The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Thus, in view preceding analysis, the order impugned contained in Annexure-P/4 and Annexure-P/5 deserve to be and are hereby quashed. The respondents are directed to restore the benefit of pay-scale of Rs.975-1650, revised pay-scale of Rs.1150-1800, and further revised pay-scale of Rs.35005200 to the petitioners, with effect from the due dates. Accordingly, any amount recovered on the strength of the impugned orders contained in Annexure-P/4 6:55:13 PM and Annexure-P/5 be also refunded to the petitioners within a period of ninety days from the date of production of certified copy of this order.
16. With the aforesaid, the writ petition stands allowed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MANINDER S. BHATTI
ON THE 7 th OF NOVEMBER, 2023
WRIT PETITION No. 19282 of 2019
BETWEEN:-
Signed by: AJAY KUMAR
CHATURVEDI
Signing time: 11/9/2023
6:55:13 PM
1.
JOSEPH
VARGHESE
S/O
LATE
KURIEN
VARGHESE,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS,
OCCUPATION: HAND PUMP MECHANIC R/O DX/E 44 OLD MIND RESIDENCY, J.K. ROAD,
GOVINDPURA,
BHOPAL
(M.P.)
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
MUJEEB AHMED (DIED) THROUGH LRS. SMT.
KISHWAR JAHAN W/O LATE SHRI MUJEEB
AHMED, AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HOUSEWIFE 9/1 CHAMARPURA (CHATAIPURA)
BUDWARA HUZUR BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
SAAD AHMED S/O LATE MUJEEB AHMED, AGED
ABOUT 25 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE 9/1
CHAMARPURA (CHATAIPURA) BUDWARA HUZUR
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
MUNEER AHMED S/O LATE SHRI MUJEEB
AHMED, AGED ABOUT 18 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
STUDENT 9/1 CHAMARPURA (CHATAIPURA)
BUDWARA HUZUR BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
(Above LRs of the deceased - Mujeeb Ahmad were
brought on record vide Court order dated 31-08-2023)
5.
RAGHUNATHSINGH S/O BHIKAMSINGH THAKUR,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS, OCCUPATION: HAND
PUMP MECHANIC A-19 ROHIT NAGAR BAIRASIA
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
RAMKRISHNA S/O HALKAIPRASAD NAMDEV,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, OCCUPATION: HAND
PUMP MECHANIC R/O 139, PRIYADARSHINI
NAGAR T.T. NAGAR BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
7.
NAGESHWAR PRASAD S/O RAMKUMAR PRASAD
SHARMA, AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HAND PUMP MECHANIC 739 NORTH T.T. NAGAR
BANGANGA BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
8.
RAJENDRA PRASAD S/O SHIVMANGAL SINGH
YADAV, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
HAND PUMP MECHANIC VILLAGE POST RUHANA
TEHSIL BERASIA DISTRICT BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI KAMAL KISHORE KAUSHAL AND SHRI ABHAY GUPTA ADVOCATES )
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THR. ITS
SECRETARY PUBLIC HEALTH ENGINEERING
DEPTT. VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL (M.P.)
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
THE ENGINEER IN CHIEF PUBLIC HEALTH
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT R/O JAL BHAWAN,
BANGANGA BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
THE
CHIEF
ENGINEER PUBLIC
HEALTH
ENGINEERING
DEPARTMENT SATPURA
BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PUBLIC HEALTH
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT DIVISION BHOPAL
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, MATA MANDIR CHOURAHA,
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
THE
JOINT
DIRECTOR TREASURY AND
ACCOUNTS
DEPARTMENT
(FINANCE
D EPARTM EN T) SATPURA BHAWAN BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SANJEEV KUMAR SINGH - PANEL LAWYER)
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
This is a petition filed by the petitioners while praying for the
following reliefs :
"(a)
Signed by: AJAY KUMAR
CHATURVEDI
Signing time: 11/9/2023
6:55:13 PM
That, the disputed order Annexure-P/4 and P/5
may kindly be quashed and the respondents be directed to
grant the petitioners their salary as pay scale of Rs.975-1650
revised Rs.1150-1800 p.m. it is further revised 3500-5200
p.m. from the date of their intially appointment as Hand
Pump Mechanics.
(b)
allowance,
That, same as total arrears of pay scale,
other
benefits
from
the
date
of
their
appointments.
(c) Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court deems fit
in the interest of justice may also be awarded in favour of the
petitioners."
2.
The facts as detailed in the writ petition, reveal that the petitioners
herein, were initially appointed as daily-rated employees in the Public Health
Engineering Department. Thereafter, the petitioners were posted as Hand Pump
Mechanics in the Work-charged Establishment by the orders which are
contained in Anenxure-P/1.
The petitioners were granted the pay-scale of
Rs.975-1650 and its revised scale i.e. Rs.1150-1800, and thereafter further
revised pay-scale of Rs.3500-5200. The petitioners were drawing regular payscale of Rs.975-1650 (revised pay-scale Rs.1150-1800) from the date of their
initial appointment. However, the respondents suddenly without issuing any
show cause notice and opportunity of hearing to the petitioners, reduced the
pay-scale from Rs.975-1650 (revised pay-scale Rs.1150-1800) and re-fixed the
petitioners' pay at the lower pay-scale of Rs.870-1420 (revised pay-scale
Rs.950-1530).
3.
The action of the respondents of reducing the pay-scale on the
strength of the order dated 12-10-2018 and also the subsequent order dated 10Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AJAY KUMAR
CHATURVEDI
Signing time: 11/9/2023
6:55:13 PM
06-2019 which are contained in Annexure-P/5 and Annexure-P/4 respectively,
are the subject-matter of challenge in this writ petition.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners contends that in the present case,
the impugned orders deserve to be quashed, inasmuch as firstly, the
Department of Public Health Engineering issued a Circular dated 20-04-1988
contained in Annexure-P/7 and it was decided by the Government that Hand
Pump Mechanics will be entitled for the pay-scale of Rs.975-1650.
5. It is further contended by the learned counsel that the aspect of grant
of the said pay-scale to the Hand Pump Mechanics came up for consideration
before this Court in W.P. No.4473 of 2009 (S) [Ajay Singh Rathore vs.
State of M.P. and others] and this Court found the petitioners therein entitled
for the pay-scale of Rs.975-1650 with its further revision, who were working as
Hand Pump Mechanics in the said pay-scale.
6. It is further contended by the learned counsel for the petitioners that
the judgment in the case of Ajay Singh Rathore (supra) has been
subsequently considered by this Court in the case of Jagjit Singh vs. The
State of M.P. & ors. (W.P. No.12488/2003 ) and this Court has quashed the
recovery while placing reliance on the decision in the case of Ajay Singh
Rathore (supra). It is, therefore, contended by the learned counsel that the
impugned orders deserve quashment. It is the further contention of the counsel
that the petitioner vide covering memo dated 27-10-2023 (I.A. No.14413/2023)
enclosed a copy of the M.P. Work-charged Contingency Paid Employees
Revision of Pay Rules, 1990.
7. It is contended by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the said
Rules came in force with effect from 01-01-1986 and as per the Scheduled
appended to the Rules the pay-scale of Rs.975-1650 was revised to the paySignature Not Verified
Signed by: AJAY KUMAR
CHATURVEDI
Signing time: 11/9/2023
6:55:13 PM
scale of Rs.1150-1800. Therefore, contends that the impugned order contained
in Annexure-P/5 which suggests that the petitioners were entitled for the said
pay-scale from a prospective date i.e. 07-07-1998 and not from the year 1988 is
misconceived.
It is contended by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the
impugned orders have been issued in ignorance of the Circular dated 20-041988 and also the law laid down by this Court in Ajay Singh Rathore
(supra). Thus, the learned counsel submits that the impugned orders deserve
to be set aside.
8.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submits that a
detailed order has been passed by the respondents which is contained in
Annexure-P/5. It is contended by the learned counsel that the petitioners were
initially extended the pay-scale of Rs.975-1650 and on the contrary, they were
entitled for the pay-scale of Rs.950-1530, the pre-revised pay-scale of the same
was Rs.870-1420. Therefore, the said aspect having been appreciated by the
authorities, the orders impugned have been passed, which require no
interference by this Court.
9. No other point is pressed or argued by the parties.
10.
Heard the submissions advanced on behalf of the parties and
perused the records.
11.
In the present case, the controversy is as regards the extension of
benefit of pay-scale of Rs.975-1650, revised pay-scale of Rs.1150-1800 and
further revised pay-scale of Rs.3500-5200 from the date of appointment to the
petitioners against the post of Hand Pump Mechanics. The records reflect that
the petitioners herein, were appointed in the Work-charged Establishment
Signed by: AJAY KUMAR
CHATURVEDI
Signing time: 11/9/2023
6:55:13 PM
against the post of Hand Pump Mechanic and they were granted pay-scale of
Rs.975-1650 which is evident from Annexure-P/2 dated 29-12-1988. The said
order dated 29-12-1988 was issued in terms of the Circular issued by the Public
Health Engineering Department, dated 20-04-1988.
12.
The said Circular specifically provided that the Hand Pump
Mechanics shall be entitled for the pay-scale of Rs.975-1650.
Therefore,
undisputedly, the present petitioners having been appointed as Hand Pump
Mechanics in the Work-charged Establishment, were extended the pay-scale of
Rs.975-1650. As the said pay-scale was being withdrawn by the Department,
some of the employees approached this Court and this Court in Ajay Singh
Rathore (supra) passed the following order :
“In the present case it has been admitted that the petitioners
were appointed in the pay-scale of Rs.975-1650 and the order
passed by the M.P. State Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No.5/94
also reflects that the petitioners were enjoying the pay scale of
Rs.975-1650 at the time of their appointment and the action of the
respondents in withdrawing the aforesaid pay scale was held to be
bad in law. The petitioners by virtue of the order passed by the
Tribunal were entitled for pay-scale of Rs.975-1650. However,
erroneously higher pay scale of Rs.1150-1800 was paid to the
petitioner and w.e.f. 1/9/96 the pay scale of Rs.975-1650 has been
revised to Rs.3500-5200 and the respondents have also admitted
in the impugned order dated 11/5/09 that the petitioners are
entitled for the aforesaid pay scale of Rs.3500-5200 and,
therefore, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
petitioners are
certainly entitled for the pay scale of Rs.3500-5200 w.e.f. 1/1/96.
Signed by: AJAY KUMAR
CHATURVEDI
Signing time: 11/9/2023
6:55:13 PM
So far as the excess amount received by the petitioners on account
of wrong fixation is concerned, as the petitioners were not at fault
in the matter, the question of recovering the same in the light of
judgment delivered in the case of Sahibram (supra) does not arise.
Resultantly, pay fixation done by the respondents is upheld
in the matter. However, the recovery ordered against the
petitioners is quashed.
With the aforesaid, the writ petition stands partly allowed.
No order as to costs.”
13.
The order passed in Ajay Singh Rathore (supra) has attained
finality, as the said order was affirmed by the Division Bench by a slight
modification and the subsequent SLP was not entertained by the Apex Court.
Therefore, since the petitioners herein, also stand on similar footing, as they
were extended the benefit of pay-scale of Rs.975-1650 at the time of their initial
appointment,
by virtue of the impugned orders they could not have been
deprived of the said benefit.
14. The respondents in the entire return have failed to controvert the
asseveration as regards the Circular dated 20-04-1988 contained in AnnexureP/8. The respondents have also failed to controvert the fact that the Revision
of Pay Rules 1990 came into force with effect from 01-01-1986 by which the
pay-scale of Rs.975-1650 was revised to Rs.1150-1800.
15. Thus, in view preceding analysis, the order impugned contained in
Annexure-P/4 and Annexure-P/5 deserve to be and are hereby quashed. The
respondents are directed to restore the benefit of pay-scale of Rs.975-1650,
revised pay-scale of Rs.1150-1800, and further revised pay-scale of Rs.35005200 to the petitioners, with effect from the due dates. Accordingly, any amount
recovered on the strength of the impugned orders contained in Annexure-P/4
Signed by: AJAY KUMAR
CHATURVEDI
Signing time: 11/9/2023
6:55:13 PM
and Annexure-P/5 be also refunded to the petitioners within a period of ninety
days from the date of production of certified copy of this order.
16. With the aforesaid, the writ petition stands allowed.
(MANINDER S. BHATTI)
JUDGE
ac
Signed by: AJAY KUMAR
CHATURVEDI
Signing time: 11/9/2023
6:55:13 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review