Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 02
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
HCP No. 35/2026
Reserved on: 01.10.2026
Pronounced on: 06 .10.2026
Uploaded on: 06.10.2026
Operative part or
full judgment: Full
Din Mohd Wani, Age 65 years
S/O Munnar Wani, through his Son
Shahraz Hussain Wani, Age 25 years,
R/O Shuryan Tehsil Doda District Doda
…..Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Through: Mr. N. D. Qazi, Advocate with
Mr. Amir Ajaz, Advocate
Vs
1. UT of J&K through
its Principal Secretary to Govt.,
Home Department,
Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
2. The Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir,
Through its Financial Commissioner
(ACS Home) to Govt. Civil Secretariat, Jammu.
….Respondent(s)
3. District Magistrate, Doda.
4. Senior Superintendent of Police, Doda.
5. Superintendent, District Jail, Udhampur.
Through: Mr. Adarsh Bhagat, GA
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M A CHOWDHARY, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
01.
Petitioner-Din Mohd Wani, S/O Munnar Wani, R/O Shuryan Tehsil
Doda, District Doda (hereinafter referred to as “the detenue”) through the
medium of this petition filed through his son, challenged the Detention Order
No. PSA/02 of 2026 dated 28.04.2026 (hereinafter referred to as “the impugned
order”), issued by respondent No. 3, District Magistrate, Doda (hereinafter
HCP No.35/2026
referred to as “the detaining authority”), whereby he has been placed under
preventive detention, in order to prevent him from acting, in any manner,
prejudicial to the maintenance of „public order‟.
02.
The petitioner has contended that the detaining authority has passed
the impugned order mechanically, without application of mind and in violation
of the constitution safeguards guaranteed under Articles 21 and 22 of the
Constitution of India; that there is no sufficient ground to connect the alleged
activities
of
alleged
„bovine smuggling‟, „illegal
transportation‟ and
„slaughtering of bovines‟ with the activity prejudicial to the maintenance of
„public order‟; that there is no live or proximate link between the alleged
activities and the detention order. The allegations, even if, taken at their face
value, relate purely to „law and order‟ issues and not „public order‟; that the
detaining authority has merely reproduced the police dossier verbatim, while
formulating the grounds of detention, thereby demonstrating complete nonapplication of mind and absence of independent subjective satisfaction; that the
DD entries relied upon by the respondents are vague, repetitive and stereotyped
in nature.
03.
Pursuant to the notice, the respondents filed counter affidavit through
respondent No. 3, wherein the respondents have denied the averments made by
the petitioner in the writ petition as factually incorrect and legally misconceived;
that the detention of the petitioner is not punitive; instead, it is purely preventive
detention on the basis of the dossier provided by the police, containing the
previous and present conduct of the detenue; that, keeping in view the
prejudicial activities of the detenue, the preventive detention has been ordered so
HCP No.35/2026
as to deter him from acting and/or indulging in those activities; that the
petitioner has raised disputed questions of facts which cannot be adjudicated
upon in a writ petition; that the detaining authority has observed all the
safeguards enshrined in Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India as well as the
provisions of the Jammu & Kashmir Public Safety Act, 1978, while directing his
detention; that the liberty of the detenue is subservient to the welfare, safety and
interest of society at large, as such, the detention order has been passed by the
detaining authority within the ambit of law. It has been further asserted that the
detenue was involved in cases of commission of several offences punishable
under Sections 299 and 223 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, and
Section 11 of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act (PCA), 1990, registered
at Police Station, Doda, and the detaining authority had drawn its satisfaction on
the basis of cogent, credible and incriminating material against the detenue to
prevent him from the activities prejudicial to the maintenance of „public order‟,
and finally, it was prayed that the petition be dismissed and the impugned order
be upheld
04.
Mr. N. D. Qazi, learned counsel for the petitioner, while making
reference to the grounds raised, has, inter alia, restricted his arguments and
argued that the detaining authority has shown involvement of the detenue in two
cases for the commission of offences punishable under the Bharatiya Nyaya
Sanhita (BNS), 2023, and the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, and on the
basis thereof, has drawn satisfaction to detain the detenue under preventive
detention, which cannot be done in view of various judgments passed by this
Court on the subject. In support of his submissions, he has relied upon the law
HCP No.35/2026
laid down by this Court in an earlier case, “Hamid Mohd. Vs. UT of J&K &
Ors.” (HCP No. 4/2024), in similar facts and circumstances, holding that the
involvement of a person in cases of bovine smuggling or cruelty to animals,
there being no instance of creating communal disharmony resulting in „public
disorder‟, preventive detention cannot be ordered in terms of the J&K Public
Safety Act. He has also taken the Court to the various other grounds enumerated
in the petition and argued extensively in support thereof. The learned counsel for
the petitioner further contended that the Daily Diary (DD) entries dated
25.02.2026, 27.02.2026 and 01.03.2026 are almost identical in nature and do not
disclose any fresh or independent incriminating material against the detenue. It
is, therefore, prayed that the impugned detention order be quashed and the
petition be allowed. Lastly, it is prayed that the writ petition be allowed and the
impugned detention order be quashed.
05.
Mr. Adarsh Bhagat, learned GA, ex adverso, argued that smuggling of
bovines and subjecting them to cruelty while transporting them without requisite
permission, is a sensitive issue, for the reason that such activities do hurt the
religious feelings of a particular community, where the cow is revered and
considered sacred. He further submits that, on religious feelings being hurt, there
is always an apprehension in the minds of law enforcement agencies that it can
result in communal disharmony and consequently lead to a „law and order‟
problem, which may erupt in breach of Public Order. It was finally argued that
the detenue, being a potential threat to the „public order‟, was rightly placed
under preventive detention, in view of his continuous involvement in such
HCP No.35/2026
activities. The learned counsel for the respondents also produced the detention
record to lend support to the stand taken in the counter-affidavit.
06.
Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the detention record and
considered the matter.
07.
The detention record, as produced, reveals that the detenue was
involved in following 02 cases registered at Police Station, Doda:1)
FIR No.0050/2026; U/Ss 223BNS, 11 PCA Act.
2)
FIR No. 0133/2025; U/S 299 BNS
Besides the above two FIRs, following DDR entries were also made against the
petitioner at P/P Gundana Tantna:
i) DD Extract No.13 dated 25.02.2026
ii) DD Extract No.15 dated 27.02.2026.
iii) DD Extract No. 13 dated 01.03.2026.
The involvement of the detenue in the aforementioned cases appears to have
weighed heavily with the detaining authority, while passing the impugned
detention order.
08.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, while seeking quashment of the
impugned order, reiterated various grounds but his main thrust during the course
of arguments was on the following grounds:
(I)
That the petitioner was not informed that he has a right to file a
representation before the detaining authority within the specified time
frame, seeking revocation of the detention order passed against the
petitioner.
(II) That the grounds of detention are a replica of the police dossier; and
(III) That the allegations relate purely to „law and order‟ issues and not to
„public order‟.
09.
HCP No.35/2026
So far as the DDR entries (supra), recorded within a short span of a week,
are concerned, it is an admitted case that those have not culminated in any
criminal cases. Merely recording DDRs alleging some acts, without specifying
any activity allegedly carried out, cannot be the ground to detain a person. It is
surprising that, if the acts mentioned in the DDR entries are criminal acts and
are cognizable in nature, then why the State has not filed any First Information
Report. Law provides that if a cognizable offence is committed and is brought to
the knowledge of any authority, a First Information Report should be lodged. If
at all those acts mentioned in the DDRs make out any criminal offence, what
prevented the State from filing a First Information Report is a mystery
10.
The second ground, as argued, is that the detenue was not informed about
his right to make a representation before the detaining authority within the
specified time frame, thereby violating his statutory and constitutional rights. It
is translucently clear from a perusal of the impugned detention order that the
Detaining Authority has not communicated to the detenue that he can make a
representation to the detaining authority against the impugned detention order
seeking its review and revocation, within a certain time period. The above fact
of conveying the time period for approaching the detaining authority has not
been communicated to the detenue, which is conspicuous on a bare reading of
the communication No. 519-19/DM/Doda dated 28.04.2026, issued by the
District Magistrate, Doda to the detenue, which shows that „you can also
represent before District Magistrate, Doda against your detention, if you so
desire‟
11.
HCP No.35/2026
In a case of National Security Act, titled “Jitendra Vs. Dist. Magistrate,
Barabanki & Ors.”, reported as 2004 Cri.L.J 2967, the Division Bench of
Hon‟ble Allahabad High Court, has held:“10. We make no bones in observing that a partial communication
of a right (in the grounds of detention) of the type in the
instant case, wherein the time limit for making a
representation is of essence and is not communicated in the
grounds of detention, would vitiate the right fundamental right
guaranteed to the detenue under Article 22(5) of the
Constitution of India, namely, of being communicated, as soon
as may be the grounds of detention.”
12.
Since the detenue‟s right to make a representation to the detaining
authority was only available to him till the approval of the detention order by the
Government, it follows as a logical imperative that the detaining authority
should have communicated to the detenue, at the first hand, that he has a right to
file a representation before the detaining authority as well, and secondly, the
time limit, within which detenue could make a representation to it, i.e., till the
approval of the detention order by the State Government. It is settled law that
once the Government passes an order approving the order of detention, the
Detaining Authority becomes functus officio and thereafter cannot review its
order. Therefore, the Detaining Authority had to inform the detenue about his
right at the very outset, so that the detenue could make a representation for
reconsideration by the Detaining Authority. There is, therefore, force in the
above argument of the detenue. On this count alone, the impugned detention
order being unsustainable and is liable to be quashed.
13.
HCP No.35/2026
The last ground, which has been urged by the learned counsel for the
detenue, is that the Detaining Authority, while formulating the grounds of
detention, has failed to apply its mind, inasmuch as the grounds of detention are
almost a photocopy of the police dossier. A perusal of the grounds of detention
and the police dossier reveals that the language and expressions used in both the
documents are almost similar to each other, with intermixing of words here and
there. This clearly shows that the Detaining Authority has acted in a mechanical
manner.
14.
The Supreme Court has, in the case of Jai Singh and others Vs. State of
Jammu and Kashmir, (1985) 1 Supreme Court Cases 561, clearly stated that
where the grounds of detention are a verbatim reproduction of the dossier
submitted by the police, it goes on to show that there is non-application of mind
on the part of the Detaining Authority. In Rajesh Vashdev Adnani Vs. State of
Maharashtra and others, (2005) 8 SCC 390, the Supreme Court again
reiterated that where the detention order is a verbatim reproduction of the police
dossier, the said order suffers from non-application of mind on the part of the
Detaining Authority.
15.
The next ground argued, referring to the judgment passed by a Coordinate
Bench of this Court while deciding a petition titled “Hamid Mohd. Vs. UT of
J&K & Ors.” (HCP No. 4/2024) on 06.08.2024, is that, on record, there is not
even a single incident referred to or reported that, by the alleged involvement of
the detenue in any one of the said FIRs registered for alleged bovine smuggling,
the so-called communal tension or disharmony took place on such and such
occasion, which led to the „law and order‟ enforcement agency suffering a
difficult time in bringing under control the disturbed „public order‟, so as to
HCP No.35/2026
showcase the detenue to be a threat to the maintenance of „public order‟.
Paragraphs Nos. 14, 15, 18 and 19 of the judgment (supra), are reproduced for
convenience as under:“14.In the grounds of detention, the very fact that in almost in all
the cases related to the FIRs registered against the petitioner, it
is the offences under section 188 Indian Penal Code read with
offence under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1969
which are involved and that is a pointer to the fact that the same
are not relatable in any manner to maintenance of public order.
On record there is not even a single incident referred or reported
that by alleged involvements of the petitioner in anyone of the
said FIRs, the so called communal tension or disharmony came
to take place on such and such occasion which led to the law and
order enforcement agency suffering a difficult time in bringing
under control the disturbed public order so as to showcase the
petitioner to be a threat to maintenance of public order.
15.The“Public Order” as a concept in distinction to “Law and
Order” has been considered by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of
India in a long line of cases. In the case of “K. K. Saravana Babu
vs. State of Tamil Nadu and another” (2008)9 SCC 89, the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India has recapitulated the case law
on the said aspect in which the Security of the State followed by
the Public Order and last by “Law and Order” has been set up
in an hierarchy. The “Public Order” has been read to be even
the tempo of the life of the community taking the country as a
whole or even a specified locality. Disturbance of Public Order
is meant to be distinguished from acts directing against
individuals which do not disturb the society to the extent of
causing a general disturbance of public tranquility.
16. xxxxxxx
17.xxxxxxx
HCP No.35/2026
18.”Maintenance of Public Order” as being one of the grounds
of subjecting a person to preventive detention is not to be easily
assumed to be readily available by a just reference to series of
FIRs reporting crimes against a particular individual which
would at the most render him to be branded as a habitual
offender for which the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 in itself
has conceived a preventive measure under section 110 which
enlists a number of categories for an Executive Magistrate to
take cognizance and bind a person so as to prevent him from
indulging in repeat of the alleged activities. What is meant to be
effectively cured and dealt with under section 110 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 cannot be diverted to be dealt with by
the application of preventive detention mode of J&K Public
Safety Act, 1978 by depriving a person of his personal liberty for
any given period of time. A preventive detention cannot be
restored to by the debunking ordinary criminal procedure and
trial of cases.
19.Sr. Superintendent of Police (SSP), Jammu in his dossier did
not serve the respondent No. 2-District Magistrate, Jammu with
full picture of facts with respect to the petitioner, which is born
out from the very fact that the state of trials of the FIRs starting
from FIR No. 194/2017 and ending with FIR No. 119/2023
relating to the petitioner was kept withheld from being known
and disclosed meaning thereby that state of trial of the cases was
of no interest be told and disclosed by the Sr. Superintendent of
Police (SSP), Jammu and consequently of no interest to be known
by the respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Jammu.”
16.
This Court again in a judgment titled as “Reham Ali Vs. UT of
J&K & Ors” (HCP No. 9/2026) decided on 13.05.2026 has followed the
dictum laid down in the case of “Hamid Mohd Vs. UT of J&K & Ors”
(supra).
17.
HCP No.35/2026
On a perusal of the grounds of detention, it is apparent that the
detenue has been accused of being involved in the commission of illegal
transportation of bovines and cruelty against animals, regarding which two
FIRs had been registered at Police Station, Doda, viz., FIR No. 0050/2026
under Sections 223 BNS, 11 PCA and FIR No. 0133/2026 under Section
299 BNS. The detenue has been ordered to be detained in preventive
custody, preventing him from indulging in activities prejudicial to the
maintenance of „public order‟.
18.
Both of the cases registered vide the aforestated FIRs were
regarding illegal transportation of bovines. A perusal of the grounds of
detention would show that the said FIRs do not specifically or categorically
insinuate that the detenue is involved in the illegal transportation of such
animals which are revered by a particular community.
19.
The detention order, however, is conspicuously silent with regard to
any development based on the cases relating to the maintenance of „public
order‟. Though the detaining authority has apprehended the „public order‟ based
on the FIRs (supra), however, the detaining authority has failed to record as to
what was the „law and order‟ problem, much less than that of „public order‟, in
the year 2025 or immediately after registration of the last FIR in the year 2026.
Communal disharmony erupts at the spur of the moment and cannot be expected
at a later stage. Since the registration of all the cases, which has been made the
basis for the passing of the detention order, has neither evoked communal
tension nor any problem of „law and order‟, which is even far away from „public
order‟, is shown to have erupted.
20.
HCP No.35/2026
This court, in view of the aforesaid opinion of the Coordinate Benches
and the discussion made hereinabove, has no reason to take a different view in
this regard and is persuaded to agree with the view expressed by the Coordinate
Benches in the aforesaid cases.
21.
The other grounds urged by the learned counsel for the petitioner need
not be deliberated upon by this court, in view of succeeding of the writ petition
on the grounds discussed in the preceding paragraphs.
22.
For the aforesaid reasons, the petition is allowed and impugned
Detention Order No. PSA /02 of 2026 dated 28.04.2026 issued by respondent
No.3, District Magistrate, Doda, is hereby quashed. The detenue- Din Mohd
Wani, S/O Munnar Wani, R/O Shuryan, Tehsil Doda, District Doda is directed
to be released forthwith, in case he is not required in any other case(s).
23.
The detention record produced by the counsel for the respondents be
returned to the respondents, through their counsel.
(
( M A Chowdhary )
Judge
Jammu
06.10.2026
Meenakshi
Raj Kumar
2026.10.06 14:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Whether the order is speaking?
:Yes/No
Whether the order is reportable?
:Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review