Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
WPA No. 27675 of 2025
Bizitza Retail Ventures Private Limited and Others
Versus
Central Bank of India and Others
Mr. Chayan Gupta
Mr. Niladri Banerjee
Mr. Debayan Ghosh
Mr. Abhidipto Tarafdar
Mr. Deepankar Thakur
.....For the petitioners.
Ms. Suchismita Ghosh
.....For the R.B.I.
Ms. A. Rao
…...For the respondent nos. 1 to 3.
Hearing Concluded On : 07.01.2026
Judgment on
: 15.01.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1.
The petitioners have filed the present writ application praying for a
Mandamus upon the respondent nos. 1, 2 and 3 to act in terms of the
Framework for Revival and Rehabilitation of Micro, Small and Medium
Enterprises dated 29th May, 2015 and 17th March, 2016 and the Master
Direction for Lending to Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Sector
dated 21st July, 2016.
2.
The
petitioner
no.1
is
a
registered
Micro
Enterprises,
having
Registration No. UDYAM-WB-10-0023419. The petitioner no. 1 has
availed Cash Credit Facilities of Rs. 4,95,00,000/- from the respondent
no.1 bank. The petitioner nos. 4 and 5 are guarantors of the petitioner
no.1 of the said Cash Credit Facilities.
3.
By a notice dated 24th June, 2025, the respondent no.1 has informed
the petitioner no.1 that the cash credit account of the petitioner no.1 is
under SMA-2 and will be turned to NPA on 25th June, 2025, due to
non-service of interest and requested the petitioner no.1 to immediately
pay the overdue amount of Rs. 14,33,608/- (Excluding revenue leakage
of Rs. 33,365/-) and to regularize the account.
4.
On 26th June, 2025, the respondent no.1 by a notice under Section
13(2) of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and
Enforcement of Security Interest (SARFAESI) Act, 2002 calling upon the
petitioners to discharge the liabilities in full by paying the entire
amount of Rs. 5,12,64,234.67 with interest.
5.
The petitioner no.1 by a letter dated 13th August, 2025, sent a reply to
the notice dated 26th June, 2025, requesting the bank to withdraw the
said notice and to follow the provisions of the “Framework for Revival
and Rehabilitation of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs)”
and the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
M/s. Pro Knits Vs. The Board of Directors of Canara Bank reported
in (2024) 10 SCC 292.
6.
On 6th September, 2025, the bank again issued a notice under Section
13(2) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002, calling upon the petitioners to pay
the amount of Rs.5,22,42,577.67 along with interest within 60 days
from the date of receipt of the notice. In the said notice, it was also
informed by the bank to the petitioners that the earlier notice dated
26th June, 2025, issued under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act
stands withdrawn.
7.
By a reply dated 17th November, 2025, the bank has informed the
petitioners that the bank has rightly classified the account of the
petitioner no. 1 as NPA by the system itself as per guidelines of the RBI.
In the said reply, the bank has also informed the petitioners that the
Bank has never received such request from the petitioners for any
Corrective Action Plan or restructuring as per the Framework for
Revival of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises.
8.
On 28th November, 2025, the petitioner no. 1 has made request to the
Zonal Head of the bank for implementation of the MSME. The petitioner
no. 1 also made request to the Reserve Bank of India with the request
to issue direction upon the bank for implementation of the guidelines.
9.
Mr. Chayan Gupta, Learned Advocate representing the petitioners
submits that inspite of the representations submitted by the petitioners
neither the bank nor the Reserve Bank of India has taken any action in
terms of the Framework for Revival and Rehabilitation of Micro, Small
and Medium Enterprises and on the other hand, the bank is proceeding
against the petitioners under the SARFAESI Act.
10. The petitioners have relied upon the judgment in the case of Pro Knits
(supra) and submits that prior to declaring the account of MSMEs, the
instructions
and
directions
of
the
Framework
for
Revival
and
Rehabilitation of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises is required to
be followed but in the case of the petitioners, the bank has not followed
the said guidelines.
11. Mr. Gupta relied upon the judgment in the case of A.K. Karthikeyan
vs. Authorized Officer, Canara Bank reported in 2025 SCC OnLine
Mad 3785 and submits that the Hon’ble Division Bench of the Madras
High Court also held that the bank is bound to consider the case of the
petitioners under the 2015 Notification, if not viable then only ought to
have proceeded under the SARFAESI Act.
12. Ms. A. Rao, Learned Advocate representing the Bank/ the respondent
nos. 1 to 3 submits that on 24th June, 2025, it was duly informed to
the petitioners that the Cash Credit of the petitioner no. 1 is under
SMA-2 and will be turned to NPA on 25th June, 2025 and requested the
petitioners to immediately pay the overdue amount of Rs. 14,33,608/but the petitioners have not paid the said amount. She submits that as
the petitioners have not paid the amount, accordingly, the system of
the bank automatically classified the account of the petitioner no. 1 as
NPA.
13. Ms. Rao submits that the petitioners have never made any request to
the bank for consideration of its case under the Framework for Revival
and Rehabilitation of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises. She
submits that the bank has issued notice to the petitioners under
Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act, on 26th June, 2025 but the
petitioner no. 1 has submitted its reply only on 13th August, 2025. She
submits that in the said reply also the petitioner no. 1 has not made
any request but has only stated that the bank has violated the
Notification and the order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Pro Knits (supra).
14. Ms. Rao has relied upon the judgment in the case of Shri Shri Swami
Samarth Construction & Finance Solution and Another Vs. Board
of Directors of NKGSB Co-Operative Bank Ltd. and Others reported
in 2025 SCC OnLine 1566 and submits that the Hon’ble Supreme
Court while interpreting the “FRAMEWORK” held that it do not prohibit
the lending bank/ secured creditor (assuming that it has no conscious
knowledge that the defaulting borrower is an MSME) to classify the
account of the defaulting MSME as NPA and to even issue the demand
notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act without such
identification of incipient stress in the account of the defaulting
borrower (MSME). She further submits that the Hon’ble Supreme Court
also held that upon receipt of demand notice, if such borrower in its
response under Section 13(3-A) of the SARFAESI Act asserts it an
MSME and claims the benefit of the FRAMEWORK citing reasons
supported by an affidavit, the lending bank/ secured creditor would
then be mandatorily bound to look into such claim keeping further
action under the SARFAESI Act in abeyance.
15. Ms. Rao submits that the petitioners have not filed any affidavit with
the bank after receipt of notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI
Act.
16. Ms. Suchismita Ghosh, Learned Advocate representing the Reserve
Bank of India submits that the petitioners have made representations
to the Reserve Bank of India only on 28th November, 2025 and filed the
present writ application on 2nd December, 2025, thus the Reserve Bank
of India could not get sufficient time to consider the representations
made by the petitioners. She has relied upon an unreported judgment
in the case of Mahua Bhaumik vs. Union of India & Ors. passed in
WPA No. 27289 of 2025 dated 16th December, 2025, passed by this
Court and submitted that in the similar circumstance of the case, this
Court by considering the judgement passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Shri Shri Swami Samarth Construction and
Finance Solution and Anr. (supra) directed the bank to consider the
case of the petitioners in terms of the FRAMEWORK and till the
decision is taken, the proceeding initiated by the bank under the
provisions of SARFAESI Act be kept in abeyance.
17. Heard the Learned Counsel for the parties, perused the materials on
record and the judgments relied by the parties. The petitioner no.1 is a
MSME and availed cash credit facility from the Central Bank of India
for an amount of Rs. 4,95,00,000/-. The allegation of the petitioners is
that the bank without following the Framework for Revival and
Rehabilitation of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises declared the
account of the petitioner no.1 as Non-Performing Assets and started
proceeding under the SARFAESI Act.
18. Interpretation of the Notification dated 15th May, 2015, (Framework for
Revival and Rehabilitation of Micro Small and Medium Enterprises)
came up for consideration before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Pro Knits (supra) wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that:
“17. What is contemplated in the “Framework
for Revival and Rehabilitation of MSMEs” contained
in the Instructions/Directions stated hereinabove,
is required to be followed prior to the classification
of the borrower's account, (in the instant case
MSMEs loan account), as non-performing assets.
The said Instructions contained in the Notification
dated 29-5-2015 as part of measures taken for
facilitating the promotion and development of
MSMEs issued by the Central Government in
exercise of powers conferred under Section 9 of
the MSMED Act, followed by the Directions issued
by the RBI in exercise of the powers conferred
under Sections 21 and 35-A of the Banking
Regulation Act, the banking companies though may
be “secured creditors” as per the definition
contained in Section 2(zd) of the SARFAESI Act, are
bound to follow the same, before classifying the
loan account of MSME as NPA.
20. Therefore, the stage of identification of
incipient stress in the loan account of MSMEs and
categorisation under the Special Mention Account
category, before the loan account of MSME turns
into NPA is a very crucial stage, and therefore it
would be incumbent on the part of the MSME
concerned also to produce authenticated and
verifiable documents/material for substantiating its
claim of being MSME, before its account is
classified as NPA. If that is not done, and once the
account is classified as NPA, the banks i.e. secured
creditors would be entitled to take the recourse to
Chapter III of the SARFAESI Act for the enforcement
of the security interest.
21. It is also pertinent to note that sufficient
safeguards have been provided under the said
Chapter for safeguarding the interest of the
defaulters-borrowers for giving them opportunities
to discharge their debt. However, if at the stage of
classification of the loan account of the borrower as
NPA, the borrower does not bring to the notice of
the bank/creditor concerned that it is a Micro,
Small or Medium Enterprise under the MSMED Act
and if such an Enterprise allows the entire process
for enforcement of security interest under
the SARFAESI Act to be over, or it having challenged
such action of the bank/creditor concerned in the
court of law/tribunal and having failed, such an
Enterprise could not be permitted to misuse the
process of law for thwarting the actions taken
under the SARFAESI Act by raising the plea of being
an MSME at a belated stage. Suffice it to say,
when it is mandatory or obligatory on the part of
the Banks to follow the Instructions/Directions
issued by the Central Government and the Reserve
Bank of India with regard to the Framework for
Revival and Rehabilitation of MSMEs, it would be
equally incumbent on the part of the MSMEs
concerned to be vigilant enough to follow the
process laid down under the said Framework, and
bring to the notice of the Banks concerned, by
producing
authenticated
and
verifiable
documents/material to show its eligibility to get the
benefit of the said Framework.”
19. Now, recently the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Shri Shri
Swami Samarth Construction & Finance Solution & Anr. (supra)
held that:
“6. The way Mr. Nedumpara urges us to read
the notification and the terms of the framework, if
accepted, would lead to the conclusion that every
lending
bank/secured
creditor
under
the
Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial
Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act,
would be obliged to find out in every event of
continuing default, likely to give rise to
classification of the relevant account as nonperforming asset, whether the borrower is an
micro, small and medium enterprise to which the
framework applies, whether its business has failed
or whether it is suffering from any disability to pay
its debts; and upon receiving a response, to apply
the terms thereof by, inter alia, including the
account in the special mention account for the claim
for a corrective action plan to be considered by the
Committee for stressed micro, small and medium
enterprises. This could not have been the intention
behind introduction of the framework to aid the
micro, small and medium enterprises which, for
reasons personal to them, is unable to clear its debt
and require revival and rehabilitation that the
framework envisages. If indeed it is only the
obligation of the lending bank/secured creditor to
identify incipient stress in the account, subparagraphs 2 and 3 of paragraph 1 would be
rendered redundant. A micro, small and medium
enterprise, despite finding that its business is
failing or that it is unable to pay its debts or
accumulation of losses equals to half or more of its
entire net worth and classification of its account as
non-performing asset is imminent, it would rest on
its oars believing that it has no responsibility and
that its account will not be classified as nonperforming asset because it is the entire obligation
of the lending bank/secured creditor to do what the
framework requires. We would read and interpret
the seemingly confusing terms of the Framework
harmoniously to ensure that a right under the
Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise Act is not
destroyed by the Securitisation and Reconstruction
of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security
Interest Act, or vice versa. In our reading, the terms
of the framework do not prohibit the lending
bank/secured creditor (assuming that it has no
conscious knowledge that the defaulting borrower
is a micro, small and medium enterprise) to classify
the account of the defaulting micro, small and
medium enterprise as non-performing asset and to
even issue the demand notice under section 13(2)
of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of
Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security
Interest Act, without such identification of incipient
stress in the account of the defaulting borrower
(MSME); however, upon receipt of the demand
notice, if such borrower in its response under
section
13(3A)
of
the
Securitisation
and
Reconstruction
of
Financial
Assets
and
Enforcement of Security Interest Act asserts that it
is a micro, small and medium enterprise and claims
the benefit of the Securitisation and Reconstruction
of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security
Interest Act, citing reasons supported by an
affidavit, the lending bank/secured creditor would
then be mandatorily bound to look into such claim
keeping further action under the Securitisation and
Reconstruction
of
Financial
Assets
and
Enforcement of Security Interest Act in abeyance;
and should the claim be found to be worthy of
acceptance within the framework of the framework,
to act in terms thereof for securing revival and
rehabilitation of the defaulting borrower.
7. As has been noted above, the petitioning
enterprise does not seem to have ever claimed the
benefit of the terms of the framework after the
demand notice under section 13(2) of the
Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial
Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act
was issued. It is at the stage of compliance with an
order passed by the relevant Magistrate under
section 14 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction
of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security
Interest Act that this writ petition has been
presented before this court claiming benefits of the
framework to restrain respondent No. 2 and its
officers from proceeding further under the
Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial
Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act
and other enactments except in the manner
contemplated under the said notification. We find
the bona fides of the petitioning enterprise to be
suspect.
8. Pro Knits (supra) is a decision of a coordinate Bench of this court holding, inter alia, that
the notification is binding on the lending
banks/secured creditors. Finding to the contrary by
the High Court of Bombay in the judgment and
order under challenge in the appeal was, thus,
quashed. Though while stressing that the terms of
the framework need to be followed by the lending
banks/secured creditors before the account of an
micro, small and medium enterprise is classified as
non-performing asset, this decision also lays stress
on the obligation of the micro, small and medium
enterprises by holding that “it would be equally
incumbent on the part of the micro, small and
medium enterprises concerned to be vigilant
enough to follow the process laid down under the
said framework, and bring to the notice of the
banks concerned, by producing authenticated and
verifiable documents/material to show its eligibility
to get the benefit of the said framework”. It was
cautioned that “if such an enterprise allows the
entire process for enforcement of security interest
under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of
Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security
Interest Act to be over, or it having challenged such
action of the bank/creditor concerned in the court
of law/Tribunal and having failed, such an
enterprise could not be permitted to misuse the
process of law for thwarting the actions taken
under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of
Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security
Interest Act by raising the plea of being an micro,
small and medium enterprise at a belated stage”.
This decision, however, left unsaid something
which we have explained hereinabove while
construing the terms consistently to prevent
undermining of rights that one central enactment
confers by another.”
20. In the present case, on 24th June 2025, the bank has issued notice to
the petitioners intimating that the cash credit account of the petitioner
no. 1 is under SMA-2 and will be turned to NPA on 25th June, 2025,
and requested the petitioner no. 1 to pay the overdue amount of Rs.
14,33,308/- and to regularize the account. On 26th June, 2025, the
bank has issued notice upon the petitioners under Section 13(2) of the
SARFAESI Act directing the petitioners to discharge its liability by
paying the total due amount of Rs. 5,12,64,234.67 and if the
petitioners failed to pay the said amount, the consequential steps which
the bank will take was also informed to the petitioners.
21. In reply to the notice in paragraph 9, the petitioners have stated as
follows:
“9. That the provisions of the “Framework for
Revival and Rehabilitation of Micro, Small and
Medium Enterprises (MSMEs)” as per the RBI
circular and also as notified by the Central Govt
vide notification dt. 29.05.2015 have been
blatantly violated by the Bank. Also in terms of the
recent judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the matter of M/s Pro Knits Vs The Board of
Directors of Canara Bank delivered on 1st August
2024 the same has been contemptuously avoided
and disregarded by the bank.”
22. Subsequently, the bank has issued another notice under Section 13(2)
of the SARFAESI Act wherein the bank has withdrawn its earlier notice
dated 26th June, 2025. The contention of the bank is that the bank has
not intentionally declared the account of the petitioner no. 1 as NPA on
26th June, 2025. If the borrower will not regularize the account, the
system automatically shows the account of the borrower as NPA. It is
the further contention of the bank that the petitioners have not made
any request for any Corrective Action Plan or restructuring the account
of the petitioner no. 1 in terms of the Framework.
23. On receipt of notice dated 26th June, 2025, the petitioners, though, did
not categorically requested the bank for consideration of its case under
the FRAMEWORK but have stated that the bank has violated the
notification dated 29th May, 2015 and the order passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Pro Knit (supra). The respondent bank
has withdrawn the notice dated 26th June, 2025 but has issued fresh
notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act on 6th September,
2025. After the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Shri Shri Swami Samarth Construction and Finance
Solution & Anr. (supra) on 28th July, 2025, the bank has withdrawn
the notice dated 26th June, 2025 and issued another notice dated 6th
September, 2025 under Section 13(2) of the Act and thereafter by a
reply dated 17th November, 2025, have taken a stand that the
petitioners have not made any request for any Corrective Action Plan or
Restructuring.
24. This Court finds that the petitioners in its reply dated 13th August,
2025 informed the bank that the bank has violated the notification
dated 29th May, 2015 by not considering the case of the petitioners in
terms of the said notification though the bank admits that the
petitioner no. 1 is a MSME. When the bank came to know about the
order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Shri Shri
Swami Samarth Construction and Finance Solution & Anr.
(supra), the bank has taken the stand that the petitioners have not
requested the bank for restructuring.
25. It is mandatory on the part of the bank that, in reply, if the borrower
claims benefit of the FRAMEWORK with reasons and affidavit, the bank
is bound to look into the claim of the borrower. Considering the above,
this Court finds that the proceeding initiated by the bank against the
petitioners is at the initial stage and there is no dispute that the
petitioner no. 1 is not MSME. The petitioners are directed to file its
claim within a week from the date along with an affidavit and
documents to the respondent no. 2. If the petitioners submit its claim
within a week from date, the bank shall consider the same in
accordance with notifications dated 29th May, 2015 and 17th March,
2016. Till the final decision is taken by the bank, the proceeding
initiated by the bank shall kept be in abeyance.
26. WPA No. 27675 is disposed of.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review