Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010174222025
2026:GAU-AS:304
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : RSA/131/2025
JAVED PERVEZ CHOUDHURY
S/O. ATIQUE UDDIN CHOUDHURY, R/O. CHANDRAPUR PART-I, P/S. LALA,
DIST. HAILAKANDI, ASSAM.
VERSUS
BEGUM NAJIFA YASMIN CHOUDHURY
D/O. BADRUL HUDA CHOUDHURY, R/O. RANGAUTI PART-I, P/S. AND DIST.
HAILAKANDI, PIN-788151, ASSAM.
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A K HANNAN, MR M J QUADIR
Advocate for the Respondent : MS. S K LASKAR, MR. S R BARBHUIYA,MR M HUSSAIN,MR.
N HAQUE,MR. A K AZAD
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE MITALI THAKURIA
JUDGMENT
Date : 08-01-2026
Heard Mr. M.J. Quadir, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr. N.
Haque, learned counsel for the sole respondent.
2.
This is an appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
against the judgment and decree dated 25.06.2025 passed by the Learned Civil
Judge (Sr. Div.), Hailakandi, in T.A. No. 09/2025, whereby the judgment &
Page No.# 2/11
decree passed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi in Matrimonial (D)
Suit No. 18/2024 was set aside.
3.
After hearing the appellant, this Court had framed the following
substantial question of law:“Whether the learned lower appellate Court has rightly set aside the
Judgment and Decree passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Hailakandi, in Matrimonial (D) Suit No. 18/2024, on the
ground of jurisdiction in the absence of jurisdictional Family Court?”
4.
It is submitted by Mr. M.J. Quadir, the learned counsel for the appellant
that the present appellant as a plaintiff had filed a Matrimonial (D) Suit before
the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi which was registered as the
Matrimonial (D) Suit No. 18/2024, whereby it was prayed for a declaration of
dissolution of marriage dated 25.07.2021, in the form of talaq along with a
decree for confirmation of written divorce, executed and given by the appellant
on 12.11.2023, 17.12.2023 and 30.01.2024 to the respondent, with further
prayer for declaratory relief that the marriage between the appellant and the
respondent is dissolved & freeing them from their marital tie.
5.
Mr. Quadir, the learned counsel for the appellant further submitted that
during pendency of the suit, the appellant had adduced five witnesses including
himself and exhibited some documents.
6.
After considering the evidence on record as well as the document
adduced, the Learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi had passed the judgment
Page No.# 3/11
dated 15.05.2025 with the following reliefs:
(i) that the marriage between the parties stands dissolved in the f
orm of 'talaq'; and
(ii)that the written divorce/talaq executed by the appellant is hereby
confirmed.
7.
Mr. Quadir, the learned counsel for the appellant further submitted that
notices were duly served upon the defendant/respondent but failed to appear
before the learned Trial Court below and the case proceeded exparte. He further
submitted that the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi had made detail
discussions on the following issues:
(i) Whether the marriage between plaintiff and defendant is
dissolved upon talaq by the plaintiff?
(ii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the decree as prayed for?
8.
Thereafter, considering the documents as exhibited by the appellant,
wherein it has also been shown that he issued three (3) consecutive notices to
the defendant/respondent but in spite of receiving those notices, she never
returned to her matrimonial house and as per the requirement of ‘talaq e hasan’
and as such the divorce was already completed. Thereafter, the learned Civil
Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi had passed the decree, declaring that the marriage
between the parties stands dissolved in the form of talaq and the written
divorce/talaq, executed by the plaintiff was also confirmed.
9.
Mr. Quadir, the learned counsel for the appellant further submitted that it
is not a case of seeking any divorce before the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.),
Hailakandi but it was case seeking declaration that the talaq which was given by
Page No.# 4/11
the plaintiff in written form is valid and the wife can be considered as a divorced
wife of the present appellant. Thus, the learned counsel submitted that there
cannot be any bar to entertain such nature of declaratory suit by the learned
Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi and the consequent decree passed by the
learned Trial Court as a valid one. He further submitted that thereafter, the
respondent/defendant had preferred an appeal in the Court of learned Civil
Judge (Sr. Div.), Hailakandi against the said judgment and decree passed by the
learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi on 15.05.2025 and 22.05.2025, which
was registered as the T.A. No. 09/2025, and the learned Appellate Court had
framed three issues for determination but without discussing on the merit of the
case had allowed the appeal only with the view that the learned Civil Judge (Jr.
Div.), Hailakandi has no jurisdiction to entertain such nature of case and as a
result, the appellate Court had declared the decree passed by the learned Civil
Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi as nullity and there is no further discussion on the
merit of the case.
10.
Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree passed by the learned
Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), Hailakandi in T.A. No. 09/2025, the present Regular second
Appeal has been preferred under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908.
11.
The learned counsel for the appellant further submitted that the learned
appellate Court had misconceived with the law and failed to appreciate the fact
that the plaintiff/appellant had approached the Court of learned Civil Judge (Jr.
Div.), Hailakandi only with a prayer for declaration that the talaq given by the
plaintiff is a valid talaq as well as with a further declaration that the written
talaq/divorce, executed and given by the appellant/plaintiff on 12.11.2023,
Page No.# 5/11
17.12.2023 and 30.01.2024 can be considered as a final talaq. He further
submitted that as per the Family Courts Act, 1984, the District Judge Court and
the other subordinate Courts are barred in entertaining the matrimonial disputes
which includes decree for divorce, decree of nullity, restitution of conjugal
rights, judicial separation or dissolution of marriage or any other suit/ petitioners
that are filed under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 and/or Special Marriage Act,
1954. But here in the instant case, the appellant had only prayed for a
declaration that the talaq which was given by the plaintiff/appellant on three
subsequent dates in written form was a valid talaq, which was accordingly
decreed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi. So, the question of
entertaining such kind of petition by the Family Court or in absence of the
Family Court, by the Court of District Judge does not arise at all as the Court of
Munsiff or Civil Judge (Jr. Division) has every authority and power to entertain
such declaratory suit.
12.
In support of his submission, Mr. Quadir, the learned counsel for the
appellant relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Samar Kumar Roy through Legal Represntative (Mother) vs. Jharna Bera ,
reported in (2017) 9 SCC 591 and basically emphasized on para 15 and 16,
which reads as under:
“15. It is obvious that a suit or proceeding between parties to a marriage for a decree
of nullity or restitution of conjugal rights or judicial separation or dissolution of
marriage, all have reference to suits or petitions that are filed under the Hindu
Marriage Act and/or Special Marriage Act for the aforesaid reliefs. There is no
reference whatsoever to suits that are filed for declaration of a legal character under
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act. Indeed, in Dhulabhai v. Madhya Pradesh (1968) 3
SCR 662, this Court had occasion to consider whether the civil court’s jurisdiction was
expressly or impliedly barred by statute. After referring to a number of judgments, this
Court laid down 7 propositions of law, of which two are of relevance to the present
case:
Page No.# 6/11
“32......(2) Where there is an express bar of the jurisdiction of the court, an
examination of the scheme of the particular Act to find the adequacy or the
sufficiency of the remedies provided may be relevant but is not decisive to
sustain the jurisdiction of the civil court.
Where there is no express exclusion the examination of the remedies and the
scheme of the particular Act to find out the intendment becomes necessary and
the result of the inquiry may be decisive. In the latter case it is necessary to see if
the statute creates a special right or a liability and provides for the
determination of the right or liability and further lays down that all questions
about the said right and liability shall be determined by the tribunals so
constituted, and whether remedies normally associated with actions in Civil
Courts are prescribed by the said statute or not.
*
*
*
*
(7) An exclusion of the jurisdiction of the Civil Court is not readily to be inferred
unless the conditions above set down apply.”
16.
On a reading of the aforesaid propositions, it is clear that the examination of the
remedies provided and the scheme of the Hindu Marriage Act and of the Special
Marriage Act show that the statute creates special rights or liabilities and provides for
determination of rights relating to marriage. The Acts do not lay down that all questions
relating to the said rights and liabilities shall be determined only by the Tribunals which
are constituted under the said Act. Section 8(a) of the Family Courts Act excludes the
Civil Court’s jurisdiction in respect of a suit or proceeding which is between the parties
and filed under the Hindu Marriage Act or Special Marriage Act, where the suit is to
annul or dissolve a marriage, or is for restitution of conjugal rights or judicial
separation. It does not purport to bar the jurisdiction of the Civil Court if a suit is filed
under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act for a declaration as to the legal character of
an alleged marriage. Also as was pointed out, an exclusion of the jurisdiction of the
civil courts is not readily inferred. Given the line of judgments referred to by the High
Courts, and given the fact that a suit for declaration as to legal character which
includes the matrimonial status of parties to a marriage when it comes to a marriage
which allegedly has never taken place either de jure or de facto, it is clear that the civil
court’s jurisdiction to determine the aforesaid legal character is not barred either
expressly or impliedly by any law”.
13.
In that context, the learned counsel for the appellant also placed reliance
on the judgment of a co-ordinate Bench of this Court passed in RSA No.49/2024
(Tika Ram Nepal vs. Ambika Devi) and emphasized on para 14 of the said
judgment, which reads as under:
Page No.# 7/11
“14. I have decided to agree with Mr. Biswas when he submitted that the Family courts
Act would be applicable where there is a Family Court. At Sonitpur, there is no Family
Court. So, the citizens of Sonitpur has to depend upon the available courts there. They
cannot be compelled to travel to another place or city to get legal relief. Moreover,
Section 8A of the Family Courts Act excludes civil court’s jurisdiction in respect of a suit
or proceeding which is between the parties and filed under the Hindu Marriage Act or
Special Marriage Act where the suit is to annul or dissolve a marriage or is for
restitution of conjugal rights or judicial separation. It does not purport to bar
jurisdiction of the civil court if a suit is filed under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act
for a declaration as to the legal character of an alleged marriage”.
14.
Mr. N. Haque, learned counsel appearing for the sole respondent
submitted in this regard that the learned appellate Court had rightly passed the
order, as the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi has no jurisdictional
authority to pass such kind of declaration. Mr. Haque further submitted that
though it is stated to be a declaratory suit but by the said suit, the appellant is
seeking for a decree of divorce which cannot be entertained or passed by the
Court of learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi. Mr. Haque accordingly
submitted that the learned appellate Court had rightly discussed the point of
jurisdiction and accordingly, it was held that the decree which was passed by
the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi is a nullity, as it did not possess any
jurisdictional authority to pass such kind of declaration, whereby the prayer for
declaration of divorce is granted by the learned Court below. Mr. Haque further
submitted that it is the Family Court under which such nature of matrimonial
suits/petitions can be decided and in absence of the Family Court, the District
Judge has the authority/power to entertain such kind of matrimonial suit/
petitions.
15.
Mr. Haque further submitted that as per Section 8 of the Family Courts
Act, 1984, the jurisdiction of the District Judge or Subordinate Court is barred in
presence of the Family Court and where the Family Court is absent, it is only the
wherein such kind of matrimonial suits/proceedings seeking divorce or
Page No.# 8/11
dissolution of marriage etc. can be entertained by the District Court or by the
District Judge. He further submitted that the learned appellate Court had also
granted the opportunity to the appellant to approach the proper forum, seeking
the decree of divorce through talaq and instead of approaching the appropriate
forum, the appellant had approached this Court by filing this appeal under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which is not maintainable and
the same is liable to be dismissed. Mr. Haque accordingly submitted that there is
no reason to make any interference in the judgment and order passed by the
learned appellate Court in the T.A. No. 09/2025, whereby the judgment &
decree, passed on 25.06.2025.
16.
Hearing the submissions made by learned counsel for both sides, I have
also perused the case record and the annexure filed along with the appeal.
17.
The present Regular Second Appeal has been filed under Section 100 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, against the judgment and decree dated
25.06.2025 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), Hailakandi, in T.A. No.
09/2025, whereby the judgment & decree passed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr.
Div.), Hailakandi in Matrimonial (D) Suit No. 18/2024 was set aside. However,
the learned appellate Court had made an observation that the parties are at
liberty to approach the appropriate forum for relief.
18.
While passing the impugned order, the learned appellate Court did not
discuss the case on merit and only on the point of jurisdiction, the appeal was
decided with the observation that the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi
had no jurisdiction to try a case which relates to matrimonial dispute, by which
the appellant sought for relief of decree of divorce. It is also observed by the
Page No.# 9/11
learned appellate Court that the “District Court” is the competent forum to deal
with the matrimonial issues under the Hindu Marriage Act in absence of the
Family Court and in that case, the District Court would be equally competent to
deal with the matrimonial issues under dissolution of Muslim Marriage Act in
absence of the Family Court. It is further held that the learned Civil Judge (Jr.
Div.), Hailakandi is neither the Court with an equivalent jurisdiction, competency
or authority to that of the Family Court and the District Court, to deal with such
cases and thus, without much discussion on the merit of the case, the learned
Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), Hailakandi had opined that the judgment and the decree
passed by the Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi is a nullity on the point of lack of
jurisdiction. Accordingly, the substantial question of law is also formulated as
stated above, wherein also the jurisdictional issue is raised.
19.
It is a settled law that the family disputes, the dissolution of marriage,
decree of divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act or the Special Marriage Act can
only be entertained by the Family Court under Sections 7 & 8 of the Family
Courts Act, 1984 and in absence of the Family Court, the District Court can
examine the matters. It is also rightly observed by the learned Appellate Court
that in view of Section 2(4) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, read with
Sections 3/17 of General Clauses Act, 1897, the “District Court” with family
jurisdiction would be a Principal Civil Court of original jurisdiction i.e. the learned
District.
20.
Here in the present case, it is the plea of the appellant that he has not
sought for any decree of divorce or talaq, before the Court of Civil Judge (Jr.
Div.), Hailakandi. It is the further claim of the appellant that on three
subsequent date i.e. on 12.11.2023, 17.12.2023 and 30.01.2024, the appellant
Page No.# 10/11
had already given written talaq to the respondent and even after service of
those three notices, the respondent did not return to her matrimonial house and
thus the talaq is complete within the meaning of talaq-e-hasan. But it is seen
that while passing the impugned judgment and decree, the learned Civil Judge
(Jr. Div.), Hailakandi had passed the decree that the marriage between the
parties stands dissolved in the form of talaq and the written divorce/talaq,
executed by the plaintiff on 12.11.2023, 17.12.2023 and 30.01.2024, was also
confirmed.
21.
Thus it is seen that though it is submitted by Mr. Quadir, the learned
counsel for the appellant that it was merely a declaratory suit in regards to the
talaq given by the plaintiff but it is seen that the learned trial Court below had
already dissolved the marriage between the parties in the form of talaq and thus
it is seen that in the garb of declaration of valid talaq, the learned Civil Judge
(Jr. Div.), Hailakandi had authenticated the talaq given by the appellant husband
to the respondent wife. It is also not a case that a simple declaration is sought
for any legal character under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 which
has already been observed by the Hon’ble Apex Court but it is a case wherein in
the name of declaratory suit, the plaintiff is seeking a divorce decree which is
authenticated by the Court of learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi, under his
seal and signature. Accordingly, it is not a simple case of declaration under
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963, rather the plaintiff is seeking a
decree of divorce/talaq by the Matrimonial (D) Suit No. 18/2024, which he had
filed before the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi.
22.
It is a settled principle that in absence of the Family Court in the District,
the only competent authority to deal with such matrimonial matter is by the
Page No.# 11/11
District Judge or the Civil Court. But the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.), Hailakandi
had no such authority or power to pass any decree of divorce/talaq.
23.
Thus, this Court is of the opinion that the learned appellate Court did not
commit any error or mistake while disposing the appeal on the point of
jurisdiction with a further direction to the parties to approach the appropriate
forum, seeking any relief of divorce/talaq. Further, the appellate Court had
rightly observed that the decree passed by the learned Civil Judge (Jr. Div.),
Hailakandi can be considered as a nullity due to lack of jurisdiction and hence,
the question of discussion on merit on the other issues are also does not arise
and accordingly, the appellate Court had rightly observed and passed the
judgment and award dated 25.06.2025, passed in T.A. No. 09/2025 directing the
parties to approach the competent authority.
24.
Accordingly, in the opinion of this Court, the appeal is devoid of merit and
accordingly dismissed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review