Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
--t
[ 34851
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI
RAO
WRIT PETI TION N os:219 76 and 294O1 of 2016
IT
ETITI
N
: 21975 0F
Mallikarjuna.
.Nagar Welfare Association, Rep. by its president S.Swamv
yaoav s/o Muttarah.
aoed. 30. years, R/o H.No.2_X_2617g/8, Mallikariun6
:"fl,f,,I3rn,*1,8ilfi
La'^?:r;H,Iiqi,T#aY!"1;:l*:,!ztztL?a:'ff
Nagar, Uppal, Hyddrabad.'
..PETIT|ONER
D
1. The State of Telanoana,. rep. py its principal Secretary, Municipal Admn.
Department, Secreta;iat, HyairraniO'-
2 Greater Hyde.rabad Municipar corporation, Rep. by its commissioner, office at
Tank Bund, Hyderabad.
3. The .Deputy Commissioner, Greater Hyderabad, Municipal Corporation,
Uppal, Hyderabad.
4. M/s Ascend rerecom- rnfraskucture private Limited, rep. by its Manager, prot
No.332. H.No. 3712 Mani Mansion, Oetenie CoOnV, Sa'iniipuii HVa"iEniO'
5. Mallik Akbar Ari Kha.n, s/o.Late .Mailik Ari Khan, aged Major, R/o 2-22-26t35,
Plot No. 35, Chilka Nagar, Uppal, Hyderrbaa.- '
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High court may
pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or Direction,
be
more particurarry one in
the nature of writ of Mandamus, to declare the action of the 2nd respondent in
granting provisionar crearance/permission to the 4th respondent
company for
installation of Roop Top Tower (RTT) and rerecom equipments for broad
band
services in the premises belonging to the sth respondent bearing
D No.2-23-26135, Plot No.35, Chilkanagar, Uppal, Hyderabad, inspite of the
obiections r:rised by the petitioner and the locality people followed by written
rep resentaticrns, as being illegal, arbitrary and unjust and consequently
set aside
the provisional permission granted by the 2nd respondent in
Procs.No.l2ITPIPer/HO/TPS/GHMC/CT
12015 148 dt 20-1-2016 in so far Sl.No.3
is concerned
.A. N
P. NO: 27008 OF 2016
Petition under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the, provisional permission granted by the 2nd respondent in
Procs.Roc.Ncr. l2l fPlPerlHOiTPS/GHMC/CT 12015-48. dt 20.01.20'16 in so far
as Sl.No.3 is concerned, pending disposal. of the main Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI K.V.V.VEDANTHA CHARYA
Counsel forthe RespondentNo.l: GP FOR MCPL ADMN & URBAN DEV
Counsel for tlre Respondent No.2 & 3: SRI SRINIVASA RAO PACHWA,
SC FOR GHMC
Counsel for tlre Respondent No.4: MOHD ISLAMUDDIN ANSARI
WRIT PETITION NO: 29401OF 2016
Between:
M/s. Ascend Telecom lnfrastructure Pvt. Ltd., Plot No.332, H.No.37-2, Mani
Mansion, Defence Colony, Sainikpuri Secunderabad-94 Rep. by its Manager,
Sri Sadr: Venugopal
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation,
Commissioner, Tank Bund Road, Hyderabad.
Represented by its
2. The Zonal Commissioner, Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation, East
Zone, L.B. Nagar, Hyderabad.
Mallikarjun Nagar Welfare Association, Represented by its President,
S. Swarny Yadav S/o. Muttaiah, aged 30 years, R/o H.N o.2-23-2617818,
Mallikarjun Nagar, Chilka Nagar, Uppal, Hyderabad.
4. S. Narasimha Reddy, S/o Malla Reddy, Secretary, aged 42 years, R/o
2-23-261511A, Mallikarjun Nagar, Chilka Nagar, Uppal, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of tndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ or order or direction particularly one in the
nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondents No. 1 and 2
in interfering with the erection of the tower, which is being erected as per the
permission bearing ProcgsNo 12ITP/PER/HO/TPS/GHMCtCTt48t2016i399,
dated 20-01-2016 on building bearing H.No.2-23-26t135, Plot No.35, Sy. No.46
and 47, Chilka Nagar, Uppal, R R. District, at the behest of the Respondent No. 3
and 4 and not considering the representation dated 16-8-2016, as arbitrary,
illegal and in violation of well settled principles of natural justice.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2015(WP P. NO: 36406 OF 2016)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondents No.1 and 2 not to interfere in the erection of roof top
poles on the building bearing H.No.2-23-26135, Plot No.35, Sy. No.46 and 47,
Chilka Nagar, Uppal, R.R. District, pending disposal of the main writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI A.ROHIT SINGH, rep.
SRI MOHD ISLAMUDDIN ANSARI
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 & 2: SRI SRINIVASA RAO PACHWA,
SC FOR GHMC
The Court made the following: GOMMON ORDER
l'l
) '-)
IN THE I{IGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRI IUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION
Os.21976
D 29401 0 F 2016
DATE: 29.0L.2026
o.2l
of 20L6:
Between:
Mallikarjun,r Nagar Welfare Association,
Rep.by its P:esident S.Swamy yadav,
r/o.Chilka |Jagar, Uppal, Hyderabad.
.
... Petitioner
,A.nd
The State of 'felangana, rep.by its
Prl.Secretary, Municipal Admn. Department,
Secretariat, Flyderabad and four others.
. .. Responclents
ORDER:
Heard Mr. K.v.V.vedantha Charya, learned counsel for
petitioner in w.P.No.21976 of 2076, Mr. A.Rohit singh, learned
counsel for petitioner in w.P.No.29401, of 201,6 and Mr. srinivasa
Rao Pachwa, learned standing counsel for GHMC in both the writ
petitions.
2.
In w.P.Ir'[o.27976 of 201,6, the prayer was, to cleclare the action
of the 2"d resp<>ndent in granting provisional clearancef permission
\.
to the 4ft respondent company for installation of Roof Top Tower
(RTT) and Telecom equipments for broadband services in the
premises betonging to the 5th respondent bearing D.No.2-23-26/35,
Plot No.35, Chilkanagar, Uppal, Hyderabact, despite the objections
raised by the petitioner and the locality people, as illegal, arbitrary
and unjust and consequently, to set aside the provisional Permission
granted by the 2nd respondent in proceedings dated 20-01'.201,6 is
challenged.
3.
W.P.No.29401 of 2076 is filed by M/s.Ascend Telecom
In-frastructure Private Limited declaring the action of the respondent
No.s.1 and 2 in interfering with the erection of the tower, which is
being erected as per the permission bearing proceedings No.12 /TP/
PER/ HO /Tre / GH}/IC / CT / 48 / 2076 / 399
, dated 20 .0L.201.6 on
building bearing H.No.2-23/26/35, Plot No.35, Sy.Nos.46 and 47,
Chitka Nagar, Uppat, Ranga Reddy District, at the behest of the
respondent Nos.3 and 4 and not considering the representation
dated 15.08.201,6, as arbTtrary,illegal, and in violation of well settled
principles of natural justice is challenged.
.,, '.,]"
I
I
4'
since the issue invorved in
common, bcth the writ petitions
ancl disposecl of by this
5'
both the writ petitions being
being heard together anarogousry
common order.
The main grievance of both
respect of trre Celr Towers
the writ petitioners is that,
I
erected by M/s.Ascend Terecom
Infrasrructure pvt. Ltd., (w.p.No.2940r
admittedly, the respondent-GHMC
erection of said Celr Towers
TPS/GHNIC/ cT
in
of 2076 _ writ petitioner)
has granted permission for
uicre proceedings No.12
/
/Tp/pER/Ho/
/ 2a7s/ 4g, dated 20.01.2016 and the Mailikarjun
Nagar Deverop';rlgnl werfare
inhabitants of the locarity
Commissi'oner, G:HM., aileging
safety and hearth of pubric
Towers are erected and
Associatiory who are the
Iocal
have made a compraint to
the
that it wourd be endangering
at large in the vicinity if
that due to the emission of
the said towers, th:re is every
the locality peopre which
to the
the said ce,
i
radiation from
i
I
I
possibility of serious health
hazards to
may arso be dekimentar to the
birds and
I
I
I
envrrorunent of the locality
i
i
I
6'
As seen frorn the averments
admittedry, Ceil Tolvers are
i
in both the writ petitions,
I
i
I
I
proposed to be erected in
I
pursuance of
I
i
i
I
4-=
the due permission granted by the GHMC authorities. It is also
contended that during the pendency of the writ petitions, Cell
Towers have already been erected and. have been functioning as on
today. Be that as it may, in a recent past, there is a emerging new
technology which came out reducing the radiation from the cell
towers. In that view of the matter, as the cell towers have been
erected by obtaining due permission from the competent authority,
petitioner- M/s.Ascend Telecom lnfrastructure Pvt. Ltd., cannot be
directed to shift the said erection towers and therefore, the
W.P.No.27976 of 2016by the local inhabitants is devoid of merits.
7.
The W.P.No.29401 of 201..6, which is filed by M/s.Ascend
Telecom Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., declaring the action of the
respondent Nos.L and 2 therein in interfering with the erection of
the cell tower by issuing show-cause notice dated 10.08.20L6, basing
on
the complaint made by the Mallikarjun Nagar Welfare
Association, on the ground that due to installation of cellular tower,
the colony residents are fearing for heavy emitting of radiation, and
due to its radiation and side effects, the local inhabitants would face
the diseases and the cell tower management has not followed the
.\
-,f
.F
r
tt
structural stabitity. Admitte d\y, Mls.Ascend Telecom Infrastructure
pvt. Ltd., has obtained due permission from the GHMC ztide
proceedings d ated 20.01. -2076
8.
In ttrat view of the matter, it would suffice to direct the GHMC
to issue appropriate directions to M/s. Ascend Telecom
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. to upgrade its technology in accordance with
I
t
the ner,r, ernerging standards being followed in the recent past, so as
to reduce radiation levels and to ensure that there are no health
hazards to the local inhabitants.
g.
With the above directions, both the Writ Petitions are disposed
of. It is net:dless to mention that the GHMC shall address a letter to
the Teleccm Enforcement Resource and Monitoring Cell of
Department of Telecommunications of Government of India, with a
request to accord permission to M/s. Ascend Telecom Infrastructure
Pvt. Ltd., 1s, grant permission for upgrading into new technology
the interest of the M/s.Ascend Telecom Infrastructure Pv1
in
Ltd'' and
GHMC
inhabitants of the local resid.ents. As it is also stated that the
has already submitted a letter dated 01.08.2016 for up- gradation
cell towers r>f M/s. Ascend Telecom Infrastructure Pvt' Ltd' In
of
that
,
i
event, GHMC is directed to take further recourse
of action as
expeditiouslyaspossibleandensurethatthatM/s.AscendTelecom
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., upgrade the new technology
which reduces
the radiation.
10.
There shall be no order as to costs.
pending miscellaneous
applications if any shall stand closed'
SDT.P. PONNA KRISHNA
ASSISTANT
//TRUE COPY//
STRAR
OFFICER
To,
I ThePrincipalSecretary'MunicipalAdmn'Department'Secretariat'
Hyderabad.
2.TheCommissioner,GreaterHyderabadMunicipalCorporation,officeatTank
Bund, HYderabad
3.TheDeputyCommissioner,GreaterHyderabad,MunicipalCorporation,
UpPal, HYderabad'
corporation' East
Greater Hyderabad Municipal
4. The Zonal commissioner,
ilii"lt.g. Nagar, HYderabad'
Plot
lnfrastructure Private Limited'
Telecom
Ascend
M/s
Manager,
Hvderabad
5. The
'gi"/'i'Ml"i ili..ribii:#i;";; coionv, s'inikpuri'
No.332, H No
Advocate [OPUCI
6. One CC to SRI K'V'V'VEDANTHA CHARYA'
ANSARI' Advocate [OPUC]
7. One CC to SRI MOHD ISLAMUDDIN
r'
8. One CC to SRI A'ROHIT SINGH' Advocate tOl':
SC FOR GHMC IOPUC]
9. One CC to SRI SRINIVASA RAO PACHWA'
lo.TwoCCstoGPFoRMCqLA?MN&URBANDEV,HighCourtfortheState
of Telangan,
it HYderabad [OUTI
11.Two CD CoPies
BSR
BS
\.
a
HIGH COURT
DATED 2910112026
"
'fr
(
2 5 tr8 lrl2f,
i
COMMON ORDER
THE S
*
WP.Nos;.21976 and 29401 of 2016
DISPOSiING OF BOTH THE WRIT PETITIONS,
WITHOIJT COSTS
a4 a
yh
*.
?
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review