Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
ON THE 11th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 2121 of 2020
BETWEEN:DR. (SMT) SHIKHA TRIVEDI W/O SHRI SUNIL TRIVEDI,
AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE 403,
SECTOR 'B', SURYADEV NAGAR,INDORE (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
( SHRI L. C. PATNE-ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY GOVT. OF M.P. VALLABH BHAWAN
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
THE REGIONAL ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR OF
HIGHER EDUCATION HIGHER EDUCATION
DEPARTMENT INDORE DIVISION, MOTI TABELA,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
THROUGH
ITS
REGISTRAR DEVI AHILYA
VISWAVIDYALAYA INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
THE CHAIRMAN,
GOVERNING BODY DEVI
AHILYA ARTS AND COMMERCE COLLEGE
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
THE PRESIDENT, BOARD OF GOVERNORS
SANYOGITAGANJ
EDUCATION
SOCIETY 8/1,
USHAGANJ,
JAORA
COMPOUND,
INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SATISH CHANDRA BAGADIYA SENIOR ADVOCATE
ALONGWITH SHRI SHASHANK SHARMA,-ADVOCATE)
(BY SHRI RAVINDRA SINGH CHHABRA, SENIOR ADVOCATE
ALONGWITH AMAN ARORA)
( BY SHRI KUSHAL GOYAL- DEPUTY ADVOCATE GENERAL) .
(BY MS. VINITA PHAYE-ADVOCATE/R-1)
CONTEMPT PETITION CIVIL No. 664 of 2023
BETWEEN:DEVI AHILYA ARTS AND COMMERCE COLLEGE
THROUGH OFFICER IN CHARGE MR. ABHISHEK
KAUSHAL R/O 8/1 USHAGANJ NEAR JAORA COMPOUND
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI
SATISH CHANDRA BAGADIYA SENIOR
ALONGWITH SHRI SHASHANK SHARMA-ADVOCATE)
ADVOCATE
AND
1.
MR. AJAY VERMA S/O SHRI DALUMAL VERMA,
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SERVICE
REGISTRAR
DAVV
R/O
DEVI
AHILYA
VISHWAVIDHYALAYA R.N.T MARG INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
REGISTRAR DEVI AHILYA VISHWAVIDHYALAYA
R.N.T. MARG, INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI
RAVINDRA SINGH CHHABRA, SENIOR
ALONGWITH SHRI AMAN ARORA-ADVOCATE)
ADVOCATE
WRIT PETITION No. 16540 of 2023
BETWEEN:DEVI AHILYA ARTS AND COMMERCE COLLEGE
THROUGH OFFICER IN CHARGE MR. ABHISHEK
KAUSHAL R/O 8/1 USHAGANJ NEAR JAORA COMPUND
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI SATISH CHANDRA BAGADIYA, SENIOR ADVOCATE SHRI
SHASHANK SHARMA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER.)
AND
1.
DEVI
AHILYA
VISHWA
VIDHYALALAYA
REGISTRAR DEVIAHILYA VISHWA VIDHYALAYA
R.N.T MARG INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
EXECUTIVE COUNCIL DEVI AHILYA VIDHYALAYA
THROUGH
REGISTRAR DEVI
AHILYA
VISHWAVIDHYALAYA R.N.T. MARG, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
REGISTRAR
GENERAL
VISHWAVIDHYALAYA R.N.T.
(MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
SMT. SHIKHA TRIVEDI W/O SHRI SUNIL TRIVEDI
403, SECTOR-B, SURYADEV NAGAR, INDORE
(MADHYA PRADESH)
DEVI
MARG,
AHILYA
INDORE
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI
RAVINDRA SINGH CHHABRA, SENIOR
ALONGWITH AMAN ARORA-ADVOCATE)
(BY MS. VINITA PHAYE-ADVOCATE-R-1)
BY SHRI L. C. PATNE-ADVOCATE/R-4.)
ADVOCATE
T h is petition coming on for orders this day, t h e cou rt passed the
following:
ORDER
Petitioner has filed the Writ Petition No.2121/2020 seeking reinstatement,
back into services, payment of salary and subsistence allowances on account of
quashment of order of termination dated 01.02.2016.
2. Devi Ahilya Vishwavidhyal is a University established under the
Vishwavidhyal Adhiniyam (hereinafter shall be referred as '' DAVV'').
3. The petitioner was initially appointed vide order dated 22.07.1998 on
the post of Lecturer (Assistant Professor) in Commerce Subject after following
the due process prescribed under Statute No.28 of College Code by the
respondent No.4 and 5 for the period of one year probation. After completion
of 6 years of services, the petitioner was conferred with the benefit of senior
grade pay scale of Rs.10000-152000. While serving as Assistant Professor, the
petitioner acquired the M.Phil, thereafter Ph.D.decree in the Commerce Subject
in the year 2012 from Devi Ahilya Vishwavidhyal ( in short ''DAVV'').
4. The respondent No.4 issued an advertisement to fill the post of
Principal in which
four applications were received. Vide order dated
02.06.2010, the Administrator informed the DAVV in respect of selection
process and receipt of four applications. The Deputy Registrar, Administration,
DAVV constituted a selection committee headed by Dr. H.P.S. Chouhan for
recommending the suitable name of persons.
The committee conducted
interview under the Statute 28 of the College Code. Vide letter dated
03.08.2011, the Administrator informed the Registrar of DAVV that the
selection process has been completed and Dr. (Smt.) Shikha Trivedi i.e.
petitioner has been selected for the said post. The respondent No.4 issued an
appointment order and she gave joining on 06.08.2011. The appointment order
of the petitioner was placed before the Executive Council meeting held on
01.10.2011. The council decided to call the all the applications with biodata and
documents, accordingly, a letter dated 25.10.2011 was written to the President
of College for sending all the documents. Thereafter reminder dated 07.01.2012
was issued. According to the reply filed by the DAVV, the College did not send
any information and documents, therefore, the University did not approved the
appointment of Dr. (Smt.) Shikha Trivedi to the post of Principal as required
under Statute 28 of the College Code. According to the petitioner, she
continued to work as Principal of Devi Ahilya Arts and Commerce College,
Indore.
5. The Governing Body of respondent No.4 and 5 passed resolution to
take disciplinary action against the petitioner and vide order dated 26.05.2015,
she was placed under suspension in contemplation of the departmental
proceedings. Thereafter a charge-sheet dated 03.07.2015 was issued under Rule
14 of the Madhya Pradesh Civil Service (Classification, Control and Appeal)
Rules, 1966 leveling four allegations about the embezzlement of fund of the
College. The petitioner submitted detailed reply denying all the charges.
According to the petitioner, during the suspension period, she was not paid
subsistence allowance. The Enquiry Officer submitted enquiry report dated
16.12.2015 and thereafter vide order dated 01.02.2016, the petitioner was
punished of the dismissal from the services.
6. The petitioner approached before this Court by way of Writ Petition
No.1903/2016 (s) challenging the termination order inter alia on the ground that
she has been terminated in violation of principle of natural justice and provision
31(3) of the Statute 28 of the College Code. Vide order dated 04.09.2017, the
Writ Petition No.1903/2016(s) was allowed by remanding the matter back to the
respondents to follow the prescribed procedure as provided under Statute 28 of
the College Code. All other issues were left open.
7. Being aggrieved by the order, the respondent No.3 and 4 college
management preferred a Writ Appeal No.531/2017. The respondent No.3 and 4
specifically raised a ground that the appointment of the petitioner was made
without prior approval of the Executive Council of the DAVV, therefore, the
question of following the Statute 28 of the College Code does not arise. Vide
order dated 31.10.2017, the Writ Appeal No.531/2017 was dismissed affirming
the order of Writ Court in respect of direction to the follow prescribed
procedure as provided Statute 28 of the College Code. Thereafter the
respondent No.3 and 4 preferred an Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. (s)
18115/2018, which came to be dismissed vide order dated 27.07.2018. After the
aforesaid order, the petitioner was taken back into services but kept under
suspension and vide order dated 25.01.2018, requested DAVV to grant
approval for termination of the petitioner. In response to the aforesaid request,
vide letter dated 15.03.2023, the Registrar communicated the decision taken by
the committee that documents demanded by the University were not supplied
therefore no approval could be given at the relevant point of time in respect of
the appointment of the petitioner, hence, the approval from the Executive
Council of the University is not necessary in the matter of termination of the
petitioner.
8. Meanwhile, the Devi Ahilya Arts and Commerce College also filed a
Writ Petition No.4942/2022 seeking direction to DAVV to decide the pending
application dated 25.01.2018 regarding approval for dismissal of Dr. (Smt.)
Shikha Trivedi. The said Writ Petition was disposed of vide order dated
01.04.2022 by giving direction to the respondents/DAVV to pass speaking and
reasoned order.
9. The Devi Ahilya Arts and Commerce College filed Contempt Petition
No.664/2023. The Registrar has rejected the application vide order dated
15.03.2023 as stated in the above para 7. So far as Contempt Petition
No.664/2023 is concerned, same has become rendered infructuous
because the University has taken the decision on the pending application
which is under challenge in the Writ Petition No.4942/2022.
10. Now the Devi Ahilya Arts and Commerce College (respondent No.4)
filed a Writ Petition No.16540/2023 seeking quashment of communication dated
15.03.2023.
11. Shri Chhabra learned Senior Counsel for the DAVV submits that the
University is not required to take any decision in the matter of termination of Dr.
(Smt.) Shikha Trivedi because at the time of appointment no approval was
given by the council of University. If this is the sole stand of the DAVV in this
matter, then the University ought to have contested
on this issue in Writ
Petition No.1903/2016 (s) and Writ Appeal No.531/2017. In both the orders,
this Court had already taken view that in the matter of termination, the
procedure of Statute 28 of the College Code be followed. The both the orders
have attained the finality after dismissal of Special Leave of Appeal (C) No.(s)
18115/2018, therefore, now the DAVV cannot decline to follow the procedure
prescribed under Statute 28 of the College Code. The orders passed in Writ
Petition No.1903/2016 (s) and Writ Appeal No.531/2017 are having binding
effect on the DAVV because they were party in Writ Petition No.1903/2016 (s)
and Writ Appeal No.531/2017, thus the University is estopped from taking this
plea, hence, Writ Petition No.1654/2023 is allowed. The order dated
15.03.2023 is hereby quashed with direction to the University to follow
Statute 28 of the College Code and take a decision within two month
from today.
12. So far as Writ Petition No.2121/2020 is concerned, no direction can
be given to grant full salary to the petitioner as before termination, petitioner was
under suspension and Shri Bagadiya, learned Senior Counsel submits that the
petitioner has taken back into the services as suspended employee and college
is paying all the allowances admissible to her. The issue of payment of arrears,
allowances shall be considered after conclusion of the matter of termination.
13. In view of above,Writ Petition No.2121/2020 is disposed
of.Contempt Petition No.664/2023 is dismissed as rendered infructuous.
Writ Petition No.16540/2023 is allowed.
In the facts and circumstances there shall be no order as to costs.
Office is directed to place the photocopy of this order in all the
connected cases.
Certified copy as per rules.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Praveen
Date: 2024.01.17 15:33:12
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review