Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132s21
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: '15'12 I OF 2026
Between:
Annam Dasharath Reddy, S/o: A. Muthyal, Reddy Aged about. 50 years,
Occ. Business, P.No.24, Road No. 4, Jyothi Nagar Colony, Near pochimma
temple, KarmanGhat, Hyderabad.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, rep by its Prl. Secretary, General Administration
(SB)Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
2. The State of Telangana, rep by its prl. Secretary, Finance and planning
Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
3. The Superintending Engineer, Roads and Buildings electrical circle
Hyderabad
4. The Executive Engineer, Roads and Buildings EBD East Building Division,
Hyderabad.
5. The Chief Engineer, (RandB) Road and Buildings, lrrumanzil Hyderabad.
6. The Pay and Accounts Office, O/o Directorate of works and projects,
Nampally, M.J Road, Hyderabad -01.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Ariicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate writ or direction declaring the
action of the respondents in not paying the final bill amount against the Token No.
2522922185 dated 15.10.2024 for an amount of Rs. 33,29,404i- and Token
No.2601631016, daled 17.10.2025 for an amount of Rs. 3,64,164/- towards the work
completed by the petitioner as illegal and arbitrary and consequenily direct the
IEFTEF
respondents to pay the final bill amount Rs 36,93,56g1 sanctioned by the
respondents to the petitioner with interest from the date of completion of work till the
date of payment.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct the
respondents to pay the final bill amount against the Token No. 2522922195 dated
15.10.2024 for an amount of Rs. 33,29,404t- and Token No260i631016, dated
17 10.2025 for an amount of Rs. 3,64,164/- total amounting of Rs. 36,93,568 to the
petitioner forthwith.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI K. R. SRIKANTH
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: cP FOR GENERAL ADMINISTRATION
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 and 6: Gp FOR FINANCE AND PLANNING
Counsel for the Respondent No.3,4 and S: Gp FOR ROAD AND BU|LDINGS
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION No.15128 of 2O26
DATE: 15O6.2O26
Between:
Annam Dasharath Reddy
...Petitioner
And
The State of Telangana and others
,..Respondents
ORDER
Heard Sri K.R. Srikanth, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner, learned
Assistant Government Pleader for
General
Administration appearing on behalf of the respondent
No.1 and learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Finance and Planning appearing on behalf of
respondent Nos.2 and 6 and learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Roads and Buildings
appearing on behalf of respondent Nos.3, 4 and 5.
,)
SN,J
W.P.No.15128 of 2026
2,
The Detitioner a DDroach ed the Court seekinq
Draver as under:
". to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other
appropriate Writ or direction declaring the action of the
respondents in not paying the final bill amount against
the Token No. 252292218 5 dated 15.10.2024 for an
amount of Rs. 33,29,404/- and Token No.2601631016,
dated 17.10.2025 for an amount of Rs. 3,64,7641towa'ds the work-completed by the petitioner as illegal
and arbitrary and consequently direct the respondents
to pay the final bill amount Rs.36,93,568/- sanctioned
by the respondents to the petitioner with interest from
the date of completion of work till the date of payment,
and pass such other or further order or orders as deem
fit and proper in the circumstance of the case."
3. The case of the Detitioner in brief as Der the
averments made in the affidavit filed bv the petitioner
in suDDort of the Dresent Writ Petition is as under:-
3.1 The petitioner, being an experienced civil contractor,
successfully participated in the tender process conducted by
the 1tt respondent and was awarded the said works.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner duly executed and
completed the entrusted works as per specifications.
sN,J
W.P.No.15128 of 2026
3.2 Upon inspection, the respondents certified satisfactory
completion of the works by the petitioner herein. The total
value of the works executed by the petitioner was
Rs.44,00,000/- and Rs.19,00,000/- respectively. Out of the
said amount, the respondents paid only Rs.10,70,596/- and
Rs.15,35,836/- respectively, leaving a balance amount of
Rs.36,93,568/- payable to the petitioner.
3.3 The competent authorities sanctioned the final bills
and issued Token No.2522922185 dated 15.10.2024 for
Rs.33,29,404/- and Token No.2601631016 dated
L7 .10.2025 for Rs.3,64,764/ -.
3.4 Despite completion of the works, certification of
completion, sanction of final bills, issuance of token
numbers and repeated representations dated 03.02.2025,
09.02.2026 and 20.03.2026, the admitted and undisputed
bill amount of Rs.36,93,568/- remains unpaid without any
justification. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner
approached this Court by filing the present writ petition.
4.
PERUSED THE RECORD:-
SN.J
W.P.No.15128 of 2026
The relevant Dortio n of the iudoment
(A)
dated O8.O3.2O19 oassed in M/s. Surva Constructions
Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and othe
16 SCC 794
h
Tw
reoorted in
of h
x Court in Civil A
flsrn
out of SLP (C) No.295O5 of 2O14). is extracted
hereunder:
"...It is clear, therefore, from the
aforesaid order dated 22.03.2074 that there is
no dispute as to the amount that has to be paid
to the appellant. Despite this, when the
appellant knocked at the doors of the High
Court in a writ petition being Writ Civil
No.25126 of 2014, the impugned judgment
dated 02.05.2014 dismissed the writ petition
stating that disputed questions of fact arise and
that the amount due arises out of contract. We
are afraid the Hioh Court was whollv
incorrect inasmuch as there was no
disputed question of fact, On the contrary,
the amount pavable to the appellant is
whollv un disputed, Eouallv, it is r rell
settled th at where the Sta
behaves
arbitrarily. even in the realm of contract,
fhc lliah Cnr rrt enrr .l 1n fFrfara r rlr.lar A?ti.la
))R
+ha a^6cli+t r .rrr ri+ Trr/i'
r t^nl
^1
International Ltd. and Another v. Exoort
Credit Guarantee Corooration of India Ltd.
and Others' (2OO4 (3) SCC 553)1.
This being the case and the work having
been completed long back in 2OO9, we direct
the Uttar Pradesh Jal Nigam to make the
SN,J
W.P.No.1512a of 2026
necessary payment within a period of four
weeks from today. Given the long period of
delay, interest at the rate of 6 per cent per
annum may also be awarded.
The appeal stands disposed of
accord ing ly. "
(B) The
Dex Court n the iudo ent reDo ed in
Limit
r
lum
vs. Tamil N du Electricitv Board and
vide i udoment d ated 06.07 .2023. at
n
nother
raoraDh N os.39
and 40 observed as under:
"39. A Bench of two learned Judges of
this Court in Shrilekha Vidyarthi (Kumari) v.
State of U.P.a observed that there exists "an
obvious difference" between contracts
concerning private parties to those which have
State as a party. The primary difference being
that the State while exercising its powers and
discharging its functions "acts indubitably, as is
expected of it, for public Aood and in public
interest". The said factor singularly is sufficient
to bring into any transaction the minimal
requirements of public law, to which the State is
a party. The fact that a dispute Falls into the
contractual realm does not relieve the State of
its obligation to comply with the requirements
of Article 14.
40. Further the Court in Shrilekha
Vidyarthi case4 had observed that: (SCC p.237,
para 24)
SN,J
W.P.No.1512a of 2026
"24. The State cannot be attributed the
split personality of Dr.Jekyll and Mr. Hyde in the
contractual field so as to impress on it all the
characteristics of the State at the threshold
while making a contract requtring it to fulfil the
obligation of Article 14 of the Constitution and
thereafter permitting it to cast off its garb of
State to adorn the new robe of a private body
during the subsistence of the contract enabling
it to act arbitrarily subject only to the
contractual obligations and remedies flowing
from it, It is really the nature of its personality
as Sfate which is significant and must
characterize all its actions, in whatever field,
and not the nature of function, contractual or
otherwise, which is decisive of the nature of
scrutiny permitted for examining the validity of
its act. The requirement of Article 14 being the
duty to act fairly, justly and reasonably, there is
nothing which militates against the concept of
requiring the State always to so act, even in
contractual matters. There is a basic difference
between the acts of the State which must
invariably be in public interest and those of a
private individual, engaged in similar activities,
being primarily for personal gain, which may or
may not promote public interest. Viewed in this
matter, in which we find no conceptual difficulty
or anachronism, we find no reason why the
requirement of Ar-ticle 14 should not extend
even in the sphere of contractual matters for
regulating the conduct of the State activity."
(c) The r leva nt oortio n of the iu dqment
.o4.2022
Prade sh in Ka
s
h
a
Kotaiah v
n
he Sta te of
SN,J
W.P.No.15128 of 2026
Andhra Pradesh reoorted in MANU/APlO721l2022, is
extracted hereunder:
"The Aoex Court and this Court in
catena of decisions held that when there is
rt.rri-irtv'rrarr)
^f
}}ra
rrndicnrrfod
h
c tha
same is violative of Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India. The counsel for the
petitioner rightly placed reliance on the decision
of the Apex Court in Surya Constructions Vs.
State of Utter Pradesh and others, following the
judgment in ABL International Ltd. Vs. Export
Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd. Cited
supra. In view of the Apex Court judgment, the
contention of the learned Government Pleader
that the writ petition is not maintainable before
this Court could not be countenanced. The bills
of the petitioner dated 13.3.2019 are admitted
by the respondents and forwarded for payment
after due measurements and obtaining quality
control and the Vigilance report. Hence, the
authorities are estopped from stating that the
bills are submitted without executing the works.
On the mere ground of pendency of Vigilance
report, payment cannot be
stopped.
Accordinglv, there shall be a direction to
the respondents to pav the bill amount of
Rs.8,O8.828/- to the petitioner within a
period of six weeks from the date of
receiDt of coDy of this order,"
(D)
The relevant portion of the iudqment
dated 15.O3.2O21 passed bv the High Court of Andhra
Pradesh in Mutvala Veera enkata Satvanaravana vs.
The State of Andhra Pradesh reoorted in 2021
SN,J
w.P.No.15128 of 2026
SCCOnline AP 14L0, in particular DaraqraDh Nos.8 and
9, is extracte d hereunder:
"8. The provisions of the Act make it
clear that it is a welfare legislation meant to
create em ployment/eradicate unemployment in
TuTal areas and in the process to create durable
assets for rural India. Thus, it is clear that a
public element is involved in these works with
State participation and funding. The "States"
presence is therefore all pervasive in this
scheme. The law on the interpretation of
welfare legislation is also very clear. As held in
number of cases including K.H,Nazar v. Mathew
K Jacob case by the Supreme Court of India
"Judges ought to be concerned with the colour,
content and the context of such statutes".
Therefore, in view of the settled law and
keeping in mind the purpose for which the
legislation is enacted, this Court has to hold
that there is a public element involved in this
and that lt ls not a pure case of the State
enterlng into a commercial contract.
9. Apart from this when State or
Ct-+6
n
m n
ti + c aat ln
I h +r
manner or fail to act within time the Writ
Court does have iurisdiction to entertain
the matter. Even the case law cited by the
learned counsel for the petitioner supports this
to an extent. Besides this Court notices that
there is no method/mode for settlement of
disputes provided for. Section 23 of the Act and
Rule 14 of Schedule-I for example provide for
constant monitoring of the works/books to be
maintained etc. Despite this, there is no strict
denial of the exact quantum of work executed,"
SN,J
W.P.No.1512A of 2026
(E) The relevant portion of the iudqment
date
22.O3.20 2 Dassed b v the Hioh Court of A dhra
Prad esh in
W.P.No.
511 of
2022.
in oarti cu lar
paraoraph Nos.23 and 24, is extracted hereunder:
The H ioh Cou ofA dh ra
P ra esh in J Deven ra Redd vvKa
tiva
Univ rsitv and another
oorted in 2015
(3) ALp 97, hetd that withholding of the
amount payable to the petitioner for the
3 'l
contract works. constitutes oatent
arbitrariness on the oart of the
respondents and directed the respondents
to pav 2015 the amount due to the
oetitioner along wath interest @ 12olo per
annum.
24) The High Court of Andhra
Pradesh in S, Srinivas vs. State of Andhra
Pradesh and others reported in 2021 (5)
ALT 267 , held that th e oetitioner is entitled
ln +araci
/61 'l 2 Ola na
fF^an
+
of expirv of one month from the date of
submission of bill to till the date of
Davment."
(F)
The
releva nt
2L.
rtion of the iud ment
h
ou
W.P.No.11744 of 2O25 in oarticular paraoraoh No.5, is
extra cted hereu nder:
"5. Havin
reoard to the sub issions of
both the le arned counsel, this C urt deems
SN,J
w.P.No.15128 of 2026
it appropriate to dispose of the Writ
Petition bv directino the respondent
a uthorities to relea e the admitted bill
f.r tho
oetitioner, as expeditiously as possible,
preferably within a period of six (6) weeks
from the date of receipt of a copy of the
order. No costs."
-rrrar.rr+
af Pc t 16 E 1 aa,A nn L{rra
(G) The relevant portion of the order of this
Court dated 03.10.2023 Dassed under similar
circumstances in W.P.No.12655 ot 2()23 in particular
paraqraph Nos.12 and 13, is extracted hereunder:
"12. In the light of the pleadings and
arguments referred to above, it is clear that
there ls no dispute with regard to amounts
payable under Bill Nos.34, 35 and 36 It has
been held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
from time to time that writ jurisdiction per
ca aaitiiail' ha dcniad rrraralrr haarrrea fl'ta
disoute arose out of a commercia! contract
as held in Surva Constructions' case (Supra
1), ABL International Limited's case (Supra
2'l
and
Century Spinning and
Manufacturing Comoany Limited's case
(Supra 3). In Surya Constructions' case
(Supra 1), the Hon'ble Supreme Court
oranted relief to th e Det tioner there n
taking note of the fact that bills payable to
t h c nct I o n c r
rc rrnd €nr rfFal- In t h
instant case, the oetitioner stands on a
befter footino as the bills of the petitioner
are not onlv admitted but also certified. As
observed above, in the present case there is no
dispute as such between the parties. The only
ll
SN,J
W.P.No.15128 of 2026
issue is with regard to release of payment under
Bill Nos.34, 35 and 36 by the respondents State. No explanation is forthcoming from the
respondents as to why the amounts covered by
Bill Nos.34, 35 and 36 cannot be released.
Accordlng to the respondents, Bill Nos.34, 35
and 36 are pending for want of budgetary
clearance. On the face of it, action of the
respondents is arbitrary, unreasonable and
unjust and the same cannot be countenanced.
13. The contention of the learned
Additionat Ad!{acate General that the
petitioners have to approach civil Court
even for pavment of admitted bills runs
nt r
the sett azl laarl nr^nncili^n
This Court would also look into the public
interest involved. The project, as informed by
the learned counsel on either side, is an
ongoing project and the bills worth of hundreds
of crores are kept pending for no reason and
there is every possibility of non-release of
payment impacting the ongoing project and the
same would not be in public interest. Even for
this reason, this Court holds that the petitioner
has made out a case warranting interference in
writ jurlsdrction. Further, as there is inordinate
delay in release of payments covered by the
subject bills by the respondents to the
petitioner without any justification, in the
opinion of this Court, the respondents are liable
to pay penal interest. However, as against the
claim of l8o/o per annum sought by the
petitioner, this Court holds that the respondents
are liable to pay penal interest dt 9olo per
annum."
H
Th
d m n
f
he
Krishna Mandir Trust V. State of Maharashtra and
sN'l
W.P.No.1512a of 2026
Others re D o rted in AIR 20 O Suoreme Court
969 and
in parti cular oara Nos.lOO and 101 held as f llows:
" 100.
The High Courts exercising their jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of india, not only
have t he power to issue a writ of mandamus or in the
of mandamus, but are dutv-bound to
n atu re
exer cise such ower, wh ere the G vernment ora
D ublic aut horitv has f led to e xercise or has
wron lv exercise d iscretion conferred u oon it
bvast atute, or a rule, or a oolicv decision of the
Gove rnment or has e xercised s uch discretion
mala fide, or o irreleva n consider tion.
101. In all such cases, the High Court. must issue a
writ of mandamus and give directions to compel
performance in an appropriate and lavrful manner of
the discretion conferred upon the Government or a
public authority."
DISC USSION AND CONCLU SION:-
The I arned coun el aooearin o on behal f of the
et
n
r sub
hat
b ect i
tn
Dresent writ Deti tion is sou a relv cove red bv the order
of thi s Court da ted O2.03. 2025 Dass ed in W.P. No.
3345 of 2026 and hence, the Detationer is entit led for
the ora nt of relief as extended to the oetiti ner in
No. 3
5.
f20
o2.0
The learned Assistant Government Pleader for
Finance & Planning appearing on behalf of the
l3
SN,J
W.P.No.15128 of 2026
respondent Nos.2 and 6 does not dispute the said
submission made by the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner, in so far as the application of
the principle laid down in the said judgments
(referred to and extracted above) to the facts of the
present case on the point that when there is nonpayment of the undisputed bills, the same is violative
of Articles 14 & 16 of the Constitution of India and the
state is bound to act fairly.
7. A bare perusal of the record indicates that
petitioner received part payments and the competent
authorities sanctioned the final bills and issued Token
number 2522922LA5 dated L5.LO.2O24 for
Rs.33,29,4O41- and token number 26O1631016 dated
L7.LO.2O25 for Rs.3,64,L641-, but however the said
due amounts which had been admitted and
undisputed remained unpaid as on date without any
justification indicating failure on the part of the
Respondent Authority in discharging its function and
obligation towards the petitioner, hence this Court
1.1
SN,J
W.P.No.15128 of 2026
opines that subject issue needs consideration by the
respondents herein.
8.
TAKING INTO CO NSIDERATION:
a) The aforesaid facts and circumstances of the
case,
b)
The submissions made by the learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner and learned
Assistant Government Pleader for Finance & planning
appearing on behalf of the respondent No.2 and 6,
c) The observations in the judgments referred to and
extracted above and again enlisted below:
(i) (2019) 169CC794,
(ii) (2023) 8 SCC 24O,
(iii) MANU/AP / O72r / 2022,
(iv) 2021 SCCOnline AP 1410,
(v) The judgment dated 22.03.2022 passed by
the High Court of Andhra Pradesh in
W.P.No.251L ol 2022,
(vi) The judgment dated 21.04.2O25 passed by
this Court in W.P.No.11744 ol 2025,
(vii) The order dated 03.1O.2023 passed by this
court in w.P.No.12655 0l 2023,
(viii) AIR 2020 Supreme Court 3969
(d)
The discussion and conclusion as arrived at
paragraph Nos.S & 6 of this order,
l5
SN,J
W.P.No.15r.28 of 2026
The present writ oetition is also disoosed of in
terms of the order of this Court. date d 02.03.2026
oassed in w.P.No.3346 of 2026. directinq the
resoondents herein to consider the r quest of the
oetitioner for release of the a dmitted, undisouted bill
amount of R .36,93,568/- (Ruoees Thi y Six Lakhs
Ninetv Three Thousand Five Hundred a d Sixtv Eioht
tn
suoolv, fabri
to th work
n
tion, installation of eouio ent reouired
u
ofn w
R
nt
n
buildinos an d erection of MS oates at Dr. B.R.
Ambedkar Telansana Secretariat, Hvderabad, as oer
No.2 22 22
15.10.2 24
amount of Rs.33.29,404l- and Token No.2601631016
dated 17.10.2O25 for an amount ol Rs.3,64.1641-.
alono with interest, within a oeriod of eiqht (08)
weeks from the date of r
eiDt of a coDv of this order
dulv takino into consideration the observations of the
Aoex Court a d other Courts in the vario us iudqments
referred to a d extracted above and oa
approDriate
orders oertai inq to release of the said jue amounts
l6
SN,J
W.P.No.1512a of 202O
th
on
e ntitle men t. No
M iscella
h
r IN
ti
rder as t o cos ts,
neous petitions, if any, pending in this Writ
Petition, shall stand closed.
sD/-P. PONNA KRTSHNA ,,/
ASSIST NT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
1-.F
,
SECTION OFFICER
To,
'1
. The Prl. Secretary. General Administration (SB)Department, Secretariat
Buildings, The State of Telangana, Hyderabad
2. The Prl. Secretary, The State of Telangana, Finance and Planning
Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
3. The Superintending Engineer, Roads and Buildings electrical circle
Hyderabad
4. The Executive Engineer, Roads and Buildings EBD East Building Division,
Hyderabad
5 The Chief Engineer, (RandB) Road and Buildings, lrrumanzil Hyderabad.
6. The Pay and Accounts Office, O/o Directorate of works and projects,
Nampally, M J Road, Hyderabad -01.
7. One CC to Sn K R. Srikanth, Advocate [OPUC]
8. Two CCs to GP for General Administration, High Court for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
9 Two CCs to the GP for Finance and Planning, High Court for the State of
Telangana. at Hyderabad[OUT]
'10. Two CCs
to the GP for Road and Buildings, High Court for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad[OUT]
1 1. Two CD Copies
.TJ
BS
<w
--
'l
\
HIGH COURT
CC TODAY
DATED: 1510612026
1 Y\ e
T A rF
(
25JUN2U20
o
ORDER
WP.No.15128 ot 202G
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
($)
,L,
,q
t D FS ,P]C o
,
fi
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review