Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3301 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITIO N NO:18101 OF2021
Between:
Kommu Srinivas, S/o. Komuraiah, Aged about 49 years, Assistant Motor
Vehicle lnspector, Presently working in wankidi check Post, Asifabad Dist
(On Deputation) R/o Chaitanyapuri' Karimnagar-505001
...PETITIONER
AND
TheStateofTelangana'rep.byitsPrincipalSecretarytoGovernment,
Transport, Roads and Buildings Department Secretariat,T S' Hyderabad'
The Tiansport Commissioner, Telangana State, Hyderabad'
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an appropriate writ, order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of
writ of Mandamus declaring that the Petitioner is entitled to have his case
considered and be promoted as Motor Vehicles lnspector without reference to the
No.
disciplinary proceedings initiated by the 2nd Respondent vide charge Memo
year
1224N3N2t2014-1 dated 11t0512018 for an alleged incident pertaining to the
the
2014with all consequential benefits in the interest of justice duly setting aside
disciplinary proceedings which are being continued pursuant to charge Memo
daled
1224N3N2t20',14-1 dated 11t05t2018 and the rejection Memo No. 351C312020
No.
15tO2t2O2O issued by the 2nd Respondent, as being arbitrary, illegal,
vitiated by the
delay, contrary to the orders issued in GO Ms No 679 dated 01-1
provisions of Rule 20 of TSCS (CC and A) Rules, 199',1 and in violation of Articles
1-20'18'
and 16 of the Constitution of lndia
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 1{t1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
respondents to consider the case of the petitioner for promotion to the post of Motor
Vehicle lnspector without refe'ence to Charge Memo No 1224N3N212014-1 dated
'l I-05-20'18 issued by the 2nd Respondent for an alleged incident pertaining to the
year 2O14on the analogy of t)rders passed in similar cases duly suspending the
operation of Memo No 35/C3/12020 daled 15-02-2020
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2021
Between:
1. The State of Telangana. rep. by its Principal Secretary to Government,
Transport, Roads and B.rildings Department Secretariat,T S Hyderabad.
2. The Transport Commissioner, Telangana State, Hyderabad.
...PETITIONERSRESPONDENTS
AND
Kommu Srinivas, S/o Komureriah, Aged about 49 years, Assistant Motor Vehicle
lnr;pector, Presently working in Wankidi Check Post, Asifabad Dist (On Deputation)
R/o Chaitanyapuri. Karimnagar-505001
...RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the pretition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim orders dt 04.08 2021 passed in lA No. 1of 2021 in WP.No.18101 of 2021
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. RANGARAJULA RAJASEKHARA RAO
Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES I
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA I(ARTHIK
WRIT PETITION No.181Ol of 2O2l
Dated 23'a July,2026.
Betwee n:
Kommu Srinrvas
. Pctition cr
AND
'l'hc Statc ol 1'clangana,
Rep. br its [)rinr:ipal Sccrct.lr\'.
1'ransport., Roads & Buildings I)cparl.nrcnt,
Secretariat, T.S., Hyderabad. and othcrs.
. Respondcn Ls
ORDER:
,\ggrrevt-'rl l)\ th('action ol lcspon(lcnL No.2 irr rcjccting the claim of
the petitioner for prornotion to thc post of Motor Vehiclc lnspector vidc
Memo. No.35/ C3l2O2O datcd 15.02.2020, for the alleged incident of the
rr:ar 20 I4, and sccking to drrcct thc rcspondcnts to consider his case lor
pron)otion to the aforcsaid post. thc prcscnt. wril pctition is filcd.
2.
Heard Sri Rangarajula Rajasekhar Rao, learned counsel appearing
lor the pctitioner, and lcarncd Government Pleader for Services-I,
zrppcaring on bchall ol Lhc rcspondcnLs
)
P K. ..1
ll' P.\'a.1,,1O1 af 20)l
3.
Lcarncd coLlns( l ior thr pctrtion.r subniits rhat rhc peritioner $as
appoin:ecl :rs .\ssistar:r \ otor \ clricle lnspcctor rhroush direcr rcr:ruilmcnI
in lhc vcar- 201-1. anrl uhilc sorking as such. on 18.O1.2014. a surprlsc
chcck u"as ('on(lrLCr.il Irr thc .\nti Corruption []urcau olficials at the
integrated c:heck post. Shoraj. i\dilabad District. an(l unilateral check
procecclings u:erc prcp:ir( d. u'hcrt'in, no discrcpancies were rcc:ords and all
thc zrmol.inls ri c'rc lallicd c()rrccll\ . I loucvcr, ll \\'as err oneousl-,- recorded
that tire cir ivt-rs rr hrr r rsi;rri r:l1c ('hcck post had r,'oluntarilv olTcled a bribe
to thc pctitioncr anrl z -l raffrc Constabic. \\'ithout I hem making anv
clemand. Sr-Lbscrlr.rcn: lr . alt('r a lapsc ol nrorc th:ln fotrr vcars and ttrrce
nronr.hs 'rl Lhi' sarrl irc'irlc'L.it. rcslrondcnL No.2 inil iatecl disciplinarl'
procecclinqs against llri' pctitioncr rrdc Cherrgc NIcrnr,.No. 122.1 lV3l\t2I
2Ol4 I daled 1 1 .05.201t1, alleging thc petitioncr rvas involved in corrupt
practiccs :rncl colle<'Lcd bribcs lrom the dri\,ers of lolries and thal an
amounl or- lls..ll. lO, r
u as serzccl lronr him at thc cher'k post. llou'ever.
rhe impur;,rtron ol rhr aLlcqccl misc'ondLrcL is norhing but a rcpctition o[ thc
surprise check prc,r:t'r'd nqs prr'parcd br thc ACB authoritics dated
1E.01.201.1. anrl ll'cri
s no inrlcpt'rrrlcnl applicaLior: oI minrl br the
disciplinal arullroriti rn issL:inq tlrc s:rirl Chargc 1\1cmo.
4.
It is lurthcr-sr-r [rrnir.e<1 rhat rhe au[horities had taken up pr()motions
to thc 1)osl ol \,roror \ t'hicrc Inspcctor, but thc petitioner,s case. despite his
PK, ,J
W.l'.No. ) 8101 of 2a2l
cligibilitl and cntitlcment, \\'as ovcrlookcd and delerred. As such, thc
petitioner '&,as constrained to approach thts Court by filing W.l).No.27880
of 2019, rvhich was disposcd of vidc orde r dated I 6.12.2O19, directing the
aurhorlties to consider his casc l'or promotion in accordance r"'ith thc
provisions ol Ci.O.Ms.No.257 datcd l().0().1999. o,'r'cvcr, rcspondcnt No.2
issued the impugned Memo dated 15.O2.2O2O, rejecting the claim of the
petitioner for promotion, on the sole ground of pcndency of disciplinary
procecdings, u hich r,r'ere init-iated belatcdll' after a lapse of more than four
vcars. As such, both thc disciptinar,r procccdtngs and thc impugncd
rejection order are vitiated on the ground of delay, solely attributable to the
rcspo:rdcnts. Irurther, thc documcnts rclicd upon by the rcspondents for
rssuing the Charge Memo, including the slaLcrlcnts of the drivcrs. u'erc
also nevcr communicated to the pctitior-Lcr in contravcntron ol Rule 20 ol
the Telangana Civil Services (C lassification. Control and Appeal) Rules,
199 l.
It is further submitted that the pctitioncr had submitted his wrilten
statcment of defense dated 20.06.2018, denying the allegations, and stated
that thcre was no difference in the personal cash or government cash; that
t.he ACB placed a carton and made lhe drivers forcibly place amounls
thcrr:in; and prcparcd thc slt rprisc cht:ck procccdings, lalsell, implicating
hinr.
/)
i1 i
\r, '';r,, ,,, .,, ,'
[t is fi'lrther submrttecr that though Lhe (]harge Memo was issued on
11 05 2o18 ar-rd rhc peti[ron.r submrtted his expranation
on 20.06.201g,
Lhcrc is no progr-ess itr rhc said proccc.<lings. irnd evcn as pcr
(i o.NIs.)'1..679 rlrrr.d 0 r. r r .roog. rhc prcscribccl timc
iimit ol threc r.cars
and srx months. li, r--.rrLprclion .r cnquin, has also erapsed. Hencc. not
onh' rhe dist iplirrer^ pr-o.ccclinqs zLrc vitiated, but the rejcction ordcr
passcd .a tlr. basrs .r' pcrrrrcnc'r ol rrr. saicr riiscrplina^ pror:c.cdings
rs
also riiizrLerd l.urtr:cr. LhoLrgh tl,rc Di.titioncr is not rcsponsiblc for thc
dclav anrl pcndencr ol' ,he said proccedings. he is being deprived of a
rightful pr()motion t1r ih(' p.)sr of \ro[or Uehicle Inspcclor. u.h e his juniors
are being pr() n1o t('cl
Co Ll
lht,re.iorc. li'arncrl couns,-.1 seeks indulgence ol this
rt to set :rsiclc thc rl sc iplrr.r:tr'', procccclings initraterl pursuan[ [o Lhc
Ch:rr_qc \icmrr c1arr.,l ll.C)-..lOl,S. a.cl thc rcjccrion order passcd
br
respondent No.2 rl:rtr,rl 1:.,.02.2020. :r[rd tO drrcct l.tu auth()rrtlus
to
considcr lr s r'lainr f.r- rr rrrroLi,[]. ,)n [)(rr rrrrh his juniors. $.ith al]
conscque.rial benc[irs Ilelia.rce ]ras been place<1 upon the decision of
thc
Ilon'ble Alrr:_x Cour-r i.r State of punjab q.nd others u. Chaman Lal
Gogall
t)
.
orr thc .rhcr- i-r ,rcr . r('.rr1r('(l c.r'crnmcnl [)]eade:, on firine of a
coLlnrrrr alrrclar iL. sLrr-'r'.,rs Lrr.rr orr rc.('rpr of
I 19(l:) I
2 S(,1
dralt artrc.res of charge from
t'K i
W.P.No 18lt)l ol 2t)21
the (iovernment, datcd 30.04.20i8. a Charge Memo dated I I .O5.20 tg r.r.as
issued against the petitioner, and ln pursuance of the same, he filed his
u'rittcr-r staLcnlcnt of dclensc. <lcnving [hc charge. Howevcr. having bccn
dissatisfied with the said explanation, the disciplinary authont\- had
appointed one Mr. Puppala Srinivas. DTC. Adilabad, as enquiry officer on
0.1.08.2020. and an enquir',' is undcrn'ar. While so, in compliance w,ith
thc ordcr of this Court dated lir. t).2019 in W.lr.No.27gg0 ol 2019. lhc
clairn ol the pctitioncr lor promoLion t() thc posr. of Mol.or \rchiclc Inspector
was rejectcd vide rmpugne-d mcmo datcd lJ.O2,2O2O. l.hereafter, the DpC
lor promo[ion to thc post ol Motor V.hicrc Inspector was convencd on
04.12.2O2O, and hrs name was oncc again placcd beiore the Commit[r_.c.
Ho*'ever. due to the pencrencY ol th. disciplinarl, proceedings initiated
against him vide Charge Mcmo datcd I 1,05.2018, his claim r.,",as deferred,
as it u'as not feasible for inclusion ol rhc pctitioncr's name. in rerms of rhc
guidelines issued by the Governmr:nr in G.O.N{s.No,257 datcd 10.06. I99t_)
a.d Circular Mcmi.r.No. 158 1.)/Scr C l2OO7 .larcd I i .Og.2OO7. lrurther, as
pcr the dccision of thc Flon'blc Apcx Court in tlnion oJ Indi(r u. K,V.
Janakirqman2, since the petitioner is lacing disciplinary procecdings, he
is not entitled for promotion. IIence, his claim has rightly been rcjectcd
vidc rmpugned memo dalc.l r'r.o2.2o2o. Thcrefore, it is prayed to dismrss
Lhc prcsent $'rit pctition.
, (1991) 4 SCC 109
PK,,]
lt, P )io lSlol of 2r)21
7.
-fhis Court lt;rs l;tl:c.n i-t.)lc ol th(. rir.,ai
sL.ltmisstorrs r.rr:rdc br k:atrncd
counsel lir thc rcsp('('ti "'c pirrtics anrl pcruscl the mrrLerial avarlable on
r( co r(l
8.
.\drnittcdh. tht p:rrtionor \\:ls appoinrccl .rs a,t 1\ssisLant ivlotor
Vchiclc llrspcctor t1t th€ \ear' 2012. :rnd h:rring com6rleted consiclcrable
lengt.l'r of serr.,ice. hc rs eligtblc for promotion to the post ol Motor Vehicle
lnspcctor Ilorr lr r':'. lris r Lairrr ,.r ls rc jcctcd vidc impr_ gncd Nlr:mo d:rtcd
1.r.02..10-lO. ol.i tlr,' allL qt tl qrottncl 6[ pt't'rclt't'tcr 1l clrscip initry procc.cii,es.
In this c()nn('LrLiolt. it is lterrit-rcrrt Lo not(' thilL thc p,tritioncr has bccn
issucrl u rtl'r the L hargr' \l<'r'no datcd 1 1.0o.2018. in respect of the lncident
pcrtarninq to Lh(' -\ t lrr- .]() i.l. allcging thirL hr: $:rs iT'"olvr.d in corrLlpt
practlces and collectt'rl i,ribe lront Lhr, lorrv dt'ivers passit'rg through thc
check posl. and ihal zrn zrmount ol Rs.37.100/ ri.as seized from thc check
post. In nL.rsLlan( . 'ht'rc rl. lhc p('titioner submittc(l his explanation dated
20.08.20i8. JIc,,.rr'r't. i1 1- 11, 11;;1, IIL 1,, ll(rL, 11Jl an t']C;ttirr Ohrcr.r ,,,.aS
appotlttecl 'lil('I :rlrn.)s L\'o \(',rr-s. L.i'.. ,rrr 04 ()t.1O20. iLn(l an enclLrin is
duc to ir, condrir':c r. .llthoLrgh sisrlificant rine has -lapsed since the
initiaLior.r ,r1 clLsciplinrr:r 1>r,;t:r'cdrn{s. lh€l sam(' h:tve ltot atLaincd linalitr.
till date. Houeicr', ils h('lci b',' thc Ilon blc ,,\pcx Couit in a calcna o1'
.ludgments t1'r:rt clt la-r. in c rnc lr-rsion ol-drsciphnar,r' procet:dings is not fatal
t. srrrh o..cc<c1i.qs.r all .:rs.s. arrd thc same is conting(,nt upon the facts
PK, J
Itt l'.No. 18101 of )021
and circumstanccs of each casc, morc particularl\, the gravit] of allcgcd
misconduct. In the present case, the disciplinary proceedings agarnst thc
petitioner pertain to his alleged corrupt practices, and the veracity of this
allcgation can oni]' be elicited afrcr due enquiry, which is yet to be
concluded. Llence , rhis Court is not inclincd ro interfcrc u.ith lhc
impugned Charge Memo, mcrelv on the ground of delav.
.1.
ls rcgards thc pcritioncr's pronrollon ro thc posl ol Motor Vchiclcs
Inspe ctor, it is pcrtincnt to rcler to thc dccision of thc t lon'blc Apcx Cou rt
in Chrrman Lal Gogal (supra), ri'hcrein, iL has been categorically held that
inordinate delali'in completing a disciplinan, cnquiry cannot be used as a
ground Lo rnd(-.finitelv deny or stall an cmployee's promolion. The lollowing
rs the relevant excerpt of the said decisron:
"12. Applving thc balancirrg l)roccss, \,,c arc of thc opinion that thc
qilashing of chargcs and ol tho or(l('r allpotnrlng enclurn offrcer rras not
$arrantccl rI thc lacts arrd cr(.LLnrslanccs of thc case. lt rs more
appropratc and rtr thc lntcrCSI ol .lusttcc .rs ur.ll as in lhe intcrcst of
administratron LhaL rhc crrcllrrrr sltrch lracl procccclccl to a largc cxtcrrt
be allou,ed to be complercd. At the salllq timq, 1! LS dirqqtqd tha!- lhc
lCsI)orrdl! ! slqU Id ttq cqlsrdr-'rcci iorrhy, ith !-qI ll]oq1qlrqn !.itLqLLt
lqfereqcc. tq 4!d \\rthoU! raking rlrto consrdqlariqn lhe.qhatges qfthq
pe_ndq4l: ot thq. said eqqgqrl a4d ii hc tS [qqnd lit ]!r plgmo-tioq, ]re
shorll! b.€ pr!mQ1ed !14mqdralclr. 'l his direction is made in the
particular lacls and circumstanccs ol the casc though ue are a\\-arc
that the rules and practrce normall-v lbllou.ed in such cascs mar be
difle rent. lLq prq!.,r!!iqL qo.. r!afl!', 11- anr , p4QLng.1]I]_ ::1rq*u14- qb4ll,
however. be subiect to revie$ a fter the conclusion of the eno uirv and rn
tbq lrght oJ thg [!!dings -rn rhe cnqllul. Ir is also directed that the
cnqurn against thc rcspondcnt shirll bc concluded rrrthrn eight months
Irom toda\. The rcspondent sllall coopcratc in concluding thc cnqLlir\.
It is ob\,lous that iI the rcsltondcnr (locs r]ot so cooperatc. lt shall bc
PK. I
tl 1'\,) 1tl/)l i,/,.14).,j
open to tlte t,trqLDn oifi(t.r to pro(.cc(l ex partc. 1[ thc cr-rcllrrn rs rr,,t
coa.luclccr an(l hlral ot(1ers ar( not passed \\'itL n the afo.esaid pcrlo(1.
the cnqrrrrr sltir,i lre ,lccmccl to ha\( bcen droppecl.
lcm p h asis sr-rpp ltccl)
10. In '. rcr.r ol LIrc al),)\(,. thls ( ()ulr is ol thc considcrtd opinion that thc
case ol- thc petirioner lbr promor ion to the posl of \1otor Vehiclc Inspector
dcscn'r's c,rnsrder:rlion. -l herefore. lhe impugned I\4emc, dated 75.O2.2O2O
is liabl,' 1o bc seL rLstdc
11. .\cc'ordirrglr. LIti' $ nt l)ctlriol.l is :rllouc<l in part. sctting asidc [hc
impugnecl Mcmo No.35,
'
l3 2020 clatecl 15.02.2020 iss,_red bt. respondent
No.2. :rncl th(' r('so(,r-l(lci- ts iu c clirc'r:rcd to lirrthu tth consider thc casc ol
thc petrtiorrcr lol l)r rntot on lo lltc posL of !lotrrr \ r'hiclr. lnspt'c[()r, as pcr
his scnioritv :rnd clrgrbrlitr. $'ithoul t.cfcrencrt ro the pcndcnc-\' ol thc
disciplinan proccr'dinqs iniliat(.(l agalnst him vide Charge Memo dated
1l.05.201t. Ijr-ir-t I'rc . Lhi' icspondc,nLs arc dir',tctc:cl to concludc thc said
drsciplinar-r pror:e'i'd nqs. i1s ('xp('ciit toLrslr as possiblc. prclcrablr u.ithin a
period .rI thrct' (0i]) ntontl- s fl-om thc datc o[ reccipl of a cop! ol this order.
NlrsL i ll:rncoLrs irppliL'zr1i,rns.
il:rn\. pcnding in this "rrit pcrition. shall
stalrd Closr'r1. \-o ( ,l-sls
That Rule Nisi has been made absolute as above
witness rHE HoN'BLETHE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH,
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY THIRD OAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
SD/- B.REKHA RANI
asqsrANr REG|STRAR
//TRUE COPY//
\l\
r \i
To,
The Princrpal Secretary to Government, Transport. Roads
Department Secretariat T S Hyderabad.
and Buildings
2. The Transport Commissioner, Telangana State, Hyderabad.
3 One CC to SRl. RANGARAJULA RAJASEKHARA RAO Advocate [OPUCJ
4. Two CCs to GP FOR SERVICES l, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad IOUT]
5 Two CD Copies
BM
PSK
Ny
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2310712026
1i e :,IA I€
ORDER
WP.No.18101 of 2021
o
o
);
'(
31 Jrttz$z$ ',
t
I DESI'A1 -'t(;'9.
,r
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review