The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. Having regard to the aforesaid judgments the impugned order dated 21.01.2019 rejecting petitioner's application for compassionate appointment on the sole ground that his mother is working as Safai Karamchari cannot be sustained and is hereby set aside. The respondents are directed to consider the case of the petitioner afresh and to pass appropriate order in the matter for grant of compassionate appointment within a period of sixty days from today and his case will not be rejected merely on the ground that his mother is working as Safai Karamchari.
8. With the aforesaid, the petition stands allowed and disposed off.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT INDORE
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE PRANAY VERMA
ON THE 3rd OF JANUARY, 2024
WRIT PETITION No. 8425 of 2019
BETWEEN:AJAY S/O LATE SHRI RAJU JI CHAWRE, AGED
ABOUT 22 YEARS, 47, SUBHASH NAGAR, RATLAM
(MADHYA PRADESH)
.....PETITIONER
(BY SHR PRVIN KUMAR BHATT- ADVOCATE )
AND
1.
LOCAL
GOVERNMENT
DEPARTMENT
PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY
VALLABH
BHAWAN, BHOPAL (MADHYA PRADESH)
2.
COMMISSIONER NAGAR PALIK NIGAM
RATLAM RATLAM. (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI TARUN KUSHWAH- ADVOCATE FOR RESPONDENT NO.2. )
This petition coming on for admission this day, the court passed
the following:
ORDER
With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, the matter is
finally heard.
2.
By this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
the petitioner has challenged the order dated 21.01.2019 passed by the
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 08-Jan-24
12:54:52 PM
respondent No.2 whereby his application for compassionate appointment
on the death of his father Raju Chavare has been rejected on the ground
that his mother is already working as a Safai Karamchari.
3.
The case of the petitioner is that his father was working as a
Safai Karamchari with respondent No.2/Municipal Corporation and
expired on 12.10.2016. Thereafter, petitioner had made an application for
compassionate appointment in terms of the applicable clause and the
same has been wrongly rejected.
4.
The stand of respondent No.2 is that since petitioner's mother is
already working as Safai Karamchari in the respondent No.2/Municipal
Corporation therefore, in terms of the general policy of the State
Government as contained in the circular dated 29.09.2014, the petitioner
is not entitled for compassionate appointment.
5.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have
perused the record. Counsel for the petitioner has contended that
petitioner's father was working as Safai Karamchari. If that is so then the
issue which the petitioner is raising is squarely covered by the order of
the Coordinate Bench dated 11.04.2018 passed in W.P.No.4340/2017 in
the case of Jitu Narvale Vs. State of M.P. and another which itself is
based
upon
the
earlier
order
dated
01.07.2013
passed
in
W.P.No.5769/2011 in the case of Motilal Balmiki Vs. State of M.P. and
others. The Coordinate Bench in the case of Jitu Narvale (Supra) while
considering the same issue has held as under:-
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 08-Jan-24
12:54:52 PM
“Mr. Mahesh Choudhary, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Mr. Aditya Garg,, learned counsel for the respondent State.
Mr. B L Jain, learned counsel for the respondent No.2.
The petitioner before this Court has filed this present writ
petition claiming compassionate appointment. The contention of
the petitioner is that his mother Yashodabai was working as
Safai Karmchari and she was permanent employee of Municipal
Corporation, Ujjain. She expired while in service on 10/8/2013.
The petitioner after the death of his mother who was an
employee serving the Municipal Corporation submitted a
request to the respondents based upon the Circular issued by the
Urban Administration and Development Department dated
21/5/2002 claiming compassionate appointment and the
application submitted by the petitioner has been rejected. The
contention of the petitioner is that he is entitled for grant of
compassionate appointment as his mother was serving as Safai
Karmchari.
A reply has been filed in the matter and the
respondents have stated in the reply that father of the petitioner
is also serving as Safai Karmchari and, therefore, as the father of
the petitioner is serving as Safai Karmchari, the request of the
petitioner has rightly been rejected by order dated 26/9/2014.
Respondents have placed heavy reliance upon the policy issued
by the State Government dt. 29/9/2014 and their contention is
that in the light of the aforesaid policy the question of grant of
compassionate appointment does not arise.
Heard learned counsel for the parties at length and perused the
record.
Undisputed facts of the case reveals that the petitioner's
mother namely; Yashodabai was serving as Safai Karmchari and
while in service she expired on 10/8/2013. The petitioner
immediately submitted an application for grant of
compassionate appointment and the same has been rejected by
the respondents by order dated 26/9/2014. The sole reason
assigned by the respondents is that the petitioner's father is also
a Safai Karmchari. Executive instructions issued on 21/5/2002
provides for appointment on compassionate appointment and
Clause 3 of the aforesaid executive instructions do provide that
in case if both the husband and wife are employees of a local
body as Safai Karmchari, even in case of death of one of them,
either husband or wife, their children will be entitled for grant of
compassionate appointment. The State Government has also
issued various instructions from time to time for implementation
of the aforesaid policy.
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 08-Jan-24
12:54:52 PM
This Court is of the considered opinion that there is a
specific policy framed by the State Government in relation to
Safai Karmcharis. It was resolved on a demand made by the
Safai Karmcharis to issue a policy dated 21/5/2002. The same
has not been withdrawn by the State Government. Not only this,
the Safai Karmcharis are belonging to the lowest strata of the
society and the Government as per the constitutional framework
has provided a right to compassionate appointment even in case
of death of father or mother even though both are employees of
local bodies.
A similar dispute arose in respect of Nagar Panchayat,
Narwar Distt. Shivpuri and the learned Single Judge has also
dealt with the policy issued by the State Government dated
21/5/2002. The judgment delivered by learned single Judge in
W.P.No. 5769/2011, decided on 01/07/2013, reads as under:
1. By filing this petition, the petitioner stated
that his father was a Safaikarmi/sweeper and died in
harness on 27.11.2009. The petitioner submitted an
application for grant of compassionate appointment
with relevant documents (Annexure P-6). He submitted
representation to Chief Municipal Officer (CMO)
Narwar, stating that his father died in harness and,
therefore, the application be allowed and he be given
appointment. Similar representation was preferred to the
Collector, Shivpuri for grant of compassionate
appointment in the light of para 3 of policy dated
21.5.2002 issued by Urban Administration and
Development Department. The case of the petitioner is
basically based on this circular, which is specifically
issued on the demand of the unions of sweepers,
wherein the Government took following decision:-
3 uxjh; fudk;ksa dh lsok esa dk;Zjr lQkbZ
dkexkj ifr ifRu es ls fdlh dh Hkh e`R;q gks tkus ij
muds ifjokj ds vkfJr lnL; dks vuqdaik fu;qfDr nh
tk;s A
On 25.2.2010, the Project Officer of Urban
Administration and Development Department issued a
letter to the CMO, Narwar directing him to take action
in accordance with law. This letter, Annexure P-10,
shows that it was made clear by the Urban Development
Tribunal, Shivpuri that CMO is competent to issue
appointment order. It is stated that the appointment can
be made as per the policy in vogue. Thereafter, the
petitioner again submitted a representation, pursuant to
which respondent No. 5 wrote a letter seeking guidance
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 08-Jan-24
12:54:52 PM
from the Urban Administration and Development
Department. This letter seeking a direction was replied
by Annexure P-3. The relevant portion of this letter
reads as under:-
^^uxj ikfydk fofn'kk esa e- iz- 'kklu uxjh;
iz'kklu ,oa foHkkx ds i= dza 1671@16&3@02 fnukad
21@05@2002 dh dafMdk 03 esa mYysf[kr uxjh; fudk;ks
dh lsok esa dk;Zjr lQkbZ dkexkj dh ifr ifRu es ls
fdlh dh Hkh e`R;q gks tkus ij muds ifjokj ds vkfJr
lnL; dks vuqdaik fu;qfDr dh vuqefr nh tk;s A D;k
Jheku es ;g ifji= ykxw gS vFkok lac/a k esa ekxZn'kZu pkgk
gS A mDr lac/a k es funsZf'kr fd;k tkrk gS fd lkekU;
iz'kklu foHkkx ds ifji= dza0lh&7@2000@3@,d fnukad
22@01@2007 ds }kjk mijksDr ifji= fujLr ugha fd;k
x;k gS A ;g ifji= orZeku le; esa Hkh izHkko'khy gS ** A
2. Another letter dated 21.5.2010 (Annexure P2) is issued by Urban Development Department,
Gwalior directing the CMO Narwar to follow the policy
dated 21.5.2002 (supra) and take action for issuance of
appointment order. By order dated 21.5.2010 Nagar
Panchayat rejected the claim of the petitioner on the
basis of Clause 4.1 of the policy dated 18.8.2008.
3. Thus, the pivotal question is whether the
action of the respondent Nagar Panchayat is correct and
legal ?
4. In the opinion of this Court, the policy dated
21.5.2002 issued by the Urban Administration and
Development Department, Mantralaya, Bhopal is a
specific policy which is issued for giving benefits to
Safaikarmis, whereas the subsequent policy dated
18.8.2008 is a general policy issued by the General
Administration Department (GAD). By policy of GAD,
the policy of 21.5.2002 issued by Urban Administration
and Development Department is not cancelled,
superseded, modified or annulled. The Urban
Administration Department in explicit terms made it
clear that the policy of 21.5.2002 is still in force and
needs to be implemented. This direction was issued by
the Urban Administration Department on the request
made by the Nagar Panchayat.
5. It is a matter of common knowledge that the
sweepers hail from almost the lowest strata of our
society. The Government as per the constitutional
scheme, has taken measures for upliftment of the said
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 08-Jan-24
12:54:52 PM
class. A demand was made by their union on which the
decision in specific for Safaikarmis was taken on
21.5.2002. This is also settled in law that a specific
provision excludes the general. The respondents are
unable to show that this policy of 21.5.2002 was
modified, superseded or cancelled at any point of time
later on. As per clause 3 of this policy dated 21.5.2002,
the petitioner is eligible to get compassionate
appointment. There is no impediment in this policy in
getting employment which may be there in the general
policy (clause 4.1). In the opinion of this Court, the
Nagar Panchayat has erred in following the general
policy and further erred in relying on clause 4.1 of the
said policy. In the opinion of this Court, petitioner is
very much eligible for consideration under the policy
dated 21.5.2002.
6. Consequently, the order Annexure P-1 dated
21.5.2010 is set aside. The respondents are directed to
consider the case of the petitioner and issue appropriate
orders within 45 days by considering the petitioner's
case as per policy dated 21.5.2002. The appropriate
orders be passed and communicated to the petitioner
within aforesaid time.
Petition is allowed. No costs.
Not only this, in another case decided by a
coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Jay
Prakash Vs. Urban Administration and Development
Department
(W.P.No.7396/2016,
decided
on
07/03/2018), a similar view has been taken by this
Court. In the light of the aforesaid judgments and also
in the light of the policy which governs only Urban
Administration and Development Department, to be
more specific only Safai Karmcharis, the petitioner is
certainly entitled for grant of compassionate
appointment and, therefore, the impugned order
(Annexure P/5) dated 26/9/2014 passed by the
respondents is hereby quashed. The respondents are
directed to consider the case of the petitioner afresh and
to pass appropriate order in the matter of grant of
compassionate appointment within a period of 30 days
from today and his case will not be rejected merely on
the ground that his father is already serving as Safai
Karmchari.
With the aforesaid, the present Writ Petition
stands allowed and disposed of. No order as to costs.
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 08-Jan-24
12:54:52 PM
6. Similar is the view taken by another co-ordinate Bench
of
this
Court
in
order
dated
07.03.2018
passed
in
W.P.No.7396/2016 [Jaiprakash Bilwan Vs. State of M.P. and
other]
and
order
dated
03.07.2019
passed
in
W.P.
No.28439/2018 [Dinesh vs. State of M.P. and another].
7. Having regard to the aforesaid judgments the impugned
order dated 21.01.2019 rejecting petitioner's application for
compassionate appointment on the sole ground that his mother
is working as Safai Karamchari cannot be sustained and is
hereby set aside. The respondents are directed to consider the
case of the petitioner afresh and to pass appropriate order in the
matter for grant of compassionate appointment within a period
of sixty days from today and his case will not be rejected merely
on the ground that his mother is working as Safai Karamchari.
8. With the aforesaid, the petition stands allowed and disposed
off.
(PRANAY VERMA)
JUDGE
jyoti
Signed by: JYOTI
CHOURASIA
Signing time: 08-Jan-24
12:54:52 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review