Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Rai Chattopadhyay
WPA 10583 of 2020
With
CAN 1 of 2023
Appejay Infra Logistics Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
For the petitioners
: Mr. S.N. Mukherjee, ld. Sr. Adv.
: Mr. Sagar Bandopadhyay
: Mr. Rudraman Bhattacharya
: Mr. Lalit Baid
: Mr. Saptarshi Banerjee
: Ms. Saberi Saha
For the respondents
: Mr. Bhaskar Prasad Banerjee
: Mr. Tapan Bhanja
Judgment on
: 15.05.2026
Rai Chattopadhyay, J. :(1)
Three notices of demand issued against the petitioner
No.1/company, for the alleged outstanding amount on
account of cost recovery charges, dated (i) April 4, 2016, (ii)
July 2, 2020 and (iii) November 10, 2020 respectively and a
letter of the respondent dated August 12, 2020, imposing
restrictions/suspension
of
movement
of
incoming
container/cargo, to the Container Freight Station [CFS] of
the petitioner No.1/company at Haldia/Kolkata port with
effect from August 13, 2020, are under challenge in this writ
petition.
Page |2
(2)
According to the respondent the writ petitioner/company,
being the notified operator of the CFS at Haldia port and
having been appointed as a ‗custodian‘ under provision of
section 45(1) of the Customs Act, 1962 of the goods
imported and meant for export through Haldia/Kolkata port,
via the said CFS, is obliged to pay to the respondent the cost
recovery charges, in lieu of the manpower deployed by the
respondent at the CFS, of which the petitioner No.1 is the
operator, in accordance with the Regulation and Circular
existing in this regard. The respondent says that the
petitioner company, though initially has duly fulfilled its
legal obligation of payment of cost recovery charges but
subsequently has failed to comply with the same with effect
from January 1, 2015 and has not remitted the charges any
further. Hence, demand has been raised by the respondent
firstly vide the notice dated April 4, 2016 and also
subsequently vide the other two notices dated July 2, 2020
and November 10, 2020 respectively. However, the exercise
culminated into futility as the petitioner company has
allegedly never paid any attention to those demand notices
for payment of the amount demanded on account of
outstanding cost recovery charges.
(3)
Due to non-remittance of the cost recovery charges by the
petitioner, as stated to have been demanded in terms of the
applicable Regulations, the impugned letter dated August
12,
has
been
restriction/directing
issued
suspension
against
of
it,
movement
imposing
of
the
incoming container/cargo to the company‘s CFS from
Haldia/Kolkata port with effect from August 13, 2020. The
said letter reads as follows:
Page |3
“ F.NO. S37(Misc)-102/09P(Pt)SOA
**
**
**
**
**
Dated: 12.08.2020
**
Sub: Restrictions/suspension of movement of incoming
container/cargo to M/s Apeejay CFS from Haldia/Kolkata
port with effect from 13.08.2020-reg
**
**
**
**
**
**
Due to non-payment of Rs. 5,04,51,775/- (Five crore four
lakh fifty one thousand seven hundred and seventy five
only) as cost recovery charges for the Custom Officers
posted at M/s. Apeejay Infralogistics Pvt. Ltd., CFS of the
period from 01.04.2016 to 29.02.2020, the following
restrictions have been imposed:
(4)
(i)
No new containers/cargo will be allowed to enter into the
CFS w.e.f 13.08.2020.
(ii)
The import/export containers/cargo which have already
entered into the CFS as on 12.08.2020, the
importers/Exporter/concerned parties are allowed to clear
their goods on(or) before 12.09.2020.
**
**
**
** ”
The writ petitioner‘s case is otherwise; that the said
company is not at all obliged under provision of any
Regulation or Circular to pay the cost recovery charges to
the respondent. The reason therefor has been stated to be
due to non-fulfilment of the condition precedent for such
charges to have accrued, by way of sanction of post meant
for CFS and actual physical deployment of the man power at
the CFS. According to the writ petitioners the provision
under
the
Regulation
or
Circular
applicable,
require
sanction of post and actual physical posting of personnel as
against those sanctioned posts. That, in case of the CFS of
the petitioner No.1, neither of these conditions have been
fulfilled by the respondent. Hence, no liability of the
petitioner company arises towards payment of any cost
Page |4
recovery charges whatsoever. The petitioners have stated
that for initial two years of operation such charges have
been wrongly paid due its own ignorance of law. Similarly,
for that reason only, the petitioner No.1 has once sought to
have the benefit of the waiver scheme, though such prayer
was absolutely irrelevant and inconsequential due to the
fact that the petitioners would not have any liability at all,
for payment of cost recovery charges. Hence, no question of
seeking any waiver could have arisen at all. The writ
petitioners say that as the company would not be liable at
all for payment of any cost recovery charges to the
respondent for operation of CFS at Haldia, the above stated
impugned demand notices may be set aside along with the
other letter dated August 12, 2020, as impugned in this
case.
(5)
The relevant facts leading to filing of the instant writ petition
is required to be discussed. On June 25, 2012 a Public
Notice No. 26/12 was published establishing Container
Freight Station [CFS] at Haldia, to be operated by the
present petitioner No. 1. On August 13, 2012, the other
Public Notice No. 34/12, has been published by the
Commissioner of Customs (Port) Kolkata, in exercise of
power under Section 45 (1) of the Customs Act, 1962,
appointing thereby the petitioner No. 1 as the ‗custodian‘ of
the FCL/LCL containers as well as over dimensional and
break bulk cargo, imported goods received in containers
from Haldia/Kolkata Port and goods meant for export
through Haldia/Kolkata Port, via CFS owned and operated
by it.
Page |5
(6)
The said Public Notice dated August 13, 2012 inter alia laid
down the conditions that the company had to execute a
bond of Rs. 18.60 Crores with surety and furnish a bank
guarantee of Rs. 1.86 Crores for a period of two years. It has
further
been
provided
that
as
a
‗custodian‘,
the
petitioner/company shall have to bear the cost of Customs
Officers ―posted at the Container Freight Station by the
Commissioner of Customs on cost recovery basis‖. Let the
relevant conditions as prescribed in the said Public Notice
dated August 13, 2012 be quoted hereinbelow: “
th
Dated the 13 August, 2012
PUBLIC NOTICE NO. 34/12
**
**
**
**
**
**
2. M/s. Apeejay Infralogistics Pvt. Ltd. as the custodian of the
goods meant for Import and Export will comply with the provisions
of Section 45 (2) of the Customs Act, 1962 as well as the rules,
regulations and instructions issued from time to time on the
subject relating to Handling of Cargo in the CFS governed by
Handling of Cargo in Customs Areas Regulations, 2009.
**
**
**
**
**
**
9. The Custodian shall bear the cost of the Customs Officers posted
at the Container Freight Station (CFS) by the Commissioner of
Customs on Cost Recovery basis and shall make payments in
advance on half yearly basis.”
The company thereafter was granted approval and
started operation of the CFS.
(7)
As per record, the petitioner company has made payment of
cost recovery charges as demanded by the respondent
authority to the tune of Rs. 1,83,82,420/-, for the period
from November 14, 2012 to December 31, 2014. The
petitioners say that, this has been done due to ignorance of
Page |6
it, in spite of no officers of Customs being posted at the CFS
during the relevant point of time. That, the petitioners have
been unaware of the condition precedent prescribed in the
applicable Rules, Regulations and Circulars, that any
demand by the respondent of cost recovery charges has to
be preceded with sanction of posts and actual physical
placement of the officers of Customs at the CFS. The
petitioners have stated that such mandatory precondition of
sanction of post and placement of officers have never been
complied with by the respondent in case of the CFS owned
and controlled by the petitioners and hence, the petitioner
company is not legally liable to make any payment towards
cost recovery charges to the respondent.
(8)
Permission granted to the petitioners under the Public
Notice dated August 13, 2012 which was initially for two
years period, was extended for a further period of five years
and finally, till August 12, 2019. Since thereafter, operation
of CFS under the control of the petitioners has been
suspended.
(9)
Waiver notification dated November 03, 2015 has been
issued by the respondent for grant of waiver of cost recovery
charges in the manner and extent provided by an earlier
Circular dated September 12, 2005. As a one-time measure,
waiver of cost recovery charges was granted to the eligible
facilities under certain circumstances as specified in the
said Circular. The Director General of Human Resource
Development was authorized to deal with the request for
waiver of cost recovery charges. It also provided that the
conditions for grant of waiver shall be same as provided in
the Exemption Circular of 2005. The writ petitioner applied
Page |7
for grant of waiver in terms of Circular dated November 03,
2015.
Vide
an
order
dated
February
18,
the
petitioner‘s request for grant of waiver was rejected on the
ground that the petitioner did not meet the eligibility criteria
in terms of the Exemption Circular of 2005.
(10)
In the meantime, in the Board Meeting of the Central Board
of Excise and Customs dated June 18, 2015, the Board
resolved in the following manner: “2. Giving the background to the scheme of posting of Customs
officers on cost recovery charges borne by the custodians, it
was explained that the process begins with the sanction of
posts as per prescribed staffing norms; staffing norms were
fixed vide Circular No.52/97-Cus., dated 17-10-1997 for ICDs
and CFSs and vide Circular No.16/2013-Cus., dated 10-4-2013
for Seaports, Air Cargo Complexes, Airports, Courier Terminals
and Diamond Plazas. The next step is the grant of exemption
from payment of cost recovery charges when the facility meets
the specified performance norms for two consecutive financial
years (Ref: F.No.434/17/2004-Cus.IV, dated 12-9-2005 and
Circular No.16/2013-Cus., dated 10-4-2013). The exemption is
always prospective. Simultaneously, the sanctioned posts are
regularized. For the Department, the implication of the sanction
of the posts on cost recovery basis is the promotion on ad-hoc
basis of the officers from within the sanctioned strength to
replace the officers who are deployed on cost recovery basis.
The implication of the grant of exemption and regularization of
the posts is that the custodian no longer pays the cost recovery
charges and the regularized posts get en-cadred in the
permanent strength of the Department. It was informed that
when considering cases for grant of exemption from cost
recovery charges, IFU / D/o Expenditure observed that in some
cases the posts were not sanctioned in the first place. This gave
rise to the following issues for decision:
i. Whether the sanction of posts could be done ex post facto?
ii. Whether the exemption from payment of cost recovery
charges could be granted to eligible facilities even if the posts
were not initially sanctioned?
iii. Whether the grant of exemption from payment of cost
recovery charges is to be restricted to the number of Customs
officers indicated in the staffing norms or could it be granted
for the total number of Customs officers actually deployed? This
issue is in respect of few facilities that were functioning prior to
Page |8
fixing of norms for staffing and grant of exemption in April,
2013 and wherein the number of Customs officers already
working on cost recovery basis was found to be in excess of the
norms.
3. In regard to the outstanding issues mentioned at Para 2
above, the D/o Expenditure has responded as follows:
**
**
**
**
**
**
ii. DoE cannot sanction posts ex post facto. Such posts may be
subsumed in the posts created during the cadre restructuring of
CBEC.
**
**
**
**
**
**
4. DG(HRD), CBEC has examined the comments of D/o
Expenditure and have furnished following comments:
**
**
**
**
**
**
ii. Though the posts were not initially sanctioned, exemption
from the payment of cost recovery charges may be granted to
the facilities that fulfill the specified performance norms. HRD,
CBEC has informed that the annual financial implication of such
exemption is Rs.149 cr. This cannot be viewed as financial loss
as such since it is Government policy to exempt the cost
recovery charges when the facility fulfills the performance
norms.
**
**
**
**
**
**
5. The Board was informed that further, this matter had been
discussed with Member (P&V) and DG(HRD) in the meeting
chaired by Chairman (CBEC) on 06.05.2015. The consensus
arrived was as under:
i. 1,630 diverted posts that were not sanctioned may be
subsumed in existing cadre strength.
**
**
**
**
**
**
6. On the basis of above, following proposals were placed before
Board for consideration:
i. Allow, as a one-time measure, Chief Commissioner of
Customs to exempt as per norms, cost recovery charges for
eligible facilities for which posts were not sanctioned.
DG(HRD), CBEC would monitor the action; and
ii. Exempt cost recovery charges for the entire staff sanctioned
for which cost recovery charges were taken for eligible
Page |9
facilities even if it is in excess of the 2013 norms. D/o
Expenditure would deal with these cases.
**
**
**
**
**
**
Thus, the Board decided that:
a) 1,630 diverted posts that were not sanctioned but were
diverted to various facilities on cost recovery basis would be
subsumed in the Department's existing cadre strength.”
(11)
Subsequently, an office order dated February 23, 2016 was
issued stating inter alia that the diverted posts that were not
sanctioned but were diverted to various facilities on cost
recovery basis has been subsumed in the existing cadre
strength of Kolkata Customs Commissionerate. From the
‗Annexure- A‘ annexed therewith, it transpires that a total
number of eight posts as against the CFS of petitioner No. 1
at Haldia have been subsumed by the respondent in the
existing
cadre
strength
of
Kolkata
Customs
Commissionerate.
(12)
On April 04, 2016, the first impugned demand notice was
issued by the respondent authority towards the writ
petitioners, demanding cost recovery charges for the period
from January 01, 2015 to March 31, 2016, as per
Regulation 5 (2) of Regulation of 2009. The ―Handling of
Cargo in Customs Areas Regulations, 2009‖ came into
operation vide notification No. 26/2009–Cus. (N.T.) with
effect from March 17, 2009. Regulation 5 thereof lay down
the conditions which have to be fulfilled by a customs cargo
service provider like the present petitioner No. 1, to be
eligible for the benefit of waiver of cost recovery charges.
Regulation 6 of the same provides for the responsibility of
such customs cargo service providers. As per Regulation
6(1)(o) the customs cargo service provider has to bear the
P a g e | 10
cost of the Customs Officers posted by the authority, on cost
recovery basis and has to make payment for the same at
such rates and manner specified by the Government of India
in the Ministry of Finance, unless specifically exempted by
an order of the said Ministry.
(13)
A Circular dated March 23, 2009 is in the nature of
clarification of the said Regulations of 2009 mentioned
above. Provisions have been made therein for exemption of
cost recovery charges. It is necessary that relevant portion
from there be quoted: “5.1. Regulation 5 provides the conditions to be fulfilled
by an applicant who wishes to be appointed as a
custodian of the imported/ export goods in a customs
area (ICD/CFS etc.). An exhaustive list of infrastructure
and operational requirements for efficient handling of
imported or export goods has been provided. Further, it
may be noted that
sufficient discretion has also been provided for the
Commissioner of Customs to decide on the nature of
infrastructure and equipments required to be installed at
the premises of CCSP. Hence, it may be ensured that all
the facilities provided by the custodians are sufficient for
efficient handling of cargo. It is clarified that the facilities
required for handling cargo at a particular ICD/ CFS etc.
need not be the same as at any other ICDs/ CFSs/ other
customs areas at another place in the country. However,
the facilities should be sufficient to enable efficient
handling of the cargo having regard to the volume of
containers/ cargo and its nature, etc. required to be
handled at the particular ICD/CFS/ customs area. In some
of the conditions in the regulations where it has been so
specified, the Commissioner of Customs can lay down
certain general standards or requirements such as height
of boundary wall, quantum and specifications of material
handling and other equipments etc., to ensure that the
facilities are adequate for effective and efficient handling
of cargo.
5.2. As regards the requirement of the Customs EDI
Systems under Regulation 5(1)(j), the infrastructure
required to be provided by the custodian shall include the
P a g e | 11
Civil and electrical infrastructure including properly airconditioned office space, cabins with proper furniture,
power backup facilities, hardware, networking and
secure connectivity to customs data centres for customs
officers and service centres specified by Customs.
Facilities required for secure exchange of electronic
information between the custodian and Customs shall
also be provided. The technical requirements shall be as
per the specifications prescribed by the Directorate
General of Systems & Data Management. In addition to
the above, the requirements as specified vide Board's
Circular No.94/2003-Customs dated 31.10.2003 to bring
uniformity in automation and to expedite automation
process at ICDs / CFSs, shall continue to apply.
5.3. The charges in respect of the Customs officers
deployed
at
the
customs
clearance
facility
(ICD/CFS/port/airport etc.) are required to be paid by the
Custodian, unless these have been exempted for an
individual custodian by an order issued by the Ministry of
Finance or by a circular or instructions issued by the
Ministry of Finance [Regulation 5(2)]. Payment of cost
recovery charges in respect of ports and airports has been
exempted for three categories of custodians specified in
Circular No.27/2004-Customs dated 6.4.2004. It is
clarified that these specified categories of custodians at
ports / airports would continue to be exempt from the
payment of charges for the customs officers deployed
therein.
5.4. In terms of the Greenfield Airports Policy framed by
the Government and notified by the Ministry of Civil
Aviation for setting up of private greenfield airports, it
has been specified that in case of an international
airport, the applicant for setting up of a greenfield
airport will obtain clearance from the Department of
Revenue for provision of Custom services. The cost of
providing these services will have to be borne by the
Airport Company. Hence, such custodians shall also be
required to pay cost recovery charges in terms of the
extant policy.
5.5. As regards ICDs / CFSs, Government had taken a
decision to waive the requirement of cost recovery
charges to be paid by ICD / CFS, if they fulfill the laid
down norms and are in existence for a consecutive period
of two financial years. These norms include parameters
such as the total number of import or export containers
handled, the customs declarations filed for import or
export, etc. Board’s instructions vide D.O. letter
F.No.A.11018/12/2008-Ad.IV dated 2.7.2008 refer in this
P a g e | 12
regard. Accordingly, the eligible ICDs / CFSs which fulfill
the laid down criteria are being considered for exemption
from payment of cost recovery charges and specific
orders in individual cases are issued by Ad.IV Section.
These orders are being referred to as the orders issued by
the Ministry of Finance under the Regulation 5(2).
5.6. Imported or export goods lying unclaimed, uncleared
or abandoned in ICDs / CFSs / customs area shall be
disposed of within the specified time by the CCSP who is
holding custody of the such goods. [Regulation 6(1)(m)].
Accordingly, it may be ensured that the existing Board’s
instructions for proper and timely disposal of unclaimed,
uncleared or abandoned goods as per Circular
No.50/2005-Customs dated 1.12.2005 as amended, are
properly followed.”
(14)
After issuance of demand notice by the respondent against
the petitioners dated April 04, 2016, the petitioners
challenged the same before the Delhi High Court. The
petitioner also challenged the order of the respondent dated
February 18, 2016 by which the petitioner‘s prayer for grant
of waiver has been rejected. The Division Bench of Delhi
High Court has decided the matter vide its judgment dated
September 24, 2020. The Court held that, the petitioner‘s
challenge as to Regulation 5 (2) of the Handling of Cargo in
Customs Areas Regulations, 2009 was not sustainable in
view of the authoritative decision of the Supreme Court in
Allied ICD services Limited Vs. Union of India and
Others reported in 2018 SCC OnLine Delhi 10816. The
Supreme Court in the said judgment has upheld the
impugned provision of Regulations. Therefore, the Division
Bench of Delhi High Court in the said case only adjudicated
the petitioner‘s prayer regarding invalidity and setting aside
of the impugned demand notice dated April 04, 2016 issued
by the respondent authority. The Court held further that the
petitioner had failed to satisfy conditions for becoming
eligible for any exemption and dismissed the writ petition
P a g e | 13
filed by the same. The Division Bench of Delhi High Court
vide its order dated September 28, 2020 noted that the
petitioner wishes to challenge the quantification of the cost
recovery
charges
on
the
grounds
other
than
those
mentioned in WP(C) 5581 of 2016. The Court held that the
issue of quantification of cost recovery charges has not been
decided in the said writ petition but only the question of
validity of the provision of the Regulation 2009, has been
decided, that is in affirmative.
(15)
In the meantime, the Joint Commissioner of Customs and
SPS issues a letter to the petitioner No. 1 dated July 02,
2020 on demand of cost recovery charges totalling an
amount of Rs. 5,04,51,775/- for the Officers posted at the
CFS.
(16)
The impugned letter dated August 12, 2020 was issued
thereafter by the authority thereby restricting and/or
suspending movement of incoming container/cargo to the
petitioner‘s CFS from Haldia/Kolkata Port with effect from
August 13, 2020. The relevant portion of that letter have
been quoted above.
(17)
Finally, the third and last demand notice has been sent by
the authority to the petitioner company dated November 10,
2020 demanding the amount of cost recovery charges, stated
to have remained due and outstanding for the period from
January 01, 2015 to August 12, 2020, totalling a sum of Rs.
6,75,15,678/-, less the amount already realized by the
respondent by invocation of the bank guarantee earlier
submitted by the petitioner to the tune of Rs. 52,10,000/-.
P a g e | 14
(18)
Hence, in this writ petition, the three demand notices as
mentioned
above
and
the
letter
of
imposition
of
restriction/suspension of movement at the CFS of the
petitioner No. 1 dated August 12, 2020 have been challenged
with the prayer to set aside all of those.
The petitioner’s argument: (19)
Mr. S. N. Mukherjee, Learned Senior Counsel has appeared
for the writ petitioners. He has referred to the Regulations,
2009 and the subsequent clarificatory notification dated
March 23, 2009. He says that, sanction of post for the CFS
and actual physical deployment of Customs Officers therein
are the necessary and mandatory precondition upon which
the petitioner‘s liability to pay the cost recovery charges
actually depend.
(20)
He has relied on another circular No. 52/97-Cus dated
October 17, 1997. It is submitted that as per the same,
customs officers/staff are required to be posted on cost
recovery basis at customs facilities including CFSs. It is
submitted that for the said purpose, posts have to be created
and such posts shall operate and continue only with due
approval of the competent authority. The competent authority
for grant of approval for creation and continuation of posts on
cost recovery basis is the Department of Expenditure in the
Directorate General of Human Resource Development of the
respondent No.2/Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs,
Government of India, Department of Revenue.
(21)
The writ petitioners have alleged that no such post has been
either sanctioned or created by the said competent authority
P a g e | 15
to be deployed at the CFS with respect to which the writ
petitioner No.1 is the custodian. Mr. Mukherjee, Learned
Senior Counsel, by referring to the circular dated October 17,
1997 has submitted that though staff of all Inland Container
Depots [ICDs] and Container Freight Stations [CFSs] notified
are referred to therein, the sanction was granted only in
respect of the ICDs and not for the CFSs.
(22)
Mr. Mukherjee, Learned Senior Counsel has further referred
to the ―Handling of Cargo in Customs Areas Regulations,
2009‖
and
the
subsequent
clarificatory
circular
dated
September 23, 2009. He says that as per Regulation 6(1)(o) of
the same, the petitioner No.1 being a customs cargo service
provider, has to bear the cost of the customs officers posted
by the Principal Commissioner or the Commissioner of
Customs, on cost recovery basis and has to make payment
for the same at the stipulated rate and the specified manner.
The writ petitioners‘ argument is that in order that such
charges become payable, a necessary precondition is that the
posts be sanctioned and the officers be physically posted at
the end of the service provider. According to the writ
petitioners
in
their
case,
none
of
these
necessary
preconditions have been fulfilled by the respondent authority.
Hence, they say that any claim of cost recovery charges or of
imposition of restriction due to the alleged non fulfilment of
the same, to which the petitioner No.1 has been subjected to,
tantamount to gross arbitrariness and illegality, on part of
the respondent authorities.
(23)
It is further submitted that as per the circular dated
September 23, 2009, the charges in respect of the customs
P a g e | 16
officers deployed at the customs clearance facility are
generally required to be paid by the custodian, unless the
same have been exempted. This has been relied on to further
buttress the petitioners‘ contention that actual physical
deployment of customs officer is the mandatory prerequisite
for recovery of any charges on cost recovery basis from the
CFS of the writ petitioner No.1 in this case.
(24)
According to Mr.
Mukherjee,
Learned Senior Counsel,
remittance of charges for cost recovery by the writ petitioner
for the period from November 14, 2012 to December 31,
2014, to the tune of Rs.1,83,82,420/- or its prayer to seek
waiver of such charges have only been due to ignorance of the
company about the mandatory prerequisites necessary to be
fulfilled for imposition of any such charges. That the
petitioner is not at all liable for and cannot be forced to pay
the cost recovery charges if the aforementioned conditions
precedent are not met, which would require the sanction and
creation of a post and the actual physical deployment of the
customs officers for any such charges to be applicable in the
case of the writ petitioner company.
(25)
The writ petitioners have also relied on a statement from the
website of the respondent No.7, containing the list of posts
sanctioned for creation on cost recovery basis at ICDs/CFSs
et cetera for the period from January 1, 2014 to December
21, 2019. On the basis of the same Mr. Mukherjee, Learned
Senior Counsel has submitted that no posts on cost recovery
basis can be seen to have been sanctioned for the Haldia CFS
operated by the petitioners/company during the period from
January 1, 2014 to December 31, 2019. It is mentioned that
P a g e | 17
the petitioner/company‘s name does not figure in the said list
though
the
same
contains
names
and
other
related
particulars of 85 ICDs and CFSs. For those 85 ICDs and
CFSs posts have been duly sanctioned and created on cost
recovery basis, since January 1, 2014, but not for the
petitioner company.
(26)
Lastly, the writ petitioners have expressed their grievance to
the respondent authority by dint of a letter dated November
3, 2020 and made request to withdraw the said demand
notices and the restriction imposed as regards the operations
of the said CFS, which was allegedly illegal and not
sustainable. The last demand notice has been issued against
the petitioner company dated November 10, 2020, for a total
amount of Rs. 6,23,05,678/- for the total period starting from
January 1, 2015 till suspension of operation of the petitioner
company that is, till August 12, 2020, including deduction of
an amount of Rs. 52,10,000/-realised by the respondent after
invoking the bank guarantee.
(27)
According to the writ petitioner it is an admitted fact that cost
recovery posts of Customs officers stood subsumed in the
department‘s existing cadre strength since the diverted posts
have been treated as absorbed in the existing cadre strength.
That, once those posts were subsumed in the existing cadre
strength there is no question of any future liability of the writ
petitioner towards payment in respect of the manpower, who
got subsumed and regularised in the existing cadre. That, it
is only when fresh posts on cost recovery basis for the
petitioner‘s CFS are sanctioned in the manner prescribed, its
liability towards making payments on cost recovery basis can
P a g e | 18
accrue. According to the petitioner it is only for the sake of
record and documentation that deployment figure is shown
by the respondent in fraction which itself proves that there
was no actual physical deployment of any person or even any
sanction therefor. Also, that no record is available there
pertaining to the purported posting of any Officer there.
(28)
The following judgments have been relied on by Mr.
Mukherjee, Learned Senior Counsel in support of the
arguments advanced by him:
(a) Allied ICD Services Limited versus Union of
India & Others at 2018 SCC Online Del 10816;
[cost recovery charges are in the nature of ―fee‖ for
services rendered by the customs officers at the
concerned CFS; cost recovery charges are to be levied
and imposed at a particular rate on the basis of total
salary of the officers posted at the CFSs].
(b) R.K.Sabharwal & Others versus State of
Punjab & Others at (1995) 2 SCC 745. [for
deployment/posting, a post should exist being duly
sanctioned; in other word in absence of a sanctioned
post a person cannot be posted or deployed there].
The respondent’s argument: (29)
The respondent has been represented by Mr. Bhaskar Prasad
Banerjee, Learned Advocate. He submits that admittedly the
petitioner‘s CFS is a ‗customs area‘ notified under section 8 of
P a g e | 19
the Customs Act, vide the public notice dated June 25, 2012.
That the petitioner is the designated ‗custodian‘ vide the
public notice dated August 13, 2012. Also, that the petitioner
by furnishing bond with bank guarantee in favour of the
respondent, has undertaken and is duty bound to ensure
compliance of the statutory provision as regards payment of
charges and indemnify the authorities for loss, if any. Mr.
Banerjee
has
submitted
strongly
that
the
petitioner‘s
endeavour to deny enjoyment of the services provided by the
customs authorities is condemnable insofar as without the
active support of the customs authorities, the CFS of the writ
petitioner could not have been operated for such a long
period of time. That, in order to run the CFS the petitioner
had to compulsorily obtain permission of customs without
which it could not have operated at all and the permission
includes deployment of customs officer in the CFS of the
petitioner. Mr. Banerjee has relied on the affidavit in
opposition filed by the respondent to narrate the manner of
deployment to the CFS of the petitioner and demand of cost
recovery charges from the same.
(30)
Mr. Banerjee, Learned Advocate has submitted further that in
terms of the Handling of Cargo in Customs Area Regulation,
2009, the Commissioner of Customs Port is authorised for
overall implementation of the policy including ensuring
deployment/posting
of
the
customs
officer
for
normal
functioning of the CFS, which has been duly done in case of
the writ petitioner. In lieu thereof, it is submitted, that the
petitioner is obliged to meet the cost recovery charges. That,
only upon the petitioner having undertaken to remit the cost
recovery charges in lieu of services to be provided by the
P a g e | 20
customs officers in the CFS, it has been accorded permission
for commencement of operation. He further states that the
petitioner has been paying the cost recovery charges for a
long period of time without raising any dispute as regards its
own liability for the same. That, all on a sudden it has
stopped and discontinued remitting the cost recovery charges
and challenged as to imposition of the cost recovery charges
and also the vires of the regulations before the Delhi High
Court. The respondent contends and the petitioner has not
denied, that the Delhi High Court has dismissed such
challenge by the petitioner, vide an order dated September
24, 2020. According to the respondent the Court has left
open the only issue of quantification of cost recovery charges
which stands due and payable by the petitioner. Therefore,
Mr. Banerjee has submitted that the petitioner has no scope
to reopen the issue of applicability of cost recovery charges
against the same before this Court, as the issue has already
been decided and settled finally by the above order passed by
the Delhi High Court.
(31)
So far as the question of quantification of the cost recovery
charges to be remitted by the petitioner is concerned,
according to the said respondent the same involves various
disputed questions of fact which need to be tested on
evidence before an appropriate forum. For the said part of the
dispute, according to the respondent, this Court while
exercising power of judicial review may not intervene.
(32)
Failure of the writ petitioner to remit the cost recovery
charges as demanded even after rejection of its challenge to
the regulations by the Delhi High Court, has led to issuance
P a g e | 21
by the respondent of the impugned order dated August 12,
directing
certain
restrictions
and
suspension
of
movement of incoming cargo of the writ petitioner. According
to the respondent there is no infirmity or illegality as alleged
as regards the said order in the facts and circumstances of
the present case.
(33)
Mr. Banerjee, Learned Advocate has stated that the petitioner
had been enjoying the commercial benefits by virtue of the
permission from the customs and deployment of the customs
officers; that, in such circumstances it cannot now contend
no liability as regards payment of the cost recovery charges. It
is submitted further that actual physical posting of Customs
officers at the CFS of the petitioner is a fact evident on
records and without the posting/deployment, the CFS of the
petitioner could not have functioned. Hence, according to the
respondent
proportionate
charges
regarding
posting
of
officers have been demanded from the petitioner similarly as
to the other CFSs.
(34)
It has further been submitted that for a long period of 3 years
the petitioner has been protected with the interim order
granted by the Delhi High Court dated June 3, 2016,
preventing the Department from taking any course of action
against it regarding non-payment of cost recovery charges.
Therefore, now after dismissal of the petitioner‘s prayer before
the Delhi High Court, the petitioner cannot bring to the fore
same challenge by way of filing separate writ petition before
this Court. The respondent says that the instant writ petition
is barred by the principals of estoppel, acquiescence and also
res-judicata.
P a g e | 22
(35)
Mr. Banerjee, Learned Advocate for the respondent has relied
on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Godavari Sugar
Mills vs State of Maharashtra reported at (2011) 2 SCC
439; specifically, paragraph 8 thereof, which runs as
follows:“8. The observations in Suganmal [AIR 1965 SC 1740]
related to a claim for refund of tax and have to be
understood with reference to the nature of the claim
made therein. The decision in Suganmal [AIR 1965 SC
1740] has been explained and distinguished in several
subsequent cases, including in U.P. Pollution Control
Board v. Kanoria Industrial Ltd. [(2001) 2 SCC 549]
and ABL
International
Ltd. v. Export
Credit
GuaranteeCorpn. of India Ltd. [(2004) 3 SCC 553] The legal
position
becomes
clear
when
the
decision
in Suganmal [AIR 1965 SC 1740] is read with the other
decisions of this Court on the issue, referred to below:(i) Normally, a petition under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India will not be entertained to
enforce a civil liability arising out of a breach of a
contract or a tort to pay an amount of money due
to the claimants. The aggrieved party will have to
agitate the question in a civil suit. But an order for
payment of money may be made in a writ
proceeding, in enforcement of statutory functions
of the State or its officers. (Vide Burmah
Construction Co. v. State of Orissa [AIR 1962 SC
1320 : 1962 Supp (1) SCR 242] .)
(ii) If a right has been infringed—whether a
fundamental right or a statutory right—and the
aggrieved party comes to the Court for
enforcement of the right, it will not be giving
complete relief if the Court merely declares the
existence of such right or the fact that existing
right has been infringed. The High Court, while
enforcing fundamental or statutory rights, has the
power to give consequential relief by ordering
payment of money realised by the Government
without the authority of law. (Vide State of
M.P. v. Bhailal Bhai [AIR 1964 SC 1006] .)
P a g e | 23
(iii) A petition for issue of writ of mandamus
will not normally be entertained for the purpose
of merely ordering a refund of money, to the
return of which the petitioner claims a right. The
aggrieved party seeking refund has to approach
the civil court for claiming the amount, though
the High Courts have the power to pass
appropriate orders in the exercise of the power
conferred under Article 226 for payment of
money. (Vide Suganmal v. State of M.P. [AIR 1965
SC 1740] )
(iv) There is a distinction between cases
where a claimant approaches the High Court
seeking the relief of obtaining only refund and
those where refund is sought as a consequential
relief after striking down the order of assessment,
etc. While a petition praying for mere issue of a
writ of mandamus to the State to refund the
money alleged to have been illegally collected is
not ordinarily maintainable, if the allegation is
that the assessment was without a jurisdiction
and the taxes collected was without authority of
law and therefore the respondents had no
authority to retain the money collected without
any authority of law, the High Court has the
power to direct refund in a writ petition.
(Vide Salonah
Tea
Co.
Ltd. v. Supdt. of
Taxes [(1988) 1 SCC 401 : 1988 SCC (Tax) 99 (2)] .)
(v) It is one thing to say that the High Court
has no power under Article 226 of the
Constitution to issue a writ of mandamus for
making refund of the money illegally collected. It
is yet another thing to say that such power can be
exercised sparingly depending on facts and
circumstances of each case. For instance, where
the facts are not in dispute, where the collection
of money was without the authority of law and
there was no case of undue enrichment, there is
no good reason to deny a relief of refund to the
citizens. But even in cases where collection of
cess, levy or tax is held to be unconstitutional or
invalid, refund is not an automatic consequence
but may be refused on several grounds depending
on facts and circumstances of a given case.
(Vide U.P. Pollution Control Board v. Kanoria
Industrial Ltd. [(2001) 2 SCC 549] )
P a g e | 24
(vi) Where the lis has a public law character,
or involves a question arising out of public law
functions on the part of the State or its
authorities, access to justice by way of a public
law remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution
will not be denied. (Vide Sanjana M.
Wig v. Hindustan Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. [(2005) 8
SCC 242] )
We are therefore of the view that reliance
upon Suganmal [AIR 1965 SC 1740] was misplaced, to
hold that the writ petition filed by the appellant was not
maintainable.”
(36)
Admittedly,
the
petitioner
No.1
was
appointed
as
a
―custodian‖ under Section 45(1) of the Customs Act, 1962 by
Public Notice dated August 13, 2012 and was permitted to
operate the Container Freight Station at Haldia subject to the
express terms and conditions incorporated therein. One of
the categorical conditions governing such appointment was
that the petitioner ―shall bear the cost of the Customs Officers
posted at the Container Freight Station by the Commissioner of
Customs on cost recovery basis and shall make payments in
advance on half yearly basis.‖ The said stipulation was
neither ambiguous nor contingent. The petitioner accepted
such condition unequivocally, furnished bond and bank
guarantee in terms thereof, availed the benefit of operation of
the CFS for several years and also admittedly remitted cost
recovery charges from November, 2012 till December, 2014.
Having consciously accepted the regulatory regime under
which the CFS was permitted to function, the petitioner
cannot now approbate and reprobate by contending that no
liability for payment of cost recovery charges ever existed. The
conduct of the petitioner in seeking waiver under the Circular
dated November 3, 2015 itself unmistakably demonstrates
acknowledgement of the subsisting liability; for, a party who
P a g e | 25
asserts total absence of liability cannot simultaneously seek
exemption or waiver from such liability. The plea that the
earlier payments and the application for waiver were made
under ―ignorance of law‖ is wholly unacceptable in the case of
a commercial entity operating a customs bonded facility
under statutory control.
(37)
The scheme of the ―Handling of Cargo in Customs Areas
Regulations, 2009‖, also militates against the petitioner‘s
stand. Regulation 6(1)(o) obliges the Customs Cargo Service
Provider to bear the cost of the Customs Officers posted by
the Commissioner of Customs on cost recovery basis unless
specifically exempted by the Government. The provision does
not make the liability dependent upon prior formal sanction
of posts by the Department of Expenditure in the manner
sought to be argued by the petitioner. The materials on
record rather demonstrate that Customs personnel were in
fact deployed for functioning of the petitioner‘s CFS and that
the facility itself could not have operated without customs
supervision and clearance support. The respondent has
specifically disclosed the manner of deployment and the
proportional recovery of charges. The petitioner‘s contention
that there was no actual deployment is contrary to the
admitted
factual
position
that
import-export
activities
continued at the CFS under customs control for years
together. A Container Freight Station operating under the
Customs Act cannot practically function in absence of
customs supervision, examination, sealing, clearance and
allied regulatory activities. Therefore, the argument that no
services were rendered or that no officers were deployed is
P a g e | 26
wholly misconceived and contrary to the operational realities
emerging from the records.
(38)
The principle of contemporanea expositio est optima et
fortissima in lege [contemporaneous exposition is the best
and strongest in law], also lends support to the respondent‘s
interpretation of the regulatory framework. The consistent
executive understanding of the Regulations of 2009, the
Public
Notices,
Circulars
and
administrative
practice
unmistakably indicate that operators of ICDs/CFSs are liable
to bear the expenses of customs personnel deployed for
facilitation and supervision of customs operations unless
specifically exempted. Such contemporaneous administrative
construction, particularly in matters involving specialised
fiscal and customs administration, deserves due weight
unless shown to be manifestly arbitrary or contrary to
statute. The petitioner has failed to establish any such
inconsistency. On the contrary, the petitioner‘s own conduct
over several years in remitting cost recovery charges accords
with the respondent‘s interpretation of the regulatory scheme.
(39)
The subsequent subsuming of diverted posts into the existing
cadre strength of the department also does not extinguish the
petitioner‘s liability retrospectively or prospectively in the
manner contended. The Board proceedings dated June 18,
2015 and the office order dated February 23, 2016 merely
indicate an administrative exercise by which diverted posts
earlier functioning on cost recovery basis were absorbed
within the departmental cadre strength. Such internal
administrative regularisation cannot automatically obliterate
the contractual and statutory obligation already undertaken
by the petitioner under the Public Notice and the Regulations
P a g e | 27
of 2009. The decision of the Board itself records that
exemption from payment of cost recovery charges is not
automatic but is dependent upon fulfilment of prescribed
performance norms and issuance of specific exemption
orders.
Admittedly,
the
petitioner‘s
prayer
for
waiver/exemption was rejected on February 18, 2016 on the
ground of ineligibility. Therefore, in absence of any specific
exemption order granted in favour of the petitioner, the
liability under Regulation 6(1)(o) continued to operate.
(40)
The petitioner‘s argument that in absence of formally
sanctioned posts no liability could arise, proceeds on an
overtechnical reading divorced from the substance and object
of
the
statutory
framework.
In
fiscal
and
regulatory
jurisprudence, courts consistently recognise the doctrine of
substance over form, particularly where commercial entities
seek to avoid obligations despite actually availing services
and benefits. The material consideration is not merely the
internal nomenclature or administrative classification of
posts
within
the
customs
establishment,
but
whether
customs infrastructure, supervision and manpower were
made available for operation of the petitioner‘s CFS. The
records
clearly
establish
that
customs
functions
were
continuously discharged in relation to the petitioner‘s facility
and that the CFS functioned under active customs control.
The petitioner therefore cannot evade liability by relying upon
internal
administrative
arrangements
regarding
cadre
sanction or absorption of posts.
(41)
Though
Mr.
Mukherjee,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
has
emphasized in his argument on the doctrine of strict
compliance, according to the Court in the facts of the case,
P a g e | 28
the
doctrine
of
substantial
compliance
would
be
the
appropriate principle to be applied here. The doctrine of
substantial compliance is a legal principle allowing the Court
to accept a party‘s actions as valid, if they meet the essential
purpose
of
a
law,
despite
missing
minor
procedural
formalities.
It
acts
as
equitable
tool
to
an
prevent
technicalities from overriding justice when the core objective
is achieved. The key aspect of the doctrine is that, it
differentiates between mandatory, substantive requirements
(which need strict adherence) and directory, procedural steps
(which can be relaxed). This doctrine prevents harsh
consequences and ensures that if genuine efforts have been
made to comply and achieve the ―intended use‖ or ―objective‖,
technical flaws do not invalidate the action, though by its
application, fundamental statutory requirement to constitute
the essence of the law cannot be touched.
(42)
In a recent judgment in Sumita Jha Vs. Aaone Developers
Private Limited [2025 SCC OnLine SC 1822], the Supreme
Court, though was dealing with absolute different fact
situation as well as legal context, has propounded a principle
that ―substantial compliance‖, in simple terms, refers to a
pragmatic
approach
whereby
Courts
in
exceptional
circumstances, recognize a party‘s partial or not-so-strict
adherence to the statutory procedural requirements, provided
the basic legislative intent is fulfilled.
(43)
This Court also finds considerable force in the respondent‘s
objection founded on principles of res judicata, estoppel and
acquiescence. The petitioner had earlier challenged the
validity and applicability of the very levy before the Delhi High
Court. The Division Bench by judgment dated September 24,
P a g e | 29
2020 rejected such challenge and upheld the regulatory
framework governing levy of cost recovery charges. The
subsequent clarification dated September 28, 2020 left open
only the issue of quantification of charges on grounds not
decided earlier. Therefore, the petitioner cannot be permitted
to reagitate before this Court the foundational issue that no
liability for payment of cost recovery charges exists at all.
Such an attempt amounts substantially to reopening an issue
already adjudicated inter parties. The limited question
surviving after the Delhi proceedings could only relate to
quantification, which necessarily involves disputed factual
issues regarding deployment, staffing pattern and calculation
of recoverable amount. Such disputed questions are not
amenable to adjudication in exercise of writ jurisdiction.
(44)
The judgments relied on by the petitioner are distinguishable
on facts and principle. The decision in Allied ICD Services
Limited (supra) does not assist the petitioner; rather, it
supports the respondent. The said judgment recognises that
cost recovery charges are levied in respect of services
rendered by Customs officers deployed at the concerned
customs facility. In the present case, the existence of customs
supervision and operational support is evident from the
continued functioning of the petitioner‘s CFS under statutory
control.
The
issue
in
the
present
case
is
not
the
constitutional validity of the levy but the petitioner‘s attempt
to evade liability despite availing the benefits of the regulatory
arrangement for years together. Similarly, the reliance placed
on R.K. Sabharwal (supra) is also misplaced. The said
judgment was rendered in an altogether different context
concerning reservation and operation of sanctioned posts in
P a g e | 30
public employment. The principles laid down therein cannot
be mechanically imported into the regulatory framework
governing
customs
administration
and
cost
recovery
arrangements under the Customs Act and the Regulations of
2009. The question before this Court is not whether a public
servant can hold a non-sanctioned post, but whether the
petitioner, after availing customs services and operating
under statutory permission, can deny liability towards cost
recovery charges on the basis of internal administrative
modalities concerning cadre sanction. The ratio of the said
judgment has no application to the controversy involved
herein.
(45)
The challenge to the impugned communication dated August
12, 2020 also fails. Once the petitioner persistently defaulted
in payment of cost recovery charges despite repeated
demands,
the
respondent
authorities
were
justified in
imposing operational restrictions upon the CFS in order to
protect revenue and ensure regulatory compliance. The
restriction
imposed
was
neither
arbitrary
nor
disproportionate but a consequential administrative measure
flowing from continued non-compliance by the petitioner. In
the facts of the present case, the respondent authorities
cannot be faulted for taking such action after the petitioner
failed to honour its admitted obligations under the governing
statutory and contractual framework.
(46)
This Court is also mindful of the limited scope of judicial
review in contractual or fiscal matters involving specialised
statutory frameworks. Unless manifest arbitrariness, mala
fides, patent lack of jurisdiction or violation of statutory
mandate is demonstrated, Courts exercising jurisdiction
P a g e | 31
under Article 226 ordinarily refrain from interfering with
administrative decisions taken in the realm of economic
regulation
and
revenue
administration.
The
impugned
demands are founded upon the governing Regulations, the
conditions of appointment accepted by the petitioner and the
actual
operational
arrangement
prevailing
between
the
parties over several years. No perversity or jurisdictional error
has been demonstrated warranting interference in exercise of
constitutional writ jurisdiction.
(47)
The petitioner‘s challenge also falls foul of the doctrine of
estoppel by conduct. Having represented through its conduct
that it accepted the levy and the corresponding regulatory
framework — first by furnishing security, thereafter by
remitting charges over a substantial period and subsequently
by applying for waiver under the applicable circulars — the
petitioner cannot now be permitted to assert a position
fundamentally inconsistent with its earlier representation,
especially when the respondent authorities altered their
position
and
continued
deployment
and
facilitation
arrangements on that basis. Public law remedies under
Article
are
equitable
in
nature,
and
a
litigant
approaching the writ court must do so with consistency,
candour and fairness. The conduct of the petitioner does not
satisfy those equitable standards. Accordingly, this Court
finds no illegality, arbitrariness or procedural impropriety in
the impugned demand notices or in the consequential order
imposing restriction upon operation of the petitioner‘s CFS.
The writ petition therefore deserves dismissal.
P a g e | 32
(48)
Hence, for the reasons discussed above, the instant writ
petition No. WPA 10583 of 2020 is dismissed; application
pending if any, stands disposed of.
(49)
Urgent certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite
formalities.
(Rai Chattopadhyay, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review