Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: '13800 OF 2025
Between:
M/s M.V.R Associates, Rep. by its Managing Partner, l\,4. Surrender Reddy, S/o
M.Venkateswara Reddy, Aged 45 years, Office at 3-43, Gandhasiri Village,
Mudigonda [Vlandal, Khammam-5071 58.
...PETITIONER
AND
The Union of lndia, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Finance
Department, Jeevan Deep Building, Sansad [\/arg, New Delhi.
The Reserve Bank of lndia, Represented by its Regional Director, 6-1-56,
Secretariat Road, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
3. The Managing Director and CEO, Union Bank of lndia, Union Bank Bhavan,
239, Nariman Point, Mumbai, Maharashtra-4O0021 .
4. The Regional Head, Khammam, lt/SME loan point, D.No.5-7-H00019, Swati
Towers, Opp. Janpahad Dargah, Cheruvu Bazar, Manikya Nagar Basti,
Khammam, Telangana 507 0O2.
5. The Branch Manager, Union bank of lndia, BURHANPURAM Branch Door no
11-10-7435, opposite to DRDA complex Burhanpuram khammam-507001.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue writ or direction preferably Writ of lVlandamus declaring action of the
Respondents No.3 to 5 in issuing the impugned recall notice daled 2410412025
proposing to classify the petitioners account vide CC Account No.
1 381 1 5010000006 including all facilities as a Non-Performing Asset (NPA) with
effect from 3110312025 (With retrospective effect) and withdrawing all the credit
I
facilities granted to the petitioner is illegal, arbitrary and violation of principles of
naturaljustice and consequentially set aside the said impugned notice.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all the further proceedings in pursuance of the impugned recall notice dated
2410412025 issued by the Respondent No.s pending disposal of the main writ
petition.
lA NO: 2 OF 202s
BETWEEN
1. The Branch ltrlanager, Union bank of lndia, BURHANPURAM Branch Door no
11-1O-7435, opposite to DRDA complex Burhanpuram khammam-507001.
...Vacate Petitioner/Respondent No 5
AND
'1
. M/s M.V.R Associates, Rep. by its Managing Partner, M. Surrender Reddy,
S/o M.Venkateswara Reddy, Aged 45 years, Office at 3-43, Gandhasiri
Village, Mudigonda Mandal, Khammam-507158.
...RespondenV writ petitioner
2. The Union of lndia, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Finance
Department, Jeevan Deep Building, Sansad Marg, New Delhi.
3. The Reserve Bank of lndia, Represented by its Regional Director, 6-1-56,
Secretariat Road, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
4. The Managing Director and CEO, Union Bank of lndia, Union Bank Bhavan,
239, Nariman Point, Ivlumbai, Maharashtra-400021 -
5. The Regional Head, Khammam, MSME loan point, D.No.5-7-H00019, Swati
Towers, Opp. Janpahad Dargah, Cheruvu Bazar, Manikya Nagar Basti,
Khammam, Telangana 507002.
.........Respondents
Petition under Section '151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate
the interim order dated 30.04.2025 passed by this Hon'ble Court in l.A No. 01 of
2025 in WP. No. 13800 of 2025 and dismiss the W.P with exemplary costs in the
interest of justice.
lA NO: 3 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to fix an
early date of hearing in WP. No. 13800 of 2025 in the interest of justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI M. V. HANUMANTHA RAO
'
Counsel for ihe Respondent No 1: SRI N. BHUJANGA RAO,
DEPUry SOLICITOR GENERAL OF :NDIA
Counsel for the Respondent No 2 : M/S N. LEGAL HYDERABAD
Counsel for the Respondent No 5: SMT V. DYUMANI
Counsel for the Respondents No 3 & 4: -The Court made the following: ORDER
e<{'J
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATT OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 138OO OF 2025
2L.OL.2026
Between:
M/s MVR Associates
Rep. by its Managing Partner
M. Surrender Reddy
..... Petitioner
And
The Union of India,
Rep. by its Principal Secretar5z,
Finance Department,
& others.
. -.
. Respondents
ORDER:
Aggrieved by the action of the 5ft respondent in
issuing recall notice dated 24.O4.2025 classifying petitioner's
MSME Suvidha CC Account No. 138115010000006 including
ai1 facilities as a Non-Performing Asset (NPA, effective from
3L.O3.2O25 and withdrawing all the credit facilities granted to
petitioner, this Writ Petition is l-rled.
2.
The case of petitioner partnership firm which is
doing business of Dealership for Tractor Sales, Service in the
name and styte'MVR Associates' uide Firn Registration No. 660
It
...-.-:---.......
of 2022, is that as a part of expansion of business, they
obtained credit facility from the 5ft respondent bank. The bank
sanctioned credit facility to arr extent of Rs.6,00,00,OOO l- uide
LR. No. MLPlKMMl2023-24/S-l lA, dated 29.O4.2023, bearing
[,oan Account No: Union MSME Suvidha No.
138115O 10000006. For this purpose, petitioner provided
collateral security by depositing their propergr title deeds.
2.1.
It is stated, petitioner is routing its sale
transactions into the said account and utilized the credit limit.
Due to slackness in business, they agreed to reduce its credit
limit by One Crore before December 3 1 , 2024 and, also would
reduce its credit limit to Three Crores on or before 3 I .03.2025.
After taking into consideration petitioner's regular payment into
the CC account, KYC documents, stock statements and
inventory, respondent-Bank renewed the loan on 18. 1 1.2024 for
the period up to 17.O5.2025.
2.2.
Petitioner is stated to have made representation
dated 11.O4.2025 to the 5ft respondent seeking time for
reducing the credit limit to Three Crores till 30.06.2025,
however, the latter denied the same and asked to issue another
representation with modihed terms stating that they would
reduce credit fimit by One Crore before 3O.O4.2O25 and also
J
would reduce credit limit to Three Crores on or before
30.06.2025. While so, respondent-Bank without any notice as
per RBI guidclines, issued the impugned recall notice dated
24.04.2025 on the ground that there is a persistent default on
the part of petitioner, classifying it as NPA effective from
31.03.2025, which, according to petitioner, is bad in law.
2.3.
It is contended that renewed loan is sanctioned on
18.11.2024 and as per the agreed terms and conditions of
reneu,al 'in case of non-improvement of routing in next six
months, branch is advised to explore reducing the limits as
mentioned in the note'. The six months period ends with
17.05.2025, hence the impugned notice dated 24.04.2025 is
issued much prior to the agreed terms and conditions. It is also
stated, petitioner is paying interest regularly and the last
payme nt is dated 31.03.2025. As per the guidelines on Fair
Practices Code for lenders, a prior notiie to the borrowers be
given before taking coercive action. As per 'Framework for
Revival and Rehabilitation of MSMEs', before a loan account of
Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise turns into NPA, Banks or
creditors are required to identifu incipient stress in the account
by creating three sub-categories under the Special Mention
l
Account (SMA). Since petitioner is paying interest regularly and
there is no default, the question of NPA does not arise.
2.4.
As per RBI Circular in regard to NPA/lncome
Recognition, once debt continues to be in default for a period of
90 days, there are various stages before that i.e. SMAO, SMAI,
SMA2 and then NPA. Without issuing any notice/ intimation of
default much less without categorizing as a special mention
account, respondent-Bank issued the impugned notice, is the
grievance of petitioner. It is vehemently contended that as per
the principles laid down by the MSMED Act and also the RBI
Circulars, for every account to be categorized as NPA, prior
notices of default are to be given to the borrower, however,
respondent-Bank failed to issue such notices.
3.
While issuing notice, this Court by order dated
3O.O4 .2025 granted interim stay
of all further proceedings
pursuant to the impugned notice of the 5e respondent.
4.
The 50 respondent Bank filed counter mainly
stating that there is no turnover as projected by petitioner and
the stoek which is available as-' a primary securigr is not
sufficient for the limit already availed by them. At the request of
petitioner, Bank renewed the CC limit subject to the terms and
conditions dated 18.11.2024 rnentoned in the sanction letter. It
*--
,/
t
--/
is clearly mentioned therein that the limit should be reduced by
One Crore by 31.12.2024 and further limit of Tiro Crores should
be reduced by 31.03.2025 and the total CC limit should be
brought down to Three Crores by 3 1.03.2025. However,
petitioner failed to bring the limits as per the terms of the
sanction letter. It is stated, because of the non-compliance of
sanction terms arrd non-availability of drawing power, the
Statutory Auditors appointed by RBI have written MOC '... The
account is over drawn beyond drawing power as well as
sanction limit. In view of above, the account is classilied as
substandard' and directed to classify the account as NPA with
effect from 31.03.2025 and accordingly, respondent-Bank
classihed the account as NPA.
4.1
.
It is also stated, the lis is regarding contractual
obligations that too in respect to the credit norms, hence, a writ
under Article 226 of the Constitution is not maintainable.
5.
Petitioner hled reply mainly stating that it has
already deposited Rs. One Crore into the cash credit account
and submitted e mail representation dated lO.O7 .2025
requesting the bank to reduce the sanction limit to Rs. Five
Crores. Further representalions dated I1.O4.2O25 were also
I
I
a'
made to respondent-Bank, however, the bank turned deaf ear to
all these represen I ation s.
6.
Heard learned counsel for petitioner Sri M.V.
Hanumantha Rao and Smt. V. Dyumani, learned Standing
Counsei for respondent bank.
7.
It is an undisputed fact, as contended by petitioner
and not rebutted by respondent-Bank that no prior
notice/ intimation of either default by petitioner or decision of
bank to treat petitioner's account as NPA, is given to petitioner.
Petitioner contends that such a prior-notice is mandatory not
only as per the guidelines on Fair Practices Code for Lenders'
but also as per the 'Framework for Revival and Rehabiiitation of
Micro, Small ald Medium Enterprises' issued uide notification
dated 29.O5.2Oi5 issued by Central Government in exercise of
powers u/Sec. 9 of the MSMED Act.
8.
Learned counsel for petitioner rightly relied on the
judgment in M/s PRO .8(JVITS o. The Board of Directors of
Canara Bcnk (SLP (C) No. 7898 ot 2024l, dated, O1.O8.2O24,
wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court held: "The
instructions/directions issue by the Central Government under
Section 9 of the MSMED Act arrd by the RBI under Section 21
s.
l'
I
and Sec. 35A have statutory force and are binding to all the
Banking companies."
9.
Undisputedly, petitioner sent e mail to respondent-
Bank on 11.04.2025 at 19.O5 hrs, as: 'Kindly request that you
please give us arr extension time period to reduce our credit
limit as here I attached the request letter for your reference'.
They also submitted another representation: '... Regarding to it,
we promised to pay back the loan and limit the loan, but due to
unexpected reasons we have iaited to pay the loan to you. It is
requested you to give time till June 30th 2025 to limit loan
amount. Before the requested time period we will pay back the
loan to you. If in case of any failure of payment from our side we
are liable for the actions taken by you against us for our default.
Hence it is requested you to grant time for use to pay the loan to
you'.
10.
Petitioner is stated to have submitted yet another
representation dated 11.O4.2025: '... we wanted to limit our loan
amount by payrng 1 crore rupees on or before April 30th 2025
and 2 crore rupees on or before June 3oth 2025.lf there is any
default in our loan payments before the said dates we will be
liable for the action taken against us by the bank. It is
requested and prayed to you to accept and give "me this
&
\
opportunity to pay the loan'. Undisputedly, respondent-Bank
has not considered and passed orders on the representations.
11.
Another factor is that renewed loan was sanctioned
to petitioner on 18. I I .2024 . As per the agreed terms and
conditions of rene'a,al letter 'in case of non-improvement of
routing in next 6 months, Branch is advised to explore reducing
the limits as mentioned in the note'. So the time limit is up to
17.O5.2O25, whereas the impugned recall letter was issued on
24.O4.2025.
12.
The Government of India and the State Government
are, time and again, trying to encourage entrepreneurs and self-
employment. Petitioners are budding small entrepreneurs and
stated that they are providing employment to 20 members. If the
Bank is harsh in extending its helping hand, petitioner and its
dependents will be on roads. It ls not out of place to mention
that the Government of India has brought into play a policy
called 'Make in India' rn 2Ol4 to transform the country into a
global manufacturing hub. It aims to achieve this by
encouraging both domestic and foreign companies to invest in
manufacturing in the country, with a focus on improving the
business environment, fostering innovation, and building world-
./
class infrastructure. The initiative is built on four pillars: new
processes, new infrastructure, new sectors, ald a new mindset-
13.
Respondent-Bank being a
public sector
undertaking, is supposed to keep in mind the policy of
Government of lndia in dealing with loans of young
entrepreneurs. Therefore, if respondent-Bank takes a lenient
and sympathetic view and considers the request of petitioner, it
will be appreciated. In view of the above discussion, without
going into the merits as to issuance of recall notice dated
I
t
24 .O4.2O25
is correct action or not, this Court deems it
appropriate to dispose of the Writ Petiton.
14.
Respondent-Bank is directed to consider and pass
orders on the representation of petitioner dated I 1 .O4.2O25
keeping in view the terms and conditions of renewal letter dated
1a.77.2O24; guidelines on Fair Practices Code for Lenders;
Framework for Revival and Rehabilitation of Micro, Small and
Medium Enterprises issued by Government of India's
notihcation dated 29.O5.2O15 and the Government's policy of
'Make in India'; undertaking given by petitioner in its
representations that if it fails to fulfill/ remit within the time
limit given by Bank, Barlk is at liberty to proceed against it and
pass appropriate orders within four weeks from the date of
t
receipt of a copy of this order. Till such orders are passed by the
Baak, operation of the impugned recall notice dated 24.04.2025
is put on hold.
15.
The Writ Petition is accordingly disposed of. No
costs.
L6.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
SD/- C.DEEPIKA
SSISTANT REGISTRAR
,TRUE COPY//
\
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Union of lndia, Jeevan Deep
Building, Sansad Marg, New Delhi.
2. The Regional Director, Reserve Bank of lndia, 6-'1-56, Secretariat Road,
Saifabad, Hyderabad.
3. The Managing Director and CEO, Union Bank of lndia, Union Bank Bhavan,
239, Nariman Point, lt/umbai, Maharashtra-400021 .
4. The Regional Head, Khammam, l\,4SME loan point, D.No.5-7-H000'19, Swati
Towers, Opp. Janpahad Dargah, Cheruvu Bazar, Manikya Nagar Basti,
Khammam, Telangana 507002.
5. The Branch Manager, Union bank of lndia, BURHANPURAM Branch Door no
11-10-7435, opposite to DRDA complex Burhanpuram khammam-507001 .
6. One CC to SRI M. V. HANUIVANTHA RAO, Advocate [OPUC]
7. One CC to SRI N. BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
loPUCl
8. One CC to It{/S N. LEGAL HYDERABAD, Advocates [OPUC]
9. One CC to SMT V. DYUMANI, Advocate IOPUCI
'10. Two CD Copies
DAN
TKS
*-
HIGH COURT
DATED:21 10112026
I
(
ORDER
o
.J
WP.No.13800 of 2025
1 H E S T4
0 2 ti:g 7q7(
a
*
-t-
r-1411,1r/O
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
@
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review