Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Vacation Bench
November 6, 2026
Sl. No.1
Court No.08
s.biswas
MAT 1920 of 2026
with
CAN 1 of 2026
Altabur Rahaman Mollah
vs.
The State of West Bengal and others
Mr. Tilak Bose, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Suddhasatva Banerjee
Mr. Sagnik Majumdar
Ms. Anyapurba Banerjee
Ms. Shreya Ghosh
Ms. Arin Chakraborty
... for the appellant
Mr. D. N. Ray, GP
Mr. Ajit Kumar MIshra, AGP
Mr. Prashant Agarwal
Mr. Sourav Haldar
... for the State
Mr. Biswaroop Bhattacharyya
Mr. Sounak Mondal
... for the respondent no.3
1. Affidavit of service filed on behalf of the appellant is
taken on record.
2. The present appeal arises out of a writ petition filed by
the appellant, whereby the action of the tender issuing
authority in permitting the private respondent to upload
further additional documents much after the last date
of submission of documents in terms of the tender
document, as well as assailing the eligibility criteria at
the technical stage of the private respondents.
The
learned Single Judge, by the impugned judgment,
relegated the matter for decision to the tender issuing
authority.
3. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant
argues that in view of the private respondent having
failed to meet the essential criteria which was essential
for crossing the technical eligibility threshold, the
learned Single Judge ought to have allowed the writ
petition, thereby precluding the participation of the
private respondent at any further stage of the tender
process.
4. Secondly, it is contended that the additional documents
which the private respondent was permitted to upload
much
after
the
last
date
of
submission
of
the
documents as per the tender document ought not to be
looked into at all by the tender issuing authorities. It is
contended that “the rules of the game cannot be
changed after the game has started”, in the sense that if
the private respondent is permitted to file such
document to cure the shortfalls pertaining to the
eligibility itself and the essential criteria thereof, it
would be a travesty of the tender process, in effect
tantamounting
to
contravention
tender
condition
themselves, without extending such facility/advantage
to the other unsuccessful bidders.
5. Learned Senior Counsel takes the Court in particular
through several clauses of the tender document,
whereby the criteria and credentials for participation in
the tender are delineated.
6. It is argued that although the Clause (ii) under the
heading “Non-Statutory Cover” and the sub-heading “To
be filled in Credential Folder” stipulates that the bidder
must produce records satisfactorily evidencing similar
nature of a single work “with experience in providing
mechanized cleaning and housekeeping service in a
government hospital etc. having minimum involvement
of Rs.7 crore per annum for three years prior to the
date of issue of e-tender notice”, the private respondent
failed to upload any document indicating experience in
mechanized/automated cleaning.
Furthermore, it is
contended that the list of documents which were
compulsorily to be submitted were not uploaded within
time and a proforma performance statement as per
format given in Form-7 with required documentary
evidence was not filed, rather, the private respondent
altered the format itself.
7. Furthermore, the checklist for bidders also included a
valid licence for providing pest control service under
Insecticide
Rules,
1971,
respondents
furnished
a
whereas
licence
the
at
the
private
initial
submission stage which had expired on December 31,
2025 and was not valid at the relevant juncture. Only
subsequently,
in
garb
of
furnishing
additional
documents with the blessings of the tender issuing
authorities,
the
private
respondent
furnished
an
apparently valid document in that regard.
8. Moreover, in the checklist-in-question, a complete work
plan indicating buildingwise, floorwise and shiftwise
deployment of manpower was required to be furnished
at the inception, which was only submitted later by way
of additional documents.
9. Learned
Senior
Counsel
places
reliance
on
the
instruction in bold letters at the end of such list, which
categorically provides that valid documents as noted in
the said table will “have to be” submitted and that the
same will form a part of the Technical Evaluation (T.E.).
10.
Learned Senior Counsel next takes the Court
through Clause 18.2 of the tender document, which
permits the relevant committee of the tender issuing
authority to summon bidders and seek clarification,
information/additional documents or original hard
copies of documents submitted online.
11.
If those are not produced within the specified time
limit, as per the said clause, the bid proposals would be
liable for rejection.
12.
Learned Senior Counsel argues that the expression
“additional documents” in the said clause has to be
read in the context of the other criteria stipulated
therein and had to be in the nature of clarification.
13.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
cites
Banshidhar
Construction Private Limited vs. Bharat Coking
Coal Limited and others reported in (2024) 10 SCC
273, in support of the proposition that when the
technical bid of a particular bidder was rejected on the
ground that it did not comply with the essential clauses
of the Notice Inviting Tender (NIT), there was no
justification on the part of the respondent authorities
for accepting the technical bid of the said bidder, which
clearly was not in compliance of the said mandatory
clause stipulated in the essential criteria. In the said
case, it was observed that the tender issuing authority
has miserably failed to justify as to how the technical
bid of the said bidder was accepted, when it had not
submitted
the
requisite
document
related
to
the
qualification criteria as mentioned in the said essential
clause, being Clause 10 of the NIT in the said matter.
14.
A submission made on behalf of the tender issuing
authority that the tender evaluation committee could
call for the shortfall of the documents was turned down
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the said judgment.
15.
Learned Government Pleader appearing for the
tender issuing authority contends that the learned
Single Judge in the impugned judgment has left the
matter to be decided by the tender issuing authority,
which, according to the learned Government Pleader,
includes a prima consideration of whether a clause in
the tender document is essential or not. It is contended
that in such view of the matter, no interference is called
for at this stage.
16.
Learned Government Pleader further submits that as
yet, no final decision has been arrived at in respect of
the evaluation of the technical bids. In such context,
learned Government Pleader places reliance on Clauses
18.2, 18.3 as well as 18.4. According to the learned
Government Pleader, a composite reading thereof would
clearly indicate that it was open to the tender issuing
authority to summon bidders and seek additional
documents as well even if those were not produced
within the last date of submission initially fixed for the
tender.
17.
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
private
respondent no.3, whose participation in the tender
process has been challenged by the appellant, cites
Central Coalfields Limited and another vs. SLL-SML
(Joint Venture Consortium) and others reported at
(2016) 8 SCC 622 and argues that the issue of
acceptance or rejection of a bid or a bidder should be
looked at not only from the point of view of the
unsuccessful party but also from the point of view of
the employer and the terms of the NIT cannot be
ignored as being redundant or superfluous.
18.
It was further observed in the matter whether the
terms of an NIT are essential or not, the decision taken
by the employer should be respected.
19.
Learned counsel takes the Court through the
relevant clauses of the tender document, in particular
Clause 3 under Section V thereof, stipulating the
general conditions of contract.
According to learned
counsel, it were the said provisions which were to be
met by a bidder for qualifying at the technical stage. It
is submitted that all the said criteria were substantially
complied with by the respondent no.3.
Moving on to
the list of documents which were relied on by the
appellant, learned counsel submits that said list does
not comprise a part of the essential criteria but is only
an ancillary clause.
20.
Learned
counsel
further
submits
that
all
the
additional documents permitted to be uploaded in
respect of the bid of the respondent no.3 are in the
nature of clarification of the original information filed by
the respondent no.3 before the cut-off date.
21.
Learned counsel for the respondent no.3 also adopts
the arguments of learned Government Pleader to the
effect that it is the tender issuing authority which
ultimately interprets as to which of the conditions of the
tender document are essential criteria and which are
not.
22.
Upon a careful consideration of the arguments of the
parties and the materials on record placed before us,
including the tender document clauses, this Court is of
the opinion that on a proper reading of Clause 18.2, it
would be evident that the doctrine of Noscitur a Sociis is
squarely applicable insofar as the phrase “additional
documents” is concerned, since the said phrase finds
place in the relevant clause between the expressions
“clarification” and “original hard copies of documents
submitted online”. Thus, on a plain reading of the said
provision, it is clear that the nature of the additional
documents is inextricably tied up with the information
and clarification which the tender issuing authority is
entitled to seek and has to be in the nature of such
clarification, which is further evident from the fact that
the next part of the clause permits the authority to seek
original hard copies, not of new documents but of
documents
already
submitted
online,
essentially
meaning that the documents which are submitted
before the cut-off date for submission of documents.
23.
However, we are equally aware of the dictum laid
down in the Central Coalfields (supra), which is a trite
principle of law, that whether a tender clause is
essential or not ultimately needs to be decided by the
employer and it is not for the Court to adjudicate on the
merits of such issue. Moreover, the issue of acceptance
or rejection of bid also has to be seen from the
perspective of the employer, who floated the tender to
meet his needs.
24.
Be that as it may, simultaneously, we also find logic
in the argument of the appellant to the effect that
unless the private respondent no.3 or any of bidders did
not meet the essential technical eligibility criteria at the
outset and furnish all necessary documents in that
regard within the last date for such submission i.e.
October 5, 2026, subsequently, by invoking Clause 18.2
read with Clauses 18.3 and 18.4, it was not open to the
tender
issuing
authority
to
permit
entirely
new
documents to be submitted which, if those were not
produced
at
the
outset,
would
have
altogether
invalidated the candidature of the concerned bidder.
25.
Thus, although we do not find much fault with the
impugned judgment to the effect that the decision has
been left for the tender issuing authority to be taken,
such decision has to be subject to the following
yardsticks:
i) The tender issuing authority has to ascertain and
take a reasoned decision as to what are the
essential criteria as per the tender document for
crossing the technical stage;
ii) Whether
the
private
respondent
no.3,
as
per
documents which were furnished before the cutoff date, i.e., October 5, 2026 by the said
respondent, could have been otherwise held to be
eligible;
iii) Whether the additional documents furnished by the
respondent no.3 are in the nature of clarification
of
the
original
information
and
document
furnished by the respondent no.3.
26.
Upon
taking
such
decision
in
the
light
of
representation given by the appellant, the tender
issuing authority shall pass a reasoned order in writing
and communicate the same to the parties to the present
litigation.
27.
For such purpose, the entire time-line scheduled by
the learned Single Judge is extended by/postponed for
a week.
28.
It is made clear that we have not entered into the
merits of such adjudication. However, the adjudication
to be undertaken by the tender issuing authority shall
be in terms of the yardsticks as stipulated hereinabove.
29.
It is made clear that the other components of the
impugned judgment are not interfered with.
30.
MAT 1920 of 2026 is disposed of with the above
observations, by modifying the impugned order by
reading into the same the yardsticks which have been
mentioned above.
31.
CAN 1 of 2026 is consequentially disposed of as well.
32.
There shall be no order as to costs.
(Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.)
(Arindam Mukherjee, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review