Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
134421
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
WRIT PETITION NO: 19617 OF 2025
Between:
Kwality lce lndustry, D.No.19-2-21 1/C, Ramnasthpura, Near Zoo Pay'r., Hyderabad 5OO 064 Rep. by its Proprietor Sri Vijay Kumar Agarwal, S/o Late Rajeshwar Lal
Agarwal, aged about 43.
.....PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by Principal Secretary (Energy), Govemment of
Telangana, Secretariat, Hyderabad - 500 063.
2. The Assistant Engineer, Operation, Chandulal Baradari, Hyd (South)'
Telangana Southem Power Distribution Company Limited, Hyderabad.
3. The Assistant Divisional Engineer,, Operation, Miralam, Hyd (South)'
Telangana Southem Power Distribution Company Limited, Miralam Tank,
Hyderabad - 500 064.
4. The Assistant Accounts Officer, ERO, Salarjung, Hyd (South), Telangana
Southem Power Distribution Company Limited, 1st Flool Salarjung Sub
Station,Hyderabad - 500 064.
5. The Divisional Engineer, Operation, Charminar, Hyd South'Telangana
Southem Power Distribution Company Limited, Punja Shah, Hyderabad - 500
064.
6. The Superintending Engineer, Operation, Hyderabad, South, Telangana
Southem Power Distribution Company Limited,l0thFloor, Vasanth Vihar,
Nampally, Hyderabad - 500 001.
7. The Vidyut Ombudsman for the State of Telangana, 1st Floor, 33/1 1 KV Sub
Station, beside Hyderabad Boats Club, Hyderabad - 500 063.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Arlicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
'circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
the file of Honourable
certiorari by callng record of Appeal No. 1 4 of 2O25 26 on
the award dated
Vidyut ombudsrnan for the State of Telangana and set aside
passed vide letter No' letter
30.06.2025 alonrl with the order of the DE, Charminar
07 I 2025 dAtcd
NO. DEE/ OP/ CHARMINAR/ TECHNICALI HYD / D. NO.
to additional charges
o4to4t2o25 inclrrding clairn of Rs. 11,72,462/-pertaining
2025 and direct to issue
claimed by the F.espondents from March, 2005 to February,
2025 in compliance of
revised C.C. Charges bills from March, 2005 to February,
Clause Vll 7.1 (i) (ii) of Regulation 5 of 2016'
|.A.NO:1 OF 20i!!
stated in the
Petition Und,ar section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
may be pleased to stay on the
affidavit filed in s;upport of the petition, the High court
Hon'ble Vidyut ombudsman
operation of the award dated 3oto6t2o25 passed by the
fortheStateof.I.elanganainAppealNo.14ot202S.26.
:2OF
t.A.
Between
Hyd (south)'
. The Assistant Engineer, operation, chandulal Baradari,
Hyderabad'
tetangana Southeli Po*"t Distribution Company Limited,
Miralam, Hyd (South),
2 . The Ass,istant Divisional Engineer,, operation,
Tank'
Telangana Southern Power Distribution Company Limited, Miralam
Hyderabard - 500 064.
fe]angana
3. The Assistant Accounts Officer, ERO, Salarjung, Hyd (Soutlt)'.
Sub
Satarjdng
Floor,
1st
power
Limited,
Company
Distribution
Southern
Station,Hyderabad - 500 064.
4. The Divisional Engineer, operation, charminar, Hyd Soulh,Telangana
- 500
southern Power Distribution company Limited, Punja Shah, Hyderabad
064.
Telangana
5. The superintending Engineer, operation, Hyd.erabad, south,
Vihar,
Southem power D"istribition Company Limited,lgthFloor, Vasanth
Nampalll', HYderabad - 500 001'
'
....PETITIONERS,RESPONDENTS NOS.2 tO 6
AND
Kwality lce lndustry, D.No.19-2-2'.11tc, Ramnasthpura, Near Zoo
Park,
S/o Late
HVJ.rlOrO - 500 OOi'nep. by ils Proprietor Sri Vijay Kumar Agarwal,
Rijeshw,ar Lal Agarwal, aged about 43'
.....RESPON DENT/WRIT PETITIONER
2. The State of Telangana, Rep. by Principal Secretary (Energy), Government of
Telangana, Secretariat, Hyderabad - 500 063.
3. The Vidyut Ombudsman for the State of Telangana, 1st Floor, 33111 KV Sub
Station, beside Hyderabad Boats Club, Hyderabad - 500 063.
petitionundersection.,u.,#f
t,T,f"UiilT'ft
:t"?':H5}::J:;tlo*'l
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate
the order dated09.7 .2025 passed in l.A.No.1 of 2025 in W- P No. 19617 of 2025, in
the interests of justice.
|.A.NO:2 OF 2026
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the respondent officials to restore the power supply of service connection bearing
No. M3009491 in W.P.No. 19617 of 2O25.
Gounselfor the Petitioner : Ms. NISHTHA
Counselfor the Respondent No.1 : GP FOR ENERGY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 to 6: SRI N.SREEDHAR REDDY
Counselfor the Respondent No.7 : The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HI(;H COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
WRIT PETITION NO.l96l7of 2025
THE IOTH DAY OF APRIL,2O26 "
Between:
Kwality lce Industry
...Petitioner
AND
The State of Tr:langana and 6 others
Respondents
ORDER:
This wri. petition is filed seeking the following relief:
"
... to issue a writ, order or direction more
particularly one in the nature of Writ of Ccrtiorari by
calling record of Appeal No.14 of 2015-26 on the fite of
Hon'ble Vidyut Ombudsman for the State of Telangana
and set aside the award dated 30.06.2025 along with the
orde: of the DE, Charnrinar passed vide letter No.DEE/
OP/ CHARMINAR/ TECHNTCAT./ I.IYD/D.NO.O7I2025
daterl 04.04.2025 including claim of Rs.!1,72,4621-
pertaining to additional charges claimed by the
Respondents from March, 2005 to February, 2025 and
direct to issue revised C.C.Charges bills from March,2005
to Fe bruary,2025 in compliance of Clause VII 7.1 (ixii)
of Re:gulation 5 of 2016 and ....."
2.
Heard Ms. Nishitha, learned counsel for the petitioner, learned
Government Ple:ader for Energy for respondent No. t and Sri N. Sreedhar
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
Reddy, leamed Standing Counsel appearing for respondent Nos'2
to 6
Perused the entire record-
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner is a consumer of
respondent Nos.2 to 6 of LT III Category service connection bearing
No.M300g4gl situated at Door No.l9-2-2lllC, Ramnastupura, Near
Park, Telangana. The petitioner is engaged in manufacture of
Zoo
ice blocks'
The respondents issued CC charges bitl for billing month of March,2005
dated 08.03.2005 other than monthly cc bill of Rs.52,455/amount of Rs.1,10,8 l7l- as arears and levied an amount of
showing an
Rs'2,5231- as
additional charges without furnishing any details and without
any prior
notice. The petitioner paid the CC charges bill as on February,
Thereafter, the petitioner approached this court vide Writ
No.5451 of 2005 and an interim order dated 17-03'2005 was
w.P.M.P.No.7217 of 2005 of W.P.No.5451 of 2005,
Petition
passed in
wherein, the
petitioner was directed to pay only monthly CC charges of
p.s'52,4551-'
Prima facie, it was determined that the claim of Rs'[,10,8171'is
billing and the same was to be verified at the time of final
Thereafter, the petitioner paid only CC charges after deducting
charges which were levied illegally every month in
Court's order. The respondents raisecl CC charge bills
2005'
wrong
hearing'
additionat
violation of this
from the month of
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
March 2005 to February 2o25,levying additional cc charges bills
every
month without fumishing any details of their claim of additional charges'
The respondents have levied massive amount of Rs'1L,72,461/- towards
additional charges from March, 2OO5 to February, 2025- The writ
petitioner dr.rring the pendency of W.P. No.545l of 2005, in addition to
monthly CC charges, paid amount of Rs.80,000/- on 05.11'2011,
Rs.60,0001- :,n2l.o4.2ol t, R1.18,000/- on 28.03.2013 and Rs-18,740l3 I .05.2013 i.e., total amount of Rs.1,76,7 40/- against
on
the disputed amount
of Rs.l,[0,817/-. Vide order dated 08.10.2014, this Court in W'P'No'5451
of 2005 dir,:cted the respondents to defer demand of Rs'1,[0,8171-, to
issue a noti,:e to the petitioner within a period of 3 months, to
give an
opportunity of submitting representation and then to pass appropriate
orders for recovery of alrears. From 08.10.2014 up to 15'02'2025, the
respondents have not taken any steps to issue notice' Left with no
alternative, the petitioner fited W.P.No.4 741 of 2025 about the inaction of
the respondent Nos.2 to 6 in compliance of orders dated 08.10'2014 in
w.P.No.54jil of 2oo5.This court disposed of w.P.No.474l of 2025 with
a direction to consider the representation dated 22.01.2025 submitted by
the petitioner in pursuance of impugned notice dated 17.01 .2025 and
J5.02.2O25 and to fotlow principles of, natural justice by giving an
RY,J
w.P t9617 2025
opportunity for hearing. The DE, Charminar, in compliance of the orders
dated 25.02.2025 in w.P.No.474l of 2025, issued Letter
No.DEE/Op/Charminar/Technical/ Hyd/D.No.2 I 49124, dated I 1.03 .2025
with a demand for payment of Rs.[4,27,0971- instead of the disputed
amount of Rs. 1,10,8 17 /-. The petitioner was directed to appear for hearing
on 15.03.2025 and after one adjoumment, on 22.03.2025, hearing was
conducted. The DE, Charminar disposed of the representation of the
petitioner vide order dated 09.04.2025 directing to pay an amount of
Rs.12,40,4511- upto March 2025 as per ledger balance. The petitioner
approached Consumer Grievances Redressal Forum-2 (CGRF-2),
challenging the order passed by the DE, Charminar by preferring
C.G.No.03t2\25-26lllyderabad South Circle. An award was passed vide
Order dated 31.05.2025 by CGRF to the effect that complaint is regarding
non-implementation of High Court order and therefore, expressing
inability to deal with said subject, the complaint was rejected- Aggrieved
by the same, the petitioner approached Vidyut Ombudsman vide Appeal
No.14 of 2025-26 and the same was disposed of vide Award dated
30.06.2025. In Appeal No. t4 of 2025-26, the Vidyut Ombudsman
directed the petitioner to pay an amount of Rs.9,8 6,4591- in 10 equal
RY,J
w.P t9617 2025
monthly inr;tallments from 05.07.2025 to 30.04.2026. Aggrieved by the
same, the writ petition is preferred.
4.
The oetitioneCs case is that payments made by a consumer as per
Clause 7 of Code of Practice have priorities. Firstly, to adjust the payment
towards arft)ars of CC charges, then towards arrears of additional charges,
surcharge u'hich is undisputed, then second priority towards payment of
current month CC charges, followed by current month additional charges
surcharge. While so, the respondents have repeatedly adjusted the
payment made by the petitioner towards CC charges, towards disputed
additional c:rarges multiple times during the period between March 20A5
to February 2025. [n grounds of the writ petition, it is pleaded that this
Court had deferred payrnent of arreztrs of Rs.1,l0,817l- but the same was
not considered as observed in this court's order dated 25.02.2025 in
W.P.No.474l of 2025. Further, it is case of petitioner thar the Vidyut
OmbudsmarL failed to consider the adjustment of Rs.7,ll,68l/- in
additional charges account in violation of Clause 7 of Code of Practice on
payment of llills by consumer. The adjustment of amount of Rs.7,l1,681/-
of the respondents' ledger shows due amount in CC charges, which was
actually pai<l of,f every month and subsequently additional charges were
levied on those impugned CC charges and thereby, respondents
RY,J
w.P 19617 7025
accumulated the impugned additional charge of Rs.11,72,,462l- illegally'
The petitioner pleaded that additional charge of Rs. I1,72,462l- claimed
in
the CC charge bills from March 2005 to February 2025 is not correct and
in violation of court order dated 17.03.2005 in W.P.M.P.No.72l7 of 2005'
The Vidyut Ombudsman failed to consider the amount paid by the
petitioner for Rs. 1,40,000/- on 2L .O4.2Ol1 and Rs.36,740l- on 3 I '05 '2013
due to disconnection of power supply illegatly against disputed amount
of
Rs.[,L},}lll-. The petitioner pleaded that the disputed amount of
Rs.l,l},8l7l- is already paid and therefore, additional charges from
2l.o4.2}tl to February, 2025 is incorrect. tt is further contented that
Vidyut Ombudsman failed to consider this court's order dated 25.02-2025
in Wp No. 4741 of 2025 in recording the fact that this Court's order dated
08.10.2014 in w.P.No.545l of 2005 and recorded that respondents issued
notice dated 20.10.2014 served in person by Registered Post without
veriffing the original documentary evidence of the respondents- tt is
claimed that the respondents created fatse documents to cover up their
lacuna. In 2015, it is the petitioner who approached the respondents
with
written representation dated 19.06.2015 to comply the Court order in
W.p.No.S+St of 2005, dated 08.10.2014. In view of the foregoing, the
RY.J
w.P 19617 2025
petitionerprayedthattheorderofVidyutombudsmanandtheDE,
Charminar be set aside.
5.
The respondent Nos.2 to 6 filed counter affidavit
the petitioner is a consumer of electricity with the
to the effect that
respondents' For the
month of August 2002, a bill was raised for Rs.1,22,739l-
under status
.door lock' i.e. whenever, a meter reader went, the premises of the
consumer wls closed and not available for taking
average consumption was automaticalty taken
F(s.|,22,73g1.. was raised. Thereafter, the
meter reading' The
and bill for an amount of
petitioner approached the
Accounts Offrcer, General Revenue Circle, Mint
Compound and the bill
was revised by deducting Rs.tl,g22l'for an amount
However, du,e to system error, in September,2002'
Status
of Rs'1,10,817/-'
the bill issued under
,03, tbr Rs.(-)l,2},t}6l-(negative amount) as the amount was
withdrawn t'wice. The system was showing excess balance
and the Same
wasreflecterjasnegativealTearsofRs'1,30'019/-'Theconsumerdidnot
pay the monthly charges but utilised the alrears
with adjustment of excess
amountdur.ingtheperiodSeptember,2oo2toApril,2003.This
was discovered during audit conducted in the month of
discrepancy
f"bruury, 2005. There was shortfall amount of Rs'1,10,817/- and
the same
was added in the bill of February, 2005- Aggrieved by said
bill, the
I
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
petitioner preferred Writ Petition No.5451 of 2005, which was disposed of
in the year 2014 with a direction to issue notice and then to give an
opportunity of hearing before making the demand for payment.
Accordingly, the respondents issued notice dated 20.10.2014 under
acknowledgment. There was no response from the petitioner. The
respondents issued another notice dated 15.05.2022 and the petitioner
submitted representation dated 17.02.2022. The Assistant Accounts
Officer gave details of the bills of the year 2002, which were rectified in
the year 2005. The petitioner was requested to pay the pending amount
with surcharge amounting to Rs.10,03,206/-. The petitioner did not pay
said amount and therefore, the respondents disconnected the connection.
Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner filed W.P.No.474l of 2025, which
was allowed directing the respondents to consider restoration of power
supply. Then, representations were submitted on 22.01.2025- In
conformity with principles of natural justice, opportunity for hearing was
given and notice dated 11.03.2025 was issued to the petitioner for a
personal hearing on22.03.2025. Thereafter, the petitioner was directed to
pay an amount of Rs. 1,4,27,097l- upto February 2025. The petitioner did
not pay the amount of Rs.[4,27,0971- but approached Consumer
Grievances Redressal Forurn (CGRF) for redressal. CGRF rejected the
I
RY,J
w.P 19617 202s
complaint ''ride order dated 31.05.2025. Aggrieved by the same, the
petitioner approached Vidyut ombudsman by filing Appeal No.l4 of
2025-26 an,J said appeal was disposed of vide order dated t4.04.2025
directing tht: petitioner to pay an amount of Rs.9,86 ,45g/-to be paid in l0
equal monttrly installments commencing fiom 15.07.2025. The petitioner
again chose not to pay the installments and approached this court by filing
writ petition. The respondents pleaded that all the facts and reasons given
were consiclered by Vidyut Ombudsman while passing the impugned
award. Further, the amount dues were ordered to be paid in l0 equal
monthly installments. As such, there is no irregularity or illegality in
passing of ttre award. The respondents pleaded that in a writ of certiorari,
this Court cannot make a roving inquiry on facts decided by fact-finding
authorities and can interfere only when there is an error of law which is
apparent on the face of the record but cannot be an appeal. It is pleaded
that the petitioner is simply trying to avoid payment by dragging the issue
over past 20 years in spite of having complete details of the issue. As
such, sought dismissal of the writ petition.
6.
The leamed counsel for petitioner argued that the respondents have
failed to adhere ro the directions given by this court in w.p.No.545l of
2005, wherein the disputed amount of arrears of Rs.l,tl,gl7l- are
'j -9
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
deferred. Since said amount was deferred, no additional charges
attracted on the disputed amount as the respondents did not
would be
give notice for
said disputed amount nor passed any speaking order in compliance
argued that
orders of this Court. Further, the learned counsel for petitioner
an amount of Rs.7,11,861/-has been adjusted in additional charges
violation of Clause 7 of Code of Practice. When the petitioner
charges only in compliance of this court orders, the Vidyut
of
in
paid CC
Ombudsman
failed to consider the adjustment of Rs.7,11,861/- with the respondents
charges
showing ledger due amount in CC charge account and additional
were tevied on the impugned CC charges and thereby, the respondents
accumulated the impugned additional charges of Rs' 11,72,462l-
claimed on
The petitioner argued that additional charges of Rs.1L.,72,462lthe CC charge bills from March 2005 to February 2025
illegally'
is not correct and
that same is in violation of Clause 7 of Code of Practice on
payment of
bills by consumer. Further, the amounts paid by the petitioner from
year 20l l were not considered. The petitioner argued that no
notice was
issued pursuant to the order passed by this court in w.P'No'5451
dated 08.10.2014. Though a pleading is made about issuing
ZO.1O.ZOi4, said notice was served without veriffing
the
of 2005
notice on
documentary
evidence. The respondents did not file the original documents
of
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
registered posts first or in-person served notice along with written
representatic'n dated I 9.06.2005.
7.
The learned counsel for respondents argued that complete details
about the manner in which arrears have been calculated are furnished to
the petitioner in compliance of this court's order in W.P.No.545l of 2005.
An opportunity for hearing was given and thereafter, the D.E., Charminar
has passed order dated 09.04.2025 directing to pay an amount of
Rs.12,40,451/- upto March 2025 as per ledger balance. Subsequently, the
petitioner hr:rein challenged the same vide Appeal No.l4 of 2025-26
before Vid5'ut Ombudsman and said appeal was disposed of by
considering merits of the petitioner's case in detail by directing the
petitioner to pay an amount of Rs.9,86,4591- against the Demand notice
issued for Fi.s.14,27,0971- tt is argued that facility was given to the
petitioner tc, pay the affears in l0 installments commencing from
15.07 .2025. 'the petitioner herein did not comply with the order of Vidyut
Ombudsman but approached this court. [t is argued that the sole intention
of the petitioner is to drag on the proceedings which it had been doing
from 20 years, in spite of providing details as to the manner in which the
arrears have been accumulated. In that context, the learned Standing
Li
.,i;M
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
Counsel for respondents relied upon order of this court in Writ Petition
No.3l 163 of 2023,dated 22.07.2024, wherein, it is held as follows:
*8.
In the absence of petitioner.'s challenge to the orders
of CGRF which was affirmed by the ' Award dated
25.05.2023 passed by the Vidyut Ombudsman in Appeal
No.2 of 2023, this Court is not inctined to delve upon the
allegations levelled against the respondents by petitioner
nlore particularly with respect to the contention of
petitioner that in the CC bill for December, 2021, the
Maximum Demand (MD)/Total Consumption (KVA) has
been incorrectly shown and charged as 28852, whereas as per
Settlement Statement, the highest recorded MD was 28316 as
the said issue was already dealt with extensively and
adjudicated upon by the authorities stated supra."
8.
The above ratio is not applicable as the petitioner herein not only
challenged the award passed by the Vidyut Ombudsman but also
challenged the award passed by CGRF and therefore, there is no issue
about the writ perition being not maintainable. It is held that this Court is
not inclined to delve upon the allegations levelled against the respondents
in the CC Bill, when said issue has been dealt with extensively and
adjudicated by the CGRF as well as the Vidyut Ombudsman. This finding
is partty applicable to the facts of the present case as wetl in view of the
respondents giving notice to the petitioner through D.E., Charminar with
coyfrete details of the manner in which alrears of Rs- 14,27,097/- has
t2
RY,J
w.P 196t7 2025
been arrived. Thereafter, a hearing was conducted and award was passed
by the D.E. ,\ggrieved by the same, the petitioner approached the CJRF
f,ollowed by Vidyuth Ombudsman. The Vidyuth Ombudsman has dealt
with the issue in detail and reduced the arrears to Rs.9,8 6,4591'with a
direction to pay the arrears amounts in 10 instalments. Therefore, it is
argued that orrce the concemed authorities have dealt with factual aspects,
this Court under the writ jurisdiction of certiorari cannot delve upon said
issues in the manner of an appeal. Further, the learned Standing Counsel
for responderits relied upon the case of Central Council for Research in
Ayurvedic Sr:iences and another v. Bikartan Das and othersl, wherein,
it is held that while exercising the extraordinary jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Cgnstitution, more particularly for issuing a writ of certiorari,
the High Court does not exercise powers as an Appellate Tribunal. The
only purpose of issuing a writ of certiorari is when the order is considered
to be without jurisdiction or palpably erroneous, but not for the purpose of
substituting its views with those of the inferior tribunal. Further, it is held
that certiorari shalt be issued to correct elrors ofjurisdiction i.e. excess or
failure to exercise jurisdiction or to correct a patent illegality. A writ of
certiorari, beiirg a high prerogative writ, is issued by a superior court with
' (zoz:)scconline s(l 996
RY,J
w.P
19617
]ozs
respecttojudicialorquasi-judicialfunctionsbyanotherauthority.Itis
arguedthatthereisnoallegationonthepartofthewritpetitionerwith
respecttoeitherexerciseofexcessjurisdictionornon.exerciseof
jurisdictionorapatenterrorapparentonthefacloftherecord.Itis
arguedthatthewritofcertiorarimaynotbeissued,incasethewrit
petitionerintendstochallengethefindingoftheVidyutombudsmanand
thefindingoftheCGRFwithrespecttofactualissuesadjudicated.As
such,contentedthatthecurrentwritpetitionisnotmaintainable.
g.Aperusaloftherecordshowsthatthedemandnoticewhichwas
challengedbythewritpetitionerwasissuedintheyear2005.Saidnotice
demandingpaymentofRs.l,l0,8lT/-waschallengedinW.P.No.545lof
2005.Bywayofinterimprotection,thisCourtinW.P.M.P.No.T2\Tof
2005inW.P.No.545lof2005,datedl7.03.2005,directedtherespondents
todeferthepaymentaStoarrearsanddirectedthepetitionertopay
monthlyCCcharges.Thereafter,themainpetitionwasadjudicatedby
passingorderdated0S.t0.20l4directingtherespondentstoissuenotice
andgiveanopportunityofpersonalhearingandthen,topassanorderon
according to
the arrears to be paid. Thereafter,
the respondents' notice was
issuedtothepetitionerincomplianceofthiscourtsorderon20.l0.20l4,
.J
buftherewasnoresponsefromthepetitioner.Tothecontrary,thecaseof
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
the petitioner is that the respondents did not comply with the order passed
by this cotrrt and no notice was issued. Therefore, the petitioner
approached rhe respondents vide letter dated 19.06.2015 to comply the
order of this Court in W.P.No.545l of 2005, dated 08.10.2014. But there
was no res,ponse up to 15.02.2025. Thereafter, vide order dated
15.02.2025, the power supply to petitioner was disconnected. Aggrieved
by the same, W.P.No.474l of 2025 was filed and the same was disposed
of with a dir:ection to the respondents to comply with the order of this
Court in W.ll.No.5451 of 2005. In compliance of said order, the D.E.,
Charminar issued letter dated 11.03.2025 for Rs.14,27,0971- showing the
arears amouLnt up to February, 2025. According to the petitioner, said
amount ought to have been for Rs.l,l0,817l- but not Rs.14,27,097/-. ln
this context, it is alleged that there is a direction to attend hearing on
15.03.2025 ,md upon concluding the hearing, the D.8., Charminar
directed the petitioner to pay an amount of Rs.lZ,40,45ll- up to March
2025 as per ledger balance. The petitioner contends that their plea to
deduct the arnount paid in the interim was not considered. Therefore, the
petitioner approached CGRF, which disposed of the matter without
adjudicating rnerits of the case. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner then
' approached Vidyut Ombudsman and said authority has passed the
titli
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
impugned order. According to the petitioner, there is violation of Clause 7
of Code of Practice on payment of bills
10. At first, the petitioner herein approached this Court by filing
W.P.No.545l of 2005 challenging the inclusion of a sum of Rs.l, 13,34Ol-
under the head of arrears and additional charges in the bill dated
08.03.2005. This Court vide order dated 08.10.2014 deferred the affears
of Rs.l,l0,817l- inthe said bill granting liberty to the respondents to issue
notice to the petitioner with regard to payment of arrears, within a period
of three months. Due to non-compliance of said order and respondents
issuing disconnection notice dated 15.02.2025, the petitioner filed
W.P.No.474l of 2025, wherein, this Coum vide order dated 25'02'2025
directed the respondents to consider the representation of the petitioner
pertaining to restoration of power suppty to petitioner's unit within a
period of one week. However, the respondents without complying the said
order too had straight away issued notice dated 11.03.2025 demanding
payment of Rs.14,27,Og7l-. In the said notice, there is a mention about
the issuance of notice on 20.09.2014,, however, that notice is not pursuant
to orders of this Court dated 08.10.2014 in W.P.No.5451 of 2005. [n the
said notice, it is mentioned that in pursuance of the orders passed in
W.P.No.474l of 2005, dated 25.02.2025, the respondents requested the
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
petitioner to attend personal hearing. Even though there was a direction of
this Court to defer the arrears in the monthly bill issued on 08.03.2005,
there was clrlim of Rs.11,72,4621- by DE., Charminar, with calculation of
additional charges, ACD surcharge, ED interest and R & C penalties
which is against the Clause 7 of Code of Practice. However, the CGRF
did not cons,ider the complaint of petitioner. [n appeal also, the Vidyut
Ornbudsman without considering the Clause 7 of Code of Practice
modified the order dated 04.04.2025 passed by DE., Charminar directing
\
\
the petitionr:r to pay Rs.9,86,459l- by deducting 50yo of the total
additional surcharge amount of Rs.2,53,9921- from Rs.[2,40,451/- that
was demand,:d by DE., Charminar
I
l.
As ri;ghtly pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
respondents have adjusted the monthly CC charges and subsequent
payments made by the petitioner towards arrears which was deflerred by
this Court ttrat too again levying additional charges on them, which is
against Claur;e 7 of Code of Practice. Hence, the impugned award passed
by the Vidyut Ombudsman is liable to be set aside.
12.
[n vie:w of the foregoing, the writ petition is allowed setting aside
the impugnecl award dated 30.06.2025 in Appeal No.14 of 2025-26 passed
by the Vidyut Ombudsman and the respondents are directed to restore the
L7
t
I
RY,J
w.P 19617 2025
power supply to the petitioner unit forthwith. Consequently, the matter is
remanded back to D.8., Charminar to consider the monthly payments and
interim payments that were made by the petitioner from March, 2005 to
February, 2025 as specifred in Clause 7 (Adjustment of Bill Amount) of
Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory Commission (APERC) Code of
Practice on payment of bills by consumers and to take further steps.
There shall be no order as to costs. Miscellaneous applications, if
any, pending shall stand closed
//TRUE COPYII
SD/. A. SREENTVASA
ASSISTANT REG
SECTTON OFFICER
To
The Principal Secretary, (Energy), Govern
Telangana, Secretariat,
State of Telangana at Hyderabad - S0O 063.
2. Ihe Assistant Engineer, Operation Chand
ari, Hyd (South),
Telangana Southern power Distribution Company
ited, Hyderabad
3. The Assistant Divisional Engineer, Operation, Miralam, Hyd (South),
Telangana Southern power Distribution Company Limited, Miralam
Tank,
Hyderabad - 500 064.
4. The Assistant Accounts officer, ERo, sararjung, Hyd (south), Terangana
Southern Power Distribution Company Limiied, 1st- Floor, Saiagung -5ub
Station, Hyderabad - S00 064.
5. The Divisionar Engineer,, operation, charminar, Hyd south,Tetangana
Southem Power Distribution Company Limited, Punja Shah, HyJlrabad
- S00
064.
6.
superintending Engineer,_ operation, Hyderabad, south, Telangana
Ih"
'
Southern Power Distribution Company timitiO,tOthFloor, Vasanth Vihar,
Nampally, Hyderabad - 500 001.
7. The Vidyut Ombudsman for the State of Telangana, 1st Floor, 33111KV Sub
station, beside Hyderabad Boats club, Hyderadad - 5oo 063.
8' Two CC's to G.P FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderabad. (OUT)
9. One CC to Ms. NISHTHA, Advocate tOpUCl
10.one cc to sRr N.SREEDHAR REDDY, Advbcate (opuc)
1 1 . Two CD Copies
SA
GJP \
qJx
i
i
---!.F:.;.:
HIGH COIURT
DATED: I 010412026
...,..-.
r'.
,..
l-)
i)
ORDER
WP.No.19617 of 2025
ALLOWING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
o
e."e\9
R
\5u
o'J'
,-ii':[E O A
-
(i)
1$
\\\
{ DE}
la
+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review