Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
(THROUGH VIRTUAL MODE)
Case:- CRMC No. 70/2018
Reserved on: 24.04.2026
Pronounced on: 06.05.2026
Uploaded on: 06.05.2026
Whether the operative part or
full judgment is pronounced: Full
Aijaz Hussain Sahaf S/O
Late Mohammad Hussain
Sahaf, R/O Karan Nagar,
Srinagar (Kashmir)
…..Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. I. Sofi, Advocate.
Vs
1.State of J&K through
Senior Superintendent of
Police, Crime Branch,
Kashmir-Srinagar.
2.Station House Officer,
Police Station, Crime
Branch, Srinagar.
.…. Respondents
Through: Mr. Mohsin S. Qadri, Sr. Advocate with
Ms. Maha Majeed, Assisting Counsel
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SHAHZAD AZEEM, JUDGE
(JUDGMENT)
1.
The petitioner has invoked the extra-ordinary jurisdiction
of this Court under Section 561-A of Code of Criminal Procedure,
Svt. 1989 (Cr.PC), as was applicable to the erstwhile State of
Jammu & Kashmir seeking quashing of F.I.R No. 09 of 2015
registered at Police Station, Crime Branch, Kashmir under
Sections 420, 467, 468 & 471 of the Ranbir Penal Code (RPC).
CRMC No. 70/2018
2.
Briefly stated, the allegation against the petitioner which
led to the registration of the impugned FIR is that he alleged to
have manipulated the first page of his service-book by forging his
date of birth as 28 August 1958 instead of his actual date of birth,
28 August 1955, which was recorded at the time of entry into
service. A complaint was received by the Crime Branch, Kashmir
against the petitioner, who at the relevant time, was serving as
Executive Engineer. It was alleged that he had tampered with his
date of birth in the service-book.
3.
A preliminary inquiry was conducted by the Crime
Branch which was closed as “not proved”. However, SSP, Crime
Branch, Kashmir addressed a communication to the Chief
Engineer,
Irrigation
&
Flood
Control
Department,
Kashmir
(Srinagar) recommending a departmental inquiry into the matter.
Pursuant to the direction issued by Commissioner/Secretary to
Government, PHE/Irrigation & Flood Control, a departmental
inquiry was conducted and the petitioner vide order dated 16 July
2012 was directed to record his actual date of birth i.e. 28 August
1955 on first page of his service-book. The aforesaid order was
challenged by the petitioner before this Court by way of SWP No.
1448/2012 and the Court inter-alia, ordered that competent
authority shall be at liberty to hold a proper inquiry in accordance
CRMC No. 70/2018
with the rules. Thereafter, the Government initiated an inquiry
against the petitioner. On conclusion of the inquiry, it was
established that the petitioner had tampered with his service
records and changed his date of birth from 28 August 1955 to 28
August 1958.
4.
Besides proposing the disciplinary action under the
relevant
rules,
the
Under
Secretary
to
Government,
vide
communication dated 16 February 2015, referred the entire matter
alongwith reports and supporting material to Crime Branch,
Kashmir for appropriate action under law. On the basis of material
so recorded, a prima-facie commission of cognizable offences
punishable under Sections 420, 467, 468 & 471 RPC was
disclosed, leading to the registration of FIR No 9/2015 and
investigation was taken up.
5.
The petitioner has assailed the impugned FIR primarily
on the grounds: (i) The FIR is motivated and lodged just to harass
him, as the inquiry officer was inimical to him; ii) Under Secretary
had no locus standi to lodge the FIR against him; iii) on same
facts, this Court has quashed the order of his compulsory
retirement, hence, lodging of FIR amounts to abuse of process of
the Court and iv) Crime Branch had earlier conducted an inquiry
CRMC No. 70/2018
and given a clean chit to the petitioner, therefore, on same facts,
second FIR is not legally sustainable.
6.
Per contra, the respondents have filed reply and have
narrated the sequence of events leading to the registration of FIR.
It is submitted that during investigation, prima-facie commission
of cognizable offences are established against the petitioner and,
therefore, the present petition under Section 561-A Cr.PC is not
maintainable.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
case diary.
8.
At the outset, it is clarified that the initial preliminary
verification conducted by the Crime Branch was closed, but the
matter was simultaneously recommended to department for
holding a departmental inquiry. Therefore, the plea of the
petitioner that once an preliminary inquiry was closed, a second
FIR could not be registered, is totally mis-placed. It is equally true
that mere assertion, in absence of any material to show that FIR is
outcome of malafide or same is lodged by an incompetent officer, is
not sufficient on the ground that there is presumption that all the
official acts are done rightly and regularly until contrary is proved.
CRMC No. 70/2018
9.
Perusal
of
the
investigation,
the
matriculation
certificate,
case
Investigating
result
diary
reveals
that
Officer
has
collected
the
admission
and
registers,
during
withdrawal registers, National High School records and the
service-book of the petitioner. Statements of several witnesses,
including Rajinder Kumar Dogra, Head Assistant, Industries and
Commerce Department, Vinod Pandita, Junior Assistant, PHE and
I&FC, Hafiz-Ullah Shah, S.O, PHE/IFC, Mohd. Sayed Shah and
Abdul Aziz Thoker, Principal, National High School, etc have been
recorded.
10.
During investigation, a letter dated 18 May 2015 was
received from Joint Secretary, (Verification), J&K Board of School
Education (BOSE), Kashmir Division, authenticating that the date
of birth of the petitioner is 28 August 1955. As per the
departmental record, the petitioner figures at Serial No. 160, with
the same date of birth (28 August 1955).
11.
The most crucial piece of evidence is the FSL report dated
18.07.2014, which opines that the original date of birth of
petitioner is 28 August 1955 and not 28 August 1958, thereby
confirming tampering in the service record. Equally important is
the material collected regarding the petitioner’s brother working in
CRMC No. 70/2018
the New Ganderbal Hydro Electric Power Project. His matriculation
certification and first page of the service-book reflect his date of
birth as 01 January 1959. The petitioner is shown to be only four
months younger than his elder brother, which further corroborates
the tampering of the service-book.
12.
From the material collected during investigation, prima-
facie commission of cognizable offences has been disclosed, which
necessitated the registration of the FIR mandatorily, therefore, no
illegality has been committed in
registering the FIR and
proceeding with the investigation.
13.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vinod Kumar Pandey & Anr.
Vs. Seesh Ram Saini and ors.; AIR 2025 SC 4186 held thus:“In Pradeep Nirankarnath Sharma v. State of
Gujarat,7 this Court, in a very recent judgment
held, that where the allegations pertain to the
abuse of official position and corrupt practices
while holding public office, such actions fall
squarely within category of cognizable offences
and therefore, they are to be inquired into, and
holding of any preliminary inquiry before the
registration of the FIR is not necessary. If the
information provided to the police or the
preliminary report discloses a commission of a
cognizable offence, the police is duty bound
under Section 154 Cr.P.C. to register an FIR
without any delay. ”
14.
The High Court cannot interfere under its inherent
jurisdiction to quash an FIR, merely because a preliminary
verification had earlier recommended closure, when subsequent
CRMC No. 70/2018
material collected during inquiry discloses commission of a
cognizable offence. Registration of FIR under Section 154 Cr.PC is
mandatory and no preliminary inquiry is required in such cases.
15.
It appears that the petitioner has sought to take
advantage of the findings returned in the writ petitions filed by the
petitioner from time to time. However, once the information
discloses the commission of a cognizable offence, registration of an
FIR, becomes mandatory under Section 154 Cr.PC.
16.
The petitioner has also tried to derive benefit from the
judgment passed by the learned writ Court in SWP No. 2200/2014
titled Aijaz Hussain Sahaf Vs. State of J&K and ors, whereby the
order of his compulsory retirement was quashed. However, it has
been brought to the notice of the Court that said judgment was set
aside in the Letters Patent Appeal No. 86/2017. Even otherwise,
exoneration in disciplinary proceedings which are decided on the
basis of preponderance of probabilities, does not ipso facto entitle
a person to claim quashing of criminal proceedings, which require
proof beyond reasonable doubt.
17.
been
The material collected during investigation which has
extensively
referred
to
above,
prima-facie
discloses
commission of cognizable offences, therefore, the High Court under
CRMC No. 70/2018
its inherent jurisdiction is not supposed to conduct a mini trial or
re-weigh the evidence collected during investigation, as same falls
within the domain of the trial Court.
18.
Much stress is laid on the point that once preliminary
verification resulted in closure of the case, thereafter, no second
FIR was permissible. In this regard, be it noted that a preliminary
verification closure measurely requires supplying brief reasons to
the informant. It does not amount to a closure report under
Section 154/170 Cr.PC nor does it have the sanctity of a judicial
order. Subsequent prima-facie material can always trigger fresh
action. The preliminary verification report is non-conclusive
material, therefore, it cannot prevent registration of FIR, if
cognizable offences are made out on fresh/relevant material. The
scope of preliminary verification is only to check whether a
cognizable offence is prima-facie disclosed and not to finally
adjudicate that allegations either “proved” or “”not proved”.
Therefore, once on the basis of material collected during inquiry,
the commission of cognizable offence is disclosed, registration of
FIR is the mandate of law.
19.
The power of the High Court under 561-A Cr.PC can be
exercised only to prevent the abuse of process of the Court or to
CRMC No. 70/2018
secure the ends of justice and not to shield an accused from the
penal
consequences
when
prima-facie
material
shows
his
complicity in the commission of cognizable offence.
20.
For above reasons and in view of the material collected
during investigation, no case is made out for exercise of inherent
jurisdiction. Accordingly, the petition being devoid of merit is
dismissed.
Interim
direction(s)
shall
stand
vacated.
The
Investigating Officer shall be at liberty to proceed in accordance
with law.
21.
CD file be returned to the concerned against proper
receipt.
(SHAHZAD AZEEM)
JUDGE
JAMMU
06.05.2026
Tarun/PS
Whether order is speaking:
Whether order is reportable:
Tarun Kumar Gupta
2026.04.12 20:51
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRMC No. 70/2018
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review