The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. In view of the aforesaid discussions and in view of the decision reported in Jalai Suguna (supra), we are also of the view that in an eviction proceeding, when a legatee under a Will intends to represent the interest of the estate of the deceased testator, he will be a legal representative within the meaning of Section 2(11) of Code of Civil Procedure, for which it is not necessary in an eviction suit to decide whether the Will on the basis of which substitution is sought for, is a suspicious one or that the parties must send the case back to the probate Court for a decision whether the Will was genuine or not.
15. In view of the aforesaid reasons, the revision petition is allowed. The impugned orders passed by the Trial Court dated
15. 04.2015 on I.A.Nos. V and VI made in O.S.No.71/2012, on the file of the Civil Judge *(Sr.Dn.) at Aland is set aside. The matter is remanded to the Trial Court for fresh consideration of (Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.) the said applications (I.A.Nos.V and VI) after following the procedure as contemplated under Order 22 Rule 5 of Code of Civil Procedure and in the light of the dictums of the Hon'ble Supreme Court stated supra and pass orders in accordance with law. From the perusal of the aforesaid settled legal prepositions of law by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as well as various High Courts it is apparently clear that by virtue of a Will the person is entitled to be impleaded as a party in the capacity of legal representatives. The question that whether the Will is genuine or not is to be seen in a separate proceedings. The propounder of a Will is required to get a probate as per the settled legal terms. It is the burden upon him to get his Will proved and examined before the Competent Courts if the same is objected by the other side but in the present case as far as bringing the legal representatives on record is concerned, the person having Will in his favour can always be permitted to bring on record for participating the proceedings. It is upon him to establish his rights in the proper proceedings in his civil suit. In view of the judgment passed by…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
Gwalior, Dated : 14.07.2021
Heard through video conferencing.
Shri K.S. Tomar, learned Senior counsel with Shri J.S. Kaurav
and Shri Anoop Gupta, Advocates for the petitioners.
Shri V.K. Baradwaj, learned senior counsel with Shri Rohit
Batham, Advocate for respondents No. 1 and 2.
Shri
Vijay
Sundaram,
learned
Panel
Lawyer
for
respondent/State.
With consent, heard finally.
Present petition has been filed challenging the order dated
01.02.2017 passed by the IV Civil Judge, Class-I, Gwalior, whereby
the application filed by the petitioner for bringing the legal
representatives on record on the basis of Will has been rejected.
It is alleged that plaintiff-Prakash Chaubey who is no more and
one Suresh Chaubey filed a suit jointly against the respondents for
declaration, title and permanent injunction with respect to the
agricultural land as mentioned in para 2 of plaint on the allegation that
land in dispute is of the ownership of the plaintiffs because their
grandfather had purchased the land by a registered sale-deed dated
28.06.1944 from Balmukund Chhingamal Brahmin and now the
defendants were interfering in the use and occupation of the land
claiming their right on the suit property. The decree was obtained in
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
Civil Suit No. 47-A/2007 from Second Civil Judge, Class-I, Gwalior
on 24.04.2009 as nullity against the interest of the plaintiff, therefore,
the civil suit has been filed. The written statement was filed by the
defendants No. 1 to 3 denying all the averments made in plaint and
stated that the decree has not been obtained by playing fraud or
misrepresentation. The plaintiffs are bound by the judgment and decree
passed on earlier occasion. Petitioner No. 1 was appointed as a power
attorney holder by document dated 31.12.2008 registered with the Sub
Registrar Gwalior. During pendancy of the suit, Prakash Chaubey
executed a Will dated 24.12.2007 with respect to movable or
immovable property in favour of petitioner No. 1. After death of
Prakash Chaubey on 10.01.2016, an application under Order XXII
Rule 3 read with Section 151 of CPC for impleading him as a legal
representative on the basis of Will has been filed. The reply to the
aforesaid application was filed by the respondents taking a specific
stand that the Will dated 24.12.2007 is a forged and fabricated
document; therefore, petitioner No. 1 cannot be allowed to be
impleaded in the suit. The learned trial Court without considering the
relevant provisions of law rejected the application. It is alleged that the
order passed by the learned trial Court is contrary to the provision of
Order XXII Rule 1,3 and 4-A of CPC. It is submitted that by virtue of
registered Will executed by plaintiff No. 1-Prakash Chaubey in favour
of petitioner No.1, he has required the rights over the property in
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
question. Even otherwise, he is a legal representative in terms of
Section 30 of the Hindu Succession Act, therefore, he should have been
impleaded as one of the legal representatives of plaintiff No.1 and
should be permitted to continue in civil suit proceedings. It is argued
that Section 2(11) of CPC defines 'Legal Representative' which means
that a person who in law represents the estate of a deceased person
including any person who intermeddles with the estate of the deceased
will be termed as a legal representative. The learned trial Court without
considering the settled prepositions, has rejected the application. It is
argued that once a person is claiming to be a legal representative of the
deceased/plaintiff, then it is the duty of the Court to see whether he is
one of the legal representatives or not; It is further argued that it is the
duty of the Court to determine the question with respect to legal
representatives in case there is a dispute or misunderstanding with
respect to the same. The Court cannot deny in an arbitrary manner the
application of legal representative. Besides the new provision of Rule
4-A of Order 22 of CPC which has been inserted by an amendment of
the year 1977. It is not mandatory but can be constituted merely for
discretionary as the language empowers in sub-rule 4-A of CPC which
provides the procedure where there is no legal representative. The
aforesaid aspect has not been considered by the learned trial Court and
has rejected the application outrightly. Learned counsel for the
petitioners placed reliance upon the judgment passed by the Hon'ble
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
Supreme Court in the case of Jaladi Suguna (D) Th. Lrs vs Satya Sai
Central Trust & Ors reported in AIR 2008 SC 2866, wherein in
similar situations the legal representatives on the basis of the Will were
brought on record. It is argued that the aforesaid is just to avoid the
multiplicity of the litigations. In such circumstances, the order passed
by the learned trial Court is per se illegal.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents have vehemently
opposed the contentions and supported the impugned order stating that
the Will in question is forged and fabricated document as alleged in the
reply, therefore, until and unless the Will in question is proved and a
probate is obtained upon the same, no right accrues in favour of the
petitioners. The learned trial Court has considered the aforesaid aspect
to the case and rightly rejected the application. No illegality is found to
have been committed by the learned trial Court. It is settled preposition
of law that once a Will is disputed then the propounder of the Will is
required to get a probate by initiating appropriate proceedings. In such
circumstances, no illegality has been committed by the learned trial
Court in passing the impugned order. They prayed for dismissal of the
present petition.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
From perusal of the record it is not disputed that petitioners were
contesting the suit on the basis of power of attorney on behalf of
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
plaintiff No. 1. During the pendancy of the Civil Suit the plaintiff No.1
expired and he had executed a registered Will in favour of petitioner
No. 1. The petitioner No. 1 filed an application to bring him on record
as one of the legal representatives of late Prakash Choubey. The
aforesaid application was rejected by the learned trial Court holding
that the Will in question is a disputed Will as the same is being
objected by the respondents, therefore, until and unless probate is
obtained, no right accrues in favour of petitioner No.1.
The definition of “Legal Representatives” is required to be seen
which is given under Section 2(11) of CPC which reads as under:“Legal representative” as defined in Civil Procedures
Code, under s.2(11), means a person who in law represents
the estate of a deceased person and includes any person who
intermeddles with The estate of the deceased and where the
party sues or is prosecuted in a representative manner by the
person to whom the estate is transferred upon the death of
the party so suing or sued.
The definition is inclusive and broad in nature, not
limited to legal heirs, but rather defines a person who may
or may not be the heir, who is eligible to inherit the
deceased’s estate but who must represent the deceased’s
estate. This includes all heirs and individuals holding the
assets either without ownership, even as executors even
administrators of the deceased’s estate. All such persons are
covered by the expression “legal representative.” If there are
many heirs, then those in good faith are also entitled to
represent the deceased’s estate, without fraud or collusion.”
Further legal representative in terms of Section 30 of Hindu
Succession Act says that by virtue of a Will, the propounder of the Will
acquires the legal rights.
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
Reliance is also placed on judgment dated 26.07.2016 passed by
the High Court of Karnataka in Gurubai Vs. The Govt. of Karnataka
in Civil Revision Petition No. 200015 of 2015, which reads as under:"14. The Hon'ble Supreme Court while considering the
provisions of Section 2(11) and Order 22 Rule 5 of Code of Civil
Procedure in the case of Suresh Kumar Bansal vs. Krishna Bansal
and Another reported in (2010) 2 Supreme Court Cases 162 has
held as under:
"19. The Code of Civil Procedure enjoins various
provisions only for the purpose of avoiding
multiplicity of proceedings and for adjudicating of
related disputes in the same proceedings, the parties
cannot be driven to different Courts or to institute
different proceedings touching on different facets of
the same major issue. Such a course of action will
result in conflicting judgments and instead of
resolving the disputes, they would end up in creation
of confusion and conflict. '
20. It is now well settled that determination of the
question as to who is the legal representatives of the
deceased plaintiff or defendant under Order XXII
Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure is only for the
purposes of bringing legal representatives on record
for the conducting of those legal proceedings only
and does not operate as res judicata and the inter se
dispute between the rival legal representatives has to
be independently tried and decided in probate
proceedings. If this is allowed to be carried on for a
decision of an eviction suit or other allied suits, the
suits would be delayed, by which only the tenants
will be benefited.
21. In order to shorten the litigation and to consider
the rival claims of the parties, in our view, the proper
course to follow is to bring all the heirs and legal
representatives of the deceased plaintiff on record
including the legal representatives who are claiming
on the basis of the Will of the deceased plaintiff so
that all the legal representatives namely, the appellant
and the natural heirs and legal representatives of the
deceased plaintiff can represent the estate of the
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
deceased for the ultimate benefit of the real legal
representatives. If this process is followed, this would
also avoid delay in disposal of the suit.
22. In view of our discussions made hereinabove, we
are, therefore, of the view that the High Court as well
as the trial Court were not at all justified in rejecting
the application for impleadment filed at the instance
of the appellant based on the alleged Will of the
deceased plaintiff at this stage of the proceedings.
23. Before parting with this judgment, it is necessary
to consider the decision of this Court in the case of
Jalai Suguna (deceased) through L.Rs. v. Satya Sai
Central Trust and Others, [(2008) 8 SCC 521] cited
by the learned senior counsel for the appellant. In
Jalai Suguna (supra), this Court held that the intestate
heir (husband) and the testamentary legatees (nieces
and nephews), seeking impleadment as the heirs of
the deceased respondent in an appeal have to be
brought on record before the Court can proceed
further in the appeal. Furthermore, in that decision it
was also held that a legatee under a Will, who intends
to represent the estate of the deceased testator, being
an intermeddler with the estate of the deceased
testator, will be a legal representative.
24. In view of the aforesaid discussions and in view
of the decision reported in Jalai Suguna (supra), we
are also of the view that in an eviction proceeding,
when a legatee under a Will intends to represent the
interest of the estate of the deceased testator, he will
be a legal representative within the meaning of
Section 2(11) of Code of Civil Procedure, for which
it is not necessary in an eviction suit to decide
whether the Will on the basis of which substitution is
sought for, is a suspicious one or that the parties must
send the case back to the probate Court for a decision
whether the Will was genuine or not.
15. In view of the aforesaid reasons, the revision petition is
allowed. The impugned orders passed by the Trial Court dated
15.04.2015 on I.A.Nos. V and VI made in O.S.No.71/2012, on
the file of the Civil Judge *(Sr.Dn.) at Aland is set aside. The
matter is remanded to the Trial Court for fresh consideration of
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
the said applications (I.A.Nos.V and VI) after following the
procedure as contemplated under Order 22 Rule 5 of Code of
Civil Procedure and in the light of the dictums of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court stated supra and pass orders in accordance with
law.
From the perusal of the aforesaid settled legal prepositions of
law by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as well as various High Courts it is
apparently clear that by virtue of a Will the person is entitled to be
impleaded as a party in the capacity of legal representatives. The
question that whether the Will is genuine or not is to be seen in a
separate proceedings. The propounder of a Will is required to get a
probate as per the settled legal terms. It is the burden upon him to get
his Will proved and examined before the Competent Courts if the same
is objected by the other side but in the present case as far as bringing
the legal representatives on record is concerned, the person having Will
in his favour can always be permitted to bring on record for
participating the proceedings. It is upon him to establish his rights in
the proper proceedings in his civil suit. In view of the judgment passed
by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Suresh Kumar Bansal
Vs. Krishna Bansal and Anr. reported in (2010) 2 SCC 162, wherein,
the Court has considered view that in terms provisions of law under
Order XXII Rule 5 of CPC, the petitioners should have been brought
on record for continuing and permitted to continue those legal
proceedings. The bringing on record of the petitioner will not operate
as res judicata and the inter se dispute between the rival legal
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
WP No.1776/2017
(Alok Raghuwanshi and Anr. vs. Ghanshyam Chaubey and ors.)
representatives can always be settled in separate legal proceedings.
There is every right to the petitioners to get the genuineness of a Will
and get the probate on the same in appropriate proceedings. In such
circumstances, the order impugned is per se illegal and is hereby set
aside. The trial Court is directed to implead the present petitioners as
legal representative of plaintiff No.1 along with all other natural heirs
who claim to be a legal representatives of plaintiff No. 1 and proceed
further in the civil suit with respect to all other inter se claims between
the parties with respect to genuineness of the Will the same will be
governed by the probate proceedings of the Will and will not be
effected by the present proceedings.
With the aforesaid directions, present petition is allowed and
disposed of. No order as to costs.
(Vishal Mishra)
Judge
LJ*
LOKENDRA
JAIN
2022.07.12
10:38:10
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review