Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN
THE
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MANINDER S. BHATTI
ON THE 14 th OF DECEMBER, 2023
WRIT PETITION No. 14914 of 2022
BETWEEN:ALOK KUMAR SINGH S/O LATE SHRI GAURI NARAYAN
SINGH, AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS, OCCUPATION:
REVENUE INSPECTOR MUNICIPAL COUNCIL RAMPUR
NAIKIN SIDHI (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHRI K.C. GHILDIYAL - SENIOR COUNSEL ASSISTED BY SHRI
PRADEEP KUMAR DWIVEDI - ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH THROUGH
THE
PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY
URBAN
ADMINISTRATION
AND
DEVELOPMENT
DEPARTMENT VALLABH BHAWAN DISTRICT
BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
THE COMMISSIONER URBAN ADMINISTRATION
AND DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT MADHYA
PRADESH BHOPAL (MP) (MADHYA PRADESH)
3.
THE JOINT DIRECTOR URBAN ADMINISTRATION
AND
DEVELOPMENT
DEPARTMENT REWA
DIVISION REWA M.P. (MADHYA PRADESH)
4.
MUNICIPAL COUNCIL SIDHI THROUGH ITS CHIEF
MUNICIPAL
OFFICER DISTRICT SIDHI (M.P.)
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(SHRI K.V.S. RAO - PANEL LAWYER FOR RESPONDENT NOS. 1 TO
3/STATE )
(SHRI NEERAJ SINGH CHAUHAN - ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.4)
(SHRI ATUL SINGH AND SHRI RAJESH KUMAR SHARMA - ADVOCATES
FOR THE INTERVENERS)
This petition coming on for admission this day, the Court passed the
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
following:
ORDER
This petition has been filed by the petitioner while praying for the
following reliefs:"(i) A writ order or direction in the nature of certiorari
thereby quashing the impugned order dated 20/06/2022 issued by
respondent No.2 (Annexure-P/4).
(ii) A writ order or direction in the nature of Mandamus
thereby directing the respondents to immediately promote the
petitioner to the post of Revenue Inspector in pursuance to the
DPC proceedings held on 14/10/2021 with all consequential
benefits including pay and allowances, seniority, continuity of
service etc.
(iii) Any other apporpirate writ order or direction which this
Hon'ble Court may deem just and proper in the nature and
circumstances of the case including cost of the litigation."
2. The facts, as put forth in the petition, reveal that the petitioner, after
undergoing selection process in terms of Madhya Pradesh Municipal
Employees Recruitment and Conditions of Service Rules, 1968 (hereinafter
referred to as the Rules of 1968) was appointed against the post of Assistant
Revenue Inspector vide order dated 1.9.2006. Later on, the petitioner was
transferred to some different Municipalities, which are detailed in Paragraph 5.1
of the petition. The petitioner performed his duties with utmost dedication and
to the satisfaction of all concerned and accordingly, petitioner's performance
was assessed as outstanding in all his Annual Confidential Reports (for short
ACRs) by the Reporting Officers. It is further averred in the petition that as the
petitioner was originally appointed with Municipal Council, Sidhi, therefore, he
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
maintained his lien with his parent Council i.e. Municipal Council, Sidhi. A
meeting of Departmental Promotion Committee (for short DPC) for promotion
against the post of Revenue Inspector was convened on 14.10.2021 in terms of
the provisions of Rule 11 of the The Madhya Pradesh Municipal Services
(Scale of Pay and Allowances) Rules, 1967 (hereinafter referred to as the
Rules of 1967). In the aforesaid meeting, the cases of 5 employees were
considered including the present petitioner. Upon appreciation of overall
performance and confidential reports, the petitioner was awarded 20 marks and
rest four candidates were awarded 15 marks, therefore, petitioner's name was
recommended for promotion, as the criteria was merit cum seniority. The
recommendations made by the DPC were approved by the Council vide
resolution dated 29.10.2021, which is contained in Annexure P-3 and thereafter
the recommendations were sent to the Government for its concurrence.
However, vide impugned order dated 20.6.2022, which is contained in
Annexure P-4, the Joint Director, Urban Administration and Development
refused to accord sanction to the recommendations of the DPC. Thus, assailing
the impugned communication dated 20.6.2022 (Annexure P-4) this petition has
been filed by the petitioner seeking further direction to the respondents to
promote the petitioner against the post of Revenue Inspector in terms of the
recommendations of the DPC dated 14.10.2021.
3. Learned senior counsel for the petitioner contends that Rule 4 of the
Rules of 1968 contains the method of recruitment and in terms of Rule 4 of the
Rules of 1968, recruitment to the Municipal service or a post or class of posts
may be made by direct recruitment, by promotion of a person employed in the
Council or by transfer or deputation of a person serving in connection with the
affairs of any local Authority or of the State. It is further contended that in terms
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
of Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968, recruitment by promotion is based on
consideration of merits and seniority is required to be taken into account where
the merits are equal. Therefore, the criteria of merit in terms of Rule 12 of the
Rules of 1968 prevails when the cases of promotion of employees of Municipal
Council are considered. It is also contended that apart from the Rules of 1968,
the legislature has framed the Municipal Services (Scale of Pay And
Allowances) Rules, 1967 in purported exercise of powers conferred under subsection (2) of Section 355 read with Section 95 of the Madhya Pradesh
Municipalities Act, 1961 and in terms of Rule 11 of the Rules of 1967, there
exists a provision for constitution of the District Selection Committee, which
takes decision as regards, the promotion/absorption of the employees.
4. It is further contended that Schedule III appended to Rules of 1967
provides that the post of Revenue Inspector shall be filled up by the employee
having experience of revenue work of 3 years and with qualification of Higher
Secondary School Certificate. It is contended that aforesaid Schedule III
nowhere provides that for being promoted as Revenue Inspector, the feeder
post is Deputy Revenue Inspector. The only criteria which is required to be
considered for promotion against the post of Revenue Inspector is that a
person should have experience of revenue work of 3 years and should possess
the qualification of Higher Secondary School Certificate. It is nowhere provided
that a person against a particular feeder post can be considered for the post of
Revenue Inspector. It is contended that the Authority while passing the
impugned order has observed that the post of Deputy Revenue Inspector is the
feeder post for the purpose of promotion against the post of Revenue Inspector
and the promotion from the post of Moharrir (now known as Assistant Revenue
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
Inspector) cannot be made to the post of Revenue Inspector. It is further
contended that the State has declined to accord approval to the
recommendation made by the DPC on the ground that in terms of the Madhya
Pradesh Public Service (Promotion) Rules, 2002, (hereinafter referred to as
the Rules of 2002) in the cases of promotion from Class III to Class III posts,
the criteria of seniority cum merit is required to be adhered to and as one Shri
Pawan Kumar Singh, who was the senior most employee out of five employees,
was eligible for promotion, there was no question of extending benefit of
promotion to any employee, other than Shri Pawan Kumar Singh. It is
contended by learned senior counsel that the aforesaid finding, so arrived at in
the impugned order by the respondents, is misconceived on the face of it,
inasmuch as, there is total failure on the part of the State Government to
consider the scope of Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968 as well as Schedule III
appended to the Rules of 1967.
5. Learned senior counsel further contends that petitioner’s performance
was outstanding as he was graded A + in last 5 years and the DPC rightly
recommended the name of the petitioner for promotion against the post of
Revenue Inspector, which was not objected to by any other employee. Only
one employee namely Shri Ramsiya Saket, who never objected to the
recommendations of the DPC, has now chosen to seek intervention in the
present case. Thus, it is contended that the Authority grossly erred in making
reference to the Rules of 2002. The said Rules were only applicable to the
limited extent of applying provision for reservation and marking towards
grading of the employees concerned. It is further contended that the qualifying
service in terms of Schedule III was taken note of by the DPC, which is evident
from Para 8 of the minutes of the meeting of the DPC dated 14.10.2021
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
(Annexure P-2). Though in Para-6 of the same, the Committee made reference
to Rule 7 of the Rules of 2002 and concluded that the criteria of merit-cumseniority was to be adopted, however, there was no need to make reference to
Rule 7 inasmuch as, Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968 still contains the provision,
which unequivocally reflects that the recruitment by promotion is made on
consideration of merit and the seniority only comes into play where the merits
are equal. Therefore, the Rules of 1968 being applicable in the case at hand, the
interference with the recommendation made by the DPC by the State
Government was not called for and therefore, the impugned order is liable to be
set aside.
6. Per contra, the counsel for the respondents submits that the present
petition is liable to be dismissed. It is submitted that when the Authority
received the proposal from the Municipal Council for grant of concurrence, it
was found that there was violation of the provisions of the Rules of 1967 and
the Rules of 1968 read with the Rules of 2002. It was further observed by the
Authority that in the cases of promotion from Class III to Class III post,
seniority-cum-suitability was the criteria, which was required to be adhered to
but unfortunately in the present case in complete oblivion of the provisions of
the Rules of 2002, the said criteria was ignored and promotions were
recommended on the basis of merit-cum-seniority. It is contended that even
after passing of the impugned order, a disciplinary action was taken against all
the officials, who were instrumental in recommending the name of the petitioner
for promotion. Therefore, it is contended that in view of the specific stand so
taken by the respondents in the return, the present petition filed by the petitioner
is liable to be dismissed.
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
7. The counsel appearing for the proposed intervener submits that the
name of the proposed intervener finds mention at serial number 4 in the table
contained in Para 13 of the minutes of the DPC (Annexure P-2) and a perusal of
the same, reflects that the proposed intervener is placed over and above the
petitioner, therefore, prior to petitioner’s name, the name of the proposed
intervener was required to be considered for promotion, as he is senior to the
petitioner. Thus, the present petition is liable to be dismissed.
8. No other point is argued or pressed by the counsel for the parties.
9. Heard the submissions advanced on behalf of the parties and perused
the material available on record.
10. In order to deal with the rival contentions of the parties, it would be
appropriate to refer to the provisions contained in the Rules of 1967. Rule 6 of
the Rules of 1967 being relevant is reproduced below for ready reference:“6. Departmental set up and designations of posts.- The
office of a Municipal Council may consist of the departments as
mentioned in Schedule II. Each such department may consist of the
posts as mentioned in Schedule III. The State Government may add
to or delete any post in Schedule III, in consultation with the
Municipal Council concerned. The set up prescribed in Schedule III
shall be deemed to have taken effect from the “appointed date”.
11. A perusal of aforesaid Rule 6 reflects that the office of Municipal
Council may consist of the departments as mentioned in Schedule II. The State
Government is empowered to add to or delete any post in Schedule III, in
consultation with the Municipal Council concerned. It is also evident from the
perusal of aforesaid Rule 6 that the set up prescribed in Schedule III shall be
deemed to have taken effect from the “appointed date”. The “appointed date”
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
has been mentioned in Rule 2(a) of the Rules of 1967 as First of April, 1964.
Schedule III appended to the Rules of 1967 contains the following entries:(to be quoted)..........................
12. A perusal of aforesaid entries of Schedule III, if are subjected to
penetrating scrutiny, it would reveal that in the set up, there exists a post of
Deputy Revenue Inspector, which can be filled up through direct recruitment
and also through promotion and for the purpose of promotion, the employee
concerned is required to be possessed with the experience of 5 years as
Moharrir (ibid). Therefore, so far as promotion against the post of Deputy
Revenue Inspector is concerned, undisputedly, the post of Moharrir is the
feeder post and experience of 5 years as Moharrir is required to be possessed
by the employee concerned, who is seeking promotion against the post of
Deputy Revenue Inspector. So far as promotion against the post of Revenue
Inspector is concerned, the Schedule III provides that in the cases of
promotion against the post of Revenue Officer, an employee, who has
experience of revenue work for 3 years and also having qualification of Higher
Secondary School Certificate, can be considered for promotion.
13. Column No. 4 of Part II of the Schedule III makes it abundantly clear
that there is no mention of any feeder post for the purpose of promotion against
the post of Revenue Inspector. The feeder post, so far as the promotion against
the post of Deputy Revenue Inspector is concerned, is clearly mentioned as
Moharrir, however, the entire Part II of the Schedule III to the Rules of 1967,
nowhere stipulates that the post of Deputy Revenue Inspector is the feeder post
for the purpose of promotion against the post of Revenue Inspector. Therefore,
in view of the aforesaid analysis of the Schedule III, if the impugned order is
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
examined cogitatively, the same would reveal that in the entire impugned order
dated 20.6.2022, there is no consideration by the Authority as regards the said
Schedule III appended to the Rules of 1967. Though the Authority has made a
reference to the Rules of 1967 in Para II of the impugned order but there is no
discussion in the entire order as regards Schedule III of the Rules of 1967.
14. Now, in order to deal with the question pertaining to the criteria,
which was required to be followed by the DPC, it would be apposite to deal
with Rules 4, 12 of the Rules of 1968. Rules 4 & 12 of the Rules of 1968 is
reproduced below for ready reference:"4. Methods of Recruitment. - Recruitment to the Municipal
service or a post or class of posts may be made by one or more of
the following methods:(a) by direct recruitment;
(b) by promotion of a person employed in the Council;
(c) by transfer or deputation of a person serving in
connection with the affairs of any local authority or of the State.
12. Recruitment by Promotion.- (1) Recruitment by
promotion shall be made on consideration of merits, seniority being
taken into account where merits are equal.
(2) In selecting candidates for promotion regard shall be
had to(i) tact and energy;
(ii) intelligence and ability;
(iii) integrity; and
(iv) previous record of service.
(3) In the case of posts carrying a maximum monthly salary
not exceeding Rs.95/- the Chief Municipal Officer and in other
cases the District Selection Committee shall consider the cases of
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
all the eligible candidates and may in his or its discretion interview
any of the candidates.
(4) The Chief Municipal Officer or the District Selection
Committee, as the case may be, will select candidates and will
arrange their names in the order of preference. Where the Chief
Municipal Officer is the competent authority for making
appointments, the orders will be issued by him. In other cases the
District Selection Committee shall recommend the names of the
candidates found suitable for promotion to the Standing
Committee. The Standing Committee will then make a final
selection."
15. The aforesaid provision reflects that the recruitment in the Municipal
service can be made by promotion apart from direct recruitment as well as
transfer/deputation. In the cases of recruitment by promotion, the criteria for
consideration is merit. As per the provision of Rule 12, the seniority shall only
come into play where merits are equal. In the present case, the Rules of 1968
contains a specific provision in Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968, which contains
the criteria, which is required to be applied by the DPC while considering the
cases of the employee for the purpose of promotion and, therefore, in terms of
Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968, the merit will prevail over the seniority. So far as
Rules of 2002 are concerned, they contain criteria of seniority-cum-suitability
while considering the cases of the employees from Class III to Class III post.
The criteria of seniority-cum-merit or seniority-cum-suitability is to be applied in
what manner when there exists no particular feeder post, is a debatable issue in
the present case.
16. If the provision of Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968 are kept in mind and
the order impugned dated 20.6.2022 (Annexure P-4) is scanned, the same
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
would reveal that in Paragraph 6 of the order, the Authority has taken into
consideration, the provision of Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968. Even the
provisions of Rule 12 are quoted in Paragraph 6 of the order by the Authority
while passing the impugned order. However, in subsequent Paragraph No. 7,
the Authority considered the provision of the Rules of 2002 and proceeded to
conclude that in terms of the provisions of Rules of 2002, the criteria of
seniority-cum-suitability was required to be followed while considering the
cases of promotion. The entire impugned order, however, does not deal with
the effect of Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968. There is merely a reproduction of
Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968 in the impugned order but there is no discussion
as regards its import and applicability to the facts of the case. The Authority
has further proceeded to pass the impugned order on the ground that as the
promotion was to be made against the single vacant post and the senior most
employee namely Shri Pawan Kumar Singh was not inclined to accept the
promotion, the post was to be kept vacant till the superannuation of Shri Pawan
Kumar Singh and also observed that the post of Deputy Revenue Inspector
would be filled up by promotion from the post of Assistant Revenue Inspector
and thereafter the Deputy Revenue Inspector so promoted would be considered
for promotion against the post of Revenue Inspector.
17. A conjoint reading of Paragraphs 9 and 10 of the impugned order
suggests that the Authority proceeded to pass the order under an assumption
that the feeder post for promotion against the post of Revenue Inspector is
Deputy Revenue Inspector whereas the said findings so arrived at in Paragraph
10 are in conflict with the provisions contained in Schedule III of the Rules of
1968.
18. It is further important to take note of the fact that the present
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
petitioner was graded as A+ for 5 years from the year 2015 to 2019. The said
grading of the petitioner was not disputed by any of the employees and on the
basis of said grading, 20 marks were awarded to the petitioner by the DPC. It is
further important to take note of the fact that the criteria of awarding marks was
fixed by the DPC in terms of Para 9 of its recommendation contained in
Annexure P-2 and the DPC itself concluded that complete evaluation of the
confidential reports of last 5 years should be of 20 marks and the criteria of
outstanding (Utkrisht) category so fixed by the DPC in Paragraph 9 of the
recommendations, was being fulfilled by the petitioner only, inasmuch as, none
of the employees, whose names find mention in Paragraph 13 of the minutes of
the DPC, were ever graded A+ in last 5 years. Therefore, the petitioner having
experience of more than 3 years of revenue work, as he was appointed with the
Municipal Council in the year 2006 and was also graded A+ (outstanding) in last
5 years, the DPC while applying the criteria of merit-cum-seniority in terms of
Rule 12 of the Rules of 1968, recommended the promotion of the petitioner for
the post of the Revenue Inspector.
The Municipal Council by way of
resolution affirmed the proposal for the promotion of the petitioner. Thus, the
Director, Urban Administration and Development grossly erred in passing the
impugned order dated 20.6.2022 as the same has been passed in complete
ignorance of the provision of Schedule III appended to the Rules of 1967.
Whether in absence of a feeder post for promotion as Revenue Inspector in
Schedule III of the Rules of 1967, Rules of 2002 could be applied or not? is the
key issue which requires to be mulled over by the State.
19. So far as proposed intervener is concerned, none of his rights are
being affected as nary criteria of merit nor of seniority makes him entitled to be
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
promoted taking into consideration his position reproduced in table in the DPC
minutes.
20. In view of the aforesaid analysis, the petition is allowed. Impugned
order dated 20.6.2022 contained in Annexure P-4 stands quashed. The matter is
remitted back to respondent No. 2 to take decision afresh
as regards
concurrence to the recommendation of the DPC contained in Annexure P-2 in
the light of the provisions of Schedule III of the Rules of 1967.
21. Let aforesaid entire exercise be completed within a period of 90 days
from the date of production of certified copy of this order.
(MANINDER S. BHATTI)
JUDGE
PB
Signed by: PRADYUMNA
BARVE
Signing time: 12/26/2023
2:17:08 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review