Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3304 ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO
WRIT PETITION NOs: 32875 & 4s869 0F 2016
W.P.No.32875 OF 2016
Between:
!-!in!ujq Foundries Limited, (Ductron Castings Unit) B-15, 16 and 3/i3, lDA, Uppal
Hyderabad - 500 039, Telangana Represented by ita Authorised Signatory
...PETITIONER
AND
The Chairman-cum-Presidin s Officer Addl. lndustrial, Tribunal-cum-Addl.
Labour Court, 1st Floor Chan d ra Vihar, M.J. Road Nampally, Hyderabad - 500
2. Bachu Sambasiva Rao, S/o Late B. Ramatataiah Aged hbout 54 years
3- A. Sreeramulu, S/o late A. Hanumaiah Aged about 47 years
4. f. Chenna Reddy, S/o T. Venkata Reddy Aged about 52 years
5. IMd. Sharief Hussain, S/o Md.Hameed Hussain Aged about 56 years
6. P. Eswaraiah, S/o P. Venkataiah aged about 57 years
7. B. Narsimha Reddy, S/o B. Sathireddy Aged about 54 years
B. M. Ganesh Kumar, S/o M. Ananthaiah Aged about 51 years
9. P. Ramulu, S/o P. Pentaiah Aged about O5 years
10. Md. Raheemuddin, S/o Md. Fakruddin Aged about 55 years
'11. N. Mallesh, S/o N. Yelialah Aged
about 53 years,
12.K. Swamy, Sio K. Chandraiah Aged about 52 years
'13. T. Bal Reddy, S/o T.
Chittareddy Aged about 55 years
14. S. Narsimhulu, S/o S. Rajaiah Aged about 49 years
15. K. Ramulu, S/o K. Anjaiah Aged about 54 years
'16. Ch. Ashok, S/0 Ch. Ramachandraiah
Aged about 51 years
17. B. Malta Reddy, S/o late B. Rajiredy Aged about 54 years
'l 8. Ahmed Bin Mehmood, S/o Ahmed Bin Annumiya Agetl rbout 55 years
'19. P. Pratap Reddy, S/o P. Ramireddy Aged about 53 ye a s
20.A. Raghupathi Reddy, S/o A. NarayanareddyAged ab: rt 56 years
2'l . R. Agaiah, S/o R. Naraiah Aged about 56 years
22. P. Shankar, S/o P. Narasalah Aged about 54 years
23. M. Balanarasimha, S/o. M. Balaiah Aged about 54 year ;
24.B. Sree Pandu, S/o B. Sattiah Aged about 52 years
25.Gudi Sudhakar Reddy, S/o Gudi Mallareddy Aged abor 54 years
26. E Ganga Raju, S/o E. Anjaneyulu Aged about 54 years
27. Butti Narasimha, S/o B. Ramaiah Aged about 50 years
28. Kondala Venkatesh, S/o K. Kistalah Aged about 46 yert s
29. Damabolna Ramulu, S/o D. Basavaiah Aged about 54 1 :ars
30.S. Sathi Reddy, S/o Rajamallareddy Aged about 50 yea.s
31 . A. Balram, S/o A. Mallesh Aged about 52 years
32. M. Narendher Reddy, S/o M. Sanjeeva Reddy, Aged a I )ut 52 years
33. K. Yadagiri, S/o K. Paravathaiah Aged about 56 years
34. M. Krishna, S/o M. Satyanarayana Aged about 53 years
35. K. Yaddaiah, S/o K. Sallu Aged about 54 years
36. S. Bal Reddy, S/o S. Venkata Reddy Aged about 49 yee rs
37. G. Dhana Raj, S/o G. Balaiah Aged about 46 years
38. M. Balaiah, S/o M. Narasaiah Aged about 47 years
39. B. Ranga Reddy, S/o B. Malla Reddy Aged about 54 yei rs
40. M.N. Mallikarjuna Rao, S/o M.N. Narasimhulu, Aged ab( ut 54 years
41. N. Venkateswara Rao, S/o N. Ramaiah Aged about 52 y ..ars
42. P. Ravinder Reddy, S/o P. Narayana Reddy Aged abottl 54 years
43.K. Kishna Reddy, S/o K. Ranga ReddyAged about 52 ,r, ars
44.K. Lakshmaiah, S/o K. Dhanaiah Aged about 57 years
45.D. Raghupathi, S/o D. Gandalah Aged about 53 years
46. M. Ravinder Reddy, S/o M. Lachi Reddy Aged about 521 rears
47. E. Mahesh, S/0 E. Yelloii Aged about 51 years
48.V. Narasimha Reddy, S/o V. Yadi Reddy Aged about 50 /ears
49.R. Sanjeeva Reddy, S/o R. Narasimha Reddy Aged abo tt 52 years
50.D. Sanjeeva Reddy, S/o D. Lakshma Reddy Aged about 53 years
51 . B. Ramchander, S/0 B. Narasalah Aged about 55 years
52. N. Kishan, Sio N. Yelleshwar Aged about 52 years
53.A. Balender, S/o A. Siva Raj Aged about 47 years
54.P. V. Subba Raju, S/o P.V. Venkat Ram Raju Aged about 55 years
55.G. Thirupathi Reddy, S/o G. Amrutha RedyAged about 54 years
56. B. Narasimha Reddy, S/o B. Achi Reddy Aged about 51 years
57.Abdul Saleem Khan, S/o Abdul Majeed Khan Aged about 44 years
58. J. Darshan, S/o J. Venkaiah Aged about 51 years
59. T. Dass, S/o T. Venkaiah Aged about 48 years
60.Shaik Dawood, S/o Shaik Monuddin Aged about 51 years
61. K. Ramulu, S/o. K. Yadagiri Aged about 47 yearc
62.K. Balraj, S/o K. Venkatalah Aged about 52 years
63. U. Maisaiah, S/o U. Peddulu Aged about 57 years
64.S. Gal Reddy, S/o S. Venkat Reddy Aged about 52 years
65. P. Ramesh, S/0 P. IVlasalah Aged about 45 years
66.L. Rambabu, S/o L. Surya Rao Aged about 50 years
67. G. Sathya Reddy, S/o G. Narasimha Reddy Aged aboui 51 years
68.B. Satyanarayana, S/o B. Rangaiah Aged about 45 years
69. K. Dass, S/o K. Mallalah Aged about 5'l years
70.Md. Qadeer, S/o Md.Khaseem Aged about 52 years
71 .A. Kistaiah, S/o A. Narasimha Aged about 51 years
72.Sk. Hasansaheb, S/o Sk. Meera Saheb Aged about 49 years
73. K. Obaiah, S/0 K. Benjiman Aged about 48 years
74.Ch. Srinivas, S/o Ch. Mukundalah Aged about 52 years
75. R. Narasimha, S/o R. Beeraiah Aged about 51 years
76.A. Thrimurthulu, S/o late A. Ballaiah Aged about 55 years
77. N. Veerasham, S/o N. Ramulu Aged about 40 years
78.P. Subbaiah, S/0 P. Veeraiah Aged about 54 years
79. K. Sivaiah, S/o K. Yacob Aged about 50 years
80.T. Narisimha Reddy, S/o T. Ram Reddy Aged about 47 years
81.T. Balaji Rao, S/o T. Janardhana Rao Aged about 51 years
82.T. Yadaiah, S/o T. Agaiah Aged about 51 years
83. N. Ramulu, S/0 N. Pentaiah Aged about 49 years
84. B. Muthyam Reddy, S/o B. Anii Reddy Aged about 52 y )ars
85. Y. Srinivasulu, Sio Y. Saialah Aged about 51 years
86. B. Venkatesham, S/o B. Ramulu Aged about 50 years
87. K. Laxma Reddy, S/o K. Yadi Reddy Aged about 48 Ve; rs
88. D. Suvarthudu, S/o D. Mosess Aged about 53 years
89. P. Raji Reddy, S/o P. Veera Reddy Aged about 48 yez,r ;
90.K. Yadagiri, S/o K. Muttaiah Aged about 50 years
91 . E. Venkataramana, S/o E. Anjaneyulu Aged about 52 'r ,ars
92. B. Sudhakar Reddy, S/o B. Pratap Reddy Aged about 4 ) years
93. B. Jaganadha Rao, S/o B. Surya Rao Aged about 50 y€ ars
94. M. Shankar, S/o M. Basavaiah Aged about 53 years
95. B. Ashok, S/o B. Govardhan Aged about 54 years
96.J Shaker Reddy, S/o J. Muthyam ReddyAged about 43 years
97. G. Sathaiah, S/0 G. Balaiah Aged about 5'l years
98. D. Lingam, S/0 D. Beeraiah Aged about 52 years
99.C. Mohan, S/o C. Agafah Aged about 48 years, -
100. G. Sreenivas, S/o G. Masalah Aged about 48 years
. Ch. Bikhapathy, S/o Ch. Lachalah Aged about 45 yean;
102. K. Radha Krishna, S/o K. Narasimha Rao Aged about ti years
103. B. Sathi Reddy, S/o B. Janga Reddy Aged about 57 yez-s
104. K. Yadi Reddy, S/o K. Janardhan ReddyAged about 5z years
105. R. Shankar, S/o R. Mallaiah Aged about 52 years
106. D. Narasimha, S/o D. Beeraiah Aged about 51 years
. K. Anjaneyulu, S/o K. Durgaiah Aged about 55 years
108. T. Prabhakar, S/o T. Yadaiah Aged about 50 years
109. G. Narvothama Reddy, S/o G. Raji ReddyAged about I I years
110. D. Satyanarayana, S/o D. Mutyalu Aged about 52 year:;
111. P.V. Rama Rao, S/o P. Yanadhi Rao Aged about 51 ye. rs
112. B. Ramaswamy, S/o B. Lalcshmaiah Aged about 54 ye€ 's
113. J. Venkat Reddy, S/o J. Muthyam ReddyAged about 44 years
114. P. Pratap Reddy, Sio P. Pula Reddy Aged about 54 years
115. B. Narsi Reddy, S/o B. Maya ReddyAged about 44 years
16. M. Kamal Reddy, S/0 late M. Chandra Reddy Aged about 48 years
117. N. Janga Chary, S/o N. Mallaiah Aged about 52 years
118. A. Shivashankar Rao, S/o A. Chiftabbaiah Aged about 43 years
119. S. Bal Reddy, S/o S. IVIalta ReddyAged about4Tyears
120. G. Mallesh, S/0 G. Srisailam Aged about 48 years 121. R. Raju, S/o R. Narasimha Aged about 48 years
122. E. Krishna Reddy, S/o E. Penta Reddy Aged about 49 years
123. Ch. Venkatesh, S/o Ch. Gandaiah Aged about 47 yearc
124. B. Yadagiri, S/o B.Yellaiah Aged about 48 years
125. T. Venkatachary, S/o T. Raghunatham Aged about 43 years
126. R. Sal Reddy, S/o R. Ram Reddy Aged about 53 years
127. N. Srinivas, S/o N. Narasaiah Aged about 44 yearc
128. T. Dayakar Reddy, S/o T. Chandra Reddy Aged about 46 years
129. M. Venkataratnam, S/o M. Venkatalah Aged about 49 years
130. K. Bal Reddy, S/o K. Yadi Reddy Aged about 49 years
131. P. Janardhan Reddy, S/o P. Venkat ReddyAged about 56 years
132. G. Ramulu, S/0 G. Narasaiah Aged about 56 years
133. Oh. Parvathalu, S/o Ch. Devalah Aged about 52 years, 134. Ch. Venkata Rao, Sio. Ch. Narayana Aged about 49 years
135. P. Arlaiah, S/o P. Chinnalah Aged about 44years
136. M. Sankaraiah, S/o M. Narayana Aged about 48 years
137. Yakubbin Ali, S/o Mahamoodbin All Aged about 45 years
138. N. Jagedeeshwar, S/o N. Srihari Aged about 40 years
139. G. Anjalah, S/o G. Maisaiah Aged about 46 years, .
14O. P. Kumar, S/o Venkatalah Aged about 43 years
. K. Malla Reddy, S/o K. Venkata Reddy Aged about 48 years
142. K. Sadaiah, S/o Yesaiah Aged about 50 years
143.." V. Ramchandra Reddy, S/o V. Nagireddy Aged about 49 years
144. K. Raghavarao, S/o K. venkateshwarlu Aged about 53 years
145. M. Yellareddy, S/o M. Narasimha Reddy Aged about 50 years
146.
M. Ram Reddy, S/o M.Yadi ReddyAged about 43yea':
147.
J. Sankaraiah, S/o J. Muthyalu Aged 44 years, -
148.
R. Shekar, S/o R.Pentaiah Aged about 45 years
149.
P. Jangaiah, S/o P. Pentaiah Aged about 45 years
150.
P. Jangaiah, Sio P. Gopal Aged about 46 years
15'l
S. Srinivasan, S/o T. Sarangan Aged about 45 years, -
.
152.
T. Raja Rathnam, S/o T. Anantharamulu Aged about 43 years
153.
P. Sham Rao, S/o P. Yadaiah Aged about 48 years
154.
P. Ashok, S/o P. Yadaiah Aged about 43 years
'155.
S. Nagaraju, S/0 S. Anjalah Aged 43 years
156.
A. Vittal, Sio A. Rajamalaiah Aged about 43 years
157.
K. Srinivas, S/o K. Venkataramaiah Aged about 45 yee r
'l 58.
K. Narasimha Reddy, S/o K. Ramachandra Reddy, Ag() I about 43 years
159.
J. Bhaskar Reddy, S/o J. Narasimha Reddy Aged abotrl 46 years
160.
K. Brahmananda Reddy, S/o K. Parvatha Reddy,Aged z cout 49 years
161 .
R. Malla Reddy, S/0 R. Achi ReddyAged about 45year
162.
B. Pochi Reddy, S/o B. Janga Reddy Aged about 51 yer rS
163.
l. Laxmi Reddy, S/o. l. Obula Konda ReddyAged about 19 years
164.
A.Parameswar Reddy, S/o A. Ram Reddy Aged about 4 ) years
K. Balaguravaiah, S/o K. Guravaiah Aged about 44 yezrr
166.
V. Ashok, S/o V. Yadaiah Aged about 46 years
167.
V. Pochetty, S/o V. Yadaiah Aged about 48 years
'168.
G. Narasimha Reddy, S/o late G. Ranga Reddy,Aged et out 55 years
169.
Boggula Mallaiah, S/o B. Narasimhulu Aged about 57 y€ ars
170.
S. Mallareddy, S/o S. Ramreddy Aged about 50 years
171.
S. Ralanarsaiah, SiO Shankaralah Aged about 43 year:;
172.
K. Srishailam, S/o K. Gouraiah Aged about 45 years
173.
A.Damodar Reddy, Sio A. Jagga Reddy Aged about 45 'ears
174.
B. Srinivas, S/o B. Narsimha Aged about 40 years
175.
R. Narsimhareddy, S/o R. Laxmareddy Aged about 44 r )ars
176.
R. Jayakumar, S/o Ramalcrishna Pillai Aged about 49 5't ars
177.
T. Satyanarayana, S/o T. Narsaiah Aged about 49 yeats
178. T. Nageshwara Rao, S/o T. Balanna Aged 46 years
179. V. Ramesh, S/o V. Kistaiah Aged about 45 years
180.
P. Shankaran, S/o P. Partha Saradhi Aged about 57 years
181 .
N. Shyam Rao, Sio Yellaiah Aged about 46 years
182. T. Devender Reddy, S/o Mohan ReddyAged about 44years
183.
M. Ramanujam, S/o late Laxminarasaiah Aged about 46 years
184.
K. Kumar, Sio K. Agalah, Aged about 48 years
(All the Respondent Nos.2 to 184 are C/o Mr. Chikkudu Prabhakar, Advocate,
Flat No.40'l , SRMR Nilayam, 13th Street Chikkadpally, Hyderabad-SO0 020)
185.
The Commissioner of Labour, Government of Telangana T Anjaiah Karmika
Bhavan, RTC X Roads Hyderabad - 500 020
The Ashok Leyland Employees' Union (Regd.No.8-942), rep. by Rs General
Secretary, Mr. Pakir Narasaiah, S/o Pakir Veeraiah, Aged 46 years, Rio 2-2l24lTll Vijayapuri Colony, Uppal, Ranga Reddy Dist. Hyderabad - 500 039
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to (a) issue a Writ more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
Prohibitioh restraining the Respondent No-1, viz., the Chairman-cum-Presiding
Officer, Addl. lndustrial Tribunal-cum-Addl. Labour Court, Hyderabad from
proceeding further with l.D. No. 30 of 2016 (b) declare that the impugned
proc""iling" are totally without jurisdiction (c) consequently quash the said
proceedings pending on the file of the Respondent No.1 i.e., the Chairman-cumPresiding Officer, Addl. lndustrial Tribunal-cum-Addl. Labour Court, Hyderabad.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2016(WP MP. NO:40674OF20161
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings in l.D.No.30 of 2016 on the file of the learned respondent
No.1 viz., the Chairman-cum-Presiding Officer, Addl. lndustrial Tribunal cum Addl.
Labour Court, Hyderabad, pending disposal of the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petjtioner : SRI C.R.SRIDHARAN, Senior Counsel,
rep., SRI G.V.S.GANESH
.
Counsel for the Respondent No.1&&185: GP FOR LABOUR
Counsel for the Respondent No.2to184 : SRI CHIKKUDU PRABHAKAR
Counsel for the Respondent No.185 :
W.P.NO: 45869 OF 2016
Eq!rygg-rr:-
uinaqi:rounJrieitimireil (rjuctroneastrn-ga unit) B-+5'r6 & I '13; ioA, uppal
Hyderabad - 500 039, Telangana Represented by its Authoriz(t Signatory.
...Petitioner
[eelitionei in W.F.rk 45869 or 2016
on the fi ) of High Court)
AND
1, The Chairman-cum-Presiding Officer, Addl. lndustrial 'lr )uoal-cumAddl. Labour Court, l" Floor, Chandra Vihar, M.J. Rca i Namapally,
Hyderabad - 500 001.
2 A. Madhava Naidu, S/o. Pothaiah Naidu, Aged about 5l /ears
P. Karunakar Reddy, S/o..Raji Reddy, Aged about 44 /{ ars
N. Ramesh, S/o. Papaiahi Aged about 27 yeani.
B. Sagar Reddy, S/o, Venkat,Reddy, Aged abotrt'56 y,l .S
V. Arogya R€ddy, S/o. Oasi Reddy, Aged about 47 yeilr
Y. Mohan Reddy, S/o. Narsi Reddy, Aged about 55 yi,e s
A. Bala Narsimha, S/o. Ramaswamy. Aged about 5'1 ye rS
G. Ramulu, S/o. Yadaiah.Aged about 45 years
10. K Sanieeva Reddy, S/o. Narsi Reddy, Aged about.l: ,ears
11. G. Srinivas, Sio. Kistaiah. Aged about years
12. A. Prasad, S/o. Safyanarayana, Aged about 45 years
1 3. J, Satyanarayaoa, S/o. Pentaiah, Aged about 49 yea s
14. M Srinivasa Rao, S/o. Ramakrishna, Aged about 49 y 'ars
15. Ch. copala Krishna, S/d. Narasimha Rao, Aged aboLi 4 years
t 6. S. Swamy, S/o. Ramulu, Aged aboilt 49 years
17. A. Bikshapatti, S/o. Ramaswamy; Aged about 49 year
I
I
8. P. Gopalal Krishna. S/o. Radhakrishan, Aged about 41 yearc
19. E.V. Adharaiah, S/o. Yohan, Aged about 47. years
20. U Nageswara Rao, S/o- Ankaiah, aged about 49 years
21. K.Agaiah, S/o. Rajaiah, aged about 46 years
22. Sadanand Maji, S/o,Narayana Chandramaji. aged abor t ;'l years
23. S.Subba Rao, S/o. Sathiraju, aged about 53 years
24- Kamalmangal. S/o.Muktiswarmangal. aged about 50 yEE S
25. R.Narsimha Reddy. Sfo. Chandra Redily, aged about 54 years
26. B.Raghava Redduy, S/o. Na6i Reildy, aged about 4€ )€
27. T.Rama Rao, S/o. Ramulu, aged about 4tl years
28. S.Sahodar Reddy, S/o. O.Venkat Ram Reddy, aged abc t 50 years
29. KSridhar, S/o. Narsihmaiah, aged about 50 years
30. B.Ravinder Reddy, S/o, Nalayana R6ddy, aged bout 4i ears
3'l. V.Srinivas, S/o.Rairachaidram, a0ed about 48 years
32. T.Mallesh, S/o. Chandraiah. aged dbout 47 years
33. R.Shankeraiah, S/o. Ramaswamy, aged about 47 yea(,
Contd.2..,
I
:.3i-!;;41!-+,..-.,:.'':-.....;|:|+..:
34) B. Venkateswara Rao,
'
Aged about 51 years
35) S. Ganga Raju, S/o Narayana Raju
Aged about 54 years
36) Ch. Malla Reddy, S/o Agireddy
Aged about 49 years
37)
V. Pushpa Raju, S/o Devadanam
Aged about 46 years
38)
L. Narsimha Reddy/ S/o Lakshmi Narsimha
Reddy, Aged about 49 years
39) B. Prabhakar Reddy, S/o Pratap Reddy
Aged about 42 years
40) K. Krishna Reddy, S/o Ramireddy
Aged about 53 years
47)
P. Ramakrishna Reddy, S/o Narasimha Reddy,
Aged about 51 years
42) G. Pramod Reddy, S/o Mahipal Reddy
Aged about 49 years
43) Ch. Balaiah. S/o Ramaswamy
Aged about 55 years
44) T. Anjaneyulu, S/o Narayana
' Aged about 46 years
45) N. Pochalah, S/o Yellaiah
Aged about 45 years
,46)
V. Satyapal, S/o Ayyanna
Aged about 46 years
47) Ch. Srinivasa Rao, S/o Appala Ramanna
Aged about 47 years
48) B.V. Ramana Murthy, S/o Surayya
Aged about 44 years
49) T. Vittal Reddy, S/o Kista Reddy
Aged about 51 years
50) P. Yadaqiri, S/o Maisaiah
Aged about 47 years
51) P. Mohan deddy, S/o Lachi Reddy
Aged about54 years
52) K. Narsimha Reddy, S/o Sai Reddy
Aged about 57 years
53) S. Tirumalesha. S/o Narsimha '
Aged about 48 years
54) A. Jangaiah, S/o Yadaiah
Aged about 46 years
-
55) B.V, Satyanarayana/ s/o Late veeraswamy
Aged about 51 years
56) G. Biksham Reddy, S/o Veera Reddy
Aged about 53 years
57) G. Satyanarayana, S/o Mohan Rao
Aged about 43 years
58) K. Krishna Reddy, S/o Narayanareddy
Aged about 56 years
59)
Ch. Mahender, S/o Mallaiah
Aged about 46 years
60) P. Raju, S/o Yadaiah
Aged about 49 yea.s
61)
Ch. Ravindra Reddy, S/o Chandra Reddy
Aged about 49 years
62)
K. Madhu Sudhan Reddy,
S/o Raji Reddy, Aged about 50 years
63) V. Someswara Chary, S/o Shekaraiah
Aged about 45 years
64)
N. Chandra Reddy, S/o Raji Reddy
Aged about 48 years
65)
G. Swamy, S/o Shivaiah
Aged about 52 years
66) K. Kondal Reddy, S/o Late Parvatha Reddy
Aged about 53 years
67) B. Srinivas, S/o Buchaiah
Aged about 48 years
68) K. Brahmanandam, S/o Jangaiah
Aged about 49 years
69) G. Venkateswarlu, S/o Tirupathaiah
Aged about 47 years
70) P. Narsimha. S/o Lamaiah
Aged about 47 years
7L)
P. Balaiah, S/o Mallaiah
Aged about 47 years
72) P. Ananda CharyJ S/o Dathatreya
Aged about 49 years
73) M. Danish, S/o Sabsteen
Aged about 49 years
74)
M. Narsimha Reddy, S/o Yadireddy
Aged about 50 years
75) G. Srinivasa Reddy, S/o Amrutha Reddy
Aged about 51 years
7.6) J. Mallesh Chari, S,/o Narsimha Chary
Aged about 56 years
17) G. Venugopal Rao, S,/o Janaki Ramaiah
Aged about 58 years
78) G. Venkat Reddy, S/o Papireddy
Aged about 47 years
79) V. Anji Reddy, S/o Venkat Rami Reddy
Aged about 47 years
80) M. Subba Raidu, S/o Sanjeeva Raidu
Aged about 47 years
81) D.V. Srinivasa Rao, S/o Sambashiva Rao
Aged about 48 years
82) l. Pentaiah. S/o Late Mutyalu
Aged about 49 years
83) K. Krishna Reddy. S/o Ganna Reddy
Aged about 48 years
84) Md. Yousut S/o Jamaluddin
Aged about 53 years
85) A. Mohan Rao, S/o Potharaju
Aged about 56 years
86) B. Anjireddy. S/o Chandrareddy
f
Aged about 52 years
87)
R. Srisallam, S/o Rama Swamy
Aged about 54 years
88) T. Satyam, S/o Lakshman
Aged about 51 years
89) S. Ourgaiah, s/o Ettaiah.
Aged about 41 years
(All the Respondent Nos.2 to 89 are c/o Mr. chikkudu Prabhakar Advocate,
n. no. f-e-zlr.3, Krupa Vilasam, Carona Lane, ChikkadpallY Hyderabad-soo
o2o)
e0)
The Commissioner of Labour
Govemment of Telangana
T Anjaiah Karmika Bhavan, RTC X Roads
Hyderabad - 500 020
e1)
F
f
i
,",
The Ashok Leyland Employees Union
Regd. No. 8-942. its rep. by General Secretary
Pakir. Narsaiah
S/o. Pakir Veeraiah, Age: 46 years
N o. 2-Z- L24/7 / l, Vijayapuri Colony
./
Uppal, Hyderabad-soo 039
Rangareddy Dist
...RESPONDENTS/
RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lrc ia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to- (a) issue a Writ more particularly one in I re nature of Writ of
Prohibition restraining the Respondent No.1 , viz., the Ch:ri 'man -cum- Presiding
Officer, Addl. lndustrial Tribunal -cum- Addl. Labour Cour , '1 5t Floor , Chandra
Vihar, M.J. Road, Nampally, Hyderabad - 500 001, from 1r oceed ing further with
l.D. No. 39 of 2016 (b) declare that the impugned p., ceedings are totally
without jurisdiction (c) consequently quash the said proce
<
d
ings pending on the
file of the Respondent No.'l viz., the Chairman-cum-P1 siding Officer, Addl.
lndustrial Tribunal-cum-Addl. Labour Court, 1st Floor
Shandra Vihar, M.J.
Road, Nampally, Hyderabad - 500 001.
l.A. NO: 1 OF2016(WPMP . NO:56525 OF 2016)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in th€ ;ircumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High CoJ 1 may be pleased To
stay all further proceedings in LD.No.39 of 2016 on tl-'r file of the Learned
Respondent No.'l viz., the Chairman-cum-Presid ing Or'f cer, Addl. lndustrial
Tribunal-cum-Addl. Labour Court, 1St Floor, Chandra Vihar, M.J. Road,
Nampally, Hyderabad - 500 001, pending disposal of the U rit Petition.
counsel ror the Petition"'
'
,t}i,t;[lt#5.tXtkti"'"r
Counsel forthe Respondent No.1&90: GP FOR LABOUR
Counsel for the Respondents No.2to89,91:
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
3 runsel'
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT I{YDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI WSTICE NAMAVARAPU RAJESHWAR RAO
WRIT PETITION Nos.328 7S and 45869 of2O16
Date : 09.01.2O26
Between :
Hinduja Foundaries Limited.
.. Petitioner
AND
The Chairman-cum Presiding OfIicer,
Additional Industrial Tribuna,l-cumAdditional Labour Court, Hyderabad and others.
.. Respondents
COMMON ORDER:
These two Writ Petitions are hled seeking to issue a
writ of prohibition restraining the Chairman-cum-Presiding
Officer, Additional Industrial Tribunal-cum-Additional Labour
Court, Hyderabad-Respondent No.1, from proceeding further
with I.D.Nos.3O of 2016 and 39 of 2016 on its file and
consequently quash the said proceedings-
2.
Since the issue involved is identical, these two writ
petitions are being disposed of by way of common order'
3.
For convenience, the facts in W.P.No.31) \75 of 2016 arc
discussed hereunder:
(a) The Petitioner herein is a Compar f incorporated
under the Companies Act, 1956, and it -is Ingaged in the
business of castings for automobiles and trac :ors, industrial
engines, construction equipment and pc\ 'er generation
equipment. It has its unit known as 'Ductro.t Castings Unit'
at IDA, Uppal, Hyderabad.
(b) The said unit has become unv able, and the
Petitioner Company incurred recurring losse ; for the past
eight years. The operations were suspended fr rm June 2O14,
ahd the said Unit has been totally r on-operational
from 01.O9.2015.
(c)
In the year 2014, the petitioner .r afized that the
further sustenance of the unit is not possitrl : unless some
extreme steps are taken to reduce the hxed c rsts. After due
deliberations with the Respondent No.1ti' ' Union and
apprising them of the reasons for the units unr, able situation,
the petitioner management introduced a
Voluntary
Retirement Scheme on O 1.O9.2O 14, offering c < mpensation to
eligible workmen who opt thereunder. Out of 425 workmen on
the units ro11 as on 01.09.2014, 193 opted for the said VR
Scheme by submitting appiications in the prescribed Telugu
language. All the employees, inciuding respondent Nos.2 to
184 herein, have voluntarily submitted their applications,
which were. accepted, and they were all paid compensation
under the said Scheme, and thus the first VR Scheme itself
came to an end.
(d)
Respondent No. 2 was also one such employee
who opted under the First VR Scheme, having submitted his
application dated 07.O9.2014, which was accepted by the
Petit ioner management.
(e)
A11 the workmen, who had opted under the First
VR Scheme were paid compensation in two instalments and
since the VR Scheme introduced by the Petitioner
management was in accordance with Section 1O (1OC) of the
Income Tax Act, 1961 read with Rule 2-BA of the Income Tax
Rules, 1962, a1l the workmen availed the benefit of exemption
from the computation of the said compensation as 'Income'.
(f)
Even after downsizing the worl force, thereby
reducing the fixed cost towards labour, the petitioner
management realized that the efforts to imprc ,,e the viability
of the unit are not likely to yield any positive lesired results
in the light of technical, commercial ar-r I other issues
plaguing the unit and in order to protect the nterests of the
workmen, the petitioner management introdrL ed the second
VR Scheme dated 27.05.2015 offering ex-grat i in addition to
the VRS compensation and all the remainir^t1 l2S workmen
opted thereunder, which was accepted by tt e respondents
ald a1l the said workmen were paid compens,.tion, ex-gratia
and other dues, which were received by them.
G) While things stood thus, aJter : lapse of more
than one year after the first VR Scheme, respt rdent Nos.2 to
184 frled a petition under section 2-A(2) of tt
r
ID Act before
respondent No.1 herein, and the following are the brief
averments in I.D.No.30 of 2016 before the 1"t re ;pondent:
(1) TLLe Petitioners therein u)ere wor| i Lg in tlrc
respondent No.7 org anization ttrcrein;
0l 'fhe petitioners are questioning the ac ion of tle
respondent No.l therein in ollegedly tosirtg the
(
a)
industry in a purported aduertisement issued on
19.08.2015, uithout prior pertnission of tle
state gouernment as illegal, arbitrary, unjus| unlauful,
unconstitutional and again-st the prouisions of the ID Act
and Articles, 12, 14, 16, 19 & 21 of the Constttrttion of
India, as also uarious judgments of th.e Apex Court;
(iii) The manogers of tLLe respondent No. 1 componA
threatened/ u.tarned them in such a utag to "get ouaA
them from tLte Compang" stoting that "the company is in
loss" and if only oll of them resign uoluntailg, tle
componA will suruiue, othenlise, false ollegations and
cases uill be foi-sted against then for terminating them
from the seruices;
(iu) Ttnt the uorkmen tuere harassed by the respond.ent
No-1 therein in different uags and ttey uere forced to
resign by deploying the police in the establishment to
threaten them and thot tLeg came to knou from the
relioble source that the recognized union colluded uith
tLrc management regarding forcible settlement of the
seruices of the u-,orkmen;
(u) That out of the blue, the respondent No.1 placed.
plain tuhite papers before them and forciblg obtained_
their signatures ond after feu days, the management
ha,s paid some amounts to th_em through cheqtes,
(u-thich is dubbed bg them as 'Forcible Retrenchment' in
uiolation of the proutsions of the ID Act);
(h)
The prayer is as follows:
"It is therefore prayed that this Hon'ble ct rt mag be
pleased to declaing the action of the 7st r.l pondent in
termination of the workmen from seruic(
in u.tithout
follouing the Sec.2SFF of the Industrial ltt *)utes Act,
1947 and other prouisions of the la u.t anti lso closi"ng
the companA by an aduertisement ;sued on
1g/ 08/ 201 5 ulithout pior permission ot the State
Gouentment os illegal, arbitrary, unju.s , unlauful,
unconstitutional ond agoinst to tlrc prot i,; tns of the
Industial Di-sputes Act, 1947 and against an Article
12, 1 4, 19 & 2 1 of Constitution of In(1 ( and aLso
uarious judgments of an Apex Court, con: .-quentially
pass auard to the workmen to reinstate tlt, seruice of
the workmen in an organi.z,ation of tle lst t 'espondent
and pass such other order or orders may tl em fit and
t
L
proper in the ciranmstonces of the case.
It is further proAed that this Hon'ble Cou 1 mag be
pleo.sed to suspend the oral tennination fror, seruice of
the uorkmen in uithout follouing tlte Sec. . iFF of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 and other Lt luisions of
the la u.t and also in issuing proceedings )f the l st
Respondent in closing thE compan I bg an
aduertisement issued on 19/O8/2O15 ui lrcut pior
permission of the State Gouentment and r. nstate th.e
petitioner seruice uith full back tlioql s in ata
organization of the lst respondentpending t isposal of
the aboue petiti:on and pass such otlrcr orde 'or orders
maA deem fit arul proper in the circumstc. t ces of the
case-"
\
In this regard, the present writ petitions are filed.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits
as follows:
(a) The enquiry by the Labour Court/Industrial
Tribunal as contemplated under Section 2-A of the ID Act is
and shall be limited to adjudication of the validity of
termination, discharge, dismissal or retrenchment of art
individual 'workman' by his employer and the scope of such
enquiry/jurisdiction cannot be enlarged at all, so as to decide
the
broader
questions of ceased employer-employee
relation sh ip.
.
(b) Section 2'A of the ID Act only permits 'art
individual workman' to make an application directly to the
Labour Court or Tribunal for adjudication of a dispute
connected with or arising out of discharge, dismissal,
retrenchment or termination of the services of such
'individual workmal'. Whereas, respondent No. I exceeded the
jurisdiction thereunder in entertaining a
purported
application frled by respondent No.2 herein for himself arrd on
behalf of the respondent Nos.3 to 184 collectively, which is
impermissible, particularly when the aver nents in the
petition disclose that the said workmen had c tted under the
Voluntary Retirement Schemes introduced b1 the petitioner
management and were paid amounts through r heques.
(c)
Respondent No.1 being a creatur: of the statute,
derives power by virtue of a reference under S.t ction 10 of the
ID Act or the like, and cannot assume j risd ictior-r ald
r_
entertain a purported petition under section 2 \ of the ID Act
even when the averments in the petitt r n themselves
unequivocally indicate that respondent Nos. j
to 1g4 have
ceased to be 'workmen' on account of their beir
3 relieved after
the acceptance of their VRS applications.
(d)
The Labour Court constituted unrl :r Section 7 of
the ID Act has no inherent jurisdiction like hat of a Civil
Court, because the powers are very clearly pr.< scribed by the
statute itself as per several judicial pronc I ncements, to
entertain a petition of the nature involved in tt e present writ
petition. The prayers in the petition frled by re; rondent Nos.2
to 184 are totally beyond/outside the scope ar1 I arnbit of the
powers of the Labour Court/Tribuna-l under Ss :tion 2 A(21 of
the ID Act and arnount to exceeding the jurisdiction and
exerclse
of non-existing jurisdiction, which deserves to be
prohibited by this Court.
(e)
Respondent Nos. 2 to 184 herein were admittedly
relieved from the services, pursuant to their opting for VR
Schemes which were introduced by the petitioner
mzrnagement and therefore, they cannot now raise aly
dispute without any cause whatsoever, much less, on the
alleged closure of the unit, purportedly seeking reemployment or reinstatement. Even on this ground' the
purported ID raised bY
respondent Nos. 2 to 184 under
Section 2-A of the ID Act is without jurisdiction and the
question of maintaining or raising any valid 'industrial
dispute' as against the petitioner company does not even
remotely arise and consequently, respondent No'1 would not
have jurisdiction whatsoever to entertain the present dispute
as against the petitioner herein and hence the proceedings in
theimpugnedlDaretotatlywithoutjurisdictionarrdareliable
to be quashed straightawaY.
l0
fl
(f)
The expression 'workman, as d,: ined in Section
2(s) of the ID Act relates only to those rr,-ro
employees. The only
are existing
addition to existing employees is
statutorrly provided under Section 2(s) of _ Le
dismissed, discharged, and retrenched emplc
grievances can be looked into by the Fora
ID Act, viz.,
vees, arld their
crr ated under the
Act. In the instant case, respondent Nor;2 to lg4
resigned/voluntar y retired from the services r
had
f the petitioner
company pursuant to the VR schemes int r rduced
by the
Management and therefore, they cannot be :overed
by the
expression 'workmen, at all insofar as tt r petitioner
is
concerned
.
(g)
Even from the very pleadings/aver.. rents made
the respondent No.2 in his petition before reslr ,ndent
is evident that as many as 1g3 employees like
by
No. 1, it
rim had opted
the VR scheme announced by the petitioner,s Company
and
all of them have got relieved pursuant the eto and vast
majority of them have no complaints whatsoe rer
force, etc., as is sought to be pleaded by
as threat,
respor dent Nos.2 to
184 herein. Therefore, ex-facie the very petitic n filed
under
ll
t.'I
Section 2-A of the ID Act is frivolous and incredible and
therefore, respondent No.l ought not to have entertained
such a petition.
(h)
Even from the documents filed along with the
impugned proceedings do not demonstrate any ingredients for
the invocation thereof, and there is a total lack ofjurisdiction
on the part of respondent No.1 and the total lack of bonalides
on the part of respondent Nos.2 to 184
(i)
From the prayers in the petition under Section
2- A(2\ of the I.D.Act, it is clearly evident that the grievance, if
any, is the alleged closure of the Union, which completely
goes out of the purview of Section 2A of the ID Act and at any
rate, cannot give rise to reinstatement/ re-employment of
respondent Nos.2 to 184, who have ceased to be 'workmen'
under Section 2(s) of the ID Act.
(,)
The petition hled under Section 2-A(2) of the ID
Act, purportedly in Form K4 prescribed under the AP
Industrial Disputes Rules, 1958,
1S
evidently signed by
respondent No.2 herein alone, who claims to represent the
\
t2
remaining 182 persons, who have opted for t te VR scheme,
by tiling the afhdavit on their behalf as well.
(k)
Form K4 read with Rule 11 (6) of r he Rules, even
assuming that it is directory in nature, permit ; al individual
workman to present the application under S<:, tion 2 A (21 of
the ID Act to the Labour Court/Tribunal, but r oes not permit
one person to represent 182 other persorr, but the l"t
respondent erroneously entertained the l etition under
Section 2 A(21 of tL,e ID Act.
(1)
Respondent Nos.2 to
184 ste.ed that the
petitioner allegedly violated Section 25-FF of tlL, ID Act, which
deals with compensation to workmen in cas: of transfer of
undertakings. Admittedly and undisputedll , there is no
transfer of undertaking in the instant case, rnd therefore,
Section 25-FF of the ID Act is irrelevant.
(m)
It is misleading to state that the pr titioner issued
an advertisement on 19.08.2015 regarding th,: closure of the
Unit, when it is a mere news item carried by t te newspaper.
l3
The alleged advertisement of closure of the unit without the
permission of the State Government is illega1 and
unconstitutional, ald it is also outside the scope of the
enquiry contemplated under Section 2-A of the ID Act
(n)
Therefore, in the light of the aforesaid averments
and prayers, it would automatically lead to the irresistible
conclusion that the Labour Court has no jurisdiction at all to
entertain I.D. Hence, allow the writ petitions
5.
Respondent No.2 frled a counter affidavit stating AS
follows:-
(a) The petitioner has its unit known as 'Ductron
Castings Unit' at Uppal, Hyderabad, and it was running well,
ald there was no proof that it was running at a loss. The
Auditing reports were not filed before the competent labour
authority, showing that the unit was running at a loss
Although it was running very well without any loss, the
petitioner herein, with malafide intention, without following
the due procedure, introduced the Voluntary Retirernent
Scheme and deployed the local police and threatened the
t4
labourers to accept the Voluntary Retirement Scheme and
paid the terminal benefits by way of cheques o respondent
Nos.2 to 186
(b) The workmen/respondents here n made a
representation to the competent Labour AutlL ,rity, but the
Labour Authority did not take aly actiorr against the
Management. Subsequently, ali the resgr, ndents had
approached a recognized Trade Union, but unfc -tunately, the
recognized Trade Union also colluded with thr' management
The petitioner forcibly implemented a compuls,r ry retirement
scheme, which is against the law and also aga: st the catena
of judgments of this Court and the Apex Court
(c) It is false to state that the manufir :turing at the
unit had stopped from O1.O9.2015 and there vas sufhcient
production during that time. While so, t re petitioner
displayed CRS on the board, but the responden s herein have
not come forward to take compulsory ret rement. The
petitioner depioyed a large number of local pol::e and forced
the respondents to sign the compulsory retirt ment scheme
(
f
documents. The respondents herein opposed the illegal and
criminal action of the petitioner, and quarrels took p1ace, and
some criminal cases were also registered against some of the
respondents due to the influence of the petitioner. Out of 425
workmen, 193 were forcibly terminated on 01.09.2014 with
terminal benehts.
(d)
The said scheme was introduced by the petitioner
without any notice or representation to the competent labour
authority. The petitioner, depending upon the local police,
introduced a compulsory retirement scheme. The petitioner
threatened the respondents herein that if they did not agree
to sign the papers for compulsory retirement, not only would
they be suspended from service, but they would also be
foisted with false cases, would not receive any benehts, ald
would be thrown out of employment. The respondents, having
no other alternative, signed on CRS papers and received some
of the amounts in two installments. Subsequently, after the
respondents were removed from the petitioner's industry on
O7.O9.2OI4, on 27.05.2015, the second term CRS was
introduced by the petitioner without following due procedure,
l6
and a large police force was again deployed i r the industry,
and the labourers signed the CRS papers; Some of the
amounts paid to employees were increased, and they were
forced to sign CRS documents. Between the i -st ald second
batches of CRS, there is a significant differen:e the way the
Management emoluments to
employees, which is
illegal and arbitrary.
(e) The respondents, having no otf er alternative,
approached the l.t respondent to declare tl e CRS of the
petitioner herein as illegal, arbitrary, discrimir r rtory, un lalvful
and unconstitutional and also against tit : catena of
judgments of this Court and the Apex Court, a rd also further
piayed that to set aside same and pass the a.rl.i rd to reinstate
the respondents herein in the petitioner's indus -ry.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for respot-r jent Nos.2 to
184 submits as follows :-
(a)
The question whether the action <> the petitioner
in introducing the CRS/VRS and forcing the r espondents to
sign on it is fair, reasonable, lawful and cor r ;titutional can
only be decided during the course of the trial n I.D.No.3O of
f
I
t7
2016 and I.D.No.39 of 2016 before the l"t respondent. If the
petitioner had followed due process of law ald obtained VRS
papers signed by the respondents herein in a fair and lawful
manner, the Tribunal would dismiss ID No.30 of 2016; if not,
then ID would be allowed, directing the reinstatement of the
respondents herein. The petitioner has an alternative to prove
his case before the l"trespondent, but despite having such an
alternative remedy, he approached this Court, which is bad in
law.
(b)
Respondent Nos.2 to 184 neither voluntarily
retired nor opted for the voluntar5r retirement scheme; only by
the force of the management of the petitioner industry, were
teqminated, retrenched or discharged from the industry, and
also forcibly given cheques by the Management of the
petitioner's industry. The l"t respondent will conduct the trial,
and it will be determined whether the so called VR Scheme is
valid under the law.
(c)
The petitioner company has not produced any
materia-l or audit reports to show that the company is running
in loss as on the date of introducing the VRS. The petitioner's
l8
company has various branches all over India, e'r :n though the
respondents were never offered any tra-nr; er to other
branches, rrghich is against the provisions of he Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 , as well as against 1l e catena of
judgments of the Apex Court. Moreover, the I ister concern
industry of the petitioner 1S continuing th,: business at
Madras,
even
though the petitioner comp z ny had not
transferred the respondents, as is mandatory r- I Lder Sec.25-H
of the ID Act, 1947.
(d)
This court is not the appropriate f r um to decide
whether the petitioner company had be: -r closed in
accordance with law or not. The same would te decided by
the l"t respondent herein, after considering 1l e substantial
evidence
(e)
As the petitioner's company is n-r rning well, it
requested the State Government of erstwhiie AI dhra Pradesh
in the year 2OO8 to allot the land to an exten: of Ac. 100.0O
guntas for the expansion of the organ tzation. ' 'he same was
considered by the State Government of ers 1 n'hile Andhra
(
lJ
t9
a)
Pradesh and allotted the land to an extent of Ac.60.00 guntas
at Muppireddypally, Toofran Mandal, Medak District. While it
was running well and turning a profit day to day, in August,
2014, th,e management posted a notice on the factory's notice
board stating that the lactory would be forcibly shut down
because it was running at a loss. On the pretext that the
factory would not run in future, the Management had decided
to retrench 200 employees and also announced that if the
employees did not make an application voluntarily to retire
from service before the concerned authorities of the
petitioner's Organisation, the management would close the
factory without paying any remuneration to the employees.
Subsequently, one of the personnel managers by the name
Sri.Surya Narayana Reddy and one Executive Director
Mr.Edward, called the respondents herein to their office one
by one and warned them that if they opt for VRS, only the
cornpany will survive.
(f)
The petitioner's Marl2gement used to harass the
respondents by stating as follows:
a) if ue haue come late bg a feu ininutes to dutg, toe haue
not been prouided a leaue card.
l
/
l
I
b) Although we lutue not committed ang misttt:e on dutg,
u.te haue been transferred to an unktttltt 1 or neu)
de p artme nt freque ntly.
c) We lnue been placed in a high manpower equirement
orea bg ftxing less ffLanpou)er and th-ereby inc 'easing the
u,tork load upon us, if ue failed to do so ant thing, th.eg
u.tould receiue nothing.
(g) The respondents are eking out tl.r,: r livelihood by
working in the petitioner's organization. The lr spondents are
deprived of their means of livelihood, and henr( their lives are
kept in the utmost miserable condition. WherL the employees
exceed 100 in number, working in an est rblishment or
industry Iike the petitioner's prior permis,r ion must be
obtained from the concerned authority to ; rut down the
company.
(h) The Petitioner has given publica: cn in Eenadu
on 19.08.2015 stating that the organisation ol the petitioner,
in order to survive and grow, and also in reconr truction of the
organization, terminated the respondents from service
through CRS (Compulsory Retirement Service). The Petitioner
ZI
did not initiate conciliation meetings between the parties in
accordance with Section 12 of the Industrial Disputes Act,
1947, to resolve the problem, as mandated by the provisions
of the Industria,l Dispute Act, L947
(i)
A settlement of service in an establishment
should be voluntar5r but should not be coercive, and the same
has been contemplated in the provisions of the Industrial
Dispute Act, 1947 , but the organisation of the petitioner has
not followed the same and forcibly retrenched the employees
for closing the establishment, which is illegal in the eyes of
the law. Hence, the writ petitions are devoid of merit and are
liable to be dismissed.
7.
Heard Sri. C.R Sridharan, learned senior counsel
representing Sri. G.V.S. Ganesh, learned counsel for the
petitioner, learned Government Pleader appearing for
respondent Nos. 1 and 185 in W.P.No.32875 of 2016 and
respondent Nos. 1 and 9O in W.P.No.45869 of 2016 and Sri
Chikkudu Prabhakar, learned counsel appearing for
l
respondent Nos.2 to 184 in W.P.No.32875 of 1O16. Perused
the material available on record.
8.
Initially, after hearing the matters, on )- '/ .09.2016, this
Court granted an interim stay of all further pr,) )eedings before
the 1"t respondent in W.P.No.32875 of 2076
FINDINGS OF THIS COURT :-
9.
The petitioner filed the present ,r,rit petitions
questioning the Iiling of the I.D.Nos.3O and 3() of 2016 before
the 1"t respondent by the unofhcial respor dents on two
grounds, viz., maintainability of the said .Ds. and the
jurisdiction ol the l"t respondent in proceedinl further in the
IDs. It is an undisputed fact that, after filirLl , the IDs, and
receiving the notice, the petitioner, without :ontesting the
matter before the 1"t respondent, straightavr Ly approached
this Court with the above said grounds.
10. A perusal of the proceeding sheet dat :d 27 .O9.2016
goes to show that this Court, after considering he submission
of the learned Senior Counsel appearing for tl-r: petitioner that
respondent Nos.2 to 184 retired from service accepting the
o
VRS and received all the benehts under the Scheme only on
the ground of VRS, this Court $anted an interim stay of all
further proceedings.
I 1.
This Court has gone through the averments in ID
No.3O of 2O 16 filed by the respondents herein. The averments
stated in the said ID are as follows :'The respondents herein questioning the oction of the
petitioner herein in closirLg the Industry in aduertisement
issued on 19.08.2015 utithout prior permission of the State
Gouentment as illegol and unconstitutional and against
the prouisions of the ID Act, 1947. The respond.ents herein
also stated that the petitioner's Compang is ntnning utell
and it also requested tLrc State Gouemment of . erstuh e
AndLwa Pradesh in the year 20OB to allot tlrc land to an
extent of Ac.1)O.OO gts. for ertension of the Organization
' and the some u)as considered by the State Gouernm.ent of
erstuhile Andhra Pradesh and allotted. tLrc land. to. an
erteft of Ac.6O-O0 gts., at Muppiredd.ypallg, Toofran
Manda| Medak District. While the Company is ntnning
utell and getting profits, in the month of August, 2O14, the
Manogement hos displaged on the notice board_ that the
factory wa.s going to be forciblg closed because the factory
u.tas running in loss. Hence, the factory utould not run in
future. In tluTt contexl, the Management had decided to
retrench 2O0 emplogees and also announced_ tlnt if the
employees u-tould not make application uoluntarily to retire
J
()
from seruice before the authorities of the oetitioner's
organizotion, the manogemerut uLill close t Le Factory
utithout paying onA remuneration to the emplotl :es.
The Personnel Manager of the Monaq tment has
threatened the respondents herein bg calling t em one by
one into the room and moking them he.ld up 'r that room
and the personal mdnager bg name SuqT t Narayana
Reddg and Mr.Edutard, tuho was Executiue Lrt ector Luere
used to u.tam them in such a tuay to "get au.t g from the
companA", "Company is in loss", if all of the r spondents
tuould resign uoluntailA from the compang tll, n only tLe
companA uill suruiue and uould run and tlle emplogees
uere threatened by th-e local police."
12. The above mentioned facts are dispute<l facts. Hence,
the same would require a full-fledged tri:1 bv the 1"t
respondent. The petitioner, without proceedine further in the
matter, simply approached this Court, after- receiving the
notice, ard obtained an interim stay () all further
proceedings, which cannot be entertained. To prove his
justifiable action, the petitioner did not file -he necessary
documents and oniy hled'documents relating tc the voluntary
retirement scheme and the letters of the resp<> rdents herein.
Moreover, the petitioner did not frle the docu r ent regarding
pubiication of the Advertisement dated 19.08.11 )15
I
I
n
13. This Court is of the considered view that the petitioner
can oppose the IDs before the 1"t respondent itself, if its
action is genuine. If the petitioner had followed due process of
1aw and obtained VRS papers signed by the respondents
herein in a fair and law{ul manner, all rnatters would be
established either against the respondents herein or against
the petitioner herein before the 1"t respondent only.
14. In support of his contentions, learned counsel for the
petitioner relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in
J.K.COTTON SPI IMAIG AND WEAWNG MILLS COMPAI.IY
LIMITED Vs. STATE OF U.P. AND OTHERS,T, relating to
whether the Labour Court has jurisdiction under Section 2-A
of the ID Act, especially when the pleadings disclose that
respondent Nos.2 to 184 received the benehts under the
Scheme and seized to be employees/workmen.
15.
In the above case, at para No.8, it is held as follows :-
"... the employee's reqtest contained in the letter of
resignation uas accepted bg 'the emploger and that
brought an end to the contract of seruice. Tle meaning of
I ( 1990) 4
Supreme Court Cases 27)
I
C)
term 'resign' as found in the Shorter Oxforu Dictionary
includes 'retirement'. Therefore, when c r emplogee
uoluntailg tenders his resignation it is an ctc:t t g u,hich he
uoluntailA giues up his job. We are, ther,z bre, of the
opinion thot such a situotion uould be cot < "ed by the
expression 'uoluntary retirement' utithin the neaning of
clause (i) of Section 2 (s) of the State Act.,'
16. In the above mentioned case law, the p(l itioner himself
wrote a letter to the authorities seeking esignation on
r
personal reasons due to family non-co-operati In to continue
the job. But in the case at hand, there are ro resignation
letters to the authorities on personal grounds, i nd there is no
non-co operation of the family members, and rnly based on
the advertisement ald on the forcefulness of th : petitioner by
deploying police, the respondents herein accep.,( d the VRS.
.
Whether the respondents themselves ar: :epted VRS or
were under any threat or force, there is no clal ity in the writ
petitions. The said facts would be establishecl r nly before the
1"t respondent. Hence, the above case is not al) rlicable to the
case at hand.
o
18. In the present case, this Court, on 27.O9.2O 16, after
recording the submissions of the learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the petitioner, granted an interim stay of all
further proceedings
19. Whether the VRS is legal or not, or due to the
threatened action of the petitioner, would be known only after
a full-fledged trial. Therefore, the contention of the petitioner
that after receiving the VRS benehts, the respondents cannot
file IDs before the 1"t respondent calnot be accepted
20. With regard to \,vorkman', learned counsel appearing
for the petitioner relied upon the judgment of Kerala High
Court in EVERE,STEE Vs. DISTRICT LABOT R OFFICER2,
lr,herein it is held as follo'*,s :-
"9. In order to appreciate the iual contentions, it
is beneficial to extract 5.2(s) of the Industiol Disputes
Act:
"(s) "Workman" meants anA person (including an
apprentice) employed in ang industry to do ang manual,
unskilled, skilled, technical, operational, clerical or
supenisory uork for hire or reutard, uhether the tenns of
employment be express or implied, and for tlrc purpose of
I L999
l3l LLN 678
2tt
anA proceeding under this Act in relation to c t industial
dispute, includes ang such person uhr, has been
dismissed, discharged or retrenched in conne: ion uith, or
as a consequence of that dispute, or u)ho:;t dismissal,
discharge or retrenchment has led to that dispt te."
21. As per para 9 of the above judgment, : re respondents
would come under the meaning of norkman. In the present
case. the respondents approached the 1.t resp( ndent, and the
case \ /as numbered, and notice was issued r r the petitioner
herein. The petitioner herein, without par1i, ipating in the
proceedings before the I", respondent and without
proving/disproving the allegations made by rl e respondents
before the 1.t respondent, straightway approac 1ed this court
C)n the ground that the respondents herein ao repted the VRS
and received the benefits, the petitioner obtai red arr interim
stay of all further proceedings. But the petiticr er is unable to
satisfy this Court, on the basis of the pleadir l s, whether the
respondents' allegations in their IDs are cor', ect. How the
respondents do not fall within the mealin i of the term
torkman'. Mere acceptance of the VR schemr: does not prove
that the respondents do not fall within the l realing of the
term \rorkman'. The petitioner has failed 1r establish the
(
.)
sarne.
In the said circumstances, the above case law would
not apply to the present case.
.
If the petitioner really wanted to prove its case, it
would have explained the genuineness of the VR scheme, but
r,r,ithout doing so, the petitioner only pleaded about the VR
scheme again and again
23. With regard to the VR scheme, learned counsel for the
petitioner relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in
K.KOilIARAIAH Vs. INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAI'-CUM-ADDITIO|'IAL
LABOUR COLIRT, IIYDERABAD AND ANOTHER3, wherein the
Apex Court at para No.27 held as follows :"The tlvee authorities relied on bg the learned counsel for
the management support tle uieut tlat o person uho has
uoluntarilg retired or d person u-tho has uoluntailg
accepted the compensation under Section 25-FF or a
person uho hos uoluntailg submitted resignation cannot
be said to be treated as retrenched entitling him for the
beneJit under section 25-H (2)."
24.
In the above mentioned case, the Government directed
the 2"a respondent to close down its manufacturing activity
r
2000 scc ontine AP 352
The 2"d respondent sought permission from 1t e Government
of Andhra Pradesh under Section 25-O of -he Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 , to close down the rr rit, as liquor
manufacturing cannot be carried on.
25.
[n the present case, the petitioner has r ot sougtrt any
prior permission from the Government beforr: closure of the
unit and as there rs no trarsfer of ownr:r s hip from one
employer to anothcr, Section 25 FF of the, ID Act is not
applicable to the case at hand. Hence, the at r ve case would
not support the petitioner's contention
26. With regard ro the VR Scheme, itz rned counsel
appearing for the petitioner relied upon the j _ lgrnent of the
Madras High Court in K.JAYAPAL Vs. Ul\trOiV, >F INDIA AND
O?IIERS4. [n the said case, the petitioner tendered his
resigrration, u.hich was duly accepted, and ir : received his
terminal benefits. After two years, he sought e-emplovment
I
on the ground that the resignation letter was tendered
without his conscious knowledge and that he .r as mentally ill
during the period in question.
o
zool 1+1t,.L.N.450
3l
27.
But, in the present case, the respondents herein took
VRS after the announcement of the VR scheme bv the
petitioner herein, only under the coercion and undue
influence ol the petitioner. After accepting the VR scheme,
the respondents herein approached the 1"t respondent within
one year. Moreover, there is no mental illness alleged by the
respondents herein while making an application for VRS
Hence, the above case would not apply to the case at hand.
28. With regard to the VR scheme, learned counsel for the
petitioner relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court
in A.K.BINDAL AND ANOTHE.R yS. UIIIOil OF INDU AttO
O?IIERSs. In the said case, the employer was a sick
Government company. In the present case, the petitioner's
company is neither a sick company nor a Govt. company, and
moreover, it is operating in other places. Hence, the said case
is also not helpful to the petitioner's case.
29. With regard to the .lurisdiction, learned counsel for the
petitioner relied upon the judgment of the Apex Court in
t
1ZOO3) S Supreme Court Cases l6l
GYANENDRA SAIIAY Vs. TATA IRON AND STlrrL CO. LTD.6'
wherein the Apex Court held as follows
14.
We haue also perused the memo of r opeaL and
other represertation made bq the appellant. 'ltr ap1'tellant
has made a uague allegatktn that he u.tas fo't':d to take
retirement. Neither has he made it specific no lt-ad qiuen
the name of ang ofJicer utho compelled hin '., tttrite the'
letter dated 01.O4.1995 or exercised undue u t excessiue
pressure to sign the letter of prematu ( / uoluntory
retirement. Though the Labour Couft hc.s t'L nte to the
conclusion that the appeLlant uas compelled tt' ;ubmit the
letter of resignatiort, the same is not suppt'trt 'd by any
acceptable euidence. It is settled lattt that su:')icion ond
doubt cannot take the place of euidence. No Jltt ting of fctct
can be giuen on mere doubt ctnd suspicion or '> the basrs
of baseless allegations. The appellant haui r written a
letter of uoluntary retirernertt and after houing t cepted the
retiral benefits uithout anA protest cannot nou' 'urn round
an-d soA that he was conpelled to ; tbmit his
The a1 oeal has
absolutely no merits and we, therefore, haue r t hesitation
premahtre/ uoluntary retirement.
fo riismiss the same and to affinn the order pc : sed by the
leanted Judges of the Diuision Bench of the Hig,l Court "
30. In the above mentioned case, the appt [1ant wrote in
his
own handwriting the
"2006 (5) scc 7s9
letter
;eeking his
a
volunta-ry/premature retirement and personally submitted the
sarrre to the authority concerned. Subsequently, the
appellant alleged that he was pressured and coerced to take
the retirement. Neither did he make it specific, nor did he give
the name of any officer who compelled him to write the letter
or exercised undue or excessive pressure to sign the letter
31.
But, ln the case at hand, while approaching the lst
respondent, the respondents herein specifically mentioned the
persons names who threatened them to accept the VR
scheme. The petitioner did not say anything about
threatening his own employees against the respondents. The
petitioner did not disclose any details regarding the
allegations made by the respondents. The same would come
out only after a full fledged trial. The petitioners, knowing all
these things well and without participating in the proceedings
before the Tribunal, succeeded in obtaining a stay of a-ll
further proceedings by approaching this Court. Hence, the
above case law a-lso supports the respondents' contentions.
J+
a)
32.
Learned counsel appearing for the respt rdents relied
upon the judgment of the Honble Apex Court i. . K.JAYARAM
AND OTHERS Vs. BA)\IGALORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITYT,
wherein the Apex Court held as lollows
" 10.
h i.s utell-settled that the jurisdiction exercts zd bg the
Higlt Court under Article 226 of the Constitutiort f India is
,
extraordinory, equitable and discretionary . td it is
imperatiue that the petitioner approaching the urit courl
must come utith cleon hands and put fonoar i all facts
before the court tuithout concealing or s I tpressing
onything. A litigant i.s bound to state all facts thich are
releuant to the litigation. If he uithholds sonr, uital or
releuant mateial in order to gain aduantoge ourr tlrc other
side then he uould be guilty of playing frautl tuith the
court as uell as uith the opposite parties u.thich annot be
;
countenanced-"
33.
In the above mentioned judgment, it is I eld that the
petitioner must approach the Court with clean I i nds and put
forward a1l the facts before the Court without rncealing or
<
suppressing anything. In the prbsent case, tlrc I etitioner did
not establish anything, whether it
acte<l
legally the
respondents or not, and, without participatir r ; in the ID
proceedings or proving its legality against the respondents
' 1ZOZZ1 lZ Supreme Court Cases 8 t5
herein, it straightaway approached this Court. In the said
circumstances, the contention of the respondents that the
petitioner should approach the court vr.ith clean hands is
sustained, and the above case supports the respondent's
contentron.
34. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents also
relied upon the judgment of the Hon"ble Apex Court in
UTTARANCHAL FOREST DEVELOPMENT CORPIV. AND
ANOTHER Vs. JABAR SLIVGII AND OTHERS8, wherein the Apex
Court held as follows :-
"46. On tLrc other hand, the respondents in ciuil appeals
arising out of special leaue petitions as detailed infra uho
approached the Tribunal and the High Court are entitled
for the relief of reinstatement, back utages and continuity
of seruice in uiew of our finding that the appellant
Corporation is an industrial establishment and that
proui-sions of Section 25-N of the Industial Disputes Act
are attracted.
48. For the foregoing reasons, ue hold that tle proui.sions
of Section 25-N of the Industial Disputes Act, 1947 are
attracted ond non-compliance uith the soid section mokes
retrenchment order illegal ond non est.
'1200712 Supreme Court Cases I l2
l^)
35. In the above case, without compliance ol iection 25-N,
the authorities approached the High Court. In rl e iight ol the
authorities' action, the Apex Court obsen., d that the
retrenchment order itself is illegal and non esl .
36.
Section 25-N of the Industria-l Disput:; Act, l94T
reads as follows
"Cond.itions precedent to retrenc\ nent o!
workmcn : (1) No utorkman employed in anq ndustial
establkhment to u-thich this Chapter applies, ttho has
been in continuous seruice for not less than one tt ar und"er
an employer shall be retrenched bg that emploge r until -
(a) tlte workman hos been giuen thn,t months'
notice in uriting indicating the reasons for ret r nchment
. and the peiod of notice has expired, or tlte u,c,rL, nan has
been paid in lieu of such notice, woges for the pe,, )d of the
notice; and
(b) tLE pior
perrnission of tLE a t ropiate
Gouernrnent or such authority as maA be speciJ t by that
Gouernment bg notificotion in the Offtciol Gaze e :as been
obtained on an application made in this behatf. "
37. In the present case, there is also no such
implementation of Section 25-N. Hence, the above case iaw
supports the respondent's contention.
38. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents also
relied upon the judgment of the Honble Apex Court in VASAW
EIVGIMERINC COLLEGE PARE]\|IIS ASSOCIA?ION Vs. S?A?E
OF TELAI,IGAI|IA AND O?I{ERSe, wherein the Apex Court held
as follows :"
18.
Judicial restraint in exercke of judicial reuiew
u.tas considered in the State (NCT of Delhi) u. Sanjeeu
(2OO5) 5 SCC 181) as follotus :-
"16....... One can conueniently classifg under three heads
tlte grounds on uhich administratiue action is subject to
control by judicial reuieu.t. The fi.rst ground is " illegalitg ",
the second 'inationalitg", and tLrc third "procedural
impropietg". These pinciples utere highlighted bg Lord
Diplock in Council of Ciuil Seruice [Jnions u. Miruister for the
Ciuil Seruicp (commonly known as CCSIJ case). If the
power has been exercised on a non-consideration or nonapplication of mind to releuant factors, tLrc exercise of
pouter uill be regarded as manifestly erroneous. If a
pouer ftihether legislatiue or admini.stratiue) is exercised
on tte basts of focts uhich do not eist and which are
'12019; 7 Srp."me Court Cases 172
patentlA erroneous, such exercise -of power uill stand
uitiated.
19. It needs no emphasis that complex execu.lit't decrsior.rs
in economic motters are necessarilg empiic ant based ort
expeimentation. Its ualidity cannot be tested o any igil
prtnciples or tle application of ang straitjach r ' forunulct.
The Court uthile adjudging the ualilitg of a 1 e,xealtiuc
decision in economic matters must grant o cen(.i t medsure
of freedom or plag in the joints to the exeantiu,z Not mere
erors, but onlg palpablg arbitrary decisions o,r te can be
interfered with in judiciol reuieu). The reconr lend.ation
made bA a statutory body consisting of doma t ( tpetls not
being to the satisfaction of the State Gouent r ent is arr
entirelA different matter uith which u.te u)ere no' :oncentecl
in the present di,sanssion. The Court should t t refore b<,
loath to interfere utith such recommendation or en expert
bodg, and accepted bg tlrc Gouernment, unless it suffers
from the uice of arbitrariness, irrationality, 1;t't rcrsitg or
uiolates ang prouisions of the laut under r., rich it i-s
constituted. The Court cannot sit as an appellatr: tutltoitg,
entering the arena of disputed facts and ftgur,z; to opine
uith regard to manner in uhich TAFRC ougt, to haue
proceeded uithout anA finding of ang uiolation t f tules or
procedure. If a statutory bodg has not exercised
juisdiction properlA the onlg option is to r<:, tand. the
matter for fresh consideration and not to usurp ,t e polUers
of tte authoitg."
39. In the above said case,-the observation of the Apex
Court with regard to judicial review is wherever iliegality,
irrationality and procedural impropriety takes place or if not
foilowed, such exercise of power u,ill stand vitiated. In the
present case, the petitioner had not participated in the
proceedings before the 1"t respondent for proving/ disproving
the illegality or irrationa_lity or procedural impropriety alleged
by the respondents and the szune \.\.,as a-lso not disclosed in
the present writ petitions. The action of the petitioner
company supports the contention of the respondents herein.
The Apex Court also observed that the Court cannot sit as
al appellate authority, entering the arena of disputed facts
and figlrres to opine with regard to manner in which TAFRC
ought to have proceeded without any Iinding of any violation
of rules or procedure. So, in the present case also, the
petitioner did not explain how the l st respondent acted
against its jurisdiction and the entire case is only disclosing
the VR Scheme. Therefore, the above judgment is supporting
the contention of the respondents.
40.
l,earned counsel appearing for the resl), ndents also
relied upon the judgment of the Honble Alr:x Court in
RAMJAS IIOUITIOATION AND OTHERS Vs. UMO]V CF INDIA AND
OTHE.RSI0, lr,hereitr the Apex Court held as follov s
"As regards the objection of the uiolation of the t nndatory
prouisions of Section 5-A of the Act in not a.\ trding art
opportunitA of personal heaing uhile dec r ing sucLt
objections, tue granted an opportunitA to I t ,learnecL
Additional Solicitor General to ploce mat. ial after
examining tlrc oiginal record. We gronted this t ryortunity
to the respond.ents on account of the reason tl t t the uit
petition had been dismissed bg the High Cott
-,
h Limine:
u.tithout issuing notice to tLrc respondents ontT tr, such the
respondents had not been giuen dnA opportunitt r rcfore the'
High CourT to place ang mateial to refute the t tlegations
made by the oppellants in this regard. The ldditionaL
Solicitor Generol duing the course of th.e hectr ng o-f the
matter placed on order of ttrc Land Acqui.sitiott Collector,
Delhi, dated Febntary 23, 1968 tlhich has beer. laken on
record and for the purposes of identificatiort
t-as been
marked as Annexure 'X'. A apy of the said Al rcxure'x'
u.tas aLso giuen to the learned counsel for tlw apy zllants. A
perusal of the aforesaid order dated March )2, 1968
clearly shotus that the Ramjas Foundation S,t ietA uas
represented through Shi Ratan Lal Gupta, Adu cate uho
u.tas giuen a personal heaing. From a perus tl of the
aforesaid document Annentre 'X' dated Februar,l 23, 1968
r0
I99l Supp (2) Supreme Court Cascs 20
\
4l
I
it is clear thqt ful opportunttg of Learing through coun sel
utas afforded to tLre Ramjas Foundation. It has been
furiher mentioned. in this order thnt tle Ramjas
Foundation Societg u)as also allowed to file fresh
objections if so desired, but Shn Ratan Lal Gupto, learned
Aduocote for the petitioner Society declined and stated that
there was nothing more to add in the preuious objection
petition. After binging the said document Annexure 'X' to
the notice of ttrc leanned counsel for th-e appellants, no
satisfactory explanation or arryment came fonuard on
behalf of the appellonts. The conduct of tle appellants in
raising the plea that no opportunity of personal heaing
tuos giuen to the appellants in respect of the objections
filed under Section 5-A of the Act lDos totally baseless and
factuallg inarrect and such conduct is reprehensible. It is
utell settled that a person inuoking ant equitable
extraorditary juisdiction of the Court under Article 226 of
tLe Constitution is required to come with clean hands ond
should not conceal the mateial facts. The objection
regarding not affording an opportunitA of personal heaing
in respect of objections filed under Section 5-A of the Act
u)as one of the main planks of the grounds raised in the
utrit petition as well as in the special leaue petition filed
before this Court and ougfu ue knou if such ground had
not been taken thi.s Court uould haue entertained this
appeal or not. Tte appellants haue taken the aduantage of
obtaining tLrc staA order al.so from this Court uhich is
continuing for the last 14 gears o.s tle special leaue
petition uas filed in 1978 itself."
41. In the above case 1aw, the observatio,t of the Apex
Court is that it is well settled that a perso -r invoking an
equitable extraordinar5r jurisdiction of the Court r.tncler Article
226 of the Constitution is required to come wirl clean halds
and should not conceal the material facts. I the present
case, the material facts were not disclosed exct ot for the VR
scheme. Therefore, the above case supports tht respondent's
contentlon
42.
Learned counsel appearing for the re,.,1 ondents also
relied upon the judgment of the Division Benc.r of this Court
iN IWOHAMMAD FAREED PASHA Vs. STATE Ct TEI.ANGAIiTA
AND OTHERST r, wherein the Division Bench of -_l is Court held
as.follows:'1O. The junsdiction of this Court under Articlc, 226 of the
Constihttion of India is extraordinary, eqt i ctble and
discretionary. It is a fundamental pinciple of ru that a
person inuoking the juisdiction under Artick .,26 of the
Cortstitution of India must approach the Court uith clean
hands and should not conceal material facts. It t as further
been held that there is necessity to saue judi: tl process
for becoming abuse to subuert justice. 'IYl need to
approach the Court with clean Lnnds i.s a,l the more
" 202q e) x.o r46 (TS) (t)u)
necessary a.s lau i.s not a gome of ctess (see Ramja.s
Foundation u. Union of India, 1993 Supp. (2) SCC 20;
Rajkumar Sani u. State of U.P., (2007) 10 SCC 635;
K.D. Shanna u. Steel Authoitg of India Limited, (2008) 12
SCC 481; Manoharlal u. Ugrasen, (2010) 11 SCC 557;
Amarsingh u. (Inion of India, (2O11) 7 SCC 69 and Shri K.
Jagaram u. Bangalore Deuelopment Authoritg, 2021 SCC
Online SC 1194)."
43. In the above case law, the Division Bench of this Court
observed that a person invoking the jurisdiction under Article
226 of the Constitution of India must approach the Court
with clean halds and should not conceal material facts.
There is a need to protect the judicial process from abuse that
subvert justice. In the present case, the material facts were
not disclosed except for the VR scheme. The petitioner did
not establish the allegations made by the respondents herein.
The said case is in favour of the respondents.
44.
Learned counsel for the respondents also specifically
mentioned with regard to the workman under Section 2(s).
The meaning of the fuorkman' incorporated in the judgment
of the High Court of Kera-la in EVERESTEEs case (supra),
which is relied upon by the petitioner, is as follows :-.
4-*+i'
"An industial dispute, includes ang such pzson taho
has been dismissed, discharged or retrenched in c nnection
u-tith, or as a consequence of thot dispute, or uhase r ismissal,
dischorge or retrenchment has led to thot dispute."
45. Under the ID Act itseif, the respondents; herein come
under the meaning of Vorkman'. Though tr :re is a VR
scheme, the respondents disputed it.
The
luty of the
petitioner is to participate in the proceedings t efore the 1"t
respondent, and it must establish its legality be bre granting
VRS to the respondents. Without doing so, siml Iv after frling
the IDs, immediately approached this Court urr' ler the guise
of the VRS Scheme and obtained the interim orc[, r and stayed
all the proceedings in the IDs before the 1st resp l ident.
46. The petitioner raised an objection with :egard to the
exercise ofjurisdiction of the l"t respondent in tl : said IDs by
way of filing a writ of prohibition. With regarc to the same,
this Court relies upon the judgment of the Apex t )ourt in ISIIA
BEEW ON BEHALF OF THE MINOR TIMAIBE,\ BEEW AND
O?I{ERS Vs. TAX RECOVERY OFFICE,R AND AJIDL. P.A. TO
observed as follows :-
.. The eistence of an alternatiue remedy is not
generally o bar to the issuance of such o urit or order.
But, in order to substantiate a ight to obtain a urit of
prohibition from a High Court or from this Court, an
"...
applicant has to demonstrate total absence of juisdiction
to proceed on the part of the olficer or autlnity complained
against. It is not enough tf a wrong section or prouision of
latu is cited in o notice or order if tLe pouter to proceed is
actually thereunder another prouision."
47. As per the above observation of the Apex Court, once
any person approaches the writ court by way of a writ of
prohibition, he has to demonstrate the total absence of
jruisdiction of the Authority or the Tribunal to proceed
further. Without doing so, a writ of prohibition cannot be
maintained on the mere ground of respondents acc€pting the
VRS.
48.
Moreover, in the ID Act, 1947, tb.e Second Schedule
read with Section-7 indicates ttre matters within the
jurisdiction of the Labour Courts, in point No.6 all matters
'' ( 1976) I scc 70
other than those mentioned in the Third Schedr- [e. Schedule
Three read with Section 7-A discloses matl( r I w.ithin the
jurisdiction of the Industrial Tribunals,
anc'
point No. 11
discloses ar-ry other matter that may be pres < ribed by the
appropriate Govemment
49. As per the above Schedules of the I[) Act, the l"t
respondent has the power to exercise its jurisdi :tion in these
matters. Therefore, the petitioner can part i, ipate in the
proceedings belore the I't respondent and est iblish alt the
facts and prove its genuineness against the res1r, ndents
50.
Generally, the High Courts, after admir ri rg the matter
and after considerable pendency of the writ p: .ition, cannot
dismiss the writ petition on the ground that r n alternative
remedy was not availed. But, in the pres,r nt case, the
question is not about alternative remedy. Tl- t respondents
herein have a,lready approached the 1"r rer; rondent, and
proceedings have been initiated against the pe :itioner. The
petitioner can establish its genuineness withorr approaching
this Court before the l"t respondent itse f.
While
approaching this Court, the petitioner did not respond to the
respondents' contentions in the IDs.
51.
With the above submissions of the respondents in their
counter, the petitioner has failed to establish its genuineness
to approach this Court, except for the VR scheme. Hence, to
prove genuineness, the petitioner must contest the IDs; if not
satisfied with the Tribunal decisions, the petitioner may
approach the superior court
52.
In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered view that the writ petitions are devoid of merit and
are liable to be dismissed.
53.
Accordingly, the writ petitions are dismissed. The
petitioner is given liberty to prove its fairness, genuineness
and, legality against the allegations made by the respondents
before the 1"t respondent in the IDs. Consequently, the
interim stay granted by this court on 27.O9.2016 is vacated.
54.
As the matter pertains to the year 2O16, the Chairman-
cum-Presiding Officer, Additional Industrial Tribunal-cumAdditional Labour Court, Hyderabad, is directed to dispose of
the IDs, in accordance ',r,ith law,
f,
AS
early
TS
possible,
preferably within a period of six months frorr the date of
receipt of a copy of this order. No order as to cost j
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any shall stand
closed
SD/. ]. PONNA KRISHNA
REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
/<\S'STANT
\ \--\ ' a="r,oN oFFtcER ,/
One Fair CoPY to the Hon'ble Sri Justice Nam
(For His LordshiP's Kind Per
To,
pr Raieshwar Rao
va
a r)
lndustrial '- bunal-cum-Addl'
1. The Chairman-cum-Presiding Officer Addl'
M'L noao Nar r rallv Hvderabad -
&;Xi;'Vili;''
I abour Court. 1st Floor
50000'1 . (With records if any)
l"'sni-c V.S.cAN'ESH, Advocate loPucl
, 6;;cb
t
dd 6 sFii cHrxxuriu-p-nnenRxAR, Aovoss[s
A. 5;;
)PUC1
[OUT]
4. Two CCs to Gp rOn r-n-e6UR, iiUi, Cor.t to|. the Sta['
5. 11 LR.Copies
and Companv
6. +h"-1.i";-#'S;cretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law' J rstice
Affairs, New Delhi.
Court Buildings'
'The
Secretary, Advocates' Association Library' lligh
7.
Hyderabad.
8. Two CD CoPies.
BSK
W
of Tdlangana.
HIGH COURT
DATED:0910112026
'1.
O'1
o
a
iE S AT
(9
\j
COMMON ORDER
WP.No.32875 & 45869 ot 2016
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITIONS
WITHOUT COSTS
nb
()
I [N 1 \ls
I ) e l!\ rl; .r;
F,-
.L
-t"
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review