Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on 10.09.2026
Pronounced on 18.09.2026
Uploaded on: 18.09.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced: Full
HCP No. 45/2026
…..Appellant(s)/Petitioner(s)
Baldev Raj th. wife Bholi Devi
Through: Mr. Prince Khanna, Adv.
Q
vs
.…. Respondent(s)
U. T. of J&K and others
Through: Mr. Pawan Dev Singh, Dy.AG
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner has challenged detention order bearing No. PSA 03
of 2026 dated 06.02.2026 issued by District Magistrate, Jammu
(hereinafter to be referred as the Detaining Authority). In terms of
the said order, the petitioner, namely, Baldev Raj alias Raju (for
short, the detenue) has been placed under preventive detention in
order to prevent him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the
maintenance of the public order.
2.
The petitioner has contended that respondent No. 3, Senior
Superintendent of Police, Jammu, has not brought all the relevant
facts and material to the notice of the Detaining Authority,
respondent No. 2 herein, inasmuch as, the petitioner had already
been detained under Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic Substances(PITNDPS) Act in terms of detention
order bearing No. PITNDPS 09 of 2023 dated 19.04.2023,
whereafter, he was set at liberty in terms of the judgment passed by
the Division Bench of this Court on 19.09.2024. It has further been
contended that whole of the material, on the basis of which, the
grounds of detention have been formulated, has not been furnished
to the petitioner. It has further been contended that the petitioner
had made a representation through his wife before the Detaining
Authority as well as before the State Advisory Board, but the said
representation was never considered nor the result of the said
representation was conveyed to the petitioner. It has also been
contended that the proceedings in respect of as many as 05 FIRs
out of 14 FIRs mentioned in the grounds of detention had
culminated, but this fact was not brought to the notice of the
Detaining Authority by the sponsoring agency. It has further been
contended that the impugned order of detention suffers from nonapplication of mind because the grounds of detention are exact
replica of the dossier formulated by the sponsoring agency. It has
been contended that having regard to the nature of allegations made
in the grounds of detention, the same cannot form a basis for
HCP No. 45/2026
passing an order of preventive detention under the Public Safety
Act.
3.
Respondent No. 2-Detaining Authority has filed its affidavit in
answer to the writ petition. In the affidavit, it has been submitted
that all the procedural safeguards guaranteed under Article 22(5) of
the Constitution have been adhered to by the Detaining Authority
while effecting preventive detention of the detenue/petitioner. It
has been further contended that the petitioner is a habitual criminal,
and he has been violating the rule of law blatantly by involving
himself in illicit trafficking of narcotic drugs such as heroin and
liquor. It has been further submitted that 14 FIRs have been
registered against the detenue/petitioner and his
repeated
involvement in criminal cases clearly demonstrates that ordinary
criminal law has proved insufficient to deter him from continuing
his unlawful activities.
4.
Thus, according to the respondents, the activities of the petitioner
pose a serious threat to public order. It has been contended that the
whole of the material relied upon for formulating the grounds of
detention, comprising 232 leaves, has been furnished to the
petitioner, regarding which he has executed a receipt. It has also
been contended that the representation of the petitioner was
considered by the Government and vide communication dated
HCP No. 45/2026
19.05.2026 addressed to Superintendent, District Jail Bhadarwah,
the petitioner was informed about the rejection of his
representation. It has further been contended that merely because of
similarity in some sentences of the Police dossier and the grounds
of detention, it cannot be stated that the Detaining Authority has
not applied its mind independently to the material before it. It has
further been submitted that the petitioner was informed about his
right to make a representation before the Government as well as
before the Detaining Authority. To lend support to the stand taken
in the counter affidavit, the respondents have also produced the
detention record.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record,
including the detention record produced by the respondents.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner, while seeking quashment of
order of detention, has projected various grounds, but his main
thrust during the course of arguments was on the ground that the
representation filed by the petitioner against his preventive
detention has not been considered by the Authority, thereby
violating his constitutional and statutory rights guaranteed under
Article 22(5) of the Constitution and the J&K Public Safety Act.
7.
In the above context, a perusal of the detention record reveals that
the representation of the petitioner addressed to the Detaining
HCP No. 45/2026
Authority was received by the said authority on 16.03.2026. It
appears that the Detaining Authority forwarded the said
representation to the Government vide its communication dated
23.04.2026, whereafter the Home Department of the Government
sought report from the Criminal Investigation Department (CID)
vide communication dated 25.04.2026. The requisite report was
forwarded
by
the
CID
to
the
Home
Department
vide
communication dated 14.05.2026, whereafter on 19.05.2026, the
representation of the petitioner was disposed of by rejecting the
same. In this regard, a communication came to be issued by the
Home Department to District Magistrate, Jammu, on 19.05.2026
informing him about the disposal of the representation of the
detenue/petitioner. A copy of the said communication was also sent
to Superintendent, District Jail, Bhardarwah for its onward
transmission to the detenue. It is not clear as to whether or not the
information with regard to the rejection of the representation of the
petitioner was communicated to the petitioner, as there is no receipt
of detenue, in this regard, on the file of the detention record.
8.
From a perusal of the detention record, it is, thus, clear that the
wife of the petitioner had made a representation against the
impugned order of detention and the said representation was
received by the District Magistrate, Jammu on 16.03.2026. The
HCP No. 45/2026
representation was ultimately disposed of by the Advisory Board
and the Home Department on 19.05.2026. Thus, there is a delay of
more than two months in disposing of the representation of the
petitioner. It is also clear from the detention record that information
about the fate of the representation has not been conveyed to the
detenue/petitioner.
9.
The question that arises for determination is as to whether
consideration of the representation after a period of more than two
months from the date of receipt of the same, satisfies the
requirement of law.
10.
The aforesaid question has been answered by the Supreme Court in
the case of Sarabjeet Singh Mokha v District Magistrate,
Jabalpur and others, (2021) 20 SCC 98. It would be apt to refer
to the observations made by the Supreme Court in paragraph 47 of
the judgment, which are reproduced as under:
“47. By delaying its decision on the representation, the State
Government deprived the detenu of the valuable right which emanates
from the provisions of Section 8(1) of having the representation being
considered expeditiously. As we have noted earlier, the
communication of the grounds of detention to the detenu “as soon as
may be” and the affording to the detenu of the earliest opportunity of
making a representation against the order of detention to the
appropriate government are intended to ensure that the representation
of the detenu is considered by the appropriate government with a
sense of immediacy. The State Government failed to do so. The
making of a reference to the Advisory Board could not have furnished
any justification for the State Government not to deal with the
representation independently at the earliest. The delay by the State
Government in disposing of the representation and by the Central and
State Governments in communicating such rejection, strikes at the
HCP No. 45/2026
heart of the procedural rights and guarantees granted to the detenu. It
is necessary to understand that the law provides for such procedural
safeguards to balance the wide powers granted to the executive under
the NSA. The State Government cannot expect this Court to uphold its
powers of subjective satisfaction to detain a person, while violating
the procedural guarantees of the detenu that are fundamental to the
laws of preventive detention enshrined in the Constitution.”
11.
From the foregoing analysis of law on the subject, it is manifest
that delaying the decision on the representation of the detenue
amounts to infringement of his valuable right which is available
to a detenue in terms of provisions contained in Section 13 of
the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act, which makes it
obligatory on the Detaining Authority to communicate to the
detenue the grounds on which the order of detention has been
made within a maximum period of ten days from the date of
detention and to afford him the earliest opportunity of making
representation against the order of detention. The purpose of
furnishing the grounds of detention within a maximum period of
ten days is to enable a detenue to make a representation against
the order of detention at the earliest opportunity. Thus, a duty is
cast upon the Detaining Authority or the Government to
consider the said representation at the earliest opportunity.
Failure to decide the representation of a detenue within a
reasonable time in an expeditious manner strikes at the valuable
right of a detenue emanating from the provisions of Section 13
HCP No. 45/2026
of the Jammu and Kashmir Public Safety Act.
12.
In the present case, the respondents have considered the
representation of the petitioner after more than two months of its
receipt. The record shows that the Detaining Authority has
retained the representation of the petitioner with it from
16.03.2026 to 23.04.2026 for more than one month without
processing the same and forwarding the same to the
Government. There is no explanation forthcoming from the
affidavit furnished by the Detaining Authority or from the
detention record as to what circumstances prevented the
Detaining Authority from forwarding the representation of the
petitioner to the Government for more than five weeks. This
slackness on the part of the respondents to take a decision on the
representation of the petitioner renders impugned order of
detention illegal.
13.
Apart from the above, in the present petition, the respondents
have not placed on record anything to show that the order of
rejection was conveyed to the petitioner. Communication dated
19.05.2026 is an inter-departmental communication between the
Home Department and the District Magistrate, Jammu, and it is
not forthcoming from the record produced by the respondents as
to whether the result of the representation has been conveyed to
HCP No. 45/2026
the detenue/petitioner.
14.
The Supreme Court in Sarabjeet Singh Mokha’s case (supra),
while dealing with the effect of failure to communicate the result
of the representation, has held that failure in timely
communication of the rejection of the representation is a
relevant factor for determining the delay and whether the
protection granted to a detenue under Article 22(5) of the
Constitution has been violated. It has been further held that
failure of the Government to communicate rejection of detenue’s
representation in a time-bound manner is sufficient to vitiate the
detention order.
15.
Viewed thus, the instant petition is allowed, and the impugned
order of detention is quashed. The detenue/petitioner is directed
to be released from the preventive custody forthwith, provided
he is not required in connection with any other case.
16.
The detention record be returned to the learned counsel for the
respondents.
(SANJAY DHAR)
JUDGE
Jammu
18.09.2026
Rakesh PS
Whether the order is speaking:
Whether the order is reportable:
HCP No. 45/2026
Rakesh Kumar
2026.09.18 14:15
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Jammu
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review