Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!
i
132521
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original J urisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JA\UARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTTCE SUREPALLI NANDA
i
I
WRIT PETITION NO: 23835 OF 2020
Between
iK. tVlahender, S/o K.Subbaiah Aged about 53 years, Occ. Chief Executive
'officer, Primary Agriculture coop. society, Garlapadu Koilkonda Mandal,
Mahabubnagar district
r
.PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, Department of
Cooperation, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad. 500 022'
2. The District Collector, Wanaparthy District (Ealier Mahabubnagar District)
Wanaparthy.
3. The District Cooperative officer, JVlahabubnagar, Mahabubnagar District
+. itne primary Agricultural Cooperative Society Ltd, Garlapahad, Koilkonda
Itlandal Mahabubnagar district. Rep.by its President
i
...RESPONDENTS
petition under Article 226 ot the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a Writ, order or direction more one in the nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS
declaring the issuance of proceedings of the 4th respondent dated 2811012020 in
suspending the petitioner from the services of Chief Executive Officer, Primary
i
Agriculture Cooperative Society Ltd., Garlapahad, Nagarkurnool district (Erstwhile
Mahabubnabar district) is illegal, arbitrary, tt/alafide, contrary to the Procedure laid
down in the Section 59 of the Cooperative society Act, and rules, violation of Articles,
14,21of the Constitution of lndia and consequently set aside the same.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 20:20
petition uncer Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend
the operation of tlre proceedings of the 4th respondent dated 28fi012020 by directing
the respondents to continue the petitioner as Chief Executive Officer, PACS,
Garlapahad, Nergarkumool District(Erstwhile tVlahabubnagar District) Pending
disposal of the Writ Petition.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2021
Between:
The primary r\gricultural Cooperative Society Ltd, Garlapahad, Koilkonda Mandal
Mahabubnag;rr district. Rep.by its President
.PETITIONER
AND
1. The Statt: of Telangana, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, Department of
Cooperati,ln, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad. 5OO O222. The District Collector, Wanaparthy District (Ealier Mahabubnagar District)
Wanapartny.
3. The Distrir:t Cooperative officer, Mahabubnagar, Mahabubnagar District
4. K.'Mahender, S/o K.Subbaiah Aged about 53 years, Occ. Chief Executive
Officer, F'rimary Agriculture Coop. Society, Garlapadu Koilkonda Mandal,
Mahabubrragar d istrict
...RESPONDENTS
Petition unCer Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in r;upport of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim order dt.1l8l12l202} in l.A. No. 1 of 2O2O in W.P. No. 23835 of 2020, pending
disposal of the u,rit petition.
l.A. Nb: 1 OF 2023
Between:
The Stat,e of Telangana, Rep.by its Principal Secretary, Department of
Cooperation, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad. 500 022.
The District collector, wanaparthy District (Ealier Mahabubnagar
District)
WanaparthY.
The District cooperative officer, Mahabubnagar, Mahabubnagar
District
...PETITIONERS
AND
chief Executive
K. Mahender, S/o K.Subbaiah Aged about 53 years, occ'
Mandal'
officer, Primary Agriculture coop. society, Garlapadu Koilkonda
1,
Mahabubnagar distric
Garlapahad,
4 The Primary Agricultural cooperative Society Ltd,
MandalMahabubnagardistrict.Rep.byitsPresident
I
Koilkonda
...RESPONDENTS
t
I
i
stated in the
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
may be pleased to vacate the
amoariit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
2020 in w'P' No' 23835 of 2020
tnterin\ order granted on 28.1 2.2ozo in l.A. No. 1 of
I
and dLmiss the Writ petition as devoid of merits'
for the Petitioner: SRI MOHD GULAM RASOOL
Cou
cornl.t for the Respondent No.1 to 3: AGP FOR SERVICES-I|I
I
counlelfor the Respondent No.4: SRt P.VENKATESWAR RAO
i
I
The Court made the following: ORDER
f
I.N THE HIGH COURT OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
-
rttE HoN,BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLT NANDA
WRIT PETITION No.23835 oF 2o2o
DATE: 21St DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
Between:
K. MahenCer
Petitioner
And
State of 'Ielangana & 3 Others
Respondents
ORDER:
Heard sri Mohd Gutam Rasool, learned counsel
appearing on
behalf of
the petitioner and
Sri P.Venkateswar Rao, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of respondent No.4 and the learned Assistant
Governnrent pleader for Services-rrr appearing on behalf
of the respondent Nos.L, Z and 3.
fts: petitioner approached the court seekino prayer
as underi
"...to issue a writ, order or direction more one in the
nature
of \A/RIT oF MANDAMUS decraring the issuance of
proct:edings of the 4th respondent dated 28.10.2020
susp{snding the petitioner from the services of
Execr;tive officer, primary Agricurture cooperative
in
chief
Society
Ltd., Garlapahad, Nagarkurnoot district (Erstwhile
i;{
Snw, J
lvp_2383 5-2020
Mahabubnagar District) is illegal, arbitrary' Malafide'
contrarytotheprocedurelaiddownintheSection5gofthe
cooperative society Act, and rules, violation of Articles 14
and 21 of the constitution of India and consequently set
aside the same and pass such other order or orders as
this
Hon,bleCourtdeemsjustandproperthecircumstancesof
the case...".
3.
PERUSED THE RECORD
2O2O is extracted hereunder:
I.A.No.1 of 2O2O
Counsel for petitioner stated that in similar writ
petition being W-P.trio.7972 of 2020, this Coyrt granted
And
interim suspension on 11'06'2020 in I'A'No' I of 2O2O'
petition
writ
present
iherefore, similar order be passed in the
.
also.
there shall be
In view of the above submission this
order does
interim suspension ut p'uyed for' However'
course of
further
taking
not come in the *",
members
"irespondents
action to enquire into the allegations made by the
of the society against the petitioner'
AKS,I
r
/
J
SN,.I
up_21835_2020
-
orders oranted by this court dated 2g.12.2o2o passed in
r.A..N.o;t of 202o in w.p.No.23g35 of 2o2o and puts-forth
the foll<lwino submissions:
i) tn pursuance to the interim orders granted in favour of
the petitioner, a letter No.RC.No.65/20 2\-cL,dated 26.02.202L,
was issued by the District cooperative officer, Mahabubnagar
District, 1:o the president, PACS Limited, Garlapahad.
ii) The matter had been examined and placed before the
Committt:e and a resolution was passed in favour of the
petitioner on 08.03.202L and on the same day i.e .,
on
08.03.2021, respondent No.4, namely, the president, PACS
Limited, (iarlapahad, had sent a letter to the petitioner herein
by
registered post and the same was received by the petitioner
on
10.03.20.21 and the letter dated 08.03.2021was also pasted
on
the hous': of the petitioner, intimating the petitioner that the
respondent No.4/Society has passed a resolution to
take the
services of the petitioner into the society at Garlapahad,
Koilkonda, Mahabubnagar District. However, the petitioner
did
not join ard resume his duties.
iii) Another letter dated 16.03.2021 was sent to the
learned crluflser for the petitioner, which was received
by the
e'
SN. J
wp_23835_2020
learned counsel for the petitioner on 17.03.2021' However, the
petitioner visited the office only once and thereafter did not
attend his duties till date. Subsequently, proceedings dated
16.02.2025 vide Order No. PACS-Garlapah adl2}25l1 was issued
against the petitioner by the Managing committee of the Primary
Agricultural cooperative Society Limited, Garlapahad, under
Section 59 of the Telangana Cooperative Societies Act, L964'
removing the petitioner from service as Secretary of the Society
with immediate effect.
infructuous.
5.
The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner
submits that it is incorrect to say that the petitioner
was absent
from duty and that the petitioner had, in fact, attended
of the respondent No.4-Society, however, the
the office
petitioner was not
permitted to do any work and therefore, the writ
petitioner is
entitledforthesubstantiveallowancefromthedateof
the letter dated
suspension to till the date of issuance of
08.03 .202L, which WaS forwarded
to the petitioner herein,
l1:
SN. J
\\,p _2-1835__2020
intimating the petitioner about the resolution of the respondent
No.4-sor:iety to allow the petitioner to perform duties and to join
duty.
DISCUISSION AND CONCLUSION:
6.
On bare perusal of the record and counter affidavit filed on
behalf of the respondent No.4 herein, it is evident that the said
counter affidavit had been filed on 19.08.2023. In view of the
interim orders of this Court dated 28.L2.2020 passed in LA.No.1
of 2020 n w.P.No.23835 of 2020, which clearly stipulated that
the said interim orders did not come in the way of the
respondents taking further course of action to enquire into the
allegatiors made by the members of the society against the
petitioner herein, action had been initiated against the petitioner
under ser:tion 59 of the provisions of the Telangana cooperative
Societies Act, 1964.
7.
The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent
No.4/society brings on record the proceedings dated t6.02.2o2s
vide order- No.pcAS-Garlapahad/2ozs/L, issued by the Managing
committee of the primary Agricultural cooperative society
Limited, Garlapahad, Mahabubnagar District and bare perusal of
the same indicates that an order of removal had been passed
:qr
SN. J
wp_23835_2020
against the petitioner herein, removing the petitioner from
service as Secretary of the respondent No.4-Society with
immediate effect.
B. In view of the fact as borne on record that the prayer
sought for by the petitioner is for issuance of a Writ of
mandamus declaring the issuance of proceedings, dated
28.tO.2O2O, issued by the respondent No.4, suspending the
petitioner from service of the respondent No.4/Society, as illegal
and arbitrary and to set aside the same and in view of the fact as
borne on record that the said suspension proceedings ultimately
culminated in an order of removal vide proceedings No.PACSGarlapah ad/2025/ 1, dated t6.02.2025, issued by the Managing
Committee of the respondent No.4-Society, the relief sought for
by the petitioner cannot be granted at this point of time.
g. In so far as the request of the learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the petitioner for release of substantive allowance to
the petitioner is concerned, this Court opines that the same is
beyond the scope of the prayer as sought for by the petitioner
herein and further, in view of the specific plea of the respondent
No.4-Society that the petitioner failed to join duty pursuant to
the resolution of the respondent No.4-Committee dated
/
SN. J
wp_2381 5_2020
:
I
I
t
I
I5
I
t
I
t
i
l
08.03.2'.021, which was communicated to the petitioner to join
duty and the said contention being disputed by the petitioner
that thr: petitioner was not permitted to work cannot be gone
into untier writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, since this court opines such disputed questions of fact
cannot be adjudicated in the present writ petition.
10. r4
i) The aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case.
ii)
The submissions made by the learned counsel
appeariing on behalf of the petitioner and the learned
counsel' appearing on behalf of respondent No.4 and the
learned Assistant Government pleader for services-rrr
appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos.1, 2 and 3.
iii)
The averments made in the counter affidavit filed
on
behalf of the respondent No.4 and
iv)
The interim orders passed in favour of the petitioner
dated 28.12.2o2o in r.A.No.l of 2o2o in w.p.No.23835
2025 (rr:ferred to and extracted above)
I
of
SN. J
wp_23835_2020
n
shall be no order as to costs'
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this
Writ
+
Petition, shall stand closed'
SD'. S. MALLIKARJUNA RAO
STANT RE
I
t
I
//TRUE COPY/'
l
i
SECTION OFFICER
I
I
{
I
I
To,
t
I
of Coo
r. i The Principal Secretary, Depa'tl:nt
022'
Hvoo"uud, State of Teiangana- 500
District (Ealie
2 The District Collector, Wanaparthy
,l
WanaParthY.
Secretariat Buildings,
Mahabubnagar District)
District
Mahabubnaga r, [r/lahabubnagar
3. The District Cooperative officer'
CooPerative SocietY Ltd, GarlaPahad,
4. The President, Primary Agricultural
r district.
Koil konda Mandal Mahabubnaga
RAS OOL, Advocate [OPUC]
5. One CC to SRI MOHD GULAM
RAO , Advocate IOPUCI
6. One CC to SRI P.VENKATESWAR
State of Telangana' at
SERVICES-Ill, High Court for the
7_ Two CCs to GP F OR
Hyderabad [OUT]
8. Two CD CoPies
BS R
GJP
CC TODAY
HIG
COIJRT
I
oateo: 2',110112026
o
ER
WP No.231835 of 2020
o
* r)
.!lil';
..,.;:
'i:. "
DIS POSING OF THE WRIT PETITION t
i
WITHOUTCOSTS
t
I
i
I
i
i
\\ -\fft
'e
,11 APB 2026
L)
C}
b
*
FS PAT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review