Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MANINDER S. BHATTI
ON THE 18th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 30229 of 2023
BETWEEN:LILA @ LILADHAR JATAV S/O SHRI MAKKHULAL
JATAV, AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCCUPATION: LABOR
BANGALI
COLONY
TEHSIL
AND
DISTRICT
NARMADAPURAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI ASEEM TRIVEDI - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
COMMISSIONER NARMADAPURAM DIVISION
NARMADAPURAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
PRADESH)
MAGISTRATE NARMADAPURAM
NARMADAPURAM
(MADHYA
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI PRADEEP SINGH - GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
There is a challenge to an order dated 31.7.2023 (Annexure P-3) passed
by District Magistrate Narmadapuram in Criminal Case No. 01 of 2023 and also
an order dated 22.11.2023 (Annexure P-6) passed by the Commissioner,
Narmadapuram in Appeal No. 23/Criminal Appeal/2023-24, under the
provisions of the M.P. Rajya Suraksha Adhiniyam, 1990 (hereinafter referred
to as Adhiniyam of 1990 for the sake of brevity).
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 1/22/2024
6:42:02 PM
2. The facts, as detailed in the petition, reveal that the petitioner herein,
who is a resident of Bengali Colony, Narmadapuram, was issued a notice and
was informed about initiation of proceedings of externment. The said notice
was replied by the petitioner. However, an order was passed by the District
Magistrate on 10.12.2007 by which the petitioner was externed for a period of
one year. An appeal preferred against the order of externment, was allowed by
the Commissioner vide order dated 25.2.2008 and the order of externment was
set aside. Thereafter, again the proceedings for externment were initiated, which
led to passing of an order dated 24.3.2018. The order of externment dated
24.3.2018 was assailed by the petitioner by filing an appeal, however, the said
appeal was also dismissed and order of externment dated 24.3.2018 was
affirmed by the Appellate Authority by passing an order dated 26.6.2018.
3. Assailing the orders dated 24.3.2018 and 26.6.2018, the petitioner
preferred a petition before this Court vide W.P. No. 15060 of 2018. This Court
by interim order dated 10.10.2018 has stayed the operation of orders dated
24.3.2018 and 26.6.2018 passed by the District Magistrate and the Appellate
Authority respectively.
4. Thereafter again the proceedings under Adhiniyam of 1990 were
initiated against the petitioner and order dated 31.7.2023 (Annexure P-3) of
externment has been passed by which the petitioner has been asked to remain
outside the territories of the areas/Districts, which are mentioned therein. Being
aggrieved by the order dated 31.7.2023 (Annexure P-3), the petitioner preferred
an appeal, however, the Appellate Authority has dismissed the appeal vide order
dated 22.11.2023 (Annexure P-6). Thus, assailing the orders dated 31.7.2023
(Annexure P-3) and 22.11.2023 (Annexure P-6), this petition has been filed.
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 1/22/2024
6:42:02 PM
5 . The counsel for the petitioner contends that in the present case, the
orders passed by the Authorities are unsustainable on the ground that the orders
impugned have been passed in view of the provisions of Section 5(a) and 6(c)
of Adhiniyam of 1990. It is contended that none of the aforesaid provisions are
applicable in the present case. It is further contended that the impugned order
cannot be passed by the District Magistrate in a purely mechanical manner. The
District Magistrate was required to arrive at a satisfactory conclusion that the
order of externment was imperative as future acts of the person concerned may
cause detriment to public tranquility. It is contended that in order to invoke the
provision of Section 6(c) of Adhiniyam of 1990, there has to be conviction
under Section 4-A of the Public Gambling Act, 1867 on three occasions within
a period of three years from the date of passing of an order of externment. It is
further contended that the said requirement is not fulfilled in the present case. It
is further contended that the orders impugned cannot be passed in violation of
the principles of natural justice. No independent witness was examined by the
District Magistrate before passing the impugned order. It is the further
contention of the counsel for the petitioner that since an order of externment has
direct nexus with the fundamental rights as enshrined under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India, the order has to be passed with utmost caution and the
Authority is duty bound to assign the reasons, which necessitate the order of
externment. Thus, the counsel while placing reliance on the decisions of this
Court in Meena Sonkar Vs. State of M.P. and others - 2017 (2) MPLJ
565, Preetam Sahu Vs. State of M.P. and others - 2012 (2) MPLJ 232
and Pappu @ Dinesh Gupta Vs. State of M.P. and others - 2007 (3)
MPHT 168 submits that the impugned orders be set aside.
6. Per contra, the counsel for the State submits that the present petition
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 1/22/2024
6:42:02 PM
filed by the petitioner is misconceived and, therefore, is liable to be dismissed
with cost. It is contended that there were three convictions of the petitioner in
last 3 years, which is evident from the perusal of the reply filed by the
respondents. It is also contended that in past, as many as 47 cases have been
registered against the petitioner and out of those 47 cases, about 44 cases
pertain to Section 4-A of the Public Gambling Act, 1867. It is further contended
that the details of all cases are mentioned in the Table, which has been
reproduced in the order of the District Magistrate and a perusal of the same
reveals that since the year 2002 till the year 2023, the petitioner has been
continuously committing the same offence. It is also undisputed that on earlier
two occasions, the proceedings under Adhiniyam of 1990 were initiated against
the petitioner and earlier also order of externment was passed but the operation
of the said order has been stayed by this Court vide order dated 10.10.2018
passed in W.P. No. 15080 of 2018. It is further contended that in the present
case there is due compliance of Section 5(a) and 6(c) of Adhiniyam of 1990
and, therefore, the present petition being devoid of merits, is liable to be
dismissed. The counsel has placed reliance on the order of this Court in W.P.
No. 6955 of 2019 (Sheikh Soyeb Vs. State of M.P. & another) dated
1.5.2020 and order dated 2.7.2019 passed by this Court in W.P. No. 9550
of 2019 (Umesh Patel Vs. The State of M.P.)
7. No other point is argued or pressed by the counsel for the parties.
8. Heard the submissions advanced on behalf of the parties and perused
the record.
9. Before dealing with the rival contentions of the parties, it is first
germane to refer to statutory provisions contained in Sections 5(a) and 6(c) of
Adhiniyam of 1990. Adhiniyam of 1990 has been enacted with an object to
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 1/22/2024
6:42:02 PM
provide for the security of the State, maintenance of public order and certain
other matters connected therewith. The two basic objects, which ensued in
enactment of Adhiniyam of 1990 are security of the State and maintenance of
public order. Section 5(a) of Adhiniyam of 1990 provides for removal of the
person, who are about to commit the offence. As per the provision of Section
5(a), if the movements or acts of any person are causing alarm, danger or harm
to person or property or if there are reasonable grounds for believing that such
person is engaged or is about to be engaged in commission of any offence
mentioned in section 5(b), the District Magistrate is empowered to remove him
outside the District or such area or Districts adjacent thereto. Section 6 also
provides for removal of persons, who are convicted of certain offences and as
per Section 6, apart from other offences, if a person has been convicted under
Section 4(a) of the Public Gambling Act thrice within a period of last three
years, the District Magistrate can pass an order of externment, if he has reason
to believe that such person is likely to engage in commission of offence similar
to that for which he was convicted. Therefore, so far as Section 5 is concerned,
it does not deal with an eventuality where a person has been convicted. It
comes into operation as preventive measure when there are reasonable grounds
for believing that such a person is engaged or is about to engage in commission
of offence which are mentioned therein. On the contrary, Section 6 deals with
the eventuality when a person is tried and convicted. Accordingly, Section 6
refers to certain provisions under which if the person is convicted, the power of
externment can be exercised. In Section 6(c), an amendment was made by M.P.
Act No. 28 w.e.f. 5.9.2006 and by the said amendment Section 4(a) of the
Public Gambling Act was also inserted in Section 6(c) of Adhiniyam of 1990.
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 1/22/2024
6:42:02 PM
Section 6(c) of Adhiniyam of 1990 provides that if a person has been convicted
thrice within a period of 3 years under Section 3 or 4 or 4(a) of the Public
Gambling Act, the District Magistrate may, if he has reason to believe that such
person is likely again to engage himself in commission of offence similar to that
for which he was convicted, direct such person to remove himself outside the
District or area of District as well. It is thus, clear that if in a case where there is
conviction on three occasions in last three years under the provisions, which are
mentioned in Section 6(c), the District Magistrate is empowered to invoke the
power of externment.
10. In the present case, the order impugned has been passed by the
District Magistrate on 31.7.2023. The order refers to as many as 47 cases,
which were registered against the applicant and out of those 47 cases, about 44
cases were registered against the applicant under Section 4(a) of the Public
Gambling Act. It is further evident from the perusal of Annexure R-1 filed by
the respondents along with the return that vide order dated 1.12.2020, the
present petitioner was convicted as a fine of Rs.1,000/- was imposed in Crime
No. 290 of 2020. Thereafter the petitioner was again convicted as regards Crime
No. 707 of 2020 as a fine of Rs.500/- was imposed upon the petitioner vide
judgment dated 21.12.2020. Then again two cases in the year 2022 vide Crime
Nos. 601 of 2022 and 825 of 2022 were registered but trials of those cases are
still pending. Thereafter again in the year 2023, a case vide Crime No. 28 of
2023 was registered against the applicant and again he was convicted vide order
dated 31.1.2023 as a fine of Rs.1000/- was imposed. Therefore, it is evident
that in last 3 years from the date of passing of impugned order dated 31.7.2023,
the petitioner was convicted thrice under Section 4(a) of Adhiniyam of 1990. It
is also evident from perusal of the record that earlier an order of externment was
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 1/22/2024
6:42:02 PM
passed and after passing of an order of externment way back on 24.3.2018,
again the petitioner committed similar kind of offence in the year 2020, 2022 and
2023, therefore, it is a case where the present petitioner committed similar kind
of offences repeatedly. Even after passing of order of externment dated
24.3.2018, again same kind of offences have been committed by the petitioner.
It is also evident that in last 3 years from the date of passing of order of
externment dated 31.7.2023, there are convictions under Section 4(a) of the
Public Gambling Act on three occasions. A perusal of order passed by the
District Magistrate further reflects that one Shri Vikram Rajak, SHO, P.S.
Kotwali, Narmadapuram was examined by the prosecution, who testified
specifically that the petitioner has been indulged in criminal activities since 2002
onwards. The said witness also narrated the effect of offences on the public at
large, which were being committed by the petitioner. It was further stated that as
the members of the vicinity were investing their hard earned money in
gamblings, which were being organized at the behest of the petitioner, their
financial conditions were being deteriorated and they were also being indulged
in other illegal activities. It was also testified by the said witness that the financial
position of families of vicinity were being deteriorated gradually and despite the
order passed, there was no improvement in the conduct of the petitioner.
11. The petitioner also examined one Smt. Jiji Bai Asre in his defence. It
is further evident from the perusal of the impugned order that the witness, who
was sought to be produced by the petitioner in his defence, even expressed her
unawareness as regards registration of 45 cases against the petitioner as well as
his criminal antecedents. The said witness was also not aware of the fact that in
past also an order of externment was passed against the petitioner.
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 1/22/2024
6:42:02 PM
12. Thus, the District Magistrate, taking into consideration, the
registration of aforesaid criminal cases and particularly the fact that despite the
measures taken recourse to by the Authorities, the petitioner did not make any
effort to ameliorate his conduct, opined that in order to maintain public order,
an order of externment was imperative and accordingly by passing the order of
externment, removed the petitioner for a period of one year from the territories
of Districts/areas mentioned in the impugned order.
12. In the considered view of this Court, the impugned orders do not
require any interference in view of the fact that right from 2002 till 2023 within a
span of 20 years about 44-45 cases under Section 4(a) of the Public Gambling
Act were registered against the applicant and in last three years, on three
occasions, the petitioner has also been convicted under Section 4(a) of the
Public Gambling Act.
13. The decisions relied upon by the petitioner are distinguishable on
facts, inasmuch as, in the present case, the District Magistrate has rightly
exercised the power under Section 5(a) and 6(c) of Adhiniyam of 1990.
14. Resultantly, the present petition being devoid of merit, is hereby
dismissed.
(MANINDER S. BHATTI)
JUDGE
PB
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 1/22/2024
6:42:02 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review