Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3301 J
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUST]CE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NO: 14847 OF 2024
Between:
K. Manmadhu, S/o Late K. Ghatya Naik, Aged.41 years, Occ; Ex PC 5455, R/o 1-31,
Nazeerabad Thanda, Parigi Post and Mandal, Vikarabad Distict, Telangana.
.....PETITIONER
AND
1.
The State of Telangana, Rep by its Principal Secretary, Home (Ser.ll) Dept,
Secretariat, Hyderabad, Telangana.
2. The Director General of Police, Hyderabad, Telangana.
3. The Commissioner of Police, Cyberabad, Telangana.
4. lnspector of Police, lbrahimpatnam Police Station, Rachakonda, Telangana.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Ar,ticle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in -the -affidavit Jiled therewith, the High Court may
pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the 3rd respondent in passing final '
orders imposing major punishment by dismissing the petitioner from service vide
proceedings Rc.No.05/majorlPR-1lcybl2O14-16, dated.4-6-2016 and the rejection
of the appeal by the 2nd respondent vide proceeding Rc:No.05/major/PR1lcybl2}14-16, dt.21-11-2}16 and further rejection order passed by the lst
respondent vide proceedings vide Memo.No.2183/ser.ll/A112017, Dt 28-6-2017 as
llegal,-arbitrary, and in violation-of theprinciples of natural justice and set-a-side
the same, and consequently direct the 3rd respondent to reinstate the petitioner
into service with all consequential benefits.
|.A.NO:1 OF 2024
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the vide proceedings Rc.No.05/major/PR-1lcyblZO14-1?, dated;4/612016 and ther rejection of the appeal by the 2nd respondent vide proceeding
Rc.No.05/major/PR-1lcybl2014-16, dt.21l11l 2016 and further rejection order
passed by
the
1st
respondent vide proceedings vide
Memo.No.218:]/ser.111A112017, Dt:281612O17 issued by the 3rd 2nd and 1st
respondents.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SMT G.UMA RANI
Counsel for the Respondents.: G.P FOR SERVICES (HOME)
The Court made the following ORDER
i
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA IGRTHIK
TIIRIT PETITION No.14847 of 2o24
Dated 9th January, 2026.
Between:
K. Manmadhu
.. Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Home (Ser.II) Dept., Secretariat,
Hyderabad, Telangana and three others.
... Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, is
Iiled seeking the following reliel
"...to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature
of Writ of Mahdamus declaring the action of the 3'd respondent in
passing final orders imposing major punishment by dismissiqg the
petitioner from service vide proceedings Rc.No.OS/major/pRLlcyb/2Ola-16, dated:4-6-2016 and the rejection of the appeal by the
2nd respondent vide proceeding Rc.No.05/major/PR-l/cyb/2014-16,
dt:21-11-2016 and further rejection order passed by the lst respondent
vide proceedings vide Memo. No.2 1 83/ ser.II/A | / 20 t7, Dt;28-6-2O17 as
illegal, arbitrar5r, and in violation of the principles of natural justice and
set-a-side the same, and consequently direct the 3'd respond.dnt to
reinstate the petitioner into service with all consequentid blnefits and
pass..."
PK, J
W.P.No.14847 of 2O24
2'
Hea'd Smt. G. Uma Rani, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, and learned Government pleader for Services (Home),
appearing
on behalf cf the respondents
3'
Leartred counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner
was
originally eLppointed as a Police Constable (Civil) vide proceedings dated
04. 1 1 .2oo9, and since then, he has been rendering his
services with
utmost devrtion and diligence. However, respondent No.3 issued a charge
Memo date,1 11.11.2014, alleging (21) days of unauthorized. absence
and
misconduct under Rules 3(1-3) of the Andhra pradesh Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, L964
In response the petitioner submitted his
explanation denying the charges on 10.06.2015. However, without
considering the same, respondent No.3 appointed an enquiry office vide
proceedings dated l4-O7.2015, and the said enquiry oflicer conducted
an
enquiry. Hc,wever, except respondent No.4 herein, who is the complainant
himself, no other witnesses were examined during the enquiry, and
consequentl'r, the enquiry officer submitted his report on 30.1I.201s,
holding the charges leveled against the petitioner as proved beyond
reasonable doubt. Thereafter, respondent No.3 issued proceedings dated
07.12-2015, calling for a final expranation from the petitioner, and the
petitioner submitted his explanation on 24.o2.2oL6, denying the charges
and requestel to drop further action against him.
/
It
,/
)
PK, J
W.P.No.14847 of 2024
4.
It is submitted that the petitioner, in his explanafion, had
specifically stated about his domestic problems, for which, he hd'd sought
for permission, but the same was not granted, and therefore, due to the
unavoidable circumstances, the petitioner remained absent to his duties'
However, without considering the said explanation in proper perspective,
respondent No.3 issued the impugned proceedings dated 04'06'2016,
imposing upon the petitioner a major punishment of dismissal from
service, which is highly disproportionate to the charge. It is submitted
that the petitioner preferred an appeal against the dismissal order before
respondent No.2, but the same was rejected vide proceedings dated
2L.lL.2OL6, without assigning any valid reasons. Thereafter, the revision
preferred by the petitioner was also erroneously rejected by respondent
No.l vide proceedings dated lg.o7.2oI7. It is submitted that the
petitioner has not exhibited any grave misconduct, and he waS absent to
his duties only due to the compelling circumstances prevailing beyond his
i
control. As such, ihe imposition of a major punishment of disrnissal from
service is highly disproportionate. Therefore, learned counsel for the
petitioner seeks indulgence of this Court to set aside the impugned
dismissal order and the orders of rejection in appeal and revision, and
consequently, to direct the respondents to reinstate the petitioner into
service with all consequential benefits.
I
I
I
L
a
PK, J
W.P.No.14847 of 2O24
5.
On t,re other hand, learned Government Pleader appearing on behalf
of the r€sprlndsnts submits that the petitioner was habitually absent to his
duties without obtaining prior permission, and despite repeated warnings,
he continued to remain unauthorisedly absent to his duties on multiple
occasions. Further, the petitioner was frequently found in intoxicated
cqndition, argued with section in-charged, senior Constables and Assistant
Sub-lnspectors of Police, and also failed to cooperate with the co-staff. As
such, basi.rg on the report of respondent No.4 dated 06.09.2014, the
petitioner rvas issued with a Charge Memo dated 11.11.2014. However,
since his e:xplanation to the Charge Memo was unsatisfactory, an oral
enquiry was ordered, and the Additional DSC, Traffic-Il was appointed as
enquiry officer vide proceedings dated 14.O7.2OL5. Thereafter, an oral
enquiry wars conducted, in conformity with the principles of natural justice
and the enquiry officer concluded the enquiry holding the charge leveled
against the petitioner as proved vide enquiry report dated 30.11.2015.
Subsequenlly, vide proceedings dated 07.L2.2O15, a further representation
was called for from the petitioner, and the petitioner submitted his
explanation dated 03.03.2016, and after going through the entire material
*
on record, ::espondent No.3 concluded that the petitioner was a habitual
offender of absenteeism and indiscipline, which is highly intolerable in
such a disc:iplined police force. As such, the petitioner was awarded with
".,J\\
.,
=fl
PK, J
W.P.Nq-14847 of 2O24
the punishment of dismissal from service vide proceedings dated
04.06-2016. Further, since the petitioner's case lacks anlr merit for
consideration, his appeal and revision were rightly rejected by respondent
Nos.2 and I respectively, vide proceedings dated 2l.Ll.2oL6 and
rg.o7.2ol7, respectively. Therefore, it is prayed to dismiss the present
writ petition as devoid of merits.
I
6.
Having regard to the submissions made by the respective parties
and on perusal of the material on record, it is evident that the disciplinary
proceedings initiated against the petitioner, vide charge Memo dated
11.11.2014, culminated with the imposition of a major punishment of
dismissal from service vide proceedings dated o4.06.2oL6 issued by
respondent No.3. Here it pertinent to note that the charge leveled against
the petitioner relates to his unauthorized absence on multiple occasions
for an overall period of (21) days. The petitioner, in his explanation,
categorically asserted that his absence was due to compelling
circumstances and family issues.
a
7.
It is trite law that the scope of judicial review under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India is limited in matters concerning disciplinary
i!4
PK, J
W.P.No.14847 of 2024
\
\
proceediiags. The Hon'ble Apex court, in tlnlon oJ rndla and others u. p.
GunaselcarantT, cate gorically held as follow s :
"2o. Eouallv. it was not open to the High court. in exercise of its
j!.ris4iction under Articles 2201222 of the constitution of tndia. to, eo
UI:o the proportionality of punishment so tone as th;r;;ish;;;tE;
not shock the conscience of the court. In the instant case, tne
dir;ciplinary authority has come to the conclusion that the respondent
la<:ked integrity. No doubt, there are no measurable standards as to
wtat is integrity in service jurisprudence but certainly there are
inrlicators for such assessment. Integrity according to oxford.
Di<:tionary is "moral rFrightness; honest5r". It takes in its swlep, probity,
inrtocence, trustfulness, openness, sincerigr, utamltessness,
im:naculacy, rectitude, uprightness, virtuousniss, righteousness,
go.dness, clea^ness, decency, honour, reputation, nobility,
irrt:proachability, purity, respectability, genuinenes!, moral excellencl,
etc. In short, it depicts sterling character with firm adherence to a code
of rnoral values."
(Emphasis supplied)
8.
Frotn the above, it can be inferred that the punishment so imposed
upon a Gc'vernment servant cannot be interfered with unless it shocks the
judicial ccnscience, and that it shall be commensurate with the proven
misconduc:t. For better appreciation of the instant case, it is relevant to
note that the Government has issued instructions in G.O.Ms.No.260 dated
O4.O9.2OO!), for removal of Government servants from their duties, where
unauthorized absence exceeds one year. However, in the instant case, the
period of at>sence is merely (21) days and the petitioner, in his explanation,
categorically pleaded his family problems and mental agony as the reason
for his abst:nce. In view of the above and duly taking into consideration
the allegati,lns leveled against the petitioner, which are not of so grave
I (2015) 2 SCC)610
-7
PK, J
W.P.No.14847 of 2O24
nature, this Court is of the considered opinion that the impugned
punishment of dismissal from service is highly excessive and
disproportionate to the proven misconduct. Therefore, this Court deems it
appropriate to remand the matter back to the authorities for imposition of
a lesser punishment.
9.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed setting aside the
impugned orders vide Rc.No.OS/Major/PR-1/Cyb/2OL4-16 dated
04.06.2016, Rc.No.O5/Major/PR- I lCyb /2014-16 dated 2l.Ll.2O 16, and
Memo.No.2 183/Ser.II/A1 1 ZOI-Z dated 28.06.2017, respectively, issued by
respondent Nos.3, 2, and 1, respectively, and the matter is remanded back
to respondent No.3 for impositioh of a punishment other than
dismissal I re.movalltermination/compulsory retirement from service. The
respondents are also directed to forthwith reinstate the petitioner into
service.
Miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in this writ petition, shall
stand closed. No costs.
*SDI-C. DE
ANT
//TRUE COPY//
a
ECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Principal Secretary, Home (Ser.ll) Dept,
State of Telahgana
at Hyderabad, Telangana.
2. The Director General of Police, Hyderabad, Telangana
3. The Commissioner of Police,, Cyberabad, Telangana'
4. The lnspector of Police, lbrahim-patnam Police Statipn, Rachakonda,
Telangana.
5. rwo ic's to G.P FOR SERVICES (HOME), High Court for the State of
Telangana at Hyderabad. (OUT)
6. one cc to SMT G.UMA RANI, Advocate IoPUC]
7. Two CD Copies
SA
t
:-'*1
HIGH CISURT
DATED:09/01,2A26
1 I{E S Te
\
U
?
x
| JAl|
*
ORDER
WP.No.1,4847 of 2024
a
ALLOWING THE W.P
WITHOUTCOSTS.
\
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review