Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3383 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALTSHETTY
WRIT PETITION NO: 22177 OF 2025
Between:
1. Kallem Balvanth Reddy, S/o.Late Seetha Ram Reddy, Aged about 58 years,
Occ.Business, R/o.6-34, Balapur Village, Balapur Mandal, Ranga Reddy
District.
2. Kallem Yella Reddy, S/o.Late Narayan Reddy, Aged about 55 years' Occ.
Business Rl/o.Villa No.1 12, Nakshatra Colony, Balapur Village, Ranga Reddy
District.
...,.PETITIONERS
AND
. The State of Telangana, Rep.by its Principal Secretary Municipal
Administration and Urban Development Department Secretariat, Hyderabad,
Telangana State.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Jalpally Municipality, Jalpally, Ranga Reddy
District, Telangana State.
3. The Town Planning Officer, Jalpally Municipality, Jalpally, Ranga Reddy
District, Telangana State.
4. The Hyderabad Metropoplitan Development Authority, (HMDA), Rep.by its
Secreteary, Swarnajayanthi Commercial Complex, Ameerpet, Hyderabad 500 038 Telangana State.
5. The City Planning Officer, Shamshabad Zone, Hyderabad Metropolitan
Developmnet Authority, Ranga Reddy District.
6. The Metroppolitan Commissioner / Director (Planning) - ll, I lyderabad
Metropolitan Development Authority Swarna Jayanthi Complex, Ameerpet,
Hyderabad.
7. The District Registrar, Prasanth Nagar, lDA. Kukatpally. Ranga Reddy
District.
8. The Sub-Registrar, Champapet S.R.O.. Ranga Reddy District.
t-
I M/s. Snehitha Builders Private Limited., Rep.by its Managing Director Sri
V5mireddy Narasimha Reddy. S/o.Linga Reddy Age 66 years. Oce. Business,
R/o. H.No.3-2-87013, VNR Complex, Station Road. Kacheguda, Hyderabad.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of
Certiorari to call for the records from the 6th respondent authority declaring the
action of Respondent No.4 to 6 in approving the final layout over the land in Sy. Nos.
vitt
'145 situated at Balapur and Mandal, Ranga Reddy District in favour of M/s. Snehitha
Builders Private limited. i.e. Respondent No.9 vide Letter No.
Part025152lSMD/LfNGF112019, dated 28.09.2024 as arbitrary, illegal,
unconstitutional, violation of principles of natural justice and contrary tothe
proceed ings videProc. No.2335/S HZPLGIHMD N2020, dated 06. 1 2.202 1 issued by
Respondent No.4 and consequential relief to revokethe approved layout, dt..
28.09.2024 in favor of Respondent No.9 withthe further directions to the Respondent
Municipal Authorities i.e.Respondent No. 2 and 3 to demolish the illegal structures
over theproperty to an extent of Ac.348-35 Gts in Survey Nos.144 and 145 situated
at Balapur Village and Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
|.A.NO:1 OF 2025
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the final layout pending disposal of the writ petition.
LA.NO:2 OF 2025
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the Sub RegistrariDistrict Registrar and l0 (INSPECTOR GENERAL OF STAMPS)
not to entertain any sale deed or sale deeds of plots which form part of final layout
which is subject matter of the writ petition and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI C.HANUMANTHA RAO
Gounsel for the Respondent No.1 : GP FOR MCPL ADMN AND URBAN DEV
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 & 3 : SRI J.RAVINDER REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.4 to 6 : SRI V.NARASIMHA GOUD
Counsel for the Respondent No.9 : SRI D.PRAKASH REDDY' SENIOR
COUNSEL REPRESENTING SRI D.RAGHAVENDRA RAO
The Court made the following ORDER
IN I'HE HIGH COTJR'T FOR 1'TI]] STATE OF TELANCANA AT
IIYDERABAT)
HON'BI,E SRI JUSTICE LAXMI NARAYANA ALISHETTY
WRI'l'PE-lt'flON No.22177 of 2025
Dated:17 .06.2026
Between:
Kal lem lJalvtnt h Redd.,'
and unother
Pelitioners
And
'[
The State of elangonu. reptd., hv
i t.s Princ ipo l Secretary
.
Munit'i1tal ldnt in istrution & Develctpment
Deportmenl. l!.vderabd and ei,qht others.
Respondents
ORDER:
-l
his \[Irit I)etition is fllcd to declare the action of respondent Nos.4
to 6 in approvin!, 15" final lal,oLrt in lcspect of the Iand in S1,.No.1,15
situatcd at [3alapur Village and Mandal. Ranga Reddy District. in favour
ol re'spondent n\o.9. r'rrle letter No.PartO25 I 52/SMD/L1' ltJ6ll I l2ol9.
dated 18.09.102-1. as illcgal. arbitrary and in violation ol principles of
natural justice and lbr conscquential rclief
2.
fleard Sri ('hava Ilanr.rntantha Rao, Ieamed counsel for petitioners,
Sri J.Ravindcr Rcddr,. lcarncd Standing Counsel for respondent Nos.2
and.l. Sri V.\a.asinrlta (ioud. Iearncd Standing Counscl for respondent
LNA, J
l,l/P No.22 l7t o1 2025
Nos.4 to 6 and Sri D,Prakash Reddy, leamed senior counsel appearing
for Sri D.Raghavendra Rao, leamed counse l-on-record for respondent
No.9.
3. tn nurshell the facts of the case, as averred in the writ affidavit'
are that petitioners are the legal successors ol late Kallem Bat Reddy-
owner of land admeasuring Acs'348.35 gts in Sy.Nos 144 and 145 of
Balapur village and Mandal, Ranga Reddy District (hereinafter referred
to as 'the subject property'); that the name oi late Kallem Bal Reddy
was reflected as pattadar/land holder in the revenue records (Sesala
Pahani) upto the year 1963 64; and that the narne of one Kadari
Venkaiah was recorded as a protected tenant.
3.1. White so, the Tahsildar issued proceedings vide File No'
P,1563llg87 dated 20.08.1987, wherein names of 12 unrelated persons
are shown as protected tenants besides the legal heirs of Kadari
Venkaiah; that aggrieved thereby, the tegal heirs of Kadari Venkaiah
filed Appeal No.F215036/2006 (renur.nbere<l as F2/5402120 l3), which
was dismissed on the ground ol limitation; that challenging the same,
the legat heirs of Kadari Venkaiah filed CRP.No.436l2008 before this
LNA, J
,l/P.No.22 l1: of 2a25
Courr. which stood allowed and the matter was remanded to the Joint
Collector tbr licsh ad.judication; that questioning thc said order, the
protected tenanrs filed Special Leave Petitions, vrde SLP(C ).Nos.573 7,
5738 and 5739 of2() l4 against respondent No.9 and others along with
an intervention application and the Hon'ble Supreme Court, by order
dated 17.03.2015, directed the Joint Collector to afford an opportunity
of hearing to all parties. consider the documents produced by them and
then pass appropriate ordersl that pursuant thereto, the Joint Collector
passecl order daLed 31.08.2018 in File No.F2l540212013, cancelling the
alleged surrender of lenanc\ rights; that aggriered thereby, the
petitioners (landlords) Iiled CRP.No.l9l7 of 2019, wherein inrerirn
order dated 21.08.20 l9 was granted not to conduct survey over the
subject property lor the purposc oftaking away the sanre in terms of the
order dated 31.08,20 I8 passed by the Joint Collecror; and that the
protecled tenants also filed CRP.No.7212019, wherein this Court passed
interirr order dated 17. 122019 staying operation of the order dated
I I .08.10 l8 passcd bv thr. Joint Collector.
3.2
It u,as lurther ar.erred that circumventing the afuresaid orders of
this Court, third parries creatcd illegar sare deeds over the subject
-
I-N A, J
ll/P.No.22l7t'ol 2025
property and the Tahsitdar, Balapur Mandal, confirmed the surrendering
of rights of protected tenants in favour of respondent No'9' vlde
proceedingsinFileNos.Bl|386/21dated28'01.2022,13179|12019,
dated27.07.2019,andBl79220l9,dated2l'07'2}lgandinalltheWrit
Petitionsfiledbytheprotectedtenantschallengingthesaidproceedings,
vide WP.Nos.21063, 22795, 25466 and 39449 ol 2022' this Court
granted interim order suspending the aloresaid proceedings of the
Tahsildar.
3.S.Itisfurtheraverredthatinpursuanceoftheinterimorders
passed by this Court, the subject property has been included in the
prohibitory properties list. Despite the same, respondent No'9
misrepresented the facts and obtained technical approval for layout'
ttide
Permit No.00009 I /LO/PIg/HM D A12020, dated 25'08'2020'
3.4. T'he petitioners further avened that respondent No'9 has also
obtained final layout approval lor open plots and a clubhouse
(stilt + 4
floors) in Sy.No. 145/1, vide letter No.Part-02i 52lSMD/LTru6lH12019
dated 28.09.2024. Aggrieved thereby' the petitioners, being
the legal
LNA, J
ll/ P. No )2
l:- ol 2l))5
heirs of Kallem llal Reddy'-original landlord. filed the presenr wril
petlt ton
1. [-eamed counsel 1br the petitioners submitted that the peritioners
are the pattadars and absolute owners ol the subject property, being the
legal heirs ol late Kallem Bal Reddy, whose name was reflected as
pattadar/landh o lder in the Sesala Pahani as well as in the revenue
records upto 1963 64. and that there is no dispute with regard to their
o\\,ncrship oVer Acs.3.+8.35 grs in Sy.Nos. l44 & 145. He lur-r.her
submitted that respondcnt No.9, without an) lawful ritle or authoritv,
obtained lay'out permission lrom HMDA by playing fraud,
misrepresenting and deliberately suppressing the material facts, vL., the
subject property bcing notified in prohibited properties list under
Section 22-A of the Registration Act, 1908, pendency of disputes as
regartls the titie and tenancy over the subject proper-ty, pendency of
several CRPs and Writ [)ctitions filed in respect of the subject property
and also pendencl, of the connected proceedings pending before the
revenue authorities, and as such, the layout permission is liable to be
cance lled
LNA, J
lv P. No 22177 of2025
4.1
.
Learned counsel lor petitioners submitted that since respondent
No.9 obtained the layout approved by playing fraud, the same is vitiated
in law. In support of his submission, he relied upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in S. P,Chengalvaraya Naidu v' lagannatht
and A.V.Papayya Sastry v- Government of A'f ', wherein it is
categorically hetd that fraud vitiates att judicial acts, irrespective of
whether the same are in personam or in rem.
4.2. Learned counsel for petitioners further submitted that
verification of clear and undisputed title is mandatory before grant of
layout approval, and the HMDA lailed to discharge this statutory
obligation cast on it by issuing layout approval without verifying the
revenue records and the entries in prohibitory list and also ignoring the
pendency of various litigations with regard to the subject property' He
lurther submitted that the IIMDA erred in not exercising the power
under Section 22 ol the IIMDA Act and revoking the final approved
Iayout granted to respondent No.9.
4.J. Learned counsel lor the petitioners further submitted that since
respondent No.9 has no valid right or title over the subject property, the
'"rsga 1r1 scc r
' zoo7 lt) scc zzr
LNA,I
W P. No.2)
t?7 ol 2025
sale deeds cxccuted b1, it in favour of third parties ha\,e no effect and in
support of the said submission, he relied upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Apex ('ourt in K.Gopi Vs. Sub-Registray'.
4.4.
Learned counsel further asserted that since the subject property
is included in prohibitor-v list, the same bars the statutory authorities
concemed from entertaining anr registration or sranting developmental
permission in respecr of the subject property until the prohibition is
removed. He f'urther subrritted that the doctrine of lis pendens under
Section 52 o1'the Transfer of Properly Act prohibits creation of third-
partr 1ig[15 in respect of the property during the pendency ofdisputes in
relation thereto.
,1.5.
I Ie llrthcr submitted that the proceedings dated27.07.20t9 and
28.01.2022. issued bv the Tahsildar, purporting to accepr surrendering
of protected lcnanc) rights b;- the alleged third parlies in lavour of
respondent \o.9 and deleting the names ol the legal heirs of Kadari
Venkaiah lrom the then existing PT register, are wholly without
jurisdiction since the tenancy dispute was already sub judice belore this
Coun in CRI,.Nos.72 and l9l7 ol 20 19. and the alleged surrender of
-r,'\x€nc)
rights by third parties in la'our of respondent No.9 was not
- 2025 SCC ONLTNt
SC 740
LNA, J
lYP. No.22177 ol 2025
lawful. He further submitted that respondent No.9, having knowledge
that the subject tand was in prohibitory list, pendency of litigations with
regard to tenancy rights and the interim orders granted by this Court in
CRP.No.72 ol 2019 and l9l7 of 2019, cannot claim to be a bona fide
purchaser; that the continuation of development or construction
activities by respondent No.9 in the subject property will lead to
multipticity of proceedings, creation of irreversible third-party rights,
and cause irreparable loss to the petitioners' legitimate rights and by
application of doctrine of lis pendens, no legal rights are said to be
transferred fiom respondent No.9 to the third parties.
5.
By advancing the aforesaid arguments, learned counsel for the
petitioners prayed to allow the Writ Petition.
6. In support of his contentions, leamed counsel for petitioners placed
reliance on the following judgments:-
l. S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath
2. A.V. Papayyo Sastry) v. Governmenl ofA,P
3. K.Gopi v. Sub-Registrar
LNA J
1,1/
P. No 2211' of 2a2 5
4. Shivshankaro and onr v. H.P. Vedavyssa Char4
5, State ofPunjab ond onr v. Gurdial Singh and orss
6. State of ,1P and ars r'. ,\. Autlikesava Reddl' and ors6
7. Jagmittar Sain Bhagat and ors v. Director, Health Services,
Haryuna'
8. Order dated 27.12.2022 passed in ll/rit Appeat No.t57 of2023
9. Ramokant Ambalsl Choksi v. Hqrish Ambalal and orss
10. Ramesh Chand (D) thr. Lrs v. Suresh Chand and anre
. In S. P,Chengalvaraya Naidu's case (cited supra), the Hon'ble
Supreme C ourl obserr,cd thus:
''The principle ol ".finalit.t of litigotion" cannot
be pressed Io the
extent o-f such an ahsurdin that it becomes an engine offraud in
rhe hands o./'dislnttest litigants. The c.ourts of !aw c,re meant .lbr
onporting justi(e between the parlies. One who (omes to lhe
courl. mltst conte titl't cleon hartds. lYe are constrained to sa1,
thol ntore o.fien than not. process of lhe court is being abused
Prope rn'-grab bc rs, tt:tx- cvaders. bank-loa n-dodgers and other
unscru pt!l()1t.t pcr.\on.\ .fi-om crll walk.s of lifc ./ind the cottrt -
proce.\.t (r cony(nienl lever to retoin tlte illegal-gainS
'2023 Lrve Law (SC) 261
' rgao (z) scc +zr
zooz 1t'1 scc zzt
-,'-zor:1r01 scc r:o
u
2024 tNSC 913
2025 tNSC 1059
-
LNA.,I
trP No.22177 o{ 2025
indefinitety. We have no hesitation to say thal a person, whots
case is based on falsehood, has no right to approach the court'
He can be summarily tht own out at any stage of the litigation".
ln A.V.Papayya Sastry's case (cited supra), the Hon'ble Supreme
Couft observed thus
"
lt is well settled principle of Law lhal if anv .iudgtnent or order
is obtained by fraud, it cannot be said to be o judgment or order
in law. Before three centuries, Chief Justice Edward Coke
proclaimed;
"Fraud avoids alljudicial acts, ecclesiastical or temporal"
It is thus settled proposition of law that a iudgment, decree
or order oblained by playing fraud on the Court, Tribunal or
Authority is a nulliry^ and non est in lhe eye of law Such a
judgment, decree or order by the Jirst Court or by the finaL Court
has to be treated as nullitv bv everv Court, superior or inferior'
It can be challenged in an1' Cotrrt, at any time' in appeal'
revi.sion, v,ril or even in collateral proceedings
Fraud nta)' be deJined as on act of deliberate deception with
the design oJ'sectrring some unfair or undeserved benefit by
taking undue advantage of another' ln fraud one gains at the
loss if another. Even mosl solemn proceedings stand vitiated {
they are actualed b1'fraud. Fraud is thus an extrinsic collateral
act which vitiales all judicial acts, whelher in rem or in
personam. The principle of finality of litigation' cannot be
stretched to lhe extent of an absurdity that it can be utilized as
"
an engine ofoppression b.v' dishonest and fraudulent litiganls'
ln K,Gopi's case (cited supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court as held
that.'.- -..
LNA, J
WP i\io 22 l1: of 2025
" l he regi.stt,ring
olfitet r.s not toncerned v,ith the title het(l by
Ihe eyecutdtlt. He has no atljudicaron,power to dccide whether
the execliant has any title.
... Once the r('gistering authority is satisfiecl thot the parf ies to
the document are present before him and the y;arties aclmit
exe.Ltttotl thereo/' before him, subject to making procedural
cr:tntpliance.s Lts narruled above, rhe document mltsl he
registered.
.. .Tlp execution and registration o/ a clocumt,nt have the
e//icr of rron-;lert.rng onlt those rights, i.[ ant,, that rhe execLttant
po.r.rd.rses lJ tlte e.recutunt hos no right, title, or inleresl in the
properh'. the rt'gi.stered document connot eJfect on.r lransfer.
l0
In the case ol- Shivshankoro ond onr's case (cited supra) the
Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:
'It ts a well-nrgh settled posltion that v,herever
Tp Act s nor
applicable, such principle in the saicl provision of the said Act.
v hich i.s hast'tl on iu.rti(.e. eqttin, and goocl conscience
is
opplitcrble in o eiven sintilot circtrntston.,e, like Cottrt sale ett..
7'rans./ir oJ p().t.\cs.tiot1 p(ndente lite vilt olso be tran-sfer o/
properfi' wtthin the meaning of Section 52 and, th,zrefore, the
itnporr of Section 52 of the TP Act is that i,f there is ctny transfer
o/' righr in irnnoyable propertt. durrng rlrc pendency of a suit
strch trunsfer v ill be non e.\t it1 the et,e of low if it wiil adversel.l,
al/icr the intercst of the other party to the suit in the propery,
concerned. I{e mu.t hasten to add that the effect of Se,ction
52 is
-
L2
LNA, J
WP.No 22177 of 2025
that the right of the successftrl partf in the litigalion in regard to
lhat proper$'vould not be aJfeaed by the alienation' but it does
not mean that as againsl the transferor the lransaction is
invalid. "
I
l.
Per contra, learned Senior Counsel appearing for respondent No 9
submitted that the petitioners, who claim to be successors to the subiect
property, have deliberately and willlully suppressed the crucial fact that
their family had already alienated their limited l/l5th share in the subject
property.
11.1. Learned senior counsel, in support of his submission' has
brought to the notice of this Court the registered Agreement of Sale-
cum-General Power of Atlorrrey with possession vide Document
No.10954/2006 dated 15.05.2006 for Acs.9.37 gts in Sy'No'144, and
document No. 13750/2006 dated 29.06.2006 for Acs l3'13 gts in
Sy.No. 145, executed by the petitioners, (shown as Vendor Nos 5 and
19), along with other lamily members representing their branch' in
favour of third parties and the petitioners having received total sale
consideration, delivered possession of the subject propefty to the
vendees. Thus, the petitioners are estopped from asserting any right,
title or interest over the lands covered under the aforesaid deeds, which
L,\ 1 .J
ll/P No )) l-) o1 2025
includes the land covered under the HMDA approved layout and hence,
the rvrit petition is liable to be dismissed at the threshold for want of
locus stctndiolthe petitioners as l,u,ell as on the ground of suppression of
material lacts.
ll,l.
[.earned senior counscl turther subrnitted that the present
Writ Petition raises disputed questions of title, or,,,nership and
possession in rcspect of the subject property extending over a period of
nearlv ser,en decades and such issues cannot be adjudicated in writ
proceedings under Article 226 and can only be decided by a competent
civil Court after recording evidence and therefore, on this ground also,
the writ petition is nor maintainable.
I 1.3.
He lurther submitted that the bona fide third party plor
purchasers lrom respondent No.9. who have commenced construction in
the subject property! strictly in accordance w.ith the pcrmission granted
by the competent authorities, are necessary and proper parties to the /ls,
as an1 order passed in their absence rvould directly anrl adversely. affect
their vested rights. llence, the writ petition is liable to be dismissed lor
non-.io indcr of nccessun partics.
-..-
-
I,N A. .I
WP.No.22lt7 of 2025
11.4. He further submitted that the impugned final approved layout
dated 28.09.2024 was granted by HMDA only after the subject properry
was deleted from the prohibitory list, which was the sole basis lor
passing ofthe abeyance order dated 06.12.2021, earlier thereto.
12.
Learned senior counsel has drawn the attention of this Court to
the Undertaking, dated 26.09.2024, given by respondent No.9
specifically stating that it will indemniff and compensate the HMDA
for any loss, damages or liabilities in the event of passing any adverse
orders by the Court in the pending cases, including CRP.No.l9l712019
filed by the petitioners herein. Thercfore, the irnpugned final layout
approval is neither illegal nor arbitrary and the same is issued in
accordance with law. The petitioners have failed to produce a single
document evidencing their possession over the land in Sy.Nos. 144 and
145. Hence, on the aloresaid grounds, the writ petition, being devoid of
merits, is liable to be dismissed.
12.1. Leamed Standing Counsel lor respondent Nos.4 to 6 submitted
that the IIMDA had accorded dlaft layout approval for 747 plots,
consisting of 136 housing plots, open spaces, and a clubhouse area in
LNA,,]
WP.No.)2177 o[ 2025
the Iand situated in Sy,.No. 145/P, Balapur Village, admeasuring
3,43.864.92 square merers, r'ide Application No. 0251 52/SMDll,TlU6/
HI\{I),\i160620 I 9 and Lal,our Permir No. 00009 I /LCt/PlglllMD A12020
dated 10.09.2020. lhar subsequently, on receiving objections lrom
Kadari Aniaiah and others. claiming protected tenancy rights over the
said sr.rn,e)' number, detailed hearings were conducted and the
documents produced by all parties were examined, and the proceedings
dated 06.11.2021, werc issued keeping the final approval of the layout
in abcyancc until disposal of the related court cases and deletion of the
sub.iect lancl 1l'orn thc prohibitory list.
12.2.
l-eamed Standing Counsel further submitted that some of the
protccted tenants filed alfidavits belore the I'IMDA as well as before the
'fahsildar
surrendering their protected tenancy rights in favour of
respondent No.9. which were confirmed vide Proceedings No.
Bi13861202l dated 28.01 .2022, and the said persons also withdrew rhe
objections pcnding bcfore thc llMDA. Further, based on the letter dated
27.10.2.022, of the Sub-Registrar, Champapet, inlorming that ther.e were
no prohibitor",'- orders on S;-.No. 145 i.e., subject survey number, and that
accordingll,. the said Survev number was deleted from the prohibitorv
.-
I,NA,J
W P. No.22lt 7 ol 2025
Watch Register, the HMDA issued the final approval of the layout on
28.09.2024
12.3. Learned Standing Counsel further submitted that the petitioners
have not impleaded the bona fide purchasers/third-party plot owners,
who are necessary and proper parties and as such, the writ petition is not
maintainable lor non-joinder of necessary parlies, The draft layout was
never cancelled or revoked; it was merely kept in abeyance, pending
clarification on protected tenancy claims. Once HMDA was satisfied
about the prima facie title, and in the absence of any stay, injunction,
status quo order, or other prohibitory direction binding HMDA, the
respondent authorities were statutorily obligated to process the
application under Section 22 of the I{MDA Act. As on the date of
lssuance of final approved layout, dated 28.09.2024. there existed no
tegal impediment preventing HMDA from issuing the same and
therefore, the Writ Petition is Iiable to be dismissed
I
3. This Court gave its earnest consideration to the submissions
advanced by the learned Counsel for petitioners as well as leamed
Senior Counscl lor respondent No.9 and learned Standing Counsel for
1,7
LNA, J
WP.No.22l77 of 2025
respondent Nos,4 to 6 and perused the entire material available on
record
14. The petitioners allege that respondent No.9 obtained the layout
approvals by' suppressing the pendency ol various Iitigations and
prohibitory orders. and relied upon the principles laid down in S.P"
Chengalvaraya Naidu's case (cited supra) and A.V. Papayyo Sastry's
case (cited s upra/ wherein it was held that fraud vitiates alljudicial and
admin istratir.'e acts.
15. A careful examinarion of the record reveals that the HMDA had
initially kept the trnal approval of the layout ln abeyance through
proceedings dated 06.12.202 I, on the grounds rhat the subjcct property
is in prohibitorv list and that this Courl in CRP.No.72 of 2019, vide
orders dated 21 .02.2019, has granted stay oforder passed by the Joint
Collector with regard to surrendcr of tenancy rights.
16. It is the case of the HMDA that based on the letter of the SRO,
Champapet, dated 27.10.2022, stating that there are no stay/injunction/
status quo olders granted b1, thc Court of law and the subject Survey
-
LNA, J
llP.No.22l77 of 2025
number was deleted from the prohibitory Watch Register, the HMDA
has approved the final layout, vide the impugned proceedings.
ll .
Respondent No.9 claims to have title and ownership over the
subject land by virtue ol surrendering of tenancy rights by the tenants.
Therefore, the crux ofthe issue goes to surrendering of tenancy rights in
respect of the subject property ln favour of respondent No.9. The
surrendering of tenancy rights was dealt with by the Joint Collector,
who vide orders dated 31.08.2018 cancelled the alleged surrender ol
tenancy rights and set aside the succession orders, dated 20.08.1987,
issued to Kadari Balaiah and 30 others, who are the legal heirs of Kadari
Venkaiah. However, this order of the Joint Collector was challenged
before this Court in CRP.Nos. I9l7 and 72 of 2019 and this Court vide
orders dated 21.08.2019 and 27.02.2019, respectively, has granted
interim stay of operation of the said order.
18. Further, it is bome out from the record that some of the legal
heirs of Kadari Venkaiah filed WP.Nos.22795 and 25466 of 2022
seeking to quash the proceedings of the Tahsildar, Balapur, dated
27 .07 .2019, whereunder the protected tenancy rights were sunendered
LNA,.)
lt/P. No.2 2
li7 o/ 2025
to respondent No.9 herein and this Clourt vide orders, dated 29.04.2022
and )7.10 202). passed in WP\os.22795 and 25466 of 2022,
respectivell. has categorically obscrvcd that under Section l9(l) of the
A.P. (Telangana Area) Tenancy and Agricultural l,ands Act, 1956,
protected tenancy riehts can be surrendered only in favour of landlords
and not in lavour ol an1' third parties and accordingly, suspended the
orders impr.rgned thelein. The said interim orders passed by this Court
are subsistins as on todal'
19.
Admittedly. respondcnt No.9 is not the landowner and he is a
third party to the subject propetty and therefore, surrendering of
protccted tenancy rights by the persons who are claiming tenancy rights
over the subject propertv in lavour of respondent No.9 is nonest in Ihe
eye ol lau and has no lesal validity
20.
Furthermore, even in WPNo.2l063 of 2022, this Court. vide
orders datecl 29.04 2.(122. suspcndcd the impugned proceedings therein
surrendering the tenancy rights by the protected tenants in favour of
respondent No.9 in respect of the subject property. These orders
.-
1N.4. .i
ItP.No.22l:i ol 2t)25
necessarily mean that respondent No.9 has no right or title over the
subject Survey number
21.
Therefore, from the above it is manifest that as on the date of
addressing the letter dated 27.10.2022, by the Sub-Registrar,
Ohampapet, to the tlMDA, the interim orders passed in WPNo.22795 of
2022, dated 29.04.2022 and in W.P.No.2 1063 of 2022, dated
29.04.2022 and CRP.Nos. l9l7 and 72 of 2019, dated 21.08.2019 and
27.02.2019, respectively, with regard to the subject Survey Number
were subsisting. The Tahsildar, Balapur Mandal, was a party to the said
Writ Petitions, therefore, passing of the aforesaid orders by this Court
was in the knowledge of the revenue authorities. However, there
appears to be some miscommun ication between the revenue and
registration Departments and the said orders are not noted in the
Registers maintained by the Sub-Registrar.
22.
In addition to the above, it is apt to note that respondent No.9
herein is a party to the aforesaid Writ Petitions, whereunder interim
orders were passed to the effect that surrender of tenancy rights in its
favour were suspended by this Court, and as such, it is well aware and
21,
l.tiA. J
u/P.\o 22 t7- ol 2025
has knor.r,ledge of the said orders. However, respondent No.9 has
suppressed and not disclosed the orders passed by this Court in the Writ
Petitions rlentioned hereinabove while making application for final
approval o1' the layout
23.
In this resard, it is trite to refer to the judgment of this Court in
Smt. I-olitha Srikrish & others Vs, The State of Telangana, rep. by its
Principal Secretory, .l4A & UD, Secretqriot, Hytlertbad & othersto,
wherein it is held that the applicanr shall necessarily disclose all the facts
and file all the lelevanl documents while applying lor permission for
construction. lt was turther held that the pending cases or litigations over
the building permission is invariably linked to ownership or title, such
pending lit igation s/d isputc with regard to title over the property is a
rnaterial lact u hich has to bc mandatorily disclosed by the appellant who
seeks building permission over said property. Such discloser ol pending
litigations/su its is necessan, for the authorities to determine prime
facie
title and possession.
21.
With regard to the same aspect, it is pertinent to note the ratio laid
dor,,,n by a Division llench of this Courr, vide judgment dated 24.09.2021
o
lzozz'1
: att 3 t
-
LNA, J
WP No 2217 ; ol 2025
in Writ Appeal No.l62 of 2021 {M/s. Fortuna Infraslructure India Pvt
Ltd vs. State of Telangana|, wherein it is held that non-disclosure of
pending litigation amounts to material m isreprese ntation under Section
450 of the GHMC Act, 1955.
25.
In the light o[ the aforesaid two judgments of this Court, the
inaction on the part of respondent No.9 in disclosing the pendency of the
Writ Petitions and CRP before this Court with regard to the subject
survey numbers belore the HMDA while making application for approval
of final Iayout amounts to rnaterial m isrepresentation and suppression of
facts.
26. The final approved layout was issued with an observation that
the protected tenants have surrendered their tenancy rights in favour of
respondent No.9 and also made representations that they have no claims
over the subject lands. Due to the misrepresentation of the material lact
as regards suspension olsurrendering oftenancy rights in its lavour by
this Court in the aforesaid Writ Petitions, the administrative power
exercised by HMDA by approving the final layout is vitiated, since it is
settled principle of law that lraud vitiates all judicial and administrative
LNA, J
ll/P.No.22l7i ol 2025
acts. (Sce S.P. Cftangalvaraya Naidu's case (cited supra) and
A.V. Papayyu .Sas/rJ's case (cited supra).
27.
In the teeth of thc interim orders passcd by this Court, the
surrender ol- tenancr rights in I'avour of respondent No.9 in respect of
the subjecr property stood suspended. thereby, respondent No.9 holds no
valid title over the subject properly.
28.
Hence, the observations and understanding on which the
HMI)r\ granted fina1 approved layout are factually incorrect and are
contrary to the interim orders passed by this Court in the pending Writ
Petitions and CRP. mentioned hereinabove
As reqards the contcntion of respondent No.9 that the
petitioners have already' alienated their share in the subject survey
number and as such. they have no iocus standi to file the present Writ
Petition, a perusal of the record discloses that the interse tenancv rights
in respect r:1'the subject survey numbers between the legal heirs of the
protected tenant-Kadari Vcnkaiah arc not adjudicated conclusively and
the rnatter is pending considcration before the revenue authorities.
= Therefore, this Couft erercising the powers under Article 226 of thc
LNA, J
l{P No.22177 of 2025
Constitution of lndia cannot delve into the said disputed question of title
and it is for the parties to agitate the same before the appropriate forum
which after conducting detailed enquiry, shall pass appropriate orders in
accordance with law
30.
For the foregoing reasons and discussion, this Court holds that
respondent No.9 has suppressed and not disclosed the subsistence of
interim orders passed by this Court in the alorementioned Writ Petitions
in respect of the subject survcy number, which amounts to
m isrepresentation
of material facts and therefore, the impugned final
approved layout is liable to be set aside.
31.
Accordingly, this Writ Petition is allowed, setting aside the
letter No. Par1025 I 52/SMDILT lU 6l F I 120 19, dated 28.09.2024, whereby
final layout was approved in favour of respondent No.9, and the matter
is remanded to respondent No.6 with a direction to take into account
and scrupulously follow all the orders passed by this Court in the
aloresaid Writ Petitions in respect of the subject survey number, afford
an opportunity of hearing to all the parties concemed and pass
appropriate orders in accordance with law. No costs.
t-
LNA, J
trP No )111'o[20)5
32. Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed
SD/- C. DEEPIKA
AS
TANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPYII
ECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Principal secretary, state of relangana, Rep.by its principal secretary
Municipal Administration and Urban Development Departmeni Secretariai
Hyderabad, Telangana State.
2. The Municipal Commissioner, Jalpally Municipality, Jalpally, Ranga Reddy
District, Telangana State
3. The Town Planning Officer, Jalpally Municipality, Jalpally, Ranga Reddy
District, Telangana State
4. The Hyderabad Metropoplitan Devetopment Authority, (HMDA), Rep.by its
!99r9!eaV, Swarnajayanthi Commercial Comptex, Ameerpet, iyOeiaOaO _
500 038 Telangana State
5. The city Planning officer, shamshabad Zone, Hyderabad Metroporitan
Developmnet Authority, Ranga Reddy District.
6. The Mekoppolitan Commissioner / Director (planning) _ ll, I lyderabad
Metropolitan Development Authority Swarna Jayanthi -Complex, Ameerpet,
Hyderabad.
7. The District Registrar, Prasanth Nagar, lDA. Kukatpally. Ranga Reddy
District.
8 The Sub-Registrar, Champapet S.R.O.. Ranga Reddy District.
9. M/.. snehitha Buirders private Limited., Rep.by iti Managing Director sri
Vemireddy Narasimha Reddy. s/o.Linga ReddyAge 66 years-. orce. Business,
R/o. H. No.3-2-87013, VNR Complex, Station Road. Kacheguda, Hyderabad.
10 Two ccs to Gp FoR MCPL ADMN AND URBAN OeleloptueruT, High
Qourt for the State of Telangana, at Hyderabad. [OUT]
11. One CC to SRI C HANUMANTHA RAO, Advocat,e
[OPUC]
12.One CC to SRI D.RAGHAVENDRA RAO, Advocate (OpUb)
'13 One CC to SRI J RAVTNDER REDDY, Advocate
(OPUC)
14. One CC to SRI V.NARASTMHG GOUD, Advocate (OpUC)
'15. Two CD Copies
SA
GJP
tuy
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1710612026
1 \lE
j
o
STATC-
(
z
1eJuN2o26
o
_b
.ar=-
* C,'. S,,i.'r';'l
ORDER
WP.No.22177 of 2025
ALLOWING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
I
\q
b
1 l.
.-t ,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review