Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC040010062022
2026:GAU-AP:475
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Crl.A. (J) No. 12 (AP) of 2022
1. Shri Jaha Ekroya, S/o-Shri Duti Ekroya, R/o-Italin,
PO/PS-Anini, District Dibang Valley, Arunachal Pradesh.
……..Appellant
-Versus1. The State of Arunachal Pradesh, represented by the
learned Public Prosecutor.
2. SmtiNutha Pulu @ Shanti Pulu, W/o-Shri Chana Milli
PO/PS-Anini, District-Upper Dibang Valley, Arunachal
Pradesh.
……Respondents/Opposite Parties
Advocates for the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. M. Boje, Adv.
Mr. M. Doji, Adv.
Advocates for the Respondent(s)
: Mr. G. Tado, Addl. P.P.
Mr. J. Jini, LAC.
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: 09.03.2026
Date of pronouncement of Judgment
: 15.05.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the Judgment ?
: NA
Whether the full Judgment has been
pronounced ?
: Yes
::BEFORE::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (C AV)
Heard Mr. M. Doji, learned Amicus Curiae for the Appellant.
Also heard Mr. G. Tado, learned Addl. P.P., representing the State
and Mr. J. Jini, learned Legal Aid Counsel for the victim.
2.
The instant appeal, under Section 374(2) of the Criminal
Procedure Code, 1973, has been filed assailing the Judgment &
Order of conviction and sentence dated 20.12.2021 in Sessions
Case No. 50/(UDV)/2012, under Section 307 IPC and Section
25(1B) of the Arms Act, 1959, whereby the Appellant was
convicted for rigorous imprisonment for 10 years under Section
307 IPC and 1 year of rigorous imprisonment under Section
25(1B) of the Arms Act and a fine of Rs. 1000/- and in default, to
undergo simple imprisonment for one month.
3.
The prosecution’s story in brief is that an FIR was lodged
on 19.06.2012, by one Shri Baro Ekroya that Shri Jaha Ekroya,
son of Duti Ekroya of village Italin has shot at SmtiNutha Pulu
wife of Chana Milli of Italin on 18.06.2012. After receipt of the
FIR, Anini P.S. Case No. 08/2012, under Section 307 IPC, read
with Section 25(1A)/27(1) of the Arms Act was registered
against the Accused/Appellant. During the investigation, it was
revealed that the victim was standing outside her residence and
at that time, the Appellant, who is her neighbor, without any
reason and provocation shot at her with an intention to kill her
with an SBBL gun. It was also found that the victim sustained
bullet injuries on her upper chest and she was shifted to Roing
District Hospital from where she was again referred to
Dibrugarh. The Accused/Appellant Jaha Ekroya was arrested and
also, the weapon of the offence was seized. The empty cartridges
seized were sent to FSL for testing. On having collected sufficient
materials, the Investigating Officer (IO) had filed the ChargeSheet under Section 307/326 of IPC, read with Section
251(A)/27(1) of the Arms Act. It was stated in the Charge-Sheet
that if required, a Supplementary Charge-sheet would be filed
after receipt of the FSL report.
4.
After receipt of the Charge-Sheet, the Trial Court framed
charges against the Accused/Appellant on 24.02.2013, under
Section 326/307 IPC, read with Section 25 (1B) of the Arms Act,
1959. The Trial Court examined 7 witnesses and also recorded
the statement of the Appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
However, it is seen from the record that though several
summonses were issued for presence of the IO in the instant
case, the IO could not be examined as the IO did not make himself
present in the Trial Court, in the instant case. It is seen that the
Trial Court hadalso examined the Magistrate before whom the
Appellant had allegedly confessed his commission of the alleged
offence under Section 164 Cr.P.C. After examination of the
Magistrate, the Trial Court examined the Appellant again under
Section 313 Cr.P.C. on 06.12.2021 as the Magistrate was made a
witness on a later stage of the trial. After hearing the parties, the
Trial Court had come to a conclusion and passed the impugned
Judgment
and
Order
dated
20.12.2021,
convicting
the
Accused/Appellant, under Section 307 of IPC and under Section
25 (1B) of the Arms Act as mentioned above.
5.
PW-1 is the own brother of the Accused/Appellant, who
had lodged the FIR against the Appellant for having shot at the
victim and for having caused grievous bullet injuries on the
victim. The FIR was exhibited as Exhibit-1 and his thumb
impression was exhibited as Exhibit-1(A). P/Exhibit-2(A) is his
signature related to seizure of SBBL gun. In his crossexamination, he stated that he did not know the contents of the
FIR. He further deposed that he did not know the reason for the
quarrel. He further deposed that there was no enmity between
the victim and his brother, i.e., the Appellant.
6.
PW-2 is the brother of the victim and he deposed that the
Accused is the neighbor of his sister and their house is located at
a distance of 10-20 metres from the house of the Accused. He
deposed that the Accused shot at her victim sister with 12 bore
gun and caused bullet injuries on her chest for which his victim
sister was taken to Roing hospital and thereafter, to Dibrugarh.
During his cross-examination, he stated that he was told by his
victim sister that the Accused had fired at her from the window
of his house.
7.
PW-3 is the victim and she deposed before the Court that
Accused had shot her from his house while she was standing
near her house. The bullet hit her chest and went out from her
back, for which, she became unconscious and retained
consciousness only at the medical at Dibrugarh. She stated that
the incident took place on 18.06.2012 about 9.30 A.M. to 10.00
AM. She further stated that the bullets were recovered from her
body. During her cross-examination, she deposed that the
Accused had shot at her from the window of his house and she
had only seen the gun but not seen the person who had shot her.
8.
PW-4 is the Medical Officer who had examined the victim.
He deposed and confirmed that injury was caused due to hit of
bullet. He deposed that bullet entered from the right side of chest
of the victim. He deposed that the bullet entered from the front
side of the chest and exited from the back side of the victim. The
bullet that had got stuck inside the body was taken out through
back hole and was handed over to the patient and her attendant.
He had exhibited the MLC report of the patient as Exhibit-3 and
his signature as Exhibit-3(A). He had exhibited the information
given to the local police of Assam as Exhibit-4. During his crossexamination, he had deposed that the age of the wound would be
less than 48 hours as blood was still oozing out of the wound. He
further deposed that he could not exactly say the nature of the
arms said to have been used for firing and also could not say the
distance from where it was hit causing the injury.
9.
PW-5 deposed that he knows Jaha Ekroya and before the
death of his father, he was told that the gun of his deceased
father was given to Accused/Appellant Jaha Ekroya. During his
cross-examination, he deposed that he did not have any
documents to prove that the gun used was the weapon of offence
belonged to his deceased father.
10.
PW-6, deposed that she did not know from where the
police had seized the gun. She deposed that she had not put her
thumb impression on the seizure memo. Hercross was declined
by the defence.
11.
PW-7 is the Magistrate, who recorded the Confessional
Statement of the Accused. He had identified the Accused standing
on the dock as Jaha Ekroya. He deposed that he recorded the
Confessional Statement of the Accused on 27.06.2012. He
deposed that the Accused/Appellant was informed about the
legal formalities before recording his Confessional Statement. He
deposed that the Accused confessed before him that he shot the
victim Shanti Milli while he was drunk. He had exhibited the
Confessional Statement as Exhibit-5, which contains 5 pages and
his signatures asExhibit-5 (A) and (B). During his crossexamination, he deposed that he recorded the Confessional
Statement in the capacity of JMFC. He deposed that he did not
remember from whose custody, the Accused/Appellant was
produced before him for recording of his Confessional Statement.
He deposed that he gave sufficient time to the Accused to refresh
his mind before he made his Confessional Statement, which took
half an hour.
12.
The Accused/Appellant was examined under Section 313
of Cr.P.C., wherein, in a question posed to him that PW-2 Shri
Erita Pulu deposed that his sister had been shot by 12 bore gun by
you. What do you have to say on this? The Accused/Appellant
replied saying “I have compensated the victim for causing injuries
on her by gunshot”. Another question to the effect that PW-3
Shanti Pulu deposed that you assaulted her, what do you say on
this? The Appellant replied “This is true; I shoot at her because I
got annoyed with when she dumps garbage in my place.”
13.
It is seen that the IO in the instant case had not been
examined.However,
the
Magistrate,
who
recorded
the
Confessional Statement of the Accused/Appellant was produced
before the Court and his statement was recorded. He further
exhibited the Confessional Statement before the Trial Court.
After hearing the parties and finding material against the
Accused/Appellant, the Trial Court had convicted and sentenced
the Accused/Appellant for 10 years rigorous imprisonment for
committing an offence under Section 307 of the IPC and
sentenced one year imprisonment for committing an offence
under Section 25 (1B) of the Arms Act and a fine of Rs. 1000/and in default, to undergo a simple imprisonment of one month.
It was directed that the sentence has to run concurrently. Being
aggrieved by the aforesaid Judgment and Order passed by the
learned Sessions Judge, Tezu, Lohit district, Arunachal Pradesh,
dated 20.12.2021, the instant Appeal has been filed by the
Appellant.
14.
Mr. M. Boje, learned Amicus Curiae, appearing for the
Appellant submits that the entire conviction has been based only
on suspicion and the prosecution has failed to establish the guilt
of the Appellant beyond reasonable doubt. He submits that
though there was a mention of filing of Supplementary ChargeSheet after receipt of the FSL report regarding the empty
cartridges recovered from the body of the victim, neither any
such FSL report nor anySupplementary Charge-Sheet had been
filed in the instant case. He submits that without the FSL report,
it cannot be proved that the empty cartridges found in the body
of the victim can be treated as the bullets shot from the gun used
in the offence. He submits that the custodial gun was seized from
PHC Italin, PO/PS-Anini, Dibang Valley District on 20.06.2012
wherein, two seizure witnesses were named. However, except
Baro Ekraya PW-1, the second seizure witness was not
examined. He further submits that it was not explained how the
gun was seized from PHC Italin and not from the house of the
Accused/Appellant, wherein the allegation was that the gun shot
was fired from the house of the Accused/Appellant. He submits
that the seizure witnesses did not support from where the
seizure was actually made. He further submits that in the instant
case, the IO who is a vital witness in the instant case, who had
investigated and filed the Charge-Sheet had not been examined,
which goes to vitiate the whole prosecution story in the instant
case. He submits that Charge-Sheet was not exhibited and proved
in the instant case. He submits that serious suspicion cannot
replace the proof that is required in a criminal case, and in the
instant case, the whole case is based on suspicion and the case
has not been proved by the prosecution beyond reasonable
doubt. He further submits that the Accused/Appellant has
already spent more than 8 ½ years behind the bars and
therefore, at this stage, he is liable to be released from the jail.
15.
In support of his submissions, the learned counsel has
referred to the case of Radha Mohan Hajong Vs. The State of
Assam, reported in (2025) 3 GLT 117, wherein, the Hon’ble
Gauhati High Court has held that suspicion however grave, it may
be, cannot take place of proof and there is a large difference
between ‘that may be proved’ and something ‘that will be
proved’. He submits that in the instant case, since the story of
prosecution is not proved beyond the reasonable doubt though
there is a Confessional Statement, the same cannot justify the
conviction in the instant case. He submits that though the victim
had stated that the gun shot was fired from the window, she
specifically mentioned that she did not see as to who had fired
the gun. In view of the aforesaid submissions, the learned Amicus
Curiae submits that the instant case is the correct example
wherein, the prosecution’s story is totally based on suspicion and
the conviction and sentence passed by the learned Trial Court is
also based on suspicion and not proved beyond reasonable
doubt; and therefore, the instant Appeal should be allowed by
releasing the Accused/Appellant from the jail.
16.
Per contra, Mr. G. Tado, the learned Addl. P.P. submits that
the case is proved by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt
as the Confessional Statement which was recorded properly by
the Magistrate as well as the statement under Section 313 of
Cr.P.C., proves that the version of the victim and that can be
taken into account as proof as there is consistency in both the
statements. He further submits that the Magistrate who had
recorded the Confessional Statement had also been examined
and he had also deposed that after following the due procedure,
the Confessional Statement of the Accused/Appellant was
recorded. The Confessional Statement of the Accused/Appellant
was exhibited and the same had been proved by the Magistrate.
In view of the Confessional Statement as well as the statements
under Section 313 Cr.P.C., in addition, the statements of the
witnesses recorded in the instant case, it is clear that none other
than the Accused/Applicant had committed the offence of
shooting the victim in the instant case. In view of the aforesaid, it
is submitted that no wrong has been committed by the Trial
Court in convicting the Accused/Appellant under Section 307 of
the IPC as well as Section 25(1B) of the Arms Act. He further
submits that non-examination of the IO cannot be treated as fatal
in a criminal case as the same had not prejudiced the
Accused/Appellant in any way. In view of the aforesaid
submissions,
he
submits
that
the
conviction
of
the
Accused/Appellant is right in the instant case, taking into
account the facts and circumstances and the depositions of the
witnesses in addition to the Confessional Statement recorded by
the Magistrate in the instant case.
17.
In support of his argument that non-examination of the
Investigating Officer as a witness is not fatal, he has referred to
the case of Bahadur Naik Vs. The State of Bihar, reported in AIR
2000 Supreme Court 1582, wherein it has been held by the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
that
non-examination
of
the
Investigating Officer as a witness is of no consequence in the
facts and circumstances of that case. He further referred to the
case of Mahiram Bora Vs. The State of Assam, reported in 1993
2 GauLR 79, wherein the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court has held
that a reading of confessional statement, which is voluntary and
not in contradiction to Section 313 Cr.P.C. then, it can be trusted
as true and trustworthy. In support of his argument that nonexamination of IO is not fatal to the prosecution’s case, he has
also referred to the case of Behari Prasad Etc. Vs. The State of
Bihar, reported in (1996) 2 SCC 317.
18.
Mr. J. Jini, learned Legal Aid Counsel, appearing for the
victim, supported the submissions made by the learned Addl. P.P.
and submits thatthe statements under Section 164 CR.P.C.,
recorded by the Magistrate, the Accused/Appellant had
voluntarily admitted his guilt by his Confessional Statement. He
submits that in the instant case, the Magistrate was also
examined and the whole formalities of Section 164 were
followed
during
the
Confessional
Statement
of
the
Accused/applicant. He submits that the Confessional Statement
corroborates the statements made under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. of
the Accused/Applicant. In view of the aforesaid, he submits that
there is nothing wrong in the Judgment &Order passed by the
learned Trial Court in the instant case and therefore, the instant
Appeal is liable to be dismissed.
19.
This Court has heard the submissions made by the counsel
appearing for the respective parties and has also carefully gone
through the Trial Court Record that have been produced before
this Court.
20.
It is seen from the records that the Confessional Statement
under Section 164 Cr.P.C. of the Accused/Applicant was recorded
on 27.06.2012 by the Magistrate. The Accused/Appellant was
brought before the Magistrate after about 8 days of the alleged
commission of the offence. It is also seen that after the detention
of the Accused/Appellant by the police at 3:00 AM of the
intervening night, he was brought before the Magistrate at about
11:00 AM on the next day, after he was produced before the
Magistrate (JMFC) at 10:00 hours. It is also noticed that to
normalize the Accused/Appellant and to find the truth, the
Magistrate had asked certain questions to find out his mental
condition. It is also seen that the Accused/Appellant was
explained about the provisions of Section 164Cr.P.C. read with
Section 281 Cr.P.C. and Section 24 to 30 of the Indian Evidence
Act in details. Several questions were asked and information was
given to the Accused/Appellant before recording his statement
after finding the Accused/Appellant to be in normal state of
mind. It is seen that the statement of the Accused/Appellant is
very specific that to the effect that in the morning of 18.06.2012,
he was heavily drunk from many places and when he returned to
his house, he saw that his veranda was deposited with large
number of timbers and wood. He was annoyed that those people,
specifically, the victim always used to disturb him; so, getting
angry due to his drunkenness, he took out his gun and shot at the
victim. It is also mentioned that the recording of the Confessional
Statement of the Accused consumed about half an hour of time,
meaning thereby that sufficient amount of time was given to the
Accused/Appellant to make his statement before the Magistrate.
It is also seen from the record that a certificate had been issued
by the Magistrate to the effect that he being conversant with the
provisions of Rule 23 of Gauhati High Court Rules, Circulars,
Orders
and
relevant
provisions
regarding recording
of
confession, he had recorded the Confessional Statement of
theAccused/Appellant
provisions
of
law.
after duly
He
following the aforesaid
further
certified
that
the
Accused/Appellant was explained that he was not bound to make
any confession and if he did so, the same might be used against
him and the confession had been made voluntarily.
21.
As discussed above, it is also seen that the statements
made under Section 313 CR.P.C. also, the Accused/Appellant
had stated that he had shot the victim and for that he had
paid money as compensation to her. Thereby, admitting the
fact that he was the one who had shot the victim. There is no
inconsistency in the statements of the Accused/Appellant
under Section 164Cr.P.C. as well as under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
22.
Now, coming to the evidence of the witnesses for the
prosecution, it is seen that PW-1, namely, Baro Ekroya, is the
elder brother of the Accused/Appellant and they are of same
parents. He deposed that he was told that his brother, i.e., the
Accused/Appellant had assaulted the victim and on advice of
others, he lodged the FIR. He also deposed that he could not
read or write as he was an illiterate person. During his crossexamination, he stated that he did not see the incident himself
and as told by the PI and other villagers, he had lodged the
FIR, which was drafted by the PI but, he did not know the
contents therein. He also stated that he did not know the
reason of the quarrel. He stated that the victim and the
Accusedwere not having any enmity prior to the incident. He
further stated that he did not know about the gun shown to
him before this Court today and the gun belonged to whom.
PW-2 is the brother of the victim. He stated in his deposition
that Accused and his sister are neighbours and the distance
between their houses was 10/20 metres. He stated that the
Accused/Appellant shot his sister by 12 bore Gun. In his
deposition, he stated that he was not present at the time of
the incident and he did not see the incident. He had only
heard about the incident as the victim’s sister told him that
the Accused had fired from the window of his house. He also
stated that his sister did not tell him as to why she was shot
by the Accused. PW-3 is the victim who stated that the
Accused/Appellant shot her with a gun when she was
standing near her house. She stated that she was shot from
his house and the bullet hit her in the upper chest and went
outside when she became unconscious and she regained her
consciousness on the way to Dibrugarh hospital. She stated
that she was doing some gardening work in her kitchen
garden when the Accused/Appellant shot her. In her crossexamination, she stated that Accused shot her from the
window of his house. She stated that she had seen the gun but
not the Accused in that room. She stated that other than the
Accused, nobody would shoot her from his house. From the
aforesaid depositions of PW-1, PW-2 and PW-3, one aspect is
certain that the victim was shot by someone, allegedly, by the
Accused/Appellant. However, there is no certainty as no one
had seen the Accused/Appellant firing the gun as the victim
had stated herself that she had seen only the gun but not the
person who has shot the gun. However, she had presumed or
she is sure that nobody other than the Accused/Appellant
could have shot her from the house of the Accused/Appellant.
PW-4 is the Medical Officer who confirmed that the victim
was injured by gun shot and small palettes of bullet were
recovered from her body, which were handed over to the
patient and the attendants. PW-5, namely, EpenduEkru stated
that he knew the Accused/Appellant. He stated that before
expiry of his father, he was told that his gun was given to the
said Accused Jaha Ekroya. In his cross-examination, he stated
before
the
police
that
he
did
not
know
the
Accused/Appellant. He further stated that he did not have
any document to show that gun belonged to his father. He
further stated that he could not identify the gun of his father.
PW-6, namely, Episo Ekroya, who was named as one of the
witnesses in the seizure memo stated that she knew the
Accused/Appellant. She stated that she did not have any idea
from whom the police had seized the gun. She also stated that
she had not put thumb impression on any seizure list. Her
cross-examination was declined by the defence.
23.
From the aforesaid depositions of PW-4, PW-5 and PW-
6, it certainly cannot be ascertained from where the gun was
recovered though PW-5 wanted to say that the gun was
delivered to the Accused/Appellant by his father; he could
not specifically state anything neither about the gun nor the
identification of the gun.He made a very general statement
about the delivery of the gun by his father to the
Accused/Appellant without any corroboration or proof. He
could not further explain why the gun was given to the
Accused/Appellant by his father. The witness to the seizure
memo also, could not state anything about the seizure of the
gun as she denied putting her thumb impression in the
seizure memo. The prosecution’s story regarding the seizure
of the gun from PHC is also very difficult to understand as
how the gun has reached the PHC, if the gun was used by the
Accused/Appellant from his house. Therefore, the recovery of
the gun from a different place other than the house of the
Accused/Appellant makes the prosecution story doubtful.
24.
PW-7, the Magistrate had deposed before the Court that
the
Confessional
Statement
recorded
of
the
Accused/Appellantwas voluntary and the same was done
after due compliance to the relevant legal provisions as well
as in terms of Section 164 of Cr.P.C.
25.
Now, the question as to on the face of the Confessional
Statement recorded under the 164Cr.P.C. by the Magistrate
and his statement under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., the
discrepancies about the seizure of the gun will carry how
much creditability that the same will negate the story made
by the prosecution case in the instant case.This Court has
carefully gone through the P. Ext. No.5, i.e., the Form for
recording the statement of the Appellant under Section 164
Cr.P.C.
The Form contains not only the Confessional
Statement of the Accused/Appellant but also various
questions which were put by the Magistrate during his
recording of the Confessional Statement. It is seen that all the
cautionthatis required by the Magistrate had been taken by
the Magistrate while recording the ConfessionalStatement of
the Accused/Appellant. It is seen from the Form that the
Accused/Appellant was appropriately explained about the
provisions of law and that he was not bound to make any
confession, but if he did make a confession, it might be used
against him as evidence and that he should not say anything,
because others had asked him to say and that he had liberty
to say whatever he really wanted to say and that he should
say nothing, which was untrue. It is also seen that the
Magistrate
had
given
time
for
reflection
to
the
Accused/Appellant and also asked several questions which
would reflect his mental condition. Sufficient time was taken
in recording the ConfessionalStatement also. It is also seen
that the Magistrate was examined as witness as PW-7 and he
had been cross-examined also. It is seen that the observation
made by the Magistrate, was not negated and infact, it had
gone completely unchallenged by the defence.
26.
Now the question comes whether on the basis of a
Confessional Statement which is corroborated by the
statement under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., an accused person can
be convicted or not. In this connection, the case of the
Sankaria Vs. State of Rajasthan, reported in AIR 1978 SC
1248, being relevant is taken for consideration. In the
aforesaid case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as
follows: -
“If the first case is satisfied, the Court must, before acting upon
the confession, reach the finding that what is stated therein is
true and reliable. For judging the reliability to such a
confession, or for that matter any such substantive piece of
evidence, there is no rigid cannon of universal application.
Even so, one broad method, which may be useful in most cases
for evaluating a confession may be indicated. The Court should
carefully examine the confession and compare it with the rest
of the evidence, in the light of the surrounding circumstances
and probabilities of the case. If on such examination and
comparison, the confession appears to be probable catalogue
of events and naturally fitsin with the rest of the evidence and
surrounding circumstances, it may be taken to have satisfied
the second test.”
27.
From the above ratio laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, it is clear that the judicial confession made by
the Accused/Appellant in the instant case is not only
voluntary, but true as well. In another case of Sarwan Singh
Rattan Singh Vs. State of Punjab, reported in AIR 1957 SC
637, the Hon’ble Supreme Court laid down as follows:
“……………………………………………It is, however, true that Sarwan
Singh has made a confession and in law, it is always open to
the Court to convict anAccused on his confessionitself though
he has retracted it at a later stage. Nevertheless usually
Courtsrequire some corroboration to the confession statement
before convicting an Accused person on such statement. What
amount of corroboration would be necessary in such case
would always be a question of fact to determine in the light of
the circumstances of the case.”
28.
In the case of Kehar Singh Vs. The State, reported in
AIR 1988 SC 1883, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has made it
clear that there is no impediment in law in conviction of
anaccusedsolely on his own confession, even if retracted,
provided that the Court believes such a confession as true.
The law, that no Court can throw away a confession merely
because the confession was retracted, has been explained by
the Hon’ble Supreme Courtin the case of Tamil Nadu Vs.
Kutty alias Laxmi Narashinhan, reported in 2001 Crl. Law
Journal 4168, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
observed as follows:
“……………………….Learned Judges of the High Court declined to
act on the said confession mainly for two reasons. First is that
the confession was retracted by the maker thereof and second
is that the recovery of articles was made prior to the
confession. We may state at the outset itself that both reasons
are too insufficient for overruling the confession. It is not the
law that once a confession was retracted the Court should
presume that the confession is tainted. As a matter of practical
knowledge we can say that non-retracted confession is a rarity
in criminal cases. The retract from confession is the right of the
confessor and all the Accused against confessions were
produced by the prosecution have invariably adopted that
right. It would be injudicious to jettison a judicial confession on
the mere premise that its maker has retracted from it. The
Court has a duty to evaluate the evidence concerning the
confession by looking at all aspects. The twin test of a
confession is to ascertain whether it was voluntary and true.
Once these tests are found to be positive the next endeavour is
to see whether there is any other reason, which stands in the
way of acting on it. Even for that, retraction of the confession
is not the ground to throw the confession overboard.”
29.
In the case of K.I. Parunny Vs. Asstt. Collector (HQ),
Central Excise Collectors, Cochin, reported in (1997) 3 SCC
721, the Supreme Court has settled the legal position that
confession can form the sole basis of conviction and the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as follows: -
“………………………It would thus be seen that there is no
prohibition under the Evidence Act to rely upon the retracted
confession to prove the prosecution case or to make the same
basis for conviction of the Accused. Practice and prudence
require that the court could examine the evidence adduced by
the prosecution to find out whether there are any other facts
and circumstances to corroborate the retracted confession. It is
not necessary that there should be corroboration from
independent evidence adduced by the prosecution to
corroborate each detail contained in the confessional
statement. The court is required to examine whether the
confessional statement is voluntary; in other words, whether it
was not obtained by threat, duress or promise. If the court is
satisfied from the evidence that it was voluntary then it is
required to examine whether the statement is true. If the court
on examination of the evidence finds that the retracted
confession is true, that part of the inculpatory portion could be
relied upon to base the conviction. However, prudence and
practice require that court would seek assurance getting
corroboration
from
other
evidence
adduced
by
the
prosecution.”
30.
In view of the aforesaid ratios laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, it is apparently cleared that a conviction,
solely, on the basis of the Confessional Statement, which has
been recorded as per the law in true terms be made.
31.
In the instant case, it is seen that the Confessional
Statement was recorded in compliance of all relevant
procedures and laws and in a proper Form. It is also seen that
the Confessional Statement has been corroborated by the
statements of the victim who had been injured allegedly by
the Accused/Appellant. It is also seen from the records that
there is no material of any enmity between the Appellant and
the victim and therefore, there is no reason why the victim
who had been injured will implicate the Accused/applicant
unnecessarily. It is also seen from the statements made under
Section 313 Cr.P.C. that the Accused/Appellant had himself
corroborated the Confessional Statement by his statements
under Section 164 Cr.P.C. before the Magistrate. In a specific
question made to him, he had himself stated that he had shot
the victim being annoyed and drunk. He had also stated that
he had paid some money as compensation as he had shot the
victim. The aforesaid facts clearly show that there is no much
doubt
about
the
shooting
of
the
victim
by
the
Accused/Appellant in the instant case. However, as for the
statements recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. are concerned,
it is important to bear in mind that though a statement
recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. is not a statement made
on oath and is not,strictly speaking evidence, yet the
statement, so made, can, indeed be taken into consideration,
at the trial, against the Accused for the purpose of arriving at
the guilt or otherwise of the Accused.
32.
As far as the reliability that can be given to the
statements made under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. is
concerned, the case of The State of Maharashtra Vs.
Sukhdev Singh, reported in AIR 1992 SC 2100, can be
referred to, wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as
follows: -
“51. That brings us to the question whether such a statement
recorded under Section 313 of the Code can constitute the sole
basis for conviction. Since no oath is administered to the
Accused, the statements made by the Accused will not be
evidence stricto sensu. That is why, sub-section (3) says that
the Accused shall not render himself liable to punishment if he
gives false answer. Then comes sub-section (4), which reads:
"313 (4) The answers given by the Accused may be taken into
consideration in such inquiry or trial, and put in evidence for or
against him in any other inquiry into, or trial for, any other
offence which such answers may tend to show he has
committed."
33.
Therefore, the answers given by the Accused, in response
to his examination, under Section 313, can be taken into
consideration in such enquiry or trial. Hence, though not strictly
evidence, Sub-Section 4 permits that it may be taken into
consideration in the inquiry or trial.
34.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Hate Singh
Bhagat Singh Vs. State of M.B., reported in AIR 1953 SC 468,
held that an answer given by an Accused under Section 313
Cr.P.C. examination, can be used for proving his guilt as much as
the evidence given by a prosecution witness.
35.
In view of the aforesaid principles laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the statement under Section 313, though not made under
oath, can be taken into account in finding out the guilt of the
Accused if the same is corroborated by other evidence. In the
instant case, it is seen that the Confessional Statement recorded
under Section 164 Cr.P.C. as well as the statements made under
Section 313 Cr.P.C. corroborates each other and the same could
not be demolished by way of any cross-examination or any
material relevant in the instant case by the defence.
36.
On the basis of the aforesaid and taking into account the
whole facts in the instant case, it is seen that though there is no
eye witness, except the statement of the victim that the gun was
shot from the house of the Accused/Appellant, the Confessional
Statement made before the Magistrate which has been found to
be properly recorded by the Magistrate as well as his statements
under Section 313 Cr.P.C., are sufficient to prove the guilt of the
Accused/Appellant in the instant case beyond reasonable doubt.
37.
This court has considered the case referred by the Amicus
Curiae appearing for the Appellant, i.e., Radha Mohan Hajong
(supra).This Court is of the opinion that in the instant case, there
is more than suspicion is involved as there are Confessional
Statement as well as the same has corroboration by the
statements of witnesses as well as the statements under Section
313 Cr.P.C. made by the Accused/Appellant voluntarily.
38.
In view of the aforesaid findings, this Court is of the
considered and conscious opinion that there is no infirmity in the
Judgment & Order rendered by the learned Court of Sessions
Judge, Tezu, Lohit District (A.P.), vide his Judgment dated
20.12.2021. Therefore, the Appeal being devoid of merit, is
hereby dismissed.
39.
The Trial Court Records are to be sent back immediately.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review