Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 24th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 15848 of 2023
BETWEEN:1.
M/S MASTER POINT THROUGH PARTNER
JAGDISH CHOUHAN S/O LATE SHRI MANIRAM
CHOUHAN, AGED 64 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
BUSINESS
READYMADE
GARMENTS
COMPLEX
DISTRICT
INDORE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
MASTER POINT (PROPRIETOR FIRM) THROUGH
PROPRIETOR JAGDISH CHOUHAN S/O LATE SHRI
MANIRAM CHOUHAN, AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: BUSINESS 140 READYMADE
GARMENTS
COMPLEX
DISTRICT
INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(SHRI ABHINAV DHANODKAR, COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS).
AND
SMT. SANDHYA CHOUHAN W/O SHRI RAJENDRA
CHOUHAN, AGED 51 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS
RESIDING AT 138 GH SCHEME NO. 54 DISTRICT
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(SHRI PARESH JOSHI, COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT).
This petition coming on for admission this day, Justice Sushrut Arvind
Dharmadhikari passed the following:
ORDER
Heard on the question of admission.
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 25-012024 16:50:45
I n this petition under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioners have challenged the validity, propriety and legality of the order dated
30.06.2023 passed in Arbitration Case by the Sole Arbitrator wherein the
application under Section 16(3) read with Section 32 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act of 1996 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Act of 1996') was
dismissed.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that the respondent and petitioner No. 2
entered into partnership vide agreement dated 07.01.2010 for carrying out
business and for the said purpose, they had purchased an under-constructed
shed in the year 2005 and the entire consideration for the purchase of the land
was allegedly made by respondent (claimant). A dispute arose between the
petitioner No.2 and respondent due to dissolution of the partnership firm M/s
Master Point (petitioner No.1).
It is alleged that petitioner No.2 in collusion
with his sons malafidely took signatures of the respondent and her husband
under pretext of obtaining credit facility and thereafter executed Deed of
Dissolution of partnership firm dated 27.04.2017. Thereafter, respondent filed
an application A.C.No. 40/2021 under Section 11 of the Act of 1996 before this
Court seeking appointment of the Arbitrator. The said application was allowed
vide order dated 28.10.2022 appointing Hon'ble Shri Justice I.S.Shrivastava
(Retd.) as the Arbitrator.
3. Before the Arbitral Tribunal, the petitioners filed an application under
Section 16(3) read with Section 32 of the Act of 1996 contending that as per the
respondent/claimant, the entire case is based on the alleged fraud and forged
deed of Dissolution of Partnership dated 27.04.2017, therefore, the matter is
non-arbitrable in nature.
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 25-012024 16:50:45
4 . Vid e impugned order dated 30.06.2023, while dealing with the
application under Section 16(3) read with Section 32 of the Act of 1996, the
Arbitrator observed that the mere allegation of fraud was not sufficient to
detract from the obligation of parties to submit their dispute to arbitration. It
was further held that the petitioners have failed to raise the objection on the
latest opportunity under Section 4 of the Act of 1996 therefore, their right to
raise the objection has been waived. Being aggrieved, the petitioners have
approached this Court by filing the present writ petition
failed
5.
Learned counsel for petitioners contended that the Arbitrator has
to
consider the fact that from the very initial stage, the
respondent/claimant has raised the issue pertaining to fraud and forgery and has
reportedly specified the same before adjudicating authority stating that her right
in rem got affected.
Learned Tribunal has also failed to considered the
objections raised by the petitioners in Statement of Defense and application
under Section 16(3) read with Section 32 of the Act of 1996 that the subject
matter cannot be adjudicated before the learned Arbitral Tribunal. In support of
his contention, learned counsel for the petitioners has relied upon the judgment
of the Apex Court in case of A.Ayyasamy vs. A.Parmasivam & Ors. AIR
2016 SC 4675, wherein it has been held that :
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 25-012024 16:50:45
''In view of our aforesaid discussions, we are of the opinion that mere allegation of
fraud simplicitor may not be a ground to nullify the effect of arbitration agreement
between the parties. It is only in those cases where the Court, while dealing with
Section 8 of the Act, finds that there are very serious allegations of fraud which
make a virtual case of criminal offence or where allegations of fraud are so
complicated that it becomes absolutely essential that such complex issues can be
decided only by civil court on the appreciation of the voluminous evidence that
needs to be produced, the Court can sidetrack the agreement by dismissing
application under Section 8 and proceed with the suit on merits. It can be so done
also in those cases where there are serious allegations of forgery/fabrication of
documents in support of the plea of fraud or where fraud is alleged against the
arbitration provision itself or is of such a nature that permeates the entire contract,
including the agreement to arbitrate, meaning thereby in those cases where fraud
goes to the validity of the contract itself of the entire contract which contains the
arbitration clause or the validity of the arbitration clause itself.''
6 . Learned counsel for the petitioners contended that the Arbitral
Tribunal has failed in considering the fact that the subject matter of dispute prior
to settlement of account of the partnership firm, is the manner in which the deed
of dissolution of partnership has been executed or the manner in which the
partnership firm M/s Master Point got dissolved. The adjudication as to the
manner of dissolution of partnership firm by fraud and forgery can only be
exercised by a civil court. In view of the aforesaid, it is prayed that the petition
may be allowed, impugned order be quashed and the Arbitral Tribunal be
directed to terminate the arbitration proceedings as the same is not arbitrable.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent contended that the
present petition has been filed by the petitioners being aggrieved by the
dismissal of their application under Section 16(3) of the Act of 1996. There is
no remedy under the Act of 1996 against dismissal of the application under
Section 16(3). It is only after passing of the final award that the issue can be
raised in appeal under Section 34 of the Act of 1996. In support of his
contention, learned counsel for the respondent relied on the judgment of the
Apex Court in case of Deep Industries Ltd. vs. Oil and Natural Gas
Corporation Ltd. & Anr., (2020) 15 SCC 706 wherein the aforesaid position
has been settled as follows:
''The drill of Section 16 of the Act is that where a Section 16 application is dismissed,
no appeal is provided and the challenge to the Section 16 application being dismissed
must await the passing of a final award at which stage it may be raised under
Section 34. What the High Court has done in the present case is to invert this
statutory scheme by going into exactly the same matter as was gone into by the
arbitrator in the Section 16 application, and then decided that the two year ban was
no part of the notice for arbitration issued on 02.11.2017, a finding which is directly
contrary to the finding of the learned Arbitrator dismissing the Section 16 application.
For this reason alone, the judgment under appeal needs to be set aside. Even
otherwise, as has been correctly pointed out by Mr. Rohatgi, the judgment under
appeal goes into the merits of the case and states that the action of putting the
Contractor and his Directors “on holiday” is not a consequence of the termination of
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 25-012024 16:50:45
the agreement. This is wholly incorrect as it is only because of the termination that
the show cause notice dated 18.10.2017 proposing to impose a two year ban was
sent. Even otherwise, entering into the general thicket of disputes between the
parties does not behove a court exercising jurisdiction under Article 227, where only
jurisdictional errors can be corrected."
8. Learned counsel for the respondent also relied on the judgment in case
of SBP & Co. vs. Patel Engineering Ltd. and Another, (2005) 8 SCC 618,
wherein the Apex Court in paragraph 45 and 46 has categorically dealt with the
aspect as to whether a petition under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution
against rejection of application under Section 16 of the Act of 1996 would be
maintainable or not. Hence, it is prayed that the impugned order passed by the
Arbitral Tribunal does not suffer from any illegality and therefore, this petition
deserves to be dismissed.
9.
10.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
The Apex court in case of Bhaven Construction Through
Authorised Signatory Premjibhai K. Shah vs. Executive Engineers
Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Ltd. & Anr., (2002) 1 SCC referring to
the aforesaid observation in Deep Industries Ltd. vs. Oil & Natural Gas
Corporation Ltd. & Anr., (2020) 15 SCC 706 has held as follows :
"20. In the instant case, Respondent No. 1 has not been able to show exceptional
circumstance or 'bad faith' on the part of the Appellant, to invoke the remedy under
Article 227 of the Constitution. No doubt the ambit of Article 227 is broad and
pervasive, however, the High Court should not have used its inherent power to
interject the arbitral process at this stage. It is brought to our notice that subsequent
to the impugned order of the sole arbitrator, a final award was rendered by him on
merits, which is challenged by the Respondent No.1 in a separate Section 34
application, which is pending."
11. A petition under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India can
be filed challenging the order of the arbitral tribunal dismissing application under
Section 16 of the Act, only if the possible conclusion is that there is a patent
lack in inherent jurisdiction. Nothing has been indicated in the present case
showing patent inherent lack of jurisdiction.
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 25-012024 16:50:45
12.
This Court while dealing with similar issue in case of Suncity
Dhoot Colonizers Pvt. Ltd. vs. Ram Chandra Patidar, in W.P.No.
28151/2023 dated 16.01.2024 has held as under:
''25. The principle which culls out from the aforesaid decisions of the Hon'ble Court
is that petition under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India can be invoked on
the ground of patent lack in inherent jurisdiction or exceptional circumstances or 'bad
faith' of the opposite party. It is already found that none of the aforesaid grounds
exist so far as the present case is concerned. Since the petitioner is not left
remediless and has a chance of appeal under Section 34 of the Act, we find
substance in the submissions of the learned counsel for the respondent. Hence the
petition under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India is not maintainable.
26. Bearing in mind the principles laid down by the Apex Court Deep Industries
Ltd. (supra) and Bhaven Construction (supra) specifying the extent of
application of provisions under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India to
proceedings under Arbitration Act, are not maintainable.
27. In view of the aforesaid reasons, we allow the preliminary objection raised by the
respondent in the light of the judgment in case of SBP & Co. (supra) and hold that
the writ petition under Article 226 or 227 of the Constitution of India is not
maintainable against every order passed by arbitral tribunal or sole arbitrator until and
unless exceptional circumstances or 'bad faith' of the opposite party has been shown
in the petition.''
13. In view of the aforesaid pronunciation of law and in the light of the
principle laid down by the Apex Court in the aforementioned cases as well as
by this Court in case of Suncity Dhoot (supra), this Court does not find any
ground to intervene with the impugned order by exercising powers under Article
226 or 227 of the Constitution of India.
14.
However, the petitioners would be at liberty to wait until the final
award is pronounced and thereafter, avail the remedy of appeal as available to
them under the Act of 1996 raising all these questions, as the case may be.
15.
Accordingly, this petition, being devoid of merit and substance
stands dismissed.
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
vidya
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 25-012024 16:50:45
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
Signed by: SREEVIDYA
Signing time: 25-012024 16:50:45
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review