Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3484 ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION NO: 11087 OF 2004
Between:
1. Khaja Faraz Hussain, S/o. Khaja Shakir Hussain, All R/o. H.No. 12-13-98,
Tarnaka, Secunderabad.
2. Muktharunnisa Begum, W/o. Late Khaja Nazir Hussain, All R/o. H.No. 12-1398, Tarnaka, Secunderabad.
3. Khaja Wajid Hussain, S/o. Khaja Nazir Hussain, All RUo. H.No. 12-13-98,
Tarnaka, Secunderabad.
4. t\Iohd. Ameen, S/o. Khaja Nazir Hussain, All R/o. H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad.
5. tt/ir Sattar Ali, S/o. Late tVlir Sadath Ali, All R/o. H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad.
6. Mir Hameed Ali, S/o. Late Mir Sadath Ali, All R/o. H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad.
7. Mir Muzzamil Ali, S/o. Late Mir Razack Ali, All R/o. H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad.
8. Mir Dastagir Ali, S/o. Mir lftekhar Ali, All R/o. H.No. 12-13-98, Tarnaka,
Secunderabad.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1.
Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District, At Hyderabad.
2. Revenue Divisional Officer, Hyderabad, East Division, Malakunta, Gosha
Mandal, Hyderabad.
3.
Tadeti Sai Reddy, S/o. Venkat Ram Reddy, R/o. Bairamalguda,
Saroorngar Mandal, (Case No. F11441812001) Ranga Reddy District.
4.
Edulakanti Narsimha Reddy, S/o. Narsi Reddy, Baramalguda Village,
Saroornagar Mandal, R.R. District.
5.
9.
Bltt!- Fe{dy, S/o. Bairamalguda Village, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga
Reddy
District.
6. Chakali Venkaiah, S/o_. Agaiah, (Case No. 441012001) R/o. Karmanghat
Village, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
7.
P. Ramanand Guptha, S/o. Gunnaiah Gupta, (Case No. F1l6055/2001)
R/o. Saroornagar Village and Mandal, R.R. Distribt.
8. V.V. Flaju, S/o. Ti rupathi
( Case_ No.
_F1l4S42t2OO1l R/o.
Baira mirlguda Village, s aroornagar
dal, Ranga Reddy District.
l.l
lmt lrevamma
@ Devakamma, (Case No.
-i 6051/2001) Wo.
Red d-y, Rro. xi'm i nb r, ii viiia
sd,
Rfllfl I :lm:f "
",JJi.;;'#',M andal,
ral
'olif fl l;lllx3.:,'0l,Ud's;,tii,i*;i,f"TJlf 'J.R:"oLlli;,'1t*ost2oo1l
11. Gajasimha Rao, S/o.
No. F1l4409/2001 ) R/o.
strict.
Karmanghat Village, Sa
12.Devamma. @ Devakam ma, W/o.
F1t1o1ol20o1\ R/o. Ka rmanghat Vil
District.
Redd v (Case No.
agaf M andal, R.R.
l3.Pindi Pulla Reddy, s/o. Venkat Re-ddy, (case No. F1l60s4/2001)
Bairamartguda Villige, Saroornagar man'riai-C.n-. District. --- "-vv !, R/o.
'|vv!
l4.Edulakanti Bal Reddy, S/o. Narsi Reddy (Case No. F1l43S5/2001)
R/o.
Bairamatguda Viilage, Saroornaga, Mindil) F]il oistrict
15.Edulakanti Lachma Reddy, s/o. Narsa Reddy (case No. F1l1133/2oo2t
R/o. Bair;rmatguda ViuageiSaroo.nigai irii'Jir,'n.n-.bliiiidt.' ' 'ee''ev-t
16.9. Ram Reddy, S/o. Narsi Reddy (Case No. F111134120021 FUo.
Karmaghat Villa-ge, saroornagar'MlnZat,'i.h-.bistrict
17.Darsi Laxma Reddv- s/o. Mara-Reddy, (case No. F1t4354t2002)
R/o.
Sultanvatva Viilage, Saroornagai Min?;tl A.-C.tistrict.
l8.Sama Yad Reddv. S/o. Mutha
_Be<lgy (Case No. F1l4538/2001) R/o.
Champapetviuasi',saroornasa?rian;A,h-ri-g-"nilai,'Ddtii;i--',."".
19.Sama Bal Redd y, S/o. Seetha Reddy, (Case No. F1l4539/200'il
R/o.
Champapet Vil lage, Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga
20. Sama
S/o. Yella
Saroornagar Mand E[
Case
y District.
No. F114353t2001) R/o.
Reddy District.
21.Sama Rami Reddv. S_/o. Bal
$edd-y (,Gase No. F1/4S43/2001) R/o.
Champaper Viflage,-Saroo.nagi. iviandil
i;;a Reddy District.
22. Seethamnrra
Wo. Yella Red dy, (Case No. F1 14544t2001 R/o.
Bairamalg uda Village, Sa roornagar Ma ndal, R.R.
D istrict.
)
" fliff!:'gl#fi;3llti3;f',j?l3li,!",{,33J}"aF.1/4t54s/2001) Rr/o champapet
* $iiilu::,t:itt}"""i* s/o {istaiah, (case No. F1t1ooat2oo2)Rr/o. champaper
25.Elimineti Rama Reddy, S/o. Kis-taiah, (Case
Champape:r Viltase, sii6ornisai M;a;i,,
---- No. F111008/2002) Rl/o.
26.Elimineti Buchi Reddv S/o. Jang-a Reddy, (Case
No. F1l1008/2002) R/o.
Cha mpapet Vltage, SSioornagai iiTi
no*i.",,,
"""
"'Xi:x,i:J:l\fi fi
"5s:Sli"?'1#itf, ,I"if"11,$A,"dsa;gl"?0e/2001)R/o.
28.Vennu Pratap, S/o. Yella neUav. ( Case No. F1l4351l2OO1l R/o.
Champapet Village, Saroornagar Ma-nhai , Ranga Reddy District.
29.Jakka Balamma, wo. Late Badaru shiva.ia.h, (case No. F1ff/loil2oo1l
R/o. champapet village, Saroornagar Mandat, hinga neaoy riiitiict.
Dismissed fordefault against RR 3 to 22,25,27to2g as per court order,
date 2911212010.
30.I. P.radeep Kumar S/o Late T. Ramanath Gupth_a, Aged about 70 years, occ.
Business and Agriculture Rl/o. Karmanghai, Siroornagar i!!v!
[Vlandaf,
rsvrr fiangi
- -'.'-r-'
Reddy District.
31.f.vidya Bhushan s/o Late T.Ramanath Guptha, Aged about 67 years, occ.
Business and Agriculture R/o. Karmanghit; Saroornagar ManOal, nangi
Reddy District.
"{,ffi l:isx&."ftl,",."]#3ift:?li,F,jiiii"s},%?1"#i,,ff 3"H?^*f,!?
Reddy District.
8R90, 31 and 32 impteaded as per c.o. dt. 13.09.2023 in tA No. 1 of
2022.
33. [oyg]q[on!q^Sy!l,qkar, S/o Late K. Sathaiah, ased 60 years, Occ Business,
Fl/o P.No...549, Vaidehi Nagar, Opp AilahaOici e;ndf, S'aGb' Nagar Kalan,
Vanasthalipuram, Ranga RedOy bjstrict.
Respondent No.33 is impleaded as per c.o. dt.21.o2.zo2s in lA. No.
1t2025.
34.5oyalakonda.Rqyi3.de1
[q!?r, S/o Late K.Babaiah, aged 55 years, occ pvt.
Employee, R/q
l.Np..e:t-238, ord Karmanghat Vitiigd, Near'G;;ohisiaire,
Saroornagar, R. R. District.
35.50yalakonda Raj.[rr?r,-^Q/o_Lglg K.Babaiah, aged 45 years, occ pvt.
Employee, R/q
[.Np..a:t-238, otd xarminghat'ViGge, Near Gandhi statue,
Saroornagar, R. R. District.
36.[oyalakonda Mahender.K^u11ar,_S1o Late K.Babaiah, aged 55 years, occ pvt.
Employee, R/q
l.Np..e:t-238, ord xarmangrriiVitijge, Near'c*ohiStrir6,
Saroornagar, R. R. District.
3T.Koyalakonda D"^rjgj,s/g Late K.Rgmtlru, aged 45 yeqrs, occ Govt.Emproyee,
R/o H.No.8-1-23?-, otd Karmanshit -Vrr"gll' rv"ri --G;;ahi Statue,
Saroornagar, R. R. District.
rf :^r.yr"dl,, |l"fiiio*l:,1l r?f io{i.p e a d e d a s pe r c. o. d t. 0 4 1 2.20 25 in
r
.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High
in the
Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, order or direction more particularly
in the nature of Writ of
certiorari and call for the records and quash the common order dated
3-3-2004
passed in Appeal case Nos. F114418t2001, F1t4537t20O1,
F116052t2001,
I
i
,I
441012001, F1 t605512001, F11454212001, 6051/2001 ,
F1t4548t2001,
F11440912001, F11101012001, F1 t6054t2001, F114355t20O1, F111133t2002,
F111 13412002, F1 1435412001, F1 t4638t20}1, F1 t453gl2o}1, F1 t435312001,
F114543120001, F11454412001, F11454512001, F1t1oo8l2oo2, F1t1o}gt2oo2,
F11435112001. and F11440712001 by the Joint Collector, Ranga Reddy District, in
confirming occupancy rights granted in favour of the Respondents by the
Revenue Divisional officer, East Division, Ranga Reddy District.
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
permit the pelitioners to effect the service of notices to the respondents in
substitute service through the daily newspapers circutated in the locatity in the
interest of justice in the above W.P.No.11O87 of 2OO4 pending disposal of the
above writ petition.
lA NO: 3 OF 20,21
Petition utnder Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filerl in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to set
aside the order dated 18.02.2011 made in the above writ petition W.p.No .111gl
of 2004, ln the interest of justice pending disposal of the above writ petition and
pass such other order or orders.
counsel for the Petitioner : sRt sRlNtvASA RAo purLURl
counsel for the Respondents No.i&2 : Ms.T.swETcHA, ASsr.Gp FoR REVENUE
counsel for the Respondents No.30 to 32 : sRl B.VENKAT RAMARAO
Counsel for the Respondents No.33 : SRI G.ARUN KUMAR
counsel for the Respondents No.34To37 : sRt p.pANDU RANGA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondents No.3TO2g :
The Court made the following: ORDER
r
I
;t
IN THE HIGH COT'RT F1OR THE STATE OF TEI"ANGAT{A
AT TTYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
IIIRIT PETITION
o.1 1087 of 2OO4
DATE: A+A2.20126
BETWEEN:
Khaja Faraz Hussain and
7 others
....Petitioners
AND
.Joint Collector, Ranga lReddy
district and 36 others.
Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri P.Srinivasa Rao, learned counsel for thc
petitioners, Ms.'l'.Srvetcha, learned Assistani Government
Pleader tbr Revenue for respondent Nos.I and 2; Sri l3.Venkat
Ramarao, learned counsel fcrr r-espondertt Nos.30 to 32,
Sri G.Arun Kumar, learned counscl for rcspondcnt No.33 and
penrsed the record. Despite service of notice, none appeared flor
other private respondents.
2.
This writ pctition is filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, u,ith the follouring prayer:"to issue a Writ, crctcr rlr directiorr rriore particularly in the
nature of Writ oi Ccrtioiari and call lci' tht: n:cords and quash
the Common order rlated 3.3.'2OO4 passcd in Appeal Case Nos.
r't I 4418l2OOr, Ft I 4537 l2OOI, Ft l6052l2OOt, 44tOl2OOt,
I',r l6ossl2oor, F1 l4s42l2oor, 6osl l2OO1, F\ l4s48l2OOt,
E rl4409l2OOr,
F1/ l0rOl2OOr,
Frl6Os4l2OOr,
t'tl4355l2OOr,
Frl4ss4l2oor,
F1l43s3l2OOr,
Ftl4s4sl2oor,
Ftlrt33l2Oo2, Ftltt34l2oo2,
Ftl4538l2OOt, Fl/4s39l2OOr,
Frl4543l2OOr, Ftl4s44l2OOr,
Frlroo8l2oo2, Frltoogl2oo2,
Fll4351l2OOl, and Fll4407l2OOl by the Joint Collector,
Ranga Reddy District, in confirming the occupancy rights
granted in favour of the Respondents by the Revenue Divisional
C'fficer, East Division, Ranga Reddy District and pass such other
order or orders this Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper in the
cr rcumstances of the case.."
Factual matrix (in brieff
3.
The petitioners claim to be the successors-in-interest of
late ArrLeena Bee Saheba, wife of late Khaja Altaf Hussain, who
was the original Inamdar of extensive agricultural lands
admeasuring approximately Ac.1964.OO Gts situated in various
survey numbers of Karmanghat, Bairamalguda, Sultanvalva and
Mirpet villages of Saroornagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
Respon<lent Nos.3 to 29 are private individuals in whose favour
the 2"d respondent-Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) granted
Occuparrcy Rights Certificates (ORCs) in respect of different
extents of the said lands under the relevant provisions of the
Inams Act.
4.
TLte record discloses that Ameena Bee Saheba, described
as the 'Mali lnamdar' of the subject lands, died in the year
1946. Upon her demise, the Nazim Atiyat Revenue Department,
Hyderabad, issued a Munthakab (Succession Certificate) in
.!"
?r'
Proceedings No.3897 dated 1lft Aban l3s8 Fasli (corresponding
to L948-49 A.D.), recognising her two sons, namely Khaja
shakir Hussain and Khaja Nasir l{ussain, and her daughter
Razia Sultana as'her lar,r,fur successors. 1'heir names were
accordingly entered as pattadars in the relevant revenue
records.
5.
Subsequently, Khaja Nasir Hussain died in 1916leaving
behind his widow and children; Razia sultana died in I9g0
leaving behind her sons; and Khaja Shakir Hussain died in
1995 leaving behind petitioner No.l. The petitioners assert that
they represent the tegal heirs of the said successors and thereby
claim interest in the subject Inam lands.
6.
It further emerges from the record that between the years
1975 and 1979, applications were filed before the 2nrl
respondent-RDo, functioning as the Inams Tribunal, by various
private individuals (respondent Nos.3 to 29 herein) seeking
grant of oRCs in respect of portions of the Inam lands on the
assertion of possession and cultivation. 'lhe applications were
instituted by impleading the original successors of the Inamdar
as respondents.
7.
Horvever, by that timc onc of the successors, namely
Khaja Nasir Hussain, had already expired, arrd no steps were
taken to bring his legat representatives on record. The
proce(:dings culminated in grant of oRCs in favour of the private
resporrdents during the period 1976 to 1988. The petitioners
conterLd that such orders \ /ere passed without notice to, or
participation of, the lawful legal representatives of the deceased
successors.
8.
l\ccording to the petitioners, they became aware of the
said pr-oceedings only in or about the year 2OOO, when certain
appealrs were preferred before the Land Reforms Appellate
Tribun,ll by some of the private respondents and notices were
issued to them.
9.
Thereafter, the petitioners filed a batch of appeals before
the lst respondentJoint Collector under Section 24 of the
Inams Act during the years 2OOl and 2OO2, challenging the
grant c,f ORCs or, inter alia, the ground that the original
proceedings were conducted against deceased persons without
impleading their legal heirs.
10. The Joint collector entertained the appeals and caused
notices lo be issued to the private respondents. Despite service,
including by way of paper publication, the private respondents
remaineC absent and were set ex parte.
11. Af[er hearing the petitioners, the Joint corlector, by
common order dated 03.o3.2004, dismissed all the appeals. The
principa. ground recorded in the impugned order was that the
)
appellants had failed to establish possession and cultivation as
on O 1. 1 I .1973 and that the appeals were preferred after
considerable lapse of time, which was held to be unreasonable.
L2. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioners have instituted the
present writ petition seeking issuance of a writ of Certiorari to
quash the common order dated 03.03.2004. During the
pendency of the writ proceedings, this Court directed the 2"d
respondent-RDO to produce the original records relating to the
grant of ORCs. The order sheet reflects that despite service of
such direction, the original records have not been produced. It
is in the aforesaid backdrop that the matter is presently
considered for adjudication.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioners
13. Learned counsel for the petitioners has advanced his
submissions as under:
i) That the entire proceedings before the 2rd
respondent-RDO (lnams Tribunal) are vitiated,
having been conducted against persons who were
no longer alive.
iil
That the applications for grant of ORCs were filed
by impleading, inter alia, Khaja Nasir Hussain, who
had died in 1976, and by proceeding without
bringing on record the l<:gal heirs of Razia Sultana.
Orders passed against deceased persons, it was
argued, are a nullity in the eye of law and uoid ab
initio.
iii) 'lhat thc petitioners, being the lawful successors,
were neither impleaded nor put on notice, resulting
in gross violation of the principles of natural justice.
The Joint Collector, while dismissing the appeals,
failed to examine this foundational jurisdictional
defect.
iv)
That the private respondents had played fraud upon
the Inams 'fribunal by suppressing material facts
relating to the death of the original parties and by
failing to disclose the existence of their legal heirs.
Fraud vitiates all solemn proceedings, and orders
obtained by suppression of material facts cannot be
permitted to stand. According to the petitioners,
they were kept unaware of the proceedings and
camc Lo knovn' ol thc grant of ORCs only in or about
the year 2000.
v) That the petitioners had produced before the
appe llate authority the Munthakab (Succession
Certificate) issued by the Nazim Atiyat Revenue
Department in 1358 Fasli, evidencing the lawful
devolution of Inam rights upon the successors of
the original Inamdar. 'r'he Joint collector, however,
dismissed the appeals on the ground that the
appellants had not established possession as on
o1.11 .r973.
vi)
That the burden of proving lawful possession as on
the date of vesting lay upon the claimants seeking
occupancy rights and not upon the Inamdars or
their successors. The appellate authority
misdirected itself in shifting the burden onto the
petitioners.
vii)
That the appeals were filed immediately upon
acquiring knowledge of the impugned orders. Since
the petitioners were ncver impleaded in the originar
proceedings, the plea of limitation could not be
invoked to defeat their substantive rights. It was
argued that where the foundational orders are void,
considcrations ol delay and raches cannot cure the
defect.
viii)
Attention of the court was also drawn to the failure
of the 2nd respondent to produce the original
records despite specific directions issued during
the
pendency of the writ petition. That an adverse
inference ought to be drawn against the
respondents, as the records, if produced, would
have demonstrated the procedural irregularities and
absence of jurisdictional findings.
ix) That the RDO had failed to record a categorical
finding regarding possession of the claimants as on
01.11.1973, which is a sine qua non for grant of
occupancy rights under the Inams Act. Reliance on
stereotvpecl affidavits, allegedly filed without proper
authority, was also assailed as indicative of nonapplication of mind.
Submissions on behalf of respondents
L4.
Lr:arned Governm<:nt Pleader for Revenue appearing for
respondent Nos.l and 2, supported the impugned order and
submitted as under:
i) That the appeals bcfore the Joint Collector were filed after
an inordinate and unexplained delay ranging from nearly
15; to 25 years from the dates of grant of ORCs. The
ap,pellate authority was justified in declining to interfere
at such a belated stage, particularly when rights had
ac:rued in favour ol' the private respondents over a
co:esiderable period.
)
I
l
;
t'
ii) That the Joint collector had correctly observed that the
appellants failed to establish possession and cultivation
as on the crucial date of 0l.l1.1973. Since the statutory
scheme under the lnams Act conl-ers occupancy rights
upon persons in possession on the date of vesting, the
petitioners, not being in possession, could not legitimately
assail the grant of certificates.
iii) That the proceedings were of considerable antiquity and
that the records might not be readily traceable. However,
no specific explanation was forthcoming for the failure to
comply with the directions issued by this Court for
production of the original files.
15. I have taken note of the respective submissions urged and
the material on record.
Consideration by this Court
16. In the present case, the material on record discloses that
certain proceedings culminating in grant of ORCs were
conducted impleading Khaja Nasir [{ussain, who had admittedly
died in 1976, and without bringing on record the legal heirs of
Razia Sultana. Orders appear to have been passed subsequent
to their demise, without substitution of their legal
representatives. This strikes at the very root of the jurisdiction
exercised by the Tribunal. The adjudication of rights affecting
l0
the estate of deceased persons, in the absence of their legal
heirs, r'enders the resultant orders void.
17. It is trite that any judicial or quasi-judicial proceeding
institu-ed or continued against a person who is dead, rvithout
bringing on record his or her legal representatives, is a nullity.
An ord,:r so passed is void ab initio and non est in the eye of law.
Such a defect is not a curable irregularity but a foundational
jurisdic:tional infirmity.
18. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Gurnam Singh a.
Gurba<:ha,n Kaurr, has held as under:
l'2. The law on the point is well settled. On the death of a
pirrt,v to the appeal. if no application is made bv the part].
concerned to the appeal or bv the legal representatives of the
dr:ceased on whom the riqht to sue has devolved for
strbstitution of their names in place of the deceased part_r,
w; thin 90 davs from the date of death of the partv. such
atrrpeal abates automatically on expirv of 9O davs from the
de.te of death of the partv. In other words, on 91st day, there
is no appeal pending before the Court. It is "dismissed as
at,ated".
2 I . ...This principle, in our considered opinion, squarell
applies to this case because it is a settled principle of law that
thldgSlgg_pApge!_bJ_q court for or aqainst a dead person is a
"nqlliql (see IV. Jagaram Reddy v. LAOIN. Jagarant
Re'ddg v. LAO, (19791 3 SCC 5781 , Ashok Transport
Ag'ency v. Awadhesh
Kumar [Ashok
Transporl
Agencgv. Awadhesh Kumar, (1998) 5 SCC 5671 and Amba
Bci v. Gopal[Amba Baiv. Gopal, (2001) 5 SCC 57Ol ).
(emphasis supplied)
19. It is to be noted that the Joint Collector, while exercising
appellatr: jurisdiction, has not adverted to this fundamental
t
lzotzy t:t scc 414
II
defect. The impugned order is conspicuously silent on the effect
of proceedings having been conducted against deceased
persons. Failure to consider a jurisdictional issue of such
magnitude vitiates the appellate order.
2o. The Joint Collector dismissed the appeals principally on
the ground that they were filed nearly two decades after the
original orders. While it is true that statutory remedies must be
pursued within a reasonable time, the concept of 'reasonable
time' cannot be applied in isolation, without reference to the
facts of the case.
2L.
The petitioners have consistently asserted that they were
never impleaded in the proceedings before the RDO and had no
notice of the grant of ORCs, and that the_\i came to know of the
orders only in the year 2000, whereupon they filed the appeals
without undue delay. This explanation has neither been
specilically disbelieved nor rebutted by any contrary material.
22. Further, where an order is alleged to be void, particularly
for having been passed against deceased persons without notice
to their legal heirs, limitation must necessarily be reckoned from
the date of knowledge, as a void order does not acquire validity
merely by passage of time. The Joint Collector, instead of
examining the plea of date of knowledge and the underlying
jurisdictional defect, dismissed the appeals on a generalized
i
!
i
g
I'I
l
q
t2
groun(l of delay, an approach which, in the facts of the present
case, t:annot be sustained.
23. )uring the pendency of the writ petition, this Court
specifi:all-r' dircctcd Lhc 2,,d respondent to produce the original
recordr; pertaining to the grant of oRCs. Despite such direction,
the records have not been placed before this court, nor has any
satisfar:tory explanation been offered for their non-production.
24. 'Ihe 2nd respondent, being the custodian of public
records', is under a statutory and constitutional obligation to
preserve arrd produce them when required by a court of law. A
vague olea that ttre recclrds are old or untraceable, ,uvithout
support.ing material, cannot be readily accepted.
25. [n these circumstances, this court is constrained to draw
an adv:rse inference that, if the original records had been
producr'd, they would not have substantiated the legality of the
impugn:d proceedings. The failure to place the original files
before this court fortifies the petitioners' case that the
pro..:eed. ngs w'ere undertaken without notice to the legal heirs
and without due compliance with the mandatory statutory
requirenrents.
26. Under the scheme of the Inams Act, grant of an ORC is
conditional upon the applicant establishing lawful possession of
the Inanr land as on the date of vesting, namery 01.11.1gr3.
l3
such possession constitutes a jurisdictional fact, and its
determination is a sine qua norl for valid exercise of power by
the Tribunal.
27.
However, from the material placed on record, it is not
apparent that the RDo recorded any clear or reasoned {inding,
based on objective evidence, regarding the claimants'possession
as on the crucial date. The appellate authority, instead of
examining whether the claimants had discharged their statutory
burden, misdirected itself by focusing on the alleged failure of
the appellants to prove their own possession. The enquiry before
the Tribunal was required to centre on the entitlement of the
claimants under the statute, and not on the possession of the
lnamdars' successors. This fundamental misdirection renders
the appellate order legally unsustainable.
Conclusion
24. For the foregoing reasons, this court is of the considered
view that the impugned common order dated 03.03.2004 cannot
be sustained. The original proceedings before the RDo suffer
from a fundamental jurisdictional deflr:ct, having been
conducted against deceased persons without impleading their
legal representatives. The dismissal of the statutory appeals on
the sole ground of delay, rvithout addressing the plea of nullity
and date of knowledge, is lcgally untenabre. The failure to
produc,l original record's, despite specific
Court, u'arrants drarving o[ an adverse
directions of this
inference' Further' the
absenc:o[acleardeterminationofpossessionason0l.ll.l9T3
vitiatesthegrantofoRCs.oncethefoundationalproceedings
arehetdtobcvitiatcd,theconsequentialcertificatescannot
survive . Thc matter requires
reconsideration by the competent
authoritY in accordance with law'
The common
29. /\ccordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed'
l"t respondentJoint
order datcd 03'03'2004 passed by the
Collectorinthebatchofappealcasesisherebyquashed.
Conserluerrtly,theordersofthe2.drespondent-RDogranting
oRCsinfavourofrespondentNos.3to33aresetaside.The
matter is remanded to the 2nd respondent-RDo
for fresh
enquir-vanddisposalinaccordancewithlau,.Theauthority
shallissuetl<lticetoailthepetitioners,beingthelegalheirsof
private respondents,
the or.iginal Inamdar els rvell aS to the
affordreasonableopportunityofhearing,andrecordspecilic
findin3sorralljurisdictionalfacts,includingpossessionaSon
01.11|gT3.Theexerciseshallbecompletedwithinaperiodof
order'
from the date of receipt of a copy of this
six (6) months
The ()hie[ secretary, Revenue Department,
shall ensure that
resporrsibilityisfixe<lforthenon-productionofrecordsdespite
l5
judicial direction and shall take appropriate action in
II
I
tt
t
I
accordance with law.
I
I
I
i
i
i
consequently, miscellaneous petitions pending if any shall
stand closed. No order as to costs.
!
i
i
i
i'
i
I
That Rule Nisi has been made absolute as above.
Witness THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH, on this
Friday, The Twenty Seventh Day Of February Two Thousand And Twenty Six
SD/. K. BHAVANI SWAMY
ANT REG
t
I
//TRUE COPY//
i
N OFFICER
l
To,
1. The Joint Col,lector, Ranga Reddy District, At
2. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Hyderabad, East
Malakunta, Gosha
Mandal, Hyderabad.
3. The Chief Secretary, Revenue Department, Secretariat, Telangana State.
(As directed)
4. One CC to SRI SRINIVASA RAO PUTLURI, Advocate. [OPUC]
5. Two CCs to GP FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana.
lourl
6. One CC to SRI B.VENKAT RAMARAO, Advocate. IOPUC]
7. One CC to SRI G.ARUN KUIVIAR, Advocate. [OPUC]
8. One CC to SRI P.PANDU RANGA REDDY, Advocate. IOPUC]
9. Two CD Copies.
BSK
GJP
!
HIGH COURT
DATED i2710212026
STATE
t
O
(J
*
ORDER
WP.No.11087 of 2004
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
t
$ t\s
{fi
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review