Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 02
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
HCP No.82/2025
CM No.7046/2025
Date of pronouncement: 05.02.2026
Date of uploading:
05.02.2026e
CR
Bilal Ahmed, Age 40 years
S/o Bashir Ahmed Wani
At Present Central Jail KotBhalwal,
Jammu, J&K
Through Brother
Shameem Ahmed, Age 20 years
S/O Abdul Rashid
R/o Tanta, Doda, District Doda,
J&K
Through:
…..Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Mr. Sanchit Verma, Advocate.
Vs
01. UT of J&K through Commissioner/Secretary, Home, Civil
Secretariat, Jammu/Srinagar.
02. District Magistrate, Doda.
03. Divisional Forest Officer (DFO), Bhaderwah.
04. Superintendent, District Jail, Udhampur, J&K
Through:
CORAM:
…Respondent(s)
Mr. Bhanu Jasrotia, GA.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SEKHRI, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
05.02.2026 (ORAL)
01.
Petitioner has invoked writ jurisdiction of this Court for quashment of
Detention Order No.PSA/02 of 2025 dated 12.03.2025, passed by
respondent No.2-District Magistrate, Doda under Section 8(1)(a-1) of J&K
Public Safety Act, 1978 (hereinafter referred as “PSA”) and consequent
release from detention.
02.
Background facts of the case are that a dossier dated 06.03.2025 came to be
submitted by Divisional Forest Officer, Bhaderwah to respondent No.2District Magistrate, Doda alleging inter alia that petitioner is a notorious
timber smuggler, causing damage to the forests of the District, especially in
compartment 05/Jai Chiralla Range of Bhaderwah Forest Division. It was
alleged that there were two FIRs already registered against him at Police
Station, Gandoh and another FIR lodged by Block Officer Jai-1st regarding
manhandling/death threatening to a Govt. official and that his activities
were causing damage not only to the green wealth of the district and local
biodiversity of the area, but also impacting the lives of the people. He had
not renounced his illegal practices even after issuance of warnings and
registration of damage cases against him. It was evident from the
registration of two FIRs/ damage cases/reports against him that he had least
respect for the Law of Land. He had got huge motivation and great
propensity to indulge in activities which can damage the forests and
environment and would be detrimental to the local ecosystem and peaceful
existence of the society. It was also alleged that activities of the petitioner
in illegal trade and smuggling of timber for personal gains not only
endangers the local environment, but also poses serious threats to the lives
of health of the people. On the receipt of this dossier, impugned detention
order came to be passed, in execution whereof, petitioner came to be
detained in Central Jail Kot Bhalwal, Jammu.
03.
Petitioner is aggrieved of the impugned order, primarily on the ground that
he has been framed by the respondents in a false and frivolous case because
he gave interview on the Social Media, whereby he had alleged rampant
deforestation in the forest area of Bhaderwah Division at the behest of the
forest officials under the command of respondent No.3. It is contended that
there is no exemplary or cogent material and details available on the basis
of which, impugned order came to be passed by respondent No.2. He has
been detained on the basis of concocted story with no material on record
regarding his involvement in damaging the forests or timber smuggling.
Page No.2
HCP No.82/2025
Since he was not provided the relevant material/documents to enable him
to make an effective representation against his detention, impugned
detention order is violative of Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India. He
was neither informed about his right to make representation nor provided
liberty of being heard, which constituted infraction of his constitutional
right. The detention order was not communicated to him in the language he
understands. Grounds of detention are replica of the dossier with interplay
of some words here and there which exhibits total non-application of mind
on the part of the detaining authority and that detention order has been
passed in sheer disregard to the provisions of PSA.
04.
The petition has been resisted on the other side by the respondent-UT,
primarily on the ground that detention of a detenue is not punitive but
preventive in nature on the basis of dossier provided by the concerned
authorities. It is contention of the respondents that conduct of the petitioner
in inflicting damage to the forests and smuggling timber, constrained the
authorities to detain him.
05.
It is further contended that petitioner was handed over the detention order
(01 leaf), notice of detention (01 leaf), copy of dossier (05 leaves) along
with all relevant documents (05 leaves), i.e. total 12 leaves through the
Execution Officer of Police Station Gandoh on 15.03.2025, i.e. on the date
of execution of the detention order, in lieu of which signatures of petitioner
were obtained against proper receipt.
06.
It is contention of the respondents that with a view to prevent the detenue
from indulging in similar activities, he was ordered to be detained in
accordance with the Provisions of the Act vide impugned Order dated
12.03.2025. He was duly informed of his detention on the grounds
specified and that he has a right to make a representation to the
Page No.3
HCP No.82/2025
Government, if he so desires. The detention order was executed by the
concerned police and the grounds of detention was read over and explained
to him in the language which he understands. It is also contention of the
respondents that only after the Advisory Board was satisfied that there was
sufficient ground for his detention, the Government confirmed the
impugned detention order, he came to be detained for a period of one year
in Central Jail Kot Bhalwal, Jammu. According, to the respondents, the
detention of the detenue, in the present case is precise and proximate and
since all statutory constitutional Provisions and legal formalities of PSA
have been duly followed, there is no vagueness in the grounds of detention.
It is denied by respondents that the impugned order has been passed
without application of mind. According to the respondents, impugned order
has been passed as a preventive measure keeping in view the activities of
the petitioner which are detrimental to the forests and environmental
health.
07.
It is also contention of the respondents that representation of the petitioner
dated 29.05.2025 was addressed to the Home Department through District
Magistrate Doda. Respondents have prayed for dismissal of the writ
petition.
08.
Heard argument and perused the file.
09.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon “Vijay Kumar V. State
of J&K & Ors.”; AIR 1982 SC 1023, “Dr. Rahamatullah V. State of
Bihar & Anr.”; AIR 1981 SC 2069, “K.M. Abdulla Kunhi and Anr. V.
Union of India & Ors.”; AIR 1991 SC 574 and a judgment rendered by
this Court in “Hasham Din V. UT of J&K & Ors.”, [HCP No.81/2025
dated 06.11.2025], besides relying upon the ground urged in the memo of
petition.
Page No.4
HCP No.82/2025
10.
Per contra, Mr. Bhanu Jasrotia, learned GA has maintained the stand of the
respondents in arguments.
11.
At the foremost, it is allegation of the petitioner that he gave interview on
Social Media news KK Portal page handle regarding rampant deforestation
in the forest area of Bhaderwah Division on the behest of forest officials,
widespread cutting of trees and illegal felling of trees by forest officials
under the command of respondent No.3, whereby he made remarks on
forests officials under whose aegis rampant cutting of trees were going on.
According to the petitioner, it was due to this interview and tussle with
forests officials that he came to be framed in two false and frivolous
damage cases by the respondents. According to the petitioner, Damage
Case No.42/2024-25, was never conveyed to him and he came to know
about it for the first time when impugned detention order came to be
issued.
12.
Interestingly, respondents in counter affidavit have not denied allegations
of the petitioner, contained in para 7 of the petition, regarding interview
given by him on Social Media alleging widespread and rampant
deforestation in the forest area of Bhaderwah division at the behest of
forest officials under the command of respondent No.3. In reply to this
para, respondents have simply stated that petitioner has been detained due
to the nature of his illegal activities those were enumerated in the dossier.
There is nothing in the counter affidavit that whether they were aware
about any such interview or that allegations levelled by the petitioner in
Social Media were false. It is settled law that no reply or evasive reply to
allegations amounts to admission on the part of the person against whom
allegation is made.
Page No.5
HCP No.82/2025
13.
It is evident from the dossier and the grounds of detention that impugned
order has been passed against the petitioner on the basis of two damage
cases regarding felling of trees by him. A question to be discoursed in such
circumstances, is whether such allegations would constitute an act
amounting to disturbance of public order.
14.
It is trite position of law that if ordinary law of land is competent to deal
with criminal activities of an offender, resort to the provisions of
preventive detention laws are illegal, because the expressions “Public
Order” and “Law and Order”, operate in different fields and have different
connotations. If an act has the potentiality to disturb public order, public at
large is affected by said criminal activity, whereas, a particular criminal
activity of a person shall be prejudicial to a particular individual or a
member or members of society. In other words, breach of law by an
individual by indulging in a criminal activity or in contravention of the
provisions of a particular statute, may tantamount to a law and order
problem, but it cannot be termed as disturbance of public order.
15.
The detenue in the present case is alleged to be involved in two criminal
cases regarding felling of trees and smuggling of timber. In both the cases,
final reports stand submitted in the competent Courts. There is nothing in
the record to suggest that whether petitioner at any point of time was
arrested or not. There is nothing in the record either to suggest that
ordinary law of land is not competent to deal with the law and order
problem alleged to have been created by the petitioner.
16.
Be that as it may, allegations contained in the grounds of detention,
certainly do not fall within the category of ‘public order’. The
allegations/contentions of the respondents that detenue is a chronic and
habitual forest offender and indulges in timber smuggling are too vague in
Page No.6
HCP No.82/2025
nature and do not satisfy the requirements envisaged under Section 8 of
PSA.
17.
Mr. Sanchit Verma, learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently
argued that delay in disposal of the representation submitted by the
petitioner is violative of Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India.
18.
It is settled proposition of law that in cases of preventive detention,
appropriate Government is obliged not only to afford the detenue an
opportunity to make effective representation, but also consider the same
without unreasonable delay because it involves the liberty of a citizen
guaranteed by Article 19 of the Constitution of India. It has been so held in
a long line of decisions rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court from time to
time that unreasonable delay in consideration of representation submitted
by a detenue amounts to infringement of Article 22(5) of the Constitution
of India.
19.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in K.M. Abdulla Kunhi (Supra) held that though
there can be no hard and fast rule regarding the timeline within which a
representation is required to be considered by the Government and there is
no limitation provided under the Constitution or under PSA within which a
representation is required to be considered and decided by the Government,
however, it is manifest from the words “as soon as may be”, occurring in
Clause (5) of Article 22 of the Constitution that unexplained delay in
disposal of representation would amount to infringement of Article 22(5)
of the Constitution of India. Relevant excerpt of the judgment for the ease
of reference is extracted below:
“…..5(a) The representation relates to the liberty of the
individual, the highly cherished right enshrined in
Article 21 of our Constitution. Clause (5) of Article 22
therefore, casts a legal obligation on the Government to
Page No.7
HCP No.82/2025
consider the representation as early as possible. It is a
constitutional mandate commanding the concerned
authority to whom the detenue submits his presentation
to consider the representation and dispose of the same as
expeditiously as possible.
5(b) The words “as soon as may be” occurring in clause
(5) of Article 22 reflect the concern of the Framers that
the presentation should be expeditiously considered and
disposed of with a sense of urgency without an avoidable
delay. However, there can be no hard and fast rule in this
regard. It depends upon the fact and circumstances of
each case. There is no period prescribed either under the
Constitution or under the concerned detention law,
within which the representation should be dealt with the
requirement however, is that there should not be supine
indifference slackness or callous attitude in considering
the representation. Any unexplained delay in the disposal
of the representation would be a breach of the
constitutional imperative and it would render the
continued detention impermissible and illegal…..”
20.
A similar observation has been made by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Dr.
Rahamatullah (Supra) and Vijay Kumar(Supra), which came to be
followed by this Court in Hasham Din.
21.
In the present case, representation dated 22.05.2025, preferred by the
petitioner came to be received by the detaining authority-respondent No.2
on 29.05.2025 and as per the record, said representation came to be decided
on 16.07.2025 by the Departmentof Home, i.e. after 45 days. Respondents
have not offered any explanation for such inordinate delay on their part to
consider representation of the petitioner, which is violative of fundamental
right of the detenue/petitioner within the meaning of Article 22(5) of
Constitution of India.
Page No.8
HCP No.82/2025
22.
Viewed from any angle, impugned detention order does not sustain in the
eyes of law. Hence, present petition is allowed and impugned order is
quashed. The petitioner/detenue is directed to be released forthwith from
detention, provided he is not involved in any other case or offence. Record
is returned to learned Govt. counsel in the open Court.
23.
Disposed of.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
Jammu
05.02.2026
Eva
Whether the judgment is speaking or not?
Whether the judgment is reportable or not?
Yes
Yes
Page No.9
HCP No.82/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review