Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3447 ]
TUESDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
WRIT PETITION NOS: 22081 220820F 2018 10578 0F 2019
8375 20549 0F 2020 4029 4030 4071 24072 24100 0F 2021
13082 AND 156260F 2022
WRIT PETITION NO: 22081 OF 2018
Between:
lv1/s
lntrend Homes Pvt. Ltd., 8-3-978/3, Road No.2, 301 Nallamada
Apartments, Srinagar Colony, Hyderabad. Telangana Represented by one of
ita Directors Sri. Kota Reddy Veerappareddy
...PETITIONER
AND
Assistant Commissioner (ST), Srinagar Colony circle, Sth Floor, B Block,
I\/avur Kushal Comolex, Besides Chermas. Abids. Hyderabad 500 001.
Staie of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary to Revenue (CT),
Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
...RES'ONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be
pleased to
i) to issue a writ, order or direction one more in the nature of MANDAI\,4US
declaring the impugned order passed by the 1sl respondent vide AAO No.30385
dated 28-05-20 18 contrary to section 3 of the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods
into Local Areas Act, 2001 and in violation of article 14,265 and 300-A of the
constitution as arbitrary, illegal, without jurisdiction and set aside the same, and
ii) to set aside the consequential demand nottce in Form D 2 dated 28-05-2018
issued by the 1st resPondent.
lA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in ther : rcumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cor- r may be pleased to
stay all f urther proceedings including stay of collection o' the disputed tax of
Rs.1 ,95,943 till the disposal of the above petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, /\ ;P FOR
SRI SWAROOPOORILLA, SPL. GP FOi STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 22082 OF 2018
Between:
I\,4/s Sri Adrtya Homes Private Limited ,8121332181A, Roa No.3, Ad tya House,
Banlara Hills. Hyderabad 500 034. Telangana. Repr: ented by one of its
Directors Sri. Kota Reddy Veerappareddy
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Assistant Commissioner (ST), Srinagar Colony circle, 5 I Floor, B Block,
IVayur Kushal Complex, Besides Chermas, Abids, Hyrie:r rbaci 500 00't
2. State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, to Fl venue(CT)
.
Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lnc
i
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the lrgh Court may be
pleased to lssue a writ, order or direction one more in the rr ture of MANDAIT/US
declaring the impugned order passed by the 1st respondenl vide AAO No.30378
dated 2E-05-2018 contrary to section 3 of the Telangana T,t On Entry Of Goods
into Locai Areas Act. 2001 and in violation of article 14, 2 )5 and 300-4 of the
Constitution as arbrtrary, illegal, without jurisdiction and sel il ide the s:rme, and ii)
to set aside the consequential demand notice in Form [) 2 dated 28-05-2018
issued by the 1st respondent.
lA NO: 1 OF 20'18
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the c I )umstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court nr ry be pleased to stay
-)
all further proceedings including stay of collection of the disputed tax of Rs
13,'18,545 till the disposal of the above petition.
CounseI for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
counsel for the Respondents: sRl T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, AGP FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOR STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 10578 OF 2019
Between
I\,4/s. Legend Estates Private Limited., 6-3-1238, Sixth Floor, LEGEND
APARTTUENTS, Renuka Enclave, Lane Opposite Necklace Road Rarlway
Station, Rajbhavan Road, Somajiguda, Hyderabad 5 00 0B2.Telangana State.
Rep. by its Accounts Manager Ramavarapu lVadhav
...PETITIONER
AND
1. Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Hyderguda - Ashok Nagar Circle, Abids
Division, 1st Floor, Old Kakatiya Hotel, Nampally, Hyderabad 500 005.
2. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary to Revenue (CT),
Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
...RES'ONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to
i)
issue a writ, order or direction one more in the nature of IVANDAIVUS
declaring the impugned order passed by the 1st respondent vide A.O
No.47972 dated O511212018 contrary to section 3 of the Telangana Tax
On Entry Of Goods into Local Areas Act, 2001 and in violation of articles
14, 19(1Xg), 265 and 300-A of the Constitution as arbitrary, illegal,
without jurisdiction and set aside the same, and
ii)
to set aside the "Arrear Notice" dated 2310412019 to the extent it
demands the entry tax of Rs.1,22,393 levied for the year 2012-2013
lA NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings pursuant to Distraint Notice dated 0610512019 including
stay of collection of the remaining disputed tax of Rs.1,22,:i' 3 til, the disposal of
the above petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, ,\ jP FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOF STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 8375 OF 2020
Between:
M/s. Gurupreet Galvanising Private Limited, Survey I'J r.83.1, lDA, l\,4edchal
Medchal vandal, Ranga Reddy District. Telanaana Represented by its
Managing Director Sri. K. S urya narayana
..PETITIONER
AND
1. Commercral Tax Offrcer, I\4alkalrgiri Circle, M - Block, [,4 z roranjan Complex,
Nampally, Hyderabad.
2. Appellate Jornt Commissioner (ST), Hyderabad Rural C i ision, 5 floor,
C.T.Complex, Opp Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabz j.
3. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secre.i ry Revenue
(Commercial Taxes), Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad
...RESpONDENTS
Petrtion under Article 226 of the Constitution of lnc i r praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the -ligh Court may be
pleased to
i)
to issue a writ, order or direction one more in the I rture of I\/ANDAMUS
declaring the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods 1to Local Areas Act,
2001 (Act No.39 of 2001)as being violative of art;les 14, 30'1 301(a).
265 and 3004 and hence Ultra Vires the Constitut rn and strike it down
as void and
ii)
to Declare the impugned order passed by the 1st espondent vide ADC
order No.B52 dated 30-04-2020 (Ex. P '1 ) as ilk; al, arbitrary, without
.jurisdiction and set aside the same and
iii) to Declare assessment order passed by the st respondent vide
A.O.No.14459 dated 23-3-2018 (Ex.P2) as ille; rl, arbitrary, without
jurisdiction and set aside the same and
iv)
to Pass such other order or orders as are deemo, lt and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case and do justice .
1 r:r=-.:-.
I'r:!:1-- j1:^ -.. -=. -:-r---
- -l ::- : -- - --..
)
Alternatively- i) to lssue a writ, order or direction one more in the nature
of IMANDAMUS declaring the impugned order-in-appeal passed by the
2nd respondent vide ADC order No.B52 dated 30-04-2020 (Ex. P 1) in
violation of sections 3(2) and 6 of the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods
lnto Local Areas Act, 2001 and articles 14, 265,3004 and section 19 of
the Constitution (101st Amendment) Act, 2016 as arbitrary, illegal,
without jurisdiction and set aside the same and
ii) to Declare the assessment order vide A.O.No.14459 dated 23-3-2018
(Ex. P 2) passed by thel st respondent as illegal, arbilrary, without
jurisdrction and set aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2O2O
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings including the stay of collection of the disputed tax of
Rs 4,45,090, (35 per cent) of the disputed tax is already paid) till the disposal of
the above writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, AGP FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOR STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 20549 OF 2020
Between:
I\rlls. Venkateshwara Hatcheries P\d. Ltd, lnjapur Village, Hayatnagar.
Rangareddy District. Telangana 500 070. Represented by its General
I\/anager Sri. M.Sreenivasa Rao
...PETITIONER
AND
'1
. Assistant Commissioner (State Tax), Vanasthalipuram Circle' Saroornagar
Division, 3rd Floor, Manoranjan Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad. 500
2. Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST), Hyderabad Rural Division, 5th Floor,
C.f.Complex, Opp. Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad
3. State of telangaria, Represented by its Principal Secretary Revenue
(Commercial Taxes), Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad
...RESpONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lnci . praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit frled therewith. the iigl^ Couft may be
pleased to
i)
To issue a writ. order or direction one more in the 1 tturr: of IT,4ANDAIMUS
declarrng the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods rto Local Areas Act,
2001 (Act No.39 of 2001) as being violative of z tcles 14, 246, 301
304(a), 265 and 3004 and hence Ultra Vires the C I rstitution and strike it
down as void and
ii)
Declare the impugned order passed by the 2ncl r )spondent vide ADC
order No 1466 dated 261812020 (Ex P 1) as ille r al, arbitrary, without
jurisdiction and set aside the same and
iii)
Declare assessment order passed by the 1;t respondent vide
A.O.No.2B774 dated 19/5i2018 (Ex. P 2) as ille r al, arbilrary, without
jurisdiction and set aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2020
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the c r )umstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petitron, the High Court nr, y be pleased to stay
all further proceedings includrng the stay of collection of the disputed tax of
Rs.8,21,899 (35 per cent of the disputed tax is already paid ill the disposal of the
above writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHATTANYA KIRAN, 6 GP FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOI STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 4029 OF 2021
Between:
M/s. Uttara Foods And Feeds Private Limited, (Pullur I) vision), Uttara Nagar,
Sy.No.326 and 330, Pullur Village, Undavally Manda, Near Alampur Cross
Road, Jogulamba Gadwal District. PlN. 509 1513 Represent6d by its
Authorised signatory Sri. [\4.Sreenivasa Rao
...PET|T|ONER
AND
Assistant Commissioner (State Tax), (Formerly known ;t , Commercial Tax
Officer), Wanaparthy-Gadwal Circle, Nalgonda Division, 1st Railway Gate,
Gadwal.
l
2. Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST), Hyderabad Rural Division, 5th Floor,
C.T.Complex, Opp. Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad.
3. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary Revenue
(Commercial Taxes), Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
...RESpONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 o'f the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to
i)
To rssue a writ, order or direction one more in the nature of ITIANDAMUS
declaring the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods into Local Areas Act,
2001 (Act No.39 of 200'1 ) as being violative of articles 13, 14, 246, 301,
30a(a), 265 and 3004 and hence Ultra Vires the Constitution and strike it
down as void, and
ii)
Declare the impugned order passed by the 2nd respondent vide ADC
order No 1979 dated 2911012020 (Ex. P 1) as illegal, arbitrary, without
jurisdiction and set asrde the same, and
iii)
Declare the assessment order passed by the 1st respondent for the year
2012-2013 vide A.O.No.47153 dated 26-10-2018 (Ex. P 2) as illegal,
arbrtrary, without jurisdiction and set aside the same, and
iv)
Pass such other order or orders as are deemed fit and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case and do justice.
Alternatively.
r)
lssue a writ, order or direction one more in the nature of
MANDAMUS declaring the impugned order-in-appeal passed by
the 2nd respondent vide ADC order No.1979 daled 2911012020
(Ex. P 1) upholding levy of entry tax for the year 2012-2013 in
violation of sections 3(2) and 6 of the Telangana Tax On Entry Of
Goods lnto Local Areas Act, 2001 and articles 14,246' 265, 300A
and section '19 of the Constitution (101st Amendment) Act' 2016
as arbrtrary, illegal, without jurisdiction and set aside the same,
and
ii)
Declare the assessment order passed by the 1st respondent vide
A.O.No.47153 dated 26-10-2018 (Ex. P 2) levying entry tax for the
year 2012-2013 as illegal, arbitrary, without jurisdiction and set
aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Sectron 15'1 CPC praying that in the c r )umstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court nt y be pleased to stay
all further proceedings including the stay of collection of the disputed tax of
Rs.81,992 levied for the year 2012-2013 (35 per cent of ther : sputed tax is already
paid) till the disposal of the above writ petition
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN' ! GP FOR
SRI SWAROOPOORILLA, SPL. GP FOI STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 4030 OF 2021
Between:
Mis. Uttara Foods And Feeds Private Limited, (Pullur t) vision), Uttara Nagar,
Sv.No.326 and 330, Pullur Viliage, Undavally Manda, Near Alampur Cross
Rbad, Jogulamba Gadwal District. PlN. 509 1513 Represented by its
Authorised signatory Sri. M.Sreenivasa Rao
...'ET,T,ONER
AND
. Assistant Commissioner (State Tax), (Formerly known rl ; Commercial Tax
Officer), Wanaparthy-Gadwal Circle, Nalgonda Division, l st Railway Gate,
Gadwal.
2. Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST), Hyderabad Rural f i ,ision, 5th Floor,
C.T.Complex, Opp. Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderalr rd.
3. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretr ry Revenue
(Commercial Taxes), Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of tfte Constitution of lnc i r praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to
i)
To issue a writ, order or direction one more in the ^ rture of IMANDAIVIUS
declaring the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods nto Local Areas Act,
2001 (Act No.39 of 2001) as being violative of arl les 13, 14, 246, 301
<
,
304(a), 265 and 3004 and hence Ultra Vires the C: rstitution and strike it
down as void, and
ii)
Declare the impugned order passed by the 2nc1 r :spondent vide ADC
order No.1981 dated 29-10-2020 (Ex. P 1) as iile yal, arbitrary, without
jurisdiction and set aside the same, and
I
iii)
Declare the assessment order passed by the 1st respondent for the year
2013-2014 vide A.O.No.47163 dated 26-10-2018 (Ex. P 2) as illegal,
arbitrary, without jurisdiction and set aside the same.
Alternatively-
i)
lssue a writ, order or direction one more in the nature of
TVANDAN/US declaring the impugned order-in-appeal passed by
the 2nd respondent vide ADC order No.1981 dated 29-10-2020
(Ex. P 1) upholding levy of entry tax in violation of sections 3(2)
and 6 of the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods lnto Local Areas
Act, 2001 and articles 14, 246,265, 3004 and section 19 of the
Constitution (101st Amendment) Act, 2016 as arbitrary, illegal,
without jurisdiction and set aside the same, and
ii)
Declare the assessment order passed by the '1 st respondent vide
A,O.No.47163 dated 26-10-2018 (Ex. P 2) levying entry tax for the
year 2013-2014 as illegal, arbitrary, without jurisdiction and set
astde the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 151 CPC prayrng that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petit,on, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings including the stay of collection of the dtsputed tax of
Rs.10,43,562 levied for the year 2013-2014 (35 per cent of the disputed tax is
already paid) till the disposal of the above writ petitton.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, AGP FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOR STATE TAX
l0
W.P.NO: 4071 OF 2021
Between:
Ir4/s. Uttara Foods And Feeds Private Limited, (Pullur tt rision), Uttara Nagar,
Sy.No.326 and 330, Pullur Village, Undavally lVlandal Near Alampur Cross
Road, Jogulamba Gadwal Distrrct. PlN. 509 15:r. Represented by its
Authorised signatory Sri.l\rl. Sreenivasa Rao
...PETITIONER
AND
. Assistant Commissioner (State Tax), (Formerly known :r: Commercral Tax
Officer), Wanaparthy-Gadwal Circle, Nalgonda Divisior st Railway Gate,
G adwa L
2. Appellate Joint Commissroner (ST), Hyderabad Rural Di' isiorr, 5th Floor,
C.T.Complex, Opp. Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderatr; d.
3. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secrelr ry Revenue
(Commerciai Taxes), Secretariat, Saifabad, HyderabarJ
...RESPONDENTS
Petrtion under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lnCi, praying that in the
crrcumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, th,: ligt, Court may be
pleased to
i)
To issue a writ, order or direction one more in the rr rture of IVTANDAMUS
declaring lhe Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods rto Local Areas Act,
2001 (Act No.39 of 2001) as being violative of : lrclr:s 14, 246, 301
,
304(a), 265 and 3004 and hence Ultra Vires the O,) rstitrtion and strike it
down as void, and
ii)
Declare the impugned order passed by the 2nd r:spondent vide ADC
order No 1980 dated 2911012020 (Ex. P 1 ) as ille ,, al, arbitrary, without
jurisdiction and set aside the same, and
iii)
Declare assessment order passed by the 1st r,: ; rondent for the year
2012-2013 vide A.O.No.47154 dated 2611012018 'Ex P 2) as illegal,
arbitrary, without jurisdiction and set aside the saq't , and
iv)
Pass such other order or orders as are deemed it and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case and do justice
Alternatively:-
i)
lssue a writ, order or direction one nro e rn the nature of
IVANDAMUS declaring the impugned orde. n-appeal passed by
the 2nd respondent vide ADC order No. ll) i0 dated 2911012020
(Ex. P 1 ) upholding levy of entry tax for t. ) year 2012-2013 in
violation of sections 3(2) and 6 of the Telang ana Tax On Entry Of
II
Goods lnto Local Areas Act, 2001 and articles 14,246,265, 3004
and section '19 of the Constitution (101 st Amendment) Act, 2016
as arbitrary, illegal, without jurisdiction and set aside the same,
and
ii)
Declare the assessment order passed by the 1st respondent vtde
A.O No.47'1 54 dated 26110120 18 (Ex. P 2) levying entry tax for the
year 2012-2013 as illegal. arbitrary, without jurisdiction and set
aside the same
lA NO: '1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition. the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings including the stay of collection of the disputed tax of
Rs.79,775 levied for the year 2012-2013 (35 per cent of the disputed tax is already
paid) till the disposal of the above writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, AGP FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOR STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 24072OF 2021
Between:
s. Aryamitra Projects, Plot No.203, Block A, Sector 4,Alkapuri Township,
Necknapur, Manikonda, Hyderabad 500 036 Telangana. Represented by one
of its Partners Sri. Venkata Sreenivasulu Posa
...pETlTloNER
t\rti
AND
1. Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST), Hyderabad Rural Division, 5th Floor, C.TCbitrplex, tVl.J.Road, Opp Gandhi Bhavan, NampaUy, Hyderabad . .
2. Commercial Tax Officer, Rajendra Nagar-ll circle, Saroornagar Division, 3rd
Floor, IV4 Block, Manoranjan Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad.
3. State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary to Revenue (CT),
Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
...RES'ONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased
t2
i)
issue a writ, order or direction one more in the r: ture of MANDAMUS
declaring the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Good s I rto Local Areas Act,
2001 passed in violation of a(icles 14, 30'1 and 302 'a) as Ultra Vires the
Constitutron arid void ab initio and
ii)
Declare the impugned order passed by the 1sl - spondent vide ADC
order No 379 dated 25-02-2021 (into which the as sessnent order vide
A.O No.8034 dated 1910212019 passed by 2nd rt::; ondent has merged)
ronfirming levy of entry tax as illegal. without jur-i ; Jictr,tn and set aside
the same and
iii)
rii) Declare the assessment order vi e A.O.No.8() i4 dated 1910212019
passed by the 2nd respondent levying entry 1a> as rllegal, arbitrary
without jurisdiction and set aside the same and
iv)
Pass such other order or orders as are deemec 'rt and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case and do justice
Alternative Praver:- ln case this Hon'ble Court fin:; the Telangana Tax
on Entry of Goods into Local Areas Act, 2001 cor I titut onally valid, with
at most reverence it is prayed to
i)
declare the rmpugned order vide ADC Ordr: No 379 dated 25-02
2021 (inlo which the assessment order vid: A.C) No.8034 dated
1910212019 passed by the 2nd responder ras rnerged) passed
contrary to principles of natural justice :.'td also contrary to
section 3(2) of the Telangana Tax On Entrl of Goods lnto Local
Areas Act, 200'1 and in violation of articles ' , , 19(1Xg), 265, 3004
of the Constitution and section 9 of :l r Constitution (10'1 st
'1
Amendment) Act, 2016 as arbitrary, illegal ,t thour jurisdiction and
set aside the same and
ii)
also declare the assessment order r i le A.O.8034 dated
1910212019 passed by the 2nd responde r t as illegal arbitrary
without jurisdiction and set aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the cir rurrstances slated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court rr ry be pleased to stay
l3
all further proceedings including stay of collection of the drsputed tax of Rs.10,0'13
(35 per cent of the disputed tax is already paid) till the disposal of the above
petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, AGP FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOR STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 24100 OF 2021
Between:
IV/s. Aryamitra Projects, Plot No.203, Block A, Sector 4,Alkapuri Township,
Neckna'pur, Manikonda, Hyderabad 500 036. Telangana. Represented by one
of its Partners Sri. Venkata Sreenivasulu Posa
...'ET'T'ONER
AND
1. Appellate Joint Commissioner (ST), Hyderabad Rural Division, 5th Floor,
C.t.Complex, tr,4.J.Road, Opp Gandhi Bhavan, Nampally, Hyderabad
2. Commeriial Tax Officer, Ra.jendra Nagar-ll ctrcle, Saroornagar Division, 3rd
Floor, M4 Block, Manoranjan Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad.
3. State of Telangana, Represented by its Princrpal Secrelary to Revenue (CT),
Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
...RESPONOENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of Indra praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to
i)
issue a writ, order or direction one more in the nature of MANDAMUS
declaring the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods lnto Local Areas Act,
2OO'l passed in violation of articles 14, 301 and 304(a) as Ultra Vires the
ii)
Constitution and void ab rnitio and
Declare the impugned order passed by the 1st respondent vide ADC
order No.3B0 dated 25-02-2021 (into which the assessment order vide
A.O.No.8039 dated 19-02-2019 passed by 2nd respondent has merged)
confirming levy of entry tax as illegal, without jurisdiction and set aside
the same and
iii)
Declare the assessment order vide A.O.No.8039 dated 19-02-2019
passed by the 2nd respondent levying entry tax as illegal, arbitrary
without jurisdiction and set aside the same.
t1
Alternative P taYet.i)
To declare the impugned order vide ADC rlr ler No.3B0 dated 25-
02 2021 (into which the assessment or,l: viCe A.O. No.8039
daled 19-02-2019 passed by the 2nd re,sr rndent has merged)
passed contrary to principles of natural jLst le and also contrary
to section 3(2) of the Telangana Tax On En r z of Goods lnto Local
Are as Act, 2001 and:in vtolation of articles i , , 19(1)(g). 265, 3O0A
of the Constitution and sectron 1g of tl ( Constitution (101st
Anrendment) Act, 2016 as arbitrary, illegal ,r, thout jurisdiction and
set aside the same. and
ii)
also declare the assessment order vide lr t.8039 dated 19-022019 passed by the 2nd respondent as irl ,gal arbitrary without
jurisdiction and set aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petrtion under Sectron 151 CPC praying that in the c r )umstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court nr ry be pleased to stay
all further proceedings including stay of collection of he disputed tax of
Rs.1,41,971 (35 per cent of the disputed tax is already pair r rll the disposal of the
above petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.R.VISWANATH
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, I Gp FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FCI. STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 13082 OF 2022
Between:
S.Shailender Sigh, H,No.2-3-100/C, Boiwada,
505001 , Karrmnagar
Kanr;
r Road. Karimnagar...PETITIONER
AND
1. The Deputy Commercial Tax Officer, O/o_ The Comme-, ial Tax Officer,
Karimnagar-2 circle,3rd Floor, NGO purlding Mankanrrr rthota. Karimnagar
^ State of Telangana, Represented by its prin-ipal Secret to Revenue(dT),
2.
ry
Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
,..RESPONDENTS
l5
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to.
i)
issue a writ, order or dtrection one more in the nature of TMANDAMUS
declaring the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods lnto Local Areas
Act,20O'1 passed in violation of Articles 14,301 and 304(a) as Ultra Vires
the Constitution and:void ab in initio and
ii)
Declare the assessment order vie A.O.No 2303 dated 2610212022
(Ex.P1 ) passed by the 1st respondent levying entry tax in violation of
a(icles 14,19(g), 21 ,2a5, 246,265 and 300-4 and section 19 of the
CAA, 2016 as illegal, arbitrary without jurisdiction and set aside the
same
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings including stay of collection of the disputed tax OF
Rs.6,O'1 .875 pending, disposal of the Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.N.SREEDEVI
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN' AGP FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOR STATE TAX
W.P.NO: 15626 OF 2022
Between:
I\,4/s. Vintaoe Coffee Private Limited, 2O2, Oxford Plaza, No' 9-1-'129 1, SD
Road SecJnderabad- 500003, Represented by its Managing Director Sri Tati
Balakrishna
...PETraoNER
AND
1. The Assistant Commissioner (ST), MG Road - SD Road Circle, Begumpet
Division,6-3-789, 4th Floor Pavarii Prestige' Ameerpet, Hyderabad500 016'
2. The Staie of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary to Revenue
(CT). Secretariat, Saifabad, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
l6
Petition under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lnc i r praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the r-ligh Court may be
pleased to.
i)
issue a writ, order or directton one more in the n, ture of l\,4ANDAtr/US
dcclaring the Telangana Tax On Entry Of Goods nto Local Areas Act,
2001 passed in violation of articles 14, 301 and :Jt , (a) as Ultra Vrres the
Constitution 1 and void ab initio. and
ii)
issue a wrrt. order or direction one mote in the rr ture of MANDAI\,4US
declaring the Act 26 of 2017 daled 211212017 ar r act to f urther amend
Telangana Value Added Tax Act, 2005 (since re; -.aled) in so far as it
provides for longer period of limitation for mak ng assessment and
passed in violation of articles 245, 246, section - I of the Constitution
(1Ol st Amendment) Act, 2016 as ultra vires the Orrr stitution and invalid
iii)
Declare the impugned order passed by the 1st re .. tondent vide AO.No.
36 daied 0110212022 confrrmrng levy of entry I :x as illegal, without
jurisdiction and set aside the same. and
iv)
Pass such other order or orders as are deemt-'cl fit and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case and do justicr.
Alternative Prayer.- In case this Honorable Cou 1 finds the Tel anga na
Tax on Entry of Goods into Local Areas Act, 20, 1 and the Act 26 of
2017 daled 211212017 co nstitutionally valid, with rtmost reverence it is
prayed to
i)
declare the impugned order vide AO. No.' 36 dated O1lO2l2O22
passed contrary to section 3(2) of the Tela I ;ana Tax On Entry of
Goods lnto Local Areas Act, 2001 and in / :lation of articles 14,
19(tXg), 265, 3004 of the Constitution ;r d sectjon 19 of the
Constitution (101st Amendment) Act, 20 as arbitrary, illegat
without jurisdiction and set aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 cPC praying that in the r i :umstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court rr ry be pleased to stay
tl
all further proceedings including stay of collection of the disputed tax of
Rs.9,'18,000 till the disposal of the above petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.N.SREEDEVI
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI T.CHAITANYA KIRAN, AGp FOR
SRI SWAROOP OORILLA, SPL. GP FOR STATE TAX
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
IN THE HIGII COURT FOR'IIIE STATE OF f iLAI-GANA
AT HYDERABAD
TIIE IIO\OUITABLE SRI JUSTICI' P.SA ] KOSHY
J\
.I't{T,
ANT)
tIO\OURABLL, SRI JUSTICE NARSI \G RAO
NANI)IKONDA
lVrit Petition Nos.2208l
2201t2 of 2018 10578 , I
20t9 8375
20549 of 2020 4029 4030 1071 21012 24100 ot 202l 13082
and 15626 of2022
Dated: 03.02.2026
\\'.P.No.2208 I of 2018:
Betrveen:
M/s.lntrend I lonrcs Pvt.l-td.,
8-3-978r3, Road No.2,
301 Nallamada Aparlrnents, Srinagar Colony,
Hyderabad, Telangana.
Rep br t'ne ol'lr\ Direclors
Sri Kota Reddv Veerappareddy.
...
Petitioner
AND
Assistant Comnrssioner (ST),
Srinagar Colonr' ()r'cle,
5'r' Floor, "ts" Illock. Ma-vur KLrshal Complex,
Ilesides Chermrs. Abids,
-500 001 & another
IIyd
Respondents
CONIN{ON ORDER Q:ar Ilon'ble Sri Justice P.Sam k s t1,)
Heard Mr.S.R.R.Visr.vanath, leamed corr sel for the
petitioners and Mr.T.Chaitanya Kiran, learr:d Assistant
Government Plcader representing Mr.Sw'atoop Oorilla, Iearned
Spccial (ior emment Pleader fbr State
2.
-l'hc
'l'ax.
l)crused thc record
prcscrrt is the u'rit petition u hich has been filed
assailing thc ordcr ol'assessment passed by the Comnrercial
'l'ax
Departrnent Rcspondent No.I levying tax under rhe 'felangana
Iax on Entrv ol'Coods into Local Areas Act. 200 t on the so callcd
inrlrorlcd notil're(l goods irrto the State olTelangana
3. ['hc impugned order of assessment has bccn challcngecl
primarill.' on the ground ol Iirnitation. In a lerv othcl matters, there
is this challenqc rnaclc to thc amendment that was blought to the
Tclangana Tax on Entry of Goods into Local Areas Act i.e., Act 26
o1' 201 7, rvhcrebv thc pcriod of limitation was enhanccd fi'om 4
).'cal s to 6 ycars
4. Thc challenge scr 1'ar as the said statutory provision is
concerned is no longer res integra as this High Court itself in the
case of Sri Sri Engineering lVorks v. Deputy Comnissioncrt has
' (zozz) roq csrR sr{rs)
dcclared thc .\ct l(r o1' l0I 7 enhancing the lir.nitn i . I firrnr .1 1'ears
to 6 years to bc unconstitutional. 'l-hcrcfbre, thc : r I cliallcnse to
the Act 2(r o1 l0 l7 stands dccidcd in favrrur of as:.r',ee crn the said
ground itselt-. \ou conrcs thc question as to \\.hct I j thc impusned
assessment ordcr in all thcsc batch of- I2 urit petitrrr s arc barrcd by
lirnitation undt.r tlrc un-antenclcd Act ol- 2001. I I r details of- the
impugned orclcrs rrndcr challenqc. the assessrncnl I :riocl involved
in cach of tlrc u rit petitions, thc pcriod orr u hich rii, fbtrr (4) ycars
tirne is conrin-lt to an cnd and also tl'rc actual d.t, on which thc
impugned assessnrent orders has been passed is f r conven lence
sake ref'lected in a tabu lar lorm hcrein uncler
S.No
W.P.No
F inuncie l
hnirugnecl
)cars (tax
()
period)
l
I
De
tails of
the
OI{IGINAL
ASSF.S.SlltrNlORDtrR
r(l(-'r
s'hcther
Appellate
i
aLrthority's
ordcr- (AAO)
or Original l
Assessrnent
ordcr (OA)
I
i
Last dlt -' tirr Date of the Timc
perssinl
assessrn
iI
Asscssnrent
Order
barred
or not
l
28.05.2018
Time
o rder
2208t20t8
20t3-t4
22082t2(.)18
20l-l-t4
OA
3 t.03..1( r
b arrcd
OA
31.03..r( J
2 8.05.201 8
-do-
I 05 ?3 ',l0l 9
2012-[ oA
-+
8t;: l0l0
2012-
l.r
)
20519 to20 i2012-ti
-101e 20l
-l
16rr) 1{)3 t
31.0i.2017 05.12.201s
-do -
AAo
I1 03.2017
-do -
AAO
..il 0i.2017 t9.05.20ts
AAO
it 0i.20t7 i26.10.20r s I -do-
l
2_t.0i.20 rs
l
-do-
l
tt
t
10 1.2- l
l
l0li- l-l .\:\o
ir0l.20rE
r1 tOII
l0l2-ll
AAO
i1.01.20t7
2101). 20)t
20 I l- I.l
o
r+r 00'202 I
2013-l 1
AAO
r') r0
r\ I-
i-do.
26. I 0.101 s
-dt,-
i1.03.2017
I 9.02.20 t 9
-do-
3103.2018
I 9.02.20 t 9
-d o-
3t.07 .202r
26 01
t0ll
-do-
3t.03.2021
0 t .02.2011
-do-
I
l9
I
'-1
ro
I
[r
i
I
i
;
']l.ios::uz:
-np r. 20171 OA
ito J unc.
)ot7
156t6,102t i2016-17 toA
5.
'l'he plain perusal ol albresaid tabular form indicating the
tax periotl, the last date by u'hich the assessment ordel could had
bccn filcd and thc actual date on ri'htch the assessment order had
bcen passcd rr ould clearll, shorv that in all these cases, the ordcr of
assessment has beeu passed beyond the period of four years, as has
been stipulatcd under Section 6 of the Telangana Tax on [:ntry of
Goods into Local Areas Act, 2001 and also the period i.e.,
prescribed under the Telangana State VAT Act. Sections 2l(3) and
2l (:l) both tlie statutcs clcarlv provirle the pcriod oi' tritlliorr to tltc
lou r ycars
6. f his I ligh Courr irr thc lcccnt past lll it batch oI rvrit
petitions. thc lead case bcen \\'.I'}.No.2.112t ol20-l(, rncl batch lirlc
its order dated 26.04.2014 had cxtcrrsivcly dealt ri i I thc said issuc
ol Iimitation to be fbur (4) years and the impugnerl r .dcr.s in all the
batch rnattcrs to have been issued bcyond the pc ird of fbur (4)
years and the batch of ri,r'it petilions stood allorved. liiven thc lhct
that we have already taken a sirnilar vierv in idcnt r t[ set ot't'acts,
we do not find any good ground macle out by thc rc; onclents in not
accepting the said vicri'taken bi this Bench in the fbrcsaitl batch
of matters. In the prescnt onc also thc actual clt:t r ls in all tltese
batch of 12 wlit pctitions also ale identical in narrr
so far as the
dates and period of lirnitarion is conccrned
7. ln view of the samc, rve arc inclincd to ii ow the instant
batch of writ petitions as well. All the impugned or crs referred to
in the table reproduced above in the respective wrir ,ctitions stands
hereby set aside holding them to bc barred by limirat )n-
8.
'l'he writ pctitions accordingly, sl.and allowed
C'onsccltrciril r. r.n isi. cllnncoLrs pctitions l)cntlill!,, il an1, shall
.1 ,,16 6lLrscd.
- rcri shall bc nrt ortlcl its to co\t5
SD/- M. OSMAN ALI BAIG
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
To
SECTION OFFICER
B Block'
The Assistant Cornmissioner (ST), Srinagar Colony circle' 5th Floor'001'
Hyderabad
(rtnui
Abrds
Chermis,
Qernplcx, Besrdcs
Vrrrr
saifabad' Hyderabad
2 ti-r".iErl,,i"rl s.,ri.i.v'to ncuenue (cr), Secretariai'
State ol Telarrgarla.
"Comnrrssioner of State Tax, Hydergudar- Ashok Nagal
stant
3 ine nis
-C^ir9l^e,
"Oirli.".
ist Ftoor. OtC kakatrya Hotet, Namp€lly,.Hyderabad 500 O05
n'OiO'.
lV - Block' Manoranjan
4 T;;C;;;.;ialiax offrcer, Malkajigiri Circle'
Comolex, NamPallY HYderabad(ST), Hverabad. Rural Division' 5 floor'
5 ii"- Xtr"rirt" i,j,ni cdmmisironer
Nampallv Hvderabad
Bhavan,
d'i C;;;i;;, opp Gandhi (State Tax),
Vah-asthalipuram Circle'
6 in" Aiiiituni Comnrissrooer
Compldx' Nampallv' Hvderabad
vanorinjan
rtobr,
3rd
i;;.;;,;"tj;; biris orr
500 001
Tax)' (Fornrerly known as Commercial
7 ii-r! nt.ittunt Corntltssioner (State
i;; ijff"ka, w;rpu.tnv crd*al Crrcle', Nalgonda Division' 1st Railwav
Gate, Gadwal.
circie ' .Saroornagar Dtvision'
8 iri"t"*-.i.ial Tax Officer' Ra.;endra Nagar-ll
Hvderahad
NamPally,
iiJfroot, tv14 Blo.k. lrlanoranjan Complex,
o The Deputy Comm,:rcial lr; 6ffi; d/"' ih" cbmme'iial Tax offrcer'
NGo Building N4ankammathota' Karimnaqar
il;;ffi;? ,;ircle, 3rd Floor,(ST),
wG Roao - SD Road Crrcle' Begump-eJ
0 ih; A;;i"ir"t Commissioner
prestige,
pavani
Ameerpet Hyderabad 500 016.
oir]ri".,o_5_7e9, +tt] rtoo,
Advocate tgP^u-cl
11 o,i. cC b-snt s R R vtswRNATH'
Advocate
s
N
SREEDEVI
,
Svtr
io
Lo-P-u^cf ^
12 o;; aa
FoR sr [oPUC]
13 5;; dc ii snr swnnijoP ooRlLLA, sPL GP
14 .Two CD CoPies
PSK.
GJP
dL
,.iri.'=
HIGH COURT
DATED:0310212026
--'l 1
a
,j 26 t8?026
COMMON ORDER
7:
*
WP.No.22081 of 2018
WRIT PETITION NOS: 22081,22082 OF 2018; 10578
OF 2019; 8375, 20549OF 2020;4029,4:30, 4071,
24072,24100 OF 2021; 13082 AND 156;2I OF 2022
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITIONS
WITHOUT COSTS
r*
\?'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review