Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
- : 1 :W.P. No.930/2022
IN THE HIGH COURTOF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 19th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 930 of 2022
BETWEEN:HULASCHANDRA JAIN S/O BADALCHAND JAIN OCCUPATION:
BUSINESS 49A PANCHAVATI JANKINAGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(SHRI ASHOK KUMAR SETHI, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH SHRI POURUSH
RANKA, ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER.)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
SUB DIVISIONAL OFFICER (REVENUE) SUB DIVISION RAU,
2.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3. TEHSILDAR TEHSIL RAU, (MADHYA PRADESH)
COLLECTOR THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH INDORE (MADHYA
4.
PRADESH)
DISTRICT REGISTRAR (REGISTRATION OF DOCUMENTS) MOTI
5.
TABELA, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
SMT. MANISHA W/O SANJAY AWASTHI OCCUPATION: UNKNOWN 6/4,
6.
KESARBAGH ROAD, OPPOSITE TO OLD RTO , (MADHYA PRADESH)
1.
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI TARUN KUSHWAH, LEARNED GOVT. ADVOCATE FOR THE
RESPONDENTS/STATE.)
(SHRI RISHIRAJ TRIVEDI, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT
NO.6.)
This petition coming on for hearing this day, the court passed the
following:
- : 2 :W.P. No.930/2022
ORDER
1.
The petitioner has filed the present petition being aggrieved by order
dated 23.7.2021 and letter dated 26.7.2021 passed by the Sub Divisional
Officer (SDO), Rau, District Indore.
2.
According to the petitioner, he being a co-owner purchased the land
bearing Survey Nos. 1464/2, 1464/3, 1464/4, 1464/5, 1464/6, 1464/7,
1464/8 and 1464/9 by registered sale-deed dated 10.8.2010 from the
erstwhile owner viz. Sudarshan Bansal, Saket Housing Pvt. Ltd., Abhishek
Bansal; and Siraj Khan. The aforesaid erstwhile owners purchased the
aforesaid land in the year 1998 by registered sale-deed from Vishwa
Bhihari Awasthi who happens to be father-in-law of respondent No.6. The
names of all the subsequent purchasers were mutated in the revenue
record.
3.
Respondent No.2 registered the case suo motu on 23.3.2021 without
issuing any notice to the petitioner and passed an order of injunction in
respect of alienation of flats and premises constructed after due permission
from Town & Country epartment. According to the petitioner, after
purchase of the aforesaid land, permission from Town & Country Planning
Department, Municipal Corporation, Real Estate Regulatory Authority
(RERA), SDO were taken and thereafter, the land was developed.
Therefore, the SDO without any authority and without any provision of
law under the M.P. Land Revenue Code (MPLRC) has wrongly restrained
the developers to sale the property. The petitioner immediately approached
the SDO and filed an application for vacating stay on 27.3.2021 along with
all the necessary documents. On 7.7.2021 the SDO heard the arguments
and posted for orders on the said application. Instead of deciding the
application for vacating stay, the SDO has passed the final order directing
- : 3 :W.P. No.930/2022
the Tehsildar to submit the report about the status of the aforesaid land and
also directed for registration of a suo motu case u/s. 115 of the MPLRC.
After passing the aforesaid order, the SDO further directed the Sub
Registrar, Registration for not registering any sale-deed in regard to the
project of the petitioner. Hence, the present petition before this Court.
4.
Shri A.K. Sethi, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that after purchasing the land in question by way of registered
sale-deed the petitioner applied for diversion of the land. The land was
diverted and thereafter the lay-out was approved by the Town & Country
Planning Department vide order dated 24.1.2013. Thereafter, the
Municipal Corporation also granted the building permission on 23.4.2015.
The permission under Rule 27 of the M.P. Bhoomi vikas Niyam, 2012 was
also granted by the Municipal Corporation for construction of multi-storied
building of six floors, basement and parking. The RERA has also approved
the project in the name of “Lal Bagh Life”. After completion of the
construction in accordance with law, the SDO has wrongly passed the
order u/s. 115 of the MPLRC and wrongly directed the Sub Registrar,
Registration not to register any sale-deed. The provisions u/s. 115 of the
MPLRC have wrongly been invoked by the SDO without taking approval
from the Collector as required under Proviso to Section 115.
5.
Respondents No. 1 to 4 have filed the reply by submitting that the
land in question was registered in the name of “Mahadev Mandir. Later on,
the name of private persons were recorded as Bhoomi Swami in the
revenue record by virtue of order of Hon'ble the Governor dated
29.10.1971. Such entries in Khasra Khatauni appears to be false and
without knowledge of the revenue authorities. The land stood in the name
of Mahadev Mandir would be treated in the name of Deity which is
- : 4 :W.P. No.930/2022
perpetual minor. Thereafter all the subsequent sales and partitions are
contrary to the settled position of law. The State being the owner of the
properties is always having authority to examine the title. It is submitted
that in case of Satlujlal Vidyut Nigam V/s. Rajkumar Rajendra Singh
(Decd.) through L.Rs. : (2019 14 SCC 449, the apex Court has held that
the fraud vitiates everything and such order can be challenged in any Court
or proceedings, even in the collateral proceedings. Therefore, all the
entries, partitions based on the fraud vitiates and liable to be interfered
with by the revenue authorities in order to protect the land.
6.
Learned counsel for respondent No.5 submits that the SDO is having
power to take suo motu action for correction of the unauthorized entries.
As on today, the final order has not been passed u/s. 115 of the MPLRC.
The proceedings are still pending before the SDO in which the petitioner
can participate and establish his right on the land.
Appreciation and conclusion 7.
The main contention of the learned senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner is that the petitioner filed an application for vacating stay before
the SDO and instead of deciding the said application the SDO has wrongly
passed the final order without giving any opportunity to argue the case on
merit.
8.
On the basis of the information that the land bearing Survey
Nos.464/2, 1464/3, 1464/4, 1464/5, 1464/6, 1464/7, 1464/8 and 1464/9 has
been registered in the name of Mahadev Mandir, but from time to time,
name of Bhoomi Swami were changed and now, a multi-storied building is
under construction. Therefore, suo motu case was registered on 23.3.2021
and notices were issued to the petitioner and other co-owners to explain as
to how the title has been transferred in their name and till then the
- : 5 :W.P. No.930/2022
construction be stopped. A common notice was issued to the petitioner for
appearance on 27.3.2021. The petitioner appeared and sought time to file
the reply. Vide order dated 31.3.2021, the Halka Patwari was directed to
submit the report. On 1.7.2021 counsel appearing for Hulashchandra filed
an application for vacating stay. Counsel for respondent No.4 submitted an
objection. The arguments were heard and final order dated 23.7.2021 was
passed for taking up the matter suo motu u/s. 115 of the MPLRC and the
Tehsildar, Rau was directed to inquire about the entries in the Revenue
Register since 1925 and submit the report within 15 days. The case which
was registered was closed and a fresh case u/s. 115 of the MPLRC was
registered.
Section 115 of the MPLRC is quoted below :
“115. Correction of wrong or incorrect entry in land record(1)A Sub-Divisional Officer may, on his own motion or on
application of an aggrieved person, after making such enquiry as he
deems fit, correct any wrong or incorrect entry including an
unauthorised entry in the land records prepared under section 114
other than Bhoo-Adhikar Pustika and record of rights, and such
corrections shall be authenticated by him:
Provided that no action shall be initiated for correction of any
entry pertaining to a period prior to five years without the sanction
in writing of the Collector.
(2) No order shall be passed under subsection (1) without(a) getting a written report from the Tahsildar concerned; and (b)
giving an opportunity of hearing to all parties interested:
Provided that where interest of Government is involved, the
SubDivisional Officer shall submit the case to the Collector.
(3) On receipt of a case under sub-section (2), the Collector
shall make such enquiry and pass such order as he deems fit.”
As per sub-section (1) of Section 115, the SDO may, on his own motion or
on application of an aggrieved person, after making such enquiry as he
deems fit, correct any wrong or incorrect entry including an unauthorized
entry in the land records. Therefore, as on today only a case u/s. 115 of the
- : 6 :W.P. No.930/2022
MPLRC has been registered by the SDO on his own motion. No final order
has been passed for correction of the entries in the revenue record and after
enquiry, if the SDO comes to the conclusion that the entries are liable to be
corrected, then as per Proviso he shall not initiate action for correction of
the any entry pertaining to a period prior to five years without the sanction
in writing of the Collector. Therefore, at this stage, sanction from the
Collector is not required. Unless after the enquiry the SDO comes to the
conclusion that the entries are liable to be corrected which are pertaining to
a period prior to five years, the permission from the Collector is not
required. As per sub-section (2) of Section 115, no order shall be passed
under sub-section (1) without getting a written report from the Tehsildar
concerned and without giving opportunity of hearing to all parties.
Therefore, at this stage, the SDO is following the procedure prescribed
under sub-section (2) as he has already directed the Tehsildar to submit the
report and also served the notice to the petitioner and others for
opportunity of hearing. Sub-section (3) of Section 115 further gives an
opportunity of enquiry by the Collector. As per this sub-section, on receipt
of a case under sub-section (2), the Collector shall make such enquiry and
pass such order as he deems fit. Therefore, as on today, no adverse order
has been passed, hence, no interference is called for by the High Court.
The SDO has only initiated the proceedings u/s. 115 of the MPLRC in
which the petitioner will get an opportunity of hearing after the report
submitted by the Tehsildar. Therefore, no interference is called for.
9.
The petition is accordingly dismissed.
( VIVEK RUSIA )
JUDGE
Alok/-
Date: 2024.01.24 15:43:24 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review