The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. In view of the above, dismissed at admission stage itself. 11:00:28 AM the instant public interest litigation is
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA
ON THE 16th OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 443 of 2024
BETWEEN:1.
ANKUSH JAIN S/O SHRI PAWAN JAIN 127,
ANURAG NAGAR, PRESS COMPLEX KE PEECHHE,
INDORE (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
CHETAN BADOLE S/O SHRI PRAKASH BADOLE,
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS, OCCUPATION: PVT.
SERVICE POST HAIDERPUR, TEH. NEPANAGAR,
JILA
BURHANPUR
HAAL
MUKAM
250,
PARIWAHAN
NAGAR,
INDORE
(MADHYA
PRADESH)
.....PETITIONERS
(SHRI ROHIT SHINDE, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH MUKHY
SACHIV MANTRALAYA, BHOPAL (MADHYA
PRADESH)
2.
PRAMUKH
SACHIV PICHHDA VARG AVAM
ALPASANKHYAK KALYAN VIBHAG MANTRALAYA
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
U P S A C H I V PICHHDA
VARG
AVAM
ALPASANKHYAK KALYAN VIBHAG MANTRALAYA
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
( SHRI ANIKET NAIK, DY ADVOCATE GENERAL FOR THE
RESOPNDENTS/STATE)
This petition coming on for admission this day, Justice Sushrut Arvind
Dharmadhikari passed the following:
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/18/2024
11:00:28 AM
ORDER
Heard on the question of admission.
Instant petition has been filed by the petitioner under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India in the shape of Public Interest Litigation praying for the
following reliefs:
''िपटीशनस के ओर से सादर िनवेदन है िक िपटीशनस के प म िनम्न सहायता दान करने क कृपा कर: अ) यह िक िपटीशनस के प म एवं रेसपांडेन्टस के िव
िवदेश छा वृित योजनान्तगत अपा
यह िपटीशन स्वीकार करके रेस्पाे ंडेन्टस के ारा
यूिनव सटी संस्थान को छा वृित जारी करके लाख करोड
जा रहा है जसे रोकने के लये रेस्पॉडे न्टस के िव
पय का घोटाला िकया
स्वतं एवं िनष्प जॉंच, योग्य िनदश एवं आदेश जारी करने क
कृपा कर◌ा
ब) यह िक, िपटीशनस को रेस्पॉडे नटस् से इस िपटीश्न का समस्त व्यय िदलवाया जावे ◌ा
स) यह िक, माननीय न्यायालय जो अन्य सहायता उिचत समझे व िपटीशनस के प
म रेस्पॉडे नटस् से
िदलवाये जाने क कृपा करे ◌ा ''
2.
Brief facts of the case are that petitioners operate consultancy
services under the name and style "Sajo Consultancy Pvt. Ltd" wherein
candidates/aspirants who want to study abroad are prepared for appearing in
entrance examinations of
international universities and on qualifying such
entrance examinations, petitioners assist them in obtaining visa . Petitioners
aiming towards social welfare also provide free assistance for appearing in
such examinations to those candidates/aspirants also who are not financially
sound. Earlier also, petitioners have preferred a petition which was dismissed
as withdrawn as the same is not drafted as per the format of Public Interest
Litigation as provided in the M.P. High Court Rules.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that Govt of M.P.
Ministry of Backward Classes and Minority Welfare Department has floated
scholarship scheme for those candidates/aspirants belonging to Backward and
Minority classes who want to study abroad in international universities. A
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/18/2024
11:00:28 AM
selection committee was constituted which has come up with certain eligibility
criteria that have to be fulfilled while taking admissions in universities abroad,
which are as follows:
a. Q.S. World ranking of the Institution/University (upto 500)
b. Admission should be based on the basis of offer letter issued by the
institution/University.
c. Minimum marks in the qualifying examination.
d. Maximum age of the candidate/aspirant should be 35 years as on
01.01.2021.
4 . Referring to the aforesaid eligibility criteria fixed by the selection
committee, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that since last few years,
they have noticed that respondents have given scholarship to students who
have taken admission in such universities which do not fulfill the criteria of
selection committee i.e. such candidates have also been given the benefit of
scholarship scheme who have taken admission in the universities which do not
come under the list of
Q.S. World University Ranking (till 500) thereby
breaching one of the basic eligibility criteria fixed by the selection committee.
5.
Moreso, petitioners have come across such cases also where the
respondents have given the benefit of scholarship to few students for two
consecutive years, though the course in which they have taken admission is
concluded in one year only.
He further submits that it has been clearly
mentioned in the offer letters issued by the Universities that duration of the
course is 12 months. Despite that, scholarship has been granted for two years.
There are few cases wherein scholarship was given to such students also
wherein reference of two different universities has been given i.e. in one year
scholarship was approved for university and in the next year scholarship has
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/18/2024
11:00:28 AM
been approved for another university.
6. Petitioners have written a letter to the Ministry of Backward Classes
and Minority Welfare Department , State of M.P. to conduct inquiry regarding
on going corruption in the matter of grant of scholarship to candidates without
adhering to the eligibility criteria fixed by the selection committee . Thereafter,
the Deputy Director, Backward Classes and Minority Welfare Department of
State of M.P. has sent a letter to the petitioner with regard to the complaint
made by him and directed him to submit evidence in his office. Looking to the
seriousness of the matter and keeping in view the principles of natural justice,
petitioners want a fair investigation in the matter for which they have written a
letter to the concerned department but till now no cognizance has been taken .
Grant of scholarship without fulfilling the eligibility criteria amounts to misuse
of public money and depriving the eligible candidates/aspirants from their
ultimate right. Respondents are approving scholarships even to aspirants taking
admissions in universities which do not fall in the Q.S. Ranking list of
Universities thereby breaching Article 21(A) of the Constitution of India.
Therefore, the present petition may be allowed and fair inquiry be conducted in
the matter and necessary directions be issued to bring such corrupt practices of
respondents to an end thereby saving interest of many aspiring candidates as
well as safeguarding the precious public money.
7. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents/State opposed
the prayer and submitted that the petitioners have not given their complete
antecedents and have also not disclosed as to what public interest work they
have performed for the Society. Learned counsel for the respondents has
brought to the notice of this Court the judgment of the Coordinate Bench of this
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/18/2024
11:00:28 AM
Court in the case of Surendra Pratap Singh Vs. State of M.P. and
Others[2019 (1) M.P.L.J. 75] to contend that the petitioners have failed to
produce on record to satisfaction of the Court such social work in last couple
of years in the area in respect of which Public Interest Litigation is involved.
Merely spending money like lawyer's fees from their own pocket does not
satisfy test of locus standi. Therefore, this writ petition is not maintainable.
8. The Division Bench of this Court in Surendra Pratap Singh(supra),
has referred to the judgment of the Apex Court involving Public Interest
Litigation in the case of State of Uttaranchal Vs. Balwant Singh Chaufal
and others[(2010) 3 SCC 402] wherein the Apex Court has laid down certain
guidelines to be followed before exercising jurisdiction of Public Interest
Litigation. The guidelines are as under :(1 ) The courts must encourage genuine and bonafide PIL and
effectively discourage and curb the PIL filed for extraneous
considerations.
(2) Instead of every individual judge devising his own procedure
for dealing with the public interest litigation, it would be appropriate
f o r each High Court to properly formulate rules for encouraging the
genuine PIL and discouraging the PIL filed with oblique motives.
Consequently, we request that the High Courts who have not yet framed
the rules, should frame the rules within three months. The Registrar
General of each High Court is directed to ensure that a copy of the RP
638/2017 Rules prepared by the High Court is sent to the Secretary
General of this court immediately thereafter.
(3) The courts should prima facie verify the credentials of the
petitioner before entertaining a PIL.
( 4 ) The court should be prima facie satisfied regarding the
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/18/2024
11:00:28 AM
correctness of the contents of the petition before entertaining a PIL.
(5) The court should be fully satisfied that substantial public
interest is involved before entertaining the petition.
( 6 ) The court should ensure that the petition which involves
larger public interest, gravity and urgency must be given priority over
other petitions.
(7) The courts before entertaining the PIL should ensure that the
PIL is aimed at redressal of genuine public harm or public injury. The
court should also ensure that there is no personal gain, private motive
or oblique motive behind filing the public interest litigation.
( 8 ) The court should also ensure that the petitions filed by
busybodies for extraneous and ulterior motives must be discouraged by
imposing exemplary costs or by adopting similar novel methods to curb
f r i v o l o u s petitions
and
the
petitions
filed
for
extraneous
considerations."
9 . Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that in the present
petition as well none of the aforesaid guidelines are satisfied as laid down in the
case of State of Uttaranchals(supra). Therefore, this writ petition is not
maintainable. Accordingly, the same is liable to be dismissed.
10. Heard, learned counsel for both the parties and perused the record.
11. From a bare perusal of the petition itself i.e. para 2.1, it is not clear
as to what social work petitioners are carrying out they styled themselves as the
owner of a Private Consultancy which provide necessary assistance to those
candidates who want to study abroad in universities. Apart from this, there is no
whisper of any social work being carried out by the petitioner.s It appears that
petitioners in order to gain publicity and with personal motive have come up
with such a frivolous petition which prima facie appears to be not maintainable
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/18/2024
11:00:28 AM
as rightly pointed out by learned counsel for the respondent/State.
1 2 . Except the averment in the petition that the petitioners are social
workers and the petitioners themselves are paying the fees of the advocate from
their own pocket, there is no assertion of their activities undertaken in the area
of the subject-matter of this writ petition. Simple self-serving statement that the
petitioners are social workers/public spirited persons is not sufficient to invoke
the public interest writ jurisdiction of this Court unless petitioners are able to
produce on record to the satisfaction of the Court such social work in last
couple of years in the area in respect of which the public interest writ petition is
involved. A practice in the cases before this Court is to make a statement that
the petitioners are social workers and they are spending the money including the
lawyer's fee from their own own pocket, that by itself does not satisfy the test
of a locus standi t o file public interest litigation. The public interest writ
jurisdiction was intended to vindicate public interest where fundamental and
o ther rights of the people who were poor, ignorant or in socially or
economically disadvantageous position and were unable to seek legal redress
were required to be espoused.
However, the individuals who are being
deprived of their ultimate right of such scholarship scheme floated by the
Ministry of Backward Classes and Minority Welfare Department having
grievance may approach this Court in individual capacity seeking ventilation of
their grievances.
13.
This Court is in consonance with the submission of State counsel
that in the light of the judgment passed in the case of State of Uttaranchal
(supra), this public interest litigation is not maintainable.
14.
In view of the above,
dismissed at admission stage itself.
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/18/2024
11:00:28 AM
the instant public interest litigation is
(S. A. DHARMADHIKARI)
JUDGE
sh
Signed by: SEHAR HASEEN
Signing time: 1/18/2024
11:00:28 AM
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review