Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 10th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 29507 of 2022
BETWEEN:DISHA MAKHIJA W/O JAGDEEP SINGH SALUJA, AGED ABOUT 31
YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE, R/O 533 NX VISHNUPURI, DISTRICT
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI DILIP KSHIRSAGAR, ADVOCATE.)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH DEPARTMENT OF GENERAL
1. ADMINISTRATION THROUGH PRINCIPAL SECRETARY MANTRALAYA
VALLABH BHAWAN, DISTRICT BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
THE M.P. PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION THROUGH SECRETARY
2. RESIDENCY AREA INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI TARUN KUSHWAH, GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE.
SHRI VINDHYAVASHINI
CAVEATOR.)
PRASAD
KHARE,
ADVOCATE
FOR
THE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This petition coming on for orders this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
The petitioner has filed the present petition seeking
revaluation of the OMR answer sheet and permission to participate in
the interview for the post of Assistant Manager in the Public Health and
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
15:26:19
-2-
Family Welfare Examination, 2021.
The facts of the case in short are as under:
02.
The petitioner completed the degree of Masters in
Administration with specialization in Hospital Administration. She
belongs to the Economical Weaker Section (EWS) category.
03.
The respondent No.2 / Madhya Pradesh Public Service
Commission (for brevity “MPPSC”) issued an advertisement dated
07.07.2021 inviting applications for filling 63 posts of Assistant
Manager out of which 6 posts are reserved for EWS category
candidates. The petitioner submitted an application to participate in the
selection process. The selection is based upon an objective type written
examination and interview. Minimum 40% marks are required for the
candidates of the general category and 30% minimum marks are
required for reserved category candidates to participate in the further
process of selection i.e. interview.
04.
The written examination is divided into two parts i.e. Part-A
contains 50 questions with 3 marks per question on the subject of
General Knowledge and Computer Knowledge and Part-B 100
questions with 3 marks each relating to subject knowledge in respect of
Hospital and Public Health Management, in total 450 marks. The
candidate is required to obtain 40 – 40 passing marks in both parts to
qualify for the interview. The petitioner appeared in the Part-A & Part-B
Examination with Roll No.100414. Four sets of question papers were
prepared i.e. Set-A, B, C & D, out of which the petitioner was given SetB. The instructions to fill the OMR sheet were printed over the leaf of
the OMR Sheet as well as on the admit card.
05.
After the examination, the M.P. Public Service Commission
published a model answers key of all four sets. Thereafter, the result was
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
15:26:19
-3-
declared that the petitioner could not secure the passing marks,
therefore, she filed this present petition before this Court on the ground
that she attempted questions correctly to secure more than 30 marks in
Part-A and Part-B of the examination. she has checked correct answers
from the model answers which comes to more than 30% hence, the
respondents have not properly valued her OMR sheet.
06.
The respondent PSC filed the reply that after the written
examination conducted on 06.03.2022, a notice dated 06.03.2022 was
published with the provisional answer keys on the website calling
objections from the candidates within 7 days. In pursuant to which 41
candidates submitted objections about 21 questions thereafter, the
Committee of the subject experts was constituted which suggested
deletion of 2 questions and amendment of the answer of 3 questions.
Thereafter, the final model answer key was published on 20.03.2022 and
no representations were received. The final result was published on
13.10.2022 in which the petitioner‟s name was not there as she failed to
secure 30 marks under the EWS category.
07.
Thereafter the petitioner amended the writ petition that she
submitted an objection for 3 questions No.28, 45 & 46 of Section-A for
Set-B. According to the petitioner, the answer to question No.28 of SetB i.e. World Wide Web (WWW) started in which year? The correct
answer is 1991 but the respondent in the model answer key declared the
correct answer is 1989. The amendment application was allowed.
Thereafter, the respondent MPPSC filed the additional reply by
submitting that the petitioner obtained 27.77 marks whereas 37 marks
were required to participate in the interview. She secured 40 marks in
Part-A out of 144 marks and 137 marks in Part B out of 330 marks
which is less than 30%. The petitioner has wrongly added the marks of
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
15:26:19
-4-
questions No.41 & 50 which cannot be considered as she did not
properly fill the circle (Gola) as per relevant clause No.7 of the
instruction.
08.
Vide order dated 03.03.2023, the petitioner was permitted to
appear in the interview thereafter, vide order dated 21.12.2023, this
Court directed respondent No.2 to produce the original OMR sheet on
the next date of hearing in order to resolve the controversy between the
parties.
09.
Today, Shri V.P. Khare, learned counsel for the MPPSC has
produced the original OMR sheet of the petitioner, it is apparent from
the OMR sheet that the petitioner attempted question No.41 of part-A by
filling circle „A‟ and erased the same by way of sharp object and
thereafter, darken the circle „C‟. Likewise, she filled circle „D‟ of
question No.50 and thereafter erased the same and thereafter, darkened
the correct answer „C‟. Shri Khare submits that PSC already printed the
instructions overleaf of the OMR sheet for darkening the correct circle.
It is further submitted by the learned counsel that the candidate was
required to darken the circle of the correct answer carefully then only it
will be valued. The candidate will be responsible for darkening correct
and wrong circles. Instruction No.7 also says that „darken only the circle
provided, the answer will not be accepted if candidate fills more than
one circle/dot(.) another circle‟.
10.
It is further submitted that not only the petitioner, but 79
candidates made the same mistake, and they were not awarded the
marks and declared disqualified. There are as many as 29 candidates
who secured more marks than the petitioner, but they have not cleared
the written examination. The OMR sheet is valued by the computer and
if more than one circle is tried to be filled then, the computer will not
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
15:26:19
-5-
read the circle of the said question.
11.
Learned counsel for the respondent MPPSC has relied on a
judgment passed by the Division Bench of this Court in the case of
Mayank
Dwivedi V/s The
Madhya
Pradesh
Public
Service
Commission and others in Writ Appeal No.1728 of 2023 decided on
25.10.2023 in which it is held that the final answer-keys are being
prepared by the body of experts. The same can neither be challenged nor
to be interfered with in a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India. He has also placed reliance on a judgment passed by this Court
in case of Somyata Sharma V/s Madhya Pradesh State Public Service
Commission in Writ Petition No.25284 of 2023 decided on 12.10.2023.
12.
Shri Dilip Kshirsagar, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the petitioner attempted question No.28 correctly but there
is a mistake in the answer sheet. It is submitted that question No.28 is
that the World Wide Web (WWW) started in which year? and its answer
was given in the model answer key “year 1989” whereas the WWW was
invented in the year 1989 by Tim Berners Lee, a British Scientist
working at CERN Company. In 1991, Tim Berners Lee released his
World Wide Web (WWW) software and in March 1991 the software
became available to colleagues using CERN computers, therefore, it was
actually started in the year 1991 not in the year 1989.
13.
The aforesaid contention is liable to be rejected as the body
of experts has taken a decision that the correct answer is 1989. Actually,
in the year 1989, Berners Lee invented and started using WWW for
himself, thereafter making available the same for public use in the year
1991 hence the WWW started working in the year 1989, therefore, the
answer of the petitioner is not incorrect. So far as the filling of OMR
sheet is concerned, it has been shown to the counsel for the petitioner
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
15:26:19
-6-
also which reflects that the petitioner first filled in the wrong answer to
questions No.41 and 50 and tried to erase it and then filled correct
answer by way of darkening the circle.
14.
11 Instructions are printed over the leaf of the OMR sheet
which is reproduced below:
15.
The rough work was not permitted to be done in the OMR
sheet, the candidates were instructed to use black ink ballpoint pen to fill
the answers, the examples for darkening the circle are also given and it
has been made clear that the answer will not be accepted if the candidate
filled more than one circle or put a dot or tried to fill incorrectly. Only
correctly filled circles will be read by the computer. Therefore, the
petitioner herself is responsible for not getting 6 marks for questions
No.41 & 50 and not only the petitioner, but as many as 79 candidates
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
15:26:19
-7-
who incorrectly filled the OMR sheets suffered disqualification.
16.
In view of the above, the Writ Petition is dismissed.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Divyansh
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 12-01-2024
15:26:19
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review