Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 20125 OF 2024
Betweqn;
I
l
,
Andhra Pradesh Association of the Deaf, Regd. No.442 1350 Fasli, Affiliated to the
All lndia Federation of the Deaf, New Delhi. Office Room No. 1- 772. tt/odel School
for Deaf, Vl Pedda Amber Pet, Hayath Nagar fMandal, Ranga Reddy District, Rep. by
Venkat Reddy.
.....PETITIOI.JER
AND
1. State of Telangana, Rep by Principal Secretary, Energy Department,
Secretariat Hyderabad, T.S.
2. Chairman and fVlanaging Director, Telangana State SPDCL, lMint Compound,
Hyderabad
3. Divisional Engineer, Southern Power Distribution Company Limited,
Turkayamjal, R. R District, Telangana.
4. M/s. Telangana Welfare Association, for the Deaf Regd No. 132112016
Address 7- 55, Madhurapuri, Near Konark Theater, Dilshuknagar,
Saroornagar, Ranga Reddy, Telangana, lndia. Rep. by its Secretary
Venkata Ramesh Bellamkonda, S/o. Venkata Satya Sai Kumar.
( CT of R-4 is amended as per Court Order dated 09.09.2024 in
I .4.No.2120241.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ or order or direction more particularly one in the nature of a
Writ of Nlandamus or such other appropriate writ declaring the action of the
Respondent No. 3 in passing the impugned mutation orders dated 05. 01 .2017 in
mutating the name of the Respondents 4 in place of the name of the Petitioner
Association and by directing the 3rd Respondent herein to rectify and re-
incorporate the name of the Petitioner Association in the place of the 4
Respondr;nt Association in the records of the 3rd Respondent.
!.A.NO:1 rCF 2024
Pe':ition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affida'vit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to grant
interim slay on mutation issued by the Respondent No.3 in favour of 4the
Respondernt under reference No. cc90617993g7gg dated 05.01 .2017 as
othenarise the Petitioners will be put to irreparable loss and inconvenience.
|.A.NO: 3 OF 2024
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidarrit fileJ in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to pass
necessar)'orders permitting the Petitioner Association to take out a notice to the
Respondent No.4 in this Writ Petition by way of substituted service under order 5
rule 20 of cPC in any newspaper to be named by this Hon,ble court.
l.A.NO:t ()F 2A25
Petition Under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidal'it filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to pass
necessary orders permitting the petitioner to being on record the documents
per the enclosed list.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI DURGA PRASAD KOTAMRAJU
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 & 3 : G.p FOR ENERGY
counsel for the Respondent No.2 : sRl N.sREEDHAR REDDy (sc FoR
TELANGANA TRANSCO)
Counsel for the Respondent No.4 : SRI G.RAMA RAO
The Court made the following ORDER
i
as
V \r,
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI(A
WRIT PETITION No. 2O125 OF 2ol24
21.o1.20.26
Between:
Andhra Pradesh Association of the Deaf,
Rep. by Venkat ReddY
Petitioner,-
And
State of Telangana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Energr Department,
& others.
..... Respondents
ORDER:
Aggrieved by the order dated O5.01'2017 issued by
the 3.d Respondent mutating the name of the 4th Respondent in
place of Petitioner - Association, petitioner is before this Court'
They consequently seek a direction to the 3'd Respondent to
rectify and re-incorporate their name in the place of the 4tt'
Respondent Association in the records of the 3'd Respondent.
2.
Petitioner Association is represented by Sri Venkat
Reddy, who claims to be its Executive committee Member and
the only surviving member of the Management Committee
since the General Secretary and some of the Executive
Membel's have been charged with the serious offences uide FIR
No. 29C, of 2010 registered by P.S. Abdullapurmet in respect of
fraud ptayed bY them-
2.1.
It is contended, Petitioner Association has
purchased land totally admeasuring Acs. 16.08 guntas in
Survey Nos. 23O to 233 situated at Pedda Amberpet Village,
Hayathnagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District through Registered
Sale Dr:eds. Some persons with vested interest and who had an
evil eyr: on the said property got themselves registered as the
4ft Respondent Association in collusion with former Executive
committee Members of Petitioner Association and have
obtaint:d electricity connection in the name of the 4ttr
Resporrdent Association in collusion with Respondents 2 and 3'
Petitioner therefore, prayed to direct respondent authorities to
rectify the same by incorporating the name of petitioner
Associ,ation in its records.
, b.
Respondent No.3 filed counter contending that
after llifurcation of composite State of Andhra Pradesh into
State r>f Telangana and residuary State of Andhra Pradesh, the
4tt Respondent made an Application for change of name in
respect of SC No. 631801052 which was released in the name
of Moriel School for Deaf. Change of name was affected based
J
on the Application made by the 4th respondent along with
supporting documents and on being satisfied that they were
managing the said Model School. It is further contended that
petitioner, except making bald allegations, has not filed any
supporting documents to show that it was managing the affairs
of the school.
4.
Thq 4tf respondent fited counter denying the
allegations of petitioner. They have put forth the litigation
pending between various persons with regard to the subject
matter. Besides that, it is asserted, as per the averments in
the writ affidavit, the deponent himself stated that he is the
only surviving member of the Management Committee of
Petitioner Association and he has not el,en stated that he got
authorisation to file Writ Petition, therefore he lacks
jurisdiction to file this Writ Petition. Further petitioner is a
defunct Association. According to this respondent, the issue as
to who is managing the school for the deaf is a disputed
question of fact which cannot be decided by this Court under
Art 226 of the constitution of India.
4.L.
It is stated, in 2O09, petitioner illegally alienated the
property to Sri M.V. Srinivasa Rao and others uia sale deeds
despite bye-laws prohibiting sales to private individuals (only to
similar societies if defunct) and obtained mutation in their
names; after coming to know of the same, the villagers informed
District collector, who suo motu initiated proceedings under
Section 9 of the A.P. Rights in Land and pattadar pass Books
Act, l9'71, and after hearing the matter at length, set aside the
mutation proceedings uide order dated 02-06-2012. Thereafter,
crime l,lo.29o of 2o1o was also registered against petitioner's
President/members.
4.2-
Petitioner Society became defunct and was unable
to continue the functioning of the school; on the advice of the
District collector, the 4th respond.ent Society was duly
constituted and till 2016, the principal Rajkumar Gour
managerl the school by raising donations and thereafter, as
Presiderrt of the Society, he has been looking after the welfare of
the school and hostel and accordingly, subsequent to
registration of society, the president, Sri Rajkumar Gour
approac.eed the 2.d respondent and got mutated the name of the
present Society in the official records in January 2oL7.lt is also
stated, t,ased on the alleged registered sale deed, one Mr. Sambi
Reddy, rvho is claiming to be a purchaser of the said property
:
i
i
l
a
I
i
t
t
I
I
I
t
t
t
T
I
I
from thr: societ5r, approached the Tahsildar, Hayathnagar for
NALA conversion, by suppressing the earlier orders of the Joint
Coliector dated 02.06.201.2, thetefore, the Tahsildar converted
the land from agricultural to non-agricultural. Aggrieved by the
said order, Appeal was filed before the Joint Collector wherein
the respondent societ5r was impleaded and after hearing at.
length, the Joint Collector, in its order dated O9.O5-2O23
cancelled thp NALA pe;mission granted by the Tahsildar,
Abdullapurmet. Thereafter, the Joint collector directed
Respondent No.4 to approach the civil court for cancellation of
sale deeds and documents executed by the society'
4.3.
Aggrieved by the same, it is stated, Sambi Reddy
filed Writ Petition No. L64gS of 2023, wherein, the 4th
respondent filed implead petition. Petitioner society with an
intention to gain illegally tried. to interfere with the possession of
respondent society. Respondent Society filed o.s-No. 23O of
2023 on the file of the Principal Senior Civil Judge's Court,
Ranga Reddy District and obtained, status quo order. It is also
stated, one Pilli Shivalimgam filed O.S.No. 93 of 2C23 on the file
of the IV Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy in respect of
land in Survey Nos. 230 to 233 situated at Peddamberpet which
is against the family members of Alladi Savithri and others who
alienated the same in favour of Societ5r in'1988 and sought for
reliefof<:ancellationofthesaidsaledeedandinthesaidsuit
also, resllondent society fited
4.4.
imptead petition'
It is also stated' in 2023' the Principal
of the
respondt:ntsociet5rtefttheAssociationaSheisagedabout94
under the former
years, as such, the Society is reconstituted
Principal Secretary to Revenue
Maheshwar Rao, Retired IAS
Department Sri Chamarthy Uma
was elected as President' It is
stated that Petitioner failed to
provide any documentary
evidenc,: to substantiate their
claim. The allegation that
responctent Society illegally-managed
the officials to mutate its
nameirrtheplaceofpetitionersociet5rintherecordsisbaseless.
it is prayed to dismiss the Writ Petition'
Hence,
5.
Heard Sri Durga Prasad' Kotamraju'
counsel for petitioner, Sri N' Sreedhar
Couns,:l for TGSPDCL and Sri
learned
Reddy' learned Standing
Gokula Rama Rao' learned
counst:l for ResPondent No'4'
6.
On considering the rival submissions'
it is seen
thatt]reauthorisationfiled'bypetitionerisdated29.o4.2o23,
support of the writ Petition, the
however in the affidavit fited in
i
deponent stated that he is the
only surviving member of the
Association since the
Managing Committee of Petitioner
Members have
Gener:al Secretary and some other Executive
I
I
:
been charged with serious offences uid'e FIR
No' 29O of 2O1O on
the file of P.S. Abdutlapurmet in respect of the
fraud played by
thembyseliingawaythepropertiesbelongingtoAssociation.If
Managing
the deponent is the only surviving member of the
Committee, no explanation is forthcoming as
to how Resolution
waspassedbytheManagingCommittee'authorizinghimtofile
the Writ Petition in 2024.
7.
Be that as it may, whether petitioner or the
4tl'
RespondentismanagingtheaffairsofModelschoolforDeafis
adisputedquestionoffactwhichcannotbegoneintobythis
court under Article 226 0f constitution. The issue
raised by
petitionerisonlyregardingmutationeffectedintherecordsof
the Electricity Department in respect of Service
connection No'
631801052releasedinfavourofModelschoolforDeaf.As
severalquestionsoffactareraisedbypetitionerandsincethe
altegedauthorisationgiventodeponentofwritaffidavitlooks
doubtful,inviewoftheavermentmadebythedeponentinthe
is of
no relief can be granted as sought' This Court
affidavit,
theopinionthatwritPetitiondeservesnoconsiderationand
the same is liable to be dismissed'
I
I
,(
8.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed'
However, tiberty is granted to petitioner to raise the issue
before competent court of civil jurisdiction. No costs'
g.
Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
/
SD/- C. DEEPIKA
REGISTRAR
/TRUE COPY/
ECTION OFFICER
To
1. Two CC's to G.P FOR ENERGY, High Court for
of Telangana at
Hyderebad. (OUT)
Advocate [OPUC]
2. o?'," c.c to SRI DURGA PRASAD KoTArytr{{Ui
TELANGANA
(sc
FoR
REDDY
N.sREEDHAR
SRt
5. on" t.c to
TRANSCO) Advocate [OPUC]
c,b to'snt c.nnruin nno, Advocate (OPUC)
4.
5. Two C;D CoPies
o*
SA
GJP
il
*
v'
€
HIGH COIURT
DATE D:211011202G
THE S
Y
r.)
2 5 r[B lr]?fr
1'
*
ORDER
WP.No.20 125 of 2024
DISMISSING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
a
L
c
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review