The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. This Court does not find any reason to depart from the aforesaid analogy and keeping in consonance with the same while partly allowing the petition, the part of the order of the Commissioner whereby it had directed the CEO District Panchayat to proceed with the matter in accordance with the Rules of 2011 is hereby set aside keeping rest of the order intact.
17. With the aforesaid, the petition is partly allowed and disposed of. CC as per rules/directions. (Milind Ramesh Phadke) Judge chandni/CHANDNI 2024.01.06 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
ON THE 19th OF JUNE, 2023
WRIT PETITION No. 788 of 2012
BETWEEN:BRIJMOHAN SHARMA S/O R.D.SHARMA, AGED24
YEARS,
R/O
GRAM
PANCHAYAT
VIRDHANPURA BLOCK AND DISTRICT BHIND
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI SHIVENDRA SINGH RAGHUWANSHI- ADVOCATE)
AND
1. STATE OF M.P TH: PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
DEPTT. OF PANCHAYAT AND RURAL
DEVELOPMENT VALLABH BAHVAN, BHOPAL
(MADHYA PRADESH)
2. COMMISSIONER
CHAMBAL
DIVISION
MORENA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3. COLLECTOR,
DIST.
BHIND
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
4. GRAM PANCHAYAT VIRDHANPURA BLOCK &
DIST. BHIND, THR. ITS SECRETARY (MADHYA
PRADESH)
5. VIRENDRA KUMAR S/O SHRI MAHADEV
PRASAD
SHARMA
R/O
VILLAGE
VIRDHANPURA BLOCK & DISTRICT. BHIND
(MADHYA PRADESH)
6. BACCHU
LAL
EX-SARPANCH
GRAM
PANCHAYAT VIRDHANPURA, BLOCK & DIST.
BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
7. SHRIRAMNIWAS, EX-UP SURPANCH GRAM
PANCHAYAT VIRDHANPURA BLOCK & DIST.
BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
8. BENIRAM SAGAR SECRETARY GRAM
PANCHAYAT VIRDHANPURA BLOCK & DIST.
BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
9. SATYAJEET S/O SHRI HANSRAM SHAKYA
R/O VILLAGE GRAM VIRDHANPURA BLOCK
& DIST. BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
10. MUKESH S/O SHRI RAMSNEHI SHARMA R/O
VILLAGE GRAM VIRDHANPURA BLOCK &
DIST. BHIND (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI SOHIT MISHRA- GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE AND SHRI
ANIL KUMAR SHRIVASTAVA- ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------This petition coming on for hearing this day, Hon'ble Shri
Justice Milind Ramesh Phadke passed the following:
ORDER
1.
The present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India is directed against the order dated 04.10.2011 passed by
respondent no.2 in Revision No.25/2010-11, whereby the learned
Commissioner had directed for initiating proceedings for
appointment of Panchayat Karmi in view of the amended
provisions of M.P. Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam,
dated 29.03.2011 and the matter has been sent to Zila Panchayat
contrary to law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case
of P. Mahendra vs. State of Karnataka reported in AIR 1990
SC 405, in the matter of Sonia vs. Oriental Insurance Company
reported in 2007 vol.10 SCC 627 and in the matter of
Madanmohan Sharma and vs. State of Rajasthan reported in
2008 (3) SCC 724. The aforesaid order has been assailed on the
ground that once advertisement has been issued on the basis of
some circular prevailing at that particular time, the effect would
be that the selection process would continue on the basis of the
criteria which had been laid down there and cannot be on the
basis of the criteria which had been made subsequently. This
analogy which is culled down from the judgments of the Hon'ble
Apex Court reiterates that subsequent amendment of the rules
made during the pendency of the advertisement will have
prospective effect and cannot be made effective retrospectively
and also cannot be made the basis for the appointments.
2.
Brief facts leading to the controversy are that on
20.08.2007
Gram
Panchayat
Virdhanpura
had
issued
advertisement for filling up the vacant post of Panchyat Karmi
and in pursuance to the aforesaid advertisement, total 13
candidates applied and list of the aspirants were published and
affixed on the Board of the Panchayat on 03.09.2007. On
21.09.2007 the Gram Panchayat convened its meeting and on that
date issued the list of the eligible candidates and found 9
candidates out of 13, eligible for consideration of the said post. In
the meeting convened on 21.09.2007 as per the merit criteria the
candidature of the eligible candidates were considered and as per
rules and regulations the petitioner was found more meritorious in
comparison to other candidates and vide resolution of the same
date the petitioner was duly appointed on the said post.
Admittedly the meeting convened by the Gram Panchayat on
21.09.2007 was presided by Up-Sarpanch in absence of the
Sarpanch and after passing of the resolution the matter has been
sent by the Gram Panchayat to the Competent authority informing
it about the appointment of the petitioner and for notifying him as
Secretary of Gram Panchayat under the provisions of Section 69
(1) of the M.P. Panchayat Raj & Gram Swaraj Adhiniyam. During
the pendency of the aforesaid proceedings an appeal has been
preferred by the private respondent no.5 against the appointment
of the petitioner. Though as per M.P. Panchayat (Appeal and
Revision) Rules, 1999 against the resolution passed by the Gram
Panchayat an appeal is maintainable before the SDO, but the
same was heard by the Collector and since the very order passed
in appeal itself was nunest, the petition preferred against the said
order was also per se illegal and as both the orders are passed
without any jurisdiction, therefore, they are liable to be set aside.
The order passed by the Collector in the appeal preferred by the
private respondent no.5 was based upon the fact that there was
procedural mistake in the proceedings conducted by the Gram
Panchayat for appointment of Panchayat Karmi, therefore, the
matter was required to be considered afresh by the Gram
Panchayat on the applications which were received for
appointment on the post of Panchayat Karmi. The revisional order
passed by the Commissioner reflects that since the name of the
private respondent no.5 was not mentioned in the resolution nor
there was merit list of the candidates prepared, therefore, there
was a total absence of transparency, therefore, the order passed by
the Collector was held to be just and proper which was not the
correct factual position as the merit list was prepared by the Gram
Panchayat, proper scrutiny of the applications were done and in
absence of any objection by any of the candidates, the result was
declared.
3.
The State Government after introducing the Rules, of 2011
known as M.P. Panchayat Service (Gram Panchayat Secretary
Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2011 repealed the
earlier instructions in respect of appointment of Panchayat Karmi
and clearly stipulated under Rule 11 that the earlier proceedings
shall be considered in accordance with the Rules of 2011 and
after introducing said rules the District Cadre of Secretary has
been constituted and the services of the earlier appointed
secretary has also been absorbed in District Cadre. The learned
Commissioner considering the new Rules of 2011 modified the
order passed by the Collector and indirectly the right of the
petitioner has been permanently curtailed because as per the
amended rules the whole procedure has been changed and even
the cadre also has been changed for which the respondent
Commissioner has no authority because the aforesaid rules shall
be applicable only to those vacancies where recruitment will be in
future and the appointment of the petitioner since was already
made, the same shall be subject to the decision of the appellate
and revisional authority even in case of final decision/remand by
such authority, the same rules and regulations shall be applicable
which were prevailing at the time of issuance of the
advertisement and the selection proceedings and, therefore,
modifying the order of the Collector by the Commissioner is
contrary to certain legal positions. Aggrieved by the same, the
present petition has been filed.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner had argued that the
respondent/Commissioner while considering the new Rules of
2011 had modified the order passed by the Collector and
indirectly had curtailed the rights of the petitioner because as per
the amended Rules the whole procedure would be changed and
even the cadre of the Panchayat Secretary would change to which
the learned Commissioner has no authority because those rules
were applicable only to those vacancies which fall vacant after
promulgation of the said rules.
5.
It was further argued that the resolution passed by the
Gram Panchayat has been challenged by the person who has not
submitted his candidature and just in order to blackmail the
petitioner had preferred an appeal and that too before an
incompetent authority and as he was not the aggrieved party, has
no locus to challenge the appointment of the petitioner.
6.
It was also argued that Hon'ble Apex Court had clearly held
that once advertisement had been issued on the basis of a circular
obtaining at a particular point of time, the effect would be that the
selection should continue on the basis of the criteria laid down at
that moment and it cannot be on the basis of criteria which has
been made subsequently or brought in effect subsequently.
7.
It was further argued that the Hon'ble Apex Court also held
that subsequent amendment of Rules made during the pendency
of certain procedure will only have prospective effect and cannot
be made applicable retrospectively and, therefore, the directions
of the Commissioner to consider the case of the petitioner in the
light of the subsequent introduction of the Rules of 2011 to the
CEO Zila Panchayat, Bhind is per se illegal.
8.
To bolster his submission with regard to the competency of
the private respondent no.5 to prefer an appeal, reliance was
placed in the matter of Jitendra Singh vs. Rambabu and Ors
reported in 2012 (3) MPHT 183, wherein it has been held by the
Division Bench of this Court that an appeal contemplated under
the Rule 3 of the Rules of 1995 can be filed only by a
person/party, who is adversely affected by a decision under
appeal, and not by a stranger or a busy body.
9.
On the contrary, counsel for the respondent no.1 to 3/State
while opposing contentions raised by the counsel for the
petitioner had submitted that from the order of the Collector, it is
very much evident that the resolution passed by the Gram
Panchayat did not made it clear as to how the petitioner was
meritorious amongst the candidates and the name of respondent
no.5 was not considered at the time of passing of the resolution
though he was one of the applicants. From the resolution it was
also not clear as to how many candidates had applied for the post
of the Panchayat Karmi and as the entire procedure was found not
to be transparent, therefore, the Collector has rightly remanded
the matter back to the Gram Panchayat, which is a well reasoned
and speaking order.
10.
It was further argued that the order of the revisional Court
affirming the order of the Collector also by a detailed and
speaking order had found that there was no transparency in the
entire selection process and, therefore, no illegality can be said to
have been committed by the learned Commissioner in affirming
the order passed by the Collector.
11.
Heard the counsels for the parties and perused the record.
12.
From the order passed by the Commissioner in the revision
it is seen that the present respondent no.5 was also one of the
candidates who had applied for the post of Panchayat Karmi, but
in the resolution dated 21.09.2007 passed by the Gram Panchayat
neither his name was considered nor his name was reflected in the
merit list. It has also been observed in the order that the resolution
passed by the Gram Panchayat also does not reflect as to how
many applications were received for the post of Panchayat Karmi
and out of the applications so received how many applications
were rejected and on what basis, therefore, it appears that the
Gram Panchayat has not maintained transparency in the entire
process. The aforesaid aspect was the basis for affirming the order
passed by the Collector.
13.
The question which has been raised by the petitioner that
since respondent no.5 who had preferred an appeal against the
appointment of the petitioner was not one of the candidates and,
therefore, he was not having any locus to prefer an appeal does
not appears to be the correct factual position and, therefore,
reliance placed by the petitioner in the matter of Jitendra Singh
(supra) is misplaced and has no applicability as respondent no.5
was not a busy body or a stranger to the litigation.
14.
Further in the matter of Mahesh s/o Mohan Jadhav vs.
State of M.P. and others reported in 2010 (3) MPLJ 470 this
Court has held that for appointment of Panchayat Karmi merits
cannot be ignored. Further similar observation has been made in
the matter of Suresh vs. Chief Executive Officer and Ors.
reported in ILR 2012 MP 698 wherein also this Court has held
that merits should not and cannot be ignored and, therefore,
though SDO is the appellate authority so far as the orders passed
by Gram Panchayat is concerned, as per Section 3 of the M.P.
Panchayat (Appeal and Revision) Rules, 1999 the order passed by
the Collector considering the merits of the case cannot be said to
be illegal and so also the order passed by the Commissioner
affirming the order of the Collector.
15.
Now the only question which is left to be addressed upon is
whether the Rules of 2011 can be given retrospective effect as has
been directed by the learned Commissioner. In that regard
reference of the order passed by the Divison Bench of this Court
in the matter of Gopal Singh Gurjar vs. State of M.P and Ors
passed in W.A. No.25/2013 dated 16.08.2013 can be taken,
wherein the effect of Rule 11 of Rules of 2011 were considered
and it was held that the norms or rules as existing on the dated
when the process of selection has begins will control such
selection and any alteration to such norms would not affect the
continuing process, unless the same were given retrospective
effect and as the Rules of 2011 had not been made effective with
retrospective date, then the process of selection of Panchayat
Karmi which has started in the year, 2007 much prior to the date
of enforcement of Rules of 2011, would be continued to be
governed under the provisions of the old rules or instructions.
16.
This Court does not find any reason to depart from the
aforesaid analogy and keeping in consonance with the same while
partly allowing the petition, the part of the order of the
Commissioner whereby it had directed the CEO District
Panchayat to proceed with the matter in accordance with the
Rules of 2011 is hereby set aside keeping rest of the order intact.
17.
With the aforesaid, the petition is partly allowed and
disposed of.
CC as per rules/directions.
(Milind Ramesh Phadke)
Judge
chandni/CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
2024.01.06
14:35:27
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review