Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132521
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 25101 OF 2021
Between:
Bhukya Ramja, S/o B.Golya, aged about 46 years, Working as Temporary
Sweeper, Panchayat Schools, Rampuram, lrilothey Mandal, Suryapet District,
Telangana State.
...PETITIONER
AND
The State of Telangana, rep by its Principal Secretary, Panchayathral
Department, Telangana Secretanat, Hyderabad.
The Commissioner of Panchayathraj and Rural Employment, Govt. of
Telangana, Urdu Galli, Himayathnagar, Hyderabad
The Zilla Prala Parishad, Suryapet District, Telangana State. Represented by
rts Chref Executive Officer.
The Mandal Parishad Development Officer, Mothey, Suryapet District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arttcle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that rn the
crrcumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus to direct the respondent herein to convert the full contingent
appointment of petitioner made temporarily on compassionate grounds by 4th
Respondent in Proc No. E|125193 dated 30/08/1993 by regularizing his servrces
in last grade post as per G.O.Ms.No.687 (GAD), daled.O311011977, and
G O.Ms.No 661(GAD), dated 2311012008 with effect from 01/09/1993 to till date
with all consequential monetary benefits, including seniority and arrears of pay in
the last grade post for 27 long years from time to time with 100 70 compensation
by applying principle laid by Apex Court in the case of Union of lndia Vs. Avtar
Chand in Civil Appeal No. 3416-3445 of 201 0, dl. 191 0212019, under Article-1 41
of our constitution by this Honourable court for wrongly treating the Petitioner as
part time employee, contrary to appointment order of temporary sweeper by
wrongly paying part time wages to the Petitioner in violation of Minimum Wages
Act 1948 and Equal Remuneration Act 1 976 by subjecting the petitioner to
exploitative enslavement due to his helpless conditions of poverty, poor social,
financial, political backgrourd in denying his legitimate t.' r 1r:s f rom 27 long years
and also award costs of tho case.
lA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Sectron 151 CPC praying that in tn' ( rcumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in suppcrt of the petition, the High (), r rt rnay be pleased to
direct the 1st Responcext herein lo convert the serI;:s ;'endered by the
petitioner in Lhe post of rernporary sweeper in the 5l l-:spondent controlled
school by regularizing his services nto last grade post rr I e e)(;sting vacancy as
per G.O.Ms.No.68/, dated 03110 1977 forthwith with fi.rl r direction to continue
to pay the last grade time scale benefits along with oe 'r:lical increments from
time to time to the pet tloner as paid to his colleagur' ull lime sweepers of
panchayat schools
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI CH. GANESH
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 & 2: ASST. GP FOR Pl I CHAYAT RAJ &
RURAL DEVELOPI\ ENT
Counsel for the Respondent No.3 & 4: SRI PRADEEP RE I )Y KATTA
The Court made the following: ORDER
l
SN, J
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRI T PETITION N 0.25101 0F 202t
ORDER
Heard Sri CH.Ganesh, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner, learned Assistant Government
Pleader for Services-II appearing on behalf of the
respondent Nos.1 & 2 and Sri pradeep Reddy Katta,
learned standing counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent Nos.3 & 4.
Th e D etitio n er a DD roached th e Court seekino oraver
as under:
"...to issue an order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of Writ of Mandamus to direct the respondent
herein to convert the full contingent appointment of
. petitioner made temporarily on compassionate grounds
by 4th Respondent in proc No.E/125193 dated
30/08/1993 by regularizing his services in last grade
post as per G.O.14s.No.687 (GAD), dated 03/tO/1977
and G.O.Ms.No. 661(GAD), dated 23l10/2008 with
effect from OL/09/1.993 to till date with all consequential
monetary beneFits including seniority and arrears of pay
in the last grade post for 27 long years from time to
time with 100 o/o compensation by applying principle laid
by Apex Court in the case of Union of India Vs Avtar
Chand in Civil Appeal No. 3476-3445 of
2OtO,
dL 19/ 02/2019 under Article-141 of our constitution by
this Honourable court for wrongly treating the petitioner
as part time employee contrary to appointment order of
temporary sweeper by wrongly paying part time wages
io the Petitioner in violation of Minimum Wages Act 1948
and Equal Remuneration Act 1976 by subjecting the
petitioner to exploitative enslavement due to his helpless
)
SN- J
conditions of poverty, poor, social, finan: al, political
background in denying his legitimate wa(l )s from 27
long years and also award costs of the cas(r . rd pass" "
Lea rn ed
counsel
ADDCA
rino on
bt half
mad e in the
oeti ioner ola cino reli ance on th e averm ent
affid avit file dinsu
Dort of the ores ent wri t oetition
rnD articular,
p e rta in inq
of the
to
the services re nde r
b
peti t ioner with th e resD ondents herein fot more than a
de
de contends that the p etitio n er is err:itled for the
rel
fasp raved for in the pres ent writ Detiti (n.
PERU ED TH
ECORD
DISCUSSION AND C ONCLUSION:-
4.
Learned
pet t
s
c ounsel ap Deaflnq
on
lr :half
of the
its that the subiect rssue ir the Dresent
case i s souar elv covere dbvth e order of th I ; Cou rt dated
o8.09. 2010
assed in W .P.No. 24377
f2a I 7 teoorted in
!V.A.N .782 o
2011( 1) ALD, Paqe 234 as co nfirmed in
2O10, dated 10.06.2 o13
Da ssed
nd als o orde r, da t :d 19.O 9.20t7
in W. P.No.272 L7 of 2OL7 re Dort edi
Paqe 282 and al so the order, d ated 2 .o4.
T
20 18 (2) ALD
o20 p assed in
W.P.No.2305 7ol 20 19 re oorted in 2020 4 ),TLDPA oe 379.
SN. ]
5.
Learned sta dino couns el aoo earinq on behalf of the
re s D ond e nt
No.3 s ubmits th at the or ievance of the
Detit ioner as out-f orth in the oresent Wri t Petition h d not
bee n address ed to the r es D o n dent s herein as o n date and
t h erefore. the oetitio ner cannot comD lain inactaon o n the
part of resoondents h erein in co nsiderinq the q rievance of
t he etitioner and hence, the relief as o raved for b v the
petiti ner in the present Wit oetition c nnot be oranted
and no Mandam us can be issu ed aqainst the resoon dents
her e under as sou o h t
for and the n eti t oner ma v tre
dire ted to DU t-forth the oetitio ner s qrr vance as Dutfo rt hintheo
resen t Writ Petit ion bv wav ofade ailed
reD resen tat ion to
the resoo nde nts herein and uDon
rece ro tofth e said reo resen tation, the reso ondents
con sider th e same
tn ac
rda n ce
to
ould
law, within
a
reas onable oe riod.
6. Lear ned co unsel ao Deaflno o n behalf of the pet itioner
doe s not dis ute the said su mlssr on made b the lea ned
sta dino co unsel aD Deaflno on beh alf of th
No.3.
res Don dent
s\.
7. The Aoex Court in th e iud qmen t reDort€ ( tn
SCC
L&
in Prem
ln
vS teofU
I
ar Prade sh and
oth er s, at Dara 3 6 hel da s under:
"36. There are some of the employees who ha I n.)[ been
for- 3Ctregularized in spite of having rendered the ser :es
( rannuatcd,
slp
been
have
4dor more years whereas they
As they have worked in the work-charged es I rtrlishment,
any particular project, their serir s oLrght to
not agalrst
-been
regularized under the Governmer'" r stru ctio n,lfs
have
and even as per the decision of this Court r State
sa id
Karnataka versus Umadevi (3)11 This Cou i n t re
bec n
decision f'as laid down that in case scrv' -' lravc
the
rof
ve
c,
?
rendered for more than ten years without th
tle
ces
Court's order, as one-time measure, the ( €,TV
regularized of such employees' In the fac::l f the case,
mOTe
th6se employees who have worked for ten / l rTSproT
to
oPer
r
should have been regularized lt would not (
e rs
regulate them for consideration of regularlzat n as oth
3e
i
services
the
that
ha-ve been regularized, we direct
that
:
clear
:
treated as a reg ular one. However, it is ma
n ce
they shall not be entitled to claiming anY dues ;f d iffere rlY
r
cgula
:e
se
in
ln wages had t hey been continued
be
before attaining the age of suPerannuation i rey shail
as if theY r rve retired
e ntitled to rece ive the Pension
ti
I e servl es
t t' ev entered
( I counted as
i
The Ape xCo urt i n the case o f Dharw; I , Distr ict PWD
S tate of
Literate D a ilv Waqe EmD lovees Associati n Vs.
e c 6l aid orin cl le
c
9 2
Kar t ka re rte
I
t hat the Stat e sho ul dnotk ee oap e rson ! ! temoorarv or
havr: to treat such
e iod an
f lo
rvl
adhoc
oers on sasre qul aro e.
SN-. J
9.
Para No.53 of the of the iud qmen t of the Aoe x Cou rt
n the State of Karnataka and others Vs . Umadevi, dated
10.04.2006 reDorted in (2006) 4 SCC 1 is extra cted
hereu nder:-
"53. O ne aspect ne eds to be clarified. The re mav be
cases where irreqular appointments (not illeqal
as exolai ned in S.V Naravan ADDA
7 1
R12
R.N. Nan nda a 1972 1
scc 4O9l and B.N. Nao araian I197 9 (4) SCC 5071
and referred to in oar a 15 abov e of dulv o ualified
on
san ioned v
t osts
hth
enm
and h em
have c
inued t
work for ten ve rs or m ore bu t thout t h e
tn tervention of orders of the courts or of trib nals.
ADDOI ntments)
The uestion of r eq u la riza ion of the services o f such
emDl ovees mav have to b e conside red on meri ts in
the liqht of the o rincio les settled bv this Court i n the
cases a bovereferred to and in th e liqht of this
iudom ent. In th at context, the Uni n of India , the
State Governm ents and their instrumentali ties
should take s teDs to req u la rize as a one- time
measure, the s rvices of s uch irreou larlv aooo inted,
who have wo rked for ten vear s or more in dulv
sa nc oned Dosts bu tn of under co ver of ord ers of the
cou sorof ribun a ls and sho ld furthe re nsure that
reoul rr ec r uit en tsa re un de rta ken t ofi ll th ose
vaca nt sancti oned oo ts that requ ire to be filled UD,
tn ca ses whe re temoo rarv emD loyees or dailv waqers
are eino no emolov ed, The D rocess must be set in
mo tion wit hin six mon ths from this d ate.....
10. The iudome nt of th eAp ex Court date d 20. t2.2024,
in 2()24 wS uit ( SC) 12O9 in Jaq o Anita and
ot hers v. Uni n of India a nd others, and the re levant
r e D rted
g
S\I
pa raq ra ph N os.12, L3, 24, 26, 27 and 28 ere extra
hereunder:
"12. Despite being labelled as "pat'l -time
ese
workers,'i the appellants performed th
essential tasks on a daily and conti tuous
basis over extensive periods, rangin(, from
over a decade to nearly two decades' Their
engagement was not sporadic or te n'' l ora ry
in nature, instead, it was recurrent, r' gular,
and akin to the responsibilitiesMot)'lr rically
)ove r,
associated with sanctioned posts'
er
the respondents did not engage any oththe
personnel for these tasks durinl
the
appellants tenure, underscoring
work'
indispensable nature of their
Th ecl aim bv the reso onden t i that
la ksm I rit, as
o
la
r
n
we
,v the
the na ture of the work oerfo rmed
er nnl lan fu amr: rtal to
etl nts wa
a
he rt cu rring
al
their
ES
nature of these d uties
how
of
c lassification as regular posts, irrespectivo
is a lso
th eir initial engagements were labelled lt(
F
these
notewo rthY that subsequent outsourcinq
the
same task s to Private agencies alt )i
appellants't ermination demonstrates the rherent
need for th ese services. This act of out; )urcing,
with
which effectivelY reP laced one set of wor t :rs
'rcrk
in
another further und erscores that the (
question was neither temporary nor occas na
13.
hes
Unii :d State
24. The landmark judgment of the
Corporz :ion [97
in the case of Vizcaino v Microsoft
F.3d 1187 (9th Cir. 1996)l serves as a r e rtinent
the
example from the private sector, illustr3 .ing
consequences of misclassifying emplrr ees to
CASC,
.i.iumuent providing benefits ln tl ;pendent
Microsoft classified certain workers as inct
j
ed
I()
SN. J
contractors, thereby denying them employee
benefits. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth
Circuit determined that these workers were, in
fact, common-law employees and were entitled to
the same benefits as regular employees. The Court
noted that large Corporations have increasingly
adopted the practice of hiring temporary
employees or independent contractors as a means
of avoiding payment of employee benefits, thereby
increasing their profits, This judgment underscores
the principle that the nature ot the work
performed, rather than the label assigned to the
worker, should determine employment status and
the corresponding rights and beneFits. It
hioh qhts the i ud icia rv's role in rec ifvinq
suc hmi scla sific at o s and ensurin o tha t
workers rec eive fa ir treat ment.
26.
While the judgment in Uma Devi (supra)
sought to curtail the practice of backdoor entries
and ensure appointments adhered to constitutional
principles, it is regrettable that its prin ciples
are
often misinterpreted or misa pplied to deny
Iegitimate claims of Ion g serving employees.
This
judgment aimed to di stinguish
between "illega l"
appointments.
I
t a
m I e s
e
a
t ents h w re n e tnn
sa
ha
nti U u
rm r th n n ear s horved
td
eco sr ered
artza ron a aon
time measure. However, the Iauda ble
intent of
the judgment is being subverted
whe n institutions
rely on its dict a io indiscriminatel y
reject the
claims of emplo yees, even in
appointments are not illega cases where th etr
l, but merel y lack
adherence to procedural formalities.
departments o ften cite th judgment Gove rnment
e
in Uma Devl
( supra) to argue
that no vested right
to
regul a rization exi sts for
t
emporary
ployees,
em
overlooking
the
judgment,s
and
t
"irregular"
or ca
hel
rr
acknowledgment of cases
explicit
where reg ula riz a tion is
1l
I torts
appropriate.
:_ ively
o
s
e
d
h
,wea oonl lno I t aoa nst e olov ees whc have
ove r
servt ce
ns ble
indi
re ndered
de ca d es.
27.
o1-rr
In light of these considerations' ir Iment
gov(rr
opinlon, it is imperative for providir;
iLpuit*.ntt to lead by example in worker: onfaira
ana staOf. employment Engaging
espt ciallv
i.rnpli-iv basis for extended periods'
the organiz:.ion s
*il'.l-il.1r- roles are integral to
intern: ional
i..iii".i.g, not only c-ontravenes
'
i-o"rt t,.'"i.rds but also exposes the orga"
'tion
lyee
emg't
undermines
and
challenges
iegar
to
nent
morale. By ensuring fSit-.. tT-p]lv
n.::.-' Ti
a.t i c
.
o' l:,.:::tJ:}}' :-ll;r,,,'"';
burden
the
reduce
p,.
",,
**$*i#':'
,i r;t
private seci:r tr to
oositive precedent toi-tn" to
lhe o1 lrall
iollow, therebv t"nitioulinL
bettermentoflabourpiacticesinthecollltry.
2a. thern vi11 ,1rj['.i:i::
ii'J:il?l,i::
ult. "::]::";^.r
*," r
the
appeals
'' I
and
' iunal
bY the Hioh court
is al owed
;i;i;"i;pt'rcation
t""
and
are set aside
findinqs,
:;;";;.;t;d
io the following extenr:
Jated
orders
i' The termination
quashed;
27 'lO '7OlB are
e aken
ll.
their
t wjth.
b
I
t
I
{
rt be
c t nia rv
I eriod
l vedd
t2
5N. .i
be entitl dto conti n u itv of se rvices
aid
erio
and the
me
ould be oun
for their o
re iral b en efits."
f r the
11. The Judom ent of he Aoe x Cou rt date d 31.O L.202s
f
in2
o
5IN
"sH IPAL AND AN THER v
NAGAR NI GAM, GHAZIAB AD", in oar tic ular, the relevant
oar a Nos.1 5to1 9aree xtract ed here under:
"15. It is manifest tha t the Aooella nt Wo rkmen
con tinuous v rend ered their s ervt ces over severa
r
s
e
sspannrnq more than a deca de.
E
en if erta in
us
na
e. Morall
an
ere n
rod ed in full
h
Em o er' fail
to urnish such recor
es
dir tion to
s
llow an
vers
tn ren
der
w l-es
is he
our
lufl prudence, Indian labour law stronq lv disfa vors
Der pe tual dailv- waoe o r contr actua I enoao ement sin
cl
s
ces wher th work is
man nt in
rol ls
rker who fu lfi I
onqoino munici Dal re outre ents vear fter v ear
cannot be dismi sed s mmari lv as d isoe n sa ble.
DA rticula rlv in t he abs ence o faq enu rne co ntractor
aq reeme nt. At th is ju ncture, it would be appropriate to
recall the broader critique oF indefin ite "temporary,,
employment practices as done by a recent judgement oF
this court in Jaggo v. Union of India in the following
paragraphs:
le
l3
SN. ]
"22. The pervasive misuse of tempore t 7 emploYment
a
contracts, as exemplified in this c a ;e, reflects
broader sYstemic issue that ad" :rsely a ffects
workers' rights and job security l r the Private
an
secior, the rise of the gig economi" ras led to
ngements,
increase in preca rious employment l rra
job
secu ritY,
often characrerized by lack of benefi ,
and fair treatment. Such Practic: ; have been
criticized for exploiting workers arr undermining
-r
entrusted
labour standards. Government institut ons, j
with upholding the principles of fairne ;s and u stice,
such
bear an even greater responsibility to avoid
exploitative employment practices When Public
sector entities engage in misuse of temPorarY
trends
contracts, it not only mirrors the det imental
a
observed in the gig economY btl a lso sets
in
trust
concerning precedent that can erode ; ublic
governmental oPerations'
realitY hat temPorarY
is. it it a disconcertinggovernntt
nt institut!ons,
employees, pa rticularly in
While
oFten face multifaceted forms of e> loitation.
maY
i
the foundational purpose of temporar contracts
needs,
have been to address short-term or ;easonal
lo
they have increasingly become a me r nanism
obligations
sci onLlne SC 3826 evade long-t( rrm
in
owed to emPloYees. These Pract 3s maniFest
several waYs:
lovees
o Mis use of "Tem oo rarv" Lab c s Empurrln
o.
for w rk h ts ss ! :ia re
en a
ion
n
I anl nstit
s mDo ra
ontr ctual
CV
n
h n
e i.
rv
or
ro les mirro r
Such
vees
lar
fre
r of th
miscl ssif icati on de nv s w )
ha r ula
b ne it !
n
s c
di nt
m inq
emplo vees ar een title dt o, des ite oerfor
th se
.!
T
identical tasks.
are
. Arbitrary Termination: Tempora -( employees
as seen
frequently dismissed without cause r notice'
l4
SN, J
in the present case. This practice undermines the
principles of natural justice and subjects workers to a
state of constant insecurity, regardless of the quality
or duration of their service. . Lack oF Career
Progression: Temporary employees often find
themselves excluded from opportunities for skill
development, promotions, or incremental pay raises.
They remain stagnant in their roles, creating a
systemic disparity between them and their regular
counterparts, despite their contributions being
equally sig n iFicant.
.
Using Outsourcing as a Shield: Institutions
increasingly resort to outsourcing roles performed by
temporary employees, effectively replacing one set
of exploited workers with another. This practice not
only perpetuates exploitation but also demonstrates
a deliberate effort to bypass the obligation to offer
regular employment.
. Denial of Basic Rights and Benefits: Temporary
employees are often denied fundamental benefrts
such as pension, provident fund, health insurance,
and paid leave, even when their tenure spans
decades. This lack of social security subjects them
and their families to undue hardship, especially in
cases of illness, retirement, or
unforeseen
circumstances. "
16. The High Court did acknowledge the Employer,s
inability to justify these abrupt terminations. Consequently,
it ordered re-engagement on daily wages with some
measure of parity in minimum pay. Regrettably, this only
perpetuated precariousness: the Appellant Workmen were
left in a marginally improved yet still uncertain status.
While the High Court recognized the importance of their
work and hinted at eventual regularization, it failed to
afford them continuity of service or meaningful back wages
i5
SN ,I
commensurate wlth the degree of stat ltory violation
evide n t on record.
t7, In light of these considerations, 1e Employer's
discontinuation of the Appellant Work- en stands in
violation of the most basic labour law prin: prles Once it is
established that their services were terr inated without
adhering to Sections 6E and 6N of th< U'P' Industrial
Disputes Acl, 7947, and that thev we I len a e IN
be
esse n tial. D e rennial dut ies, the se wor I ers canno
tl hile conc rns
al ncer int
rele a ed to er
cont rlia e with
and
bud qet
m unicipal
of
recru it ment ru les merit co n ideratio n such con c rns
do not a bsolve the Emplo ve r of statul :t,rv oblioations
In deed
entitlemt: tts
o u itab le
neq a tee
or
crat limi ion s ann tru I the leqitimate
bu re
riq h ts of work m enw o hav e serv ed ! n rnu sl tn
de facto reqular roles for an extended- leriod'
18. The imouqned o rder o f the Hiql' Cou to
w I <men to future
nt h co fine heA ell
e
o
da ly -waqe enqa qe ment without c nti
m a ntnq ful ba ck waqes rs herebv se t aside with the
followin q d irectio ns:
I. The discontinuation of the APPt la nt Workmen's
6E
services, effected without complian : ) with Section
and Section 6N of the U.P. Indusr al Disputes Act,
,ll orders or
7947, is declared illega I'
' services are
com m unlcations terminating thr:
quashed. In consequence, the Ar) rella nt Workmen
shall be treated as continuing in ;ervice from the
t
t6
\\. J
date of their termination, for all purposes, including
seniority and continuity in service.
II. The Respondent Employer shall reinstate the
Appellant Workmen in their respective posts (or
posts akin to the duties they previousl y performed
within four weeks from the date of t his judgment.)
Their en lre De riod o f abse nce (f rom th e date of
ermt ation ntil
ual r insta
en
shall e
co u nte d for conti nuitv ofs rvtce and all
con seo u entia I bene f its. s uch as senioritv a nd
eliqibilitv forp rom otions, if a nv.
III. Considering the length of service, the Appellant
Workmen shall be entitled to 50o/o of the back wdges
from the date of their discontinuation until their
actual reinstatement. The Respondent Employer shall
clear the aforesaid dues within three months from
the date of their reinstatement.
IV. The ResD ond ent Emo lover ts directed t o
initiate a fa ir and tra nspa re nt oro cess for
req ularizi
the Appella nt Wo rkmen within six
mo n ths fr om the da te of reins tate ment, dulv
co n sideri nqt he fact t hat thev have o erf ormed
perennia! muni cl pal dutae sa in to oer m anent
DO sts. In
ssess tnq
reo u la rt zation,
the
Emolover shall not imo ose ed uca ional or
Dro c edural cr iteria
retr oa ctivelv af such
re u tremen ts were never aD plied to the
Ao el la nt Workmen or to similarlv situa ted
re ul ar emD lovees in the past. To th e exten t
ha
n
edv an
for ch uti ext t
o r are reouir ed. t eRe oond en t Emo love r shall
ex edit all neces arv adm inistra tive D roce sses
o n re hes lon
e
s ren t
ind efinit lv retained on da ilv wa qes co ntra r to
statuto rva nd equatabl
or
t]
SN, J
19. In view of the above, the appeal(s)
workmen are allowed, whereas the appeal
Nagar Nigam Ghaziabad are dismissed
u
reme C ur
Sin h and other
J
Ca ses 14
:) filed by the
"
The Aoex C our t in a lu dqme n tre oor
t2.
filed by the
te ( tn (20 17) 1
inS te of un ? r and ot he rs
at Pa
s
nd ts sub -oa ras
of the said ud m nt obs rV ed as l nder:
adjudicating
"54 "fhe Full Bench of the High Cour!' '" t"l,e temporary
.thaL
uDon Lhe above controversy had concludeo
( t'rc regular paY^^^t^,,^^c tAtara nnt entitted to the minimum |
activiLi' s carried on bY
Z';:,::,';7,;;; i",'"t'n.' '""'Li, thar rhe
rutt bench
were simt
1;i;'-*'",;";; ,id resutar
:' l:t
"ipto've"s
however,madetwoexceptions'.Temporaryer-lli-oy'ees,vlhofell
were held ent 'led to wages at
in either of the two """ition''drawn
by regul't emploYees' The
the minimum of the paY-;;;le
'"'*"iii,iiJ ,"r"i"a'oi tii iuit aen'n'of ine r iqh court in the
iip,uqnea juaqment are extracted hereunder:'
aPPointee
"(1) A dailY wager, ad hoc or con' rctual
appointed after
posts
)iainst the regular sanctioned
fairness and
,'ni"iqoinq a ietection process based c t )on candidates,
Zoiutiv if opportunity to all other lible
siatt Oe entitted to minimum of the
the date of enqagement
tr pay scale from
rea
nt ctu al
o
qa rns t re tu r
.l
:_
t)
s
av I
t , bv the State
for a sufficient
i
r
lai lv
r
qe rs,
d
I !- be entitled to
! le wit ou a
that wo rk of
I
f
I ! vi ct wo rked for
ble riqht TS
e ! ut
'heir
cla tm for
I t .T,
IE
SN. J
reoularization, if anv, ma v have to be considered
ratel in terms of le I
(3) In the event, a claim is made for minimum pay scale
after more than three years and two months of
completion of 10 years of continuous working, a daily
wager, ad hoc or contractual employee shall be entitled to
arrears for a perrod of three years and two months."
13. The iudqment of the Ape x Court reDorted in 2O10(9)
SCC 2 4 7 belween: state of Karnataka and ot h e r s
M.L.Kesari and others, in oarticul ar. Daras 4 to 10 reads as
u nde
r:
4. The decision in State of Karnataka v. Umadevi was rendered
on 10.4.2006 (re Dorted in 2006 (4) SCC 1 In that case a
Constitution Bench of this Court held that appointments made
without following the due process or the rules relating to
appointment did not confer any right on the appointees and
courts cannot direct their absorption, regularization or re'
engagement nor make their service permanent, and the High
Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution should not ordinarily issue directions for absorptron,
regularization, or permanent continuance unless the recruitment
had been done in a regular mannea in terms of the
constitutional scheme; and that the courts must be careful in
ensuring that they do not interfere unduly with the economic
arrangement of its dffairs by the State or its instrumenta lities,
nor lend themselves to be instruments to facilitate the bypassing
of the constitutional and statutory mandates. This Court further
held that a temporary, contractual, casual or a daily-wage
employee does not have a legal right to be made permanent
unless he had been appointed in terms of the relevant rules or in
adherence of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. This Court
however made one exception to the above position and the
same is extracted below :
"53. One aspeet lleeds ts be elarfiied, There may be
cases whlzre irreqular a,D,ppiDtmeots not illesaI
as ex lained in S.V. Nar,
m
R 724 R,N, Nan unda a 7
SCC 4O9l aod B.N. Naqaraian f IWCC
l9
sN. l
and referred to in para 75 above. o, '_ Culv aualified
Dersons in dul v sanctioned vacant Dc ; ts miaht have
been made and the emD lovees ha va continued to
work for ten vears or more bul without the
intervention of ord ers of the courts 'of tribunals.
The question of reqularization of tl e services of
such emDlovees mav have to be r onsidered on
merits in the liqht of the orinciples : ettled bu tltis
Court in the cases above referred to 1rd in the lioht
of this udo m cnf- In fhat contex the Union et
India, the Sta te Government:: aOd their
i nstru mentalities shou ld take steDs I 1 regularize as
a one-ti me measure, the services of ; rch irreqularlv
aooointed, who ha ve worked for ter lears or more
in dulv sanctioned Dosts but not 't rder covel dt
orders of the courts or of tribunjLs and should
further ensure that re ular rec t titments are
undertaken to fill those vacant sa l ctioned oosts
that require to be filled uo. tn cases !!he!e
temoorarv emolo es or dailv wa, I :rs are b etno
now enlp loved, The Drocess must b2 set in aetie!7
within six months from this date.....
"5. It is evtdent from the above that the,i ts a n exception
to the general principles agatnst 'regularizali,) " enu nciated in
lJmadevi, if the following conditions are fulfilled
(i) The employee concerned should have worl:c'L 'or 70 years or
more in duly sanctioned post without the beneii or protection of
the interim order of any court or tribunal. In ther words, the
State Governtnent or its instrumentality shoLti. have employed
the employee and continued him in servict volLt ntariiy and
'
continuously for more than ten Years.
(ii) The appointment of such employee shor'l not be illegal,
even if irregular. Where the appointments e not made or
continued against sanctioned posts or wh. (' the persons
,1
appornted do not possess the prescribed minitr L -n qua lifications,
the appointments will be considered to be ille9. . Bu t where the
person employed possessed the prescribed 1 t,1lifications and
was working against sanctioned posts, but h. I been selected
without undergoing the process of open com. ),trtive selection,
such appointments are considered to be irregu:
( iii)
Umadevi
casts a dutv uDon l,
i ke
Government or instrumentalitv, to
ncerned
ste
5\, J
reou larize th services of t hose irreo u rlv aDDo inted
emolovees who had se rve for
re tha ten
ars
with out the nefit o r D rotection of anv interim o rders of
cou s or trib unals. as a one-ti.me meas ure, Um adevi.
dire cted that such o ne-time m easure must be set in
motion within s ixm onths from the date of its decision
rend red on 7 4.20
6. The term 'one-time measure, has to be understood in its
proper perspective. This would normally mean that after the
decision in Umadevi, each department or each instrumentality
should undertake a one-time exercise and prepare a tist of ajtt
casual, daily-wage or ad hoc employees who have been working
for more than ten years wtthout the intervention of courts and
tribunals and subject them to a process verification as to
whether they are working against vacant posts and possess the
requisite qualification for the post and if so, regularize their
services.
7. At the end of six months from the date of decision in
Umadevi, cases of several da ily- wage/ad-hoc/casua I emptoyees
w.ere still pending before Courts. Consequently, several
departments and instrumentatities did not commence the one_
time regularization process. On the other hand, some
Government departments or instru mentalities under-took the
one-time exercise excluding several employees from
consideration either on the ground that their cases were pending
in courts or due to sheer oversight. In such circumstances, thb
employees who were entitled to be considered in terms of para
53 of the decision in umadevi, will not lose their right to be
considered for regularization, merely because the one_time
exercise was completed without considering their cases, or
because the six month period mentioned in pira 53 of LJmadevi
has expired. The one- me exercise should consider a daity_
wage/ad hoc/those employees who had put in 10 years 'of
continuous service as on 10.4.2006 without availing the
protection of any interim orders of courts or tribunats. Tf any
employer had held the one-time exercise in terms of para 53 of
Umadevi, but did not consider the cases of some empioyees who
were entitled to the benefit of para 53 of Umadevi, the employer
concerned should consider their cases also, as a continuation of
the one-time exercise. The one time exercise will be conctuded
only when all the emptoyees who are entitled to be considered
in terms of Para 53 of llmadevi, are so considered.
2l
Sr-. J
nn Da r'a53of
5 idd rec
d
e
ec
e
a.
e ure
'at th os e who
tw - fol . t-t tis
ma evl
uou se ,ce
ha veD t tn more tha n ten vears of con t
or
witho ut the p rotectto nofan interim ord 50 f cou rtswas
madevi
U
u
I
tri nal be re ed e fd tslo
wof
reoularizat
for
i tn i
rend e red. are co nsidered
is to n s Jre that the
rvic .Se on
th ir lo
the
de art ents / i nstrume ta litiesd o not ,lrpetuate
qe/
'ailv-wa
adon I
n
e
I tn
f
ra ,ce
th 91 p eriod ica llv
and
hoc / casua I for lonq DE riods
th the t ave se ed for
the on he ou
re lari
itu iona I
more than ten vea rs. thereb defe atinq tltt CO
:ruitm ent and
or sta tutorv orovtslo n s relati n otort re.:ion
is tha all
e ue ffec of ed
int nt.
a
vea rs as on
oh ew rke for or tha l en
ers ns
ri) with out the
70. 4.2006 (th e date of deciston t n Umad
L ! : or tribu nal, in
rt ord of n
ro ctio of
c l alif ication, are
vacant p ostt oss esstnq the ou t5
r. The fa ct that
ul rtza
nst red for
nti edt be
,]
,se of
the em olover has not unde rtaken st h exerc
tn
ision
dec
e
ont sof l,
within s ,x
re oula rtza tio
rtake n onlv in
Uma devi o r tha t such exe rcrse was un( I
lisentitle such
'r
oula rization
't as on -tim
t
,_
measure,
g. These appeals have been pending for mo' 'than four Years
(Zila PanchaYat,
Zfter the decision in lJmadevi' The Appellar I respondents
of
Gadag) has not considered the cases ct )n in Umadevi or
i
regu l-a'rization within six months of the deci:
thereafter.
directed that the
10. The Division Bench of the High Court hasit
accordance with
considered
,it"t of respondents shoutd bethat
needs b= r1iven, in view of
iaw. The oniy further direction
should now
imadevi, is that the Zita Panchayat' aC' 1ag
rcneral one- time
undertake an exercise within six months'
are anY dailY
reoularization exercise, to tind out whethet : ere
and if
nchayat
t
Pa
)
the
wioe/ casua t/ ad -hoc employees serving
fu lfill
so'whether such employees ( including t-hr. ' =spondents)
fulfill
theY
If
ti" r"qrirem"nts mentioned in para 53 of Urt 'devi.
'
an exercise
l:hlm,'their services have to be regularrzed' ' such the cases
tnitting
or
has already been undertaken by ignoring
af these cases,
of-resporients 7 to 3 because of the pender ay
in contindation of
then their cases shall have to be consideret
S\. J
the said one time exercise within three months. It is needtess to
say that if the respondents do not futfitt the requirements of
Para 53 of Umadevi, their services need not be regutarised. If
the employees who have compteted ten years service do not
possess the educational quatifications prescribed
for the post, at
the time of their appointment, they may be considered for
regularization in suitable lo\r',/er posts. This appeal is disposed of
a ccord ing ly .
L4. In the iu domen toft he Ao
do
rs v. Stat ofP
Cou r
ab r ort
tinN ihal S inqh
tn
o13
14S
65, the Supreme Court considered the case of absorption
of Special Police Officers appointed by the State, whose
wages were paid by Banks at whose disposat their
services were made available. It held that the mere fact
that wages were paid by the Bank did not render the
appellants 'employees, of those Banks since the
appointment was made by the State and disciplinary
control vested with the State. It held that the creation of a
cadre or sanctioning of posts for a cadre is a matter
exclusively within the authority of the State, but if the
State did not choose to create a cadre but chose to make
appointments of
persons creating contractual
relationship, its action is arbitrary.
a
e
n
h
so ther
ef
ce
h
It also refu sed to
tth rew re no
ustifi
ti
for
cti ned
s
sts
o utali
s
S\
numb rof
rvl esofl r
decad es. It h eld that "sancti one doo
sts do rot fal lfrom
that t eS tate ha sto creat( them bva
nd
he aven"
ppe I lant s for
le lik th
e
,I
on clou s choic
er tion:
o so
bas
h
o
I
ss ssmen
of need. Referrino to Umadevi' it held that t
ho r t th etr
t rbi raril
befo re th m wer
re apoellants
o resc
tat l( rV o roc edure
wl h the
,l rd
ribed u n der the P o lice A ct. 186 t,
h
ard to
sor ed in
the
b
c nn
t e
re no :ntitle d to be
ervlce
of th
S
to it hei
nd not
ins
n
bv the State. I w
ld
ha
a
t m
ra
a
ti
en
sa
sa ct ne I t) sts created
u
me nt in Um adevi
ita ron
l the Sta tea nd
he
! overnment of
th
eit
I
Puniab nor those oublic sector Banks
ract ice in
n
sist nt wit
cco da ce wit
t
n
can g )ntinue such a
bri atiot ! to fun tion in
th tr
it
te rn oerma nen t
ol tm r,i s were DUr lv
a
r x
ann t eco meal e
its ins ru
the S tate
th
a
cor tn
ba si
lo
15. The iudoment of the Aoex Court rr: )orted in
sc
o line
it ial
lar'a ointr lent asi t had
intmen was n ta n 'irre
been m de in acc rd nc
in
c 1797
etwe n B.S r inivas
I
t_
u and others v
SN, J
Nellore M unicioal CorDoration
Reo.
bv its Commissioner,
Nellore District, Andhra Prade sh and others, in Darticular
oaras 7 and 8 reads as under:
(7)
We find i t difficult to acceDt the Teason tn q adopted bV the
Hioh Cou rt. The rioht of the a opella nts to seek requ ia rizatron
flows from the G.O. No.212 dated 22. 4. 1 994. The aDoellant
have been in service of the first res ndent not onlV prior to the
issuance of the said G.O. b ut even su bseq uent to the issue of
G.O. till todav. The respondent Municipality being a statutory
body is obliged by the G.O. 212(supra). Inspite of the abave
mentioned G.O. the respondents kept quite for almost 20 years
without regularising the service of the appellants and continued
to extract work from the appellants.
B.
In the circumstances, refusing the benefit of the above
mentioned G.O. on the ground that the appellants approached
the Tribunal belatedly, in our opinion, is not justified. In the
circumstances, the appeal is allowed modifying the order under
appeal by directing that the appellants' services be regularised
with effect from the date of their completing their five year
continuous service as was laid down by this Court in District
Collector/Cha irperson & Others vs. M.L. Singh & Ors. 20O9 (B)
SCC 480.
16. In Amar kant Rai v State of Biha rr CD orted (2015) I
scc 265. the SuDreme Court held that 'The objective
behind the exception carved out in this case was to permit
regularization of such appointment, which are irregular
but not illegal, and to ensure appointments, which are
irregular but not illegal, and to ensure securitv of
em D ov ment of those D erson s wh o h ad se rved the S tate
G overnm
VC
nta nd their n stru m e nta lities for more than ten
ars". In that case. emo lo ee was workinq for 29 vears.
SN, J
This d ectsron
ADDTO
ves ea rlier vi ew
)xp ressed in
M.L.Ke sari ext racted above.
L7. In State of larkhand v Kamal Pras i ljc.p-qttcd-il1
h
(20 14) 7 SCC 223, similar view was a nb
SuDreme Court and it wa s held as follow s:
"41,,.. I n view of the cateoorica I ndin 3 of fact on the
releva nt c ontentiou s issue that the respo r lent emplovees
have continue d in theirs ervice for mot c than 70 vears
conti nuousl v therefo re, the Ieqal p rrnctt. !r z laid do wn bv
kavU adevi
this Court in U madevi ca se( State of Karn
(L&s
p
(2006 )4SCC7: 2006 scc
)73 at ara 53 squarely
appL ies to th CD resent cases, The Divis i1 n Bench of the
at I 5e resDondent
Hioh Court h as riohtl v held
emplo vees are entitled for the re lief , the _;ame cannot be
int fered with bv this Court."
a
18. The Judgment of this Court date d 06.12.2022
passed in W.P.No.276O2 ot 2O19 wit ch pertains to
regularization of 35 NMRS of Sri Lak:; rmi Narasimha
Swamy TemPle, Yadadri, Nalgonda
)istrict, which
had been upheld by the Division Ben< h of this Court
in W.A.No.937 of 2023 dated 10'1C' 2023 and also
confirmed bY the order of APe ( Court dated
09.08.2024 in SLP No.32847 ot 2024'
19.
The iudqmen tof
the A ex Cou rt ir Hari Krish na
Mandir Trust V, State of Mahar ashtra an d other re orte
S\. J
in AIR 2O2O Supreme Court 3959 and in o a rticu la r oa ra
No s.10O and 101 held as follows:
"100. The High Courts exercising their jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constrtution of India, not only have the
power to issue a writ of mandamus or in the nature of
mandamus. but are dutv-bound to exercise such
ower wh e the Governm n ora ublic au h rit
has fail ed to exercise or has wronqlv exercised
discretio n conferred uoo n it bv a statute, o r a rule, or
a oolicv decision of the G overnment or has exe rci sed
ct I ch discretion
ala fide
r
n irrelevan t
o n sid erati n
101. In all such cases, the High Court must issue a wrlt of
mandamus and give directions to compel performance in
an appropriate and lawful manner of the dtscretion
conferred upon the Government or a public authority. "
20. The Divi sion Bench of this Court in its Judqment
dated 10.06.2013 passed in W.A.Nos.782 o f 2010 and 854
of '2012 while uohold Inq the Judom ent dated 08. 9.2010
passed i
W.P.No.24377 of 2OO7 and C.C.No.48 of 2 o08
obse rved as under:"Further, it is manifest from the material on record that the
services of the similarly placed persons who approached the law
Courts were regularized. The appellant-Corporation also issued
various orfice orders/circulars dated 20.12.:-9a9, 11.09.1992,
06.10.2007 and latest belng 4.7.2OO9 for regularization of
casual/contract employees, It is also to be seen that Section 25T of the ID Act prohibits unfair labour practice by any employer
or workman, As can be seen from the factual scenario of the
cases on hand, engaging the respondents for such a long and
continuous period.of time on casual basis is nothing but unFair
labour practice attracting the provisions of Section 25-T of the
ID Act. The learned Single Judge while relying on the decisions
SN, J
of the Apex Court, rightly held that the resporrr ents are entltled
to regularizailon as directed in the impugnrl I orders, as the
learned single .Judge considered all the aspecl s rlf the matter in
detail, in the proper perspective, which, in ot t :onsidered view
does not warrant interference in these appeals.
21.
The Division Bench of this Court ir its Jud oment
dated
19 .o9.2017 D a ssed
in W.P.No.2l , tt7 of 2Ol7
reported i n 2O18(2)ALD Daqe 282 at para I 6 and ara 18
ob se rved a s under:-
'16. It is trite that the law declared by the i upreme Court is
binding throughout the country under Art cle 141 of the
Constitution of India. It is noteworthy that by ihe time the
the
ludgment in LJma Devi's case (supra), tr i s rendered,
provlsions or Act 2 of 1994 and G.O. l" . No.212, dated
22.4.7994, were in existence. The Supr': ne Court, while
t
denouncing the practice of regularization a.l J absorption of f
persons, who entered service through back oors by giving a
go-bye to the due procedure prescribed for appointments to
for one-tlme
public posts, consciously ordered
absorption/regularization of those, who wr: e working for a
period of not less than 10 years. It has giver directions in th is
regard to al the State Governments and a c Union of India.
The Supreme Court is presumed to be conscic't s of various State
enaclments such as Act 2 of 1994 and execut ve orders such as
G,O. Ms. No.212, dated 22.4.1994, while r;;ing directions in
Para No.53 of the judgmenl in lJma Devi's :ase (supra) But
still, it has not made any exception in favour I'the States where
Staie enactments banning regularizatior/lbsorptlon exist'
No.212 ,da ted
Ther efore. ct2of1 994 a nd G.O .M
22.4.1994, do not whittle down the width and the
(; r ora ), does not
iud ment in Maniu la Bash ni's ca
lowe r the tra ectorv of the d i rection I issued bv the
SuDr eme Co urt in Pa ra 53 of its iud om( lfi in Uma Devi's
pe I nissible for the
case (suora) .It is, the refore, n
rf 1994 and G.O.
A
ct2
resoond ents to take shelt er under
eoulariz ation to
. No. 2 dat 22.4. 94 to n rrs
tisfied the
the oetitio ers, w ho hav e. admi tted I
j
ent in Uma
the
:dq
of
No.
Para
c rit ria laid down
(sup
ra ).
De 's case
s
s\..1
18.
For the aforementioned reasons
order, dated
.6 .2077
inO A No.1442 of 2014, on the file of the Tribunal is2tset
asid e
and h
nt
dw th dir on
th
r s
en to on
rr ulari tion f
ser ce
th Deti tio n rs aqarns t the existi nq vacanci
es of Work
I s
ors nd
ot
th
su ect
th
sa
I tn
the crite ri a la id down in Para N o .53 o fthei udqm
ent
in
ma Devi'. ase su r T
r
ssm st
o
in tw omo nths from the dat eofre ceiot of a coolet
vof
this order. "
22. The Divisi on Bench of
d
ted 21.04 .2020
a
ts
urt in i
sed in I.A- os.1 of 2
ud
20i
1 of 2O19
and w.P. N o.230 57of 20L9 reo orted in 2O2O (4)ALD
37 at
ras 45 4 an
ar
o
erv das
en
DA qe
nd er: -
"45. There is no dispute that petitioners have been working
daily wage since 1990 and have put in atmoiil:o; years on
of
service by now. They have been given minjmum
time_scale from
the year 2000. They have been continuously worktnq without
any Court orders in their favour from 1990 till date.
k
a
r
rt
50. Accordi ngly, the writ petition is allowed the impugned
orders date d 20.8.2019 passed b y the 1st respo ndent
the cases of petitioners For reg ularization of se rvices rejecting
on onetime ba sis are decla red as illegal, arbitrary and violative
Articles 14 16 and 21 of the Constitution of Indi a; of
thc
n
h
-sN.
) :r rliselh-al!-bs
n
e of receiot of
e
t
rder."
co DV of the o
h
23. The ud m ent of
l
h
A
xCo urt date i!
19.O8. 2025
2018 rep ( rt d n 02
d in Ci vil A p ea IN o.85 58 of
ln h i, 1d Othe rs v.
scc NLINE SC 1735 tn "Dhar m
th er rele van t oara
st te f .P. an Anot e r ln a rtic lar
as
Nos. 13, L7, 18, 1 9a nd2 0 are extr
act e d hert i rnder:
(:
and
"13. As we have observed in both Jaggo rpra)
lcome a
t9119^t
Sr''rripaf (Supra), outsourcingpreca.rlousrr
-l
- :SS a nd tO
ionvenient shield to perpetuate
*ltl!-; re Work iS
sidestep fair engagement practices
; further
inherently perennial The Commrsslor
''f u ll-tim e"
.ont"nt.n ifrat tne appellants.byare
.not
virtue-., )f interim
utnpilV""t but continue onlytheir case
'l'l ai interim
advance
not
does
;;;-"rt'also
r f the long
protection was granted precisely because ry of the
pende
history ot engagement and the lt neitl er creates
.nl["|rs" to the State's refusals
nents that
,ig;iil i;t did not exist nor erases entitlr:
of tht legalitY of
m-a
y arise upon a proper adjudication
those ref usa ls.
-y to recall
17. Before concluding, we think it necessl
Union and
inutlt.r" State (here referring to both th'l Te market
the State governments) is not
1 ':
constitutional employe- It cannot
a
bit
paiticipunt
-nuiu...
\\ 10 perform
budgets on the backs of those
public func:i ) ns. Where
in" ,"tt ba-sic and recurrinqand
Y!!r.af!: - year, the
*o-rr. i.irr= day after day
reality in ir.: sanctioned
!.Ltritr'.r.unt must reflect that
Th' long term
.ir"nqtn and engagement practices'
labels
of regLular labour under temil rrary
a nd
"*tiu.tlon
confidence in Publlc admini; ration
;;il;t
ancia
Fin
or equal Protecti ) r.
;;i;;;; the promise
,olicy,
but it
has a place in public
I
I,.'nq"n.v ."ituinly
It)
s\..l
is not a talisman that overrides fairness, reason and
the duty to organise work on lawful lines.
18. Moreover, it must necessarily be noted that "adhocism" thrives urhere adrninistration is opaque. The
State Departments must keep and produce accurate
establishment registers, muster rolls and outsourc ng
arrangements, and they must explain, with evidence,
why they preler precarious engagement over
sanctioned posts where the work is perennial, If
"constraint" is invoked, the record should show what
alternatives were considered, why similarly placed
rnrorkers were treated differentiy, and how the chosen
course aligns with Articles t4, 16 and 21 of the
Constitution of India. Sensitivity to the human
consequences of prolonged insecurity is not
sentimentality, It is a constitutional discipline that
should inform every declsion afFecting those who keep
pu blic off ices ru n ning.
" 19. Having regard to the long, undisputed service of
the appellants, the admitted perennial nature of their
duties, and the material indicating vacancies and
comparator regulansations, we issue the following
directions:
i. Regularization and creation of Supernumerary
posts: All appellants shall stand regularized with effect
from 24.04.2002, the date on which the High Court
directed a fresh recommendation by the Commission
and a fresh decision by the State on sanctioning posts
for the appellants. For this purpose, the State and the
successor establishment (U. P. Education Services
Selection Commission) shall create supernumerary
posts in the corresponding cadres, Class-III (Driver or
equivalent) and Class-iV ( Peon/Attendant/G ua rd or
equivalent) without any caveats or preconditions. On
regularization, each appeliant shall be placed at not
less than the mininrum of the regular pay-scale for the
it
s\. J
post, with protection oi' last-drawn wages if - gher and
the appellants shall be entitled to the : r bsequent
increments in thc pay scale as per the pa1' t rad:. For
seniority and prornotion, servlce shall col-t lro'll thr:
date of regularizatron as given above.
ii. Financial consequences and arrea rs: Each
appellant shall be paid as arrears the fu I liffe:rence
between (a) the pay and admissible allowtr t:es at the
minimum of the regular pay-level for tht: )lst from
time to time, and (b) the amounts actually pard, for
the period from 24.04.2002 until thr date of
regularization/retirement/death, as the ca: t may be.
Amounts already paid under previcL: irrterim
directions shall be so adjusted. The net arrll"s shall be
released within three months and if in c t fault, the
unpaid amount shall carry compound intt: - lst at 6%o
per annum from the date of default until Pa' nent.
iii. Retired a o oella n ts: Anv aD oella n t who has
alreadv retired shall be oranted reqr-.r arization
with effect from 24.O 4.2O02 un til th( dat eof
suI)e rannuation for oay f ixatio n, arrea rs u nd er
claus e (ii), and r eca lcu a tion of oe nsto t , oratuitv
I
and ther ter minal dues. The revi s ed or lsron and
terminal due s shall be aid within thr gmo hs
of thi s Judq ent.
lv. Deceased aooella nts: In the case of
Aopella nt No. 5 and anv othe r ap ella l ! who has
pe ndencv,
le al
his/h:'
durin
died
reDr se ntative sonre ord shal I be oaid the
arrears under claus e (ii uo to th e dat of deat h,
with all t erminal/ reti t rl dues
ther
recal culated con s istentl v with cla use 'i), within
three months of this Judq ent.
v. Compliance affidavit: The Principal Secretary,
Higher Education Department, Governmr,t t of Uttar
Pradesh, or the Secretary of the U.P. Education
Services Selection Commission or tlr I prevalent
competent authority, shall file an e 'fidavit of
compliance before this Court within four rnc nth:; of this
Judgment.
20. We have framed t I lse directions
comprehensively because, case aftei- cit: r , oi-ders of this
)-1
S\. I
Court in such matters have been met with fresh
technicalities, rolling "reconsiderations," and administrative
drift which further prolongs the insecurity for those who
have already laboured for years on daily wages. Therefore,
we have iearned that lustice in such cases cannot rest 0n
simpliciter directions, but it demands imposition of clear
duties, fixed trmelines, and verifiable compliance. As a
constrtutional employer, the State is held to a higher
standard and therefore it must organise its perennial
workers on a sanctioned footing, create a budget for Iawful
engagement, and implement judicial directions in letter and
spirit. Delay to follow these obligations is not mere
negligence but rather it is a conscious method of denial that
erodes livelihoods and dignity for these workers. The
operative scheme \ /e have set here comprising of creation
of supernumerary posts, full regularization, subsequent
financial benefits, and a sworn affidavit of compliance, is
therefore a pathway designed to convert rights into
outcomes and to reaffirm that fairness in engagement and
transparency in administration are not matters oF 9race, but
obligations under Articles 14, L6 and 21 of the Constitution
of India
24. This Cour too tn e s that in th ED resen t case th e
resoo n d en ts failed to dischar oe their dutv in exa mrntno
the reouest of the oetitioner for requ larization of
petitioner's services .whoisw orkino as full tim e sweeDer
and further to c onsider his re o uest to treat the tem D orar
rvice of th
c wee n er
IE
f
r
n
r in the licf
lar one for all ht I f
ar
r ad e n ost of full tinrp
sbvdr
nlinrr
l-rct
qrade paY with periodical increment revised fro m time to
J')
\\..r
time from the date of aooointmen t of thr petitioner, in
accordance to law.
25. This Court opines that oetiti oner is entitled for
consideration of petitio n er's case for qrant < f the relief as
praved for in the oresent Writ Petition ir view of the
observations of the Aoex Court in varic ,r ts iudoments
(referred to and extracted abov e) a nd tl- ( view of the
Division Bench of this Cour t in the Judqmer ts referred to
a nd extra
ted above.
6. Takino into consideration:-
a)
The aforesaid facts and circumstances ( f the case.
b)
The submissions made by the lc: rned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner and Iea rned standing
counsel appearing on behalf of the responclr: rt Nos.3 & 4
c) The observations of the Apex Court i1 the various
judgments (referred to and extracted abc,''e) and again
enlisted below:
i)(2020) l scc (L&s)
(ii) 1990(2) Scc Page 396
(aii) 202s rNsc 144
(iv) 2024 LawSuit(SC) 12O9
.+
SN, J
(v) (20rz) l scc 148
(vi) 2o1o(9) sc0 247
(vii) (2013) 14scc 6s
(viii) 2015 SCC Online SC 1.797
(ix) (201s) 8 scc 26s
(x) (2014) 7 scc 223
(xi) SLP No.32847 of 2024
(xii) AIR 2020 Supreme Court 3969
(xiii) (2006) 4 scc 1
(xiv) 2O11 (1) ALD, Page 234
(xv) 2O18(2)ALD page 282
(xvi) 2O2O(4)ALD page 379
(xvii)2O25 SCC ONLINE SC 1735
d) The Division Bench order of this Court dated
10.06.2013 passed in W.A.Nos.782 ot 2O1O and 854 of
2O12 while uploading the Judgment dated 08.09.2010
passed in W.P.No.24377 of 2OO7 and C.C.No.48 of 2OO8
(referred to and extracted above),
e)' The Division Bench order of this Court dated
L9.O9.2OL7 passed in W.P.No.272L7 ot 2O17 (referred to
and extracted above),
f)
The Division Bench order of this Court dated
2L.O4.2O2O passed in t.A.Nos.l of 2O2O in 1of 2019 and
W.P.No.23O57 of 2OL9 (referred to and extracted above),
9) In the light of discussion and conclusion as arrived at
as above from para Nos,4 to 26 of the present order.
I
I
3-i
:\
The Writ
Petition
allowe d, the
ts
DE titioner
I
ts
direct ed to put-f orth the claim of t he Detition er for
requla riza ti onofo et itio n e r' sse rvrces, an
r lso the cl arm
of the D eti tioner to treat the t moo ra rv
lrvtces of the
pe itioner in th e las t qrade
os tofSw eeper rs reqular one
for all pur poses b VCI rantinq I ast rade o aV I
'/ith erl o ical
rnc tements revi se d from time
apooin tment
of the
to time frcrr th eda te of
Detiti oner and
all cons equ ential
benefit s, dulv enclosi nq all the relev ant locum ents tn
suD port of Det it ioner's cas eas put-f orth ir th
resent
writ peti tion, within oeri od of one ( o1) teek from the
date of r ecer tofc oDV of th e order and tl resoondents
ll
shall examrn e and consider the same in
rn con rmt
pr ovidin
ourt
a
in term of
a
sed b
edi 20
e
the iudom ent passed tn W.P.No.2 4377
o 8.09.2O1O r e D orted in 2O
con firme
al o
atu'al
nB
c
u
et
rce
the
the Suprem e
CC Pa
e1
c,' 2OO7 d ated
1(1) ALD. Par I : 234 and as
inW .A.No. 782 of 2010 dated 1(l
tv
orda n
ofD erson lhe afln qto
rders
evi' ca
Uma
of
rr ncr
h
o pDort unitv
an
itio n r
w
lC
Ju
en
6.2 13 and
of thi ; Cour t dated
o
o
7re
.P.No .272L7 ot 2
19.09.201
ass
20 18(2)ALD
p aqe 282
lud qment
s\. l
1n
rted n
and also the D ivision
of this Court d ated
Ben ch
assed in
2r.o4.2020
I.A.Nos. Lol 20 20 in 1 of 2019 in W.P.No.2305 7of20 19
re
d
n 2O2
4 ALD
t
379 which had
a
rne
fina litv. wi hinao eriod o f four ( O4) we eks from th ed ate
fa
f
o
atio n he ob
nsid
Cou
A
his o
hel w laid
rvati ns an
in the v nou
Karn
tof
kav
dec ision to
h
A
Uma
x Cou
evt
,n
oan
o.53 ol the
Da ra
cas
of
teo
co
m nl
t
h
ndd
n o
own
ferre
n
ext racted a bove), and rn p articular,
ud m
t kin
er
the Det itio n er. Howe ver, there shall be no
order as toc osts.
Miscellaneous petitions, if
Petition, shall stand closed.
any, pending in this Writ
It
I
I
/.
Sd/.M.OSMAN ALI BAIG
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
(\,2
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
(For His LordshiPs kind Perusal)
To
1.
2.
'1
1 LR Copies
-Secretary,
fne UnOrir'
Union of lndia, trilinistry of Law, Justice and Company
Affairs, New Delhi.
J
lh" 6"ii"irw, Telangana Advocates Association, Library High Court
Buildinos. Hvderabad.
t)
i[u piiniipit Secretary, Panchayathraj Department, The State of Telangana'
Telanoand Secretariat, HYderabad.
i[" Cl.ri.ii"nei oi eancnayathraj and Rural Employment, Govt' of
Telanoana. Urdu Galli, Himayathnagar. Hydera5ad '
in,i2ir, Fi"irF"riinia suryapet Sistric[, Telangana state Represented bv
its Chief Executive Officer.
The Mandal Parishad Development Officer, Mothey, I) ryafr,et Urstflct
One CC lo SRI CH CANESH, Advocate IOptJCr-'
I Two CCs to GP FoR PANCHAYAT RAJ & nunAt D : i EL()PN4E\T, High
Coul for tre State of Telangana [OUT]
10 . Two CD Copies
BN/PMK
D
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED:2210112026
:ir..-:--
,,Lr
f
()
L)
,a
f
2 rtd 2026
\...1
ORDER
WP.No.25101 of 2021
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
\.
:s 'j'.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review