Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/6
GAHC010179872023
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP/16/2024
BIDHAN HARLALKA
PROPRIETOR OF M/S UJALA, S.S. ROAD, FANCY BAZAR, GUWAHATI781001, DIST. KAMRUP(M), ASSAM
VERSUS
SARLA HARLALKA AND 2 ORS
W/O- SRI PAWAN KUMAR HARLALKA, R/O- KRISHNA KUNJ, A.M. ROAD,
SUHAGPUR, MANIPURI BASTI, NEAR ARYA HOSPITAL, PALTANBAZAR,
GHY-781001, DIST. KAMRUP(M), ASSAM
2:PAWAN KUMAR HARLALKA
PROPRIETOR OF M/S B.P. STORE
C/O- M/S B P STORE
S.S. ROAD
FANCY BAZAR
GHY-781001
DIST. KAMRUP(M)
ASSAM
3:VISHWANATH GOENKA
S/O- LATE RADHA MOHAN GOENKA
C/O- VISHWARATAN HOTEL
A.T. ROAD
P..S PALTANBAZAR
GHY-781001
DIST. KAMRUP(M)
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. M AGARWALLA, MS P GOGOI
Advocate for the Respondent : MR B SHARMA (r-1,2,3), MR. M HASSAN (R-3),MR S SHARMA
Page No.# 2/6
(r-1,2)
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
09.03.2026
Heard Mr. M. Agarwalla, learned counsel for the petitioner and also heard Mr. B.
Sharma, learned counsel for the respondents.
2.
In this petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner has
challenged the order dated 25.05.2023 passed by the learned Munsiff No.4, Kamrup(M),
Guwahati, in Misc.(J) Case No.511/2022, arising out of Title Suit No.14/2022. It is to be
noted here that vide impugned order dated 25.05.2023, the learned Munsiff No.4,
Kamrup(M), Guwahati, has dismissed the Petition No.1511/2022 filed by the petitioner
under Section 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for stay of the Title Suit
No.14/2022.
3.
Mr. Agarwalla, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner herein
has instituted one title suit, being Title Suit No.293/2021 praying for cancellation of sale
deed dated 20.09.2020, which was executed by the proforma defendant No.2, namely,
Shri Viswanath Goenka in favour of the plaintiff, namely, Smt. Sarla Harlalka in respect of
Schedule 'A' property and after institution of the said title suit, the respondents herein
have filed another title suit, being Title Suit No.14/2022, which is pending before the
Court of learned Munsiff No.4, Kamrup(M) at Guwahati, for ejectment and arrear rent and
the parties involved in both the suits are same and it relates also to the same property
and as such, under Section 10 of the CPC, the subsequent suit has to be stayed and
accordingly, the petitioner herein has filed one petition, being Petition No.1511/2022
before the Court of learned Munsiff No.4, Kamrup(M), Guwahati, but the same was
dismissed vide impugned order dated 25.05.2023. According to Mr. Agarwalla, the
Page No.# 3/6
impugned order is illegal and arbitrary and the learned Trial Court has erroneously
dismissed the petition and on such count, he has contended to allow this petition by
setting aside the impugned order. In support of his submission, Mr. Agarwalla has also
referred to a decision of a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Subho Ram Kalita
(Deceased by LRs) & Ors. v. Dharmeswar Das Koch & Ors., reported in AIR 1987
Gau 73.
4.
Per contra, Mr. Sharma, learned counsel for the respondents submits that though
the Title Suit No.293/2021 and the Title Suit No.14/2022 are between the same parties,
yet, the subject-matters of both the suits are different. He submits that in Title Suit
No.293/2021, the subject-matter is for cancellation of sale deed dated 20.09.2020,
whereas the subject-matter of Title Suit No.14/2022, which was filed by the respondents
herein, is for ejectment and recovery of arrear rent and referring to a decision of a
Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Biswanath Paul v. Ahibhusan
Chakraborty, reported in 2018 (2) GLT 976, he submits that the aforementioned
decision of the Coordinate Bench of this Court squarely covers the case of the present
petitioner and since the subject-matter of both the suits are different, the provision of
Section 10 of the CPC cannot be invoked.
5.
Having heard the submission of learned counsel for both the parties, this Court has
carefully gone through the petition and the documents placed on record and also perused
the impugned order dated 25.05.2023.
6.
It appears that the learned Trial Court has dismissed the petition under Section 10
of the CPC, being Petition No.1511/2022, filed by the present petitioner on the ground
that the subject-matter of two proceedings are entirely distinct and different and one suit
is related to validity of termination of tenancy and payment of arrear rent and the other
suit is for declaration of title and as such, in both the circumstances, the suits are not
substantially identical and as such, Section 10 of the CPC does not attract at all for
staying proceeding of the present suit and thereafter, dismissed the same.
7.
While the impugned order passed by the learned Trial Court is examined in the light
Page No.# 4/6
of the given facts and circumstances on the record and also in view of the proposition of
law, this Court is of the view that the impugned order, so passed by the learned Trial
Court rejecting the application under Section 10 of the CPC is based on sound principle of
law.
8.
It is not in dispute that the subject-matter in both the suits are different, while in
the Title Suit No.293/2021 the subject-matter is for cancellation of the sale deed dated
20.09.2020 and the subject-matter of Title Suit No.14/2022 is completely different, which
is in relation to ejectment and recovery of arrear rent.
9.
It is to be noted here that Section 10 of the CPC deals with stay of suit, which read
as under:“No Court shall proceed with the trial of any suit in which the
matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a
previously instituted suit between the same parties, or between
parties under whom they or any of them claim litigating under the
same title where such suit is pending in the same or any other
Court in India have jurisdiction to grant the relief claimed, or in
any Court beyond the limits of India established or continued by
the Central Government and having like jurisdiction, or before the
Supreme Court.
Explanation.--The pendency of a suit in a foreign Court does not
preclude the Courts in India from trying a suit founded on the same
cause of action.”
10.
Thus, from a perusal of Section 10 of the CPC, it appears that three key test are
required to be satisfied with for invoking the provision of Section 10 are as follows:
11.
(i)
Identity of the parties.
(ii)
Identity of matter in issue.
(iii)
Previously instituted suit.
The phrase – ‘matter in issue is directly and substantially in issue’ has been dealt
with by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Aspi
Jal
&
Anr.
vs.
Khushroo
R.
Page No.# 5/6
Dadyburjor, reported in (2013) 4 SCC 333, wherein it has been clarified that identity
of the matter in issue is determined by applying the test of whether a final decision in the
earlier suit would operate as res judicata in the later suit. In holding so, Hon’ble Supreme
Court has drawn premises from its earlier decision in National Institute of Mental
Health & Neuro Sciences vs. C. Parameshwara, reported in (2005) 2 SCC 256, in
which it has been held as follows: (SCC pp. 259-60, para 8)
“8. The object underlying Section 10 is to prevent courts of
concurrent jurisdiction from simultaneously trying two parallel
suits in respect of the same matter in issue. The object underlying
Section 10 is to avoid two parallel trials on the same issue by two
courts and to avoid recording of conflicting findings on issues
which are directly and substantially in issue in previously
instituted suit. The language of Section 10 suggests that it is
referable to a suit instituted in the civil court and it cannot
apply to proceedings of other nature instituted under any other
statute. The object of Section 10 is to prevent courts of
concurrent jurisdiction from simultaneously trying two parallel
suits between the same parties in respect of the same matter in
issue. The fundamental test to attract Section 10 is, whether on
final decision being reached in the previous suit, such decision
would operate as res judicata in the subsequent suit. Section 10
applies only in cases where the whole of the subject-matter in both
the suits is identical. The key words in Section 10 are ‘the matter
in issue is directly and substantially in issue’ in the previous
instituted suit. The words ‘directly and substantially in issue’
are used in Page No.# 7/8 contradistinction to the words
‘incidentally or collaterally in issue’. Therefore, Section 10
would apply only if there is identity of the matter in issue in
both the suits, meaning thereby, that the whole of the subjectmatter in both the proceedings is identical.”
12.
In the case in hand, though the parties are identical and the properties involved are
also identical, yet, the subject-matter and the cause of action in both the suits are
different and applying the test laid down in the case of Aspi Jal (supra), this Court is
of the view that the decision in the Title Suit No.293/2021 would not operate as a res
Page No.# 6/6
judicata in case of the Title Suit No.14/2022, as the cause of action and the subjectmatter are entirely different in both the suits.
13.
This Court has considered the submission of learned counsel for both the parties
and also gone through the case laws, and finds sufficient force in the submission of Mr.
Sharma, learned counsel for the respondents and the decision in Biswanath Paul
(supra) fortified his submission. On the other hand, this Court finds the submission of
Mr. Agarwalla, learned counsel for the petitioner, devoid of merit and the decision referred
by him would not advance his argument in view of the discussion and finding recorded
herein above.
14.
Thus, the impugned order dated 25.05.2023 rejecting the Petition No.1511/2022
under Section 10 of the CPC filed by the present petitioner cannot be said to be suffered
from any perversity requiring any interference of this Court and accordingly, this revision
petition stands dismissed, leaving the parties to bear their own cost.
Sd/- Robin Phukan
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review