Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
;"
[3302 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE ELEVENTH DAYOF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
i
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION
) NO:764 OF 2017
Between:
K.Ravi Kumar, S/o Ramdev, aged 35 years, Occ SA (English) ZppSS,
Chedapalm, R/o H.No 11-26-153, Kothawada, Warangal- 506002
V. Prakash, S/o Paramathmaiah, aged 45 years, Occ SA (English) ZpHS
Narlapur, Parkal, Rl/o H.No 2-6-134211, Bhavani nagar, Hanumakonda,
Warangal- 506007.
J
P.Srinivas Gupta, S/o Chandramouli, aged 42 years, Occ SA ZppSS
Konduru, R/o H.No 5-10-201206, Harikrishna residency, Kishanpura,
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506 001 .
aged 48 years, Occ SA (Engtish) ZppSS
}l:!il_-r:t S/o,Suryanarayana,
Konkapaaka,
R/o H.No 10-1O-147t1, Ramolawada, CirmanlipJt, Warangal506 001.
B.Srinivas, S/o B.Dharmaiah, aged 48 years,
Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
M^a_dhannapeta, F/o R. No. 1 5-5/6,- main
road, flarsa, peia (P&M) Warangat506 132
6. V.Srinath, S/o B.parameshyl ,g{ 46 years,
Occ SA (English) ZppSS
Kammapauy, Narsamoeta,y9- i--!o
3:;#i, "ibos corony, phase_l
t
Hanumakonda (M) Waiangat- 506
132.
43 vears, occ sA (Ensrish) zppss
[,X.?'flffi''*?l"I"tJ:T3]^"9d.4's"d
t_s-221, Vittat wadi,
NarappagrOr, nYtt"errfjuO_ SOO
029.
8. K.Madhava Rao, S/o. K. tr
e,oh,,.,; ped"R;"c.iJ'l?:;i l??
?,X.ilJ,lffiIw?ff !1,1!g,,;g.""".
L G.Kedhari, D/o G. Shiva
oo yoo, O".. sn (.Engtish) zppss
o_s6, jurr,""r,nils"tri"t,rman1pet,
yf;#rrr,r, R/o R. No IlpglT^"S.+
waransat0_1
"fu.fl:$ii;"1?jH:,iX.gi;S,?i:ffi
fr
:#?,?f,;#*%:llffi
"i#fl ::X??i:?ff ff J.,#:aXX,"Jf L,.ffi
I
,gf,..*l?g,,Xifi?B8
12.D Sarasvathi devi, S/o D-Mohan chary, aged 46 years, Occ SA (English)
ZPPSS Challagarige, Chityal(M) R/o R.No 2-12-351/1 , Nakkalagutta'
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506002.
13. N. Surendra, S/o N. Sayann, aged 51 years' Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Chinthanek konda, Parvathagiri(M) Ryo R.No 8-1-22' Orus road, Rangasaipet,
Warangal- 506 005.
14. Ch. Srinivas, S/o .Ch. Ramalingam, aged 48 years'" Occ SA (English) ZPSS
Pasara, Rl/o R.No 3-4-686/2, New Rayapura, lndranagar, Hanumakonda,
Warangal- 506001
years, Occ SA ZPSS
15. A. Tirumalaiah, S/o A. Ramachandraiah' aged 45
Chinnagudur, Rl/o R.No 1-7'4110182' Ramachandrapuram, NSPT Road'
Mahabubabad, Warangal - 506 '101 .
years, Occ SA (Maths) Z-PPS-S
16.
- R. Ekambram, S/o Brahmaiah, aged 39Kesamudram'
Warangal- so6 112'
kalwala, RJo R.No 1-714t5-1' Laxminagar,
aged 50 years' Occ SA (English)
17. V.Gopala Krishna, S/o Laxminarayana,
2-4-557' Ramnagar'
ZPPSS Penugonda, Kesamudiam' Fl/o R
ianumakonda, llanumakonda, Warangal- 506001'
aged 53 ye.als'- .O.^rc SA (English) ZPPSS
18. K. Venkanna, S/o Lingaiah,
'nr61-g-54t8' Julaiwada' Subedari'
:
:
I
No
nNo
Redlawada, Nerronoa(Mi
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506001'
Rao' aged 45-years' Occ SA (English)
19. S.srinivasa Rao, S/o Venkateshwar
warangal'
'"
Tplsd t'rJr"oetty, clo R No 9-8-63/E' Ellambazar'
(English) ZPPSS
aSed-1g ye:3 9-:" SA
20 Yakub Ali, S/o Khaia moinuddin'
L B N's"t' waransal- 506002'
Suripally(M), cntnnur.uopti]iio'i
D/9 v Pi?:ee3
2 1 V. H ym av ath I
.
f"#, i:' H;:'.i
Govindarao Pet, R/o 5-1 1
i-iiros'
ff;:$ l?:[] ff":::
J,t'*
sA (Maths) ZPPSS
,, [X'i:-t"t":tti:.'J' s/o KVeeraiah' ased vears€ccWarangal- 506 001 '
Chelpur, Fi/o 1-7-336'
""H;;;ff
Hanumakonda'
"iil*mr".;ti,tfiffi :ulilif ?'"f"lffi
?'r"nliln*n'*"::
,l*,,;:yi1ts3,,&il[Tff "-y*"m::'Hfl ''53?#-[,l:ff ,"ff ":l
,'ffil,t"i]', d'J,{rj **,',trn}*.-
sA (Ens sh) ZPPSS
\
29.8. Pavan kumar, S/o B.Yellaiah, aged 42 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Himmathnagar, Zatfargadh, No 25-4-17 1, Mshnupuri, Kazipet, Hanumakonda
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506001.
30.N.Raghu, S/o N. Purna Chander Rho, aged 44 years, Occ SA (English)
ZPPSS Mallampally, Duggond, Wo 11-13-237, O city, Mills colony, Warangal506008
31. M.Sharath babu, S/o Basva Rajam, aged 41 years,-Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Dabeerpet, M.Khanapur, R/o)-14, Near Post office, Narsampet, Warangal506 132.
32.M. Balamuralidhar, S/o Yadagiri, aged 42 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Dharmarao pet, Khanapur, No 1-25112, Angadi road, Narasampet, Warangal
33.M. Suresh, S/o Veeraswamy, aged 44 years, Occ SA (English) ZPHS Chinna
Kodepaka, Regonda, Rlo 2-4-564, Ramnagar, Hanumakonda, Warangal506001.
34.P.Venugopal, S/o Vishwanatham, aged 36 yearc, Occ SA (English) ZPHS
Cherlapalem, Thoru(M), No 16-4-12O4, Shivanagar, Warangal - 506001
35. P. Srinivasulu, S/o P.Veeraiah, aged 46 years, Occ SA (English) ZPSS
Macharajpally, Rlo 16-1O-122711 , Shivanagar, Warangal.
36. B.Sridhar, S/o Laxminarsaiah, aged 42 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Katrapally No. 11-23-1783, L.B Nagar Warangal.
37.T Rani, D/o T.Rajaiah, aged 50 years, Occ SA (English)ZPPSS Ashoknagar,
Khanapur, Ryo 9-1 0-125, Pinnavari street, Warangal.
38. MD.Masthan, S/o MD.Moulana, aged 47 yearc, Occ SA (English) ZPSS BGudur, R/o 140212,lndiranagar, Warangal- 506 132
39. N. Viaya laxmi, D/o Narsimha reddy, aged 49 years, Occ SA (Bio-Science)
ZPSS Ootai, Kothaguda, No 2-8-474h, Srinagar colony, Hanumakonda,
Warangal- 506 001 .
40.G. Raghu Prasad, S/o G.Kedari swamy, aged 45 years, Occ SA (Maths)
ZPPSS Tharigoppula, R/o 2-3551N1, Vyasapuri colony, Madikonda, Warangal
41.Y.Naga Jhansi, D/o Ramaiah, aged 40 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Kompelly, Bhupalpally, R./o 13-4-1 9, Pathak Skeet, Matwada, Warangal506012
42.M.Simha chary, S/o M.Laxmana chary, aged 54 years, Occ SA (Maths)
ZPPSS Kompelly, Bhupalpally, Rl/o 6-7-13, Ragannadar wada,
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506 001
43. D.Veerabhardraiah, S/o D. Yakaiah, aged 46 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Peddakorpole, R/o Chandrugonde, Nekkonda(M), Warangal 506 122.
zt4
Somaiah, S/o Papaya aged 50 years, Occ SA (English) ZppSS
].
Nallabell(V), Rlo 1-7 -9OOl1lB, Nandi
Warangal- 506 O01.
hiils, Hunter Road, tianumakonda,
45.P- Raghu pathi, S/o Venkataiah, aged 43 years, Occ SA (English) ZppSS
Gabbeta, Raghunathapatty(M), R/o 1-1-695, Sidhratha'nalar,'Kazipet,
Warangal- 506004.
46. G. Shivaprasad, S/o Sammaiah, aged 34 years, Occ SA (physical Science)
ZPPSS Kamatapur, Rl/o.Nachinapally, Duggondi, Warangal_ 506331
47. N. Raia mouly, S/o N. Jaggaiah, aged 44 years, Occ SA (English) ZPHS
Rudragudem, Nallabelly, R/o 3-53/A, Near Water Tank, Gopalpur, Palivelpula,
Hanumakonda, Warangal - 506 001
.
48.M. Ramesh, S/o Pochaiah aged 40 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Chinna[,4upparam, Ryo Flat No 514, Ramnagar towers, Ramnagar,
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506 O01.
49. N. Ravi, S/o N. Sri hari, aged 38 years, Occ SA (Maths) ZPPSS Gundrathi
Madugu, R/o 3-3-45, old bazaar, Mahabubabad, warangal- 506 101.
50. N Bhaskar, S/o Kommaiah, aged 35 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS Otai,
Kothaguda, No 4-23, Togarrai (PandV), Duggondi, Warangal- 506331
51.M. Jagannadham, S/o M.Shankaraiah, aged 48 years, Occ SA (English)
ZPSS Rangaiahpally, Regonda, Ryo 6-7-155, Raipura, Hanumakonda,
Warangal - 506 01 1
.
52.T.Naveen kumar, S/o Rajashekaram, aged 36 years, occ SA (Maths) ZPPSS
Kothur, Rl,/o '1-576 Gandhinagar, near ramalayam, Narasampet, Warangal506 132
53. T. Venkatram narsaiah, S/o Kistaiah, aged 42 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Theegaiaveni, Gudu(M), Rlo 6-24814, Sri sai nagar, Rangasaipet, Warangal506005.
54.S. Govardhan, S/o Venkataiah, aged 48 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Bandarupally, No 4-5214, Anand Nagar colony, Bheemaram, K_C.Camp,
Hasanparthy (M), Warangal- 506 015.
55. V. Sarangapani, S/o V. Komuraiah, aged 40 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Chinnamupparam, Nellikudur, R/o 1-7-885/1 1/A, Nandi hills, Hunter road,
Hanmakonda(M), Warangal- 50601 5.
56. G. Jagan Mohan, S/o Kashamallu, aged 42 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Devagiripatnam, Mulugu(M), R/o 2-65, near masjid, Mulugu (P&M), Warangat506343.
57.Ch. Venkatn a,ayana, S/o Sailu, aged 52 years, occ SA (English) ZPHS
Rayaparthy, Ri/o 19-11-308/4, Vishwanadh colony, Shambumpet, Warangal506002.
58.V. Ramesh babu, S/o Bhoomaiah, aged 50 years' occ SA (English) ZPSS
Deekshakunta, Nekkonda (M), F/o 11-17-229, Kashibugga' Warangal506002
59.G.Narender reddy, S/o Ram reddy, aged 52 years, occ SA (English) ZPSS
Bhagirthipet, Regonda(M), No 5'32tC, Kalwala, Kesamudrurn, Warangal- 506
112.
60.J. Parashu ramulu, S/o Venkataiah, aged 47 years, occ SA (English) ZPSS
Dardepally, Palakurthy(M), No 3-4-7261N1' New Rayapura' Hanumakonda,
Warangal- 506 1 12.
years, occ SA (English)
61. M. Krishna Murthy, S/o Sheshachary, aged 51
ZPPSS Komuravelly, Cherial(M), Warangal- 506 112
(English) ZPPSS
62. B. Narasimhulu, , S/o Shankaraiah, aged 45 years' occ SA
Aknoor, Cherial (M), Warangal- 506 112'
i
l
l-
63. M. Chiranjeevulu, S/o Bhoomaiah, aged 49 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Narmefta, Narmetta (M), Warangal 506 112
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Andhra Pradesh, rep by its Principle Secretary, School Education
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. 22
2. The Commissioner & Director of School Education, Government of Andhra
Pradesh, Hyderabad.
3. The District Collector, Warangal District at Warangal, 506001
4. The District Educational Officer, Warangal District at Warangal-506001 '
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arlicle 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to declare the action of the respondents particulady the 4th respondent in issuing
cyclostyle proceedings in Rc.No.641 5/B1 /2009 dt.28.05.20 1 3 framing charge against
the applicants that they have produced Degree certificates from various Universities
including lndira Gandhi National open University(lGNoU) which are found to be fake
certificates and directing the applicants to submit their explanation and the
instructions issued by 2nd Respondent commissioner in Rc-No.1379/D 1-312010-3,
dt.09.04.2010, as illegal, unlust, arbitrary, violative of Art.14,16 and 21 of the
constitution besides being contrary to Rule2o(3) and (4) of ccA Rules and
consequentially set aside the same by holding that the applicants are entitle to
continue as school Assistants in their respective places as per their promotion
orders issued by the 4th Respondent with all consequential benefits'
l.A NO:1OF 2017 (WVMPffru. NO: 140 O F 20171
BETWEEN
1. The State of Andhra Pradesh, rep by its Principle Secretary, School Education
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. 22
2. The Commissioner & Director of School Education, Government of Andhra
Pradesh, Hyderabad.
3. The District Collector, Warangal District at Warangal, 50600'1
4. The District Educational Officer, Warangal District at Warangal-506001.
...PETITIONERS
/.,'
AND
1. K.Ravi Kumar, S/o Ramdev, aged 35 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS,
Cherlapalm, Rl/o H.No 11-26-153, Kothawada, Warangal- 506002
2. V. Prakash, S/o Paramathmaiah, aged 45 years, Occ SA (English) ZPHS
Narlapur, Parkal. R/o H.No 2-6-134211, Bhavani nagar, Hanumakonda,
Warangal- 50600 i.
3 P.srinivas Gupta, S/o Chandramouli, aged 42 years, Occ SA ZPPSS
Konduru, Rl/o H.No 5-10-201206, Harikrishna residency, Kishanpura,
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506 001.
4. M.Srinivas, S/o Suryanarayana, aged 48 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Konkapaaka, R/o H.No 10-10-14711, Ramolawada, Girmanjipet, Warangal506 001.
5. B.Srinivas, S/o B.Dharmaiah, aged 48 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Madhannapeta, Rl/o R.No.15-5/6, main road, Narsampeta (P&M) Warangal506 132
6. V.Srinath, S/o B.Parameshwar, aged 46 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Kammapally, Narsampeta Ri/o R.No 3-26212, NGOs colony, Phase-ll
Hanumakonda (M) Warangal- 506 1327. P. Rajini Devi, D/o P. Laxma reddy, aged 43 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Koddavatoor, Rl/o R.No 3-5-221 , Vittal wadi, Narappaguda, Ryderabad- 500
029.
8. K.Madhava Rao, S/o. K. Mohan rao, aged 41 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Budharao peta, R/o R.No 11-22-175, Kashi budha, Warangal- 506 132.
9. G.Kedhari, D/o G. Shiva lingam, aged 44 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Uppar pally, Rl/o R.No 10-10-56, Maisammagalli, Girmanjipet, Warangal506002
10. B.Lakshmi, D/o B. Narasimha reddy, aged 43 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Chinnamadur, R/o R.No 6-2-l126lAl, Jyothinagar, Hyderabad road, Jangaom,
Warangal- 506 167
11. D.Kamalakar, S/o D. Anjaneyulu, aged 45 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Chinnamadur, R/o H.No 2'10-46, Ganesh street, Jangaom, Warangal- 506
167.
(English)
12. D Sarasvathi devi, S/o D.Mohan chary, aged 46 years, Occ SA
Nakkalagufta,
ZPPSS Challagarige, Chityal(M) Rl/o R.No 2-12-35111,
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 50600213.N. Surendra, S/o N. Sayann, aged 51 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Chinthanek konda, Parvathagiri(M) R/o R.No 8-1-22, Orus road, Rangasaipet,
Warangal- 506 005.
14.Ch. Snnivas, S/o .Ch. Ramalingam, aged 48 years, Occ SA (English) ZPSS
Pasara, Rl/o R.No 3-4-686/2, New Rayapura' lndranagar' Hanumakonda'
Warangal- 506001
aged 45 years' Occ SA ZPSS
15.
- A. Tirumalaiah, S/o A. Ramachandraiah'
Chinnagudur, fuo R.No 1'7'41101P,2' Ramachandrapuram' NSPT Road'
Mahabubabad, Warangal - 506 101
16.R. Ekambram, S/o Brahmaiah, aged 39 years, Occ SA (Maths) ZPPSS
Kalwala, Rl/o R.No 1-71415-1, Laxminagar, Kesamudram, Warangal- 506 1,l2.
17. V.Gopala Krishna, S/o Laxminarayana, aged 50 years, Occ SA (English)
ZPPSS Penugonda, Kesamudram, R/o R.No 2{-557,.Ramnagar,
Hanumakonda, Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506001.
18.K. Venkanna, S/o Lingaiah, aged 53 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Redlawada, Nekkonda(M), Rlo R.No 1-9-54/8, Julaiwada, Subedari,
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506001.
Rao, aged 45 years, Occ SA (English)
ZPPSS Nallabelly, C/o R.No 9-8-63/E, Ellambazar, Warangal.
20. Yakub Ali, S/o Khaja moinuddin, aged 48 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Suripally(M), Chennaraopet, R/o 1 1-23-368, L.B Nagar, Warangal- 506002.
21.V. Hymavathi, D/o V. Pratap reddy, aged 39 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Govindarao pet, R/o 5-1 'l -636/1, Srinagar colony, Naimnagar, Hanumakonda,
Warangal- 506001
19. S.Srinivasa Rao, S/o Venkateshwar
22. K.Venkateshwarlu, S/o K.Veeraiah, aged 41 years Occ SA (Maths) ZPPSS
Chelpur, Ryo 1-7-336, Revenue colony, Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506 001 .
23.K.Srinivas reddy, S/o Konda reddy, aged 40 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Kasimdevi pet, Mulugu(M), No 9-3-77, Barkatpuram Nizamabad
24. T.V.Satyanarayana swamy, S/o Venkateshwarlu, aged 41 years Occ SA
(Maths) UPS Chinnakorpole, Nekkonda, No 3-9-2741A, Reddy mtony,
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506001
25.K. Madhavi, D/o K. Mohan rao, aged 42 yea$, occ SA (English) ZppSS
Budharao pet, R/o 1 1-1 9-66, Kashibugga, Warangal
26.M.Shankar rao, S/o Rajeeru, aged 42 years, Occ SA (Maths) MpUpS,
Karkapally, Ghanpu(M), Rlo 3-92t2, Mallareddpally street, parkal, Warangal
27. G Ye_shwanth kumar, S/o
Rao, aged 45 years, Occ SA (English)
-Wo
ZPPSS Mandelagudem, _Gajanan
Z_l'_ASAn, exercise coiony,
.Raghunathpalty ,
Subedari, Hanumakonda, Warangal - 506' OOI .
28. Shameem, D/o MD. tsmait, aged 45 years,
Occ SA (English) ZpHS
Kapulakanaparthy, No 24-7 -10571, Fathimanagar, Kazipet,' ga-numatonOa,
Warangal- 506001
29.8. Pavan kumar, S/o B.yellaiah, agei 42 years, Occ SA (English)
Himmathnagar, Zaffargadh,No2s_i_1t1,Visnnrpuri,-kazipdt,
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 50600.l.
ZppSS
ff-anrr"tonOI
30.N.Raghu, S/o N. purna Chander
?g"O 44 years, Occ SA (English)
ZPPSS Mailampaily, Duggond, wo F.ho,lt_tlilt,
O.i,i]i,rU" *rony, Wr-o"n!-"il
31.M.Sharath babu, S/o Basvg.l,1ja1, aged
4.t years, Occ SA (Engtish) ZppSS
M Khanapur, Fvo)-i 4, Ne; p;.i -oril]ivro"mpet,
waransar-
ff;?U"'
32.M. Batamuratidhar. S/o yalagiri,-aged
42 years, Occ SA (English) ZppSS
Dharmarao pet, Khanapur, ad Lziiii,
eislJirio]fi"r""rmpet, waransat
33. M. Suresh, S/o VeeraswamY, aged 44 years, Occ SA (English) ZPHS Chinna
Kodepaka, Regonda, Rlo 2-4-564, Ramnagar, Hanumakonda, Warangal506001
34. P.Venugopal, S/o Vishwanatham, aged 36 years, Occ SA (English) ZPHS
Cherlapalem, Thoru(M), No 16-4-1204, Shivanagar, Warangal - 506001
35. P. Srinivasulu, S/o P.Veeraiah, aged 46 years, Occ SA (English) ZPSS
Macharajpally, No 16-10-122711 , Shivanagar, Warangal.
36. B.Sridhar, S/o Laxminarsaiah, aged 42 yea$, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Katrapally Rl/o. 11-23-1783, L.B Nagar Warangal.
37 T Rani, D/o T.Rajaiah, aged 50 years, Occ SA (English)ZPPSS Ashoknagar'
Khanapur, Rl/o 9-10-125, Pinnavari street, Warangal.
(English) ZPSS B38. MD.Masthan, S/o MD.Moulana, aged 47 yea$, Occ SA
'l 32
Gudur, RJo 1-40212, Indiranagar, Warangal- 506
years' Occ SA (Bio-Science)
39. N. Viaya laxmi, D/o Narsimha reddy, aged 49
ZPSS Ootai, Kothaguda, No 2-8-47 4i1, Srinagar colony' Hanumakonda'
Warangal- 506 001
SA (Maths)
Raghu Prasad' S/o G Kedari swamy, aged 45 years' Occ
40.G.
Zpp# fnrrigoppula, nyo Z-:SSm;t ' Vyasapuri colony' Madikonda' Warangal
SA (English) ZPPSS
41.YNaga Jhansi, D/o Ramaiah, aged 40 yegrsa Oc9 Matwada' WarangalXorniJrv, Bhupalpally, nyo-r'a-alrs, Patirak Street'
'
50601 2
42,M.Simhachary,S/o]rrt'Laxmanachary,aged-54^years,occSA(Maths)
Rasannadar wada'
ZPPSS Kompellv, il;;lp*;llv' Fvo 6-7-13'-
Hanumakonda, Warangal- 506 001
ZPPSS
Yakaiah, aged 46 y9?,:].oc" SA (English)
43, D.Veerabhardraiah, S/o D'
122'
Warangal- 506
Peddakorpole' ruro cnanlrugonJe' Ueltonoa(tt'l)'
SA (English) ZPPSS
44.T. Somaiah, S/o papava aged 50 y-"-""'.'O::t'irr"' Hunter Road' Hanumakonda'
Nallabellv(V), nyo r-z-ffirlE]-r'r'nii
Warangal- 506 001'
43 ye-ars^9P SA (English) ZPPSS
aged
-l-t--dgs'
45 P. Raghu pathi, S/o Venkataiah'
sidnratna nasar' Kazipet'
Gabbeta, nasnunatnap';if i"'ti'i'
Warangal- 506004'
(Physical Science)
aged 34 years.^Occ SA
46.G. Shivaprasad, S/o Sammaiah'
waransal- 506331
ZPPSS Kamalap", Rv" i\;;i;;'p'ilv-'bugdonoi'
(English) ZPHS
aged 44 years' Occ SA
Jaggaiah'
N
S/o
mouly,
Rala
N.
47.
Gopalpur' Palivelpula'
ruarraoerrv''fiioeilE'iin'"lr?r.wite'rant'
Rudrasudem,
u]nr-,irronO", Warangal - 506 o01'
M Ramesh :! r3:j"'?L,"rril
:1^:"'*t""ff","1"*:H'"P,.',::;?'
*'-,
ChinnaMupparam'
'lll
"n.
-^-eq Gundrathi
$$+$*'tg:'p.l;;*r*ll;":,;';'ii.t*"
^.
*utffiln:j:I;T
aged 48 years, Occ SA (English)
ZPSS Rangaiahpally, Regonda, R/o 6-7-155, Raipura, Hanumakonda,
51 . M. Jagannadham, S/o M.Shankaraiah,
Warangal - 506 01 1 .
52.T.Naveen kumar, S/o Rajashekaram, aged 36 years, occ SA (Maths) ZPPSS
Kothur, Rl/o 1-576, Gandhinagar, near ramalayam, Narasampet, Warangal506 132.
53.T. Venkatram narsaiah, S/o Kistaiah, aged 42 years-, oc,c SA (English) ZPPSS
Theegalaveni, Gudu(M), No 6-24814, Sri sai riaQar, Rangasaipet, Warangal506005.
54.S. Govardhan, S/o Venkataiah, aged 48 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Bandarupally, Rlo 4-524, Anand Nagar colony, Bheemaram, K.C.Camp,
Hasanparthy (M), Warangal- 506 015.
55.V. Sarangapani, S/o V. Komuraiah, aged 40 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Chinnamupparam, Nellikudur, No 1-7-88511114, Nandi hills, Hunter road,
Hanmakonda(M), Warangal- 50601 5.
56.G. Jagan Mohan, S/o Kashamallu, aged 42 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Devagiripatnam, Mulugu(M), R/o 2-65, near masjid, Mulugu (P&M), Warangal506343.
57.Ch. Venkatn aayana, S/o Sailu, aged 52 years, occ SA (English) ZPHS
Rayaparthy, R/o 19-1 1-308/4, Vishwanadh colony, Shambumpet, Warangal506002.
58.V. Ramesh babu, S/o Bhoomaiah, aged 50 years, occ SA (English) ZPSS
Deekshakunta, Nekkonda (M), R/o 11-17-229, Kashibugga, Warangal506002.
59.G.Narender reddy, S/o Ram reddy, aged 52 years, occ SA (English) ZPSS
Bhagirthipet, Regonda(M), No 5-321C, Kalwala, Kesamudrum, Warangal- 506
112.
60.J. Parashu ramulu, S/o Venkataiah, aged 47 years, occ SA (English) ZPSS
Dardepally, Palakurthy(M), No 3-4-7261N1, New Rayapura, Hanumakonda,
Warangal- 506 112.
61. M. Krishna Murthy, S/o Sheshachary, aged 51 years, occ SA (English)
ZPPSS Komuravelly, Cherial(M), Warangal- 506 112.
62.8. Narasimhulu, , S/o Shankaraiah, aged 45 years, occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Aknoor, Cherial (M), Warangal- 506 112.
63.M. Chiranjeevulu, S/o Bhoomaiah, aged 49 years, Occ SA (English) ZPPSS
Narmetta, Narmetta (M), Warangal 5OO 112
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim orders daled 17-07-2013 in O.A.No.5561 of 2O13, pending disposat of the
writ petition (TR).
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2017 (WVMP(TR). NO: 141 OF 20171
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to vacate the
interim orders passed on 17-O7-2013 in o.A.No. 5561 of 2013, pending disposal of
the wnt petition(TR).
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI K.R.PRABHAKAR
Counsel forthe Respondents: SRI G.PRASHANTH, AGP FOR SERVICES-I
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
WRIT PETITION (TRl No.764 of 20L7
THE I1TH DAY OF MARCH 2026
Between:
K.Ravi Kumar and others.
...Petitioners
AND
The State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
School Education Department and others.
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Sri K.R.Prabhakar, learned Counsel for the petitioners
and Sri G.Prasanth, learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Services-l appearing for the respondents. Perused the material on
record
2.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners submits that this Writ
Petition (TR) is liled seeking to declare the action of the respondent
No.4 in issuing proceedings
IN
Rc.No.6415/Bl I 2OO9 dated
28.05.2013, framing charge against the petitioners for allegedly
producing fake Degree Certificates from various universities,
including Indira Gandhi National Open University (IGNOU) and
directing them to submit their explanations, and the instructions
\.. issued by respondent No.2-Commissioner in Rc.No.1379lDl-
3/2OlO 3 dated 09.04.2010, as illegal, arbitrary and contrary to
Rulcs 2O(3) and 2O(4) ot
the Telangana Cir.il Services
(classrfication. co,trol and Appeal) Rules and to consequently set
asidc the sarnc, holding that the petitioners are entitled to
continue as Schoor Assistants in terms of their promotion orders
issued by the respondent No.4, with all consequential benefits.
3.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners further submits that, in
conner:ted matter in O.A.No.499T ol 2013, the impugned Charge
Memo in Pro<;.Rc.No.64I5lBll2OO9 dated 2g.O5.2013 issued by
the rcspondent No.4 District Educational Officer, Warangal, was
set aside by thc learred Andhra pradcsh Ldrnir-ristrative Tribunai
(for brevity, "APAT") jn O.A.No.6299 of 2OO9 and batch, more
particularly in O.A.No.4997 of 2013 uide order dated 16.0g.20 13.
In vier' of thr: same. learned Counsel for the petitioners requested
this C.urt to allou, rhe present Writ petitio, (TR) by setting aside
the impugned charge Memo dated 28.05.2013, by following the
orders passed bv the learned ApAT in O.A.No.4997 of 2013 dated
16.08 2013
4.
On the other hand, learned Assistant Government pleader
for Ser.,,ices-l appearr ng for thc respondents, did not dispute the
submissions macle br the learned Counsel for the petitioners and
requested to pass appropriate orders.
/
J
5. In view of the submissions made by both sides, this Writ
Petition (TR) is allowed, by following the orders dated 16.O8.2013
passed by the learned APAT in O.A.No.6299 of 2OO9 and batch,
particularly in O.A.No.4997 of 2Ol3 and the impugned Charge
Memo in Proc.Rc.No.6415/Bll2OO9 dated 28.05.2013 issued by
the respondent No.4 is hereby set aside, insofar as the petitioners
are concerned.
6.
Miscellaleous applications, if arly, pending in this Writ
Petition (TR), shall stand closed. There shall be no order as to
costs. {
Sd/-P.PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Principle Secretary, School Education Department , Secretariat,
Hyderabad, State of Telangana-22
2. The Commissioner & Director of School Education, Government of
Telangana, Hyderabad.
3. The District Collector, Warangal District at Warangal-506001
4. The Districl Educational Officer, Warangal District at Warangal-506001.
5. One CC to SRI K.R.PRABHAKAR, Advocate [OPUC]
6. Two CCs to GP FOR SERVICES-|, High Court for tlre State of Telangana at
.
I
I
Hyderabad [OUT]
7. Two CD Copies
BSR/PMK
J
"-<<:;-
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1110312026
( 64, THE s
o
ORDER
WP(TR).No.764 of 2017
at ntr zW
U
qe
i>
.A
*
i.r rr-
**2',
iil J,-
ALLOWING THE WRlr PETITION (TR),
WITHOUT COSTS
('
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review