The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. LAXMAN S/O SHRI BABULAL KUSHWAH, AGED-30 Y E A R S , PATHAR MOHALLA, TAHSIL AND DISTRICT GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH) .....PETITIONERS (BY SHRI YOGESH SINGHAL- ADVOCATE ) MATHURALAL S/O SHRI MULLA, AGED-65 YEARS, R/O PATHAR MOHALLA GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH) .....RESPONDENT (BY SHRI RISHIKESH BOHRE- ADVOCATE ) This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the following: The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has 2:17:57 PM been preferred by the petitioners being aggrieved by the order dated 17.07.2014 passed by learned Trial Court, whereby an application preferred by respondent/plaintiff under Order 39 Rule 2 (a) of the CPC has been allowed and the petitioners/defendants were held to be guilty of breach of injunction and willful disobedience of the order dated 05.09.2012 passed by the Trial Court and, therefore, the petitioners were directed to be kept in Civil prison for the period of one month. Petitioners had assailed the aforesaid order in appeal, but the appellate Court vide order dated 09.01.2015 had dismissed the said appeal and had affirmed the order passed by the learned Trial Court. Aggrieved by the aforesaid, the present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has been preferred. Learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that the order passed by the learned Trial Court invoking the provisions under O…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT GWALIOR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND RAMESH PHADKE
ON THE 5th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 879 of 2015
BETWEEN:1.
BABULAL S/O SHRI MULLA, AGED-75 YEARS, R/O
PATHAR MOHALLA GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
BAHGWANLAL S/O SHRI BABULAL KUSHWAH,
AGED-45 YEARS, R/O PATHAR MOHALLA, NEAR
HANUMAN MANDIR GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
ROOP SINGH S/O SHRI BABULAL KUSHWAH,
AGED-42 YEARS, R/O PATHAR MOHALLA, TAHSIL
AND DISTRICT GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
GOPAL S/O SHRI BABULAL KUSHWAH, AGED-39
YEARS, R/O PATHAR MOHALLA, TAHSIL AND
DISTRICT GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
5.
LAXMAN S/O SHRI BABULAL KUSHWAH, AGED-30
Y E A R S , PATHAR MOHALLA, TAHSIL AND
DISTRICT GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(BY SHRI YOGESH SINGHAL- ADVOCATE )
AND
MATHURALAL S/O SHRI MULLA, AGED-65 YEARS, R/O
PATHAR MOHALLA GUNA (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENT
(BY SHRI RISHIKESH BOHRE- ADVOCATE )
This petition coming on for admission this day, th e court passed the
following:
ORDER
The present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India has
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 06-Jan-24
2:17:57 PM
been preferred by the petitioners being aggrieved by the order dated 17.07.2014
passed by learned Trial Court, whereby an application preferred by
respondent/plaintiff under Order 39 Rule 2 (a) of the CPC has been allowed
and the petitioners/defendants were held to be guilty of breach of injunction and
willful disobedience of the order dated 05.09.2012 passed by the Trial Court
and, therefore, the petitioners were directed to be kept in Civil prison for the
period of one month.
Petitioners had assailed the aforesaid order in appeal, but the appellate
Court vide order dated 09.01.2015 had dismissed the said appeal and had
affirmed the order passed by the learned Trial Court.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid, the present petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India has been preferred.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that the order
passed by the learned Trial Court invoking the provisions under Order 39 Rule
2 (a) of CPC dated 17.07.2014 is per se illegal as it was dehors the pleadings of
the respondent/plaintiff and, therefore, was not sustainable in the eyes of law.
It was further contended that from the bare allegations made by the
respondent/plaintiff, it would be evident that the allegations were regarding
flouting of order of injunction dated 05.09.2012, whereby they were restrained
from interfering with the peaceful possession of the respondent/plaintiff by
themselves or by any other means, but on 16.10.2012 petitioner no.1 to 5 armed
with deadly weapons (axe, farsa, talwar, and lathi) and along with female
members of their family entered the fields ( land in dispute) and had severed
Soyabean crop standing and when the son of the plaintiff Gendalal, Mohana
and Lalu tried to stop them they hurled filthy abuses and were ready to fight.
In furtherance of his arguments it was contended that in the complaint, it
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 06-Jan-24
2:17:57 PM
was further averred that when the respondent/plaintiff tried to show the order of
the Trial Court, the petitioners refused to accept it and tried to assault them and
somehow the plaintiff and his family members escaped and, thereafter, in total
derogation of the very order of injunction, the petitioners severed 60 quintals of
Soyabean by means of a threasher of Gajraj Singh, looted it and went away and
though the plaintiff tried to report the matter to the police, the report was not
written and on 20.10.2012 the petitioners again came to the disputed land and
started ploughing the field and when the plaintiff tried to stop them, he was
threatened for life, thus, since the petitioner in the aforesaid manner had flouted
the order of injunction, the application under Order 39 Rule 2(a) was filed,
which goes to show that there was no question of possession being taken by
the petitioners and, therefore, the learned Trial Court on a wrong assumption
that the petitioners have forcibly taken possession of the land in dispute, had
passed the impugned order which is per se illegal.
It was further submitted that the learned Trial Court in paragraph 9 has
categorically held that the factum of loot of the Soyabean crop has not been
established beyond doubt against the petitioners, which was the basic allegation
of flouting the interim injunction order and when the said allegation itself was
not held to be proved, the order dated 17.07.2014 is bad in law. It was lastly
contended that aforesaid aspect has not been considered by the learned
Appellate Court and had dismissed the appeal in a routine manner and had
upheld the order passed by the learned Trial Court which also deserves to be
set aside.
Shri Rishikesh Bohre appearing for the respondent/plaintiff submits that
no interference is warranted in the present petition as two fact finding courts
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 06-Jan-24
2:17:57 PM
have given concurrent findings against the petitioners regarding flouting of the
interim injunction order dated 05.09.2012. Thus, prayed for dismissal of the
present petition.
After hearing the rival contentions and perusing the impugned orders, this
Court finds that the learned Trial Court as well as the appellate authority had not
considered the allegations made by the respondent/plaintiff in his application
under Order 39 Rule 2(a) in its right perspective. The relevant extract of the
allegations as mentioned in the application against the petitioner of flouting the
interim injunction order is reproduced herein below:
5 . ;g fd vkosnd dh mDr lks;kchu dh Qly id dj rS;kj
gksus ij fnukad 16-10-12 eaxyokj dqaokj lqnh ,de dks vukosnd
dzekad 1 yxk;r 5 ckcwyky vkSj mlds yMds Hkxoku flag]
:iflag] xksiky] ,oa y{ke.k us fnu ds 10 cts ?kkrd gfFk;kjksa
dqYgkMh] Q'kZk] ryokj] ykBh ysdj efgykvksa ds lkFk mDr Hkwfe ds
[ksr esa ?kqldj lks;kchu dkVuk 'kq: fd;k rc vkosnd us vius
iq= xsankyky] eksguk rFkk yYyw ds lkFk [ksr ij tkdj
vukosndx.k dks lks;kchu dkVus ls euk fd;kA rc vukosndx.k
us vkosnd dks v'yhy ekW&cgu dh xanh xkfy;kWa nh vkSj yMus
>xMus rS;kj gks x, rc vkosnd us U;k;ky; Jheku ds vLFkkbZ
fu"ks/kkKk vkns'k] LVs&vkWMZj fnukad 5-9-12 dks vukosndx.k dks
fn[kk;k rc vukosndx.k us vkosnd dks v'yhy ekW&cgu dh xanh
xkfy;kW nsrs gq, dgk fd ,sls vnkyrksa ds LVs&vkWMZj geus dbZ ns[ks
gSa vkSj ge LVs&vkWMZj ugha ekurs gekjs gfFk;kjksa esa vkSj ge esa
rkdr gS blfy, ge lks;kchu dkV dj ys tk,xsa Hkys gh gesa
vnkyr ls ltk gks tk,A vukosnd dzekad 1 ckcwyky us vius
yMdksa Hkxoku flga cxSjg ls dgk fd bUgsa tku ls ekj nks vkSj
ltk gksxh mls esa Hkqxr ywWaxk rc vukosnd dzekad 1 yxk;r 5 ?
kkrd gfFk;kj ysdj vkosnd vkSj mlds yMdksa dks ekjus nkSMs rc
vkosnd vkSj mlds yMdksa us Hkkx dj tku cpkbZA
6- ;g fd vukosnd dzekad 1 yxk;r 5 us U;k;ky; ds LVs&vkWMZj
dks Hkax djds tcj&tLrh rkdr ds Hkj fookfnr Hkwfe esa [kMh
lks;kchu dh Qly tks djhc 7 DoaVy lks;kchu fudyk gS vkSj 21
gtkj :i; ewY; dh gS mls pksjh djds xtjkt flag iq=
/kUukyky dq'kokg iou dkWyksuh iBkj eksgYyk xquk ds Fkzl
s j ls
mDr lks;kchu Qly fudyokdj ys x, gSaA
7- ;g fd vkosnd us mDr ?kVuk dh fjiksVZ djds fnukad 16-1012 dks iqfyl dksrokyh dsUV xquk dks ?kVuk dk gky crk;k rFkk
fjiksVZ ntZ djus dk fuosnu fd;k ysfdu iqfyl us fjiksVZ ntZ ugha
dh vkSj ;g dgdj Hkxk fn;k fd rqEgkjk vnkyr esa eqdnek py
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 06-Jan-24
2:17:57 PM
jgk gS blfy, ogha dk;Zokgh djksA
8- ;g fd vkosnd dh mDr fookfnr Hkwfe esa vukosnd dzekad 1
yxk;r 5 us iqu% fnukad 20-10-12 'kfuokj dks fouksn iq= jkedqekj
'kekZ ckMbZ fuoklh pkWan'kkgoyh xquk dk VzsDVj ys tk dj vkSj [ksr
esa ?kqldj gkdkbZ tqrkbZ djus yxs vkSj vkosnd ds [ksr dh ckxM
rksM nhA tc vkosnd euk djus igqWapk rks yMus&>xMus rS;kj gks
x, vkSj tku ls ekjus dh /kedh nhA bldh fjiksVZ djus Hkh
vkosnd fnukad 20-10-12 dks iqfyl dksrokyh x;k ysfdu iqfyl us
fjiksVZ ntZ ugha dh vkSj vnkyr esa dk;Zokgh djus dk dg dj
Hkxk fn;kA
vr% fuosnu gS fd vkosnd dh xzke xquk igkuk 75 rglhy xquk esa
fLFkr Hkwfe losZ ua- 800 feu 2 esa ls jdok 0-335 gs- ij U;k;ky;
Jheku ds vLFkkbZ fu"ks/kkKk vkns'k fnukad 05-09-12 dk Hkax djus
vkSj tcjtLrh rkdr ds cy mDr Hkwfe esa [kMh vkosnd dh 21
gtkj :i; dh lks;kchu dh Qly fnukad 16-10-12 dks dkVdj
ys tkus rFkk iqu% fnukad 20-10-12 dks LVsvkWMZj dk mYya?ku dj
fookfnr Hkwfe esa VzsDVj ls gdkbZ tqrkbZ djus vkSj esM rksMus dk
vukosnd dzekad 1 yxk;r 5 dks mfpr o f'k{kk izn n.M fn;k
tkosA
From the aforesaid allegations it would be evident that on 16.10.2012 the
petitioners are stated to have entered the fields (land in dispute) of the
respondent/plaintiff and had harvested/severed the Soyabean crop standing and
had threatened plaintiff and his family members and had forcibly taken the crop.
There is no allegation of taking the forcible possession of the said land.
Learned Trial Court in paragraph 9 has categorically held that so far as
the loot of the Soyabean crop by the petitioners is concerned, it was not
established, but on the basis that the petitioners have taken forcible possession
of the land in question, it was held that the petitioners have flouted the interim
injunction order dated 05.09.2012 which appears to be beyond the pleadings
and completely illegal. It further observed by this Court that this aspect has also
not been considered by the appellate Court.
Both the orders, therefore, appears to be perverse and per se illegal,
accordingly, are hereby set aside.
The petition is allowed to the above extent.
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 06-Jan-24
2:17:57 PM
(MILIND RAMESH PHADKE)
JUDGE
Chandni
Signed by: CHANDNI
NARWARIYA
Signing time: 06-Jan-24
2:17:57 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review