Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE GURPAL SINGH AHLUWALIA
ON THE 24th OF AUGUST, 2022
WRIT PETITION NO. 2775 OF 2014
Between:1.
HAR NARAYAN DWIVEDI S/O LATE SHRI
GAYA PRASAD DWIVEDI, AGE 75 YEARS,
R/O C-73, GOVINDPURI, THATIPUR,
GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
–
DELETED LRs OF HAR NARAYAN DWIVEDI -
(A) SMT. SUMAN DWIVEDI W/O LATE SHRI
HAR NARAYAN DWIVEDI, AGE 75
YEARS, OCCUPATION HOUSEWIFE, R/O
C-73, GOVINDPURI, GWALIOR (MADHYA
PRADESH)
(B) RAVI KUMAR DWIVEDI S/O LATE SHRI
HAR NARAYAN DWIVEDI, AGE 54
YEARS, OCCUPATION: GOVT. SERVICE
R/O 2/11, NEW 36, F-TYPE QUATER, MATA
MANDIR, NEAR ANJALI COMPLEX, T.T.
NAGAR, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
(C) SANTOSH DWIVEDI S/O LATE SHRI HAR
NARAYAN DWIVEDI, AGE 48 YEARS,
OCCUPATION : BUSINESS, R/O C-73
GOVINDPURI,
GWALIOR
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
(D) SMT. ARCHANA TRIPATHI W/O SHRI
PRAVEEN TRIPATHI, D/O LATE SHRI
HAR NARAYAN DWIVEDI, AGE 51
YEARS, OCCUPATION : GOVT. SERVICE,
R/O
GANGOL
PANDIT
BAADI
GAAZIAWALA
DEHRADUN
(UTTARAKHAND)
(E) SMT. VANDANA PANDEY W/O SHRI
VIVEK PANDEY, D/O LATE SHRI HAR
NARAYAN DWIVEDI, AGE 49 YEARS,
OCCUPATION : HOUSEWIFE, R/O 551,
USHA NAGAR, NEAR SHANI DEV
MANDIR, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
(F) SMT. RACHNA DUBEY W/O SHRI
ASHUTOSH DUBEY D/O LATE SHRI HAR
NARAYAN DWIVEDI, AGE 40 YEARS,
OCCUPATION : PRIVATE SERVICE, R/O
B-601, MARBEL CRISE, KHARADI, PUNE
2.
SMT. UMA MISHRA W/O LATE SHRI
KISHANLAL MISHRA
3.
RAJEEV MISHRA S/O
KISHANLAL MISHRA
LATE
SHRI
4.
SANJEEV MISHRA S/O
KISHANLAL MISHRA
LATE
SHRI
ALL R/O B-3, SUDAMA NAGAR, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
NO. 2 TO 4 THROUGH POWER OF
ATTORNEY
SHRI
HAR
NARAYAN
DWIVEDI S/O LATE SHRI GAYA PRASAD
DWIVEDI, AGE 75 YEARS, R/O C-73,
GOVINDPURI, THATIPUR, GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
….....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI A.V. BHARDWAJ - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
SMT. KULWANT KAUR SONDHI WD/O
LATE SHRI RAJENDRA SINGH SONDHI,
AGE 57 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE
(DELETED)
2.
KU.TRIVENI D/O LATE SHRI RAJENDRA
SINGH SONDHI, AGE 29 YEARS
3.
KU. JASLEEM SONDHI D/O LATE SHRI
RAJENDRA SINGH
ABOUT 26 YEARS,
SONDHI,
AGED
ALL R/O B-4, RAJENDRA PRASAD
COLONY, TANSEN ROAD, GWALIOR
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
RASHTRIYA ADARSH GRAH NIRMAN
SAHAKA4RI
SANSTHA
MARYADIT
KAMAL SINGH KA BAGH, LASHKAR,
GWALIOR THROUGH PRESIDENT SMT.
SATYAVATI TOMAR W/O SHRI DWARIKA
SINGH R/O KEDARPURI KOTHI FARM
HOUSE, JHANSI SHIVPURI LINK ROAD,
IN FRONT OF SANT AASHARAM BAPU,
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
PURUSHOTTAM S/O SHRI RAMCHARAN,
R/O
LOHIYA
BAZAR,
LASHKAR,
GWALIOR (MADHYA PRADESH)
….....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI ABHISHEK SINGH BHADORIYA – ADVOCATE FOR
RESPONDENTS NO. 2 AND 3)
(SHRI SIDDHARTH SHARMA – ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT
NO. 5)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------This petition coming on for hearing this day, the Court passed the
following:
ORDER
This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has
been filed against the order dated 22.04.2014 passed First Civil Judge,
Class-I, Gwalior in Case No.54-A/2013, by which the applications filed
by the respondents/plaintiffs under Order 1 Rule 10 of CPC and under
Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC have been allowed.
2.
It is submitted by the counsel for the petitioners that the
respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 have filed a suit for declaration of title and
permanent injunction. The said suit was decreed by judgment and decree
dated 08.04.2005 passed by 6th Civil Judge, Class-I, Gwalior in Civil
Suit No.27-A/1998. The said judgment and decree was put to challenge
by Kishanlal Mishra (petitioners No. 2 to 4 are the legal representatives
of Late Kishanlal Mishra). Regular Civil Appeal No. 31-A/2005 filed by
Late Kishanal Mishra was allowed by order dated 24.12.2005 and the
matter was remanded back. The order of remand was challenged by the
respondents No. 1 to 3 by filing M.A. No.178/2006 which was finally
disposed of by order dated 20.02.2009 with the following observations:It also appears that certain observations were made
by the Appellate Court. It is made clear that those
observations shall not come in the way of the Court
while deciding the case on the basis of the evidence in
accordance with law afresh.
In view of the aforesaid, the appeal is disposed of.
The parties who are represented through counsel are
directed to appear before the trial court on 26th of
March, 09. The trial court shall issue notice to unrepresented parties. No costs.
3.
It is submitted that thereafter respondents No. 1 to 3 filed an
application under Order 1 Rule 10 of CPC for impleading the petitioner
No. 1 as defendant. Another application under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC
was also filed alleging that petitioner No. 1 was the general power of
attorney holder on behalf of Harnarayan Dwivedi and had also appeared
as a witness for and on behalf of defendant Kishanlal Mishra. On
28.07.2013 at about 10:00 AM, when the power of attorney holder of the
plaintiff went to the spot, then he found that the petitioner No. 1 has
constructed a boundary wall and has also fixed gate and has parked his
two buses and one car and, accordingly, he has forcibly and in illegal
manner taken the possession of the property in dispute. Both the
applications were opposed by the petitioner No. 1. However, by the
impugned order, the applications have been allowed and the petitioner
No. 1 has been impleaded as an additional defendant and the application
filed under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC has also been allowed.
4.
Challenging the order passed by the Court below, it is submitted by
the counsel for the petitioners that from plain reading of application filed
under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC, it is clear that the petitioner No. 1 had not
acted in the capacity of power of attorney holder, but he is alleged to
have forcibly taken possession of the property in dispute in his individual
capacity, therefore, it is a fresh cause of action against a new defendant
and the suit cannot be clubbed and the application under Order 6 Rule 17
of CPC could not have been allowed by permitting the respondent No.
3/plaintiff to join a fresh cause of action as it would amount to misjoinder
of cause of action. It is submitted that multifarious cause of action and
misjoinder of parties would frustrate the suit and relied upon the
judgment passed by the coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of
Pahalwan Singh & Others v. Leela Bai & Others reported in 1999 (1)
JLJ 349 and Devesh Chandra Gupta Vs. Dina Nath reported in AIR
1992 Allahabad 115.
5.
Per contra, it is submitted by the counsel for the respondents No. 1
to 3 that the petitioner had not raised any objection with regard to
misjoinder of cause of action before the Trial Court. Even no such
ground has been mentioned in the writ petition and for the first time, it
has been raised during the course of arguments. It is submitted that in
petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, a plea which has
not been raised in the Court below cannot be permitted to be raised and
to buttress his contention, counsel for the respondents has relied upon the
judgment passed by the coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of
Secretary Krishi Upaj Mandi Samiti, Damoh Vs. Labour Court,
Sagar reported in 2004 (II) MPWN 26, Vindhya Chamber of
Commerce and Industries Vs. Presiding Officer reported in 1993 (II)
MPWN 163, Asha Lamba (Smt.) and others Vs. Board of Revenue
and others reported in 1999 RN 401.
6.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
7.
The application filed under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC has been made
on the basis of events, which according to the plaintiffs are subsequent to
the remand of the case. Although the counsel for the petitioner tried to
submit that the amendment application has been filed with malafide
intention to bypass and over come the findings recorded by the Appellate
Court with regard to the possession over the land in dispute, but fairly
conceded that while deciding the Miscellaneous Appeal No. 178/2006,
the High Court has already directed that any observation made by the
Appellate Court shall not come in the way of the Court while deciding
the case on the basis of evidence in accordance with law. Furthermore,
while deciding the application filed under Order 6 Rule 17 of CPC, this
Court cannot look into the correctness of the pleadings. The correctness
of the pleadings is to be adjudicated after recording of evidence. Since
the petitioner No. 1 has been impleaded as a defendant for the first time,
therefore, he will be entitled to file his written statement and issues will
also be framed.
8.
Under these circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the petitioner did not raise any objection with regard to misjoinder of
cause of action before the Trial Court as well as before this Court and
took this objection for the first time during the course of arguments and
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. This Court is merely
required to ascertain as to whether the Court below has acted within its
jurisdiction or not? It is accordingly held that the petitioner cannot be
permitted to raise an objection for the first time in a petition under Article
227 of the Constitution of India and that too during the course of
arguments.
9.
As no jurisdictional error could be pointed out by the counsel for
the petitioner, therefore, the order dated 22.04.2014 passed First Civil
Judge, Class-I, Gwalior in Case No.54-A/2013 is hereby affirmed.
10.
The petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
11.
Interim order dated 09.05.2014 is hereby vacated.
12.
Since the suit was filed in the year 1988 and is pending for the last
34 years, the Trial Court is directed to conclude the Trial within a period
of one year from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order.
13.
Counsel for the parties are directed to file copy of this order before
the Trial Court positively within a period of 15 days from today.
14.
Office is also directed to immediately send a copy of this order to
the Trial Court for necessary information and compliance.
(G.S. AHLUWALIA)
JUDGE
Abhi
ABHISHEK CHATURVEDI
Date: 2022.08.26 17:00:52
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review