Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Item No.5
12.11.2026
Court. No. 12
GB
MAT 2297 of 2025
With
CAN 1 of 2026
With
CAN 2 of 2026
Aloke Kuma Dey
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
Mr. Tapash Kumar Bhattacharya,
Mr. Sandip Ghosh,
Mr. Partha Sarkar
… for the Applicant/Appellant.
Ms. Susmita Saha Dutta, Ld. AGP.,
Ms. Madhurima Saha
… for the State.
In Re: CAN 1 of 2026
1. Since the present intra court appeal was belatedly
presented, an application being CAN 1 of 2026 has
been filed under Section 5 of the Limitation Act for
condonation of delay.
2. Mr. Bhattacharya, learned advocate appearing for the
appellant submits that the delay occurred due to
reasons beyond the control of the appellant and there
was no intentional laches or negligence on the part of
the appellant. He submits that since the family
members of the appellant (wife, son and mother) fell
seriously ill and were also hospitalized, the appellant
could not take steps at the appropriate stage. The
appellant averred that he was mentally stressed and
disturbed due to the recurring health issues faced by
the family members and he was not in a position to
follow up with the learned Advocate about the fate of
the writ petition. Thus, the appeal could not be
preferred within the period of limitation. The
appellant prays for condonation of delay.
3. Ms. Saha Dutta, learned Additional Government
Pleader opposes the prayer.
4. Heard the learned advocates for the respective
parties.
Perused
the
averments
made
in
the
application and the explanation for the delay. We are
satisfied that there were sufficient causes which
prevented the appellant from preferring the appeal
within the prescribed period of limitation.
5. In view thereof, we are inclined to allow the
application for condonation of delay, subject to
payment of cost of Rs.5,000/- to be paid to the State
Legal
Services
Authority,
West
Bengal
for
transmission to the funds of the Juvenile Justice
Committee, High Court, within three weeks from
date.
In Re: MAT 2297 of 2025
1. By preferring the present intra court appeal, the writ
petitioner/appellant (hereinafter referred to as the
„appellant‟) has called in question the justiciability of
the order dated 5th October, 2023 passed in WPA
22977 of 2022. By the impugned order, the writ
petition was dismissed.
2. The facts leading to presentation of the appeal was
that, the appellant had been operating one foreign
liquor shop in the name and style of „Tinar More CS
Shop‟ standing on a plot bearing no.11953/28801 at
Mouza – Tinar under Sarai Tinar Gram Panchayat,
District – Hooghly, from a rented premises.
3. Subsequently, with the intention to run the shop from
his own land, the appellant approached the competent
authority seeking permission for shifting of his liquor
shop. Such prayer was not accepted by the authority
on the ground that the appellant‟s proposed shop fell
within the vicinity of 1000 ft. from one Anganwadi
centre. The appellant questioned the said decision of
the respondent by preferring the writ petition,
contending that the Anganwadi centre could not be
considered to be a recognized educational institution
as referred to in Sub-Rule 1 of Rule 8 of the West
Bengal Excise (New Sites and Grant of Licence) Rules,
2003. The learned Single Judge rejected such
contention of the appellant and the writ petition was
dismissed. Aggrieved, the appellant has preferred the
present appeal.
4. Mr. Bhattacharya, learned advocate appearing for the
appellant submits that an Anganwadi centre cannot
be treated to be at par with an educational institution
recognized either by the State Government or the
Central Government. He submits that such centre is
not governed by any statutory framework of the
school education department. He further submits that
his proposed shop is situated at a distance of more
than 1000 ft. but, such fact had been glossed over by
the learned Single Judge and the learned Single Judge
arrived at an erroneous finding.
5. Ms. Saha Dutta, learned Additional Government
Pleader opposes such contentions advanced on behalf
of the appellant and she asserts that an Anganwadi
centre should be considered to be a recognized
educational institution within the meaning of SubRule 1 of Rule 8 of the 2003 Rules. She referred to a
notification issued by the Deputy Secretary to the
Government of West Bengal, Department of Excise
West Bengal dated 20th January, 2012 and contends
that by this notification the concerned department
has clarified that the Anganwadi centres may not be
excluded from the meaning of educational institution
under Rule 8 of the 2003 Rules.
6. The order impugned in the appeal indicates that the
learned trial Judge, by referring to Rule 8 of 2003
Rules and Rules 5(4) and 5(5)(iv) of the Right of
Children to Free and Compulsory Education Rules,
2012 arrived at conclusion that the Anganwadi centre
was also an educational institution recognized by the
State Government. His Lordship held as follows :“10. Learned counsel for the respondent-authorities
has rightly pointed out that Rule 5(4)(iv) of the 2012
Rules clearly stipulates that the State Government,
through appropriate local authorities, shall maintain
at the level of the Circle Level Resource Centre, a
register of all children under their respective
jurisdictions from their birth till they attain the age of
14 years. The resister shall, in respect of every child
including an infant after birth, include the name of
school or pre-school or “Anganwadi Centre”, etc.
11. Thus, it is evident that recognition has been given
to Anganwadi Centres on equal footing as schools and
pre-schools under the Right of Children to Free and
Compulsory Education Act, 2009. Since the said Act
governs the imparting of education within the State
and operates in the specific field of education, the
mention of Anganwadi Centre as a school or a preschool definitely has to be construed as a recognition
of Anganwadi Centres as educational institutions
within the contemplation of Rule 8 of the 2003 Rules.
12. That apart, Section 9 of the Right of Children to
Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 also
mentions that every local authority shall ensure and
monitor admission, attendance and completion of
elementary education by every child residing within its
jurisdiction. Read in conjunction, it cannot be gainsaid
that Anganwadi Centres, within the contemplation of
the Scheme under which those have been formulated,
also have activities of imparting education to children
in the age group of three to six years.
13. Hence, the said Centres fall within the specific
ambit of Rule 8 of the 2003 Rules.”
7. We do not find either any infirmity or any perversity
in such finding.
8. The Anganwadi Centre imparts elementary education
and is established under the integrated child
development scheme (ICDS) under the Ministry of
Women and Child Development and Social Welfare.
Section 2(1) of the National Food Security Act, 2013
defines an Anganwadi Centre to mean a child care and
development centre set up under the ICDS Scheme of
the Central Government to render services under the
said Act. Under the said provision, states have also set
up Anganwadi Centres which provide care and
elementary education for children between the ages of
3 to 6 years.
9. Section 11 of the Right of Children to Free and
Compulsory Education Act, 2009 provides that the
appropriate Government must ensure pre-school
education. The said Section is quoted below :“11. Appropriate Government to provide for
pre-school education.With a view to prepare children above the age of three
years for elementary education and to provide early
childhood care and education for all children until they
complete the age of six years, the appropriate
Government may make necessary arrangement for
providing free pre-school education for such children.”
10. Accordingly, the State of West Bengal‟s School
Education Department framed the West Bengal Right
of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Rules,
2012,
and
recognized
pre-school/elementary
education through Anganwadi Centres.
11. Under Rule 5(1), the State through the appropriate
local authorities were required to maintain at the level
of the Circle Level Resources Centre, a register of
children under the respective jurisdiction from their
birth till they attained the age of 14 years. Under Rule
5(4), the said register was to be maintained
transparently and be made available in public
domain. The same was to be used to maintain
admission, attendance and completion of elementary
education of every child residing in the jurisdiction.
The register under Rule 5(5) was to provide various
information. The is quoted below:“5.Maintenance of records of children by local
authority for purpose of clause (d) of section
9.(5) The register referred to in sub-rule(1) shall, in
respect of every child including an infant after birth,
include –
(i) name, sex, date of birth (Birth Certificate Number
wherever available), place of birth;
(ii) name, address, occupation of the parents or
guardians;
(iii) present address of the child;
(iv) name of school or pre-school or Anganwadi Centre
or Alternative Innovative Education Centre where the
child avails elementary education up to the age of 6
years, wherever available;
(v) elementary school where the child is admitted, if
applicable;
(vi) class in which the child is studying (for children
between age 6 to 14 years), and if education is
discontinued in the territorial jurisdiction of the said
local authority, the cause of such discontinuance;
(viii) information regarding whether the child belongs
to the weaker section within the meaning of clause (e)
of section 2;
(ix) information regarding whether the child belongs to
a disadvantaged group within the meaning of clause
(d) of section 2;
(x) information regarding whether the child requires
special facilities or residential facilities on account of
migration and sparse population, age appropriate
admission, disability of any other reason to be
specified.”
12. Under Rule 5(5)(iv), the name of the pre-school or
the Anganwadi Centre or the Alternative Innovative
Education Centre which the child availed of for
elementary education up to the age of 6 years was also
an important information. Pre-school education /
elementary education are being imparted to children
between the age of 34 to 6 years at Anganwadi
Centres and such centres are recognised under the
Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education
Act, 2009 and Rules framed thereunder.
They
function under the Department of Women and Child
and Social Welfare. The fact that they are educational
institutions, recognized by law is not in doubt. Under
such circumstances they also fall under the category
of a school for the purpose of implementation of Rule
8 of the 2003 Rules of 2003.
13. Thus, the order impugned is upheld.
14. Accordingly, the appeal being devoid of merit stands
dismissed.
15. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
16. However, this order shall not preclude the appellant
from approaching the auithority in the event he is of
the opinion that the proposed site for the shop was
situated beyond 1000 ft. from the Anganwadi Centre.
The authority shall take appropriate steps in
accordance with law after due notice to the appellant,
in the event the appellant approaches the authority.
(Shampa Sarkar, J.)
(Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review