The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Further, claim of the petitioners is to grant retrospective regularization from dates of their appointment/ completion of 240 days. Granting of this relief would mean petitioners would have to be shown as seniors to persons whose services were regularized in pursuant to orders in G.O.Ms.No.285 dated 5.10.2007 as they were also granted regularization only prospectively. In their absence no relief of retrospective regularization can be granted. None of them are parties before this Court. They were appointed on casual basis prior to petitioners.
17. Petitioners relied on isolated cases of retrospective regularization to claim same relief. similarly situated persons Merely on the ground some were granted retrospective regularization, no such relief can be granted. More over, there is no legal right to claim retrospective regularization. Further, decision in W.P.No.20440 of 2000, dated 24.02.2003, heavily relied by learned counsel for petitioners, was prior to G.O.Ms.No.285. Further, granting relief of retrospective regularization would only open a Pandora’s box.
18. For all the afore stated reasons, there is no merit in the claim of petitioners. Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed. No costs. Having regard to the same, miscellaneous petitions, if any pending, are closed. P NAVEEN RAO,J tvk/kkm WP 14991_2010 WRIT PETITION NO.14991 OF 2010 Tvk/kkm
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P. NAVEEN RAO
WRIT PETITION No. 14991 of 2010
Date : 13.3.2018
Between:
K Srinu S/o late K Samuel
32 years
R/o Ibrahimpatnam, Ranga Reddy district
…..Petitioner
And
Govt of A P
Rep by its Principal Secretary,
Department of Transport, R & B (Tr.II)
Secretariat, Hyderabad and others
…..Respondents
The Court made the following:
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P. NAVEEN RAO
ORAL ORDER:
WRIT PETITION No.14991 of 2010
On 10.10.1999 recruitment notification was issued for
recruitment to the post of Drivers, Conductors and Shramiks in
Hyderabad city Region and Ranga Reddy Region.
responded
to
the
said
recruitment
Petitioners
notification,
selected,
empanelled and were subjected to training. It appears, petitioners
have also worked during the strike period when regular employees
went on strike for more than 21 days.
They were employed on
daily wage basis in the year 2001-02 as conductors on various
dates as mentioned in paragraph 3 of the affidavit filed in support
of the writ petition. They continued in service on daily wage basis
till their services were regularized w.e.f. 1.7.2009. In this writ
petition, petitioners challenge orders of the Government in G.O.Ms
No. 145 Transport, Roads & Buildings (Tr.II) Department dated
1.7.2009 directing regularization prospectively and consequential
orders
of
the
respondent
corporation
regularizing
services
prospectively and consequently, petitioners seek direction to
regularize their services from the date of their initial appointment
or from date of completion of 240 days as extended to other
similarly situated persons.
2.
Heard learned counsel for petitioners Sri V.Narasimha
Goud and Sri Pravin Kumar appearing on behalf of Sri Vasudeva
Reddy, learned standing counsel for respondent corporation.
3.1.
According
to
learned
counsel
for
petitioners,
petitioners were subjected to regular selection process and
empanelment. Recruitment was against existing vacancies. Their
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
appointment though described as daily wage, it should be treated
as regular and continuous and therefore their services ought to
have been regularized from date of their initial appointment on
daily wage basis. Thus, regularizing their services only with effect
from 1.7.2009 is ex-facie illegal, amounts to arbitrary exercise of
power and authority and is illegal.
Learned counsel would also
contend that batch-mates of petitioners who were similarly
recruited and appointed were also regularized from date of
appointment on daily wage basis and not extending the same
benefit to petitioners amounts to discrimination among the same
class of people and therefore arbitrary. It also amounts to unfair
labour practice.
3.2.
Learned counsel would alternatively submit that
respondent corporation granting regularization on completion of
240 days and said policy must be extended uniformly to all
similarly situated persons and therefore the services of petitioners
ought to have been regularized on completion of 240 days.
3.3.
By placing reliance on decision of the learned single
Judge of this Court in W.P. 20440 of 2000 dated 24.2.2003, he
would submit that this Court directed regularization of services of
persons similarly situated to petitioners on completion of 240 days.
The said decision was affirmed by the Division Bench in
W.A.No.1897 of 2003 dated 28.9.2011 and SLP (C) No.002417 of
2012 was dismissed on 30.1.2012.
Principle laid down by this
Court in the said writ petition ought to be extended to petitioners.
3.4.
He would further submit that there is no provision to
appoint employees on daily wage basis in the services of the
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
respondent corporation and alien concept cannot be introduced
and same was introduced only to deprive the service benefits to
which a regular employee is entitled to.
The manner in which
services of petitioners were utilized would amount to exploitation of
labour and respondent corporation being an entity of the State
cannot indulge in such practices. The services of the petitioners
were required and their services are utilized continuously until
their services are regularized. Thus, there was requirement of their
services and such requirement was continuous and regular, that
being so, denying the service rendered by petitioners before
1.7.2009 is ex-facie illegal.
3.5.
Learned counsel for petitioners would therefore submit
that condition imposed by the Government in G.O.Ms.No.145
dated 1.7.2009 directing regularization only prospectively and
consequential orders are liable to be set aside. He would submit
that as no counter affidavit is filed opposing prayer of petitioners to
set aside cut-off date in the GO, it is deemed that respondent
Government has opposed contention of petitioners, therefore the
clause fixing cut-off date is liable to be declared as illegal and
therefore consequently petitioners are entitled to computation of
entire service as regular service.
3.6.
In support of his contentions, learned counsel for
petitioner placed reliance on decision of the Supreme Court in
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
U.P. State Electricity Board Vs Pooran Chandra Pandey and
others1, Jivanlal Vs. Pravin Krishna, Principal Secretary and
others2.
4.1.
Per contra, Sri Pravin Kumar, appearing for respondent
corporation would submit that initial recruitment itself was on
daily basis; petitioners never protested when they were appointed
on daily wage basis and continued in said post till their services
were regularized. But for order of the Government in G.O.Ms No.
145 dated 1.7.2009, their services could not have been regularized.
He would submit that the Government earlier granted permission
to the corporation vide G.O.Ms No.285 Transport, Roads and
Buildings (Tr.II) Department dated 5.10.2007 to regularize casual
employees working for long time in 3750 posts then available. In
terms of the Government orders, services of casual employees were
regularized. In the process, 603 posts remained unfilled for various
reasons. Further, as some more casual employees were demanding
for regularization, permission to regularize casual employees in the
resultant
unfilled
vacancies
and
some
other
vacancies
subsequently available was granted vide G.O.Ms No. 145 dated
1.7.2009.
4.2.
He would submit, retrospective regularization claim of
petitioners cannot be granted as then existing vacancies were filled
up by regularizing services of casual employees working much
prior to joining in service by petitioner and were all seniors.
(2008) 1 SCC (L&S) 736
(2016) 15 SCCC 747
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
4.3.
By placing reliance on the judgment of learned single
Judge in W P No. 14783 of 2010 and batch, he would submit that
this Court only granted regularization of services with effect from
date when employees selected in pursuant to notification dated
10.10.1999 were regularized in terms of G.O.Ms No. 285 dated
5.10.2007. Petitioners herein were also appointed in pursuant to
the very same recruitment notification and their services are
regularized in the consequent vacancies in pursuant to G.O.Ms.No.
285 dated 5.10.2007 and as per orders in G.O.Ms No. 145 dated
1.7.2009.
4.4.
Learned standing counsel placed reliance on decisions
of Supreme Court in State of Haryana and others Vs Jasmer
Singh and others3, Registrar General of India and another Vs
V.Thippa Setty and others4, Union of India and others Vs
Sheela Rani5.
5.
In reply, learned counsel Sri Narasimha Goud would
submit that W.P. No. 14783 of 2010 and batch was dealing with
G.O.Ms.No.285 dated 5.10.2007 therefore has no relevance to the
present case. He would further submit that judgment in Sheela
Rani relied on by learned standing counsel for respondents dealt
with back-door entrants whereas petitioners are not back-door
entrants.
(1996)11 SCC 77
(1998) 8 SCC 690
(2007) 15 SCC 230
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
6.
Issue for consideration is whether petitioners are
entitled to retrospective regularization from the date of initial daily
wage appointment/ from the date of completion of 240 days?
7.
It is appropriate to note facts which are relevant and
crucial to the issue. Recruitment notification dated 10.10.1999
specifies that recruitment would be on daily wage basis and their
services would be regularized subsequently. In terms thereof,
petitioners were selected and appointed on daily wage basis and
their services were regularized w.e.f. 1.7.2009.
Further, as per
order of the Government in G.O. Ms No. 285 dated 5.10.2007
persons who were appointed on daily wage/casual basis who have
been recruited up to 1999 were regularized w.e.f. 5.10.2007. As
can be seen from proposal sent by respondent Corporation and
orders of the Government in G O Ms No. 145 dated 1.7.2009, the
corporation proposed to regularize services of casual employees
who have been working by utilizing unfilled vacancies permitted by
the Government in G.O.Ms.No.285 dated 5.10.2007 and vacancies
that arose thereafter.
Petitioners were appointed after 1999.
Accordingly, services of petitioners were regularized prospectively.
8.
As per assertion of the respondents in their counter
affidavit, ban was imposed by the Government on making
recruitment. The corporation was also under financial stress and
Government was insisting the corporation to make it profitable. It
appears, various policy decisions were taken by the respondent
corporation to improve the profitability. One such decision was to
reduce ratio of employees per bus and to bring it down to 6.10 per
bus.
All this would necessarily result in less recruitment.
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
Employer cannot be faulted if he implements austerity measures
and reduces employment. These facts cannot be ignored to direct
retrospective regularization.
9.
There is no merit in the contention of learned counsel
for petitioners that since Government has not filed counter,
challenge to G.O.Ms.No.145 should succeed. Only ground urged
by petitioners on G.O.Ms.No.145 is by not granting retrospective
regularization/regularization
on
Government acted arbitrarily.
Government
based
Corporation.
on
completion
days,
G.O.Ms.No.145 was issued by
proposals
Corporation
of
made
produced
by
the
respondent
correspondence
with
Government leading to Government issuing G.O.Ms.No.285 and
G.O.Ms.No.145. Counter-affidavit of respondent corporation also
explains various aspects on the issue of regularization.
Thus,
background facts would disclose that permission granted in G.O.
Ms. No. 145 to regularize some more daily wage/casual employees
is in continuation to G.O.Ms.No.285. In G.O.Ms.No.285 also
regularization was granted prospectively. Thus, G.O.Ms.No.145
cannot be seen in isolation. Further, the cutoff date to regularize
daily wage/ casual service is in built into scheme to regularize and
cannot be seen in isolation.
10.
It is settled principle of law that regularization of
services cannot be retrospective. In Sheela Rani, Supreme Court
held regularization of an employee can only be done as per relevant
rules and from the date on which regular vacancy/post is available
for such regularization. Further held that regularization is a policy
decision and that retrospective regularization will upset the
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
seniority of the employees already working. In Registrar General
of India, Supreme Court held regularization of casual/daily wage
workers must be done prospectively and regularization from back
date will disturb seniority of regularly appointed employees in that
cadre.
11.
Decision in U.P State Electricity Board do not come
to the aid of petitioners. The society where petitioners were
working on daily wage basis was taken over by the electricity board
in year 1997 along with those petitioners in the ‘same manner and
position’ as in the society. The electricity board passed order dated
28-11-1996 seeking to regularize services of its employees working
on daily wages before 4.5.1990. This benefit was not extended to
those petitioners claiming they were not working in the Board as
on the cutoff date. Learned Single judge held that there was no
ground for discriminating the two sets of employees since the
employees of the society have become employees of the Electricity
Board. The same view was upheld by the Division Bench of the
High Court. Supreme court upheld the view taken by the High
Court and held that services rendered by those employees in the
society cannot be ignored since employees of the society are now
deemed to be employees of the electricity board and therefore they
must be entitled to the benefit of the order dated 28-11-1996.
Thus, the facts in that case are not similar to the facts of this case.
In Jivanlal, Supreme Court held as policy of regularization was
violated many times, the Appellants cannot be discriminated as
there cannot be pick and choose policy. In facts of this case, said
decision also do not come to the aid of petitioners.
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
12.
It may be true that Supreme Court was dealing with
delay in setting up a claim for regularization in Divisional
Manager, APSRTC Vs. P.Lakshmoji Rao and others6 and
Regional Manager, APSRTC Vs. N. Satyanarayana and others7,
as contended by learned counsel for petitioners.
However, the
observations and directions in P.Laxmojirao are relevant for this
case also.
The Supreme Court held that employee has no legal
right to claim regularization retrospectively.
13.
In P.Laxmojirao supreme Court observed as under:
“18. In view of this peculiar situation and in order to avoid the
anomalies that might otherwise ensue, while we hold that the
respondent employees have failed to establish their legal right
to get the status of regular employees right from the date of
their initial appointment on daily-wage basis and the
respective dates of regularization assigned to the respondents
cannot be legally faulted, we are inclined to mould the relief in
modification of the directions given in the judgments under
appeal and direct as follows:
If any of the conductors, junior to the respondents in the
relevant seniority list of the concerned Division/Region, have
got the benefit of seniority and regularization OR are entitled to
get the same by virtue of the judgments that have become
final, then the respondents who are seniors to them, shall be
given the same benefit on the same principle.”
14.
In the case on hand also, petitioners have no legal
right to claim retrospective regularization.
15.
Employment notification indicated that appointment
would be made on daily wage basis and services would be
regularized later. Thus, petitioners cannot contend to treat their
service from initial date of appointment as regular. Petitioners did
not
protest
to
the
condition
imposed
in
the
employment
notification nor did they protest against treating their appointment
on daily wage basis and continued to work on daily wage basis till
(2004) 2 SCC 433
(2008) 1 SCC 210
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
their services were regularized prospectively. Having regard to the
terms of notification and nature of their appointment, it cannot be
said that petitioners were illegally treated in the matter of
regularization.
16.
Further,
claim
of
the
petitioners
is
to
grant
retrospective regularization from dates of their appointment/
completion of 240 days. Granting of this relief would mean
petitioners would have to be shown as seniors to persons whose
services were regularized in pursuant to orders in G.O.Ms.No.285
dated 5.10.2007 as they were also granted regularization only
prospectively.
In
their
absence
no
relief
of
retrospective
regularization can be granted. None of them are parties before this
Court. They were appointed on casual basis prior to petitioners.
17.
Petitioners relied on isolated cases of retrospective
regularization to claim same relief.
similarly
situated
persons
Merely on the ground some
were
granted
retrospective
regularization, no such relief can be granted. More over, there is
no legal right to claim retrospective regularization.
Further,
decision in W.P.No.20440 of 2000, dated 24.02.2003, heavily relied
by learned counsel for petitioners, was prior to G.O.Ms.No.285.
Further, granting relief of retrospective regularization would only
open a Pandora’s box.
18.
For all the afore stated reasons, there is no merit in
the claim of petitioners. Writ Petition is accordingly dismissed. No
costs. Having regard to the same, miscellaneous petitions, if any
pending, are closed.
P NAVEEN RAO,J
DATE: 13-03-2018
tvk/kkm
PNRJ
WP 14991_2010
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P. NAVEEN RAO
WRIT PETITION NO.14991 OF 2010
Date : 13.03.2018
Tvk/kkm
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review