Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
t 34e1 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
IVONDAY, THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
l.A. No.1 OF 2026
IN/AND
WRIT PETITION NO: 23360 OF 2025
Between:
It4/s Hanuman Tyres, Rep. by its Prop, It/r Pedhakapu Shiva Kumar S/o Pedhakapu
Chinna Narsi Reddy, aged about years Occ: Business, R/o. 4-91l1 , Anken Pally,
Makthal l'.4andal Anugonda, fi,4akthal, N4ahubnagar Telangana 509208
...PETITIONER
AND
Union Bank of lndia, Stressed Asset t\,4anagement Branch 3'd Floor, Andhra Bank
Building, Koti Hyderabad Telangana State, Rep by its Authorised Officer
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumslances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue writ in the nature of [\/andamus, declaring the impugned
Letter/Communication Dt 09-07-025 issued by the Respondent thereby cancelling
the Sale Certificate Dl 04-07 -2025 issued as per Rule 9(6) of the Security lnterest
(Enforcement) Rules 2002 in favour of the petitioner in respect of immovable
property being land admeasuring 233.33 Sq Yds situated in Sy No.1 7713
(dismantled H.No.40/37G) l/ain Road, beside VRK Silks, Mouryainn Circle,
Kurnool and set-aside the same.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondent to deliver physical possession of the auctioned property along with
the titte deeds and link documents of auctioned property i.e., land admeasuring
233.33 Sq Yds situated in Sy No 17713 (dismantled H.No 4Ot37Gl Main Road,
beside VRK Silks, l\,4ouryainn Circle, Kurnool pending disposal of the present Writ
Petitio n.
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the attidavit tiled in support of the petrtion. the Hrgh Court may be pleased to direct
the respondent to refund the excess amount oi Rs 27,98,4601 being value of land
admeasuring 26.22 Sq yds acquired/gifted to ,4unicipal Corporation and register
sale certificate in respect of auctioned property to the extent of 197.11 Sq Yds
(after deducting 26.22 Sq yds acquired/gifted to Nlunicipal Corporation) till the
disposal of the present Writ Petition.
lA NO: 3 OF 202s
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition. the High Court may be pleased to
restrain the respondent from putting the property i.e land admeasuring 233.33 Sq
Yds situated in Sy No '1 77i3 (dismantled H.No 40137G\ Main Road, beside VRK
Silks, Mouryainn Circle, Kurnool to auction/sale or return the title deeds to the
borrower by way of redemption of the mortgage till the disposal of the present Writ
Petition
lA NO: 4 OF 2025
Between:
Union Bank of India, Stressed Asset l\,4anagement Branch 3'd Floor, Andhra Bank
Building. Kothi Hyderabad Telangana State, Rep by its Authorised Officer.
...PETITIONER/RESPONDENT IN W.P.
AND
Ivl/s..Hanuman Tyres,. Represented by its Proprietor, Mr pedhakapu Shiva Kumar s/o
Pedhalapu Chinna Narsi Reddy, aged about years Occ: Business, No. 4_g1t1,
Anken Pally, tMakthal [t4andal Ahugonda, tvakthil, Mahubnagar Telangana sogzoa
...RESPONDENT/PETITIONER in W.p.
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the orders daled 07.08.2025 passed in l.A. No. 3 of 2025 in WP No. 23360
of 2025 and dismiss the WP with exemplary costs
lA NO: 1 OF 2026
Between:
V. Ravi Kumar S/o. V. Anantha Krishna, Aged about. 50 yrs., Occupation: Business,
R/o.18 2100. Belmont. Lodha Bellezza, Kukatpally, Hyderabad. PIN - 500072.
...PETITIONER/IMPLEAD PETITIONER/PROPOSED RESPONDENT No.2
AND
'1
. lrlls Hanuman Tyres, Rep. by its Proprietor, [t/ r Pedhakapu Shiva Kumar S/o
Pedhakapu Chinna Narsi Reddy, R/o. 4-9111, Ankenpally, Makthal Mandal,
Anugonda, tvakthal, l\ilahubnagar Dist, PIN - 509208
...RESPONDENT No.l,rWRlT PETITIONER lN W.P.No.233601202s
2. Union Bank of lndia, Stressed Asset Management Branch At: 3'd Floor,
Andhra Bank Building, Sultan Bazar, Koti Hyderabad PIN - 500095, Rep. by
its Authorised Officer
...RESPONDENT No.2/SOLE RESPONDENT lN W.P.No.2336012025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the crrcumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to pass
an order to have the Petitioner herein to be impleaded as Respondent No. 2 in the
above Writ Petition W.P. No. 23360 of 2025, in the interest of Justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI G. K. DESHPANDE
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI V. MURALI MANOHAR, REPRESENTING
Ms. V. DYUMANI
Counsel for the Proposed Respondent: SRI J. PRABHAKAR,
SENIOR COUNSEL REPRESENTING SRI K. KRISHNA SHRAWAN
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF'TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
I.A.No.1 of 2O26
IN AND
WRIT PETITION No.2336O OF 2O25
DATE: 16.02.2026
Betqreen:
M/s. Hanuman TJzres
... Petitioner
And
Union Bank of India,
Stressed Asset Management Branch,
3'd Floor, Andhra Bank Building,
Koti, Hyderabad, Telangana State,
Rep by its Authorised Officer.
..Respondent
Mr.C.li. Deshpande, learned counsel appearing for thc petitioner (Online)
Mr.\/. \4urali Manohar, learned counsel representing Ms.V.Dyrtmani, leamed counsel
app,'aring for the rFspondent
Mr..L Prabhakar, learned Senior Counsel represcnting Mr. K. Krishna Shrawar, learned
counsel appearing for the implcad pe titioncr/ proposed respondent No.2.
COMMON ORDER:
1.
{Per Hon'blc Justice Gadi Praveen Kumar)
Heard Mr.G.K.Deshpande, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner, Mr.V.Murali Manohar, learned counsel
representing Ms.V.Dy'umani, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent and Mr..J Prabhakar, learned Senior Counsel
.
assisted by Mr.K.Krishna Shrau'an, learned counsel appearing
for the impleacl pe titioncr/ proposed respondent No.2.
2.
The writ petition is hled challenging the impugned
letter/communication dated 09.O7.2025 issued by the
respondent/Union Bank of India cancelling the Sale Certihcate
dated 04-07.2025 issued under section 9(6) of The Security
Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2OO2 ('2OO2 Rules'), in favour of
the petitioner in respect of the immovable propert5r i.e., land,
admeasuring 223.33 Square Yards situated in Survey No.l77 /3
(dismantled house bearing No.a0/37G), Main Road, Mouryainn
Circle, Kurnool, and consequently to set aside the impugned
letter/communication dated 09.O7 .2025 and deliver possession
of the title deeds of auctioned property.
3.
The case of the petitioner is that the petitioner is the
successful auction purchaser for a
Rs.2,38,36,O0O /-
bid amount of
rn respect of the subject property. On
13.06.2025, the respondent issued a Sale Intimation letter
declaring the petitioner as successful bidder and while
acknowledging receipt of Rs.59,59,OO0/- i.e., 25o/o of the bid
amount, directed the petitioner to pay the balance 7 5o/o of the
l
bid amount, amounting to Rs. 1,78,77,0OO/- within 15 days.
Since the petitioner paid the balance 7 5%o of the bid amount
within the stipulated time, the respondent/Bank issued a Sale
Certificate dated O4.O7 .2O25, selling/conveying the title and
possession in respect of the auction property in favour of the
petitioner under Rule 9(6) of the Rules. Subsequently, an
imptrgned communication dated 09.O7.2025 was issued to the
petitioner cancelling the Sale Certihcate on the ground that
there ivas a deficit in the extent of the property, as 26.22 Square
Yards of land was already acquired/gilted to the Municipal
Corporation uide Gift Deed bearing document No.3622 /2OO9.
4.
Mr.G.K.Deshpande, learned counsel for the petitioner
subn-rits that once a Sale Certificate is issued in terms of Rule
9(6) of the Rules, the respondent has no power to cancel or
u,ithdraw the sale certifrcate of the concluded auction/sale.
Counsel further submits that a Sale Certificate issued under
Ruk: 9(6) of the Rules can be cancelled only under section of 17
of T'he Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets
and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 ('SARFAESI
ActJ, upon a challenge made by any aggrieved person, including
the borrower. It is contended that the Authorized Officcr of the
Bank has neither the power to cancel the Sale Certificate nor
-l
qualifies as an 'aggrieved person' within the meaning of section
17 ofthe SARFAESI Act.
5.
Mr. V- Murali M:rnohar, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-Bank, initially raised an objection that the cause of
action arose in the State of Andhra Pradesh since the subject
property is situated at Kurnool, and therefore, the writ petition
is liable to be dismissed for want of territorial jurisdiction.
Counsel further submits that the Bank issued an e-auction
Notice on 2O.O5.2O25 for sale ol Immovable Properties fixing the
date of auction as 13.O6.2O25. Item No.2 of the immovable
secured assets was described as 'open land, admeasuring
223.33 Square Yards situated in Municipal Ward No.40, Survey
-No.i77/3 (dismantled house bearing D.No.4O-30/G), situated at
Main Road, Kurnool, belonging to Mr. V. Raghavendra & Mr. V.
Ravi Kumar, with a Reserve Price at Rs.2,36,00,OOO/-'. The
petitioner participated in the e-auction and was declared as
successful bidder with the highest bid of Rs.2,38,36,0OO/-.
Counsel further submits that upon verihcation during the
pendency of the proceedings, it was noticed that out of 223.33
Square Yards of land, which was notified in the auction,26.22
square yards had already been gifted to the Municipal
t
I
t
T
I
I
Corporation uide Gift Deed, and therefore, the net available
extent was only l97.ll Square Yards. Therefore, the
respondent/ B:rnk issued the impugned communication
cancelling the Sale Certi{icate dated 04.07.2025 in good faith
and to avoid protracted disputes. lt is further stated that while
dealing with the issue ol territorial jurisdiction, the impugned
notice dated O9.O7.2025 was issued by the respondent/ Bank.
The Sale Certi[rcate, under Rule 9(6) of the Rules, dated
04 .O7 .2025 rvas also issued by the same Branch of the
respondent Bank.
6.
The respondent bank frled an additional counter aff-rdavit
on 12.02.2026, wherein at Paragraph 4, the respondent/Bank
states that at the request of rhe petitioner, who is a resident of
Ankerrpally, Mahaboob Nagar District, a copy of the proposed
Sale Certificatc was sent by the respondent/Bank through
I
Whatsapp on 04.07.2025, only for the purpose of ascertaining
the Stamp Duty, Registration fee etc., payable on Sale
Certificate at Sub-Registrar Office, Kurnool, and that no original
Sale Certificatc was issued or registered. It is further stated
that the respondent/ Bank has not provided physical/originat
Sale Certihcate and the original Sale Certificate remains in the
custody of the respondent Bank
7.
Paragraph 5 of the additional counter affidavit states that
prior to the issuance of the Final Sale Certilrcate, the Bank
discovered that a portion of the secured asset was affected by
road widening, resulting in a reduction of the actual extent
available. Since the full extent of the subject property could not
be conveyed, the Bank cancelled the auction dated 13.06.2025
in good faith.
8.
The additionai counter afhdavit, at paragraph 6, states
that based on the details furnished by the petitioner, the entire
bid amount of Rs.2,38,36,OOO/ - was refunded through RTGS on
O9.O7.2025 to the petitioner's Bank account and that the same
was communicated to the petitioner through email dated
09.o7.2025.
9.
After a comprehensive hearing of the Writ Petition,
I.A.No. 1 of 2O26 has been filed seeking to implead the owner of
the schedule property as respondent No.2 in the Writ Petition on
to.o2.2026.
10. Sri J. Prabhakar, Iearned Senior Counsel appearing for
the implead petitioner, submits that the implead petitioner and
his brother arc the olvners of the subject property and that the
implead petitioner is an aggrieved person. Therefore, Senior
Counsel prayed to altou the l.A.
II.
We havc heard learned counsel appearing for the parties
and given our earnest consideration to the pleadings and
perused the record.
12. The primzrry issue raised by the respondent/Bank is that
the Writ Petition is not maintainable for want of territorial
jurisdiction b1' placing reliance on the common order dated
O | .O7 .2022
, passed by a Division Bench of this Court in
W.P.Nos.299 18 of 2021 and Batch. The issue that arose in the
said Writ Petitrons was w.hether a subject matter taken up by
the Debts Recovery Tribunal-Il (DRT-II), Hyderabad, or any
order passed by the saicl Tribunal on a dispute arising out of the
SARFAESI Act, could be heard when both ttre parties to the
dispute as well as the cause of action had arisen in the State of
Andhra Pradesh. Paragraph 8 of the common order states that
the area of jurisdiction of the DRT-II, Hyderabad, in terms of the
Notification dated 25.01.2O17, categorically specifies various
places, including Anantapur, Chittoor, Cuddapah, and Kurnool
Districts in the State of Andhra Pradesh
13. As per the judgment o[ the Supreme Court in Kusum
Ingots & Allogs Llmited Vs. Unlon of Indlal , wherein the
Supreme Court categorically held that even if a small part of
cause of action arises within the territorial jurisdiction of a High
Court, the same, by itself, may not bc considered to be a
determinative factor compelling the High Court to decide the
matter on merit. In appropriate cases, the Court may refuse to
exercise its discretionary jurisdiction by invoking the doctrine of
forum conveniens. Further, Article 226 (2) of the Constitution
of India stipulates that if a part of the cause of action arises
outside the jurisdiction of the High Court, the High Court would
still have jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition.
14. In the present case, the impugned communication as well
as consequential correspondence was addressed to the
petitioner residing within the territorial jurisdiction of this
Court, thereby constituting part of the cause of action.
' (2004) 6 scc 254
t
I
I
t
i5.
Coming to the merits of the matter, the reason given by
the respondent/Bank for the cancellation of the Sale Certificate
is thzrt the Bank could not deliver the total extent of the
property, since part of the property had already been gifted to
the Municipal Corporation vide Gift Deed bearing
Doc. No.3622 / 2009 reducing the net available extent to 197.11
sq. yards. The counter affidavit filed by the respondent/Bank is
silent about the particulars of the auction and no details are
provided '"vith respect to the Gitt Deed executed in favour of the
Municipal Corporation.
16. This Court further linds that the respondent/Bank has
taken a specific stand that the email communication intimating
refund o[ the entire bid amount was forwarded to the petitioner
on 09.O7.2025. However, a perusal of the very email relied upon
by the respondent/ Bank, enclosing the RTGS transaction
particulars, reflects the date as 'O9.02.2026'. Therefore, there is
a contradiction in the material placed on record, which needs to
be addressed for the adjudication of the matter.
17. Further, It is pertinent to note that the respondent/Bank
has taken mutually inconsistent stands. In tjre impugned
l0
communication dated 09.O7.2025, the cancellation is attributed
to a prior Gift Deed executed in favour of the Municipal
Corporation rcducing the extent of land. However, in paragraph
5 of the additional counter-affidavit, the Bank asserts that the
reduction in extcnt was on account of road widening. These two
explanations arc materially distinct and cannot co-exist. The
shifting stand of the Bank undermines the credibility ol its
justification and reflects lack of due diligence in conducting the
auction process.
18. In the event that any shortfall was noticed by the
respondent/ Bank upon completion of the auction process, it
was incumbent upon the Bank to have detected and rectihed
such error with due diligence prior to issuance of the e-auction
notice. It is evident that the respondent/Bank failed to exercise
the requisite due diligence. The impugned communication
appears to have been issued only as an attempt to rectily or
cover up its own lapse, despite the absence of any authority to
!
cancel the Sale Certificate once it had been duly issued.
I
i
I
I
I
I
l1
19. Rule 9(6) of the Rules deals q,ith time of sale, issue of sale
certificate and delivery of possession etc. sub-Rule (6) thereof
states:
''
(6) On Lttlirntation ol sala h.t thc securcd creditor and if the
terms rf pavment have hecn L:omplied with. the authorized
ollicer exocising tht pov,er ol'sule shall issue a certificate of
.sale oJ the imntovtblc propertr in favour oJ' lhe purchaser in
lhe Form gircn in Appendix I' kt these rult's. "
20.
Section 17 of thc SARFAESI Act states :
I: .4pplication ogainsl meosures lo recover secured
debts. t l) .4n1' parson (including borrox,er). aggrieved by any
of the nrcusures reJbrred to in sub-section (4) of section 13
token b1, the secured creditor rr his atthorised officer under
this Chuptcr, [ma.t, makc an application along wilh suchfee, as
muy he prcscribtd,J to the Dehts Recowry Tribunal having
.jurisdiction in the malter v)ithin ./brty-live ,lays from the date
on ,'uhich such measure had been taken:
i
I
i
l
I'roridcd that di./-fcrtnt .fees may be prescribed for
making thc application by the botower and tle person
otLer than the borrower."
21. A bare perusal of the above provisions reflects that the
Bank has absolutely no power to cancel the Sale Certificate
under Rule 9(6) of the Rules, and such power vests under
1Z
Section i7 of the SARFAESI Act upon the grievance made by the
aggrieved party
22. Banks play a vital role in the financial system of the
country. Public trust in banking institutions is the foundation of
a strong national economy. When a public auction is conducted
under a law such as the SARFAESI Act, there must exhibit
transparency, clarity and finality in the process to maintain the
integriry of such transactions. Any arbitrary or inconsistent
action by the Bank especially when it gives different reasons at
different times, once states that the cancellation was due to a
Gift Deed and at another time attributing it to road widening,
weakens public confidence and creates uncertainty in statutory
auctions. Such conduct loses the conlidence of the public on
banks.
,:
I
23. In view of the foregoing discussion, W.P.No.2336O of 2025
is accordingly allou,ed setting aside the impugned
I
I
I
communication dated O9.O7 .2025. The petitioner shall pay
I
proportionate costs for 197.11 Square Yards of land, which is
the actual extent available, to the respondent/Bank, within four
weeks from the date of receipt of order. Upon receipt of such
:
i
amount, the respondent/Bank shall register the Sale Certificate
i
/
t
/
l3
i
d.ated 04.07.2025 in respect of 197 '11 Square Yards within
three weeks thereafter and deliver physical possession of the
subject property to the petitioner within three weeks from the
date of registration.
24. lnsofar as I.A.No. 1 of 2C26 (implead petition) is
concerned, this I.A has becn filcd at a belated stage and the
bona ftdes of the implead petitioner have not been established'
Therefore, we are of the view that the implead petitioner is not
an affected partY.
25. I.A.No.1 of 2026 is accorclingly dismissed
26. A1l other connectecl applications shall stand disposed of'
There shall be no order as to costs
SD/. C. DEEPIKA
SISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
I
L
-..-..
SECTION OFFICER
To
IBHATTACHA,RYA
One fair copy to the HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUS
(For Her Ladyship's Kind Perusal)
AND
One fair copy to the HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
(For His Lordship's Kind Perusal)
1. 11 L.R. Copies.
2.
The Under Secretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, Justice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi.
3.
The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association Library, High Court
Buildings, Hyderabad
4.
The Auth.orised Officer, Union Bank of lndia, Stressed Asset Management
Branch 3'o Floor, Andhra Bank Building, Koti Hyderabad Telangana Sta"te.
5.
One CC to SRI G. K. DESHPANDE, Advocate [OPUC]
o. One CC to Ms. V. DYUIVANI, Advocate [OPUC]
7.
t'h/ ,11
"V
MP
One CC to SRI K. KRISHNA SHRAWAN, Advocate tOpUCl
Two CD Copies
/
HIGH COURT
2t2026
DAT
/\)\/o
I (,
ilt
l\o
,\-t
V;'-.:
73 r
\),. *
\?-ggge.Y'
COMMON ORDER
l.A. No. 1OF 2026
IN/AND
WP.No.23360 of 2025
I
t
I
DISMISSING THE l.A. No.1 OF 2026
&
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
wryG6
,,-/
1,,7 \
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review