Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3485 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY THE TWENTY FIFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO IHOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NO: 20643 OF 2015
Between:
G Naresh Reddy, S/o. G Ramakrishna Reddy, aged 44 years, Occ ; Business, R/o.
H No B 7-'171114, Plot No 37, I/lythrivanam Colony, Old Bowenpally, Secunderabad.
.....PETITIONER
AND
Greater Warangal l\,4unicipal Corporation, Rep. by its Commissioner, Warangal,
Warangal District.
.....RESPONDENT
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that ln the
circumstances stated in the affidavlt filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, order or direction more particularly in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus declaring the action of the respondenJ Corporation in issuing the
impugned Refusal Memo bearing Roc. No. Gl/1757 812015, dated 8.6.20.1 5, as
arbitrary, illegal and u n con stitutional and violative of Articles '14 and 300-A of the
Constitution of lndia and, consequently, direct the respondent Corporation to grant
building sanction permission by settrng aside the impugned memo.
I.A.NO:1 OF 2015 ( WPMP.NO:26587 OF 2015)
Petition Under Section 1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed rn support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct
the respondent Corporation to reconsider the petitioneis application for building
sanction permission by suspending the operation of the impugned Refusal Memo
l
I
I
bearing Roc.No G1/1757812015, dated 8.6,2015, issued ty the respondent
Corporation, pending disposal of the above writ petition.
l.A.NO:2 OF 20'ls (WPMP.NO:46244 O F 2015)
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the c r; rnstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition the High Court may tre pleased restrain
the respondent Corporation from rnterfering with the I )iitioner's peaceful
possession and enjoynrent of the subject property pending rr ;posal of the above
wflt petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI KOPAL SHARRAF
Counsel for the Respondents : SRI PASHAM MOHTTH (SC r^ ARANGAL
MUNTCTPAL CORP)
The Court made the following ORDER
/'l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRIIUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
VWTIT PETITION NO.20643 OF 2015
DATE:25.02.2026
I
l
Betwee n:
G.N;rresh Retlcty, S/o. Ramakrishna Rcddl',
r/o.H.No.8-7 771 / 11, PlolNo.37, \1r'thrivanam
Colonv, Old Bou'enpallr., Sec untlcra [.,ati.
Petitioner
and
Thc Grca tcr W;rrarrgal N{u niciptr I Corpola Lion.
rep.bv its Commissioner', \Varanl;al, lValangal Dist
Respondent
ORDER:
The instant writ pr.tition has been filed declaring the action of
the respondent-Corporation in issuing the impugned refusal of
building permission oirle Memo bcaring Roc.No.G1/17578/2015,
dated 08.06.2015,
AS
arbitrarv, illegal and u nconstitutional and
violative of Article,s 1.1 .rnd 300-4 of the Constitution of India an<1
consequently, direct the respondent to grant building sanction
permission by setting aside the impugned memo
2.
The brief facts of the case are that petitioner is the absolute
owner and possessor of land admeasuring 1056 square yards in
Sy.No.1066 situated at Balasamudram, Hanamkonda Village,
Warangal Diskict. The petitioner has purchased the said land aide
registered sale deed bearing document No.'L l()' ,/2015 dated
05.02.2015 from his vendor Mr. D.Siddaiah, who in t rrn purchased
the said land from the respondent-Corporatio Ir , i'ic registerecl
Document No.37/.1965 after paying the substantial ',al considcration
to tl-re respon<lent-Corporation. Initially, the origin;rl 'iot rn'hich n'as
allotted to Mr. D.Siddaiah on pavment of con-.i,1 'r'atron b1' the
Corporation was found to be allotted to anotlr I pcrsotl, thc
respondent-Corporation has executed a
R,r:i ii:z-rtion Deed
No.206/1966 dated 18.01.1966 allotting thc'strbjci:t l, tl trr lir:u of the
receipt of earlier consideration paicl by Mr. I).Sidtl. lrir. z\pparerrtll',
the respondent-Corporation itself has conveyed rl
said ptot by
executing the document in favour of Mr. I .Sicldaiah and
subsequently, the petitioner has purchased thc
1 ltrnd z,irlc tl-re
registered sale deed duly executed arrd registcrecl I,' \tr. D.Sitltlaiah
3. In the above said factual matrix, initiallv he respondentCorporation made a layout at Balasamudram, Har i rnkonda village,
Warangal District in the year 1963, and sold out \r,r r.)us plots in the
said layout to prospective buyers upon receiving r,i le consideration
One such plot is purchased by the vendor of thc retitioner herein,
and further, at the time of allotment itself, due tc nadvertence, the
said plot originally allottel to the allottee - Sri D.Si i laiah i.0., r,endor
a
of the petitioner was already allotted to some other person, as such,
the open space in the very sarne layout rvas allotted in place of earlier
plot and the respondent-Corporation executed a Ratification Deed in
the year 7966 to that extent duly' transierring the said open space to
I
the venclor of the petitioner
4.
Further, the pctitioncr so as to clcvclop the said properfy filed
an application dated 0,1.04.2015 seekiug permission for construction
of compound wall and RCC shed antl the respondent-Corporation
has rejected the saicl aprplication lirlc Refusal Memo bearing No.CA/
17578/2075, dated 08.06.2015 stating that in view of G.O.Ms.No.72,
Municipal Administration & Urban Development Department, dated
20.02.2002, the open spaces in the lavouts cannot be kansferred by
the Municipal authorities ancl, therefore, the huilding sanction was
refused as the petitioner cannot seck permissiorr in the open space of
the layout and assailing the same, the ir.rstant \4,rit petition is filed.
Heard Mr. Avinash Desai, Iearned Senior Counsel representing
Mr. Kopal Sharraf, learned counsel for petitioner and Mr. Pasham
Mohith, learned Standing Counsel for Warangal Municipal
Corporation for respondent, and having given earnest consideration
to their submissions, perused the material on record.
6.
Learned Scnior Counsel Mr. Avinash Desa for Petitioner
submitted that the said allotment of open sPace v,',I granted r'r'ayback in the year 1965 to one Mr. D.Sicldaiah t:idc rai! ' erecl salc' cleecl
document No.37/ 1965 and Ratification Dced docuru ' rt No.206/ I996
dated 18.01.1996 anci subsequently, Petitioner has 1-' 1 ; lrusctl the saitl
open spacc frorn Mr. D.Siddaiah. Further it is ontendccl that
admittedly the open space is not a park or place l.'t for any othcr
amenities. Ilven G.O.Ms.No.72, dated 20.02.2002 c,r I catne rt'ctrntly
much later after cxecution of sale deed in favt-'t r o[ petilionerFurther, it is stated that the purport of the said (, ( t , is to prohibit
construction in the open spaces, which are left for r t;'ks or for other
arnenities. It is contended that however, in the Presl rt case, thc'open
space which l-ras been allotted to the vendor oI t' ' pctitioucr w.ts
neither earmarked for park uor for any such otht'r rmenities .rttd in
such view of the matter, the said G.O.Ms.No.71l, .latt-d 20.02.2002
will not prohibit consLruction and is not applicablt' .tr the plot of the
petitioner. Conveyed by the respondent way-back rr the year 1966
7.
Further, the learned Senior Counsel has pla< t d reiiance on the
judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in Bangalorr: Medical Trust v.
B.S.Muddappa and othersl, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has
categorically held that if the open spaces reserved for public park
and playgrounds, if permission is sought, the permission cannot be
granted in such areas. I lowevc-r, if the said open space are llot
ti
earmarked in the lavout as pl.rygrouncls, parks or for any otl-rer
amenities, there is no prohibition. The l{on'ble Division Bench of tl.ris
Court in W.P.Nos.12538 of 1999 and 25738 of 1997, dated 04.10.2023
has also categorically held that permission cannot be granted in open
spaces, which are ean-narkec'l for parks anc{ such other amenities
only
8.
Learned Senior Counsel w,ould contend that as the open space,
which has been transferred in favour of the vendor of the petitioner,
is not earmarked for parks or for such other amenities, as such, the
impugned order in rejecting the buitding permission for conskuction
of compound wall and RCC shed is unwarranted and liabte to be set
aside by directing the responden t-Corporation to grant permission
forthwith by following due procedure of law.
9.
Per contra, learned Standing Counsel for the respondent-
Corporation would contend that though the open space has been
' lrssrla scc s+
sold by the respondent-Corporation way-back in tht .'ear 1963,but,
horvever, fairll, subrnitted that the subiect op{'r r space is trot
earmarked for parks and such other amenities. It is c-'rtended as it is
open spacc, the G.O.M.s.No.72, datec{ 20.0'.1 . \'.)2, prol'ribits
construction thereupon, thus, contended that the inr -' rgncd \le rno is
valicl and intcrfe-re'nce of this Court is unwarranted
.10. The only point which falls for consideration f . ' deterrlin.rtion
of the issue in thc lvrit pctition is, whether the ope'r, :l;rcc ri'gistcrecl
irr favour of the vendor of the petitioner is earmarl e cl for parks or
anv other amenitics, which would disentitle the pr-'' i iotrer to sratlt a
building permission
11. Evidently, ir.r the layout prepared in I ( ( I by the thcrr
l
Municipal Corporation, Warangal, open space rvl r:h was solcl in
I
I
I
fayour the petitioner's vendor is not earmarked i<, public parks or
i
anv such other amenities and admittedly, the sair'l operl spacc \^ras
I
solcl by the then Warangal Municipal Corpora: rn by receiving
I
i
l
substantial sale consideration from the vendor ol' t re petitioner ancl
I
subsequently the petitioner has purchased it by r registered saie
I
l
j
deed. In that view of the matter, G.O.Ms.No.72. clated 20.02.2002
prohibits construction in the open spaces earmark: I in the layout as
:t.
public parks and other amenities places only. Admittedly, as the
subject open space of thc petitioner is not coming under the Purview
of the said amenities or park, thus, the impugnc'd order rejecting the
building pen-nission for constructiolr oI compouncl wall along lr'ith
I
\
RCC shed is r.rot tenable and is liable tc be set asicle arrd the point
framed for consideration is answcred accordirrgly
72. ln that view of the matter, the impugncd proceeding
No.G1/17578/2015 datecl 08.06 2015 is hereby set aside and quaslied.
he rcspondent-Corporation IS hereby clirected to consider the
building permission of the petitioner iu accordar.rce with law. As it is
submitted that the procedure for obtaining permission for
construction of the building is governed by the relevant Building
Rules under 'Buildnow' or Online Format, the petitioner is at libcrty
to file application under the said rules and uploacl all the necessary
documents by submitting the appropriate application onlinc, and
upon payment of the requisite charges, the same shall be processed
forthwith by the respondent-Corporation as Per the procedure
established under law and grant Permission to the petitioner or any
subsequent valid purchaser, in accordance with law.
I
13. The Writ I']etition is accordingly allowed. 'l'here shall be no
ordel as to costs
Pending rniscellirneous pctitions if4ry shall sta; J closccl
SD/-C. DEEPIKA
ASSJ{ NT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
5E TION OFFICER
To
1. The Commisstoner, Greater Warangal Municipal Corpor? ton' Warangal,
Warangal District
2 one ca to SRI KOPAL SHARRAF, Advocate IOPUC] \llclPAL
3 One CC to SRI PASHAM MOHITH (SC WARANGAL tu CORP) Advocate [OPUC]
4 Two CD Copies
SA
BS
HIGH COURT
DATED:2510212026
rrE S
oo
t ,)
ORDER
WP.No.20643 of 2015
I
i
ALLOWING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
b
Aet
1,',Q TtllF
C)
\
t
S
9.Jet
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review