Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
[ 348e ]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NO: 32888 OF 2021
Between:
Kumari G. Govinda Lakshmi, D/o. Late G.N. Acharya, Aged 47 years, Former
Junior Civit Judge, Hyderabad.
...pETlTtoNER
AND
1. The Government of Telangana, Represented by Honorable Secretary to
Government, Legal Affairs, Legislative Affairs and Justice.
2. The Honorable High, The Honorable High Court for the State of Telangana,
Represented by the Honorable Regrstrar (Vigilance) Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction especially one in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus declaring that
a) Orders issued in G.O.N/Is.No.40, Law (LA, LA and J-Home-Courts.42 )
Department, dated 131071202 1 Government of Telangana and consequential
Proceedings in ROC Nos.18'1 5/201 5,54812016,2266/2016 and 7612019VIGILANCE CELL, dated 1310712021 are illegal and contrary to Article 311of
constitution of lndia and apart from it being violative of Article 14, 16,21 and 300(4) of the Constitution of India.
b) Further the Petitioner is entitled to continue in service till she attains the age
of superannuation of 61 years with full salary and allowances and all
consequential benef its.
c) Further the Petitioner prays that this Honorable High Court to declare that the
punishment imposed ts too harsh and excessive.
IA NO: 10F 2021
PetitionUnderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinth:Circumstancesstated
be pleased to
in the affidavit filed rn support of the petition, the High C I rrt may
(LA LA and Joperation of the impugned order in G O Ms'No 'l r' Law
stay the
Home-Courts.A2)Department,datedl3/07/202lGovernrentofTelanganaand
consequential Proceedings inROCNos.1815t2O15, 948 10'l 6' 226612016
pending disposal of the Writ
76/201 g-VIGILANCE CELL, dated 13tO7t2021
anC
Petitton.
CounselforthePetitioner:SRIM.SURENDERRAO,SENIT)RCOUNSELFOR
SRI SRINIVASA RAO MAt IRAJU
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SMT. SHALINI, GP FC t SERVICES-Il
SC FOR
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI KOWTURI PAWA\ KUMAR'
TSHC
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WP.No. 3288 8 of 2O2l
DI.ZO.62.2 026
Between
Kumari C.Govinda Lakshmi
....Petitioner
AND
The Government of Telangana & another.
Responde nts
O R D E R: (Per the Hon'ble Sn Justice Sudd.o.ta Chalapathi
1.
Rao)
The present Writ petition is filed challenging G.O.Ms.No.40,
Law (LA, LA&J-Home-Courts.42) Departmenr, d.t.13.OZ.2O2I
issued by the Government of Telangana, subjecting the petitioner
to major punishment of "compulsory retirement from service,, as
Junior Civil Judge, under Clause g Rule 9 of Telangana Civil
Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1991 (for
short
'CCA Rules') and the consequcntial proceedings in
ROC.Nos. l8l5/2OtS,
948/2016, 2266/2Ot6 and T6/2otg_
Vigilance Cell, dt. 13.07 .2021 , as illegal, contra., to Article 3 I
I
apart from it berng violative of Articles 14, i6 &,21 of the
Constitution ol India
FACTS OF THE CASE
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, rlr : petitioner r.r,,as
selected and apoointed as Junior Civil Judge on 2l.1l.2o}g
pursuant to the norification issued by the then Il gh Court for the
composite St:rte of Andhra Pradesh in the year ltof)g. ,r-,, u,tr, ,n.
petitioner u'ls posted in Kurnool District an,l thereafler, she
performed her duties as Junior Civil Judge in ,r rrious Courts in
the composite State of A.P., and during trif rrcertion oi the
composite Hieh Court for the State of Andl-rra I) adesh. she rvas
allocated to the Higtr Court for the State of Telane .r na.
3.
Furthcr'. pursuant to the complaints as to ler misconduct,
the petitionel' \\,as subjected to departmenta[ :nquiry for the
period duri'g ri hich she discharged her duties ar r rr-noor(Adilabad)
and Warangal and she u.as ser.r,etl rvith four char 1e memos. The
concerned District Judges, bv fcliowing the P - )cedure, issued
shoq,-cause notice s directii-rg the petitione r
to submit
explanations, and tl-re petitioner hzrs subrnitted ex: lanations to the
said shor'.-cause notices_ Further, the respon::nts not being
satisfied with the explanations of thc pctitioner, have subjected
the petitioner to departmental enquiries and appointed the
respective Enquiry Officers to conduct enquiry on the four charge
memos in accordance rvith the procedure laid don'n under A. P.
Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 (for short 'the rules').
For convenience and better understanding, the charges
4.
framed and the findings of the Enquiry Olficer recorded, in all the
lour Charge Memos are extracted hereunder in tabular format:
Article
of
Charge
Charge framed
Findings of the Enquiry
Officer
No.
CHARGE MEMO I - ROC No.1815/20 1s-vigilance Cell, dt.O6.06.2O17
Thal- you Ms. G.Govinda Lakshmi,
Junior Civil Judge, IV Additional
J unior Civil Judge, Warang:,
while working as Junior Cilil
Judgc, Utnoor, Adilabad district,
during the relevant period from
LO-]-2-2OI3 to 3l-12-2O).3
disposed of 14 calendar cases, as
shown in the Annexure I, b-r,
taking up the entire process of
cxamination of the Accuscd under
Section 251 or 239 Cr.P.C.. as the
case may be, framed charges,
conducted tria,t and pronounced
judgment, on the self same day,
contrary to the mandatory
procedure prescribed under
Sections 242 &,254 Cr.P.C., thus
giving a go-bye to the cstablished
provision of law, acted ilicgaliy,
hastily and in hurried manner, for
the reasons best known to ou,
The cases listed in AnnexurcI and the proceedings/
_;udgmcnts undcr Exs.P8 to P21
shor.v that thc charged ofltccr
disposcd of scvcral warrant
cases on the sarne day of
framing of charges or
examination o[ the accused. She
did not fix dales for production
ol prosecution witnesses as
rcquircd uncler Scctions 242 and
254 Cr.P.C. lmmcdiatcly after
framing the charge, only one
r.l,itness was examined, and the
remaining u'itnesses were
allorved to be given up by the
Assistant Public Prosecutor, arrd
judgment u,as pronounccd on
thc samc day.
Thus, thc chargcd offrcer
failed to follovv the maldatory
rovisions of Sections 242 & 254
I
\/hich act of yours if proved or Cr.P.C., ar I did not act in
establishL.d rvoulcl amount to accordancr with law, resulting
grave misconduct, unbccoming of in miscarri r 1e of justice, ald thc
a .Judicial officcr within thc said beha ' rr of thr: charged
meaning of Rule 3 of A.P. Civil officer corl titul es misconduct
Se rvices (C-onduct) Rules 1964.
under Ru lt 3 ol- the Telangara
State Ciril Services (Conduct)
,whi le so, r,otr have also disposed Rules, 19tl.l irncl according helci
of C.C.No.t78/20 I3 on 30-12- Articles ol )harge Nos. 1&2
20 13 on the self same da;', by are proved
examinrlr g onl,r. one victim/injured
i.e., Pau:rr Iiousalya Bai, W/o.
Ganpath and givcn up the othcr
trvo victim s/ inlu red, Viz., .jadhav
Sarasr,.,athi and [)au.ar Marritha,
u'ho arc tlrr' l.rrimc u itnesses in
the sarcl c zrsc along r,vith other
witnesses :rncl thus giving a gobyc. to thc proccdure prescribed
actcd as zr mute spectator in the
procccdings \\,itltou t ad\.ising the
APP to c-rarninc the irlurcri in
support oi thc Proseclltion case,
cansed rl(.nt t() the criminal
just ice s\,stem and thereby
committ-rl qr ,rrc illegalitl in not
examinitrg the
other
two
worrld irutollnl
to
grave
victims/rn1urcd. for the reasons
bcst knorr r.t to r,.orr, u'hicl-r act of
yours i1- 1;roved or established
miscor-rduc't, r,rnltccoming of a
judrcial ,,ffr, r.r'irilhrn lll( meanir.]g
of Rulc 3 ol A. P Civil Sen,ices
Cor-rduct) lRules 1964
While so. or.r l5-0U 2015, har ing
receiyed l)tirnirlion from srr. M.
The evirlt.r ceofPWs1to4
establishes rat the Principal
District .h:, ge (PW,+) had
Raghunartrl:ur, Supcrintcndcnt,
Junior Cn il Jr.rdge's Court, communicatc, his proposed visit
Utnoor, zrboLrt the visit of to Utnoor vell in adr.ancc
Prrncipal Disrrict J r"rdge. Adilabad through P\l': L and 2, directing
to Utnoor rln the sarne clay at the charge.c officer to make
04:30 PM rcgzLrd ng the
necessary z -r'angemerlts for
r
readiness ol
the
neu4y
constructcd Cour.t builcling ar.rd
Residenti:rl quartcr at Utnoor for
lnauguratlolt, \ ou intcntio
avoided corning there and to
the Princt pirl District Ju slgs d
inspecLion
r
I
the
newly
constructed: rurt building and
residential ( uarters_ Dcspite
prior intimat rn, the charged
oflicer was rr rt present
the visit. P$'. 1P I OCCSS
only tviLh a ma.lafide intenl,ion o[
causing inconvenicnce to thc
Principal District Judge, Adilabad,
you callcd back the Attender- Sri.
Gunavanth Rao, r.r,ho \4,as
instructed to be present at the
informed that the charge ofhcer
was on protocol duty and had
sent thc kcys through an
attender and shc did not meet
PW4 before he left.
The lettcr of the Honble High
neuly constructcd court building Court datcd 24.08.2015 (Ex.D6)
a'long ri,ith the keys and retained required resenalion of a suite in
him with you :rnd thus in utter the Govcrnment (iuest House
dcliberatcly and dcputation of responsible
insu bordination,
absented yourself ald got Iocked protocol staff. The charged
neu,ly constructed building oflicer made an endorsement
without any authority and accordingly. The ofhcia-l
retained the attender with you, memorandum dated 24.08.20l5
rvhich act ol yours if proved or issued by PW4 (Ex.D7) similarly
deputation of
established u'ould amount to directed
The
grave misconduct, unbccoming of responsiblc staff.
a judicial officer r,r'ithin thc com munication docs not rcquire
meaning of Rule 3 of A.P Civil the chargcd ofltccr to personally
accornpar-ry the Honble Judge
Services (Conduct) Rules 1964.
throughout the visit and that
depu t ing responsible sl.a[[ rvas
sufflrcient.
The
trnquiry
Officer
concludcd thal, despile prior
intimation, thc charged ofhcer
failed to remain available to
receivc and assist the Principal
District Judge during ofhcial
inspection. Her absence and
lailure to extend necessaiy
assistance reflectcd disrcgard of
administrativc instructions and
amountcd lo insubordination.
Such conduct rvas held to be
r,Lnbecoming of a Government
servant and lalling within
"misconduct" under Rule 3 o[
the Telalgana State Civil
Sen,iccs (Conduct) Rulcs, 1964.
Articles of Charge No. 3
proved.
That you Ms. G.
Govinda
Lakshmi, q.hilc working as Junior
Civil Judge, Utnoor, Adilabad
district, despite advice from Sri.G.
Gopala Krishna Murthy, the then
Principal District Judge, Adilabad
and also the then Hon'ble
Thc learned District Judge
(PW4) has dcposed in his
evidence that the charged oflicer
is highly adamzrnt in attitucle
and acts as monopoly and there
were complainl-s against her
from the members of the Bar
Ad ministrative Judges ol Adilabad
ssociatior-r, Utnoor, for which
District to mcnd vour u,ays from he advised I er scveral times to
adamant attitudc and monopoly changc he. attitude and that
behavior, you c cl not hccd to thc when he rrought the sard
advice of thc strperiors and conduct arr behaviour of the
continued to be in the same charged olf r :r to ttre notice of
fashion, u.hich a juclicial Olficer the Hon'ble I ortftrlio Juclges r.iz.,
ought not to have donc, s.hich act Hon ble Sri Justice p.Naveen
of yours if pr-ovcd or cstablished Rao arrd I >n'ble
Justice
would amount to gra\.c A.Rajasekh: r l?cddy. Sri
Wherr their
misconduct and unbccoming o[ a Lordships \.sitcd
judicial officer uirhin tlrc mearrirrg and Adilab I [. tl.reirBcltampally
Lordships
of Rulc 3 ol A.P. Civil Sen,ices advised her o mend her ways,
(Conduct) Rulcs 1964.
but of nc av;dl. pW4 has
positively <ltr ied the suggestion
that no su( I tdvice was given bv
the Hon't,l : Administrativc
Judgcs to her
The Ilnquiry Officer
observed ttrz 1 I)W4, being a unit
Head, is retltr ,-r:d to appraise the
Hon'ble Jud i s u hen thev visit
the District r rri in that context,
the Hon'blt: . udges could have
adviscd the :harged ofhcer to
mend her rr e ,ls, and therefore.
relying upor lhe testimony of
PW4 and ris report-Ex. p6,
concluded r.r,ithout any
hesil ation t rrt
Disciplinarl
Authority hal; ;roved this charge
and thc act ,l (.harged ofllccr in
exhibiting caLl rus and aclamant
attitude anc behaviour while
discharging 1r, r duties,'rvithout
paying heed r thc advice of the
superiors
and
shou,ing
disrespect anc disregarcl to the
Principal Dis; i<:t .Iudge, would
certainly zu-l )unt to gross
misconduct ar d unbecoming of
a Judicial () ficer within the
meaning of : 3 of Telang:rna
State Civil rvices (Conduct)
Rules, 1961 and helrl the
charge r.r-a s
duly and
satisfactorily rroved b1. the
Sir
Disciplinary A,r trority
I
That you Ms. G.
Govinda
Lakshmi, whilc workrng as Junior
Civil Judge, Utnoor, Adilabad
drstrict. as against the various
circular instructions of the High
Court issued from time to tlme to
all the Judicierl Offtcers in the
State to maintain the timings o[
thc Bench strictly from 1O:30 AM
to O2:OO PM and from 02:30 PM
to 05:00 PM you uscd to go to the
ofhcc of Sub-Treasury for getting
your bills passed zrnd then to the
Bank to receive cash thereof
during Court working hours,
thus, in utter disobedience to the
High Court s circular instructions
actcd in such a manner
amounting to dcrcliction of duties,
u'hich a judicia-l officer ought not
to have done, u'hich act of yours if
proved or established rvould
amount to gra\/e misconduct,
iunbecoming of a judicial officer
within thc mealing of Rule 3 of
A.P. Civit Scr-vices (Conduct) Rulcs
t964.
PW 1 to PW3, did not whisper
arything about the charged
officer leaving the Court during
Court working hours and
visiting the office of
Sub-
treasury or Bank.
The refore.
the
Disciplinary Authority without
any hesitation, held that this
charge is not protcd by cogcnt
and convincing evidence. lt is
only eLn information of PW4, the
learned Principal District Judge,
Adilabad, s'hich
is not
substantiated by any evidence of
the staff members working
under thc charged officer or any
of thc advocatcs, thc said charge
has framcd aga.inst the charged
olficer. On the othcr hand. PW4
admits in his cross-examination
that no written complaints r.,"'ere
given by the members of the Bar
against the charged officer.
Thcreforc, it can bc safely
any
concluded without
hesitation that the Hon'ble
Disciplinary Authority failed to
establish thc Charge No.5
against the charged ofhcer by
cogent and convincing evidence
and hcld the charge was not
proved by thc Disciplinary
Authority
That yoll Ms. G. Govinda PW 1 to PW3, did not whisper
Lakshmi, u'hilc s'orking as .Junior anything abont the charged
Civil .Judgc, Utnoor, Adilabad officer not signing the monthly
district, had been rn the habit of pay bills of staff u till and unless
not signing the monthly PaY bills her sa1ary is credited. On the
o[ stalt unless and until your other hand, the photocopy of
salary amount is credited into Trcasury book in A.P.T-C Form
your account and therebY the No.7O (Revised) (Ex.D37) shou,s
staff membcrs, who r,verc working that the salar-v bills of the staff
undcr your control uscd to rcceire members of thc Presiding Officer
their monthly salaries onlY after (charged officer) for the month of
Sth of every month and thus October, 2015, has been sent to
caused unnecessary harassment the treasury on 03.11.2015
and mental agony to your ofhce itself. This itself supports and
subordinates, and acted in a most stren ens the defence version
heinous manner u,hich a juclicial o[ the char3'ri officer that she
officcr ought not to have donc, has bccn s i ning the monthly
which act of yours, if provccl or pay bills o1 -he staff members
establishe(l u,oulcl anount to simultancous 1, zrlong with her
grave
misconcluct and bills. Thus. he enquin, officer
unbecomirrg of a ludicial officer hclcl that he
Disc:iplinary
unthin thc mcaning ol Rtrle 3 o[ Authority hi: lailed to establish
A.P. Civil Services (Conduct) Charge Nrt.6 b1 cogent ar-rd
Rules, 19(r4.
convincing r r rlence. Thus, the
charge not 1r tved.
ChargeMemo II -ROC No.94al2OL6-Vigilance Cell, dt.2 t.O4.2OLA
That you Ms. G.Govinda Lakshmi, On a carir tl scrutiny and
Junior Civil Jr"rdge, [V Addirional appreciation ri' the evidence of
Junior cir,il Judge, Warangal, PWs I to 4 r'r upled with Exa.Pl
while r,r..orking as Junror Civil to Plg, i can be safely
judge, Utnoor. Adilabad district. concluded, without
any
on expin, o[ earncd lcavc a1;plicd hcsitation, t tat the charged
for w.e.f 06 O4-'2O1(; to 30-0-04 oflicer ha ; r,r.rllfully and
2016, prelixing anrl sufh-ring of deliberatcly
exhibited
public holidavs on 05 O4-2O16, irresponsible attitude and
01-05-2016 neither reporrcd to conduct by I iling to apply for
dut.y on O2-05 20 l6 nor sen[ extension c I leave rvell in
application extcnrling the cirrned advance ,r
informing the
lear,e ar-td llso did not infor m the Principal Drs, ir:t.ludge so as to
officcr \\,lto u,as inchzrrgc of _r,our cr-rablc him r; make incharge
court during vour lear.e pcriod arrangcmcntri u'hich would
that you are not .rttendini< the anlount to clt -eliction of duties'
court from 02 05-2016 u'hich act u,l.rich is no: r:xpected from a
of yours resulted into catrsing' Juclicial Office -and the said act
hindrar.rcc lo the ludicial u ork b1, would anto t)t
to "grave
not facilrtirring the pr incipal misconduct rL: <1 unbecoming of
District .Iudgc to makc immcrliatc a .Judicial ( ) ficcr " within t] e
alternatc irr-chargc :)rrangcmcnts mcaning oi thc Rule 3 of
and
t hcrr:bv
exhil;itcd Tclangana i; te Civil Scrvices
irresponsible elttitLlde and (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
resorted to dereliction ol drrtics, Therefore, I eld that the
'vvhich is not expccted trorn a Disciplinary Au r hority has
judicial officer, rr.hir:h act of r,ours success[ull,v p'oved the Article
if ploved ,'r estirblisherl irorrld: of Charge Nr. b.y cogelt and
amount t,r gra\c rniscorrtlucl. convincing evidence. as
unbccomirrg ol a judiciaJ officcr discusscd stLl r r.
u,ithin the meaning of Rule 3 of
A.P Civil Scrvices (Conduct) Rules
:
i
]
j
While so, in replv to the ofhcial The evidence of PWs 1to 4
memoranclu rn gir.en by the High I coupled with E \s.pl to pl9 and
Court, d ated I 1-07-2016 issu erl Ex.D4 u,orL. I
conclusivel
I
in ROC. No. 948/2016-r'igilance
Ccll, calling for your cxplanalion
on the avcrments mentioned in
the report, dated 02 05-2016 of
establish the said charge and
the chargcd officer admittcd
about herself making the said
allegations, as can be seen from
Principal District Jlldge, Adilabad, her explanation-Ex. D4. No
you in thc explanation clated 23- further proof is required in this
07 2016, without confining to lhe regard. She failed to establish
subject mattcr, \'enLure(l to huri the said aJlegations by adducing
certain bald and baseless cogent and convincing evidence
allegations against Smt. G. Udaya exccpt hcr self-serving testimony
DWl. Thcrcfore, the
Gorvri, thc then Principal District as
Judge, Adilabad, Smt. Sunitha Disciplinary Authority has
Kunchala, the thcn I Additional successfully proved the Article
District Juclge, Adilabad and the of
Charge No.2 also.
Hon'ble Sri.Justice T.Sunil Consequently, I hnd the charged
the
then ofhcer guilty of "misconduct and
Chowdary,
Administrative Judgc of Adilabad gravc insubordination and
district, as if thcy at thc instance unbecoming of a .ludicial
and influcnce oI His Lordship, Officer" within the meaning of
created host ile al mosphere in the Rule 3 r-rf T.S.Civil Serviccs
discharging,vour ofhcial dutics (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
and thus, rvitl.r a dishonest
intention to cover-up your
mistakes and lo gain undescning
sympathy, exhibitcd an act of
insubordination manner. rvhich is
not expected from a judicial
officer, u,hich act of yours if
proved or established u,ould
amount to grave misconduct,
unbecoming of a judicial offtcer
within thc meaning of Ru lc 3 of
A.P Civil Scrvices (Conduct) Rules
1964.
Whilc so, you a-rc in the habit
of rcgularly Lcaving the
Having regard to the evidence of
PWs I to 4 coupled u,rth Exs. Pl
to P19, it can bc safely
prior
hcadquarters rvit hou t
sanction of lealc or \\'ithout concludcd, q'ithout aJIy
making alternate arrangernents, hesitation, that thc I{on'ble
and on 24-03-20l6 1'ou hate sent Disciplinary Authority has
a leave application under D:s. No.
28512016, through fax at about
1:08 p.m., to I Adclitional District
Judgc, Adilabad for sanctior-r of 3
days casual leave on 24-032016,26-03 2O 16 and 2A-03-2016
with permission to avail public
holidays on 25-O3-2016 and 27O3-2O16 to attend the classes
successfully proved this Article
of Charge also that the charged
ofhccr lcft thc headquartcrs
without prior sanction of leavc
and even after rejection of her
leave by PW2 causing
inconvenience and hardship to
the Prl.District Judge, Adilabad
PW1 , in makin
al ternate
l0
conducted bl ICADR and NALSAR arrangemerr s and the
said
University of Law at Hyderabad conduct is rot expectcd from
a
and left the station u,ithout prior Judicial ( )l Lcer which would
sanction of leavc applicd for and certainly L 11ount to "gross
thereby acted in a most callous misconducr,
insubordination
manner in not appll,ing leaye u,ell and unbcr: ning of a
Judicial
in advance and get the same Officer" u ir I ir-r the mear-ring
of
sanctioned before leavir.rg the the Rule ll r ' T.S.C.S. (Conduct)
headquarlers, as a result of rvhich Rules, I9r;,1 and therefore,
the
you causcd inconr,eniencc to the Disciplina;r
Authority has
District Judiciary in making successfulh proved thc Article
a.lternate in-charge arrangements, of Chzrrge \'r 3 also.
which is not expected from a
judicial officer, u,hich act of vours
if proled or esrablished r,r oultl
amounI to grave misconduct,
unbecoming of a judicial otficer
within thc meanrng of Rule 3 of
A.P Civil Services (Conduct) Rulcs
Charge Memo III-ROC.No.22 66 l 2Ot6_Vigi\rnceCelt, dt 27.O4.2OLT
That you Ms. C;.(i ovrnda
Evidenth L)-re charge sheets
Lakshmi, IV Additional Junior and final rel )rts. as shown
in
Civil .Iudge,
Warangal, rvhile Annexures-l i II do not
working as such, in pursuance of initia.ls or ( r dorscmcnts bear
made
the dircctrons of the princr pal by thc cha lod officcr as
District Judge, Warangai, under "che<:k and r t up." Therefore,toI
letter Dis.No. 6286, darect 08-08_ have no hr':I l artion to come
to
2016, u,hen the Head of thc thc
conclr r ion
that
vigilanct: Cell-cum 1 Additional Disciplirran Authority the
has
Disrrict judge, Warangal, visitcci successlu lll
proved
thc court of IV Addition:rl Junior Articles of )harges I the
& 2
civil Judge, Waranga_I, it camc to having rcgarrl to tl-re cvidcnce
be unearthed that as or-r Og_0g_ PWs I to 4 rrt r Exs. pl to p5 of
2016, yolr kept pencling 35
charge-sheets filed b1' the police
concerncd during the period from
l3-08-20 l4
to 29-07 -2016
(Annexu r(.- I)
pcrtaining to
.Juvenilc Courl, Warangal, u.ithout
making cndorsemcnt on thosc
charge-sheets for procced ing
further. rhus. you did
nut
dischargc your legi timate duties,
and acted in a most negligent and
callous manner. resulLing in
chaotic srtuation, which act of
yours if proved or established
would amount of gravc
misconduct, unbccoming oI a
judicial officer within the meaning
of Rule 3 of A.P. Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules 1964.
While so, iL also camc to be
unearthed that as on 08 08-20 I 6.
you also kept pending 29 llnal
rcports (Annexurc- ) filed by
conccrned police without rnaking
any endorsement as check and
put up and did not proceed
further in those final reports,
thus, you did not discharge -vour
legitimate duties and acted in a
most negligent and
manner, resulting
callous
chaotic
situation, which is not expcctcd of
a judicial ofhcer, rvhich ac:t o[
yours if proved or cstablishcd
would
amount to
grel\'e
misconduct, unbecoming oI a
Judicial officer u'ithin the
meaning of Rule 3 of A.P Civil
S 9lyt99!
Lcoq4lclllulg{o +
White so, though, the Prtnt: l l)al
District Judge, Warangal [ar.ing
inspected your court on 06 O82016 and found cert:un dockcts
u,ere kept blank u'ithout there
being your initial ar-rd madc an
endorsement to thzit e[fect, but
still you handled those case
hles(Annexure Ill) and rnitialcd on
those dockets cvcn aftcr thc
observation and endorscmctrt of
the Principal District J r-rclge,
Warangal, thus, -\'olt dicl not
discharge your legitimate duties
and acted in a most negligen t and
callous manner, resulting ch ao tic
situation, which is not cxpcctcd of
a Judicial ofhcer, lvhich act of
yours if proved or establishcd
q,ould amount to
Srarve
misconduct, unbecoming oI a
judicial olficer within the me:rning
of Rule 3 of A.P. Civil Serr ices
l
Conduct Rules 1964.
While So, it also came to be
On .l ::rrelu I scrutiny of
the evident c rf PWs 1 to 4 and
Exs.Pl to P i ar-rcl coupled with
unearthed that as on 08-08-2016,
you also did not sign and make
aIIy endorscment on the dockets
of 34 calendar cases (AnnexlrreIV) relaring to undcr-trial
prisoners, lor proceeding fu rther,
thus you <lid not discharge 1.our
legitimate duties and acted in a
most negligent and callous
manner. resulting chaotic
situation tvhich is not expectcd of
a Judrcial ofhcer, which act of
yours if proved or established
thc admissi,) Ls of the charged
ofhccr, it r:an be safell'
concluded, without any
hesitation, r rat the Hon'ble
Disciplin;u-r' Au thoriry has
successfull_r' c -oved the Article of
Charge No.I r lso b_v cogent and
convincing e.,<ienL:e and I have
no hesitatio I to come to thc
conclusion t rat thc charged
officer is gLr ll ol "misconduct
would amount to gra\re and unlr, r rmirrg ,r[ a
misconduct and unbecoming of a Governmenr ierr,:u-rt bcing a
judiciaJ offir.er wirhin rhe meaning Judicial Offrr e as <lehned under
of Rule 3 of A.P. Civil Senic^es Rule 3 of il t Tcl:Lngan:L State
(Conductl Rules 1964.
Civil Scn,icc; (Cor-rduct) Rules,
1964, and tlr ls thc alticlcs of
fle1gg is pror ed
While So. rt also camc to be Thc docu n r ntar.J cr.idence
uneaflhccl lhar as on 08-08 20 16. adduced by the Disciplinaqz
you also did not sign and makc Authority u I r<:h itrc docket
any endorscment on the dockcts proceedings r :rrkcd as Er.P7
of 34 calendar cases (Annexure- revea.l that th ( , d0 not bear the
]
IV)
relatirlg to under-trial
prisoners, lor proceeding further,
thus you did not discharge your
legitimatc dutics and acted in a
)
r: charged officer
successfully proved bv the
callous Disciplina4.'l uthority by the
chaotic evidence o[ P,r s I to 4, Iixs.Pl
situation, rvhich is not expected of to P8, c,) r rlecl u,ith the
a Judicial ofhcer, u,hich act of admissions rn r lr: lrv the clrzrrged
yours if proved or establishcd officer herscll in her r,,'ritten
would amount to grave statement of (lc e't-r <:,'
misconduct and unbccoming of a
judicial offrcc'r u ithin thc mear]ing
of Rulc 3,,f A.P. Civil Scrvices
Conductl Rcrles 1964
Whilc so, it r--amc to bc uncarthcd 'lhc evidence I P\! s. I to 4 alld
that as on 08-08-2016, you kept trxs.Pl to P8 rlso conclu sively
pending about 30 charge-sheets establishes abc tt finding of the
that \r,ere f-rled by concerned charge sheets rs nrentioned in
police (Anncxr-rre-V), on the dais of Annexure-V lr ir on the dais
of
your courl, u.ithou t making any the chargerl i1
offi t.cr tvjthout
endorsement on those charge- making any ndorsemen t on
shects for
ceedin
further, those char s r rcts directin the
most negligcnt and
manner. resulting
signature of
on o2_o8.201t So, this charge
also can be I :ld to havc been
thus, you did not discharge your Chief Ministerial Officer l"o
legitimate duties and acted in a scrutinizc them and place before
callous hcr, Thus, thc Hon'ble
chaotic Disciplinary Authority has
situation, which is not expected o[ success[ully proved the said
a Judicial ofhcer, u,hich act of chargc bv cogent ald convincing
yours if prorted or established evidence as drscusscd supra and
would amou nt to gra! e the cl.rarge d officer, therelore,
misconduct, unbecoming of a c:rn be held to be guilty of
judicial officer within thc mcaling ' miscondn ct ' as she failed to
of Rule 3 of A. P. Civil Sen'ices dischargc her legitimate duties
and acted in a most negligent
(Conduct) Rules 1964.
und callous ma-nner resulung rn
chaotic situation which is not
expected by her as a Judicial
Ofhcer, thus the Articles of
charge is Held proved.
most ncghgcnt and
manner, resulting
Thc evidencc of PWs 3 & 4
coupled with the evidence of
not take any furthcr slcps il't PWs. 1 &, 2 u,hich is consistent,
convincing and
taking cognizance of lhe offence in cogent,
and which do not
filed
trlrst"\'orthy
sheets
of
the
charge
respect
[rom
any materia]
police
lo
relatirrg
suffer
by the concerned
categorically
12 cases of Juvenile court and 25 inflrmities,
cases of IV Additional .ludicial establishes that the charged
Magistrate of First class, officcr, has dclibcrately failed to
Warangal (Annexurc-VI), though takc cognizance o[ the charge
they were scrutinized, thus, )'ou sheel s :is menlioned in
did not discharge lour legitimatr' Annerure-VI immediately after
duties and acted in a most their scrlrtiny by the Chief
negligent and callous manner, Ministerial Oflrcer as revealed
Which so, it carnc to bc uncarthcd
that as on 08-08-2016, you did
resulting chaotic situation, u'hicl't
is not cxpectcd of a .ludicial
officer, which act of yours il
proved or cstablished u'ould
arnount to grave misconduct :urd
unbecoming of a judicral officcr
within l-he meaning of Rule 3 o[
A.P. Civil Services (Conduct)
Rules, 1964.
Which so, on the charge-sheet
hled by PS Ghanpur (W) Warangal
city in Crime No.73l2O I6
20l6) cognizar tcc
(CC.No.3 l3/
order was scribed bY Chief
Ministerial ofhcer of vour court on
from her ou n explanation made
in hcr ',r'ritten statemcnt of
dcfencc as well as in her
cr.idcncc as DWI, and thus the
Enclr-riry Officer stated to have no
hcsitation to hold that the
Disr:iplinarl Authority
has
successfully proved this Charge
No.6 as rvell, by the said cogent
ald convincin cvidencc
The Enquiry Officer held that
there is no sufhcient evidence to
cstablish that thc charged officer
has simph' actcd upon the
endorsement made by the Chief
Ministeri.rl Offrcer. She has
l4
27 -06-2016, instead of
you,
suggcsling you ro take cognizancc
for ccrtatrr offcnccs and against
certair-r accuscd, thus, you did not
discha ge your legitimate duties
and acted in a most negligent and
callones man ner, resulting chaotic
situation, u.hich is not expected of
considered I e charge sheet and
other mate -l rl documet'rts hled
along with tL : charge shcct- She
has taken :ognizancc rightly.
Hence, th: charged officer
cannot be (:ld guilt], of the
''miscondu,:t a s rrlleged in this
charge. Acc r dingly, the Charge
a Judicial oflicer, u,hich act ol No.7 is r ot satisfactorily
yours if provcd or establishcd proved b1' tht Disciplinary
would amou nt to grave Authoritv.
miscondlrct eurd unbecoming of a
judicial uflicer u,ilhin rhe mearing
of Rulc 3 of A.P. Civil Services
Conducr Rules, 1964
Which so, rt came to be unezuthed Having regil r to the evirlence of
that as on 08-08-20i6, in 39 PWs I to ,1 rnd Exs.l) I to P8
calend a r cnses (Annexure-Vll) you coupled u irl
the adnrissions
did not ,,vrite docket orders, but made by ti.r,: t:h;rr-ged ofll<:er in
when comparcd to court diarl, her expleurir, lon and in the
those cases \vcre said to have written starr r Lr:nt of defcnce as
becn adjourned to other dates well as in trt r r:r,irlcr-rce as DW 1,
with ordcr "accused called absent, held that the Disciplina4'
call on ' ald thereby maintained Authority I as succcssfully
incomplete dockets orders, thus proved thLs charge also, by
_vou did not discharge your cogent ernd:,r rlint:ing evrdence.
legitimatc dutics and acted in a
most ncgligcnt and
manncr. rcsulting
callous
chaotic
situatioll, tvhich is not expected of
a Judici.rl officer, which act of
yours if prot,cd or established
would
amou nt
to
grave
misconducL and unbecoming o[ a
judicial officcr rrithin lhe mcaning
of Rule 3 of A.P. Civil Services
(Conduct) Rulcs. 1964.
Charge Memo fV-ROC No. 76/2OL9-Vigilance Cell, dt.( t .O4.2OL1
Th at you Ms. G.Govinda La_l<shmi,
Junior Civil Judge, Kollapur,
Mahabul;nagar District, u.hile
Upon
rpreciation of
evidence itrl trced b1- the
charged offict I as DW I as rvell
u.orking as IV Additional Junior as her rvrit,, n sLatemen t of
Civil Juclgc, Warangal, during the
relevant pcriod, on 06-12-2olg
having rcceived and accepted thc
case property ie., an amount of
Rs. 3,59,19.250/- that u,as seized
in Crimc l.lo.2 53 2018 ol Kazi et
L)
dcfence and .r 'ittcrr argume nts,
thc enquiry ,t:T ccr hcld that due
to ttre failur: of the charged
offrcer to act I r )mptly in passing
necessary Juc i 'iaJ ()rders on the
list of ro e r\ set zgq
PW2.
ljl
J
PS along rvith Form No. 60, 1'ou Ex.P3 in connection with the
in
offenccs
did not take any steps to get thc clcctoral
said casc property deposited in Cr.No.252/2018, a huge amount
the form of FDR ald instcad giten oi Rs.3,59,19,250/- was forced
the same to the Station HoLlse to be kcpt rvith PW2 under the
Officer, Kazipet PS, on l0-12 risk of m isappropriation of the
2018 for safe custody ol the said Sit ITIC.
Tl.re r:harged officer not
amount, thus contrary lo I he
provision of law. where there is a only passed orders granting safe
duty cast upon the presidifrg custod)' of thc vaiuablc cash
propcrt), to PW2 contrary to thc
. off-rccr for safe custody of the casc
properties and despite receirtng Criminal Rr"rles of Practice ald
requisiLion from the Kazipet PS circular instructions of the
and Officia-l Memoranda dated 1 2- Hon'ble High Court issued from
12-2018 &, 28-12-2ola lrom thc time to timc but also lailed to
.Iudge, obey the direc[ions of the
Principal District
Judge,
Warangal, still you did not comply Principal District
with the directions of the Principal Warangal, rvho is thc controlling
District Judge, Warangal, ir-r officcr, bcing thc District Unit
getting the case pro pe rtv Head and thtrs. she acled in a
deposited in the form of FDR and most drsobedient manner
acted in a most disobedicnt amounling lo clereliction of
manner amounting to derelictio n dulies, gross irtsubordination
committed grave
of duties and failed to discharge and
your legitimate duties, whrch act misconduct and unbccoming of
of yours if proved or establishcd a .iudicial Ofhccr within the
would arnount to gr:rve meaning of Rule 3 of the
misconduct, unbecoming of a Telangarra Slate Ciril Sen ices
judicial officer within lhe m,,rnittg (Conduct) Rr"rles. 1964. Thus,
of Rule 3 o[ Telangana Cilil held the charge provedServices (Conduct) Rules.
5.
Basing on the Enquiry Reports submitted b1, the Enquiry
Officer in all four Charge Memos, the 2nd respondent issued show-
cause notices uide Proceeditlgs
1n
ROC. Nos.l815/20 15,
948/2016, 2266 12016 and 7612019, dt.1B.06.2O2O, to the
petitioner / delinquent officer
calling for submission of
objections/comments, to which the she submitted objections,
dt.25.O6.2O20, to all the four show-cause notices, and the 2"d
l6
respondent, not sati sfied g,ith
the explan,r ions offered bt,
tlre
petitioner/delinquent
officer,
issrt:d
proceedin6Js
ROC.Nos. 1B 1Sl20 1S,
948/2016, 2266/,.),)16 and
dt.13.OZ.2O2t, senr recommendations
to 1te
Government for imposing
,,
Retirement,' agatnst the
and pursuant to u,hich,
petitioner from ser\rrc-- u,ith
2/3d pension,
the 2.d respondent ir,r ued
G.O.Ms.No.40
"imposing a rnajor punishment
service" on rhe petitioner
Departm: rr,
dt.13.o7 .2021.
of compulsr,r I retirement frorn
as Junior Civil Jurt; e
Rule 9 of Telangana Civil
under Clause g
Sen ices (Classific: tron,
Control and
Assaiting the said. pro<:,rcdings
and 2nd respond.ents, the
the instant writ petition.
representing thc counsel
ftled
Srr. 4.Surender Rao
on record, Sri Madira.Jrr
the petitioner/ cielinquent officer,
Srir_rivas Rao, for
Smt Shalir i learned Govt.
Pleader Seryices-ll appearing
for respondent
and Sri Kos,turi pavan
ol the I,t
petitioner/d.etinqt ent offt.cer
5'l Heard thc learned Senior
counsel
respondent No.2,
1., rcspondenl-
a major pe,r r Llt1, of Compulsorv
Lan, (LA, LA&J-Home-Courts.A2)
Appeal) Rulcs, 199 1.
Z6/20t<),
I o. 1-Governmenl
l(umar, learned Stanrl ng
Counsel for
l7
The brief submissions of the petitioner are as follows:
6.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner contended that, in
respect of all the chargc memos, though the petitioncr had
submitted detailed explanations categorically shou'ing that the
charges framed neither by themselves show the misconduct on the
part of the petitioner / delinquent officer nor the supporting the
incriminating material produced by the respondents would
constitute a misconduct. Further, it is contended that the 2"d
respondent without proper appreciation of the material placed by
the petitioner to controvert the charges, nonetheless subjected the
petitioner to Departmental Enquiry and issucd proceedings,
dt.31.08.2017.
7.
Further, in the course of the enquiry, under Charge Memo I,
PWs. 1 to 5 r.r.ere examined ald Exs.Pl to P25 u'ere marked on
behalf of the department, while the petitioner examined herself as
DW1 and marked Exs.D1 to D46; under Charge Mcmo II, PWs.1 to
4 were examined and trxs.Pl to P19 u'ere marked, and the
petitioner as DW1 and marked Bxs.D1 to D31; under Charge
Memo III, PWs. 1 to 4 were examined and Exs.Pl to P8 were
marked, and the petitioner as DWl marked Exs.D1 to D239; and
under Charge Memo IV, PWs.1 an:.d 2 wete examined and Exs.Pl
to P10 were marked, '*,hile the petitioner as I) W1 and marked
Exs.D1 to D12
B.
It is contended by, the learned Senior C I rnsel that upon
completion of the enquiry, the petitioner vvas ssued notice to
submit her r,r.r-itten submissions and thereaft,)., the petitioner
submitted written submissions on 29.06.2019, ex rlaining in detail
that none of the charges framed against her sto,,d proved, either
on the basis of the oral or on documentarv evirl .nce adduced bv
the department.
.
With regard to Charqe Memo- L uide RAl I No.1815/2015-
Vigilance Cell, dt.O6.O6.2OL7, Iearned Senior co rnsel contended
that during enquin, PW1 to PW5 were examinr: I and Exs.pl to
P25 rvere markecl for the department and r r behalf of the
petitioner/ deiinquu-r-rt officer, she herseif exami:-r:d as DWl and
got marked Exs.D1 to D46. The Enquiry Offic,: without proper
appreciation of material and rvithout consider ng the written
submissions/ arguments of the petitioner, errol-t I rusly came to a
conclusion that charge Nos.1 to 4 were held pr tved despite no
evidence and charge Nos.S & 6 r,rrere held not pro.,,, ,d.
to
10. l.earned Senior Counsel further contended that there was no
complaint whatsoever against the petitioner from any of her
superior oflicers as alteged b1' the department and that Bx'P3, the
repor[, d,t.26.Og.2O15 ol the Chief Judicial Magistrate(PW5),
relating to the disposal of 14 calendar cases, u'as based on a
misinterpretation of the provisions of the code of criminal
Procedure. Sections 242(3\ and 254(1) Cr'PC' clearly mandate
that the Magistrate shall take evidence produced by the
prosecution, and cannot in no nray compel the prosecution to
examine all the witnesses before the Court' More so, the disposal
of the said cases \ ras part of the petitioner's judicial functions and
cannot made subject matter of disciplinary charges. It u,as further
contended that Charge Nos. 1 and 2 purely rclate to judicial
decision -making; Charge No.3
does not disclose anv act of
insubordination or not obeving the instructions of superior
officers; and Charge No. 4 is unsupporled b1' anl documentarl'
evidence regarding the allegcd instructions' Hence' no charge
couldhavebeenframedagainstthepetitionerunderthesaid
RoC,andthesaidchargesarebaselessandframedwithulterior
motive.
1. Thus, tht: said charge is violative of thr: lhe statutory
provisions under Cr.P.C.. and therefore, the sai I findings are
perverse and untcllable. Sigr-rifican t I5,, no complaint; *.ere recei'ed
from the Bar Association, the complainants, or the rccused in any
of the cases. ancl rro appeal or revision was preferr:d against any
of the judgments.
12. The learncd Senior Counsel contends with rr,1 ard to Charge
3 that the allegzrrio' .f mara fide intention is wholr . unsupported
by evidence. On 25.08.2015, the peritioner was on c fficial protocol
duty in connection *'ith the'isit of Hon'ble Justict-' I ri B. chandra
Kumar, former .-luclgc of the Hon,ble High Court, e s evidenced by
Exs.D6, D7, D3B, D39 and D4O. Further, ther,: rvas no prior
u.ritten or o.al intimalion to thc pe titioner regard L. Lg the visit of
the Principal Districr Juclge at -l:30 pM on the sr id day. pW.4
himself admitted that thcre *'as neither written o, lnmunication
nor documentarl cvidence to shorv that the peti ioner was in
charge of the ner'r-r' constructecl court bu ding or l. t
1.s of the said
Court buiiding. 'lhc evidcnce ol plV 1 and pW2 zu regards the
allegecl intimiition u as contradictir-rg rvith each othe. rnd
proved, and tlte said charge is basecl on conjectures i nd
thus, not
surmises.
2l
13. Further, in relation to Charge 4, it is contended that the said
charge is vague and bereft of particulars. No specific instances,
dates, or nature of the alieged adamant behaviour of the petitioner
were either pleaded or proved u,ith substantiating evidence. No
communication, of whatsoever, was ever issued to the petitioner
by the Principal District Judge or the Administrative Judges. On
the contrary, Ex.D35 shou S that the Administrative Judge
instructed for more disposals '"vithout compromising quality, and
Ex.DB is a letter of appreciation issued in recognition of her
performance. Thc alleged complaints of the Bar were neither
produced in the disciplinary enquiry nor marked. Thus, the
charge is legally untenable
14. In respect of Charge Memo-II uide RoC No.94al2Ol6Vigilance Cell, dt.26.O4.20la, learned counsel contended that
during enquiry PWl to PW4 u,ere examined and Exs.Pl to P19
were marked for the department and on behalf of the
petitioner/ delinquent ofhcer, she herself examined as DW1 and
got marked trxs.D 1 to D3 1. The Enquiry Ofhcer rvithout
considering the material on record and without considering the
written submissions/arguments of the petitioner, erroneously
came to a conclusion that charge Nos.1 to 3 were held proved.
15. Learned counsel further contended that rc allegations in
_.
the Charge Memo pertain on1-v to leave applicatrc ns submitted by
the petitioner ernd the explanation(Ex. D4) furnist.r rl in response to
Ex.D3, the Olficial Memorandum dt. 1 1.07.12 I 16, are wholly
unconnccted u,ith Judicial functions. Initiall., the principal
District Judge (PW1) sought clarification regar Jing the 1eave,
which rrvas subsequentl_v sanctioned by this Hor,rle Court under
Exs.DS and D6. Further, the suo motu report <1 )B.l2.2OlT (Ex.
P19) cannot bc treated as a complaint, and thourg h the petitioner
cannot impute motives behind the submission r,l such a l-eport,
but has got a reasonable apprehension about thr, validity of such
a report. Thercfore, the charges lramed under thi , ROC are false
and unsLrstain:rble.
16. in so far as Cl'rarge 1, it is contencled that th r cntire premise
of the charge stands destroyed by the proceedings of the Hon,ble
High court ROC No.2515/2016-B.Spl., dt.23.11.2017(Ex.D5),
whereby the Hor-r'ble High Court sanctioned exter.l: ion of leave by
granting Half Pay Leave lor 20 days from )i.05.2016 to
20.O5.2016, in continuation of Earned Leave fronr 06.04.20 16 to
30.O4.2016, r,r,ith permission to prefix pubtir: rolidays. and
expressly ratified the in-charge arrangements rr u,ell as the
a1
resumption of duty by the petitioncr on 21 .O5.2O I 6. Further
proceedings dt. 19.09.2017 (Ex.D30) only required submission of a
lormal leave application, therebv acknorvledging the absence leave
rvas regularised. The allegation of hindrance to judicial work is
disproved by the categorical admissions of PW.l, PW.2 and PW.4,
rvho admitted that alternate in charge arrangements lvere made
and that there u,as no disturbance to judicial functioning as to the
petitioner's absence. The finding under Charge No.1 is therefore
contrary to evidence and perverse
17. It is contendcd that the explanation dt.23.07.2O16 was
submitted strictly in response to the Olficial Memorandum issued
by the Hon'ble High Court pur suant to a suo-motu report
dt.02.05.2016. The petitioner was compelled to explain the factual
background under which she sought extension of leave and the
circumstances that led her to approach the Hon'ble Acting Chief
Justice, which ultimately resulted in her transfer to Warangal
District. The explanalion was bona fide and necessary for self
defence and cannot be construed as an act of insubordination.
Significantly, the Hon'ble High Court thereafter sanctioned the
entire period of leave by proceedings Ex.D5, thereby accepting the
explanation offered by the petitioner. PW4, who is the District
Judge at Warangal, admitted in cross-exami: r Ltio'r that she did
not refer to the High Court proceedings u,L r e submitting her
subsequent rcporr dt.OB.12.2OI7(Ex.pI9). l1 e linding under
Charge No.2 lacks valid evidence and is therelo e unsupported b1,
the record.
18. Insofar as Charge 3, it is contended by t re learned Senior
Counsel that the allegation of unauthor i ;ed absence is
unsustainable in vieu, of the proceedings of he Hon,ble High
Court ROC No.7421 /2017-B.Spl., dt.Ol.02:l )18 (Ex.D6), as
already stated the Honble High Court sanctionr d Half pay Leave
for the period from 24.O3.2O16 to 28 t) j.2O16, thereby
regularising the alleged absence and further r t e petitioner had
applied for Casual Leave in advance to atterri contact classes
conducted by ICADR pursuant to intimation rege rding the course
schedule. PW.2 categorically admitted that thcre was no
documentary evidence to establish unauthor i ;ed absence of
petitioner or 1ea'ing the headquarters rvithout ;:rmission.
Once
the competent authority has sanctioned tht: lear.e, the very
foundation of Charge 3 appears to be invalid anrt the said finding
is legally untenable.
19. As regards
Charqe Memo-III. ulde ROC.No.2266l2016'
VigilanceCell , dt.27.o4.2(J17 , Iearned counsel contended that
during enquiry PW1 to PW4 r,r'ere examined and trxs.Pl to PB were
ma-rked for the
d
epartrncnt and on behalf ol
the
peti tioner/ delirtquent officer, she hcrself examined as DW1 and
got malked Exs.Dl to D239. The Enquiry Officer without
considering the rrvritten submissions/ arguments of the petitioner,
came to a conclnsion that cirargc Nos. 1 to 6 & 8 were held proved
and charge Nos.7 was held not proved. Thus, contentions are
made in respect to charge Nos. 1 to 6 & 8 alonc.
20. lrarned Senior Counscl further contended that there was no
complaint either from members of the Bar Association or from
superior officers against the petitioner, ald the assertion made by
the Principal District Judge/P\,V4, in this regard, is not based on
any material. The petitioner joined as IV Additional Junior Civil
Judge (Juvenile Court), Warangal, on 23.05.2016; however, the
Court rvas on vacation until O6.06.2016. Thereafter, advocates
abstained from court q,ork from 06.06.2016 to 29.07.2016, and
that 30.07.2016 and 31 .07.2016 u'ere holidays lt was further
contended that Charges I to 6 and 8 "r'holly pertain to judicial
functions and, therefore, no disciplinarjr chargr: c:ould have been
framed and the said charge is misconceived.
2t.
Counsel for the petitioner further cor r:nded that the
petrtioner assumed charge of the IV Aclditional Jr rrior Ci,zil ,Judge,
Warangal, on 23.05.20 16, cluring r.r,hich periocl besides summer
vacation, arr advocate agitation u,ent on irorr Otj.06.2016 to
29.O7.2016.
22. Regardirrg Charge 1 , learned cour-:sel for petitioner
submitted that PW3's inspection on lO.OB.2O1rl ras nor properl_v
reflected the correct status of the 35 pendini; Charge Sheets,
marl<ed as Exs.D31 to D69, u,hic]r clearly sho,r that all charge
shccts rvere duly endorsed, and as regardr; (t rarge 2, it was
colltended that the 29 Final Reports were Lrnde r th<: scrutiny of
PW.2 (CMO), and all u.ere eventually processeci z nd endorsed as
evident from Exs.D70 to D9s. [t rvas fr,rrther contended that
findings ri,ere solelv based on the nrere de;t rsitions of the
nitnesses and u,ere not supporleci by any docunL, ntary evidence,
u,hich :enders the Enquirl, Cfficer,s finrlings r peculative and
unsirpported by any material to prove the charges.
23. With respect to Charge 3, it is contended by the petltroner
that the handling of case dockets as observed by the Principal
District Judge was due to high pend'encv of over 2300 cases
and a
newly posted Bench Clerk and therefore' the petitioner
and return
directed the Personal Assistant-cum-Typist to type
had
dockets for signature, which rvere administrative
measures to
maintain Court procedure and sanctity'
24. In respect of Charge Nos'4 and 6' it is contended that the
delay in endorsing Calendar Cases of Under Trial
Prisoners and
also not taking cognizance of 37 scrutinized cases
were due to
urgent Court duties, staff transfers, and high case
load' which
were however completed' as shorvn tn Exs'D1l3
to D146 ald D178
to D2I4. Similarly, as regards Charge 5' it is contended by the
petitioner that the 3O Charge Sheets found on the court
dais were
endorsed promptly on 09 08 2016 as evident
from the
exhibits/documents on behalf of the petitioner/delinquent
officer'
following temporary disruptions caused by a condolence
meeting
and stalf adjustments'
25. As regards Charge No'8, counsel for Petitioner contended
were
that the incomplete docket orders in 39 Calendar Cases
noted by entering penciled instructions, urhicl, tere later typed.
Further transfer of cases to other courts vas for efficient
management, and that the delay occurred was dr e to high volume
of cases and posting of temporar], staff. Hou e u,er, the trnquiry
Officer held the Charge 7 as 'dropped/not pr rved'. Thus, the
learned Senior Counsel contended that all actions bv the
petitioner u,ere consistent with procedural reqtLt:ements, and no
negligence or misconduct is attributable to the p: .itioner
26. With respect to Chq
e Mem.o-
Vigilance Cel1, dt.08.04.20 i9,
uide t?'-C No. 76/2019-
Iearned c I rnsel lor
the
petitioner/ delinquent officer contended that tht: s aid charge solely
reiates to discharge ofjudicial functions by the pe titioner ald does
not involve any allegation of
miscondt ct,
extraneous
consideration, or corruption. Consequently, no o Large could have
been framed under this ROC and the said c I irge by itself is
m isconceirred .
27 Thc learned Senior Counsel submitted tlr Lt the petitioner
being the Presiding Officer of IV Additior.ral .hr rior Civil Judge
(Juvenile Court), Warangal, has no jurisdictiotr to try election-
related oflences as the Hon'ble High Court c I Judicature at
Hyderabad, in ROC No.1848/tr1l20ia dt.25.O2.2015, had
designated the Special Mobile Court lor trial of PCR Act and
election-related offences at Warangal, s'hile another order, ROC
No.1O5/E1l2018, dt.01.05.20 18, estabiished a Special District
and Sessions Court at Hyderabad for criminal cases involving
elected MPs and MLAs. Further, the State Election Commission
had issued a Standard Operating Procedure (Order No.119SEC-
Fll2ol4l prescribing that seized election related cash should be
deposited in treasury or as directed b5r the court, and specific
gnevance redressal mechanisms were functioning. Thus, the
petitioner's role was limited to return the said amount to safe
custody by police authoritl,, tl1l proper instructions r'r'ere issued by
the superior authority or the learned District Judge.
28. It was further contended that the petitioner was on leave
from 07. 12.2Ol8 to 09.12.2018, and has been granted permission
to leave headquarters after office hours on 06.12.2078, and the VI
Additional Junior Civil Judge, Waranga-I, \'as kept in-charge
during her absence and on the evening of 06.12.2018, Lhe
Inspector of Police/PW2, produced the accused along with the FIR
and remand case diary, and Form-60 and the in charge judge
remanded the accused to judicial custody ar-rd aflixed his seal and
signaturc on all documents, but did not take st rps to deposit the
case property. Upon returning from Ieave .;r lO.12.201g, she
camc to kno*' of Form 60 containing the partr< t lars of the seized
cash and issued a Safe Custody endorsement cr the form, due to
the lack of jurisdictron to entertain election rel, L[ed offences. on
11.12.20 I8, the SHO sought appropriate orderr; from the learned
Principal Districr Judge, Warangal (pW. 1), regar 1 ng deposit of the
cash in tlre form of FDR, pursuant to which, o., 12.l2.2Olg,
the
Principal District .Judge issued ofrrciar instruct r.s directing the
petitioner to reccive the cash and keep it in the I: -m of FDR in
the
bank
29. Hou,cver, the SHO, pS Kazipet(pW.2), dep osited the cash
directl-1. i.to l-ris SHO bank account on 14.)2.2Olg *,ithout
informing cithcr the petitioner or the principal Lr; strict Judge.
He
also submittcd requisitton letters misrepresentir g the status
of
the cash, and the principal District Judge issuc< a Sho,,.r. Cause
Notice dt.03. 01.2Olg to the petitioner. In respon., ), the petitioner
issued Official Mcmorandum Dis.No.17, dt.Og.0, 2olg,
the concerned S.H.O., to produce the case propert.for
conversion
into FDR. On thc very same day i.e., on 08.01 1 Olg,
Manager of'sBI, I(azipet, issued an FDR in the rL,:rne
directing
the Chief
of IV Addl.
3l
JFCM, Warangal, which '"vas produced before the petitioner(Court)
on O9.0I.20 19. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted compliance
report to the Principat District Judge on 11.01.20 19, rvithin the
pcriod of time granted undcr the Shou' Cause Notice and
admittedly, the said amount is in safe custody.
30. Further, PW2, during cross-examination, admitted that the
cash remained in his custody from 06.12.2O1-B to 10.1'2.2018'
that he deposited the cash in his account without informing the
petitioner or the Principal District Judge, and that the bank was
advised issuance of an FDR in the Court's name. PW2 also
admitted that he did not object the petitioner's endorsement on
Form-60 directing for sa-fe custody. PW.1 deposed conlirming that
the petitioner was otl sanctioned leave, and the VI Addl. JFCM
was in-charge, and that the seized amount in connection with
election offences under the Representation of Peoples Act, fell
q,ithin the jurisdiction of Special Courts. PW. 1 further deposed as
to the receipt of the compliance report from the petitioner on
11.0 1.2019. Thus, it is contended that all the charges are vague
and not proved and the charge memo is liab1e to set aside.
3'2
. In that vie$, of the matter, learned senior C r r,tnsel therefore
submi*.tecl that none o[ the charges in any of th: charge memos
were proved bevond the prepondcrance of prob'lilities or even
remotely. Despite this, the respondents, t ithout proper
appreciatiotr ol the factuai aspects, without examining the
material on record, and rvithout discussing the :vidence of the
departmental u'itnesses or any corroborative evidt nce, and acting
under the influetlce of vested interests, issued tL r charge memos
soielv on the basis of unfounded zrccusations anrl the allegecl acts
cannot be termed as misconduct to initiate depar mental enquiry
anci the imposition of a major purrishn'rent of compulsory
retirernent, holding that the charges are proved t y the respective
enqrtiit'officers.
32. Thc learned Senior Counsel thus :ontends that
G.O.Ms.No 40, Las. (LA, LA & J-Home-Courr's I 2) Department'
datecl 13.O7 .2021 . issucd b1' the Governmr: t - of Telangana
irrrposing the rnajor punishrnent of compulsorl retirement from
sen,ice as Jutttior Civil Judge rtnder Clause (tl) rf Rule 9 of the
Telangana Crvil Serviccs (Clas.sification, Contr:l and Appeal)
Rules, 199 1 , ancl the consequential prc-,ceedin 1 ; issued by the
High Court fc.,r Lhe State of 'Ieiangana in R.OCI Iios. 1815/2O15i,
.)J
948/2016,2266 l2016 and 76l2Ol9-Yigilance CeIl, dated
13.07.2021, are illegal, arbitrary, and liabie to be set aside.
Contentions of the learned Government Pleader re D resentin p
the lst resp ondent / State:
33. The learned Government Pleader for Services-ll, I\4s. Shalini
appearing for Government-respondent No.1 would also contend in
the same lines as that of the learned Standing Counsel for High
Court and the counter affidavit is also filed in the same lines. The
sum and substancc of the contentions is that basing upon the
proper appreciation of factual matrix in the present case, the
enquir,v officers u,ho have dealt with the charges have appreciated
the entire evidence of the prosecution rvitnesses and also the
documents filed before the enquiry officers and along u'ith the
evidence of the petitioner/ delinquent officer and the exhibits filcd
by her, have unequivocally held that the charges are proved and
after follon'ing due process of law. It is contended that the 1"'at-rd
2^d respondents have imposed the major punishment of
compulsory re tirement basing on the enquiry reports and the
scope for interference by this Court in the writ petition is very
limited as the findings arrived at by the Enquiry Officers are just
and proper. The learned Government Pleader th, s contended that
the rvrit pctition rs devoid of mcrits and is liable tr be dismissed
Contentions of the learned Standing Courrr ,el for the 2"4
respondent /Hish Court:
34. l,earned Standing Counsel, Mr.Kowturi Parvan I(umar,
appearing lor the High Coult-respondent u r r-rld vehementi,v
contend that appreciation of evidence cannot t,r done in a writ
petition and this Court cannot re-appreciat: the evidence
advanced in the departmental enquiry and thr: Court has only
jurisdiction to veritv the perversity of the hndinl;; by. the enquiry
officer and onlv to the extent as to whether the prescribeci
procedure is follo'"r'ed or not. F urther, it is cont: rded that in the
departmental proceedings, the uritnesses exami I :d irt respect of
all four Charge Memos have categoricallv deposerl zLncl estzLblished
the guilt on the part o[ the petirioner/delinque rt officer. The
exhibits markc'd categoricalh provcd the content ( ns irr respect of
the charges framed against the petitioner/ delir-r; _rent ofhcer and
that the enquir,r, officers appointecl by the High I ourt have given
fair opportunit_r, ro the petitioner/ delinquent ofli :t:r to prove her
case, but though, the petitioner/ delinquent c I lcer, examined
herseif as DW 1 ar-rd filed voluminous exhibits in r r spect of all four
Charge Memos, has not controverted the evidence placed by the
department.
35. It is furlher contended by the learned Standing Counsel that
on proper scrutiny o[ the evidence of both sides, the enquiry
officers have categorically held the charges
AS
proved beyond
reasonable doubt, and basing upon the findings of the Bnquiry
Officer, the petitioner/ delinquent officer was issued show cause
notice to submit her explanation ald the explalation offered by
the petitioner/ delinqucnt officer was not satisfactory, as such, the
2"d respondent has recommended to impose major punishment
and basing on thc recommendation of the High Court, major
punishment of compulsory retirement was imposed on the
petitioner/delinquent officer uide G.O. Ms. No. 40, Law (LA, LA &
J-Home-Courts.A2) Department, dated 13.07.2021, by the l"t
respond ent.
36. F urther, the learned Standing Counsel for High Court
contended that the writ petitioner has not made out any
substantial grounds for interference of this Court and the.grave
misconduct on the part of the petitioner/ delinquent officer was
proved beyond reasonable doubt, and in such vielv of the matter,
the said punishment rvas imposed and interfere: :e of this Court
with the said punishment is unu,arranted and tlL, writ petition is
liable to be dismissed.
37. In support of the above submissions, the zrned Standing
r
Counsel has also placed reliance on the judgmenr ol R,Anburaj a.
State oJ Tamil Nadu, Registrar Genera|., High Cour-t;
Registrar(Vigilance) High Courtt.
38. We have given earnest consideration to the submissions of
the respective counsel appearing on either side .nd perused the
r
rraterial on record.
OBSERVATIONS OF THE COURT:
39. Before adverting to the lactual matrix of th : case ald also
whether the findings of the enquiry officr I are properly
appreciated or not, and also u,hether this Court ur cler 226 can re-
appreciate the evidence adduced belore the en,l tiry officers for
proper administration of ju stice and to arri,, : at a proper
conclusion, having extracted thc charges and flrr lings arrived at
by the Enquiry Officer hereinabove, u,e thought r fit to give the
gist of the evidence adduced in relation thereto.
I 2O19 Lan,Srrit (Macl) 2191=2020(2) M:rdLI 215
EVIDE NCE ADDUCED:
40. The oral evidence adduced and the exhibits marked on
behalf of the de partmcnt and the petitioner/ delinquent officer' are
since runt-ring in voluminous documents, a gist of the same
ts
mentioned hereunder:
DW1
trxs.PW1 to P25
Exs.D1 to D46
Charge Memo [l
PWs. 1 to 4
DW1
Bxs.PWl to P19
Exs.D1 to D3 1
Charge Memo lll
Pws.1 to 4
DWI
trxs.PWl to P8
trxs.D1 to D239
Charge Memo IV
PWs.1 & 2
Exs.PWl to P10
trxs.D1 to D12
Charge Memo I
PWs.l to 5
DWI
41. Now that the enquiry officers recorded findings holding the
charges proved, as noted hereinabove' agarnst the
petitioner / delinquent olficer and in vieli' of the contentions
of the
learned Senior Counsel that the evidence on record does
establish the misconcluct of the petitioner, the main
not
points which
are falling for our consideration are that:
1)
whether this Court can re-appreciate the evidence
adduced in the departmental enquiry under Article 226
of the Constitution of India and r'vhether the findings of
the enquiry officer are properly arrived; and
cl
Whether Lhe major punishment of compulsory
retirement imposed on the petitioner/ delinquent officer
ulde G.O.Ms.No.40, Lar,v (LA, LA&.- Home-Courts.A2)
Department, dt.13.O7 .2021 and the p oceedings issued
b1, the Hon'ble High Court in ROl.Nos.l8l5/2015,
94812016, 2266/2016 and 7612O1?-Vigilance Celt,
d1.13.O7 .2021, are sustainable in la\\.
42. Non' that rve have extracted rhe charges in cspect ol all four
charge memos and elucidated the evidence ac r uced in relation
thereto, the discussion is made according to the )harge Memos in
relation to Point No. f to see urhether the ct,;.rges are proved
beyond reasonable doubt and answer the said pr,r -r t.
ANALYSIS:
ChareeMemol-R OC No . 18 15/20 1s-Visilance Cel dt.06.o6.20t7
43. From a perusal of the material placed on t-(,( ord, the findings
recorded by the Enquirv Officer in respect of Cr arge Nos. 1 to 4
are vitiated by misapplication of statuton, prcr isions, improper
and selective appreciation of evidence, and nori c:onsideration of
material defence documents placed on record.
44. Charge Nos. 1 and 2: The Enquiry Officer I zrs proceeded on
an erroneous unclerstanding of Sections 24: (31 and 254(ll
Cr.P.C., wrongly imputing a dutt, upon the Ma11: strate to compel
the prosecution to examine rvitnesses, which i ; contrarv to the
settled legal position. The enquiry officer faileC t ; appreciate the
settled principle o[ criminal jurisprudence th € 1 the burden to
establish the guilt of the accused lies entirely upon the
prosecution. The Enquiry Officer, horvever, has proceeded on the
premise that it was incumbcnt upon the Magistrate to compel the
prosecution to examine all listed u,itnesses irrespective of the
prosecution's own stand. Such an interpretation effectively shifts
the prosecutorial burden onto the Court and undermines the
foundational principle that the prosecution must prove its case
beyond reasonable doubt. Thus, the conclusions drawn by the
enquiry officer ignored the admitted facts that the prosecution
itself gave up the uritnesses, that no prejudice was complained of
by any stakeholder, and that no appeal or revision was preferred
against the judgments.
45. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sh. Scttish Mehra us Delhi
Administration & Anr2 hcld as under
"But when the Judge is fairlv certain that there is no prospect of
the case ending in conliction the valuable time of the Court
should not be \rrastcd for holding a trial only for the purpose of
formally complcting the proccdurc to pronounce thc conclusion
on a futurc datc. Wc arc undcr hcarar pressure of work-load. If
the Sessions Judge is almost ccrtain that the trial u.ould only be
al exercise in futility or a sheer waste of time it is advisable to
truncate or ship the procecdings at the stage of Section 227 of
the Code itself'.
2 t996 (9) SCC 766
46. The approach adopted by the petitioner/ delir r, uent ofhcer is in
consistence nith the principle laid down by the Horr L k: Supreme Court
in Sh. Sattsh Mehra's case and the reasoning ot' L r,: Enquirl Ofhcer
in hoiding the said charges proved, is contrary to thi settled principles
of criminal larv and binding precedent. Thus, tl- t said article of
charges, in our considered opinion, are not provr_
47. Charqe No.3: The finding of mala fide intc -,ron is based on
conjectures, overlooking documentary evidence t stablishing that
the petitioner was on official protocol duty irri I hzrd no prior
intimation of the visit of the principal Disrr <:r .Judge. The
testimony of departmental r.l itnesses and the I )sence of proof
regarding possession ol keys or control over the 1, r :mises u,ere not
properly appreciated, rendering the finding unsrrs _:rinable. Thus,
in our considered opinion, the said charge is not p ovccl.
48. Charqe 4: The same is vague, unsupportc : b,r. particulars,
and rests solel] on unsubstantiatcd oral allegatio rs_ .lhe Enquiry
Officer failed to consider contemporaneous r fiicral records,
including letters of appreciation and instructior r issued by the
Hon'ble Administrative Judges, which compler .ly negate the
allegatron of improper conduct. The relianct) ln vague and
corroboration'
unproved allegations, r'vithout anY documentary
to a finding based on no evidence and is erronous Thus'
amounts
in our considered opinion, the said charge is not
provcd
49. Thus, on all Articles of Charges in Charge Memo I' uide
ROC No.1815/20l5-Vigilance Cell, dt06'06'2017'
the findings of the
enquiry officer suffer from procedural unfairness
and legal
that no
perversity, and the conclusions dranvn are such
or prudent person: properl-v instructed in law' could
reasonable
have arrived at' The impugned findings therefore
cannot be
sustained and are liable to be set aside in toto'
ChargeMe mo II -RO C No.948 120 16-Vieila nce
Cell, dt.26 .o4.2018
50. Ch arE e No. 1: The allegation of the petitioner disturbed
judicial work is unfounded PW 1, PW 2' ancl PW-4 consistently
testified that proper in-charge arrangements
were made and that
judicial functioning continued smootl-rly during the petitioner's
absence. The Enquiry Officer ignored this
unchallenged evidence
and instead relied on conjecture' rcaching a conclusion
reasonable person could accept Thus this
no
Charge is not proved'
51. Regarding Charge No 2, the expianation dt'23'07'20
submitted in good faith pursuant to the directions
16 was
of the Honble
High Court the leave was sanctioned' as a response
to a suo-motu
be ireated as insu,
:1":,." :;;""":
;'T":;": ",'))',u"ilJ,
il;T;#
t'
transferrin
Roc N o 2s t 5 / 20 f.
matter bv
charge thererore
-'-v'z'v '
,. -,:,-t::.^':"t]"""'
rhus, the said charse
q.'t
or
J""|]l;-;o
Once the Hon,ble
sanctioned and
No.251sl2016_8.
Spl., dt.23.10.2017,
the ba sis for
in disciplin ary
the leave b_v the
renders the findings
1'r
e finding under
''
rvhollv unsustainabre.
this
tlr administrative
side,
ratified the petitioner,s
eave through
ROC
B.Spt., dt.O1.O2.2O18,
exrsted. Findings
High Court, on
and resolved the
and
}OC No.742t/2017_
Charge Nt s
findings desp i
competent authority,
I and 3 no louger
e lawful approval
tmpermissible
1S
perverse.
of
ancl
53. Thus, the findir
;"',,
tr
:,,ffi, :t ;" jil:':"J"
rights'
"'::"'jn respec'i
r
of e'iclence and
are illt
Enquiry officer
ar,.'o'o'""
to consider
-.*r:;'
crocumentary
evidenc
;:"::[r;
;" ;;* :ff :,.:;;:,,, r adminis,ra,ive
*t t erns service
;:::::,::
rr officers, thus
and
on ,n"' wlr Ie, we
are of the
considered vieu, that the Articles of charges framed under Charge
Memo II are not proved.
Charge Memo III-ROC.No.2266 | 20 16-Vigilance Cell, dt.27.O4.2OL7 :
54. We have carefully perused the charges framed against the
petitioner, the trnquiry Officer's report, the evidencc led on behalf
of tl.re Department, and the documents and a,ffidavits filed by the
petltloner
55. Charge Nos. 1 & 2:
As the petitioner has produced
documents (starting from Ex.D31), to demonstrate proper Check &
Put-up endorsements for all the records during the relevant period
and the evidence of the departmental u,itnesses is either indirect,
contradictory, or does not pertain to the specific dates a1leged, we
find that the allegation of pendency of 35 Charge Sheets and 29
Final Reports without proper endorsemcnt as check and put up,
in charges No.1 & 2 are not substantiated bv credible evidence
accordingiy, we hoid that the said charges are not proved
56. Charge Nos.3 & 4 Improper handling of case filcs, dockets,
and under-trial prisoner cases is concerned, as seen from the
material produced by the petitioner, it appears that the petitioner
acted in accordance with Court procedure, taking directions from
the Principal District Judge and ensuring conti' ruity of records.
Any signatures or initialing u,ere procedural nd there is no
z
deliberate negligence, which can be held to be nr sconduct on the
part of the petitioner/ delinquent officer. Further, rvork delays are
attributable to court vacations, advocate gitation, dying
I
declarations, and inexperience of a neu,1y posterl Bench Clerk. In
our considered opinion, these charges are alsc not proved bv
cogent evidence.
CharseNos.S&6:
The ailegecl penderL, 1, of 30 Charge
Sheets ancl non,cognizanc.e of scr:utinized cases i , conccrned, the
material on record establishes that the ailegecl Cl- arge Sheets and
files were rrot before the petitioner or1 the revenant date.
Subsequent aclion on O9-O8-2015, as eviderced under the
doclrrnents marked on behalf of the petitioner, c. tegoricall-,r shou,
that all records u,'ere properly endorsed and tak,: r cognizance of.
Thus, in our considered opinion, the saLr chargcs are
unsustainable and accordingly, the same are helc -rot proved.
58. Charse No.8
:
As regards the incomplete r ocl<et orders in
39 calendar cases, the documents marked in r:spect of cases
shoq.n in Annexure-Vll categorically sho-,v thal the petitioner,s
conduct was in accordance with procedural requirements,
considering absence of accused, advocates' boycott, and the heavy
pendency of 2300 cases, including juvenile cases and SRs. Hence,
it cannot be said that the petitioner acted in-cliligently, which
amounts to misconduct, thus the said charge is also not proved
59. Further, Charge No.7 u,as held to be dropped/not proved by
the Enquiry Officers. In view of the above, this court finds that
the report of the Enquiry Officer insofar as the charges held to be
proved suffers from perversity and mis appreciation of evidence
The petitioner's documentary and oral evidence ts case specific
and the enquiry officers got carried ar'r,ay in arriving at the
findings, without proper basis and mechanicall'1 held that the
Articles of Charges 1 to 6 and 8 charges are proved.
Charse Memo IV-ROC No. 76 l20L9-Yieilance Cell. dt.O8.O4.2O19
60. Finally, coming to the sole Article of Charge framed under
Charge Memo IV, the Enquiry Officer relying on the er,idence of
PWl and PW2 and departmental documents held that the
petitioner allegedly failed to deposit the case property of
Rs.3,59,19,250/- seized in Crime No.253l20 18 into FDR
immediately, and thereby acted in a dis tbedient malner.
amounting to dereliction of duty.
61. Hor.r,ever, as seen from the material on rr: :ord, the petitioner
had been on sanctioned leave from 07. 12.20 18 to O9.I2.2O|B,
with permission to leave headquarters on 06. l2 .2}lg. During this
period, the VI Additional Junior Civil Judge u,ir; placed in_charge,
as admitted by PW-1 (principal District Jud11 :, Warangal). On
returning from leave on lO.l2.2}lg, the p:titioner promptly
endorsed a Safe Custody Order for the cash, hc wever, due to lack
of jurisdiction over election-related offences, as per the orders of
the Hon'ble High Court and the State Electiorr Commission, and
complied with the directives of the Hon'ble prin: pa1 District Judge
by issuing a memorandum on 08.01.2019 1: the SHO, p.S.
Kazipet, for production of the case property, ,",. rich subsequently
led to the issuance of an FDR in the court's nar re on 0g.01.2019,
which was received by the petitioner on 09.01 .I Ol9 and reported
compliance to the Principal District Judge orL 11.01.2O19, well
within the period of the Shou' cause Notrc:, demonstrating
prompt and lau,ful action.
62. Further, the Enquiry Officer ignored the substantial evidence
placed by the petitioner, including leave orders, Safe Custody
endorsement, and compliance report and this might be a lapse on
part of the petitioner but does not amount to a mis conduct
Thus, in our considered opinion, the Article of Charge framed
under the Clnrqe Memo IV is also not proved and the findings of
the enquiry officer a-re misconceived and in our considered
opinion, this charge is also not proved beyond reasonable doubt
FINDINGS OF THE COURT
63. Thus, in the light of the above, we find no evidence placed b-vthe respondent/ department to establish that the petitioner/
delinquent ofhcer committed any misconduct as alleged in any of
the charge in all the Charge Memos I to IV issued. The material on
record does not disclose that the charges u'ere cxamined in thc
light of the defence evidence adduced by the petitioner. On the
contrary, the documentary and oral evidence produced b1' the
petitioner uide Exs.D I to D46 in relation to Charge Merno I,
Exs.Di to D31 in relation to Charge memo II, Exs.D1 to D239 in
relation to Charge Memo III and Exs.D 1 to D 12 in relation to
Charge Memo IV, clearly establish- that the Articles of Charges rn
a-11
four Charge Memos(u'hich u'ere held to be proved b5z the
Enquiry Officer) r/ere not proved. Though 1lL, Er.rquiry Officers
recorded findings holding the charges as p r rverl, the enquiry
officer findings arc not supported by any doc; rtentary evidence.
in respect of all lour chargc memos, more so the petitioner has
exhibited voluminous documentary evidencc to controvert the
charges.
64. Thus, in our considered view, the findin_c ; recorded by the
Enquiry Officers are perverse, unsupported by t, idence, and sheer
non-application of mind.
65. Norv that *.e have already, held that the.: r.,s no e'idence to
prove the misconcluct on the part of the pet tioner/delinquent
officer and the fincling arrived by the enquiry ofl cers are perverse,
we now deal as to u,hether this Court cal) -e_appreciate the
evidence adduced in the departmental enquir.v r-rnder 226 of the
Constitution ol India, nlore so, u,hen the en(f I1ry officers have
categorically held the cherrges to be proved.
66. In the iight of thc above lactual issues, \\re i re constrained to
refer the rulings of the Honble Supreme Cotr t in the case of
Deputy General Manager (Appellate Authofir:g) & Others a,
Ajag Kumar Sriaastaua3, w-herein the Hon'b'le Supreme Court
held as under:
"When the disciplinary enquiry is conducted for the
alleged misconduct against the public servant, the
Court is to examine and determine:
i) Whether enquiry \rras held by competent
authority
ii) whether rules of natural justice are complied
with
iii) Whether the finding or conclusions are based
on some evidence and authority has porrver
and jurisdiction to reach finding of fact or
conclu sion. "
67. Further the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the said case held
that in exercise of jurisdiction of judicial review under Article
226 or Article 136 of the Constitution, Courts can not interfere u'ith
the findings of fact arrived at in a disciplinary proceeding, except
in a case of maiafides or perversity, i.e., where there is no evidence
to support a linding or where a finding is such that no man acting
reasonably and u,rth objectivity could have arrived at that findings
and so long as there is some evidence to support the conclusion
arrived at b,v the departmental authority, the same has to be
sustained.
68. Further in the case of Kuld.eep Singh u. The Commissioner
Of Police & Ors{ , the Hon'ble Supreme Court has also considered
l2o2tl 2 SCC 612
.50
a case of similar nature with the present ,l Lse, wherein the
judgment in the case of Nand Kishore prasad. t State Of Bihar
and Orss \t'as considered, rvherein it u,a_. hcld that the
disciplinary proceedings before a domestic TribL nal are of quasi.
judicial character and, therefore, it is necessar\ .l.rat the Tribunal
should arrive at its conclusions on the basis
:_
that is to szl_y, strch evidence u,hich, and thz
I
' some evidence,
too, rvith some
degree of definiteness, points to the guilt of tlL, delinquent ald
does not leave the matter in a suspicious state ,l i mere suspicion
cannot take the place of proof cven .in dome s :rc enquiries. If,
thelefore. there is no evidence to sustirin thc chilrges lramed
against the delinquent, the emplo1,6.s cannot be relcl to be guilty
as in that evenr, the findings recorded by th,_, Enquirl' Officer
would be perverse.
69. Further, in the recent judgrnent oi the I on,ble Supreme
Court in the <:ase of Nirbhag Singh Suliga a. :;:dte of Mad.hga
Prad.esh & Anothe*, wherein the r-rnfortunate
J,l ght of a judicial
officer/ apoellan t thcrcin w,ho put in 27 years of unblemished
service, lvas re tnoved from servicc, and the scl_ and exclusive
4 i999 (2) SCC t0
s I 978(3) SCC .la)()
6 Civil A1;pr:ai No..1() of 2026,
dt.O5.O I .2026
basis on which the appellant therein has been removed are four
judicial orders, by which he enlarged certain parties on bail and
those four orders were contrasted g'ith 14 other orders of bail and
after hnding that in thc four orders, section 509 A of Madhya
Pradesh Excise Act, 1915, was not referred to, action has been
taken. It is also the charge that according to the High Court, in
14 other orders the appellant referred to the said section implying
thereby he was conscious of existence of the said section on the
statute. Section 59-A prescribes rvhat has now famously come to
bc known as "twin conditions" for grant of bail and subjecting the
judicial officer to discipiinary pr oceeding for the said charge, the
judicial officer rvas removed from service. The Honble Supreme
Court has categoricall,v heid that in the case of this nature, AS
there was no charge of illegal gratification or malafide on the part
of the judicial officer, has set aside the punishment and also
seriously vien,ed that the High Court ought to have interdicted
with tne punishment imposed(the said copy of the judgment was
circulated to all the .Judges of the High Court through Registrar
General uide ROC.No.76/SOl2026, dt.19.O1.20261, r.rrhich
mandated this Court to foliow, the dicta laid down br. the Hon'ble
J2
Supreme Courrt to interfere into such cases, so ,i; to not drive the
litigants to the Hon'ble Apex Courr.
70 .
Further, lhe Hor-r'ble Supreme Court clt.r ling u,ith manv
similarly arisen issues as in the case of M.S. Btt.d.ra o. tlnion of
IndiaT held that * hilc e'aluating the materiz ts the authority
should not altogethe r ignore the reputation in .,,hich the officer
was held till recentlv. The maxim ,,Nentt Fintt Repente
Turpissimus" (no o,e becomes dishonest all ol r sudden) is not
unexceptional but still it is a salutary guidelinr to judge human
conduct, parricularlv in the fielcl of Administ r rtive Lau.. The
authorities shor-rld ,ot keep the e,ves totally cr.r ;ed toward s the
overall estimation ir-r u'hich the clelinquent officer u,as held in the
recent past b-\,those rvho u,ere supervising him ert lier. F.urther the
Hon'b1e Supreme Court held that to dunk ar: officer into the
puddle of "d.ubtful intcgritv,' it is not enougL that the doubt
fringes on a mcre hunch. That dor-rbt should be r f such a nature
as n,ould reasonabl,r, and consciously be en r rtarnable by a
reasonable ma, on the gi'ren nrateriar. Mere por;r ibirity is hardry
sufficient to assllme that it woulcl rrave happene rr rhere rnust be
preponderance ol probability for the reasonable r ein to
? i998i7) SCC :] I C
entertain
doubt regarding that possibilitl'. On11, then there is justification to
rarn an officer with the label "dorlbtful integrity"
71. Learned Senior Counsr:l Mr.M.Surender Rao, has place
reliance on other cases reiteraring the principles. Hou,ever, in the
iight of the above judicial precedent, rve have not extracted the
relevant portions as the cases rclerred by us rvould squarely cover
the instant issue and the learneci Standing Counsel for High Court
placed reliance on the decision ol a Division Bench of the Hon'bie
High Court of Madras rn R. Anburaj's case, horvever, the said
judicial precedent is on a difie;ent looting and is distinguishable
in law and facts.
72. Thus, in view of the above l udicial precedents, it is well
settled that a linding in a dr:partmental enquirv can be termed
perverse rvhen it is not suppor-ted b1, any evidence, rvhen it ignores
the evidence produced by either side, or vrhen no reasonable
person could have arrived at sllch a conclusion on the material
avaiiable. Thus, in vielr.' of the l{on'ble Supreme Court's decision
including Kuldeep Singh's CASC (supra), that although Courts
normally do not interfere rvith findings recorded in departmental
enquiries, interference is justilied rvhere the finding of guilt is
5+
based on no evidence or on unreliable evidence. .r '. clear distinction
must be maintained betu,een an incorrect findir 6 and a perverse
finding. Where there is some acceptable eviclr'r ice, the linding
should not be distr-rrbed; hor'r'cve r, u'here there i , no evidence at
all or the evidence docs not reasortably support the conclusion,
such a finding is perverse and liable to be set asirl:
73. In the present case, as discussed above, tit :re is absolutely
no material on record lrom u l-rich anv inference r f misconduct or
extraneous consideration can be drarn'n with res::ct to any of the
charges contained in the four charge memos. Ir the absence of
evidence establishing misconduct, the imposrt on of a major
penalty is wholl-r, ui rjustified anc lias resulted itr 1 rave injustice to
the petitioner, r,,,ho has been punished r.vithout far 1t
74. Although the scope of jucliciai revieu, under rrticle 226 of the
Constitution is limited, it cloes not prevent ,his Court from
intervening where disciplinar-r' ploceedings ..c founded on
perverse findings. When conclusions in an enqr.i ]' report are not
supported by a proper appreciation of the evider < e and lead to an
ex facie illegal ancl arbitrar--r. punrshment, l.tL s Court cannot
remain a silent spectator. Particularly lr.here the r clinquent officer
JJ
has effectively rebutted the charges by placing substantial and
credibie material on record, the Court is duty-bound to examine
whether the findings are susLainable. It is cqually lr,ell settled that
long and unbiemished service cannot be disregarded on the basis
of mere suspicion or conjecture
75. Thus, the contention of the learned Standing Counsel for the
High Court and the Iearned Covernment Pleader for Services-Il
that this Court is precluded from reappreciating the evidence
under Article 226, and that the chargcs stood conclusively proved
in the departmental enquirt . is untenable and accordingly
rejected.
76. In view of the above findings, rvc hold that this Court, in
exerclse
of its jurisdiction uncler ArLicle 226, IS competent to
examine the evidentiary basis of lindings recorded in
a
departmental enquiry 'n,here such findings are perverse or
unsupported by the record. Upon such examination, we are
satisfied that the alleged misconduct in respect of all four charge
memos has not been established. The findings recorded in the
respective charge memos are per\,'erse and untenable and
accordingly, all four charge memos are hereb)' ( uashed and set
aside. Accordingly, the Point No. 1 is answered
77. As a result, the impugned G.O.Ms.No.4O. Lau' (LA, LA&JHome-Courts.A2) Department, dt.13.07.2021 issued by the
Government of Telangana, subjecting the pe r ioner to major
punishment of compulsory retiremcnt from sen.i: : as Junior Civil
Judge under Clause B Rule 9 of Telalgar i Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 199 L (for short 'CCA
Rules') anrl
the
consequentiai pr rceedings
1n
ROC.Nos. 1815/ 2015, 948l2Ot6. 2266 /2016 and 76 /2Or9-
Vigilance Cell, dt.13.O7.2021, are liable tc be set aside
Accordingly, Point No.2 is answer'.:d
78. Thus, in vier,r' of the above findings on the ssues settled by
us, the Writ Petition is allolr,ed and the impugnec f.O. Ms. No. 40,
Larv (LA, LA & J Home-Courts.,A2) Department. : :led 73.07.2021
as well as the prcceedings issued b1' the High C: -lrt for the State
of Telangana in ROC Nos. 1815/2O15, 948/2OlC, 2266 l20 16 and
76 /2019 Vigilance Cell, dated 1.3.07 .2021, are t ereby set aside
The respondents No. i & 2 are l-rereby directec to reinstate the
petitioner into service forthwith, urithin a period r'four (04) weeks
:;7
lrom today, by counting the period frr-rm the clate of imposition of
major punishment tiil the date of reinstatement as continuity of
servlce. However it is made clear the petitione r/delinquent officer
is not entitled to the amoLlnts tc'u,ard s her salar'-l' on the principle
of no u,ork no pay for the said pericd. Further. if anv amount paid
towards the 213,d pension amount during the saicl period, sha1l be
treated as subsistence allou,arrce to the petitioner. No order as to
costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pcndirrg if any, shall
stand closed
above'
That Rule Nisi has been made absolute as
APARESH KUMAR SINGH' ON this
WitNESS THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETTT OAV OiiCENUARY
SD/- P.PONNA KRISHNA
SSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
AM KOSHY
One Fair CoPY to the Hon'ble Sri Justic P
(For His LordshiPs Ki nd Peru r)
AND
SUDDALA CHALAPATHT RAO
Justice
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble Sri
(For His LordshiPs Kind Perusal)
To
1. 11 LR CoPies.
i. fn" UnO"t Secretary, Union of lndia Ministry of Law' Justice and
Company
Affairs, New Delhi.
High Court
Buildinqs, HYderabad.
Telangana' Legal
3. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association Library'
of
Honorable Secretary to Government' Government
4.
- The
ntirii., L"Eiijtive ntair's and Justice'no"o'able High' The Honorable High
5. The Honorable Registrar (Vidirlil"j'
Court for the State of Telanqana, Hyoeraoao. Advocate oPUCI
o 5i"' Cc' tii'sni Snr r'r rvns*f Rnt rv(nol n4lu'
at
I
7.
for the State of Telangana'
Two CCs to GP fOn SeHVf'CiiS ii,.High Court
iji,L"bCi,ishj"rtjwrunr PAWAN KUMAR, sc FoR rsHC [oPUC]
o
PSK.
Hvderabad. [OUT]
Two CD CoPies
I'9,-
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:2010212026
(
ORDER
o
()
WP.No.32888 o12021
IHE S Tt
I2
r'i
',
q 2fl26
*
: i.rrc
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
(ql\
v_-
)
,I
t
*
z
}.6,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review