deposit so taken oraccepted.
(2) Any penalty imposable under sub-section (l) shall be
imposed by the Joint Commissioner:
f'rovided that any penalty under sub-section (l), on or after the lst
ctay of April ,2025. shall be imposed by the Assessing Officer."
I l.
The reassessment order under Section 147 read with Section l44B
of the A.ct, dated 15.03.2022 relatable to the assessment year 2017-18
reads as under:
'!i
r3
"[n this case, the assessee company f,rled its lncome Tax
declaring
Return on 4.1 l.2ol7 for the Assessment Yeat 2017-18
income at Rs.8,60,800/- and the same was processed u/1
l 3 (l) of
in the
the lncome Tax Act, t961. As per information available
in his
department, the assessee has deposited cash of Rs' 14,38'000/During enquiry
bank accounts during the period of demonetization.
the source of
specifically
Frle
to
f"il"d
proceedings, the asiesst.
details of
the
fumished
not
has
each of [e cash deposit and
'Rs'14'38'000/of
amount'
the
advances received- As such,
Tax
remained unexplained and proceedings u/s 147 of the Income
of
deposits
cash
Act, l96l were intimatid to assess the
of
p9li99
Rs.i4,38,000/-, which was deposited during the
196l was
demonetization. Notice u/s 148 of the Income Tax Act'
competent
issued on 31.03.2021 after obtaining approval of the
authority.
In response to the notice issued tr/s 148 of the Income Tax
Act, 1961, t-he assessee filed its lncome Tax Return on 5'5'2021
lncome
a"cia.ing in.o." at Rs.8,60,800/-' Notice,/s 143 (2) of the
TaxAct,lg6lwasissuedtotheassesseeon2S'12'202landin
,*p;"'to the notice, the assessee filed the requisite information.
During
The assessee is engaged to operate construction activities'
residential
the Fy 2016-17, ro.ir"" of income of the assessee was
book for
cash
of
sheets
three
the
villas. The information, including
was
assessee
the
by
filed
the period l.g.2016 to 31.2.2016,
no
and
case
the
re-opening
examined with reference to the reason
2.
adverse inference is drawn. Hence, returned income of
is accepted."
the assessee
12. The proceedings under Section 27lD of the Act were initiated by
the Joint Commissioner on the ground that during the assessment
the assessee had accepted an amount of Rs.40,00,000/- in cash
customers on sale of plots/residential house as advance/initial
year'
from its
payment'
The details of cash received were enumerated in the form of
a chart'
which showed that such amounts were received from various
persons
exceeding Rs.20,000/- during the assessment year in violation
of Section
26955 of the Act. The assessee took the plea that the assessee
had sold its
land to various persons who are farmers. They were unable
to make the
!
i
l4
(
I
payment in cheque and gave the money in cash. The accountant
unknowin;gly collected cash and deposited in the bank. The amount
collected liom its customers was below Rs.2 lakhs from every individual.
The deposrited amount is in the form of cash receipt for sale of individual
plots. Acr:ording to the assessee, under Section 2695T of the Act, a
person should not receive an amount of Rs.2 lakhs or more except by way
of an accrount payee cheque, bank draft or electronic clearing system
through a bank account or any other electronic mode in respect of a single
transaction. Therefore, the question of applying Section 26955 and
i
I
levying the penaltl, under Section 27lD of the Act does not arise. The
amounts have been treated as cash receipts and deposited in bank. He
:j
;:
ii
ii
ii
ii
made 416:quest to drop the penalty proceedings as it is within the purview
of, Section 2695T of the Act
ti
li
li
ii
'i
13. [n the light of these facts. it is relevant to refer to the CBDT
i
i
Circular No.09/DV12016 (departmental view), dated 26.04.2016 on the
subject c'f limitation for penalty proceedings under Section 27lD and
27lE of the Act. l-he circular made reference to the decision in the case
of Grihalakshmi vision (supra) rendered by the Kerala High Court. The
I
observations made therein have been treated as 'the departmental view'
and are extracted hereunder:
l5
..3. The Hon'ble Kerala High court in the case of Grihalaxmi
vision v. Addl. commissione, of In.ome Tax, Range l, Kozhikode
(Available in NJRS 2015-LL-0807-4) vide its order dated 8.7.15 in
ite Nos.gl & *6 of 2014, observed that "Question to be
initiated
considered is whether proceedings for levy of penalty' are
*ill, ,|rc passing of the order of assessment by the Assgssing Oficer
or whetie^uih pro"rrdings-hae commenced with the instance of
lhe notice issuei by the Joint Commissioner' From statutory
plrorisun, it is cleai that rhe competent authority 1o,le2 pen?lty
'bring the Joint Commissioner- Therefore' gnly the Joint
Srch
Conimissioner can initiare proceedings for levy of penalty'
Assessing
by
the
initiation of proceedings ,oild not have been done
officer. Ti;srarcmenlin the ossessment order that the proceedings
uider Secrion 271D and E are initiated is inconsequential. On the
of
other hand, if the assessmenl order is taken as the initiation
who. is
penalty procLedings, such initiation is by an aytltority
'inro,iprr"nt and tie proceedings thereafter would be proceedings
withoit authority who f incompetent and the proceedings
be so,
thereafter would'be proceedings without iurisdiction. If that
oJ
issuance
the
with
the initiarion of the penalty p,iceedings is only
to
assessee
the
the notice issied iy the Joint Commissioner to
which he hasfiled his rePlY;'
The above judgment reflects the "Departmental Yi:t'''
Accordingly, the Asslssing Officers (below the rank of Joint
4.
reference
Comrnissioner of lncome Tax) may be advised to make a
of
provisions
the
of
to the Range Head, regarding any violation
in
be'
may
case
as
the
Section 26955 and Sectlon Ziqf of the Act,
proceed-ings
the course ofthe assessment proceedings (or any other
Joint
under the Act). The Assessing Officer, (below the rank of
this
in
commissioner of lncome Tax) shall not issue the notice
regard. The Range Head will issue the penalty- notice and shall
lhe proceedings within the limitation prescribed
dilpose/complete
u/s 275(l)(c) of the Act."
14. A perusal thereof would show that the Joint Commissioner can
initiate proceedings for levy of penalty. Such initiation of proceedings
should not be done by the assessing officer. The statement in
the
assessment order that the proceedings under Sections 27lD and271E
of
the Act initiated are inconsequential. On the other hand, if the assessment
order is taken as the initiation of penalty proceedings, such initiation
is by
)
-t
t6
r
an authcrrity who is incornpetent and the proceedings thereafter would
be
the proceedings rvithout jurisdiction. If that be so, the initiation of the
penalty proceedings is only with the issuance of the notice by the
Joint
commissioner to the assessee to which he ha.s filed his reply. This
observalion of the Kerala High court in the case of Grihalakshmi vision
(supra), has been adopted as .the departmental view'.
15. From the discussion made hereinabove, it is apparent that the
CBDT Oircular, dated 26.04.2016 issued on the basis of the observations
i
,j
:]
.:i
in Grihalakshmi vision (supra) by the Kerala High court is on the
subject ,rf limitation for initiation of penalty proceedings under Section
ii
rl
it
27lD and2TlE of the Act, wherein it has been held that the competent
jl
'iiil
iI
authorit;r to levy penalty is Joint Cornmissioner and not the assessing
il
dfficer. on the other hand, in the case of srinivasa Reddy
Reddeppagari (supra), a coordinate Bench of this Court has referred
to
the case of Jaya Laxmi Rice Milts (supra) and categorically recorded
that the Supreme court had concurred with the view taken by the High
court trolding that satisfaction must be recorded in the original
asS€SSrrlrsot order for the purpose
of initiation of penalty proceedings
under st:ction 27lE of the Act. Sections 27lE and 27lD of the Act
pari ma,teria. when there is a decision of the suprerne
bounden duty of an adjudicating authority,
arc in
court, it is the
be it an income tax authority
\
t7
or any other civil authority or for that matter any court in the country, to
comply with the decision of the Supreme Court. The very issue involved
I
I
i
I
in the present writ petition, whether without satisfaction being recorded in
the assessment order, penalty can be levied by the Joint Commissioner
under Section 27lD of the Act was in question in the case of Srinivasa
Reddy Reddeppagari (supra). As such, we do not find any grounds
made out by the Revenue to take a different view in the instant case.
16. Accordingly, the order, dated 19.10.2022, imposing penalty by the
second respondent under Section 27lD read with Section 274 of the Act
and the appellate order dated 04.06.2025 upholding the same by the first
respondent are set aside.
17. The writ petition is accordingly allowed. There shall be no order as
to costs.
Miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
A. SREENIVASA REDDY
//TRUE
To
SECTION OFFICER
1. The Commissioner of lncome Tax
Centre (NFAC)
2. Assesliienruii
Centre, lncome
New Delhi.
Faceless Appeal
Faceless Assessment
Government of lndia,
3. The Joint commissioner of Income Tax, Range s, lncome Tax Department,
Hyderabad,Telangana.
- The
4.
lncome Tax dfficer, ward 16(3), rncome Tax Department, Hyderabad,
Telangana
5. ln9 -seg1eJary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Finance, 166-8 North Block, New
Delhi - 110 001
6. One CC to SRI B.KRISHNA REDDY, Advocate tOpUCI
7. ONC CC tO SRI K.SUDHAKAR REDDY, SENION SC IIrrbOUrC TAX TOPUC]
8. Two CD Copies
PSK.
GJP
N,
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:05/03/2026
ORDER
WP.No.24403 of 2025
1 HES
31 5
APB
t:(
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
I
\
frL'
2026 X
*
-t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review