The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 05.2017, the Additional Collector was not specifically assigned the powers u/s. 165(6), (7) for which a separate order is required to be passed. 17] In the considered opinion of this court, the said finding that a separate/specific order is required to passed by the Collector to assign the powers u/s.165 is erroneous as it is not the requirement of law as the reference of word “Notification” in S.165(6) & (7) is in respect of the land and tribe only, and not the powers of the Collector. It appears that the Commissioner was already prejudiced against the Additional Collector and set aside the order of sanction with that mindset only. 18] So far as the discrepancies which has occurred in the affidavits filed by respondents No.2 to 5 are concerned, the same appears to be trivial in nature and does not affect the transaction. The respondents have stated that they already have other lands bearing survey numbers 122, 138, 456/1, 456/2 admeasuring 1.850 hectare, which is still left with them after parting with 4.4440 hectare. Thus, it cannot be said that the respondents were left with some small piece of land not enough to provide for their needs. They have also stated that from the amount received by them, they would increase the procurement of the remaining land which also does not appear to be suspicious in any manner. In their application, the respondents No.2 to 5 have also 5:46:…
4. The aforesaid factual situation could not be disputed by the learned counsel for the respondents No.1 to 7/State. Thus in view of the aforesaid categoric decision of this Court, the impugned order dated 20/4/2022 passed by the Commissioner, Ujjain Division, Ujjain cannot be sustained in the eye of law. The same is hence hereby set aside.
5. The petition is accordingly, allowed and disposed off. C.c. as per rules.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 31st OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 1315 of 2024
BETWEEN:KRISHNA GIRI GOSWAMI S/O SHRI SAMAND GIRI
GOSWAMI, AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
BUSINESS R/O GRAM BANGROD RATLAM (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI GOPAL KRISHNA PATIDAR - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH ADDL.
SECRETARY REVENUE DEPARTMENT VALLABH
BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
AYUKT UJJAIN SAMBHAG UJJAIN KOTHI ROAD
UJJAIN (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
COLLECTOR DISTRICT RATLAM COLLECTOR
OFFICE NEW COLLECTORATE BUILDING MHOW
NEEMUCH ROAD, RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
APAR
COLLECTOR
DISTRICT
RATLAM
COLLECTOR OFFICE NEW COLLECTORATE
BUILDING MHOW NEEMUCH ROAD RATLAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
ANUVIBHAGIYA ADHIKARI GRAMIN COLLECTOR
OFFICE NEW COLLECTORATE BUILDING MHOW
NEEMUCH ROAD RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
TEHS ILD AR NEW COLLECTORATE BUILDING
MHOW NEEMUCH ROAD RATLAM (MADHYA
PRADESH)
7.
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 2/1/2024
5:46:55 PM
APAR
TEHSILDAR TEHSIL TAPPA NAMLI
DISTRICT RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
8.
9.
BHERULAL S/O BAGDIRAM JI BHIL, AGED ABOUT
62 YEARS, OCCUPATION: AGRICULTURE R/O.
GRAM BANGROD TEHSIL AND DISTRICT
RATLAM (MADHYA PRADESH)
SANDEEP VERMA S/O NANDKISHORE JI VERMA,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS, OCCUPATION: BUSINESS
R/O. VED VYAS COLONY JILA RATLAM (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI ANENDRA SINGH PARIHAR - P.L. FOR STATE)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
1. Heard.
2 . By this petition preferred under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioner has challenged the order dated 20/4/2022 passed by the
Commissioner, Ujjain Division, Ujjain whereby he has while exercising his suo
motu revisional power under Section 42 and Section 32 of the M.P. Land
Revenue Code, 1959
set aside the order dated 27/4/2017 (Annexure P/1)
passed by the Additional Collector, Ratlam by which permission under Section
165(6) of the Code, 1959 for sell of the land of respondents No.8 and 9 was
granted and subsequently the registered sale deed was also executed on
5/07/2017.
3. At the outset, learned counsel for the petitioner brought to the notice
of this Court an order dated 3/10/2023 passed in M.P.No.3679 of 2021 (Dinesh
Kumar V/s. State of M.P. & Ors.) by Coordinate Bench of this Court whereby
in identical fact situation the order passed by the Commissioner, Ujjain, Division
Ujjain was set aside. In the said order it was held by this Court as under :-
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 2/1/2024
5:46:55 PM
"9] From the record it is found that the agreement to sell the disputed
land was executed by respondents No.2 to 5 in the month of February, 2018,
and on 22/02/2018, the application under Section 165(6) of the Code of 1959
was filed, seeking permission to sell the land before the competent authority.
On 13/03/2018, a report was prepared by the Patwari pursuant to the
application filed by the respondents under Section 165(6) of the Code of 1959.
The advertisement was issued on the report of the Naib Tehsildar by the Sub
Divisional Officer on 26/02/2018. The Additional Collector passed the final
order on 24/02/2018 and 21/03/2018 filed as Annexure P/9, and the
registered sale deed was executed subsequently on 26/03/2018, between the
petitioner and respondents No.2 to 5. In the month of October, 2018, the
Collector made a representation to the Commissioner, Ujjain Division
alleging procedural irregularities in granting permission for sale of land in
question, and to take cognizance in the matter in Revision under Section 50 (2)
of the Code.
10] Learned counsel for the petitioner has raised a legal ground that
the Commissioner could not have taken the cognizance under Section 50 of the
Code of 1959 after more than 180 days/6 months, as admittedly the order was
passed by the Additional Collector on 21/03/2018, whereas the cognizance
has been taken by the Commissioner on 20/11/2018, and the order has been
passed by the Commissioner on 14/09/2021.
11] At this juncture, it would apt to refer to the decision rendered by
the Full Bench in the case of Ranveer Singh (supra) in which he following
question was referred for its consideration:“Whether in the case wherein an individual is not put to suffer
any irreparable loss, exercise of suo motu powers after any length of
period is justifiable in Law, more so, for protection of Government land
or public interest.”
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 2/1/2024
5:46:55 PM
12] This question has been answered by the Full Bench in the following
manner :-
“38. Ab judicatio for the reasons stated hereinabove we hereby
answer the question referred to us as under :“The suo motu powers can be exercised by the revisional
authority envisaged under section 50 of the Code within a period of 180
days from the date of the knowledge of illegality, impropriety and
irregularity of the proceedings committed by any revenue officer
subordinate to it even if the immovable property is Government land or
having some public interest. What should be the irreparable loss, it
should be considered on the facts, and circumstances of each case as no
definite yardstick in that regard can be drawn.”
We have already mentioned hereinabove certain instances which
can be said to be the “irreparable loss.”
(emphasis supplied)
13] It is apparent from the aforesaid decision that the suo motu
powers can be exercised by the revisional authority under Section 50 of
the Code of 1959 within a period of 180 days from the date of the
knowledge of illegality or impropriety. In the present case, the Collector
has not exercised his power under Section (6-b), however, he has
referred the matter to the Commissioner vide his letter sent in the month
of October 2018, whereas, the final order has been passed by the
Commissioner on 14/09/2021 i.e. after a period of 3 years and 5
months. It is also found that the petitioner and respondents were issued
show cause notice on 04/02/2019 by the Commissioner, and the
petitioner filed his detailed reply on 23/09/2019, whereas the
respondents No.2 to 5 filed their reply on 24/09/2019, and thereafter it
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 2/1/2024
5:46:55 PM
took more than around 2 years to the Commissioner to pass the final
order which was passed on 14/09/2021. Thus, the order was clearly
passed beyond the period of 180 days, and on this ground only, the
impugned order is liable to be set aside.
14] Apparently, the sale deed which was executed on 26/03/2018
has been cancelled after a period of 180 days which is surely going to
cause irreparable injury and harm not only to the petitioner, but also to
respondents No.2 to 5, the sellers, who have already obtained the entire
amount to their satisfaction and which must have been utilised by them
by now.
15] It is also found that in the registration certificate, it is
mentioned that the market value of the property is stated to be
Rs.38,31,720/-, whereas the consideration paid is Rs.45,00,000/- which
is much more than the market price. The aforesaid amount of Rs.45
Lakh has also been paid by the petitioner through bank transaction
only. Thus, it cannot be said that it was a sham transaction, and in such
circumstances, the order of sanction under Section 165 (6) of the Code,
passed by the Additional Collector could not have been set at naught by
the Commissioner only because other departmental inquiries have been
initiated against him, and it would not render the entire transaction as
null and void.
16] It is also found that so far as the powers of the Additional
Collector to pass any order under the Land Revenue Code are
concerned, vide Distribution Memo dated 22.11.2016, Additional
Collector Dr. Kailash Bundela has been assigned all the powers under
the Code, in relation to all the original applications. And subsequently,
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 2/1/2024
5:46:55 PM
vide Memo dated 19.04.2018, the Collector has kept to himself the
powers u/ss. 24, 30, 237, 240, 241 and 247(3) & (5) of the Code,
whereas has assigned the powers to exercise its jurisdiction u/s.165(6) of
the Code to the Additional Collector Dr. Kailash Bundela only. In the
impugned order, the Commissioner has held that vide Memo dated
19.05.2017, the Additional Collector was not specifically assigned the
powers u/s. 165(6), (7) for which a separate order is required to be
passed.
17] In the considered opinion of this court, the said finding that a
separate/specific order is required to passed by the Collector to assign
the powers u/s.165 is erroneous as it is not the requirement of law as the
reference of word “Notification” in S.165(6) & (7) is in respect of the
land and tribe only, and not the powers of the Collector. It appears that
the Commissioner was already prejudiced against the Additional
Collector and set aside the order of sanction with that mindset only.
18] So far as the discrepancies which has occurred in the
affidavits filed by respondents No.2 to 5 are concerned, the same
appears to be trivial in nature and does not affect the transaction. The
respondents have stated that they already have other lands bearing
survey numbers 122, 138, 456/1, 456/2 admeasuring 1.850 hectare,
which is still left with them after parting with 4.4440 hectare. Thus, it
cannot be said that the respondents were left with some small piece of
land not enough to provide for their needs. They have also stated that
from the amount received by them, they would increase the procurement
of the remaining land which also does not appear to be suspicious in
any manner. In their application, the respondents No.2 to 5 have also
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 2/1/2024
5:46:55 PM
stated that the land which they are selling is an irrigated land, and in
such circumstances, if in the subsequent document, it is mentioned that
the land is unirrigated, it would not make any difference.
19] In such circumstances, the impugned order dated 14/09/2021
passed by the Commissioner, Ujjain Division, Ujjain cannot be
sustained in the eyes of law, firstly on the ground that it has been passed
after more than 180 days from the date of the knowledge of illegality,
and secondly on its merits, and if any consequential changes have been
made in the revenue record, the same shall also stand reversed/cancelled
as the land has already been mutated in the name of the petitioner on
18/05/2018.
4. The aforesaid factual situation could not be disputed by the learned
counsel for the respondents No.1 to 7/State. Thus in view of the aforesaid
categoric decision of this Court, the impugned order dated 20/4/2022 passed by
the Commissioner, Ujjain Division, Ujjain cannot be sustained in the eye of law.
The same is hence hereby set aside.
5. The petition is accordingly, allowed and disposed off.
C.c. as per rules.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
SS/-
Signed by: SHAILESH
MAHADEV SUKHDEVE
Signing time: 2/1/2024
5:46:55 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review