Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
WRIT PETITION No. 93 of 2024
BETWEEN:INBREW BEVERAGES PRIVATE LIMITED THROUGH ITS AUTHORISED
SIGNATORY MS RUCHI NEGI A COMPANY INCORPORATED UNDER THE
COMPANIES ACT 1956 REGD OFFICE 406 KUSAL BAZAR 32-33 NEHRU
PLACE SOUTH DELHI NEW DELHI 110019 (DELHI)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI PIYUSH MATHUR, SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI
MAYUR SINGH, ADVOCATE)
AND
EXCISE COMMISSIONER MADHYA PRADESH COMPOSITE REVENUE
1. BUILDING FOURTH FLOOR, NEEDAM ROAD, NAKA CHANDRAWADNI,
LASHKAR, GWALIOR 474009 (MADHYA PRADESH)
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF EXCISE MADHYA PRADESH
2. COMPOSITE REVENUE BUILDING FOURTH FLOOR, NEEDAM ROAD,
NAKA CHANDRAWADNI, LASHKAR GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
REGENT BEERS AND WINES LTD. MAKSI DIST. SHAJAPUR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(STATE BY MS. ARCHANA KHER, ADDITIONAL ADOVCATE GENERAL)
(RESPONDENT NO.3 BY SHRI SATISH CHANDRA BAGADIYA, SENIOR
ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI KARPE PRAKHAR MOHAN & SHRI PANKAJ
CHANDRA BAGADIYA, ADVOCATES)
Reserved on
:
10th January, 2024
Delivered on
:
22nd January, 2024
This petition having been heard and reserved for order coming on
for pronouncement this day, the court pronounced the following:
ORDER
The petitioner has filed the present petition seeking quashment
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
-2-
of the order dated 03.10.2023 passed by the Excise Commissioner under
Rule 12 of the Madhya Pradesh Beer & Wine Rules made under Section
62 of the M.P. Excise Act, 1915.
02.
The petitioner is a private limited company having its registered
office at Nehru Place, South Delhi, New Delhi and is engaged in the
business of manufacture and sale of beer in the name of
'THUNDERBOLT / BOLT' (registered trademark). Initially, Mount
Shivalik Breweries Limited was incorporated on 31.10.1972, thereafter,
it was changed to Molson Coors India Private Limited and now it is
known as Inbrew Beverages Private Limited.
03.
Respondent No.3 / Regent Beers & Wine Limited is also a
private limited company registered under the provisions of the
Companies Act, 1956 and is engaged in the business of manufacturing
and selling beer from its manufactury in Maksi, District – Shajapur.
04.
The petitioner, through its predecessors has been brewing,
bottling, marketing and selling beer across India under the trade mark
'THUNDERBOLT / BOLT' registered under the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
The petitioner is claiming the acquisition of tremendous goodwill and
reputation amongst the consumers at large due to the quality of the beer.
Therefore, the petitioner is claiming the exclusive right to object to any
unauthorized use of trade mark 'THUNDERBOLT / BOLT'. The
petitioner is also selling different types of liquors in the name of
'THUNDERBOLT / BOLT', 'THUNDERBOLT SUPER STRONG
BEER', 'THUNDERBOLT AQUA' & 'THUNDERBOLT PREMIUM
STRONG BEER'.
05.
Respondent No.1 is the Excise Commissioner of the Department
of Excise (M.P.), a competent authority under Madhya Pradesh Foreign
Liquor Rules, 1996 & M.P. Beer & Wine Rules for registration of labels
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
-3-
for the purpose of manufacture, transportation, sale, export and import
of beer and wine in the State of Madhya Pradesh. The Beer
Manufacturing Unit in Madhya Pradesh is mandatorily required
registration of its label/trade mark of beer by respondent No.1 under
Rule 12 of M.P. Beer & Wine Rules, in which the provisions of M.P.
Foreign Liquor Rules have been made applicable mutatis mutandis.
06.
Respondent No.3 applied for registration of a label in the name
of 'BOLT SUPER STRONG BEER' before respondent No.1.
Respondent No.2 issued a public notice dated 24.05.2023 through the
website of M.P. Excise Department inviting objections in respect of
registration of the aforesaid label.
07.
The petitioner submitted an objection in respect of its label and
style of 'THUDERBOLT SHINE' claiming to be a similar registered
trade mark of the petitioner.
08.
Vide the impugned order dated 03.10.2023, the Excise
Commissioner turned down the objection and registered a label 'BOLT
SUPER STRONG BEER' in favour of respondent No.3. Hence, the
present petition is before this Court.
09.
Shri Piyush Mathur, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
submits that sub-rule (4) of Rule 9 of M.P. Foreign Liquor Rules says
that on receipt of an application for registration of label/labels, the
Excise Commissioner conducts an enquiry and if he is satisfied that the
pre-requisites specified in sub-rule (3) have been complied with and
there is no objection to such registration, he may register it. If the
objection is submitted like in the present case, and the Commissioner
finds that label/labels under registration bear similarity or resemblances
to any prevalent label of any other manufactory then he shall refuse to
register the same. The Excise Commissioner failed to examine the
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
-4-
registered trade mark of the petitioner, in which the predominant word is
'BOLT' with a lightening shine, respondent No.3 has no right to use the
word 'BOLT' with the same lightening shine within the letter 'O'.
Therefore, it is having similarity and resemblance with the trade
mark/label of the petitioner for its product of beer having goodwill in
the market. The matter is liable to be remanded back to the Excise
Commissioner to conduct a fresh enquiry and pass a reasoned order. In
support of his contention, Shri Mathur, learned Senior Counsel has
placed reliance upon a judgment delivered in the case of Cox Distillery
& Another v/s Mc Dowell & Company Limited, Madras reported in
2000 (1) M.P.L.J. 33.
10.
Ms Archana Kher, learned Additional Advocate General
appearing for respondents No.1 & 2 / Excise Department refutes that
there is no similarity and resemblance between the registered trade
mark/label of petitioner as well as respondent No.3, which was
registered by respondent No.1 on an application submitted by
respondent No.3. The petitioner is using the complete word
'THUDERBOLT', whereas respondent No.3 is only using word 'BOLT'.
The Commissioner has considered all the objections raised by the
petitioner and rejected the same by a reasoned order. This registration of
label is only for the purpose of purchasing and selling the product like
wine and beer manufactured in Madhya Pradesh. The registration of the
label includes various other legends and details of the product, in which
the brand is one of them. The dispute between the parties is in respect of
trade mark and copyright and is liable to be decided by the competent
Civil Court.
11.
Shri S.C. Bagadiya, learned Senior Counsel for respondent No.3
argues that the petitioner has already filed a civil suit under the
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
-5-
provisions of the Trade Marks Act, 1999 before the Commercial Court,
Indore. The application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 & 2 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 has not been decided till date and if the petitioner
succeeds in the aforesaid suit and the learned Court restrains the
answering respondent to use BOLT, then the impugned order will
automatically go. The issue, whether there is a deception, similarity or
resemblance between two labels or trade marks that are liable to be
decided in a civil suit on merit, by the learned Commercial Court, hence,
this petition is not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed.
12.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and
perused the record.
13.
Admittedly, the petitioner does not have any manufactory as
well as a bottling unit in the State of Madhya Pradesh. The petitioner is
also not claiming any sale of its product in Madhya Pradesh. The
petitioner has not applied for registration of label either under M.P. Beer
& Wine Rules or under M.P. Foreign Liquor Rules.
14.
Rule 3 of the M.P. Beer & Wine Rules mandates that a brewery
or manufactory shall be constructed / or established only with the
explicit permission of the State Government under these rules. Any
person intending to construct and/or establish a brewery or manufactory
shall apply to the State Government through the Excise Commissioner
for required permission in Form B – 1. The provision of M.P. Foreign
Liquor Rules has been made applicable for the registration and
deregistration of labels for beer and wine under Rule 12 of M.P. Beer &
Wine Rules. Under the aforesaid provisions, respondent No.3 applied
for registration of the label.
15.
Rule 9 of the M.P. Foreign Liquor Rules deals with the
procedure for registration of labels, which says that no foreign liquor
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
-6-
shall be transported within, imported into, exported from and sold
within Madhya Pradesh unless the following legends and details are
printed on the labels pasted to the bottles of foreign liquor, therefore, the
same labels are liable to be pasted on the beer also. Rule 9 of the M.P.
Foreign Liquor Rules is reproduced below:“9. Registration of labels. - (1) No foreign liquor shall be
transported within, imported into, exported from and sold within
Madhya Pradesh unless the following legends and details are
printed on the labels pasted to the bottles of foreign liquor:(a) "Consumption of liquor is injurious to health".
(b) "For sale in Madhya Pradesh only" or "Duty not paid in
Madhya Pradesh" as the case may be.
(c) Batch No., Month and year of manufacture.
(d) Name and place of distillery, manufactory or bottlery.
(e) Alcoholic contents and proof strength.
(f) Brand with contents.
(g) Registration No. of the brand/label.
(h) Minimum selling price as directed by the Excise
Commissioner.
(i) “Best within six months form the month of manufacture” on
beer bottles.
(j) 'Bottled in FL-9/FL9-A”
(k) Other information as directed by the Excise Commissioner.
(2) Only such bottles or cans of foreign liquor, with labels
showing legends/details as specified in sub-rule (1) duly
registered with the Excise Commissioner in accordance with
sub-rules (3) and (4) may be sold in, transported within,
imported into, or exported from Madhya Pradesh :
Provided that the labels manufactured by any bottling
licensee of Madhya Pradesh that have been approved by the
Excise Commissioner before the commencement of these rules,
shall be deemed to have been duly registered under sub-rules (3)
and (4) :
Provided further that the labels registered for each
manufactory or the labels approved by the Excise Commissioner
before the commencement of these rules, which shall be deemed
to have been duly registered under sub-rules (3) and (4) shall be
compulsorily renewed every year. Annual renewal fees for each
label/labels shall be such as may be prescribed by the
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
-7-
Government. No label/labels shall be used by any manufacturer
unless it has been duly registered or renewed. If any label/labels
are cancelled by the Excise Commissioner under rules (6) on the
ground that such label/labels has caused or are causing losses to
state revenue, then owner of such label/labels shall not be
entitled for registration of any new label for a period of one year
beginning with the date of cancellation of that label/labels.
(3) Licensee shall make an application to the Excise
Commissioner for registration/renewal of label/labels alongwith
the fee as prescribed for each kind of label. Three printed copies
of the label to be registered and a challan in proof of payment of
the prescribed registration fee, deposited in the treasury of the
district shall be enclosed alongwith the application. The format
of the label shall contain the details mentioned in sub-rule (1).
An application for renewal of label/labels shall be filed
alongwith the challan of prescribed fee before the end of current
year mentioning details of prior registration and renewal.
(4) On receipt of application for Registration of label/labels, the
Excise Commissioner, may make such enquiry as he deems
proper, if he is satisfied that the pre-requisites specified in subrule (3) have been complied with and there is no objection to
such registration, he may register it. No such label/ labels shall
be registered which bears similarity or resemblance to any
prevalent label of any other manufactory.
(5) A label as aforesaid in sub-rule (1) shall not have any figure,
symbol, picture, insignia, etc. that looks obscence or that may
offend the religious feelings of any particular class or hurts the
sentiments or pride of any group, community or institution. In
case of a dispute whether a label is obscence, offensive or
hurtful, the matter shall be referred to the Excise Commissioner
and his decision thereon shall be final and binding.
(6) The Excise Commissioner may order cancellation of
registration of a label made under sub-rule (4), if liquor sold
under any such registered label is found sub-standard or if he is
convinced that the sales under that label are causing financial
losses to the State Government or if he is satisfied that the label
is obscene, outrageous or hurtful. He shall, however, before
passing such an order, given the affected licensee an opportunity
to make a representation against such proposed cancellation.
Consequent upon such cancellation, the Excise Commissioner
may also pass suitable order regarding disposal of the stocks of
the cancelled label held by any licensee and the State
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
-8-
Government shall not be liable to pay any compensation to the
licensee for any loss or damage. [The procedure regarding the
disposal of stocks and for any loss or damage to the licensee in
consequence of non renewal of labels, shall be the same as is
applicable after cancellation of the label/labels.”
16.
Apart from other legends and details like warning, payment of
duty, batch number, date, month and year of manufacturing name of
distillery alcohol content, the registration number of the brand/label is
required to be printed. As per sub-rule (2) of Rule 9 of M.P. Foreign
Liquor Rules, only such bottles or cans of foreign liquor, with labels
showing legends/details as specified in sub-rule (1) duly registered with
the Excise Commissioner may be sold in, transported within, imported
into, or exported from Madhya Pradesh. The rule mandates that on
receipt of application, the Commissioner, upon his satisfaction shall
register the pre-requisites specified in sub-rule (3). No such label/labels
shall be registered that bears similarity or resemblance to any prevalent
label of any other manufactory.
17.
The petitioner has no manufactory in the State of Madhya
Pradesh and has no registration of label/labels under Rule 12 of the M.P.
Beer & Wine Rules by the Excise Commissioner. Therefore, only those
manufactory whose labels are registered under Rule 12 of the M.P. Beer
& Wine Rules or under Rule 9 of M.P. Foreign Liquor Rules, as the case
may be, may raise objections in respect of registration of label/labels on
the ground of similarity or resemblance and the Excise Commissioner is
only required to consider objection from other manufactories who have
a license to manufacture beer, wine or foreign liquor in Madhya
Pradesh. The petitioner is not claiming itself to be a manufactory in the
State of Madhya Pradesh and registration of its label/labels under the
aforesaid two Rules. The petitioner has no locus to challenge the order.
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
-9-
18.
So far as a dispute about the similarity or resemblance of
registered trademarks between the petitioner and respondent is
concerned, the petitioner has already filed a civil suit. Any findings
given by this Court on this issue would come in the way of parties
before the Commercial Court, hence, no case of interference with the
impugned order in this Writ Petition is made out.
19.
In view of the above, Writ Petition stands dismissed. However,
dismissal of the present petition shall not come in the way of deciding
the civil suit on merit which is under different provisions of law.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Ravi
Signed by: RAVI PRAKASH
Signing time: 1/22/2024
5:14:33 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review