Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Crl. Petn No.09 of 2023
Amitabha Sengupta,
Son of late Bimalendu Sengupta,
Resident of A.D. Nagar, M.B. Tilla, P.S.- A.D. Nagar,
Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN-799003.
……………..Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. Sri Atanu Banik,
Son of late Anil Banik,
Resident of Banamalipur, near Ramkrishna Ashram,
P.S.- East Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN-799001.
2. The State of Tripura,
(To be represented by the leanred Public Prosecutor, Hon’ble High Court of
Tripura)
…………….Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
:
Date of pronouncement
of Judgment & Order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
Mr. Ratan Datta, P.P.
Mr. Uttam Kumar Majumder, Advocate.
29.08.2023.
30.08.2023.
Yes.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
Heard Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing along
with Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Ratan
Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the State- respondent as well as Mr. Uttam
Kumar Majumder, learned counsel appearing for respondent No.1.
[2]
This instant petition has been preferred by the petitioner with a prayer
for passing necessary order by invoking the inherent power of the High Court
under Section 482 of Cr.P.C. and to set aside the impugned Order dated
28.03.2023 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in
case No. Crl. Revision 24 of 2022. It has further been prayed that the instant
petition be allowed by invoking the inherent power of the High Court under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. by referring the cheque in question for examination by the
hand-writing expert for determining the hand-writing of the respondent No.1 in
the said cheque and also to pass interim order, staying the further proceedings
of case No.N.I. 69 of 2017 pending before the Court of learned Addl. Chief
Judicial Magistrate, West Tripura till disposal of the instant petition.
[3]
The brief facts of the case are that the respondent No.1 had filed a
complaint petition against the petitioner, Sri Amitabha Sengupta on 22.04.2017
under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and under Section
420 of Indian Penal Code in the Court of learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
West Tripura, Agartala which was registered as case No. N.I. 69 of 2017.
Thereafter, the same was transferred and entrusted to the Court of learned
Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, West Tripura, Agartala for disposal in
accordance with law. It is contended by the respondent No.1 in N.I. 69 of 2017
that the respondent No.1, Atanu Banik and the petitioner, Amitabha Sengupta
are businessmen by profession and both of them were closely associated
business partners with each other.
[4]
In the month of March, 2016, the petitioner allegedly proposed and
requested the respondent No.1 to join in the business of the petitioner as a
partner and requested to invest some money but the respondent No.1 refused to
accept the proposal of the petitioner. Thereafter, on 25th April 2016, the
petitioner further requested the respondent No.1 to join the business of the
petitioner as a partner by investing capital in presence of some witnesses and at
that time, the respondent No.1 accepted the proposal of the petitioner and
thereafter, on 27.04.2016, the respondent No.1 allegedly made payment of
Rs.2,52,060/- (Rupees Two Lakh Fifty Two Thousand Sixty) only through
Bank Draft vide No.069336 dated 27.04.2016 to the petitioner as capital of
their partnership business. Subsequently, on 31.05.2016, the petitioner prepared
one agreement and handed over the said agreement to the respondent No.1 in
presence of witnesses. At the time of signing of the agreement by the
respondent No.1, an amount of Rs.2,060/- only, was returned to the respondent
No.1 by the petitioner, in cash, but after expiry of the agreement period, the
petitioner allegedly paid Rs.2,50,000/- only through Cheque vide No.764967
dated 26.12.2016 to the respondent No.1 which was earlier invested by the
respondent No.1 to the business of the petitioner in presence of witnesses. On
03.03.2017, the respondent No.1 deposited the aforesaid cheque in his account
with the United Bank of India, Barmura Branch, Math Chowmuhani, West
Tripura but on the same date, said cheque was returned to the respondent No.1
due to insufficient fund in the bank account of the petitioner. Thereafter, on
11.03.2017, the respondent No.1 served a legal notice through his engaged
learned counsel upon the petitioner informing the fact of dishonor of said
cheque and requested the petitioner to make payment of cheque amount of
Rs.2,50,000/- only, with interest and costs within 15 days from the date of
receipt of the notice but the petitioner did not pay the cheque amount to the
respondent No.1 in spite of receipt of demand notice and as such, the
respondent No.1 filed the complaint petition under Section 138 of N.I. Act
which was registered and numbered as N.I. 69 of 2017 currently pending before
the learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, West Tripura.
[5]
The petitioner to prove his case before the learned Additional Chief
Judicial Magistrate in N.I. 69 of 2017, filed an application before the learned
Magistrate to refer the concerned cheque to a handwriting expert for
verification of the writings therein and to prove his case that the respondent
No.1 has manipulated the said cheque. The petitioner categorically and
specifically stated that the concerned cheque has been manipulated by the
respondent No.1 by writing his own name without the consent/prior intimation
to the petitioner herein. Learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, West
Tripura, passed impugned order dated 27.04.2022 in case No. N.I. 69 of 2017,
whereby the learned Court rejected the prayer of the petitioner for referring the
concerned cheque to a hand writing expert.
[6]
The petitioner being aggrieved by the said order dated 27.04.2022 in
N.I. 69 of 2017, preferred a criminal revision petition under Section 397 read
with Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure before the learned
Sessions Judge, West Tripura. The learned Sessions Judge, West Tripura vide
impugned order dated 28.03.2023 rejected the Criminal Revision 24 of 2022
affirming the order dated 27.04.2022 passed by the learned Additional Chief
Judicial Magistrate, West Tripura, Agartala in case No. N.I. 69 of 2017.
[7]
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the petitioner contends
that the impugned order dated 28.03.2023 passed by the learned Sessions
Court, West Tripura suffers from illegality, impropriety and incorrectness as
manifest error has been caused in deciding the grounds agitated by the
petitioner in the Criminal Revision 24 of 2022. It is further contended that the
Court below has failed to consider that for ends of justice, it would have been
apposite to send the concerned cheque to a hand writing expert so that the
petitioner herein is not denied of the opportunity to a fair trial.
[8]
Learned Counsel for the petitioner has placed his reliance on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Kalyani Baskar (MRS.) vs. M.S.
Sampoornam (MRS.) reported in (2007) 2 SCC 258, which reads as under:
“12. Section 243 (2) is clear that a Magistrate holding an inquiry under
Cr.P.C. in respect of an offence triable by him does not exceed his
powers under Section 243(2) if, in the interest of justice, he directs to
send the document for enabling the same to be compared by a handwriting expert because even in adopting this course, the purpose is to
enable the Magistrate to compare the disputed signature or writing with
the admitted writing or signature of the accused and to reach his own
conclusion with the assistance of the expert. The appellant is entitled to
rebut the case of the respondent and if the document viz. the cheque on
which the respondent has relied upon for initiating criminal proceedings
against the appellant would furnish good material for rebutting that
case, the Magistrate having declined to send the document for the
examination and opinion of the hand-writing expert has deprived the
appellant of an opportunity of rebutting it. The appellant cannot be
convicted without an opportunity being given to her to present her
evidence and if it is denied to her, there is no fair trial. 'Fair trial'
includes fair and proper opportunities allowed by law to prove her
innocence. Adducing evidence in support of the defence is a valuable
right. Denial of that right means denial of fair trial. It is essential that
rules of procedure designed to ensure justice should be scrupulously
followed, and courts should be jealous in seeing that there is no breach
of them. We have not been able to appreciate the view of the learned
Judge of the High Court that the petitioner has filed application
under Section 243 Cr.P.C. without naming any person as witness or
anything to be summoned, which are to be sent for handwriting expert
for examination. As noticed above, Section 243(2) Cr.P.C. refers to a
stage when the prosecution closes its evidence after examining the
witnesses and the accused has entered upon his defence. The appellant
in this case requests for sending the cheque, in question, for the opinion
of the hand-writing expert after the respondent has closed her evidence,
the Magistrate should have granted such a request unless he thinks that
the object of the appellant is vexation or delaying the criminal
proceedings. In the circumstances, the order of the High Court
impugned in this appeal upholding the order of the Magistrate is
erroneous and not sustainable.”
[9]
It is contended on behalf of the petitioner that learned Sessions Judge
did not take into consideration the basic principle of natural justice of affording
all reasonable opportunities to the accused-petitioner. As such, the impugned
order dated 28.03.2023 is the result of about absolute non application of mind
by the learned Sessions Judge. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
learned Sessions Court failed to consider that the impugned order dated
27.04.2022 passed by the learned Addl. Chief Judicial Magistrate, West Tripura
which was challenged by invoking revisional jurisdiction of the learned
Sessions Court is dehors and Court below has failed to exercise the revisional
jurisdiction vested on it under Section 397 Cr.P.C. causing miscarriage of
justice as well as abuse of the process of law. He submits that the Hon’ble High
Court has territorial jurisdiction to try and adjudicate the instant petition as the
cause of action has arisen within the territorial limit of the High Court.
[10]
Reliance has also been placed by the learned counsel of the petitioner
on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Krishnan and another vs.
Krishnaveni and another reported in (1997) 4 SCC 241, the relevant part of
which reads as under:
“4. Shri Krishnamurthy, learned counsel for the appellants, contended
that the State as well as the respondents having availed of the remedy of
revision under Section 397 of the code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for
short, "the Code") the High Court was devoid of power and jurisdiction
to entertain the second revision due to prohibition by sub-section (3)
of Section 397 of the Code, therefore the impugned order is one without
jurisdiction and vitiated by manifest error of law warranting
interference, In support of his contention, the learned counsel placed
strong reliance on the abovesaid two decisions of this Court. He further
contended that when there is a prohibition under section 397 (3) of the
code, the exercise of the power being in violating thereof, is non est. He
further placed reliance on the decisions of this Court in Simrikhia v.
Dolley Mukherjee and Deepti v. Akhil Rai. The question, therefore, is
whether the High Court has power to entertain a Revision under section
397 (1) in respect of which the Sessions Judge has already exercised
revisional power and whether, under the circumstances of the present
case, it could be considered to be one under Section 482 of the Code.
5. Chapter 30 of the code relating to reference and revisional powers
of the High Court, consists of the Sections 395 to 405. Under the codes,
the revisional power of the High Court has concurrently been given by
operation of sub-section (1) of Section 397 to Sessions Judge, to call for
the records of any proceeding and to exercise powers of revision . The
power is given to examine the record of any proceedings before nay
inferior Criminal Court situated within its or his local jurisdiction for
the purpose of satisfying itself or himself as to the correctness, legality
or propriety of any finding, sentence , or order, recorded or passed, and
as to the regularity of any proceeding of such inferior court. SubSection (3) thereof provides that if an application under the said section
has been made by any person either to the High Court or to the Sessions
judge, no further application by the same Person shall be entertained by
the other of them. This was brought by way of amendment to Section
435 of the predecessor Code i.e., Act V of 1898.
6. Section 401 of the Code gives to every High Court power of
revision. Sub-Section (1) of the said section provides that in the case of
any proceeding the record of which has been called for by itself or
which otherwise comes to its knowledge, the High Court may, in its
discretion, exercise any of the power conferred on a Court of Appeal
by Sections 386, 389 and 391 and on a Court of Sessions by Section
307. Apart form the express power under Section 397 (1), the High
Court has been invested with suo motu power under Section 401 to
exercise revisional power. In addition, Section 482 saves inherent
powers of the High Court postulating that:
"Nothing in this Code shall be deemed to limit or affect
the inherent powers of the High Court to make such orders
as may be necessary to give effect to any order under this
Code, or to prevent abuse of the process of any court or
otherwise to secure the ends of justice"
Section 483 enjoins upon every High Court to so exercise its
continuous superintendence over the Courts of judicial Magistrates
subordinate to it as to ensure that there is an expeditious and proper
disposal of cases by such Magistrates. It is, therefore, clear that the
power of the High Court of continuous supervisory jurisdiction is of
paramount importance to examine correctness, legality, or propriety of
any finding, sentence or order recorded or passed as also regularity of
the proceedings of all inferior criminal courts.
7. It is seen that exercises of the revisional power by the High Court
under Section 397 read with Section 401 is to call for the records of any
inferior criminal court and to examine the correctness, legality or
propriety of any finding, sentence or order recorded or passed, and as to
the regularity of any proceedings of such inferior court and to pass
appropriate orders. The Court of Sessions and the Magistrates are
inferior criminal courts to the High Court and Courts of Judicial
Magistrate are inferior criminal courts to the Sessions Judge.
Ordinarily, in the matter of exercise of power of revision by any High
Court, Section 397 and Section 401 are required to be read
together. Section 397 gives powers to the High Court to call for the
records as also suo motu power under Section 401 to exercise the
revisional power on the grounds mentioned therein, i.e. to examine the
correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order,
recorded or passed and as to the regularity of any proceedings of such
inferior court, and to dispose of the revision in the manner indicated
under Section 401 of the Code. The revisional power of the High Court
merely conserves the power of the High Court to see that justice is done
is accordance with the recognised rules of criminal jurisprudence and
that its subordinate courts do not exceed the jurisdiction or abuse the
power vested in them under the Code or to prevent abuse of the process
of the inferior criminal courts or to prevent miscarriage of justice.
8. The object of Section 483 and the purpose behind conferring the
revisional power under Section 397 read with Section 401 upon the
High Court is to invest continuous supervisory jurisdiction so as to
prevent miscarriage of justice or to correct irregularity of the procedure
or to mete out justice or to correct irregularity of the procedure or to
mete out justice. In addition, the inherent power of the High Court is
preserved by Section 482 . The power of the High Court therefore is
very wide. However, High Court must exercise such power sparingly
and cautiously when the Sessions Judge has simultaneously exercised
revisional power under Section 397 (1). However, when the High Court
notices that there has been failure of justice or misuse of judicial
mechanism or procedure, sentence or order is not correct, it is but the
salutary duty of the High Court to prevent the abuse of the process or
miscarriage of justice or tow correct irregularities/incorrectness
committed by inferior criminal court in its juridical process or illegality
of sentence or order.
9. The inherent power of the High Court is not one conferred by the
Code but one which the High Court already has in it and which is
preserved by the Code. The object of Section 397 (3) is to put a bar on
simultaneous revisional applications to the High Court and the Court of
Sessions so as to prevent unnecessary delay and multiplicity of
proceedings. As seen , under sub-section (3) of section 397 revisional
jurisdiction can be invoked by "any person" but the Code has not
defined the word “person”, However, under section 11 of the IPC,
“person” includes any company or association or body of person
whether incorporated or not. The word “person” would, therefore
include not only the natural person but also juridical person in whatever
form designated and whether incorporated or not. By implication the
State stands excluded form the purview of the word “person” for the
purposes of the limiting its right to avail the revisional power of the
High Court under Section 397 (1) of the Code for the reason that the
Sate, being the prosecutor of the offender, is enjoined to conduct
prosecution on behalf of the society and to take such remedial steps as
it deems proper. The Object behind criminal law is to maintain law,
public order, stability as also peace and progress in the society.
Generally, private complaint under Section 202 of the Code are laid in
respect of non-cognizable offences or when it is found that police has
failed to perform its duty under Chapter XII of the Code or to report as
mistake of fact. In view of the principle laid down in the maxim ex
debito justitiae i.e. in accordance with the requirements of justice, the
prohibition under section 397 (3) on revisional power given to the High
Court would not apply when the state seeks revision under Section
401 . So the State is not prohibited to avail the revisional power of the
High Court under section 397 (1) read with section 401 of the Code.”
[11]
Mr. Ratan Datta, learned P.P. appearing for the State respondent on the
other hand has countered the submission of learned counsel Mr. Bhattacharjee
appearing for the accused-petitioner and contended that the instant petition filed
by the petitioner is not maintainable as the accused-petitioner did not dispute
his signature on the cheque in question and the learned trial Court also passed
the impugned order after considering the provision of Section 20 of the
Negotiable Instrument Act. He submits that as the accused-petitioner did not
dispute his signature on the cheque in question, learned trial Court in case No.
N.I.69 of 2017, rejected the petition of the accused-petitioner for referring the
cheque in question to a hand writing expert for determining the hand writing of
the complainant-respondent who wrote the name of the payee “Atanu Banik in
the column of the cheque” and subsequently, the case No. Criminal Revision 24
of 2022 preferred by the accused-petitioner has also been rejected by the Court
below by order dated 28.03.2023.
[12]
Having gone through the material evidence on record and after
interacting with the learned counsel appearing for the parties, this Court is of
the view that the learned Court below has failed to apply its judicious mind at
the time of determining the case of the petitioner. The basic principle of natural
justice of affording adequate opportunity has not been provided to the
petitioner. The learned Court below has failed to exercise the revisional
jurisdiction vested on it under Section- 397 of the Cr.P.C. causing miscarriage
of justice as well as abuse of the process of law. This Court is of the view that it
would have been apposite to send the concerned cheque to a hand writing
expert, so that the petitioner herein is not denied of the opportunity to a fair
trial.
[13]
On the ground of delay, the learned Court below has decided the matter
which is not at all a good ground for deciding such cases. Basic principle of
natural justice is to afford the petitioner an opportunity to defend his case in all
probable manner following procedure of law, as it is the petitioner who would
have to bear the penal burden if a decision is arrived at without giving him an
opportunity. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 28.03.2023 passed by the
learned Court below stands set aside consequently, the present petition stands
allowed by referring the cheque in question for examination by the hand
writing expert for determining the hand writing of the respondent No.1 in the
said cheque.
In that view of the matter, the present petition stands allowed and
disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications, pending if any, shall stand
closed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI GHOSH GHOSH
Date: 2023.09.02 17:20:21 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review