Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132s21
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
Between:
B. Mahender Reddy, S/o Raji Reddy, Age. 50 years, Occ. Clerk Cum Bill
Collector, Dundigal Municipality, Medchal Malkajgiri District
PETITIONER
AND
1. State of Telangana, Rep through Principal Secretary, MunicipalAdministration
and Urban Development Department Secretariat, Hyderabad
2. Director and Commissioner of Municipal Administration State of Telangana,
640, AC Guards, MasabTank, Opp PTI Building, Hyderabad 500 004
3. Dundigal Municipality, Rep by its Municipal Commissioner Medchal Malkajgiri
District
4. Municipal Commissioner, Dundigal Municipality, Dundigal, , Medchal
Malkajgiri District
5. District Collector, Medchal Malkajgiri
6. District Panchayat Officer, Medchal Malkajgiri District
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a Writ, Order or Direction particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus
declaring the impugned order of the 4th Respondent terminating the services of the
Petitioner without issuing any notice and without conducting any enquiry merely on
the instructions of the 2nd Respondent, vide proceedings Progs.Roc.No.43/EstUMC/
Dundigal/2019 dated 2U0812O19 as illegal, null and void, unenforceable in law,
without jurisdiction, violative of Article 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of tndia and
consequently set-aside the same by directing the Respondents to reinstate the
Petitioner witlr all consequential benefits and reliefs.
l.A NO: { OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
Respondent to continue the Petitioner by suspending the impugned order of
Termination vide proceedings Progs.Roc.No.43/EstUMC/ Dundigal/2O19 dated
2AO8|2O19 tassed by the 4th Respondent, pending disposal of the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI S.R.AHUL REODY
Counsel for the Respondent No.l: SRI RAMESH CHILLA
SC FOR SERVICE MATTERS
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 to 4: SRI G.MADHUSUOHAN REDDY,
SC FOR MCPL
Counsel for the Respondent No.s & 6: GP FOR REVENUE
The Court nrade the following: ORDER
i
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF
AT HYDER^ABAD
THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
DATE: 09.O1.2026
BETWEEN:
B. Mahender Reddy
...Petitioner
And
State of Telangana,
Rep through Principal Secretary,
Municipal Administration and Urban Development
Department Secretariat, Hyderabad
...Respondents
EEEtrR
Heard Sri S.Rahul Reddy, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner, Sri Ramesh
Chilla, learned Standing Counsel for Service matters,
appearing on behalf of the respondent No.l, Sri
G.Madhusudhan Reddy, learned Standing Counsel for
Municipalities appearing on behalf of the respondent
Nos.2 to 4 and the learned Government pleader for
\ \
SN,J
W.P.No.269l5 2019
Revenue appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.S and
6.
2.
The oetitioner aporoached this Court seekinq the
oraver as under:
"....to issue a Writ, Order or Direction particularly
one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the
impugned order of the 4th Respondent terminating the
services of the Petitioner without issuing any notice and
without conducting any enquiry merely on the
instructions of the znd Respondent, vide proceedings
Progs.Roc.No.43l Estt/MC/ Dundigal /20L9 dated
28.08.2019 as illegal, null and void, unenforceable in
law, without jurisdiction, violative of Article 14, 16 and
2L of the Constitution of tndia and consequently setaside the same by directing the Respondents to
reinstate the Petitioner with all consequential benefits
and reliefs and pass such and further orders in the
interest of justice."
3.
oetition is as under:
SN,J
.1
W.P.No.269l5 2019
i)
The petitioner was initially appointed as Clerk-cum-Bill
Collector on 01.09.1988 and his appointment was duly
ratified by the District Collector, Ranga Reddy. Later, the
petitioner was granted time scale and his services were
regularized with effect from 01.05.199 by the District
Panchayat Officer, Ranga ReddY.
ii)
Subsequently, Dundigal Municipality was newly
constituted by merging six Gram Panchayats. Despite
merger of posts, the petitioner was not paid salary from May
20L9, compelling the petitioner to file W.P. No.16749 of
2OL9,'wherein this Court by an interim order dated
09.08.2019, directed the respondents to release and
continue payment of salarY.
iii)
While the petitioner was awaiting absorption into the
Municipality, an ACB case was registered against certain
municipal employees, in which the petitioner was arrayed as
accused No.3. Without issuing any notice, charge memo, or
conducting any enquiry, the 4th respondent passed the
impugned termination order dated 28.08.2019 under
SN,J
W.P.No.269l5 2019
section 48(1) of the Tetangana Municipalities ordinance,
20L9. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner approached
this Court by filing the present writ petition.
A)
"A case registered in Gr.No.03/RCT/RRR/2019
uls (7a) L2
of the Prevention of corruption (Amendment) Act, 19gg
by
the ACB Ranga Reddy Range, Hyderabad on 07.O9.2019
at
about 02:55 in Dundigar Municiparity against the foilowing
on
the complaint of Sri A.Raja Ram (Civil Contractor), R/o
Hyderabad for processing and issue of cheque for
an amount
of Rs.2,27,373/- for the works completed by them. The
following are the staff of Dundigar Municipality trapped
by
the ACB Officials:-
-t
SN,J
r1
W.P.No.269l5 2019
Sl.No
Reason
Accused
Officer
(Ao-1)
Sri Setti. Govinda Rao , manager, Dundigal
Municipality for demand and acceptance of
2.
(Ao-2)
Sri V. Krishna Reddy, Junior Assistant O/o the
Rs.7,000/- as bribe.
3.
(Ao-3)
4.
(Ao-4)
Dundigal Municipality for demand and acceptance
of Rs.13,000/- as bribe
Sri Mahender Reddy, Bill Collector, Bahadurpally
Ward, Gandimaisamme l4a_Qqe_t
Sri Narasingm Kiran Kumar, Bill Collector
(Outsourcing) at Ward Office, Bhadurpally Ward,
Gandimaisamma Mandal for accepting the bribe
amount of Rs.11,000/- b@
Fufther, the Director of Municipal Administration,
Telangana State, Hyderabad have also issued directions to
this office to terminate (AO-3) SriMahender Reddy, Bill
2.
Collector (PR Timescale employee) and (AO-4) Sri
Narasingam Kiran Kumar, Bill Collector (Outsourcing) from
service with immediate effect and report compliance vide
reference 2nd read above.
3.
Therefore, in exercise of the power conferred
under Section 48(1) T.S. Municipal ordinance 2O19.
And as per the instructions of the higher authorities
vide reference 2nd read above. Sri Mahender ReddyBill collector (PR Timescale emplovee) (AO-3) and Sri
Narasingam Kiran Kumar, Bill Collector (Outsourcing)
(AO-4) are herebv terminated from the service w.e.f.
O7.O8.2O19 i.e., date of traP."
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION :
SN,J
W.P.No.269l5 2019
5.
Learned counsel apoearinq on behatf of the
oetltioner mainlv outs forth the
foltowino
SuUAoISS!onEi
5.1 The
qned order dated 28.08.2(r 19 was
p6sea unitateralty, I
retitioner or afforainE a
re_tne oetitioner, ana
needs to be set aside.
Basi
coun
on the
aooearino
resaid su
ission,
on behalf of the
ed
oner
contends that the oetitioner is entiUed for the relief
6.
Learned standing counsel for Municipalities appearing
on l:ehalf of respondent Nos.2 to 4, placing reliance on the
averments made in the counter affidavit, submits that the
petitioner is working under the Municipal Administration and
that: the impugned order passed by respondent No. 4
terrninating the services of the petitioner under Section
SN,J
W.P.No.269l5 2019
48(1) of the Telangana Municipalities Ordinance, 2019, vide
proceedings dated 28.08.2019, is in accordance with law. It
is further submitted that there is no illegality in the
impugned order passed by respondent No. 4, as the same is
in conformity with the provisions of Section 4B(1) of the
Telangana Municipalities Ordinance, 2019.
7. Learned counsel aooearing on behalf of
resoondent Nos. 2 to 4 does not disoute the fact- as
borne on record, that no orior notice was issued to
the petitioner before oassino the impuoned order.
8.
The relevant oortion of the Apex Court iudoment
reoorted in 2O1O 1 SCC 126 in "Satwati Deswal vs.
State of Haryana and Others". at paraoraoh Nos.4 and
9, referrinq to the violation of the princioles of natural
iustice, is extracted hereunder:
"4. Admittedlv, in this case no show-cause
notice was issued tg her nor was the order of
termination passed by initiating any departmental
proceeding after giving opportuniW of hearino to
the appellant. This order of termination was
SN,J
W.P.No.269t S 2Ot9
challenged by the appellant by way of a
before the High court, which was dismissed
writ petition
by it on the
ground that the appeilant had an alternative
remedy to
file an appeal under the rutes before the appellate
authority against the order of termination.
9.
service and if such disciplinary proceedings
:
initiated, the authorities sha, give proper
are
opportunity of
hearing and permit the parties to adduce
evidence in
support of their respective stands and after
giving such
opportunity, the disciplinary authorities
thereafter shall
give hearing to the appellant and then
order on the question of termination of
pass a finat
service of the
appellant in comptiance with the statutory
rules
concerned applicable to the appellant.,,
I
l
isi
t'
I
I
,]
SN,J
W.P.No.269l5 2019
'3. From the order of termination Annexure P-7, it
appears that the same refers to the show-cause notice
dated 2O-8-2OO2 which is to be found at Annexure P-5.
It is stated therein that the appellant demanded
kickback with a view to help the complainant to get a
favourable order in the pension matter. That being so,
there was a clear charge of bribery levelled against the
appellant. No doubt. the appqllant was a
temporarv employee, but if he is sought to be
removed on the ground that he was guilty of the
charge of bribery, it becomes necessarv for the
respondent Union of tndia to hold an inquiry and
thereafter to act in accordance with law. In this
case, admittedly, no inquiry was conducted, and
that is obvious even from Annexure P-7, the letter
described as disengagement of casual labour. W€,
therefore, allow this appeal and set aside the order of
the High Court as also the order of termination
Annexure P-7 dated 30-9-2002. This, however, will not
prevent the respondents from taking action in
accordance with law."
10. This Court oassed interim order dated
1O.O1.2O2O in I.A. No. 1 of 2019 in the Dresent writ
oetition in favour of the petitioner. observino as
under:
l0
SN,J
W.P.No.269l5 ZOtg
"The petitioner submits that the respondents
have
terminated his services areging stigma
on him without
giving any opportunity before passing
the impugned
termination order.
The respondents have not fired counter
affidavit in
spite of giving sufficient opportunity.
continue in service.,,
11' This court opines that the impugned order
dated
28'08'2019 is in crear vioration of
the principres of
natural justice since no prior notice
was issued to the
petitioner before passing the impugned
'1ZOOO;9 Supreme Court Cases 167
order.
r
ll
SN,J
W.P.No.269l5 2019
L2. TAKING INTO CONSIDERATION:
a)
The aforesaid facts and carcumstances of the
case,
b)
The submissions made by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner and the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent Nos.2
to 4,
c)
The view of the Apex Court in the judgments
(referred to and extracted above),
\
\
d)
The fact, as borne on record, that the petitioner
was not given any prior notice before passing the
impugned order dated 28.08.2019 passed by the 2"d
respondent, which had even been admitted by the
respondents herein,
(
(
e) The discussion and conclusion as arrived at
paragraph Nos.S to 11 of the present order,
i
I
I
i
t2
I
t
SN,J
W.P.No.269l5 2Ot9
\
I
!
The writ petition is allowed, and the impugned
:
order of respondent No. 4t vide progs. Roc.
431 Estt/MC-Dundigar/2or9 dated
28.og.2o19, is set
asicle. The respondents are directed
to consider the
petitioner's request for reinstatement
into service,
with a' consequentiar benefits and retiefs,
period of three (3) weeks from the
No.
within a
date of receipt of a
copy of this order. However, there sha[
be no order
as to costs.
Misceraneous apprications, if any, pending
sha, stand
closed.
That Rule Nisi has made Absorute as above witness
The Hon'ble sRl APARESH KUMAR slNGH, The chief Justice on this Friday,
the Ninth Day of January, Two Thousand and rwenty six.
.MALLIKARJUNA RAO
STANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFICER
To,
The Principal Secretary, Municipal Admi
Department Secretariat, Hyderabad, State of
and Urban Development
na
2. The Director and Commissioner of Municipal Administration State of
Telangana, 640, AC Guards, Masabrank, opp pil Buitding, Hyderabad
3. Jhe Municipal commissioner, Dundigar Municiparity, Medchar Markajgiri
District
4' The Municipal Commissioner, Dundigal Municipality, Dundigal, Medchal
Malhajgiri District
5. The District Collector, Medchal Malkajgiri.
6. The Dishict panchayat officer, Medchar MarkajgiriDistrict
7. One CC to SRI S.RAHUL REDDY, Advocate tOpUCl
8. One CC to SRI RAMESH CHILLA, SC FoR SERVICE MATTERS
toPUC]
9. One CC to SRI G.MADHUSUDHAN REDDY, SC FoR MCPL
toPuc]
t'a 10'Two CCs to GP FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana at
W
Hydr=rabad TOUTI
11.Two CD Copies
,--.-
r
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 09/01 nA26
,i;S
.:)
1 6 r?ff m2$
,J
\
*
ORDER
WP.No.26915 of 2019
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
(
\6
.\
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review