Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK AGARWAL
ON THE 11th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 11632 of 2020
BETWEEN:-
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
1.
DARVARI SINGH SAREYAM S/O LATE SHRI
LAKHAN SINGH SAREYAM, AGED ABOUT 42
YEAR S , OCCUPATION: SNCU SUPPORT STAFF
DISTRICT HOSPITAL, SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
AADHAR SINGH MARSEKOLE S/O MEHTAR
SINGH MARSEKOLE, AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: SNCU SUPPORT STAFF SNCU
SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT HOSPITAL SEONI
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
DEVENDRA SHRIVAS S/O SHRI GENDLAL
SHRIVAS, AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SNCU SUPPORT STAFF SNCU SUPPORT STAFF
DISTRICT HOSPITAL SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
SMT MANJU RAJAK W/O RAMDIN RAJAK, AGED
ABOUT 27 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SNCU SUPPORT
STAFF SNCU SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT HOSPITAL
SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
DINESH PARDHI S/O CHATURBHUJ PARDHI,
AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SNCU
SUPPORT STAFF SNCU SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT
HOSPITAL SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
RANI SARATHE D/O SHRI RAJKUMAR SARATHE,
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SNCU
SUPPORT STAFF SNCU SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT
HOSPITAL SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
7.
SMT LATA BHARDWAJ W/O RAKESH BHARDWAJ,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NRC
SUPPORT STAFF NRC SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT
HOSPITAL SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
8.
KUMARI RAJNI YADAV D/O RAJU YADAV, AGED
ABOUT 34 YEARS, OCCUPATION: NRC SUPPORT
STAFF NRC SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT HOSPITAL
SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
9.
KUMARI UPASANA BARVE D/O PRAHALAD SINGH
BARVE, AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
NRC SUPPORT STAFF NRC SUPPORT STAFF
DISTRICT HOSPITAL SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
10.
DILIP DAYARAMANI S/O LATE SHRI CHIMMAN
DAS, AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS, OCCUPATION: UPHC
SUPPORT STAFF UPHC SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT
HOSPITAL SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
11.
SMT MEHANTI MARSEKOLE W/O LATE SHRI
MANU PRASAD MARSEKOLE, AGED ABOUT 40
Y E A R S , OCCUPATION:
SUPPORT
STAFF
CARETAKER SUPPORT STAFF CARETAKER
NUTRITION
REHABILITATION
CENTER
GHANSORE
DISTRICT
SEONI
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
12.
KUMARI ALIN PARTE D/O SHRI NAHAR SINGH
PARTE, AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SUPPORT STAFF COOK SUPPORT STAFF COOK
NUTRITION REHABILITATION CENTER KEOLARI
DIST SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
13.
SMT SADHNA PANDRE W/O AJAY KUMAR, AGED
ABOUT 39 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SUPPORT STAFF
CARETAKER SUPPORT STAFF CARETAKER
NUTRITION REHABILITATION CENTER KEOLARI
DISTRICT SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
14.
KUMARI SAROJ UIKE D/O SHRI RAM SHARAN
UIKE, AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SUPPORT STAFF CARETAKER SUPPORT STAFF
CARETAKER
NUTRITION
REHABILITATION
CENTER KEOLARI DISTRICT SEONI (MADHYA
PRADESH)
15.
KUMARI KAUSHALYA D/O LATE SHRI VAINI
SINGH THAKUR, AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: SUPPORT STAFF CARETAKER
SUPPORT
STAFF CARETAKER
NUTRITION
REHABILITATION
CENTER
LAKHNADAUN
DISTRICT SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
16.
KUMARI MANISHA SHRIVASTAVA D/O DAYA
KUMAR SHRIVASTAVA, AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: SUPPORT STAFF COOK SUPPORT
STAFF COOK NUTRITION REHABILITATION
CENTER LAKHNADAUN DIST SEONI (MADHYA
PRADESH)
17.
RAMSHANKAR PADWAR S/O IMRAT LAL
PADWAR, AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
SNCU SUPPORT STAFF SNCU SUPPORT STAFF
DIST HOSPITAL SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
18.
DEEPMALA KAROSIYA W/O VISHAL KAROSIYA,
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS, OCCUPATION: SUPPORT
STAFF CARETAKER SUPPORT STAFF CARETAKER
NUTRITION
REHABILITATION
CENTER
LAKHNADAUN DISTRICT SEONI (MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI K.C. GHILDIYAL - SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI
HARISH CHANDRA SINGH - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC
HEALTH
AND
FAMILY WELFARE
VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
THE COMMISSIONER HEALTH SERVICE MADHYA
PRADESH HEALTH SERVICE MADHYA PRADESH
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION MADHYA PRADESH
THR ITS DIRECTOR 8 ARERA HILLS OLD JAIL
ROAD BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
THE DIRECTOR NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION
MADHYA PRADESH 8 ARERA HILLS OLD JAIL
ROAD BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
THE CHIEF MEDICAL AND HEALTH OFFICER
SEONI THE CHIEF MEDICAL AND HEALTH
OFFICER SEONI CHIEF MEDICAL AND HEALTH
OFFICER DISTRICT SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
ROGI KALYAN SAMITI SEONI THR ITS
SECRETARY ROGI KALYAN SAMITI DISTRICT
SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA - PANEL LAWYER FOR THE
RESPONDENTS-STATE AND SHRI SATYAM AGRAWAL - ADVOCATE FOR
THE RESPONDENT NO.3)
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
WRIT PETITION No. 24232 of 2019
BETWEEN:1.
GANPAT LAL AHIRWAR S/O SHRI BHAIYALAL,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, OCCUPATION: COOK
BADAPURA BEHIND DHARMASHALA BAJARIA,
DISTRICT DAMOH (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
SMT.VAISHALI SEN D/O DEEPNARAYAN SEN,
AGED
ABOUT
YEARS, OCCUPATION:
CARETAKER 280 MANGAJ WARD NO.3 MALAIYA
MILL ROAD TEEN GALI DAMOH KHAS, DISTRICT
DAMOH (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
HARVENDRA LADIYA S/O RAMSHANKAR LADIYA,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION: COOK 412
BAJARIYA WARD NO. 4 BADAPURA NEAR
ASHARAM
DUKANDAR, DISTRICT DAMOH
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI SHREYAS PANDIT - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THR.
SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH
AND FAMILY WELFARE VALLABH BHAWAN,
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
MISSION
DIRECTOR NATIONAL
M I S S I O N ARERA HILS, DISTRICT
(MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
CHIEF MEDICAL AND HEALTH OFFICER DAMOH
DISTRICT DAMOH (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
CIVIL SURGEON
CUM
CHIEF HOSPITAL
SUPERINTENDENT D A M O H DISTRICT DAMOH
(MADHYA PRADESH)
HEALTH
BHOPAL
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA - PANEL LAWYER FOR THE
RESPONDENTS-STATE AND SHRI SATYAM AGRAWAL - ADVOCATE FOR
THE RESPONDENT NO.2-NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION)
WRIT PETITION No. 17794 of 2020
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
BETWEEN:DASHRATH SHRIVASTAVA S/O LATE SHRI LAKHAN
SINGH
SAREYAM, AGED
ABOUT
42 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: SNCU SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT
HOSPITAL SEONI SNCU SUPPORT STAFF DISTRICT
HOSPITAL SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI K.C. GHILDIYAL - SENIOR ADVOCATE ASSISTED BY SHRI
HARISH CHANDRA SINGH - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THR. THE
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY DEPARTMENT OF
PUBLIC HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE
GOVT.OF MP VALLABH BHAWAN BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
THE
COMMISSIONER
HEALTH
SERVICES
DISTRICT BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
NATIONAL
HEALTH
MISSION THROUGH
DIRECTOR 8 ARERA HILLS OLD JAIL ROAD
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
THE DIRECTOR NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION MP
8 ARERA HILLS OLD JAIL ROAD BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
CHIEF MEDICAL AND HEALTH OFFICER SEONI
DISTT.SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
6.
ROGI KALYAN SAMITI THROUGH SECRETARY
DISTT.SEONI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA - PANEL LAWYER FOR THE
RESPONDENTS-STATE AND SHRI SATYAM AGRAWAL - ADVOCATE FOR
THE RESPONDENT NO.3-NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION)
WRIT PETITION No. 1295 of 2021
BETWEEN:1.
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
MUKESH AHIRWAR S/O SHRI MAGAN LAL
AHIRWAR, AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
CARETAKER R/O INDIRA GANDHI WARD NO. 14,
PATHARIYA, DISTRICT DAMOH (M.P.) (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
CHANDRAKUMAR AHIRWAR S/O PANCHAMLAL
AHIRWAR, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
CARETAKER R/O BADAPURA, BAJARIYA, NO. 14,
DISTRICT DAMOH (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
MUKESH AHIRWAR
S/O
GAJJU PRASAD
AHIRWAR, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
COOK R/O BAJARIYA NO. 5, CHAINPURA,
DISTRICT DAMOH (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
ASHOK RANI BANSAL S/O SHRI RAJKUMAR
BANSAL, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
AYYA R/O MELVARAR, VILLAGE PATHARIYA,
DISTRICT DAMOH (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI SHREYAS PANDIT - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF M.P. THR. SECRETARY BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
MISSION
DIRECTOR NATIONAL
HEALTH
MISSION BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER NATIONAL
HEALTH MISSION BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
CHIEF MEDICAL AND HEALTH OFFICER DAMOH
DAMOH (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
CHIEF BLOCK MEDICAL OFFICER COMMUNITY
HEALTH
CENTRE TENDUKHEDA, DISTRICT
DAMOH (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA - PANEL LAWYER FOR THE
RESPONDENTS-STATE AND SHRI SATYAM AGRAWAL - ADVOCATE FOR
THE RESPONDENT NO.2-NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION)
WRIT PETITION No. 1377 of 2021
BETWEEN:1.
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
SANGEETA
PATERIYA
W/O
MUNNALAL
PATERIYA, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
CARETAKER R/O HAZARI WARD, HATA, DISTRICT
DAMOH (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
CHANDRANARAYAN
LADIYA
S/O
SHRI
LATORILAL LADIYA, AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS,
OCCUPATION: COOK R/O SAGAR NAKA, DISTRICT
DAMOH (M.P.) (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
JEEVANLAL AHIRWAR S/O O SHRI BHADDILAL
AHIRWAR, AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
CARETAKER R/O VILLAGE GHANGAURKALA,
TEHSIL TENDUKHEDA, DISTRICT DAMOH (M.P.)
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI SHREYAS PANDIT - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE
STATE
OF M.P THR
SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND FAMILY
WELFARE, BHOPAL DISTT. (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
MISSION
DIRECTOR NATIONAL
HEALTH
MISSION BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER NATIONAL
HEALTH MISSION BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
CHIEF MEDICAL AND HEALTH OFFICER DAMOH
DAMOH (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
CHIEF BLOCK MEDICAL OFFICER COMMUNITY
HEALTH
CENTRE TENDUKHEDA, DISTRICT
DAMOH (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI VIJAY KUMAR SHUKLA - PANEL LAWYER FOR THE
RESPONDENTS-STATE AND SHRI SATYAM AGRAWAL - ADVOCATE FOR
THE RESPONDENT NO.2-NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION)
These petitions coming on for admission this day, the court passed the
following:
ORDER
This bunch of petitions is filed by various persons who were initially
engaged by the respondent-National Health Mission as part of their scheme on
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
various subsidiary jobs. Subsequently, respondents vide order dated
13.08.2019 and subsequent order dated 01.07.2020, decided to delegate the
services of the petitioners to Rogi Kalyan Samiti and, in turn, Rogi Kalyan
Samiti has decided to outsource the services through a contractor.
2.
Petitioners' grievance is two fold. One is in regard to change of the
employer and another is in regard to reduction of wages which were contracted
when petitioners were engaged by National Health Mission.
3.
Shri K.C. Ghildiyal, learned senior counsel submits that respondent -
Chief Medical and Health Officer has not complied with the earlier order of the
High Court dated 28.09.2020 passed by a coordinate Bench of this Court for
which another opportunity was granted on 12.09.2022.
No reply is filed by the respondents-State to point out that why
4.
compliance is not being made. Therefore, that issue will be dealt separately.
5.
Shri Satyam Agrawal, learned counsel for the respondent-National
Health Mission, in his turn, submits that there are two different issues. One is a
policy decision taken by the National Health Mission to delegate subsidiary
services which do not form the backbone of grant of health services per se in
the rural areas to Rogi Kalyan Samiti. Another issue is that once the services
have been delegated to Rogi Kalyan Samiti, then it is Rogi Kalyan Samiti which
is free to take a call and decide the terms and conditions of such contractual
employees.
6.
It is submitted that services of none of the contractual employees are
being dispensed with and, therefore, in the light of the decision of a coordinate
Bench of this High Court at Gwalior in case of Hariom and others Vs. State
of Madhya Pradesh (W.P. No.11482/2020 (S) decided on 20.08.2020) ,
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
petitioners are not entitled to any relief.
7.
After hearing learned counsel for the parties and going through the
record and also taking into consideration the judgment of Hon'ble Division
Bench of this High Court in case of The State of Madhya Pradesh Vs.
Puneet Mohan Khare (W.A. No.418/2017, decided on 05.02.2018), matter
is taken up for hearing.
8.
Two issues emerge for determination. Whether National Health Mission
is entitled to delegate its work to Rogi Kalyan Samiti and, in turn, Rogi Kalyan
Samiti is entitled to sub delegate it to a contractor to provide these ancillary
services. Another issue which emerges is whether petitioners are entitled to
protection of wages which were contracted with National Health Mission,
inasmuch as, they will still be doing the same work as was contracted with the
National Health Mission, despite change of principal employer to Rogi Kalyan
Samiti or upon further delegation of work to a labour contractor which may be
engaged by the Rogi Kalyan Samiti.
9.
As far as first issue is concerned, there is substance in the arguments put
forth by Shri Satyam Agrawal that with a view to concentrate on the core health
services, it has been decided to hive off the work of ancillary nature in favour of
Rogi Kalyan Samiti. That being discretion of National Health Mission, and a
policy decision taken by the National Health Mission, does not call for
interference in the hands of this Court.
10.
Coming to the next question which is the bone of contention of this
case. There is no iota of doubt that once for the same work, contract was
entered into between National Health Mission and a particular set of employees
either in individual or in a collective capacity and certain wages were decided
for doing the said work then during the currency of continuance of the said
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
work, wages cannot be adversely affected.
11.
A perusal of Annexure P-8 which is a communication dated 27.07.2017
made by the National Health Mission to the Director, AIIMS, Dean, Medical
Colleges, Chief Medical and Health Officers and Civil Surgeons-cum-Chief
Hospital Superintendent, Madhya Pradesh, it is evident that it is clearly
mentioned that Rogi Kalyan Samiti shall engage subsidiary services on full time
or part time basis as per the directions of the mission. The qualifications and
eligibility for such appointment shall be same as were prescribed earlier.
12.
Thus, it is evident that overall control of the National Health Mission
has not been delegated in favour of Rogi Kalyan Samiti or the contractor. It is
only an administrative arrangement whereby Rogi Kalyan Samiti has been given
task of managing subsidiary services so that National Health Mission may
concentrate on their core function of providing health services.
13.
Thus, in view of the said facts, which could not be disputed by Shri
Satyam Agrawal, there cannot be any reduction of wages on delegation of work
to Rogi Kalyan Samiti or sub delegation of work to a contractor and, therefore,
respondents have failed to make out a case for reduction of wages for doing the
same nature of work for the same duration in the hands of a delegatee or a sub
delegatee and, thus, the submission put forth by the respondents that they are
entitled to negotiate the wages again, is not made out. They may be in a position
to negotiate the wages through Rogi Kalyan Samiti or the contractor only for
those who were not engaged earlier by the National Health Mission i.e. a new set
of employees who may be engaged by Rogi Kalyan Samiti or the contractor.
But as far as those set of employees who were already engaged by the National
Health Mission is concerned, there cannot be any reduction of wages.
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
Therefore, second issue needs to be answered in favour of the petitioners and
accordingly, this bunch of petitions is disposed of with the following
directions:1.
Petitioners who were engaged by National Health Mission on a
certain set of wages for doing a particular set of work, during the
continuance of that set of work will be entitled to the same payment of
wages or the revised wages, as may be revised by the Collector from time
to time for such contractual employees, as was fixed by the National
Health Mission.
2.
As far as change of the employer is concerned, petitioners will not
raise any objection as long as their conditions of service for contract,
except for change of the employer, is not altered any further.
3.
As far as reduction in wages is concerned, that has since been held
to be illegal, petitioners who are engaged through National Health Mission,
will be entitled to get the same wages as were contracted by them with
National Health Mission and, if any deduction was made, then the residual
amount of deduction be paid to the petitioners within a period of 30 days
of receipt of certified copy of the order being passed today.
4.
Petitioners shall not raise any objection to the change of the
employer that being Rogi Kalyan Samiti or a contractor in terms of the
aforesaid discussion.
5.
As far as decision of a coordinate Bench of this High Court at
Gwalior in case of Hariom (supra) is concerned, issue therein was
different. There petitioners were claiming regularization and, therefore,
discussion was made having regard to the law laid down by Hon'ble
Supreme Court in case of State of Karnataka Vs. Uma Devi, (2006) 4
SCC 1. In the present case, petitioners are aware of the fact that they
being contractual employees are not entitled to any regularization and that
being not a prayer, which is specified by the learned counsels for the
petitioners who are appearing herein, facts of that case are different.
14.
Thus, in case of delegation of work in favour of a delegatee, the contract
wages cannot be reduced in an arbitrary and illegal manner. Accordingly, in
above terms, these writ petitions are allowed and disposed of.
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
(VIVEK AGARWAL)
JUDGE
pp
Signed by: PUSHPENDRA
PATEL
Signing time: 11-01-2024
19:06:16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review